Sandra
Míguez-Lago
a,
Inês F. A.
Mariz
b,
Miguel A.
Medel
a,
Juan M.
Cuerva
a,
Ermelinda
Maçôas
*b,
Carlos M.
Cruz
*ac and
Araceli G.
Campaña
*a
aDepartment of Organic Chemistry, Unidad de Excelencia de Química (UEQ), Faculty of Sciences, University of Granada, Avda. Fuente Nueva s/n, 18071 Granada, Spain. E-mail: cmorenoc@ugr.es; araceligc@ugr.es
bCentro de Química Estructural and Institute of Molecular Sciences, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Av. Rovisco Pais, 1, 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal. E-mail: ermelinda.macoas@tecnico.ulisboa.pt
cDepartment of Chemistry, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zurich, Switzerland
First published on 19th July 2022
Herein we describe a novel superhelicene structure consisting of three hexa-peri-hexabenzocoronene (HBC) units arranged in a helical geometry and creating two carbo[5]helicenes and a carbo[7]helicene. The central HBC bears a tropone moiety, which induces a saddle-helix hybrid geometry into the 3D structure of the prepared nanographene. The introduction of multiple helicenes and the position of the tropone unit trigger near-infrared circularly polarized luminescence (NIR-CPL, up to 850 nm, |glum| = 3.0 × 10−3) combined with good photoluminescence quantum yields (ϕF = 0.43) and upconverted emission based on two-photon absorption (TPA). Compared to previously reported superhelicenes of similar size, higher quantum yields, CPL brightness, and red-shifted absorption and emission spectra are achieved. Besides, chiroptical properties of enantiopure thin films were evaluated. These findings place this novel superhelicene as the first NIR-CPL superhelicene ever reported and make it a promising candidate for use as a chiral luminescent material in optoelectronic devices.
Recently, the linkage of more than one carbohelicene into a single π-system in an appropriate fashion has been highlighted as a strategy to improve the limited properties of single carbohelicenes.35,36 Thus, the fusion of carbohelicenes into different topologies allows us to design and tune the resulting optical and chiroptical properties of multiple-helicene-containing compounds.37 Higher chiroptical responses are expected if the arrangement of the different helicenes improves the angle between the electric and magnetic transition dipole moments, increasing the dissymmetry g factor. Another strategy to improve the properties of pristine helicenes involves the extension of their π-conjugated system. In this regard, the family of superhelicenes, i.e. HBC-based helicenes,38 has been growing fast during the last few years, and a wide variety of members can be found in the literature.38–44 Despite an improvement in the optical properties, with red shifted absorbance and emission spectra, the obtained fluorescence quantum yields are usually poor due to the strong π–π stacking arising from the large conjugated polycyclic surfaces. Nevertheless, it has been recently shown that the deliberate incorporation of a superhelicene into a fluorescent polymeric scaffold led to an amplification of its chiroptical response,45 opening the door to highly-efficient chiral electroluminescent materials.
Our research group, primarily interested in the preparation and study of the optical and chiroptical properties of heptagon-containing superhelicenes,46–49 is directing its synthesis efforts towards a future implementation of our HBC-based helical nanographenes in NIR chiral luminescent materials. Thus, we have designed a novel structure consisting of three HBC units, containing two extended carbo[5]helicenes, an extended carbo[7]helicene, and a seven-membered ring. The superhelicene 1 (Fig. 1) was designed to improve the low photoluminescence quantum yields of the two undecabenzo[7]superhelicenes previously reported by Wang42 and by our research group47 (ϕF = 0.090 and 0.098, respectively), and to reveal the influence of the tropone unit position and the addition of multiple carbohelicenes on the optical properties of a superhelicene scaffold.
