María
Morán-Pedroso‡
,
David O.
Tiede‡
,
Carlos
Romero-Pérez
,
Mauricio E.
Calvo
,
Juan F.
Galisteo-López
* and
Hernán
Míguez
*
Instituto de Ciencias de Materiales de Sevilla (Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas-Universidad de Sevilla), C/Américo Vespucio, 49, Sevilla, 41092, Spain. E-mail: juan.galisteo@csic.es; h.miguez@csic.es
First published on 2nd October 2024
Introducing quantum dots (QDs) as the active element of an optoelectronic device demands its incorporation in the shape of interconnected arrays that allow for some degree of electronic coupling in order to inject/extract charge carriers. In doing so, beyond reducing the degree of quantum confinement, carriers are exposed to an enhanced defect landscape as they can access adjacent QDs, which is at the origin of the strong reduction of photoluminescence observed in QD solids when compared to that of the isolated QDs. In this work we demonstrate how a proper defect passivating strategy or atmospheric treatment can greatly enhance charge diffusion in a QD film, needed for an optimal carrier injection/extraction demanded for optoelectronic applications, and also improved its stability against external radiation. From a fundamental perspective, we provide evidence showing that trap density distribution, rather than QD size distribution, is mostly responsible for the observed variations in emission decay rates present in the QD networks under analysis.
When used in solar cells or light emitting diodes (LEDs), semiconductor QDs must be incorporated in the shape of films, in which a certain degree of electronic coupling between the QDs is necessary to allow for charge injection and transport.14 Among the different routes to fabricate such QD ensembles, ligand-free synthesis within the pores of nanoporous metal oxide matrices has been recently demonstrated as a suitable approach to prepare HP QD films with optical quality and versatility regarding QD size, composition and concentration.15–20 When deployed as films, the recombination properties of QD undergo pronounced changes and a bulk-like or isolated QD-like behavior is present depending on QD connectivity.21 The presence of structural defects strongly affects recombination in QD films as photogenerated carriers have access to a larger defect landscape since they can diffuse across many QDs.
In this work we study the role of crystalline defects in charge carrier recombination of ligand-free FAPbBr3 QD films grown within metal oxide nanoporous matrices. In order to evaluate the effect of defects of different nature we explore polymeric encasement, which has been recently shown to act as efficient surface trap passivators,22 as well as different environmental agents which are known to interact with the defect structure of lead halide perovskites.23,24 These results are interpreted in the light of recent literature dealing with the defect structure of FA-based HPs and the role of different trap states in carrier recombination is discussed. We demonstrate how a proper defect passivating strategy can greatly enhance charge diffusion in a QD film, needed for an optimal carrier injection/extraction demanded for optoelectronic applications, and also improved its stability against external radiation. From a fundamental perspective, we provide evidence showing that trap density distribution, rather than QD size distribution, is mostly responsible for the observed variations in emission decay rates present in the QD networks under analysis.
We next monitored the time evolution of the PL under continuous wave (CW) irradiation over longer time-scales (seconds to minutes) to evaluate the photo-stability of the samples (Fig. 1e). Here an irreversible drop in the PL is observed (Fig. S3, ESI†) indicating the onset of material degradation. Notice that for this and all measurements reported in this work, reversibility of photoinduced changes was evaluated in the same atmosphere as irradiation. This change in emission presents clear differences depending on the sample connectivity (see Fig. S4, ESI†). If we consider the two extreme cases (5 and 20% precursor concentration) we can see that for the sample consisting of a collection of isolated QDs (Cprec = 5%), where the PL spectrum is expected to comprise the convolution of spectra from different QDs,21 emission quenching is more pronounced and affects particularly the red part of the spectrum (Fig. S4a, ESI†), as evidenced by the blueshift of the final emission spectrum compared to the initial one (Fig. S5, ESI†). Such behavior points at non-radiative recombination processes occurring in the bulk of the larger QDs, which emit in the longer wavelength region. For the case of connected QDs (Fig. S4c, ESI†), PL quenching is less pronounced and does not involve spectral changes. The latter agrees with the fact that, for QD arrays, PL is expected to come from those QDs with smaller bandgap after a carrier diffusion process following the energy landscape of the array. The photostability of FAPbBr3 has been dealt with only recently26 for macroscopic single crystals where a bulk reversible PL darkening was observed and associated with the perovskite lattice decomposition upon irradiation. In such process, byproducts in gas phase can recombine with other byproducts leading to the re-composition of the lattice. The possible origin of our findings will be further discussed when results for different treatments are dealt with.
To gain further insight into the role of structural defects on both the carrier transport in QD films as well as on the observed photo-instability, we next consider identical samples to the ones discussed above, but with the remaining empty volume of the nanopores infiltrated with poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) after FAPbBr3 QD synthesis (labeled as FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2) (see fabrication details in ESI†). This approach, expected to act on surface traps, has been observed in the past to lead to defect passivation and improved PLQY on similar samples.22 These results are in line with recent ab initio studies for FAPbI3, which have shown that, while bulk defects are expected to be more abundant in this material due to a lower defect energy formation,27 only surface defects occurring for some terminations are expected to introduce deep traps that lead to non-radiative recombination paths.28 For the case of isolated QDs in FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 films with Cprec = 5%, an enhanced PL is accompanied by a much longer PL decay evidencing the passivation of deep traps. As before, PL decays are independent of fluence as expected for a collection of isolated QDs (Fig. 2a). For the case of FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 films with larger QD load, where increasingly higher QD interconnectivity is expected, we observe that not only PL decays become longer than in the presence of N2, but also they show a clear fluence dependence (Fig. 2b). The latter is indicative of a system of interconnected QDs, where recombination dynamics depend on the global population density of charge carriers that can freely move and distribute within the excited area.21 The stark difference in PL dynamics of FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 samples before and after surface passivation with PMMA highlights the detrimental role of deep traps in carrier recombination in QD solids. From these data, it becomes apparent that in the presence of a large density of deep traps (as in FAPbBr3@SiO2 samples), carriers generated in one QD recombine non-radiatively at traps either within the QD where they are generated, or at nearby ones where they can diffuse in the case of samples with a higher QD load. In this case, the fact that the carrier can diffuse across QDs increases its defect landscape, effectively leading to a lower PLQY and, since carriers are trapped before they can diffuse far from its origin, to a negligible effect of the excitation fluence. This situation, which explain the results reported in Fig. S2 (ESI†) for FAPbBr3@SiO2 samples, is represented in the top panel of Scheme 1. On the other hand, as deep traps are passivated, as in FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 samples, carriers can diffuse across many QDs eventually finding an opposite charge to recombine with (bottom panel in Scheme 1) and presenting a fluence dependence on recombination that reflects its dependence on global population density.
Trap passivation in FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 samples not only influences emission properties but also photostability. Now, samples having the lower QD loads and thus expected to consist of a collection of isolated QDs do not show any variation in PL, evidencing the absence of structural changes taking place (see Fig. 2c). The fact that irreversible degradation is now absent for this sample indicates that surface traps, beyond acting as deep traps leading to the quenching of PL, also represent seed points where degradation is triggered. For the case of the samples with higher precursor load where QD interconnectivity is expected (Cprec = 20%) we now observe a photo-induced PL darkening that is reversible when CW irradiation is removed (see Fig. S6, ESI†). Two types of mechanisms have been reported for reversible photodarkening in HPs. A decomposition of the HP lattice into its precursors and further formation of gaseous byproducts was invoked in ref. 26 as the process leading to reversible darkening of FAPbBr3 single crystals when excitation is performed in the bulk and byproducts cannot scape the crystal. If this mechanism was behind our observations, PL darkening should be observed for all QD films regardless of their load. On the other hand, Motti and co-workers proposed29 the formation of I2 upon annihilation of halide-related Frenkel pairs as a possible origin for PL quenching. This would explain the present results in the event that halide defects could migrate across different QDs in our interconnected samples. Br2 forming as a result of the annihilation of Frenkel pairs could not escape the film due to the presence of the PMMA film and the process could be reversed upon removing the CW irradiation.
Next, we consider the surrounding atmosphere as a treatment with potential to modify the defect landscape in FAPbBr3@SiO2 samples. The role of the environment on HP photophysics and stability has been extensively studied over the past decade. There is nowadays a consensus that certain gases can strongly modify the defect landscape in LHP at the expense of reducing material stability so that a compromise must be attained if one wants to employ this approach to optimize their optoelectronic properties.30,31 In this work we have explored the role of O2 and moisture. We first exposed our sample to a continuous flow of dry O2 (<3 ppm background humidity according to the provider, Linde) for 5 minutes prior to study their optical properties. Time resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) data shows a slight slowing in the PL decays for all samples under study (Fig. 2d and e). This is likely related with the interaction of O2 with a certain population of deep traps, as evidenced by the fact that TRPL becomes again fluence dependent for the highly connected sample. This interaction takes place via weak binding of O2 to FAPbBr3 (physisorption) as the effect is rapidly reversed upon restoring a N2 atmosphere.
More evident changes appear when the effect of O2 is combined with that of CW irradiation and we monitor the sample PL (Fig. 2f). Here we can observe that samples with small connectivity barely experience any change in their PL but highly connected samples undergo a >2 fold enhancement, pointing to the photoinduced interaction of deep traps with this reactive atmosphere. As with the case of samples infiltrated with PMMA, no spectral changes were observed for the highly connected samples (Fig. S7, ESI†). While reports on the interaction of O2 with FAPbBr3 are lacking, recent evidence showing emission changes of other MA-based HP may hold the key to explain the present results. In particular, a photoinduced PL rise in the presence of O2 has been previously reported32–38 and associated with the formation of superoxide species35–38 which may interact with surface halide vacancies which, as in the present case, act as deep traps. This effect is reversible over times longer than those needed for activation following a two-step process with different time scales of seconds and tens of minutes (see Fig. S8, ESI†).
Finally, FAPbBr3@SiO2 samples were exposed to humid air to explore the combined action of O2 and moisture. H2O is known to accelerate phase instability for FAPbI3 while, for the case of FAPbBr3, is known to have little effect on its stability.12 Further, the combination of H2O and O2 has been recently reported to lead to accelerated degradation in iodide based mixed Cs-FA HPs.39 As in the case of exposure to pure O2, the TRPL of all samples undergo a slowing of the PL dynamics (Fig. 2g), although more pronounced. For the more connected QDs, a significantly stronger fluence dependence is observed (Fig. 2h), indicating a larger population of defects interacting with H2O and O2 than with O2 alone. Again, irradiating with CW light in the presence of humid air leads to more dramatic changes in emission, as shown in Fig. 2i. Here a small (ca. 10–30%) PL enhancement is observed for the case of isolated QDs while connected ones undergo a remarkable 10-fold enhancement. Resorting to previous reports for MA-based HP, the combined action of H2O and light has been suggested to improve the HP emission according to two mechanisms. Brenes and co-workers proposed the partial dissolution of the HP lattice at the surface, leading to the formation of an amorphous film that could act as a passivator.36,38 Alternatively, other oxide species can form at the HP surface, namely peroxide37 and hydrogen peroxide.40 These species can further react with uncoordinated lead, in different charge states, present at the HP surface which can be oxidized into lead oxide.37,40 Both processes would lead to the irreversible passivation of traps and thus a different mechanism is expected in our case as, while much longer recovery times are observed than when using only O2, (see Fig. S9, ESI†) our sample returns to its initial low PL state. Hence, further work will be needed in order to unveil the photoinduced processes involving water that lead to such efficient interaction of atmospheric agents with traps in FAPbBr3 QDs.
For the case of FAPbBr3@SiO2 films exposed to non-inert atmospheres, while the population of traps interacting with the surrounding atmosphere is expected to be the same for all different samples, the photoinduced PL enhancement is more pronounced for the case of connected QDs. The reason behind this observation is the stronger effect of traps on the sample emission for connected QD arrays (see Scheme 1), where a larger defect landscape arises as a consequence of carriers being able to diffuse across several QDs. To evaluate and quantify the role of the different treatments, we consider the Cprec = 5% samples, i.e. those having the lowest connectivity, where fluence does not play a role in the emission. We compare the PL decay under different atmospheres as representative of the weight of non-radiative processes. To extract a parameter for comparison we fit the TRPL to a lognormal distribution of decays, ρ(Γ) (see Fig. 3a for the FAPbBr3@PMMA@SiO2 sample, and Fig. S10 (ESI†) for FAPbBr3@SiO2 exposed to different atmospheres). As previously reported,21 the mode of the distribution (Γm) represents an average value of the decay rate of the distribution of QDs. The width of this distribution will be affected by the size dispersion but could also be influenced by the defect distribution in different QD. From the comparison of all ΓT it becomes clear that the treatment that more efficiently de-activates deep traps is that of PMMA (Fig. 3b), further highlighting the detrimental role of surface defects in this material. Additional information can be extracted from a comparison of the actual decay rate distribution for QD films in N2 and with the different treatments (see Fig. 3c). The average value of the decay rate distribution ΓT comprises a radiative (ΓR) and a non-radiative (ΓNR) component. While the former is assumed to be identical for all samples, the latter depends on the defect landscape as:
ΓNR = σtrapvthNT |
Hence the non-radiative recombination is directly affected by the number of trap sites in the system, (NT) their capture cross section (σtrap) and the thermal velocity of the free charge carriers (vth), the latter remaining unchanged for the different treatments. The reduction of the number of trap sites can be explained as halide related defects interact with environmental gas molecules, while a change in σtrap can be assigned to a change in the energy level of a trap state, such as the one predicted for interstitial iodide in the presence of O2.41 To shed more light into the exact origin of the reduction in ΓNR, the distribution of recombination rates is analyzed in the following. Here it can be seen that adding the polymer as a passivating agent not only reduces the average decay rate, evidencing the reduction of non-radiative recombination paths, but also homogenizes the PL dynamics of the QD distribution as its width is reduced by an order of magnitude (Fig. 3c). This latter fact further evidences that trap density distribution, rather than size distribution, is mostly responsible for the observed variation in decay rates in the present QD films.
The distribution of decay rates can be associated to both the non-radiative (ΓNR) and radiative (ΓR) components, where non-radiative components are expected to show both larger decay times and a broader distribution of decay times. As the different treatments (atmosphere and PMMA) are acting on the sample, a reduction of the decay rate distribution is observed (Fig. 3c). The continuous decrease of both the average values of the distribution and its width is observed as surface defects interact with one of the abovementioned agents. Since both parameters decrease in the same monotonic way, the global reduction in decay rates can be solely assigned to the reduction in the number of trap states. A significant change in the distribution of defect states would involve a more drastic change in the width ΔΓ, rather than in the mean rate Γm. Further, an assignment of the broad distribution to a size and energy dispersion due to the heterogeneity of the crystals is discarded, as in this case, ΔΓ and Γm would not follow identical dynamics.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tc02362e |
‡ Equal contributors. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |