Open Access Article
Tawfik A. Saleh
*a,
Nadeem Baiga,
Fahd I. Alghunaimib and
Norah W. Aljuryyedc
aChemistry Department, King Fahd University of Petroleum & Minerals, Dhahran 31261, Saudi Arabia. E-mail: tawfik@kfupm.edu.sa; tawfikas@hotmail.com
bSaudi Aramco, Research & Development Center, Oil & Gas Treatment R&D Division, Dhahran 31311, Saudi Arabia
cSaudi Aramco, EXPEC Advanced Research Center, Production Technology Division, Dhahran 31311, Saudi Arabia
First published on 31st January 2020
The development of stable 3D surfaces for oil/water separation has been of great interest to researchers. Inspired by the lotus leaf, in this study, a superhydrophobic stable and robust surface was generated by the combination of n-octadecyltrichlorosilane, silica, polypyrrole and polyurethane (ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU). The constructed 3D network displayed superhydrophobic and superoleophilic behavior with a high water contact angle of 154.7° ± 0.8°. The superhydrophobic behavior of the porous material was found to be stable for months. Apart from the hydrophobicity analysis of the material, the various forms of the materials were investigated via scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX). Under the force of gravity, hexane displayed an exceptionally high flux of 102
068 Lm−2 h−1 through ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU. The macroporous network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed fewer chances of fouling, which is a common issue with membranes. Moreover, its porous network displayed good absorption capacity for various non-polar organic solvents. The maximum absorption capacity observed for toluene was 34 times its own weight. The separation efficiency of various non-polar organic solvents from water was observed in the range of 99.5 to 99.8%. ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU, due to its superhydrophobicity, 3D porous network, extraordinarily high flux, good absorption capacity, and excellent separation capability, has been established as a good candidate for the separation of organic and oil contaminants from water.
Superhydrophobic surfaces that display a contact angle of greater than 150° have received a great deal of attention.15 There are two main characteristics that play a crucial role in the generation of superhydrophobic surfaces. The first factor is the surface roughness, which has a significant impact in improving the hydrophobicity. If a flat surface has a contact angle in the range of 100° to 120°, it may appear to be 150° to 170° on a microtextured or rough surface.16 The second factor that has a dominant role in the material hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity is surface energy. A low surface energy imparts hydrophobic behavior to the material. A material is superhydrophobic through the combination of low surface energy and the appropriate surface topography.17 In some cases, bumpy rough surfaces were generated by coating polymers on the porous surface and then, the surface was further coated with a low surface energy material to improve the hydrophobicity of the surface.18 On the basis of the specific wettability, various porous materials that can act as a filter or oil absorber were introduced.19 A material that displays the capacity to absorb or allow the passage of oil enables the collection of the oil. After the appropriate treatment, the collected organic component or oil can be reused. Although there has been extensive research in the field, there is still a remaining need to develop a material that is environmentally friendly, cost-effective, reusable, possesses a high absorption capacity, displays a high flux and is not a source of secondary pollutants.
Herein, a superhydrophobic interconnected porous network was constructed using a combination of polymer-based organic and inorganic materials. On the porous network of polyurethane, pyrrole was catalyzed into polypyrrole and then silica particles were introduced into the polypyrrole-coated polymeric walls of the polyurethane. The silica nanoparticles were furthermore functionalized with n-octadecyltrichlorosilane. As a result, the combination of polypyrene, polyurethane, silica, and n-octadecyltrichlorosilane provided a stable superhydrophobic surface that displayed a high flux and excellent absorption capacity. The developed porous materials displayed an excellent shelf life. The developed superhydrophobic network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed good reusability and it was used multiple times for flux studies along with the absorption of various organic solvents. The absorbed oil can be released through a simple process of squeezing. The high flux of 102
068 Lm−2 h−1 and excellent absorption capacity of 34 times its own weight has established a promising future for the superhydrophobic ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU in the separation of oil and other organic contaminants from water.
| W% = (M1 − M0)/M0 × 100 | (1) |
The flux was found by passing the hexane through the tube containing ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU under gravity. The flux was calculated using the following equation:
| Flux = V/A × t | (2) |
The surfactant-free and surfactant (dodecylbenzene sulfonic acid) stabilized emulsion of water in oil was prepared by adding 1 mL of water into 8 mL of chloroform, then 1 mg of the surfactant was added. In the case of surfactant-free emulsion, the water and chloroform were sonicated for 30 minutes to stabilize the emulsion before passing through the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU. The surfactant stabilized emulsions were developed using dodecylbenzene sulfonic acid.
