Yijin
Wu
,
Shasha
Zhang
,
Jiwei
Pei
and
Xiao-Fang
Chen
*
Key Laboratory of Macromolecular Design and Precision Synthesis, Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Advanced Functional Polymer Design and Application, State and Local Joint Engineering Laboratory for Novel Functional Polymeric Materials, College of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, Soochow University, Suzhou 215123, P. R. China. E-mail: xfchen75@suda.edu.cn
First published on 26th March 2020
Photoresponsive materials have been drawing much attention due to their fast switching properties and non-contact and non-destructive features. In this paper, we report a photoinduced reversible fluorescence switching based on the α-cyanostilbene containing liquid crystalline polynorbornenes. Z- and E-stereoisomers of α-cyanostilbene monomers with different flexible alkoxy tails and their corresponding Z- and E-polymers were synthesized and characterized for the first time. P-(Z)-345 with three alkoxy tails exhibits a hexagonal columnar structure. P-(Z)-4, P-(Z)-34, and P-(Z)-35 with one or two alkoxy tails possess a lamellar structure. The substitution position and number of alkoxy tails also influence the photoluminescence behaviours, giving rise to different fluorescence colours in bulk. Both monomers and polymers show photoinduced E/Z isomerization in solution. Under the UV light of 365 nm and 254 nm, polymer thin films or monomer thin films at the noncrystalline state could change their fluorescence colours accordingly, which is mainly due to the photoinduced reversible E/Z isomerization and [2+2] dimerization in film.
α-Cyanostilbene derivatives10–13 are known as fluorescent molecules and their AIE properties14–16 have been studied for the past decade. Recent research revealed that α-cyanostilbene is a good candidate to construct stimulus-responsive materials. The luminescence intensity and colour can be readily modulated under various external stimuli, such as temperature,17–19 solvent,20–22 mechanical force,22–29 and pH.30 Most of the α-cyanostilbene derivatives are also sensitive to light stimuli. When irradiated by UV light, α-cyanostilbene moiety can undergo Z/E isomerization31–44 or [2+2] dimerization,44–47 which finally influences the conjugation length and the molecular packing. The fluorescence intensity and colour are thus modulated. Although a variety of responsive properties for α-cyanostilbene derivatives have been explored so far, most of cyanostilbene-related systems are based on small molecules and the reversible switching phenomenon only happens in a limited number of cases. In addition, it should be noted that light-triggered Z/E isomerization generally takes place in a solution, gel, or liquid crystalline (LC) state, but rarely in a solid crystalline state. α-Cyanostilbene-related materials should be heated to their LC or isotropic phase to realize the light-induced responsive properties in the bulk state. We recently reported a feasible strategy to realize reversible fluorescence switching by incorporating the α-cyanostilbene molecule into a supramolecular polymer system via hydrogen bonding interactions.48 Its fluorescence colour could be changed at room temperature by irradiating 365 nm UV light and reverting to the original state via thermal annealing. Recently, an α-cyanostilbene moiety has been reported that could be used as the mesogen to construct fluorescent liquid crystalline polymers,49–54 but its photoresponsive properties and mechanism in polymer systems have not been revealed until now.
In this work, we successfully realized reversible switching of luminescence colour in α-cyanostilbene-related side-chain LC polymers and the recovery process is readily realized via different UV light irradiation at room temperature.
The chemical structures of side-chain polynorbornenes are shown in Scheme 1. The side-chain segment is constructed with the α-cyanostilbene moiety end-attached with various aliphatic tails at different substitution positions. The α-cyanostilbene group has Z and E configurations. Generally, the Z-isomer is the thermally stable one and exhibits a rod-like shape that can act as a calamitic mesogen, while the E-isomer adopts a bent-like structure. Photoinduced E/Z isomerization could simultaneously trigger an LC phase transition and fluorescence switching in some cases. In contrast to the Z-isomer, studies of the E-isomer are seldom reported, probably due to its lower thermal stability. In this work, we synthesized both Z-monomers and E-monomers according to the synthetic routes as shown in Scheme 2. The E-isomer can be obtained by column chromatography separation from the photo-irradiated Z-isomer solution. To keep their configuration in polymer structures, we choose polynorbornene here as the main chain that can be synthesized via ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) under mild conditions.55 It can be used to avoid thermally induced structural change and to get the corresponding Z- and E-polymers. Studies of such unique isomer-based polymers would help us to gain more insight into the interplay between the molecular structures (especially the molecular configurations) and self-assembled supramolecular structures. In this system, phase behaviours and the photophysical properties of monomers and polymers either in solution or in the solid state have been systematically studied. The mechanism of photochromic fluorescence switching was also thoroughly investigated.
Scheme 2 Synthetic routes for the preparation of the Z- and E-monomers and their corresponding polymers. |
The E-monomer could be successfully separated and purified from the corresponding irradiated Z-monomer solution via column chromatography (Scheme 2). Chemical structures of both Z- and E-monomers were verified via1H NMR (Fig. 1b and Fig. S1–S4, ESI†), 13C NMR, high-resolution MS and elemental analysis. Compared to the UV spectrum of M-(Z)-345, the λmax of M-(E)-345 is blue shifted to 334 nm as shown in Fig. 1c, due to its bent structure with relatively short conjugation.
The ROMP was carried out at room temperature in CH2Cl2 solution for 4 h. Both Z-monomers and E-monomers can be polymerized under this condition with high conversion. During polymerization, the Schlenk tube was wrapped with aluminium foil to avoid light-induced isomerization. 1H NMR spectra in Fig. 2 confirm that both P-(Z)-345 and P-(E)-345 are synthesized successfully with their side chains keeping the same configurations as the corresponding monomers and no other reactions take place during polymerization. The 1H NMR spectra of other polymers can be found in Fig. S2–S4 (ESI†). Their molecular weights and polydispersity values were measured via GPC with polystyrene standards. The Mn values of polymers, as shown in Table 1, are higher than 4 × 104 g mol−1 with relatively narrow polydispersity.
Polymer | M n (g mol−1) | M w (g mol−1) | PDIa | T d (°C) | T i (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Determined by GPC in THF using polystyrene standards. b 5% weight loss temperature evaluated by TGA under a nitrogen atmosphere at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1. c Isotropization temperature confirmed by DSC at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1. | |||||
P-(Z)-345 | 102600 | 126600 | 1.23 | 372 | 182 |
P-(E)-345 | 86400 | 124400 | 1.44 | 361 | — |
P-(Z)-34 | 85300 | 110300 | 1.29 | 390 | 227 |
P-(E)-34 | 48400 | 84700 | 1.75 | 385 | — |
P-(Z)-35 | 103500 | 123600 | 1.19 | 396 | 148 |
P-(Z)-4 | 86600 | 109300 | 1.26 | 379 | 230 |
A SAXS method was further performed to verify the LC structure of these polymers. As shown in Fig. 3c, the SAXS profile of P-(Z)-4 shows three diffraction peaks in the low-angle region with the q ratio of 1:2:3, which refers to a long-range ordered lamellar structure. The calculated layer thickness (L) is 7.31 nm. Meanwhile, only a broad scattering peak exists in the wide-angle region in Fig. 3d, indicating no positional order within the layer. When the rigid mesogen is attached with two aliphatic tails at the 3,4 or 3,5 positions, the corresponding P-(Z)-34 and P-(Z)-35 keep lamellar structures with the layer thickness around 6.22 and 6.04 nm, respectively. The layer thickness is associated with the length of the repeating unit in side-chain liquid crystal polymers (SCLCPs), based on the general schematic packing model presented in Fig. 3e. The calculated length (Lc) of an extended repeating unit structure with an all-trans conformation of the aliphatic chain is around 4.45 nm. Since L should not be larger than 2Lc in the lamellar structure, the side chain adopts a partially interdigitated packing model within each layer in this case. When the cyanostilbene mesogen was attached with three aliphatic chains at the 3, 4, and 5 positions, the corresponding polymer P-(Z)-345 exhibited the other type of ordered structure. The SAXS profile of the thermally annealed sample showed three diffraction peaks with the q in a ratio of 1:√3:2. A typical hexagonal columnar (Φh) structure with the lattice parameter of a = 7.25 nm was confirmed. The POM picture in Fig. 3b presents the characteristic fan-like texture of a columnar phase for P-(Z)-345, which is also consistent with the SAXS result. The substituent position and number of aliphatic tails affect the LC structure to some extent.
Phase structures of the corresponding E-polymers have also been studied. The cyanostilbene segment here adopts a bent structure instead of a rod-shaped one. In contrast to Z-polymers, SAXS profiles of both P-(E)-4 and P-(E)-345 only show a broad peak in the low angle region (Fig. 3c). Meanwhile, no phase transition and birefringence could be detected for E-polymers, indicating the amorphous nature. It is well known that the rod-like shape of the mesogens is important for the stabilization of the lamellar structure in SCLCPs. In this system, neither a lamellar nor columnar structure could be maintained when the cyanostilbene segment changes from a Z to E configuration. The conformation of the cyanostilbene segment in this system plays a virtual role in the formation of the LC phase. Meanwhile, the aliphatic chain could be used to modulate the phase transition temperatures and phase structures. Based on the result, it could be speculated that if photoinduced Z to E isomerization could be triggered in the bulk state, an LC-to-iso phase transition would be taking place in this system.
In the solid state, the molecular packing influences the PL spectra. As shown in Fig. 4d, the maximum emission wavelengths of Z-monomers are 481 nm (M-(Z)-345), 484 nm (M-(Z)-34), 459 nm (M-(Z)-35), and 463 nm (M-(Z)-4). All Z-monomers contain the identical cyanostilbene segment, but with a substituted dodecanoxyl chain at different positions. Comparing the PL spectra of M-(Z)-345 in solution (Fig. 4b) and in the solid state (Fig. 4d), it is clearly seen that the aliphatic chains have less effect on the fluorescence properties in solution, but really affect the PL properties in the condensed state,56 especially for M-(Z)-345 and M-(Z)-34, both of which exhibit an obvious red-shift. The quantum yield (Φf) of monomers in solution is very low, exhibiting nonfluorescence, while they show high fluorescence properties in the solid state with high Φf (>50%).
Polymers also retain AIE properties. Taking P-(Z)-345 as an example, the PL intensity gradually increases upon the continuous addition of water in THF/water mixed solvents accompanied by a red-shift of maximum emission wavelength as shown in Fig. 5a, indicating the gradual formation of aggregates. As mentioned above, in the case of M-(Z)-345, when fw exceeded 60%, the fluorescence intensity was dramatically increased. But for polymers, the aggregates form more easily when fw reaches only 10%. Fig. 5b presents the PL change as a function of water content for both M-(Z)-345 and P-(Z)-345. The increase of PL intensity and the red-shift of wavelength of P-(Z)-345 are gentler than that of the monomer M-(Z)-345. Although M-(Z)-345 and P-(Z)-345 have the same concentration of cyanostilbene segment in THF, the concentration of cyanostilbene around the polymer chain is much higher than that in other places in dilute solution, which provides much higher propensity to aggregate with less water content. Other polymers exhibit similar AIE behaviours in THF/water mixtures (Fig. S8, ESI†).
These polymers can still undergo Z/E isomerization in CHCl3 solution under the irradiation of 365 nm UV light, which was confirmed via UV-vis absorption and 1H NMR spectra (Fig. S9, ESI†). The time to reach the equilibrium of Z/E isomerization for P-(Z)-345 is longer than that of M-(Z)-345. It is also due to the same reason that the presence of the polymer backbone causes the higher local concentration of the cyanostilbene segment than that of the corresponding monomer solution.
PL spectra of polymers at the solid state are shown in Fig. 5c. The emission peaks of polymers are similar to those of the corresponding monomers, which means that PL properties could be kept after polymerization in these systems. After polymerization, the Φf of polymer samples is decreased due to the noncrystalline feature of polymers.
A similar responsive process was also found in the as-prepared monomer thin film, but it should be noted that the monomer film easily appeared to be heterogeneous after several irradiation cycles. The freshly prepared M-(Z)-345 film showed a noncrystalline state and slowly entered a crystalline state as revealed via XRD experiments (Fig. S10, ESI†). After crystallization, the monomer film did not show any photoresponsive behaviours, which was confirmed via1H NMR measurements. There were no significant differences found between the results in the 1H NMR spectra before and after irradiation (Fig. S11, ESI†).
In order to study the mechanism of fluorescence switching, 1H NMR was first carried out to detect the chemical structural change of the polymer before and after UV irradiation. However, the film of P-(Z)-345 became difficult to dissolve in most organic solvents after UV illumination. It was speculated that some cross-linking reactions might occur in the film. As mentioned above, the as-prepared non-crystallized monomer film has similar photostimulus-responsive properties. Thus, the corresponding monomer was chosen instead to track the photoinduced switching behaviours. After 365 nm UV irradiation for 30 min, the M-(Z)-345 film was dissolved in CDCl3 for the 1H NMR measurements. First of all, signals belonging to the E-isomer could be clearly detected via1H NMR as shown in Fig. 7. This means that the E/Z isomerization could take place in the bulk state. Besides the E-isomer, the 1H NMR spectra of the irradiated samples also show two new singlets at 4.95 and 5.09 ppm (Fig. 7). As reported before,45–47 when cyano-substituted cyclobutanes are generated via photocycloaddition, one singlet in the 1H NMR at around 5 ppm could be detected. In this case, the 1H NMR result indicates that at least two types of cyclobutanes appeared in the thin film after UV irradiation. Here we assign the singlet at 4.95 nm to dimer 1 and the other singlet to dimer 2 (Fig. 7). The content ratio of the integrated peaks of the two singlets in irradiated film is related to the temperature. When the film was irradiated at room temperature, both dimers 1 and 2 could be detected. The content of dimer 1 decreased with increasing temperature. When it was irradiated at 75 °C, only dimer 2 existed, which was confirmed via1H NMR (Fig. 7). Then dimer 2 was successfully separated from the mixture through column chromatography (Fig. 8a).
Fig. 7 1H NMR spectra of M-(Z)-345, M-(E)-345 and the as-casted film of M-(Z)-345 irradiated with 365 nm UV light at 25, 55 and 75 °C for 30 min. |
Fig. 8 (a) 1H NMR spectra of the irradiated sample containing dimer 1 and purified dimer 2.; Chemical structures and corresponding MS spectra of dimer 1 (b) and dimer 2 (c). |
We also got the irradiated sample that mainly contained dimer 1 rather than dimer 2 via controlling the temperature and the irradiation time (Fig. 8a). The chemical structures and the stereochemistry of the major cyclobutanes formed in this photoprocess of these two dimers were studied via 2D 1H NMR experiments. Based on rotational frame nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (ROESY) and H–H correlation spectroscopy (COSY) experiments (Fig. S12, ESI†), dimer 2 adopts a head-to-tail structure and dimer 1 possesses a head-to-head structure. Their MS spectra shown in Fig. 8b and c also confirm the formation of the dimers. Based on this result, we could also speculate that the molecules tend to adopt head-to-head packing in the non-crystalline phase, which can be a bilayer lamellar structure or a columnar structure. When heating close to the isotropic state, molecules generally adopt a more interdigitated arrangement and head-to-tail dimers become dominant.
The content ratio of the Z-isomer, E-isomer, dimer 1 and 2 in the irradiated film could also be measured via1H NMR. As shown in Fig. 9, after irradiation via 365 nm UV light, the molar content ratio of the n(Z-isomer):n(E-isomer):n(dimer 1):n(dimer 2) in the film is 1:0.60:2.88:1.28, which means that both E/Z isomerization and [2+2] cycloaddition take place within the film and most of the Z-isomer turns to E-isomer and dimers by irradiation via 365 nm. As a consequence of the UV-induced structural change, a blue shift of the PL peak from 476 nm to 462 nm was detected (Fig. 6a). Then, by subsequent irradiation via 254 nm UV light, the fluorescence colour of the film reverted to the green one. In this state, the content molar ratio of the major components n(Z-isomer):n(E-isomer):n(dimer 1):n(dimer 2) was measured as 1:0.28:0.44:0.10. The content of Z-isomer increased again.
Fig. 9 1H NMR of M-(Z)-345 film after irradiating with 365 nm UV light for 30 min and then irradiating with 254 nm UV light for 10 min. |
The confirmation of dimers in the irradiated monomer film can also answer the question of whether the polymer thin film becomes insoluble in organic solvents after 365 nm UV irradiation. The cycloaddition may take place as well within the cyanostilbene side chains to cross-link the polymer thin film. Then, the 254 nm UV light can act as a decrosslinking effect and make the blue fluorescent film return to its original green luminescence colour, accompanied with improved solubility. Other Z-polymers exhibit similar photochromic fluorescence switching behaviours at room temperature (Fig. S13, ESI†).
As we discussed above, Z-polymers are liquid crystalline polymers, while E-polymers are amorphous; the possibility of a photoinduced phase transition from the LC phase to the isotropic phase is also studied. In this work, both E/Z isomerization and [2+2] dimerization are detected in the LC phase, based on the results of Fig. 9. The photoreaction is more complicated than that of azobenzene materials.57,58 We studied the phase transition of the irradiated polymer film via POM. The irradiated zone has a relatively lower isotropization temperature than the unirradiated zone, but because the irradiated zone is partially crosslinked due to [2+2] dimerization, a weak birefringence could still be observed.
In conclusion, this work presents a useful strategy toward the combination of photochromic fluorescence switching and liquid crystalline polymers through molecular design. Further investigation on controllable colour switching and modulation in liquid crystalline systems via all-light stimuli is still ongoing.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Materials, instruments, and detailed synthetic procedures, 1H NMR spectra of monomers and polymers, DSC thermograms and POM pictures of monomers, AIE properties of monomers and polymers, XRD profiles, UV-vis absorption and fluorescence spectral data. See DOI: 10.1039/d0tc00069h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |