Tao
Wang
ab,
Zhen
Tang
c,
Dong
Xu
a,
Wei
Sun
a,
Yipeng
Deng
a,
Qidong
Wang
a,
Xingyuan
Zhang
*a,
Peifeng
Su
*c and
Guoqing
Zhang
*b
aDepartment of Polymer Science and Engineering, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, 230026, China. E-mail: zxym@ustc.edu.cn
bHefei National Laboratory for Physical Sciences at the Micro Scale, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, 230026, China. E-mail: gzhang@ustc.edu.cn
cThe State Key Laboratory of Physical Chemistry of Solid Surfaces, and College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Xiamen University, Xiamen, Fujian 5 36100, China. E-mail: supi@xmu.edu.cn
First published on 10th January 2018
Purely organic luminescent materials are extensively used in bioimaging, sensing and organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). Anthraquinone (AQ) derivatives with N- and O-substitution are incorporated into waterborne polyacrylates as single-component polymers with both thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) and two-state phosphorescence. Essential structural and optical properties are characterized for these waterborne polyacrylates. With increasing dye loadings, a convergence between singlet and triplet states due to excitonic splittings is observed.
:
3 ratio under electrical excitation according to spin statistics.14 Therefore, the internal EL efficiency of purely luminescent molecules with both fluorescence and RTP may be 100% theoretically. In general, the lifetimes of RTP from purely organic molecules are so long that oxygen quenching and vibrational relaxation could interfere with emissions desirable for OLEDs. A series of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) materials were developed by Adachi15,16 and others,17,18 where radiative lifetimes could be reduced to the sub-ms domain.
Organic molecules with π–π* transitions typically exhibit aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) due to strong “face-to-face” stacking interactions. In order to circumvent the ACQ effect, Tang19,20 and others21,22 designed a large number of molecules with aggregation-induced emission (AIE) by restricting intramolecular rotation in the solid state. Another way to avoid the ACQ effect is to incorporate small molecules into polymers covalently.2,10,11 Flexible polymeric emitters are suitable for solution-cast films and were successfully applied in OLEDs by Bryce23 and others.24,25
Here we report a different mechanism for TADF in a single-component waterborne polyacrylate system with various ratios of O-substituted anthraquinones (POAQs) and N-substituted AQs (PNAQs) (the synthetic procedure is according to the literature26,27). We found that the generation of TADF for these polymers is very likely due to the fact that they have two distinct emissive triplet states which belong to 3n–π* and 3π–π*, respectively. The energetically close, four-state configuration renders thermal back-population from 3n–π* to 1π–π* and 3π–π* to 1n–π* very effectively, according to the El-Sayed rule. Moreover, when the dye concentration is increased, energy-splitting was observed, which lines up with a recent model we proposed, polymerization-enhanced intersystem crossing (PEX).28 As a result, the luminescent waterborne polyacrylates with both TADF and phosphorescence have the potential to be used for aqueous-based photoluminescence imaging and sensing in biological contexts.
O bond conjugated to the C
C bond. However, the stretching vibration peak of the C
O bond shifts to 1730 cm−1, presumably caused by the conversion of C
C to C–C as a result of polymerization, which suggests that NAQ is incorporated into the polyacrylate covalently. The peaks at 1665 cm−1 and 1594 cm−1 are assigned to skeleton vibrations of the aromatic rings whose intensities increase with the increasing ratio of NAQ. Other characteristic peaks assignment for PNAQ is as follows: 3015–2870 cm−1 (νCH3 and νCH2), 1485 cm−1 (δC–N) and 953 cm−1 (νC–N) of trimethylamino chloride, 1150 cm−1 (νC–O–C).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 FT-IR of PNAQ films with various NAQ weight percentage on a KBr plate (number denotes the weight percentage of NAQ, e.g. 0.5% NAQ = PNAQ-0.5; control represents polyacrylate without NAQ). | ||
Shown in Fig. 2 are the thermal behaviors of PNAQ and POAQ polymers. From the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC, Fig. 2a and b) curves, all of the samples show a descending slope which is characteristic of the glass transition temperature (Tg). As the DSC curves show, Tg is around 115 °C for PNAQ and 118 °C for POAQ, which is similar to the control polymer (waterborne polyacrylate without NAQ or OAQ), suggesting that incorporation of NAQ or OAQ at a small percentage does not evidently change the motion of polymer side chains. From the thermogravimetric analysis (TGA, Fig. 2c and d), there are three apparent steps in the course of polyacrylate decomposition. All the polymer samples exhibit a slow descending trend from the onset to 240 °C due to the decomposition of the quaternary ammonium salt. A sharp descending shows between 240 °C and 300 °C, which indicates the breakage of the ester group. The polymeric main chains degrade at the final stage in between 300 °C and 450 °C. Therefore, NAQ and OAQ also do not obviously change the thermal behaviors of polyacrylates at up to 5% content.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 DSC curves of polyacrylates with different NAQ (a) and OAQ (b) contents. TGA of polyacrylates with different NAQ (c) and OAQ (d) contents. | ||
Since anthraquinone derivatives are generally weakly or non-luminescent in dilute solutions, the luminescence properties of the polymers were mainly investigated in the solid state. Compared to the steady-state emission spectrum of the POAQ-0.5 film in air (Fig. 3 and Table 1, λem = 491 nm) at room temperature, the maximal emission peak of the POAQ-0.5 film (λem = 497 nm) shifts bathochromically by ∼6 nm under vacuum, which is likely due to contribution from increased emissive triplet states at longer wavelengths. Correspondingly, the luminescence lifetime increases from 371.9 μs to 5.58 ms. Curiously, irrespective of the presence of oxygen, the measured lifetime is too long to be considered as typical fluorescence emission. We thus ascribe the emission from the POAQ-0.5 film to thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF). As a result, the steady-state emission is further red-shifted to 512 nm at 77 K, where the equilibrium favours more towards the radiative decay from a lower-energy state, i.e., the triplet state of OAQ. This is evidenced by a much longer-lived lifetime of 143.1 ms at this temperature at 512 nm. When the emission was collected after a 10 ms delay, an even more redshifted spectrum could be seen (λem = 531 nm). It is thus interesting to observe that two independently emitting triplet states (512 nm and 531, indicated by coloured lines) co-exist at 77 K.
| λ air (nm) | τ air (μs) | λ vc (nm) | τ vc (ms) | λ 77K (nm) | τ 77K (ms) | τ rad (ms) | Φ (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Steady-state emission maxima under air at room temperature. b Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under air. c Steady-state emission maxima under vacuum at room temperature. d Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under vacuum (triple exponential fitting). e Delayed emission maxima under vacuum at 77 K. f Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under vacuum at 77 K. g Calculated radiative lifetime under air. h Absolute emission quantum yields under air. | ||||||||
| POAQ-0.5 | 491 | 379.1 | 497 | 5.58 | 512 | 143.1 | 9.03 | 4.2 |
| POAQ-1 | 497 | 459.6 | 507 | 6.74 | 519 | 147.3 | 13.5 | 3.4 |
| POAQ-5 | 511 | 587.3 | 517 | 7.61 | 541 | 148.6 | 36.7 | 1.6 |
Quantum chemical calculations were performed to shed light on the possible emitting states of the AQ fluorophores (Fig. 4 and Table 2). The electronic emission spectrum (phosphorescence, triplet excited states transition to ground state, and fluorescence, singlet excited states transition to ground state) calculations are based on the Frank–Condon principle; the calculations are simulated by computing the energies of vertical transitions from excited states to the ground state with the equilibrium geometries of excited states. All the calculations were done using B3LYP/6-31+G* with the Gaussian 16 program package. From the geometry optimizations of excited states, the transition energies can be directly obtained (Table 2). The OAQ's second singlet excited state optimization cannot be obtained, while we can estimate the emission value to be larger than 425.86 nm (the second excited energy in the equilibrium geometry of the first excited states). From the calculations, the lowest singlet state (S1) has strong n–π* character while the second lowest one (S2) is π–π* with substantial charge-transfer (CT) character. Both n–π* and CT transitions favour the intersystem crossing (ISC) process to the triplet excited states, which may explain the dominant long-lived luminescence emission observed in the experiment.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Calculated molecular orbitals involved in the lowest two singlet and triplet states, where S1(2) denotes the first (second) singlet transition, respectively. | ||
| T1 | T2 | S1 | S2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OAQ | 642.16 nm | 586.84 nm | 475.07 nm | >425.9 nm |
| 1.9307 eV | 2.1127 eV | 2.6098 eV | <2.9114 eV | |
| π–π* | n–π* | n–π* | π–π* | |
| NAQ | 788.94 nm | 593.73 nm | 601.75 nm | 484.13 nm |
| 1.5715 eV | 2.0882 eV | 2.0604 eV | 2.5610 eV | |
| π–π* | n–π* | π–π* | n–π* | |
The proposed decay pathways for the excited states are shown in Scheme 2. The apparent lack of detectable fluorescence bands at room temperature indicates that the ISC process is incredibly efficient, due to the El-Sayed rule, and essentially quenches all singlet excited state populations. Based on the spectroscopic data in Fig. 3, the calculated energy gap between the lowest singlet state (S1, 491 nm) and the second triplet state (T2, 512), ΔES1T2, is 0.104 eV (or 2.39 kcal mol−1); the calculated energy gap between the lowest singlet state (S1, 491 nm) and the lowest triplet state (T1, 531), ΔES1T1, is 0.180 eV (or 4.15 kcal mol−1). And the calculated energy gap between the two triplet states, ΔET2T1, is 0.0867 eV (or 2.1 kcal mol−1). These values agree well with previous reports and allow for sufficient thermal population of all four states at room temperature. According to the equation r = exp(ΔE/T) (where r is the Boltzmann population, ΔE is the energy gap between the two emitting states and T is the temperature in Kelvin), the calculated Boltzmann population ratio at 298 K for ΔES1T2 is thus 0.0174
:
1 and 0.028
:
1 for ΔET2T1. The radiative decay rates for 1n–π*, 3n–π* and 3π–π*, however, are on the order of ns, μs, and ms, respectively. It is then not surprising to see that the majority of the radiative decay is from the TADF pathway. At 77 K, the Boltzmann ratios for the two scenarios are 1.65 × 10−7
:
1 (for ΔES1T2) and 1.10 × 10−6
:
1 (for ΔET2T1), respectively, where the upper emitting states can no longer compete with the lower one. Consequently, the dominant emission comes from the lower triplet states.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Illustration of dominant emissive states at higher (left) and lower (right) temperatures with simplified Jablonski diagrams. | ||
We then investigated the effects of dye concentration on luminescence properties, where three dye molar ratios (0.5%, 1% and 5%) were used for comparison (Fig. 5 and Table 1). From Fig. 5a, it is apparent that the emission maxima at both room temperature and 77 K are red-shifted as the OAQ content increases. The intrinsic luminescence lifetimes (τ/Φ, Table 1), however, show a dramatic increase from 9.03 ms (POAQ-0.5) to 13.5 ms (POAQ-1) and finally 36.7 ms for POAQ-5 at room temperature. The phenomenon can be explained by the splittings of excited state energy levels and generation of a relatively forbidden lowest emitting state from the dye molecule aggregates, as has been previous reported.28,29 From Fig. 4, the steady-state emission maxima change from 491 to 511 nm in air at room temperature; at low temperature, the change is more dramatic: from 512 to 541 nm. Apart from mechanisms similar to the previously reported β-diketone28 and benzophenone29 systems, in the POAQ system, the lengthened intrinsic lifetimes are also very likely due to increased mixing between the n–π* and π–π* states from dye aggregates.
Next, the substitution effect was explored by replacing the alkoxyl group with alkylamino group on the AQ dye. Since the alkylamino group is a much stronger electron donor, two major effects can be expected from the nitrogen substitution: (1) the photoluminescence, both fluorescence and phosphorescence, should be red-shifted; (2) the luminescence emission quantum yields should be enhanced given the larger separation between 1n–π* and 1π–π*. From the calculations (Fig. 4 and Scheme 2), it is clear that the presence of the stronger donor N,N-substituted amino group has reversed the relative energy levels of the 1n–π* and 1π–π* states. Both effects can be easily observed from Fig. 5 and Table 3. From Table 3, the luminescence lifetime in air has been dramatically reduced to several microseconds despite a sharp increase in the measured quantum yield in the solid state. Compared to POAQ with dye concentrations at 0.5%, 1% and 5%, the emission maxima of PNAQ polymer films at these concentrations are red-shifted to 571, 593 and 611 nm, respectively, rendering the visual photoluminescence colour from green to orange-red (Fig. 6). Correspondingly, the phosphorescence emissions at 77 K were also substantially red-shifted. The quantum yields of the N-substituted AQ polymer films, PNAQs, also exhibit much larger values at 15.7%, 13.4% and 8.6% for PNAQ-0.5, PNAQ-1, and PNAQ-5, respectively. The calculated radiative lifetimes are thus reduced to a few tens of microseconds (35.9, 24.8 and 18.8 μs). We ascribe the phenomenon to the simultaneous increase in ISC and reverse ISC rates due to the closer energy levels between the lowest singlet state (1π–π*) and the second lowest triplet state (3n–π*), compared to the O-substituted dye. Curiously, the lifetimes measured in vacuum are significantly longer than the calculated intrinsic lifetimes. The anomaly is very likely due to the complete loss of the much-longer lived 3π–π* component in air, which contributes overwhelmingly (vs. lifetime for delayed fluorescence) in vacuum (Fig. 6).
| λ air (nm) | τ air (μs) | λ vc (nm) | τ vc (ms) | λ 77K (nm) | τ 77K (ms) | τ rad (μs) | Φ (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Steady-state emission maxima under air at room temperature. b Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under air. c Steady-state emission maxima under vacuum at room temperature. d Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under vacuum. e Delayed emission maxima under vacuum at 77 K. f Pre-exponent weight-averaged lifetimes under vacuum at 77 K. g Calculated radiative lifetime under air. h Absolute emission quantum yields under air. | ||||||||
| PNAQ-0.5 | 571 | 5.63 | 577 | 3.78 | 585 | 34.2 | 35.9 | 15.7 |
| PNAQ-1 | 593 | 3.32 | 605 | 2.95 | 609 | 60.2 | 24.8 | 13.4 |
| PNAQ-5 | 611 | 1.62 | 620 | 1.36 | 624 | 75.5 | 18.8 | 8.6 |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Steady-state emission spectra under air and vacuum of PNAQ-0.5, PNAQ-1, and PNAQ-5 at room temperature and 77 K (λex = 365 nm). | ||
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: FT-IR, 1H and 13NMR. See DOI: 10.1039/c7qm00399d |
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2018 |