The desorption experiment was performed by squeezing the foam that released the adsorbed non-polar liquids. In the case of highly volatile liquids such as hexane or petrol, the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was kept in the fume hood until dry. In the case of viscous non-polar organic solvents, after releasing as much of the liquid as possible, the viscous liquid stuck to the walls of the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU. The sticky viscous liquid was removed by dipping in hexane with multiple squeezing cycles and then washing with ethanol. After that, the washed ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was kept in the fume hood to dry.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Schematic illustration of the reactions taking place between pyrrole, silicic acid and ODTCS on the surface of the polyurethane. | ||
O) stretching absorption band at 1726 cm−1. The –N–H deforming band appeared at 1537 cm−1 and the stretching band appeared at 3292 cm−1. The –C–H symmetric and asymmetric stretching vibrations were observed in the range of 2800 to 3000 cm−1.21 A sharp absorption band that appeared in the non-functionalized polyurethane at 1094 cm−1 was assigned to –C–O–C– stretching (Fig. 1A). The FTIR spectra of the polypyrrole-coated polyurethane was recorded and a broad absorption band was observed at 600 cm−1. The presence of a broad peak was due to the presence of ferric/ferrous components in the composite. A broad absorption peak after 3000 cm−1 was observed in the spectra of PP–PU. The appearance of a broad peak after 3000 cm−1 was attributed to the NH group of polypyrrole and polyurethane. Most of the absorption peaks in the PP–PU FTIR spectra appeared broad compared to those in the non-functionalized polyurethane spectra. Due to the broad absorption bands, most of the polypyrrole peaks were merged under the signal. The peaks appearing at 1292 cm−1 were assigned to the
C–H vibrations22 (Fig. 1B). The FTIR spectrum of SiO2–PP–PU revealed that the incorporation of silica into PP–PU was successful. A sharp absorption band appeared at 1081 cm−1 which represents the –Si–O–Si– antisymmetric stretching vibrations. The appearance of Si–O–Si bands in SiO2–PP–PU demonstrated the successful incorporation of SiO2 into PP–PU (Fig. 1C). In the case of, ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU along with the –Si–O–Si– peaks, the more prominent sharp peaks of –C–H stretching vibrations were observed at 2849, 2916 and 2955 cm−1. The appearance of –Si–O–Si– and –C–H prominent sharp peaks confirmed the successful functionalization of SiO2–PP–PU with ODTCS (Fig. 1D).
Morphological information of various forms of the modified polyurethane was collected by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The SEM images provided useful information related to the surface changes after each step of modification. The polyurethane consists of a porous network. The walls of the PU appeared planer and this was evident from the SEM images of the unmodified PU (Fig. 2A(a) and B(b)). The polymerization of pyrrole on the planar walls of the polyurethane was clearly observed by SEM. The walls of the polyurethane appeared wavier and thicker after the catalytic polymerization of the pyrrole. The polyurethane maintained a porous network after the pyrrole polymerization on the walls of the polyurethane, as shown in Fig. 2A(b). SEM images have revealed the SiO2 distribution on the walls of the polypyrrole-modified polyurethane. Apart from the uniform distribution of the SiO2, some aggregates of SiO2 were also observed (Fig. 2A(c) and B(c)). In the case of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU, the SEM images display the sheets which cover the SiO2-incorporated pyrrole-polymerized walls of the polyurethane. The sheets appeared as a result of ODTCS and even a lump of the SiO2 was also covered under the sheet (Fig. 2A(d) and B(d)). The SEM images revealed that the surface morphology of the polyurethane walls changed after each step of modification (Scheme 2).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 SEM images at two different magnifications (A and B) of (a) PU, (b) PP–PU, (c) SiO2–PP–PU and (d) ODCS–SiO2–PP–PU. | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Schematic showing the generation of functionalized polyurethane by the combination of polypyrrole, silica, and ODTCS on the polyurethane walls. | ||
The 3D porous network was further investigated using EDX spectroscopy. EDX spectroscopy is a valuable analytical tool that provides elemental information on the material. The EDX spectrum of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed additional peaks of Si, Cl, and Fe that were absent in the EDX spectrum of PU (Fig. 3). The sharp peak of Si highlights the presence of SiO2 and the silane group. Ferric chloride was loaded into the polyurethane to catalyze the polymerization reaction of pyrrole. Due to this, Fe and Cl peaks appear in the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU EDX spectrum. The appearance of the relevant elements during the EDX analysis support the successful production of the 3D porous composite of polyurethane.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Water contact angle on the surfaces of (A) PU, (B) PP–PU, (C) SiO2–PP–PU and (D) ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU. | ||
The weight gain ratio by using eqn (1) was found in the range of 1800 to 3400% (Fig. 5). The absorption capacity for petrol was found at 2162%. It is crucial to note that the absorption capacity might predominantly depend on the density of the various oils and the organic solvents.23 The developed 3D macroporous superhydrophobic network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed an absorption capacity in the range of 18 to 34 times better than that of the previously reported recent materials, including aerogel composites (2–16 times),24 PDMS-SW (12–27 times),25 magnetic silicone sponges (7–17 times),26 PDMS sponges (4–11 times),23 and nitrogen-rich carbon aerogels (6–11 times).27 Moreover, toluene absorption was specifically compared with the previous literature and demonstrated better efficiency here than in the previously reported work (Table 1). The increase in weight gain ratio is evidence that ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU has an excellent capability to absorb a large quantity of non-polar organic liquids and spilled oils. Moreover, its facile and robust route of fabrication using cost-effective raw materials is an attractive feature for scale-up and readily deployable for application.
| Sr.# | Superhydrophobic material | Preparation methods | Absorption capacity (toluene) | Regeneration | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Monolithic superhydrophobic silica aerogel | Sol–gel process | 9 | Distillation and vacuum filtration | 28 |
| 2 | Porous BNNS/PVDF composite material | Gelation and freeze-drying process | 5 | Washing in ethanol and drying at 60 °C in air | 29 |
| 3 | Magnetic graphene foam | Hummer's method | 19 | Hexane immersion | 30 |
| Gas based reduction | |||||
| Co-precipitation | |||||
| 4 | Fluorinated polydopamine/chitosan/reduced graphene oxide composite aerogel | Hummers' method | 8 | Heating and squeezing | 31 |
| Hydrothermal | |||||
| Immersion | |||||
| Fluorination | |||||
| 5 | Graphene foam | Modified hummers method | 20 | Washing in ethanol and oven drying | 32 |
| Sol–gel method | |||||
| Hydrolyzed and curing | |||||
| 6 | PDMS sponge | Sugar templating process | 5 | Squeezing | 23 |
| 7 | Porous BN nanosheets | Dynamic templating approach | ∼24 | Burning and heating in air | 33 |
| 8 | Superhydrophobic/superoleophilic cotton fiber | Sol–gel process | ∼30 | Drained under mild suction by a vacuum air pump | 34 |
| Self-assembling | |||||
| 9 | Carbon aerogel | Hydrothermal and post-pyrolysis process | 29 | By heating | 35 |
| 10 | PDMS-SW | Immersion | 11.5 | Mechanical squeezing | 25 |
| 11 | Magnetic silicone sponge | Hydrolysis and polymerization | 9 | By squeezing | 26 |
| 12 | ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU | Catalytic polymerization | 34 | By squeezing | This work |
| Immersion |
The regeneration is a crucial factor in deciding the fate of material scalability and practical application. For example, cost-effective materials have lost attention for practical use if they do not display the capability to regenerate after a single use. ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU regeneration was evaluated with hexane, dodecane, and petrol. The same ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was used for the regeneration study of various organic pollutants. ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed excellent regeneration capabilities for the analyzed hexane, dodecane and petrol with a RSD of ±0.7 (n = 12), ±1.2 (n = 12) and ±2.9 (n = 12), respectively (Fig. 6). The spongy nature of the macroporous material facilitated oil removal by squeezing it out. After multiple uses, the surface maintained its superhydrophobicity and repelled the water strongly from its surface. The regenerated ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was further investigated by collecting its FTIR spectrum. The FTIR spectrum of the regenerated ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU revealed all the characteristics peaks that were present in the modified PU before its use (Fig. S1†). This regeneration behavior has revealed the robustness of the material and that it can be used for a long time.
The capability of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was evaluated for the separation of the surfactant-free and surfactant-stabilized emulsion. The surfactant-free and the surfactant-stabilized water in oil emulsion were prepared by using distilled water and chloroform. The surfactant-free emulsion was stabilized by sonication whereas the surfactant-stabilized emulsion was prepared by adding the surfactant. The development of the emulsions could be observed in their respective vials that appeared as a milky color (Fig. S2 and S3†). Emulsions were passed through the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU that were tightly packed into the nozzle of the apparatus. The ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU permitted the chloroform to pass while preventing the water from passing. It is shown in Fig. S2 and S3.†
High flux through a continuous network of absorbent material is an important factor for the porous material in order to absorb large spills of oil or non-organic solvents. The macroporous network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed an outstanding capability for the continuous passing of the oil or non-polar organic component. Through the porous network, the non-polar component passed very fast while the water was rejected. The flux for hexane was found to be 102
068 Lm−2 h−1. This flux value for the non-polar organic component is exceptionally high. As depicted in Fig. 7, the hexane flux was evaluated 12 times and the RSD was found to be ±2.31. This indicates that after multiple uses, the porous network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was not clogged and continuously allowed a high flux of hexane through it. The flux is high compared to values in previously reported flux studies (Table 2). M. H. Tai studied a SiO2-carbon composite membrane with a hexane flux of 2648.8 Lm−2 h−1 under gravity and a contact angle of 144.2°.36 In the synthesized ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU, the hexane flux (102
068 Lm−2 h−1) was greater and displayed more surface hydrophobicity with a contact angle of 154.7° ± 0.8°. The macroporous network provided fewer coagulation chances, which are common issues with the membranes used for oil/water separation.
| Sr.# | Superhydrophobic material | Preparation methods | Contact angle | Flux (Lm−2 h−1) | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PVDF–HFP membrane | Electrospinning | 134.0 ± 3.2° | 94 000 (gasoline) |
37 |
| 2 | SiO2–carbon composite membrane | Electrospinning | 144.2 ± 1.2° | 2648.8 (hexane) | 36 |
| 3 | TPU microfiber membrane | Force spinner | NA | 4659 (oil flux) | 38 |
| 4 | TPU-PNIPAM membrane | Force spinner | NA | 503 (oil flux) | 38 |
| Free radical polymerization | |||||
| 5 | PAA-g-PVDF membrane | Salt-induced | NA | 2320 (hexadecane/H2O) | 39 |
| Phase inversion | |||||
| 60 Co γ-ray source irradiation | |||||
| 6 | ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU | Catalyst based polymerization | 154.7° ± 0.8° | 102 068 (hexane) |
This work |
Apart from the gravity-based separation, the dynamic separation of oil/water was also evaluated by applying pressure with the help of a peristaltic pump. For this purpose, ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU was placed at the interface of the oil and water in such a way that it was more than half dipped into the water (Video S1†). This strategy was adopted to observe during oil passage whether the water passed or was prevented from passing by the superhydrophobic nature of the material. In the dynamic separation analysis, it was observed that hexane passed rapidly from the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU network, while the water was completely prevented from passing. This is evidence that the surface remained superhydrophobic during the separation of the non-polar organic and water mixture. Through the ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU, various systems of hexane/water, heptane/water and octane/water were separated to evaluate the separation efficiency of the porous network of ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU. The separation efficiency for the hexane, heptane and octane were found in the range of 99.5 to 99.8% (Fig. 8). The efficient separation can be explained by the superhydrophobic porous network that spread over all of the polyurethane walls. It rapidly allowed the passage of the non-polar component and completely prevented the passage of the water through it.
068 Lm−2 h−1. The porous three-dimensional hydrophobic network has a great capacity to absorb and keep the non-polar organic solvents. It displayed an absorption capacity of 34 times its weight for toluene under ambient conditions. It can be used multiple times and the absorbed oil is recovered from ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU by squeezing it. ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU displayed good mechanical stability and after squeezing, the porous interconnected network was not destroyed. It displayed excellent separation efficiency for various organic solvents in the range of 99.5 to 99.8%, good recyclability, a facile route of synthesis, high flux, and a good absorption capacity. It displayed an excellent regeneration capability with hexane, dodecane, and gasoline. The RSD was found in the range of ±0.7 to ±2.9 after 12 cycles of use. Due to the high flux, great stability, excellent absorption capacity, and an efficient separation capability of oil from water and water in oil emulsions, ODTCS–SiO2–PP–PU is a unique material for the separation of oil from water.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ra06579b |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |