Open Access Article
Qian
Xu
a,
Linru
Guo
b,
Sigen
A
a,
Yongsheng
Gao
a,
Dezhong
Zhou
a,
Udo
Greiser
a,
Jack
Creagh-Flynn
a,
Hong
Zhang
a,
Yixiao
Dong
a,
Lara
Cutlar
a,
Fagang
Wang
c,
Wenguang
Liu
b,
Wei
Wang
*ab and
Wenxin
Wang
*ab
aCharles Institute of Dermatology, School of Medicine, University College Dublin, Dublin 4, Ireland. E-mail: wwgfz@tju.edu.cn; wenxin.wang@ucd.ie
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Tianjin Key Laboratory of Composite and Functional Materials, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China
cDepartment of Burn & Plastic Surgery, Shandong Provincial Hospital Affiliated to Shandong University, Jinan 250001, China
First published on 8th January 2018
Adjusting biomaterial degradation profiles to match tissue regeneration is a challenging issue. Herein, biodegradable hyperbranched poly(β-amino ester)s (HP-PBAEs) were designed and synthesized via “A2 + B4” Michael addition polymerization, and displayed fast gelation with thiolated hyaluronic acid (HA-SH) via a “click” thiol–ene reaction. HP-PBAE/HA-SH hydrogels showed tunable degradation profiles both in vitro and in vivo using diamines with different alkyl chain lengths and poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylates with varied PEG spacers. The hydrogels with optimized degradation profiles encapsulating ADSCs were used as injectable hydrogels to treat two different types of humanized excisional wounds – acute wounds with faster healing rates and diabetic wounds with slower healing and neo-tissue formation. The fast-degrading hydrogel showed accelerated wound closure in acute wounds, while the slow-degrading hydrogel showed better wound healing for diabetic wounds. The results demonstrate that the new HP-PBAE-based hydrogel in combination with ADSCs can be used as a well-controlled biodegradable skin substitute, which demonstrates a promising approach in the treatment of various types of skin wounds.
The unique pathophysiological abnormalities in different wound sites require a diversity of degradation rates of the biomaterials for functional tissue regeneration. An acute wound without disturbance in the healing process may achieve quick healing. As for chronic wounds, such as diabetic wounds (a severe complication of diabetes and frequently leading to amputation or death8), the pathogenic abnormalities in the wound site slow down the healing process.9 In this regard, by tuning the material degradation rates to match the rates of tissue formation, both normal physiological wounds and chronic wounds can proceed through orderly and timely reparation.
Poly(β-amino ester)s (PBAEs), synthesized via Michael addition between amines and acrylates, have attracted broad attention in recent years due to their highly flexible chemical compositions and properties, ease of synthesis, and low cost.10–12 The multiple ester groups on the backbone result in the degradation of PBAEs by hydrolysis in physiological conditions with non-cytotoxic amino acids and diols as side products. Due to these advantages, PBAEs have been widely utilized in biomedical applications. Langer and Anderson et al. have synthesized more than 2500 linear poly(β-amino ester)s (LPBAEs) as non-viral gene vectors which showed high gene transfection efficiency10,13,14 and excellent biosafety in animal experiments (e.g. rodents).15–17 Moreover, LPBAEs were also demonstrated as photo-crosslinkable macromers for the preparation of biodegradable crosslinked materials.18–20 However, significant limitations relating to the linear structure of LPBAE macromers render them less optimal candidates for hydrogel formation. Firstly, these LPBAE macromers with only two end acrylate functional groups result in materials with less crosslinking and weak mechanical strength. Secondly, to acquire LPBAE macromers terminated with acrylate groups, only low molecular weight oligomers (<6 kDa) can be synthesized because an excessive feed ratio of diacrylate to amine is needed. Due to the nature of the step-wise polymerization reaction, an increase in the feed ratio of diacrylate to amine has a substantial effect on yielding LPBAE macromers with low molecular weights (2–4 kDa).19 For instance, Anderson et al. synthesized a library of LPBAE macromers with a diacrylate to amine ratio of 1.2
:
1 only resulting in molecular weights of approximately 4 kDa.20 Thirdly, the amount of terminal vinyl groups is further reduced by the increase of molecular weight, resulting in a slow gelation rate and low gel fraction in the LPBAE macromer gelation system. It is a significant concern for the application of LPBAEs in biomedical fields that the gel fraction for LPBAE macromers (5–6 kDa) was only approximately 50%, suggesting that a high number of the polymer chains were not involved in the crosslinked network and would be released upon swelling of the network.18 Finally, the poor water solubility makes it very difficult for LPBAE macromers to form hydrogel systems and therefore compromises the practical application. Hyperbranched polymers are highly branched macromolecules with three-dimensional dendritic architectures. Their globular and dendritic architectures demonstrate unique properties such as abundant functional groups and good solubility. Thus, hyperbranched polymers with abundant terminal groups have shown more promise as injectable hydrogels.18,21,22 We hypothesize that PBAEs with hyperbranched structures can address the aforementioned obstacles and facilitate the fabrication of PBAE injectable hydrogel systems with diverse and tunable degradation rates.
In this paper, we have demonstrated the synthesis of a series of hyperbranched PBAEs (HP-PBAEs) via “A2 + B4” Michael addition methodology23 – an approach traditionally considered to directly form crosslinked structures with poor control (Fig. 1). HP-PBAEs display a fast gelation process with thiolated hyaluronic acid (HA-SH) via a “click” thiol–ene reaction leading to the formation of HP-PBAE hydrogels with controllable and adjustable degradation profiles. Two hydrogels with optimized degradation rates were used to encapsulate ADSCs and further injected onto humanized excisional wounds (the humanized wound model can better mimic the human cutaneous healing process24,25). Hydrogels with a faster degradation rate exhibited better wound healing in nondiabetic wounds, while hydrogels with a slower degradation rate showed a faster wound closure rate and significantly promoted the healing process as evidenced by histological assays for diabetic wounds.
:
1) only produced HP-PBAEs with a low molecular weight (2–5 kDa) while a low feed ratio (e.g., 2.2
:
1) led to fast gelation. Therefore, a feed ratio of 2.5
:
1 was selected with the aim of generating acrylate-terminated HP-PBAEs with a molecular weight of approximately 10 kDa. By varying the monomer combination of PEGDA (258, 575, and 700 Da) and diamine (ethylenediamine (EDA) and hexamethylenediamine (HDA)), a total of six HP-PBAEs were synthesized (ESI Table 1†). The resulting HP-PBAEs are named by the molecular weight of PEGDA and the type of diamine. For example, 700-EDA stands for HP-PBAE synthesized from PEGDA (700 Da) and EDA. The gel permeation chromatography (GPC) results are shown in ESI Fig. S1–S3,† and indicate a controlled polymerization without the occurrence of spontaneous gelation. The Mark–Houwink α values of the synthesised HP-PBAEs were all between 0.32 and 0.38 (ESI Fig. S4†). Since α < 0.5 in each of these polymers, they all are shown to have a typical branched structure. The compositions of all six polymers were verified by proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H-NMR) (ESI Fig. S5 and S6†). The primary amine group content in the polymer backbones was also determined by picrylsulfonic acid (TNBS) assay. The results showed that there were trace amounts of amine groups left in the polymer backbone, ranging from 4.0–11.8 μmol g−1 (ESI Fig. S7†). The well-designed hyperbranched PBAE polymers can be prepared through the “A2 + B4” strategy via kinetic control by stopping the reaction prior to the gelation points, which can address the limitation of the conventional “A2 + BB’B” approach.26 The HP-PBAE polymers will hydrolytically degrade and yield small molecules in PBS buffer (ESI Fig. S8 and S9†).20 The degradation test was monitored by GPC, and all polymers were completely degraded after 4 h (ESI Fig. S8†).
A subcutaneous implantation was designed to assess the in vivo characteristics of the injectable hydrogels (5 wt%). All of the hydrogels demonstrate tunable degradation behaviors. For example, 700-EDA/HA-SH had completely degraded in 2 weeks. The weight change was 192.3% ± 9.5%, 94.6% ± 7.1% and 61.7% ± 19.4%, at days 3, 7, and 11 post-implantation, respectively (Fig. 3B). No evidence of rejection or infection was observed during the experiment, suggesting good biocompatibility of all five hydrogels. The in vivo degradation results showed that diamines with different alkyl intervals demonstrated a small effect on the degradation rates, while PEGDAs with varied molecular weights made a big difference. Nondiabetic and diabetic wounds without treatment demonstrate different wound closure rates (ESI Fig. S20†), and require different materials to support new tissue regeneration. Then, 575-EDA and 700-EDA were selected for the performance of further animal experiments in a humanized wound model (ESI Fig. S19†) due to the differences in the degradation profiles, and the degradation products of amino acids with smaller molecular weights than those of HDA polymers, which could be more rapidly metabolised in vivo.
Based on the mechanisms of impaired diabetic wound healing, we performed histological and immunohistochemical analysis to understand the promoting factors for 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel treated wounds. From H&E staining, at day 11 post-wounding, all of the wounds showed a visible epidermal tongue, a substantial infiltration by nucleated cells (ESI Fig. S25†). At day 21, significantly more granulation tissue has grown and the epidermal tongue appears to be migrating towards the wound center. Masson’s trichrome staining was further used to visualize collagen deposition at the wound beds (ESI Fig. S26†). Compared to the PBS counterparts, the dermis of wounds treated with 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels is much thicker (Fig. 6C, p < 0.05). In consistence with the dermis thickness, the collagen deposition in 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel treated wounds appears more homogenous in comparison with those treated with PBS (ESI Fig. S26†). These results correlate well with the wound repair process, which further confirms the synergistic roles of 700-EDA, HA-SH, and ADSCs in accelerating diabetic wound repair.
The inflammation, angiogenesis, and re-epithelialization responses in wound beds were further determined using immuno-histochemical and immunofluorescent staining, and the corresponding cytokine levels were quantified by Image J (Fig. 7). Long lasting inflammation is thought to be a significant reason for delayed healing. Therefore, immuno-histochemical staining for IL-1β, CD11b, and TNF-α was performed to obtain detailed understanding of the inflammation response (ESI Fig. S27†). At day 11, a substantially lower level of inflammatory factors is determined in the wounds treated with the 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel (p < 0.05) (Fig. 7C). Similarly, at day 21, the levels of IL-1β, TNF-α and CD11b for the PBS treated group are still much higher than for the 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs treated group (p < 0.05) (Fig. 7C). The immunofluorescent staining sections for TNF-α further indicate less of an inflammatory response triggered by 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels (Fig. 7A).
Vascular network formation is an essential indicator of diabetic wound healing. Immuno-histochemical staining of CD31 and α-SMA shows that there are obviously more vessels formed at the wounds treated by 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels compared to the PBS treated group at day 21 (ESI Fig. S27†). Moreover, at day 21, more mature micro-vessels are augmented in the 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel treated group (p < 0.05) (Fig. 7D and E). The pro-angiogenic cytokine VEGF expressed in wound sections was also determined and the images of immunohistochemical staining as well as its quantification level are shown as in ESI Fig. S27† and 7F. The secretion of VEGF is significantly promoted by 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels. At days 11 and 21, the VEGF level is 1.2-fold (p < 0.01) and 0.3-fold higher (p < 0.05) than that of the no-treatment group. The presence of co-localized positively stained CD31 and α-SMA cells in immunofluorescent staining sections is strong evidence of vasculature formation and this may explain the accelerated wound healing (Fig. 7B).
Keratin is a major component of keratohyalin granules and is a known factor in wound healing. Here, we generated Keratin-10 (which is secreted in the suprabasal layer) stained sections to analyze the progress of keratinocytes migrating into the wound center. A significantly higher level of re-epithelialization is observed at the wounds treated by the 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel compared to the PBS treated group (p < 0.01) at 21 days (Fig. 7G and ESI S28†). All of these results demonstrate that 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels can effectively inhibit prolonged inflammation, and promote angiogenesis, migration of keratinocytes and re-epithelialization, ultimately accelerating diabetic wound healing.
The newly generated HP-PBAEs with a high vinyl ratio and high branching degree addressed the limitations of linear PBAEs used in hydrogel formation, such as high molecular weight, rapid gelation time, and high crosslinking degree. HP-PBAEs show fast gelation time with thiolated hyaluronic acid via a “click” thiol–ene reaction. Using combinatorial integration, these hydrogels possess in situ forming profiles and versatile degradation rates, which are important characteristics when considering tissue repair and regeneration applications. All of these advantages lead to superior performance, pointing to the promising application of HP-PBAE-based hydrogels in stem cell delivery. The degradation profile showed that we successfully generated a series of biodegradable hydrogels which can be controlled in a wide range of time periods, both in vitro and in vivo.
To better mimic the human wound healing process, an excisional humanized wound model was employed to evaluate the effectiveness and safety of the HP-PBAE hydrogels. The humanized wound model was created by Gurtner’s laboratory.24,25 This model could be a good tool for skin wound healing because of its better mimicking and recapitulating of human wound repair mechanisms. It has been reported that activated inflammatory cells and excessive pro-inflammatory cytokines like IL-1β, TNF-α,27,28 and matrix metalloproteinases16 could cause severe delay in diabetic wound healing. The termination of the inflammatory response at the right time would reverse impaired wound recovery. The in vivo data provide evidence that 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogels significantly down-regulated the inflammatory factors and terminated the prolonged inflammation phase. HP-PBAE-based hydrogels can be a temporary stem cell niche to maintain the encapsulated ADSCs’ viability and secretion profile. Meanwhile, they would degrade at an appropriate rate to match the regeneration of new tissues. The 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel can indeed promote the secretion of CD31, α-SMA, and VEGF, suggesting a possible mechanism for increased neovascularization and enhanced wound repair.29 The closure of gaps within epithelia is crucial to maintain the skin’s integrity during the biological processes of wound healing.30 Chronic wounds show proliferative and non-migratory epidermis because of the hostile wound environment.31 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel treated wounds show significantly accelerated re-epithelialization and wound closure (Fig. 7E). Correspondingly, collagen deposition, angiogenesis and re-epithelialization are enhanced, ultimately accelerating the diabetic wound repair. In addition, in comparison with direct ADSC injection, the 700-EDA/HA-SH/ADSCs hydrogel system exhibits a more significant acceleration rate indicating the synergistic roles of 700-EDA, HA-SH, and ADSCs in wound healing.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7sc03913a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |