Mark Merzlyak*a, Alexei Solovchenkoa and Sergei Pogosyanb
aDepartment of Physiology of Microorganisms, Faculty of Biology, Moscow State University, 119992, GSP-2, Moscow, Russia. E-mail: mnm@6.CellImm.bio.msu.ru; m_merzlyak@mail.ru; Fax: +7 095 9393807; Tel: +7 095 9392587
bDepartment of Biophysics, Faculty of Biology, Moscow State University, 119992, GSP-2, Moscow, Russia. E-mail: pogosyan@biophys.msu.ru; Fax: +7 095 9391115; Tel: +7 095 9395150
First published on 25th February 2005
In Aloe arborescens Mill. leaves, strong sunlight or its combination with drought induces the accumulation of the red keto-carotenoid, rhodoxanthin. Simultaneously, the transformation of chloroplasts into chromoplasts accompanied by degradation of thylakoid membranes and formation of plastoglobuli, large in size and number, takes place. Depending on stress conditions the build up of rhodoxantin occurred along with the loss of chlorophyll or on the background of relatively high content of the pigment in the leaves. Microspectrophotometrical measurements showed the presence of chlorophyll-free plastids and retention of carotenoids during leaf adaptation to strong sunlight. The plastid spectra contained absorption bands of common for higher plants carotenoids together with those of rhodoxantin, with absorption maxima situated in the blue (440–480 nm) and the green ranges of the spectrum, respectively. The studies of whole-leaf optical properties revealed a broad band of rhodoxanthin absorption in the blue–green range peaking near 540–550 nm. Within this spectral band the accumulation of rhodoxanthin occurring, probably, in plastoglobuli considerably increased light absorption by stressed Aloe leaves. A possible photoprotective function of rhodoxanthin and other carotenoids as an internal light trap analogous to that accomplished by anthocyanins in other plant species is discussed.
The carotenoids (Car) represent a group of pigments exerting photoprotective effects via different mechanisms. Within thylakoid membranes, these effects are related with deactivation of chlorophyll (Chl) excited states, quenching of singlet oxygen, interception of free radicals and dissipation of the excessive absorbed light energy via xanthophyll cycle.3,16,17 Some lines of evidence suggest that the accumulation of Car, which takes place in plants under high-light stress conditions and in the course of senescence, is related with their ability to trap harmful radiation and thus provide photoprotection in the blue range.18
The Car are represented by xanthophylls and carotenes in the majority of higher plant species, which do not contain keto-groups (referred to subsequently as non-keto Car, NKC) and exhibit characteristic three-peaked absorption spectra between 400 and 480 nm and are yellow-to-orange in colour.19,20 Although the composition of higher plant Car is highly conserved,21 under stressful conditions the accumulation of rhodoxanthin (Rhd, 4′,5′-didehydro-4,5′-retro-β,β-carotene-3,3′-dione) takes place in the leaves of some species. Due to the presence of two conjugated keto-groups rhodoxanthin absorption maximum of this Car is situated at longer wavelengths, the spectrum does not exhibit fine structure and its solutions are red.19,20
The reversible colour changes from green to reddish-brown as a result of Rhd accumulation have been extensively studied in the sun-exposed winter needles of several gymnosperms (Cryptomeria, Metasequoia, Taxodium, Chamaecyparis and Thuja)22–26 and during cold hardening of western red cedar (Thuja plicata) seedlings.28 Histological studies of Cryptomeria japonica and Taxodium distichum showed that the transition of chloroplasts to chromopolasts took place along with changes in coloration of sun leaves and Rhd was found in form of reddish particles inside chromoplasts.23 The measurements of Chl fluorescence induction curves allowed Han et al. to suggest that ‘rhodoxanthin might play an important role in long-term acclimation to cold’25 and its ‘accumulation functions to decrease the light intensity reaching the photosynthetic apparatus’27 and that it might in this way protect the photosynthetic machinery. However, little evidence for such a role of Rhd is available in the literature,25 although recently Han et al.26 estimated that in C. japonica needles Rhd intercepts about 12% of incident light.
An important information on physiological function of a pigment as an internal light screen and/or light trap could be obtained through the comparative studies of optical properties of tissues from stressed and non-stressed plants, e.g., those taken from sun and shade.10,11,18,29 For such experiments, species with large leaf blades are more suitable than needles of coniferous species.25,26
Many tropical rosette plants, often possessing CAM metabolism, are able to tolerate extremely wide variety of illumination conditions and their rapid changes. In Aloe vera subjected to artificial drought under high irradiance Diaz et al.30 observed remarkable changes in leaf Car content including the build up of significant amounts of Rhd. Aloe arborescens, probably the most widely cultivated species of the genus Aloe in the world,31 also develops reddish leaf coloration under natural light-stress conditions. Thus, during the winter period recently planted aloe cuttings often turn bright red in colour as a result of the action of strong sunlight and/or drought. Establishment of the root system or shading causes the plants to revert to green coloration (Professor Y. Gutterman, personal communication, Fig. 1).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 The appearance of intact (left) and stressed (right) Aloe arborescens plants and their leaf cross-sections (lower plates). |
In this paper we examined influence of natural light-stress conditions on A. arborescens with special reference to possible photoprotective function of Rhd. The main goal of the study was to estimate the effect(s) of Rhd on optical properties of both whole leaves and plastids in situ. We also investigated the ultrastructural changes of A. arborescens plastids occurring in the course of the plant adaptation to strong solar radiation.
The pigment composition in aloe was studied with the spectral reconstruction method (simulation of the absorption spectrum of an extract under examination by a linear combination of the absorption spectra of its constituents) previously developed, in particular, for analysing Car in higher plant leaf and algae extracts.34 In contrast to these systems, within aloe in addition to Chl one should expect a significant contribution of Rhd to extract absorption in the green–orange range.30 Therefore, aloe extract spectra were fitted using the least squares approach to finding the optimum values of the fitting parameters for fiducial pigments (i.e. Chl a, Chl b and Rhd) between 530 and 700 nm. Then the spectral curves for these pigments were extrapolated to shorter wavelengths and spectra for NKC and Rhd were calculated.
The absorption spectra of single plastids were measured in leaf cross-sections with customized Leitz MPV2 system (Ernst Leitz Wetzlar GMBH, Germany) equipped with a 150 W high-pressure xenon lamp as a light source and a USB 2000 (grating #2) spectrometer (Ocean Optics, USA); the microscope was set to trans-illumination mode. To equalise the spectral energy output of the light source with spectral sensitivity of the spectrometer two 5 mm thick purple glass FS-2 filters (Krasnogorsk, Russia) were placed between the light source and the sample. The cross-sections were enclosed between a slide and a cover slip in 66 mM phosphate buffer (pH 7.0). The measured area was selected by an iris diaphragm adjusted to a single plastid size. The light passed through the sample was directed by the microscope optics to the spectrometer and the spectra were recorded between 400 and 800 nm. The absorption of the sample was calculated as A(λ) = −log(E1(λ)/E2(λ)), where E1(λ) and E2(λ) are irradiances of a sample and reference (adjacent to the sample area), respectively.
For electron microscopy the fixation either in glutaraldehyde–OsO4 or in glutaraldehyde–KMnO4 (all from Sigma, USA) was used. The ultrathin sections were prepared with LKB-8800 ultratom (LKB, Sweden) and examined under a JEM-100 B transmission electron microscope (JEOL, Japan).
The ultrastructural investigation showed that in the green leaves the plastids possessed the shape and inner organisation characteristic of sun leaf chloroplasts (Fig. 2A), containing well developed granae and stromal thylakoids with readily discernible membranes and one or two large starch granules laying in the centre of the organelle. The onset of chromoplast formation brought about progressive degeneration of the chloroplast membrane system and a loss of granal structure (Fig. 2). The membranes of stroma thylakoids progressively blurred and eventually disappeared during chloroplast–chromoplast transition. Thylakoid membranes of granae also became less distinct until the individual thylakoids became indiscernible, the regions occupied by granae turned to a homogenous electrondense round-shaped loci. Most striking features of plastids from the red leaves included the absence of thylakoids and appearance of globular structures with sharp edges possessing higher electron density than adjacent stroma. The starch granules in such plastids were preserved or even increased in size. In the red leaves the osmiophylic globules vastly increased in size and number and occupied a considerable part of plastid volume (Fig. 2C).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Ultrastructure of plastids of green (A), reddish-green (B), and red (C) leaves of A. arborescens. G—granae, S—starch grain, P—plastoglobuli. Bar = 0.5 µm. A, B—fixation with glutaraldehyde and KMnO4, C—fixation with glutaraldehyde and OsO4. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Typical absorption spectra of aloe plastids of green leaves (1) to red leaves (6). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Representative reflection spectra of whole aloe leaves. Reflectances at 500 and 700 nm are shown as symbols and connected by dashed lines to show difference between them. Insert: Relationship between reflectances at 500 and 700 nm for visually green (open symbols) and reddish to red (closed symbols) leaves. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Reflection (A) and absorption (B) spectra of aloe adaxial chlorenchyma tissues. Panel A, insert: Relationship between reflectances at 550 and 700 nm for visually green (open symbols) and reddish to red (closed symbols) leaves. A line represents a linear fit for R550vs.R700 for whole green leaves (see Fig. 4, insert). Panel B. The lower curve is the trace of the standard deviation of absorptance (right scale) for all samples. The spectra of green and red specimens with close chlorophyll absorption near 678 nm shown as symbols were used for comparison and further analysis in Fig. 6. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Absorption spectra and pigment analysis of green and red aloe adaxial chlorenchyma (AC) tissues (see also Fig. 5). Panel A. Absorbance spectra of AC from green (1) and red (2) leaves; (3) difference spectrum ‘red − green’. Insert: AC chlorophyll, non-ketocarotenoid (NKC) and rhodoxanthin (Rhd) content. Panel B. Absorbance spectra of pigments from green (1, 3 and 5) and red (2, 4, 6 and 7) AC (see panel A). 1 and 2 are the spectra of total extracts; spectra 3–7 are results of spectral reconstruction analysis for NKC (3 and 4) and Rhd (5 and 6); 7–spectrum of total carotenoids (NKC + Rhd) from the red AC. Insert: HPLC of aloe pigments form green (1) and red (2) AC. Chromatograms are normalised to the magnitude of chlorophyll b peak. 3–difference between chromatograms 2 and 1. N—neoxanthin, V—violaxanthin, A—antheraxanthin, R′—rhodoxanthin derivative, R—rhodoxanthin, L—lutein, Z—zeaxanthin, Phea—phaeophytin a, and C—β-carotene. |
To characterise pigment composition aloe leaves were extracted with the method allowing separation of water- and liposoluble components.10 The water–methanol phase of extracts from both green and red aloe leaves obtained was pale-yellow in colour. The addition of hydrochloric acid (final concentration 0.1%) did not result in the appearance of characteristic absorption near 530 nm indicating the absence of anthocyanin pigments. Chl and Car were recovered in chloroform phase; the HPLC (Fig. 6B, insert, curves 1 and 2) and TLC (not shown) analyses revealed the presence of the NKC (neoxanthin, violaxanthin, anteraxanthin, zeaxanthin and β-carotene) common for majority of higher plant leaves.21,37 The light-stressed A. arborescens leaves contained significant amounts of the red carotenoid, Rhd. The presence of small amounts of a Rhd derivative (probably, its isomer24) with lower retention time should be also mentioned (Fig. 6B, insert). For both green and red aloe leaves no evidence has been obtained for the accumulation of Car esters eluted in this HPLC system between Chl a and carotene(s).
Typically for higher plants,36,38,39 whole-leaf and AC reflectance was low in the blue and high in the NIR (750–800 nm) and pronounced band of Chl absorption peaking near 678 nm was present in the red range of the spectrum (Figs. 4 and 5). Reflection spectral features of whole leaves and AC were similar but in the former case reflectance in the NIR did not exceed 30–34%. Characteristic of green leaves29,38,39 relatively high reflectance was recorded within the range 550–600 nm and R550 and R700 were close and highly correlated in a wide range of their changes (Fig. 4 and 5, inserts). Both in whole leaves and AC the development of red coloration was accompanied by a decrease in reflectance between 500 and 600 nm, moving the green edge of reflectance towards longer wavelengths and a strong decrease of R550 as compared with R700 (Figs. 4 and 5, inserts). In red leaves as well as in their AC R550 nm was low and reached 6.5 and 8.5%, respectively.
In spite of relatively low Chl content (<10 nmol cm−2, see Fig. 6A) AC from aloe leaves possessed high absorption (Figs. 5 and 6). Throughout visible range leaf absorption significantly exceeded equivalent absorption of pigments recovered in chloroform phase. Thus, in the red band leaf absorbance was more than two-fold higher. The difference between leaf and extract absorption was especially high near 550 nm in green but not in red leaves (cf. curves 1 and 2 in Fig. 6A and B). AC absorption spectra in Figs. 5 and 6 demonstrate that the development of red pigmentation is associated with an increase of absorption in the green range, which exceeded 80% near 550 nm. The standard deviation (STD) spectrum calculated for the entire data set revealed a strong peak of absorption variation near 550 nm as well as a band 620–700 nm with a gap around 678 nm (Fig. 5B). At wavelengths shorter than 500 nm absorption possessed a low variation especially below 410–420 nm.
To estimate Rhd spectral properties in aloe leaves, two AC samples obtained from green and red leaves with close Chl content and absorption in the red range of the spectrum were compared (Fig. 6). The difference ‘red–green’ absorbance spectrum of AC showed a broad band 450–600 nm bearing a peak centred at 535–540 nm with a small shoulder near 460–470 nm (Fig. 6A).
In accordance with optical measurements, both samples possessed close Chl content (Fig. 6A, insert) and equivalent absorption of the extracts in the red bands of Chl a and b (Fig. 6B). Furthermore, the spectral reconstruction analysis of the extracts showed very close content and spectral properties of NKC in the red and green tissues. Red AC accumulated Rhd in amounts close to that of total NKC. Then, Rhd absorption in its maximum (510 nm) was comparable with that of NKC (at 452 nm) (Fig. 6). HPLC analysis (Fig. 6B, insert) showed the presence and close relative content of Chl a, Chl b as well as individual NKC in both AC samples and remarkably high amount of Rhd in the red sample. The presence of small amounts of Rhd in chloroform extract from visually green AC should be also mentioned. The difference between the chromatograms normalised to the amplitude of the Chl b peak (Fig. 6B, insert, curve 3) revealed only a small increase in content of some xanthophylls in red leaves. Thus, the spectral difference between absorption of red and green AC (Fig. 6A) could be to a large extent attributed to Rhd.
Ultrastructural observations showed that the adaptation A. arborescens to the stressful conditions is accompanied by a deep rearrangement of chloroplasts including degradation of thylakoids and accumulation of globular electron-dense structures (probably of lipidic nature) resembling the osmyophylic globules encountered in plastids of senescing leaves.41–44 Taking into account the (ultra)structural details observed (Figs. 1 and 2), the plastids of the red aloe leaves can be regarded as chromoplasts and, more specifically, carotenoidoplasts.
In the progress of chloroplast-to-chromoplast transformation the plastids gradually lost Chl, turned reddish in colour and spectral features of Car absorption appeared in their spectra (Fig. 3) strongly suggesting retention of Car over Chl. At advanced stages of Chl-loss two types of Car absorption became apparent in plastid spectra. The comparison of plastid spectra with reconstructed absorption spectra of Car in leaf extracts (Fig. 6B) makes it possible to distinguish two main types of Car absorption in plastids: attributable to NKC (in the range 460–500 nm) and to Rhd at longer wavelengths appearing as shoulders in the region 520–550 nm (Fig. 3). Such a large shift of Rhd absorption maximum compared to solutions (Fig. 6B, see19,20,29) may involve aggregation of the pigment due to its high local concentration, presumably in lipid globules.
The contributions of NKC and Rhd into absorption of individual plastids were different and frequently the spectral features of Rhd appeared on NKC background (Fig. 3, curves 3–6). In dark red plastids a strong absorption in a broad unresolved band of 450–550 nm was observed (Fig. 3, curve 6). Thus, the spectral analysis of plastids in situ suggests that under high light/high light–drought stress in aloe leaves selective and significant destruction of Chl takes place along with retention of Car and/or activation of their biosynthesis. Then, it appears that in aloe plastids the build up of Rhd occurs in addition to that of NKC. The increase in the content of violaxanthin, zeaxanthin and lutein together with the accumulation of Rhd has been documented in A. vera plants subjected to drought under high light conditions.30 In winter-hardening sun-exposed needles of Cr. japonica, the increase in Rhd occurring along with Chl breakdown was also accompanied by an increase in xanthophylls of xanthophyll cycle pool.26,27 Nevertheless, it was concluded that Rhd might play a more important role than the volaxanthin cycle Car in protecting the photosynthetic apparatus from photodamage in winter.26 To the best of our knowledge, no evidence has been obtained on the involvement of Rhd in photoprotection within thylakoid membranes. It was reported that light-harvesting chlorophyll-protein complex of Cr. japonica does not retain Rhd.25 In contrast to some other non-native xanthophylls Rhd did not facilitate the reassembly of monomeric recombinant LHCIIb complex.37 Taking into account the changes of ultrastructure observed it is likely that the main depot of Rhd in aloe plastids is situated out of thylakoid membranes in plastoglobuli as it occurs in the course of leaf senescence.42 This is in consistence with the proposed role of osmiophylic globules as a depot for plastidic lipids, prenyl quinons and Car during dismantling of photosynthetic machinery43 as well as with photoprotective function of plastidic Car.18
Strong light stress induced remarkable changes in spectral light reflection and absorption by aloe leaves and AC (Figs. 4–6). Interestingly, all specimens investigated possessed characteristic Chl spectral features in the red, though microspectrophotometry revealed Chl-free plastids in stressed leaves (Fig. 3, curves 4–6). This indicates that aloe leaf optical properties are determined by proportion of plastids with different types of absorption and their distribution within tissue. The accumulation of Rhd under stress conditions brought about a decrease of reflectance along with increase of aloe leaf and AC absorption in the green range of the visible spectrum. The trace of the STD of absorption for AC obtained for leaves of colours from green to red (Fig. 5B) showed a significant variation in the orange–red range with a minimum near 678 nm, due to the saturation of the absorption at high content of the pigment,39 which indicates considerable changes in leaf Chl content. At the same time, high and almost invariable absorption was recorded below 500 nm in the spectral region governed by the combined absorption of Chl and NKC.38 A strong maximum of the STD of absorption peaking near 550 nm was situated in the band of 520–600 nm (Fig. 5B). The comparison of absorption spectra of selected red and green aloe leaves exhibiting close optical properties in the red as well as Chl and NKC content also strongly suggests that Rhd absorption in vivo occurs as a band in the blue–green range. According to these measurements the maximum of Rhd absorption in aloe leaves is located near 540 nm (Fig. 6).
The revealed spectral properties of Rhd in aloe leaves closely resemble those of anthocyanins in plant species accumulating these pigments.11,38 It was shown that quantitative analysis of anthocyanins could be performed using relationships between reflectances at 700 and 550 nm.38 Similarly to the leaves of anthocyanin-free species green aloe leaves possessed close R550 and R700 in a wide range of their changes. The reddening of the leaves manifested itself as the lowering of R550 compared with R700 (Fig. 4 and 5B, inserts). In winter, for aloe plants suffering from combined stress induced by light and drought, the decrease of R550 occurred at higher R700 values (Fig. 4). This suggests that under these conditions the adaptation of aloe involved a considerable decrease in Chl content, probably to reduce the amount of light absorbed by the photosynthetic apparatus. Another response has been observed in mature plants with established root systems. The relationship ‘R550vs.R700’ in Fig. 5, leaf absorption spectra and the data of pigment chemical analysis in Fig. 6 indicate that the accumulation of Rhd frequently took place in leaves with relatively high Chl content and even green leaves contained noticeable amounts of Rhd. It is tempting to speculate that in this case the level of protection provided by the build up of Rhd and, probably, by other mechanism(s) was sufficient to prevent a dramatic decrease in Chl content.
Collectively, the results of spectral measurements indicate that accumulation of Rhd in chromoplasts of light-stressed aloe leaves is able to provide a considerable attenuation of light absorbed by plant tissue in the green range of the visible spectrum. These findings are consistent with the proposed photoprotective function of Rhd,25–28 which is accomplished via efficient internal light trapping aimed to diminish the amount of radiation absorbed by Chl of photosynthetic apparatus under stressful conditions. In addition, it is possible to suggest that in plastids devoid of Chl, the combination of Rhd and NKC is able to protect lipids reserved in osmyophylic globules from the deleterious effects of irradiation over a broad spectral band.
As it has been already mentioned, the effect of plastidic Rhd on leaf light absorption closely resembles that of vacuolar anthocyanins. It appears that both pigments are able to serve as effective broad-band internal traps for radiation in the green range exactly in the gap between the bands of strong Chl and Car absorption in which light penetrates deeply into leaf tissues.11,38 Remarkably, anthocyanins and Rhd, the pigments disparate in terms of their biosynthesis, (photo)chemistry and subcellular localisation but with similar in vivo optical properties are relied upon by different plant species for the purposes of long-term adaptation to and protection against strong solar irradiation in the visible range.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and Owner Societies 2005 |