The recorded 1H NMR spectrum of 1 in CDCl3 consisted of a mixture of isomers. Considering the configuration of the helicene moieties, three possible diastereoisomers could be formed during the last oxidative cyclodehydrogenation step, namely (M,M,M)-, (M,M,P)- and (P,M,P)-1 (chirality descriptors for [5], [7] and [5]helicenes, respectively), and their corresponding enantiomers. Bearing the symmetry aspects in mind, along with tropone flipping, the configurations (M,M,M/P,P,P)-1 and (P,M,P/M,P,M)-1 can be regarded as C2-symmetric structures, whilst diastereoisomer (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1 possesses C1 symmetry. Chiral stationary phase HPLC (CSP-HPLC) was used to perform both diastereomeric and racemic resolution simultaneously (ESI, Fig. S25†). In the chromatogram, four main peaks were found, belonging to two pairs of enantiomers after comparison of their UV-vis spectra. Noteworthily, when a toluene solution of 1 is refluxed for 16 h, a more understandable chromatogram is obtained, (ESI, Fig. S25†) where two chromatographic peaks with identical 1H NMR spectra were found, confirming the presence of the C1-symmetric diastereoisomer. The two chromatographic peaks belonged to the thermodynamically more stable (M,M,P)-1 and (P,P,M)-1 enantiomers, supporting that the interconversion barrier between the two diastereoisomers is easily surmountable at ca. 110 °C. Theoretical calculations (CAM-B3LYP/6-31G(d,p), gas phase) support such an interpretation, predicting the C1-symmetric pair to be the global minimum, while the relative energy of the C2-symmetric pairs, (M,M,M/P,P,P)-1 and (P,M,P/M,P,M)-1, were calculated to be 3.32 and 10.55 kcal mol−1 above the global minimum, respectively. This diastereomeric distribution can be rationalized by looking at the geometries of the different diastereoisomers of compound 1. While the saddle curvature induced by the inclusion of the seven-membered ring is well accommodated in the geometry of the pair (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1, for the C2-symmetric pairs (M,M,M/P,P,P)-1 and (P,M,P/M,P,M)-1 the configuration of the [5]helicenes causes a partial planarization of the central hept-HBC unit (ESI, Fig. S32 and S34†). This fact leads to an increase in the relative energies of the C2-symmetric diastereoisomers, supporting the interconversion towards the C1-symmetric diastereoisomer upon heating. Moreover, suitable crystals for X-ray diffraction (XRD) were grown by slow evaporation of a CH2Cl2/hexane solution of (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1 at room temperature. The quality of the crystals was low, but good enough for a preliminary structural analysis of 1. In this sense, we found a good agreement between the main features of the structure obtained from the XRD studies and those calculated by DFT methods. From the DFT optimized structure of (M,M,P)-1, the average torsion angle (φ, Fig. 2c) of the [7]helicene moiety shows a value of 26.37°, a remarkably high value (in good agreement with the obtained XRD data, φ = 25.05°). On the other hand, the [5]helicenes show a φ = 24.82° and 25.46° according to DFT (φ = 25.35° and 26.97° according to XRD data), for the [5]helicene with the same and opposite configurations to the [7]helicene, respectively (Fig. 2d). These values are remarkably higher than those reported for pristine [5]helicene (φ = 22.10°)52 and [7]helicene (φ = 21.97°).53 The presence of the [7] and [5]helicene moieties, together with hept-HBC induces a negative curvature to one of the HBC units, exhibiting a calculated bending angle (θ, Fig. 2) of 29.11° (28.58° according to XRD). The central hept-HBC unit shares seven benzenoid rings with the three carbohelicenes. This fact is observed as a pronounced curvature of the hept-HBC unit, exhibiting an end-to-end distance (d, Fig. 2) of 9.41 Å (9.43 Å from XRD), remarkably lower than the one reported for pristine hept-HBC (10.63 Å)50 or the hept-HBC sharing a carbo[5]helicene unit with HBC (10.87 Å).46
Compound 1 exhibited good solubility in common organic solvents, presenting a dark green color in low concentration solutions (ca. 10−6 M) that turns nearly black at a higher concentration (ca. 10−3 M). (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1 showed a panchromatic absorption spectrum ranging from 250 to 700 nm with defined maxima centered at 365 nm (ε = 1.45 × 105 L mol−1 cm−1), 505 nm (ε = 6.00 × 104 L mol−1 cm−1) and a red shifted broad band extending up to 700 nm (Fig. 3a). This low-energy band is mainly dominated by a pure HOMO → LUMO transition according to TD-DFT (CAM-B3LYP/6-31G(d,p), gas phase), which was calculated at 617 nm (Fig. 3c). These red-shifted absorbance wavelengths are comparable to those measured for the green nanographene propeller reported by Wang and co-workers.40 Upon excitation at 370 nm, an extended emission spectrum along the 600–850 nm range was obtained, with a maximum centered at 697 nm. The Stokes shift was quite low, not exceeding 50 nm. In the previous undecabenzo[7]helicenes, the HOMO and LUMO orbitals are located at the central flat HBC unit, while in (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1 they fall all over the helicene moieties (Fig. 3c). This fact could originate through space interactions, causing red-shifted absorption and emission.54 Furthermore, the optical HOMO–LUMO gap, taken from the crossing point between the absorbance and emission spectra, was estimated to be 1.95 eV, in perfect agreement with the measured electrochemical bandgap (1.95 eV, ESI, Fig. S31†).
The fluorescence quantum yield (ϕF = 0.43 in CHCl3) was estimated to be four times higher than the ones reported for the two undecabenzo-[7]superhelicenes (0.098 and 0.090),42,47 with a monoexponential fluorescence lifetime (τ) of 6.1 ns. Similar values were obtained in dimethyl sulfoxide, a solvent of higher polarity (ESI, Table S2 and Fig. S27 and S28†). The obtained value for τ is three times lower compared to the previous undecabenzo[7]superhelicene47 (τ = 18 ns). This fact suggests that the increment in the ϕF is due to a faster radiative relaxation for (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1. Excitation with a femtosecond laser above 820 nm wavelength caused the simultaneous absorption of two NIR-photons, leading to emission at higher energies. The upconverted emission spectrum is depicted in Fig. 3a (TPE). The TPE spectrum exhibited a similar maximum when compared to its one-photon emission (Fig. 3a, OPE) spectrum, suggesting that the final relaxed excited states upon one- and two-photon excitation are the same. The log–log plot of the emission intensity as a function of excitation power showed a slope of ∼2 confirming the two-photon nature of the excitation process (ESI, Fig. S29†). The two-photon absorption spectrum (Fig. 3a, TPA) showed a maximum at higher energies with TPA cross-sections of ca. 110 GM at 820 nm. Estimation of the TPA cross-section below 820 nm is not possible due to interference from direct one-photon absorption. In addition, the lower energy limit for the measurement of the TPA spectra is dictated by the operation range of the Ti:sapphire laser (730–900 nm).
The abovementioned CSP-HPLC racemic resolution of the pair (M,M,P/P,P,M)-1 allowed the chiroptical property study. Thus, the ECD spectra of a chloroform solution at a concentration of 1 × 10−6 M of (M,M,P)- and (P,P,M)-1 were recorded (Fig. 3b). Mirror-image ECD spectra were obtained for both enantiomers, with a strong bisignated signal at 390 nm, exhibiting an intense Cotton effect at 366 nm (|Δε| = 200 L mol−1 cm−1, gabs = 1.5 × 10−3), and a red-shifted band that extends from 520 to 675 nm (|Δε| = 54 L mol−1 cm−1, gabs = 3 × 10−3). Remarkably, the dissymmetry factor of the last band was well estimated by TD-DFT calculations (|gabs|calc = 2.87 × 10−3). The absolute configuration was assigned comparing the experimental and TD-DFT simulated ECD spectra (ESI, Fig. S39†). Thus, the first eluted peak after CSP-HPLC, with a positive Cotton effect at 600 nm, was assigned to the (P,P,M) enantiomer, while the second eluted peak belonged to the (M,M,P) enantiomer. Remarkably, both enantiomers showed a CPL response in the 600 to 800 nm range after irradiation with 370 nm wavelength, exhibiting |glum| values of 3 × 10−3 (Fig. 3b), higher than that reported for the undecabenzo[7]superhelicene (2 × 10−3).47 In addition, the improvement of the overall efficiency of (M,M,P)/(P,P,M)-1 is evidenced by its high CPL brightness (BCPL = ε × ϕF × |glum|/2)55 of 90.5 L mol−1 cm−1 at λexc 365 nm, more than seven times higher than the one reported for the undecabenzo[7]superhelicene (BCPL = 12.3 L mol−1 cm−1, λexc 472 nm),47 standing out among most of the helicenes for which BCPL was reported.
The OLED industry has been deeply interested in chiral emitters in the last few years.56,57 Thin films are a common format for the implementation of these luminophores into final devices. Thus, preliminary studies using 1 were conducted to obtain thin films on quartz plates. Posterior optical and morphological examination via optical (OM) and tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (AFM) was carried out. Solutions of 1 in CHCl3/toluene mixtures ranging from 0 to 100% toluene were tested, obtaining the best results via drop casting of 0.1 mg mL−1 solutions in pure toluene. AFM revealed wide homogeneous areas of ca. 100 × 100 μm constituted by stacked flakes (ca. 5 μm) where height profiles of ca. 1.6 to 2.4 nm (coincident with superhelicene dimensions) hint at the presence of stacked monolayers (ESI, Fig. S43–S46†).
Based on this initial study, enantiopure thin film formation was pursued with both (M,M,P)- and (P,P,M)-1. In this case, higher concentration solutions (ca. 5 mg mL−1 in CHCl3) deposited via drop-casting led to films with observable absorptions of ca. 0.25 au. (ESI, Fig. S47†). Both absorption and emission spectra perfectly reproduced the band patterns measured in solution (ESI, Fig. S48†), and the same was observed for the ECD and CPL spectra (Fig. 4). The obtained |gabs| and |glum| reached values between 1 × 10−3 and 3 × 10−3 (ESI, Fig. S50 and S51†). To prove the absence of anisotropy effects, the CPL spectra of both enantiomers were recorded from the back side and by turning the quartz substrate by 180°, observing the same sign for each enantiomer (ESI, Fig. S52†).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthesis procedures, HPLC traces, copies of NMR spectra, optical and electrochemical properties, theoretical calculations, and thin film information. See https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc03452b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |