Lilai
Sun
a,
Lu
Han
*a,
Na
Li
a,
Pengbo
Wang
a,
Mingyue
Wang
a,
Xudong
Luo
a and
Xibao
Li
*b
aSchool of Materials and Metallurgy, University of Science and Technology Liaoning, Anshan, 114051, China. E-mail: hanlu@ustl.edu.cn
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Nanchang Hangkong University, Nanchang, 330063, China. E-mail: lixibao@nchu.edu.cn
First published on 31st August 2022
Cu2O has begun to show its charm and gain popularity in various photoelectrochemical (PEC) processes, but fast charge recombination and photochemical instability always limit its PEC water splitting activity and stability. Furthermore, H2O wetting on the Cu2O photocathode is the premise for PEC reaction, while research on carrier separation, photostability and still wettability has not been brought to the forefront. Herein, a self-polymerized dopamine coating is employed to directly anchor TiO2 (P25) on the surface of a Cu2O film electrode; nanoscale particles facilitate polydopamine (PDA) conformal assembly on Cu2O polyhedra. A ternary Cu2O/PDA/TiO2 composite photocathode is obtained and shows boosted PEC activity and stability. The advantages of this unique design are mainly reflected in three aspects: (1) the married heterojunction of TiO2/Cu2O provides a persistent driving force for charge separation by PDA natural adhesive properties; (2) the conversion of hydrophobicity–hydrophilicity is achieved to improve the wettability of the Cu2O film electrode assisted by conformal PDA coating; (3) the improvement of PEC stability is due to the inhibition of Cu2O photocorrosion covered by the PDA shelter. This advance bodes well for the development of the PEC field founded on multifunctional PDA.
Cu2O + 2H2 + 2e− → 2Cu + H2O | (1) |
Cu2O + H2O → 2CuO + 2H+ + 2e− | (2) |
TiO2 plays a positive role in alleviating the above photocorrosion and carrier recombination. By knowing the dominant deactivation mode of Cu2O, fabricating a chemically inert coating is an effective way to prevent Cu2O from contacting the electrolyte solution with redox activity.10,11 A TiO2 coating is an excellent candidate, which allows photogenerated electrons to transfer through owing to its appropriate conduction band position.12,13 An atomic layer deposited TiO2 coating can efficiently improve the stability of the p–n Cu2O photocathode in aqueous conditions reported by Gong et al.14 Furthermore, lowering the diffusion energy barrier of photogenerated carriers can be achieved by constructing a semiconductor heterojunction. The formed type-II or direct Z heterojunction by TiO2/Cu2O provides a strong driving force for charge separation.15,16 Zhang et al.17 reported that the Cu2O/TiO2 p–n heterojunction exhibited better H2 production activity and stability than pure Cu2O and TiO2.
In addition, the PEC process and performance is deeply affected kinetically by the adsorption and desorption of reactants and products.18 Theoretically, proper wettability can promote the adsorption of reactants.19 H2O attached to the photocathode serves as a reactant in PEC water splitting. In this case, the hydrophilicity of the Cu2O photocathode is particularly important. Zhao et al.20 electrodeposited NiFe hydroxide/NiFe phosphate on carbon fiber paper. The phosphate groups improved the electrode surface wettability and created more accessible active sites, which meant that electrons could transfer rapidly. Wang et al.21 modified a variety of molecular monolayers with different functional groups on TiO2 nanotube arrays. The surface chemical composition and wettability of the photoelectrode influenced the oxidation–reduction reaction on the surface and interface. Takayuki et al.22 observed that the bubble size on the electrode surface increased with the decrease of the wettability through an in situ video during the HER. This result means that ohmic loss was increased and the electrode active surface was blocked. These reports indicate that the wettability of the electrode surface has an important effect on catalytic activity. However, efforts to improve the Cu2O photocathode wettability for PEC water splitting have not been brought to the forefront. Almost no work takes into account photostability, carrier separation and still wettability for the Cu2O photocathode.
Herein, we report a simple nanoscale TiO2-induced polymerization of biology-based dopamine on a Cu2O polyhedron photocathode to enhance the PEC activity and stability. This work creatively introduces functional nanoparticles to optimize dopamine polymerization on an uneven and hydrophobic Cu2O polyhedron photocathode, not only fabricating a novel and married Cu2O/PDA/TiO2 heterojunction structure and creating a hydrophilic reduction reaction interface by the buried nanoparticle PDA overlayer for highly efficient PEC H2O reduction, but also providing a novel strategy for improving the photochemical stability of Cu2O semiconductors in various applications.
Cu2O/PDA electrodes were prepared by self-polymerization of dopamine. First, 0.1 g dopamine hydrochloride was fully dissolved in an appropriate amount of tris–HCl buffer (pH = 8.6, 2 mM) to form a dopamine solution with a concentration of 2 mg mL−1. Then, the Cu2O electrode was immersed in the above solution, and a PDA coating was polymerized on the electrode surface after 3 h.
The preparation method of the Cu2O/PDA/P25 electrode was similar to the previous method, but an additional 0.1 g P25 was added to the solution.
For comparison, Cu2O/P25 electrodes were prepared just by immersing Cu2O electrodes in the solution by dissolving 0.1 g of P25 in 50 mL of DI water.
Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was performed using an AC amplitude of 5 mV and a frequency range between 100 kHz and 1 Hz. The measured EIS data were obtained at an open circuit voltage under illumination. All of the potentials mentioned above were converted to the RHE reference electrode by the Nernst equation:
ERHE(V) = EAg/AgCl(V) + 0.059 pH + 0.197 |
The applied bias photon-to-current efficiency (ABPE) was calculated as follows:
In Mott–Schottky measurements, potential sweeps were carried out from 0.5 V to −0.7 V vs. Ag/AgCl. The AC frequency used in the impedance measurements was 50 Hz. The calculation of valence band and carrier concentration is based on previous work.23
XPS analysis was conducted to confirm the surface chemical state details. Fig. 2(a) exhibits the survey spectrum, where Cu 2p, C 1s and O 1s signals are clearly observed in the obtained samples. Fig. 2(b) and (d) show typical N 1s spectra of Cu2O/PDA and Cu2O/PDA/P25. The high-resolution N 1s region is fit with three peaks assigned to primary (R–NH2), secondary (R–NH–R), and tertiary/aromatic (N–R) amine functionalities, which represent the chemical bonds of polydopamine and its intermediates, respectively.25–27 The two characteristic peaks of 951.72 eV and 931.93 eV in the high-resolution XPS spectrum of Cu 2p (Fig. 2(b)) correspond to Cu 2p1/2 and Cu 2p3/2, respectively, which are consistent with the characteristics of Cu+ in Cu2O.28 The remaining two peaks at 946.37 and 943.37 eV are satellite peaks of Cu+.29 The signal of N 1s and Ti 2p peaks can be clearly observed in Cu2O/PDA/P25, whereas the signal of the Cu 2p peak became weak after the introduction of PDA, which demonstrated that the PDA coating can act as a shield, affecting the X-ray diffraction toward the Cu2O. Two characteristic peaks in the high-resolution spectrum of Ti 2p at 464.08 eV and 458.38 eV shown in Fig. 2(d) also correspond to 2p1/2 and 2p3/2, and the other peak is a satellite peak. All of the results indicated the successful encapsulation of P25 nanoparticles into a PDA coating on Cu2O substances.
The surface morphology and wettability of the electrodes were analyzed using AFM and the contact angle underwater, as shown in Fig. 3(a)–(d). The measured roughness values (Ra) are 122 nm, 119 nm, 143 nm and 98 nm, respectively. The uniformly smooth cubic and pyramidal grains of Cu2O can be observed on the AFM 3D images and SEM image of the Cu2O electrode. The morphology of Cu2O is similar to that reported previously (Fig. 3(e)).30 The pristine Cu2O electrode's contact angle is 92.96°, showing its hydrophobicity (Fig. 3(a)). Self-polymerization of dopamine onto the Cu2O polyhedron electrode surface forms a coating with nanoscale thickness, as shown in Fig. 3(b) and (f); meanwhile the contact angle becomes significantly smaller at 77.12°, which is due to the successful anchoring of numerous hydrophilic groups arising from the PDA coating.31 PDA-induced surface modification is again echoed in the XPS results. It is believed that the transition from hydrophobicity to hydrophilicity may accelerate the reaction dynamics of water participation, resulting in improvement of the PEC activity. After introducing hydrophobic P25 nanoparticles, the contact angle becomes larger at 120.59°. As is shown in Fig. 3(c), P25 nanoparticles tend to cluster in the protruding part of the Cu2O pyramidal grains, resulting in a greater surface roughness. According to the Wenzel model, the greater the roughness on the hydrophobic surface, the more hydrophobic it is.32,33 Interestingly, the surface hydrophobicity reverses when P25 nanoparticles are used in combination with dopamine. On the one hand, the nanoparticles speed up the polymerization of dopamine.34,35 On the other hand, they would be drawn into the viscous fluid to fill the gaps of the uneven Cu2O pyramidal grains, reducing the surface roughness of the electrode. Nanoscale particles better collaborate surface hydrophilic modification,36 resulting in a smaller roughness of the Cu2O pyramidal grains, presenting hydrophilicity with a smaller contact angle of 64.79° on the electrode surface (Fig. 3(d) and (g)). And the membrane of 3.3 μm thickness was observed through the side image of SEM (Fig. 3(h)). An enhanced interface hydrophilicity was achieved by polymerizing dopamine assisted by P25 onto the surface of the Cu2O/TiO2 heterostructure. The novel integration of inorganic and organic materials would create a synergistic modification effect for the unstable and hydrophobic Cu2O photocathode to yield enhanced PEC water reduction performance.
Linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) curves record the photocurrent response impacted by applied potential, as shown in Fig. 4(a). Pristine Cu2O exhibits 1 mA cm−2 photoresponse at 0 V vs. RHE due to the presence of surface recombination sites of bare Cu2O in practical applications; besides, the photocurrent density of either Cu2O/PDA or Cu2O/P25 increased remarkably, indicating that hydrophilic modification, photosensitivity and the p/n heterojunction are conductive to the carrier separation and transfer.17,22 In particular, at 0 V vs. RHE, the photocurrent in Cu2O/PDA/P25 yields 2.3 mA cm−2, which is approximately 2.3 times that of the pristine Cu2O electrode. Accordingly, the applied bias photon-to-current efficiency (ABPE) reaches up to 0.12%, which is about 4 times higher than that of the Cu2O electrode (Fig. 4(b)).
Fig. 4 (a) Linear sweep voltammetry curves. (b) ABPE. (c) Amperometric I–t curves. (d) Mott–Schottky test. |
Amperometric I–t curves are presented in Fig. 4(c), showing a renewable and fast photocurrent response. The photocurrent density remains uniform with the LSV curves above mentioned. It can be noticed that the photocurrent density of the pristine Cu2O electrode declines rapidly with test time, implying its instability under irradiation in electrolyte. A sluggish descent of photocurrent is observed when introducing a PDA overlayer, implying that photocorrosion is obviously alleviated. This improvement is more effective and persistent as the PDA layer provides shelter for Cu2O, delaying the loss resulting from photooxidation and photoreduction of Cu2O, but is not thick enough to have a light-shielding effect to weaken electronic migration. Nevertheless the PDA after polymerization within a short time has tiny pinholes,37 so a sluggish photocorrosion over Cu2O/PDA may still proceed with constant light. Besides, the formation of the Cu2O/P25 heterojunction promotes the transfer of photogenerated carriers, which inhibits the photocorrosion of Cu2O to a certain extent. On the integration of PDA and P25, a synchronous promotion of photocurrent density and stability was obtained. As for the improved photocurrent density, naturally viscous PDA induced married heterogeneous junctions between Cu2O and commercial P25 to further promote carrier separation.38 In addition, modifying the Cu2O photocathode hydrophobicity by decorating with a PDA coating buried P25 to improve its hydrophilicity is achieved, enhancing the adsorption of the reactants (H+/H2O). A Mott–Schottky test was performed on the electrodes, as shown in Fig. 4(d). The slope of the linear part of the curve is negative, which also proves that the Cu2O conductivity type on the electrodeposition was p-type.39 The flat-band potentials of Cu2O and Cu2O/PDA/P25 are 0.78 eV and 0.83 eV, and the carrier densities are 1.036 × 10−21 cm−3 and 1.61 × 10−21 cm−3, respectively. Thus, this kinetically facilitates the reaction from promoting the carrier separation and transfer and thus the photocurrent density becomes larger. Echoing the results of Fig. 3(d), the best stability in the photocathode half reaction is on account of the markedly improved photocorrosion resistance of Cu2O, resulting from the unique space-filling P25 induced PDA overlayer.
According to the above experimental results, the enhanced PEC activities are attributed to the unique structure composed of space-filling P25 induced PDA overlayer. To further prove this assumption, the photoexcitation process was studied by photoluminescence (PL) spectra to probe the internal electron transfer dynamics.40 As shown in Fig. 5(a), all four electrodes have two distinct emission bands, which are mainly attributed to the band gap emission and the radiative transition due to the defect state.41 The peak nearly at 470 nm is attributed to the band gap emission. And another emission band centered at 680–710 nm is the radiative transition due to the defect state. The luminescence intensity of the Cu2O/PDA/P25 composite electrode decreases sharply compared to the other samples, which shows an efficient separation of the surface electron–hole pairs and a significant suppression of the photogenerated carrier recombination. It's worth noting that the defect state emission becomes smaller after loading the PDA overlayer, which is proof of the passivation effect arising from PDA effectively reducing the electrode surface defects.24
Fig. 5 (a) Room temperature PL spectra. (b) Fitted results of TRPL spectra. (c) Nyquist plots at open-circuit voltage under illumination. |
Time resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) spectra were thereafter recorded and are displayed in Fig. 5(b), providing a quantitative lifetime of the photogenerated carrier. τ1 and τ2 represent the radiative and non-radiative recombination, respectively, and these two factors determine the electron dynamics.38,42 Cu2O/PDA/P25 possesses the shortest τ1 lifetime (0.24 ns) compared to Cu2O (0.46 ns), Cu2O/PDA (0.28ns) and Cu2O/P25 (0.26 ns), which indicates its improved band-to-band recombination of charge carriers.43 Meanwhile, Cu2O/PDA/P25 also owns the most efficient non-radiative decay pathway, giving the shortest τ2 lifetime (2.09 ns).44 The shortening of the average lifetime (τav) of Cu2O/PDA/P25 implies that integration of PDA and P25 allows efficient electron–hole separation and migration. Due to the synergistic effect of the married Cu2O/P25 heterojunction glued by PDA, surface passivation and increased wettability, the Cu2O/PDA/P25 ternary composite electrode possesses the largest transfer rate of photogenerated charge carriers.45 The charge transfer rate constants (kct) of Cu2O/PDA, Cu2O/P25 and Cu2O/PDA/P25 are calculated to be 0.57 × 109 s−1, 0.60 × 109 s−1 and 1.87 × 109 s−1, respectively. These quantified results provide strong evidence for the efficient charge transfer of the Cu2O/PDA/P25 electrode.46 In addition, the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) Nyquist spectrum is shown in Fig. 5(c). The smaller arc and smaller Rct values indicate the smaller the charge transfer resistance between the electrode and electrolyte.47,48 The wetter Cu2O/PDA/P25 electrode has a significantly lower surface charge transfer resistance. These charge dynamics results well match with the results of PEC performance. More efficient separation of photogenerated carriers and faster interfacial charge transfer favor higher PEC performance.49 The rational design of an efficient carrier separation transfer path is demonstrated by the PL and EIS results to achieve a lower carrier recombination rate.
The UV-Vis diffuse reflectance spectra are shown in Fig. 6(a) and (b). Compared with the Cu2O electrode, PDA coating does not block light absorption because it is the eumelanin polymer that has high light absorption.50 According to our previous work, the black PDA exhibits a good capability for light absorption between 200 and 800 nm.27 Moreover, an apparent enhancement of absorption can be seen for the composites.51 The band gap values of different electrodes are obtained from the Tauc plots, as shown in Fig. 6(c). From the calculated valence band and conduction band energy, a band diagram is presented in Fig. 6(d).52–54
Fig. 6 The UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectra of (a) Cu2O and Cu2O/PDA and (b) Cu2O and Cu2O/PDA/P25, (c) Tauc plots, and (d) schematic diagram of charge transfer between Cu2O and P25. |
On the basis of the analysis above, potential mechanisms of ternary Cu2O/PDA/P25 for PEC enhancement in activity and stability have been further illustrated in Fig. 7. Under light illumination, the water reduction process based on the pristine Cu2O polyhedron electrode gets a slow reaction kinetics, owing to its fast carrier recombination and surface hydrophobicity. Meanwhile, bare Cu2O polyhedrons in direct contact with the electrolyte are also threatened by photocorrosion. Once the integration of inorganic P25 and organic dopamine is employed to modify the Cu2O polyhedron surface, P25 nanoparticles as connectors are not only involved in accelerating the polymerization of dopamine but also they would be drawn into the viscous fluid to fill the gaps of the uneven Cu2O pyramidal grains, forming a unique space-filling P25-induced PDA overlayer on Cu2O. This is verified by both AFM images and contact angle analysis. The novel heterojunction structure set several favorable stages for PEC enhancement in activity and stability. Firstly, with P25 joining, a II-type heterojunction of Cu2O/TiO2 is formed. Under light illumination, both Cu2O and TiO2 simultaneously produce photo-induced electron–hole pairs. The electron and hole transfers are reversed under internal electric field forces due to the different energy band positions; electrons are transferred from Cu2O to P25 and holes are transferred from P25 to Cu2O. With the boost of PDA, the married coupling interfaces of the TiO2/Cu2O heterojunction provide a persistent driving force for charge separation. As a result, a lower charge recombination rate is achieved as proven by the PL and EIS results. Secondly, as an electron donor, PDA can also contribute to light absorption, which echoes the results of UV-Vis diffuse reflectance spectra. In particular, it is worth mentioning that there is no light-shielding in the ultrathin PDA layer, whose electronic tunneling effect is not weakened in the meantime. Thirdly, the gullies of the Cu2O polyhedron surface were filled up with nanoscale P25 assisted by dopamine polymerization, causing roughness reduction. Thus, an improved hydrophilic PDA overlayer with numerous hydrophilic groups was coated on the Cu2O polyhedron surface to reverse its hydrophobic disadvantage. This operation improves the wettability of the electrode surface and absorbs more reactants (H+/H2O), thus kinetically promoting the rate of catalytic reaction and improving the catalytic activity. Finally, the unique space-filling P25 induced PDA overlayer provides structurally optimal shelter to satisfy the inhibition of Cu2O photocorrosion from active radicals dissolved in the electrolyte, rendering the improvement sustainable. This echoes the results and discussions of amperometric I–t curves. In conclusion, we have assembled the multiple effects of polydopamine (Table 1); the integration of P25 and PDA induces a synergistic modification effect for the poor carrier utilization, hydrophobic and unstable Cu2O photocathode to yield enhanced PEC water reduction performance.
Fig. 7 The schematic of the catalytic reaction promoted by different wettability of the electrode surface. |
Materials | Function | Ref. |
---|---|---|
Cu2O/PDA/P25 | Assisting in heterostructure construction, modulating wettability and inhibiting photocorrosion | This work |
g-C3N4@PDA/BiOBr | PDA as an efficient electron transfer mediator | 55 |
TiO2/PDA | Enhancing the hole–electron separation and harvesting visible light | 50 |
CdS@PDA/TiO2 NTAs | Photosensitization and inhibition of CdS photocorrosion | 27 |
Ti/TiO2NT@PDA-AgNP | PDA coating can act as an in situ reducing agent capable of reducing some metal ions to form metal nanoparticles | 56 |
PDA15/ZnO/Co3O4 | The enhanced CO2 adsorption/activation capacity by PDA modification | 57 |
Ag/AgCl/polydopamine TiO2 | The polydopamine acts as a stabilizer and reductant in fabricating the photocatalyst | 58 |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |