Yan-Wu
Zhao
,
Bin
Xue
,
Nan
Zhang
,
Li-E
Guo
,
Sheng-Yan
Zhu
and
Xian-Ming
Zhang
*
Key Laboratory of Magnetic Molecules & Magnetic Information Materials Ministry of Education, School of Chemistry & Material Science, Shanxi Normal University, Taiyuan, 030031, Shanxi, P. R. China. E-mail: zhangxm@dns.sxnu.edu.cn
First published on 5th June 2024
Given the current depletion of energy resources and the escalating severity of environmental issues, it is of utmost importance to develop sustainable materials capable of detecting harmful substances and removing adverse environmental impacts. Herein, a rare-earth-free white-light-emitting MOF Cd-PNMI (PNMI, N-(4-pyridyl)-1,4,5,8-naphathalene-tetracarboxy-monoimide), deriving from an idea that involves the construction of a strong white-light-emitting MOFs using a weak white-light-emitting ligand PNMI with d10 metal based on ligand-to-ligand charge transfer (LLCT) luminescent mechanism, was designed and confirmed using time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations. As a sustainable white-light-emitting material, CdPNMI can not only detect explosive and highly toxic substances at low limits of detection (LOD) but also adsorb the dyes from waste liquids. The CdPNMI emulsion demonstrated ratiometric sensing with remarkable dual-emission fluorescence quenching for nitro explosive and highly toxic substances, which was confirmed to be the result of a synergetic contribution of photo-induced electronic transfer (PET) and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) quenching mechanism. Due to the distinctive structure character, CdPNMI also exhibited rapid, selective and extensive adsorption for Rhodamine B (RhB) and fluorescein (FITC) dye, contributing to the elimination of these pollutants from waste liquids.
To date, the majority of the reported rare-earth-free white-light-emitting MOFs are multicomponent MOFs (guest encapsulated emitter);13,16,22 however, single-component white-light MOFs are relatively scarce.19,21,23 We have previously reported single-component white-light MOFs by doping different quantities of Eu3+ (red light) and Tb3+ (green light) into blue-emitting MOFs based on trichromatic theory.18 However, achieving rare-earth-free single-component white-light MOFs upon UV light excitation remains a considerable challenge due to the lack of effective adjustment strategies.
Herein, a feasible strategy is proposed to obtain rare-earth-free single-component white-light-emitting MOFs constructed using the weak white-light-emitting organic ligand with d10 metals. Indeed, the emission of luminescent MOFs comprised of d10 metals (e.g., Zn and Cd) and fluorescent ligands typically involve ligand-based electron transfer or ligand-to-ligand charge transfer (LLCT) processes confirmed by recent studies.24–26 Luminescent MOFs often show significantly enhanced photoluminescence (PL) with respect to the constituting ligands themselves, and the shift in emission energy is usually less than 15 nm compared to that of the ligand.27,28 In order to create rare-earth-free, UV-excitable white-light-emitting MOFs, we aim to construct cadmium or zinc-based luminescent MOFs using white-light emissive ligands. Among various organic ligands, PNMI (N-(4-pyridyl)-1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetracarboxy-monoimide, Scheme S1†) have attracted our attention. The naphthalimides have a coplanar π-electron core and display potential photophysical properties, which can be advantageous to construct fluorescent MOFs. More importantly, PNMI emits weak white light with a relatively low quantum yield (Φf < 0.1%), rendering it an ideal linker candidate because the constructed MOFs can emit stronger white light.
As far as WLED is concerned, it is undoubtedly environmentally friendly. However, currently, the excess discharge of some pollutants such as nitroaromatic explosives and dyes has posed a serious threat to the environment and biological health.29 How to detect and eliminate them is an urgent issue to be resolved. In recent years, the sensing applications of luminescent MOFs for detecting pollutants have been an extremely active area of research,30 which is derived from their tunable and stable structures with large surface areas that can bring excellent selectivity, sensitivity, and recyclability.31–33 The versatile MOFs constructed by naphthalimides are known to be a class of excellent candidates for sensors to detect nitroaromatic explosives such as 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (TNP), 4-nitrotoluene (4-NT), and nitrobenzene (NB) due to the abundant interactions and charge transfer between the host frameworks and the targeted guest molecules.31 Up to now, the reported naphthalimide-based MOF sensors have mainly been focused on single-emission turn-off or turn-on fluorescent sensing.34–38 However, the detection accuracy of single-signal MOF sensors is limited by various factors, including the solution concentration, instrument, environment, and excitation light intensity. The ratiometric fluorescence MOF sensors could eliminate these drawbacks through self-reference of dual emission, acquiring high-precision detection.12 The constructed CdPNMI, as 3D porous MOFs, exhibits a remarkable porosity of 46% and features large pore sizes, along with abundant pyridyl-N and imide-O binding sites within the internal pore walls. Interestingly, the fluorescent titration experiments of CdPNMI emulsion by different concentrations of nitromatic explosives show a prominent dual-emission quenching effect. More distinctively, the constructing CdPNMI also displays amazing absorption for Rhodamine B (RhB) and fluorescein (FITC) dyes. Therefore, the Cd-based MOF in the work manifests multi-functional features with white light emission, fluorescent sensing, and dye absorption.
Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis reveals that CdPNMI crystallizes in the monoclinic P21/n space group, which is isostructural with the [Cd(PNMI)]·0.5DMA·5H2O crystal.39 The asymmetric unit includes one Cd(II) metal ion and one PNMI ligand. As depicted in Fig. 1, each Cd atom shows a six-coordinated environment with a slightly distorted CdO5N octahedral geometry (Fig. S4†). The Cd–O and Cd–N bond lengths are 2.213(3) to 2.347(3) Å and 2.277(3) to 2.278(3) Å, respectively. The L–Cd–L (L = N, O) bond angles range from 79.95(10) to 176.39(12)° and deviate slightly from those of the perfect octahedron (Tables S1 and S2†). Furthermore, a Cd2O8N2 cluster is formed by two CdO5N octahedrons with a shared side, which is derived from a rhomboid Cd2O2 ring generated by the two carboxylic O4 atoms of two different ligands bridging two Cd atoms (Fig. 1a and Fig. S4b†). Each O4 atom in the η2 mode coordinates with the Cd atom, and the carboxylic group of the entire ligand in the μ4-η1:η1:η1:η2 mode is coordinated to four Cd atoms (Fig. S4c†). The remaining three oxygen atoms are connected to another Cd2O2 ring, resulting in an extended 1D chain along the a-axis (Fig. S4d†). Four adjacent 1D chains are connected by Cd–N bonds of each ligand to form 3D MOFs with 1D channel (Fig. 1b–d). Topology analysis was conducted to further understand the 3D network, in which PNMI ligands and Cd2O8N2 clusters are regarded as three-connected and six-connected nodes, respectively (Fig. S4e and f†). A calculation by TOPOS reveals a (3,6)-connected rtl network with a Schläfli point symbol of (4·62)2(42·610·83). The accessible pore void was obtained to be 46% of the total cell volume by the PLATON program. The 1D rhombus-like channels of CdPNMI had the interior cross-section dimensions of ca. 15.39 × 11.90 Å along the a-axis (subtracting the van der Waals radii of the two oxygen atoms, Fig. 1c).
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was conducted to explore the elemental composition of the CdPNMI crystal. As depicted in Fig. S6,† the peaks of Cd, C, O and N are observed in the survey spectrum, confirming the presence of the above elements without impurities. The Cd 3d spectrum reveals two types of electron orbits, Cd 3d5/2 and Cd 3d3/2, at binding energies of 412.4 and 404.8 eV, respectively (Fig. 2a).40,41 Different carbon environments are identified from the C 1s spectrum (Fig. 2b): three peaks at 284.8, 285.8 and 288.7 eV corresponding to CC/C–C, C–N, and OC–O bonds, respectively.42 Meanwhile, the peaks of O 1s at 531.4, 532.0, and 533.2 eV, are ascribed to Cd–O, OC–O and OC (amide) in Fig. 2c, respectively.43Fig. 2d shows the characteristic peaks of N 1s at 400.1 eV (C–N) and 404.8 eV (Cd–N).41 In addition, IR spectra of CdPNMI describe the presence of the main functional group, further confirming the structure of CdPNMI (Fig. S3†). The PXRD analysis of CdPNMI, as depicted in Fig. S7,† shows close diffraction peaks with the simulated ones by single crystals, indicating the phase purity of the crystal. The morphology of the CdPNMI crystal is also investigated by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images. As shown in Fig. S5,† CdPNMI crystal is composed of blocks and rods with smooth surfaces.
Similar PXRD of CdPNMI crystals immersed in different solvents indicated identical phases (Fig. S8†), suggesting the good solvent stability of CdPNMI. Meanwhile, thermogravimetric analysis of the CdPNMI crystal was performed at a temperature of 30–800 °C. The first weight loss in the range of 30–75 °C is attributed to the removal of water molecules from the crystal lattice. The second stage from 75 °C to 130 °C originates from the loss of guest water molecules. The decomposition of the organic ligand occurred at 320–436 °C (Fig. S12†), indicating that the CdPNMI crystal exhibited favorable thermostability.
CdPNMI showed a strong UV absorption band shifted to 260 nm and 370 nm (including 320 nm with the maximum absorption peak) compared with the transition peak of PNMI at 255 and 348 nm, corresponding to the π → π* transition of PNMI ligands. In addition, a shoulder peak around 457 nm can be observed in CdPNMI, which could be attributed to an inter-molecular electron-transfer transition of the PNMI ligand (Fig. S13†).
The solid-state emission spectra of PNMI and CdPNMI were investigated under ambient conditions. As shown in Fig. 3a, PNMI ligands emit a weak white light and two broad bands with maximum emission at 446 and 541 nm under the excitation of 350 nm (Φf < 0.1%), which are assigned to π → π* of intraligand and interligand electronic transitions (Fig. S27†). Compared with the PNMI ligands, the CdPNMI crystal emits significantly stronger white light and exhibits two broad bands with maximum emission at 440 and 548 nm under the excitation of 356 nm (Fig. 3b and Fig. S14†). The slight shift of the emission wavelength and broadening of the spectra are perhaps due to charge transfer among the organic ligands (LLCT) in the cyclically extending framework of CdPNMI. The CIE (Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage) coordinates for the emission of the PNMI ligand and CdPNMI crystal are calculated to be (0.295, 0.342) and (0.306, 0.331), all within the white region of the chromaticity graph (Fig. S15†). Interestingly, CdPNMI crystals can produce bright white light under different excitation light from 365 nm to 390 nm (Fig. S16†). As an important parameter, the fluorescence lifetime of the CdPNMI crystal was investigated, and the time-resolved PL lifetime measurements showed biexponential decays, with lifetimes of 3.06 ns and 5.25 ns, corresponding to the emission wavelength of 440 nm and 548 nm, respectively (Fig. 3c). The absolute fluorescence quantum yield (QY) of the CdPNMI crystal was measured as 4.12% under 356 nm exciting with diffuse light within an integrating sphere. This means the fluorescence intensity is indeed enhanced by constructing the d10 metal MOFs with weak white-light-emitting PNMI ligand, confirming the feasibility of the design idea. Apparently, the rigid structure of the CdPNMI crystal confines the free movement of the PNMI ligand in the framework, resulting in the reduction of the nonradiative decay rate, further increasing the luminescent intensity and quantum efficiency.
To further confirm whether the luminescence mechanism in CdPNMI follows the ligand-to-ligand charge transfer (LLCT) or metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT), TDDFT calculations were conducted. As depicted in Fig. 3d and Fig. S26,† the change of the electron cloud density distribution on the frontier orbitals of the CdPNMI model shows that an efficient charge transfer process could occur between the organic ligands. The calculated photophysical properties of CdPNMI are listed in Table S3.† All transitions show π → π* transitions, and there are two local excitation states (SLE) and four charge transfer states (SCT). Interestingly, the two excited states exhibit a significant charge-transfer characteristic and are denoted as SCT1(ππ*) and SCT3(ππ*) with transition energies of 4.5295 and 4.6801 eV, respectively, corresponding to two large oscillator strengths (f = 0.7007 and 0.9280). The two primary types of transitions involve charge transfer (CT) from the pyridine ring of one ligand to the naphthalimide ring of the other ligand, and CT from the naphthalene ring of one ligand to the naphthalimide ring of the other ligand (Fig. 3d). The two varieties of the charge transfer process are the underlying cause of the dual-emission peak observed in CdPNMI. In fact, the fluorescence decay profile of CdPNMI for different emission wavelengths also suggests a different luminescent mechanism of the two emission peaks (Fig. 3c). This calculation verifies that the fluorescence of CdPNMI originates from LLCT, rather than MLCT.
Given that the CdPNMI crystal showed stronger white light under the excitation of 365 nm (Fig. S15†), the CdPNMI material was applied on a commercially available UV-LED lamp (Fig. 3b). Interestingly, the fabricated LED with a reported method emitted bright white light,18 which indicated that the rare-earth-free MOFs CdPNMI constructed using the d10 metal exhibit favorable white-light properties.
In addition to the application of solid white lighting, CdPNMI also displayed a similar sensing ability to these reported naphthalene diimide MOF, especially for nitroaromatic compounds (NACs) with explosive pollutants and highly poisonous substances. Although several naphthalene diimide MOFs showed distinctive single-emission luminescent sensing,35–38 few reports have appeared on similar dual-emission sensing.44 The CdPNMI emulsion in DMA shows two emission peaks at 425 nm and 468 nm (Fig. S17†). To verify the sensing ability of CdPNMI towards a series of nitroaromatic explosives including TNP, NT, and NB, fluorescence titration experiments were carried out with gradual addition of NACs solutions to the CdPNMI emulsion. Interestingly, CdPNMI emulsion displayed remarkable dual-emission fluorescence quenching in the presence of these NACs (Fig. 4). Moreover, the decreasing degrees of the fluorescence intensity at 425 nm and 468 nm are different, and the experimental results show the decline of the emission peak at 425 nm are faster than that at 468 nm, which belongs to ratiometric fluorescence sensing with the same change of the two emissions in different varying degrees.12 Given that CdPNMI shows two emission peaks due to different LLCT pathways, these analytes (NACs) partly interdict LLCT, which may further affect the descent degree of fluorescence intensity of two emissions. For the sensing of TNP, the fluorescence intensity at 425 nm is reduced to 57.4% of the original level by adding 29.4 μM of TNP into the CdPNMI emulsion, whereas the fluorescence intensity at 468 nm decreases to 42.3% of its initial intensity. Similarly, the 22.6% and 16.6% fluorescence quenching at 425 nm and 468 nm were observed by adding 29.4 μM of 4-NT (Fig. S19†), and the addition of 29.4 μM of NB results in the 23.6% and 18.5% fluorescence quenching at 425 nm and 468 nm, respectively (Fig. S18†). Among all the nitro explosives, TNP exhibits the highest quenching efficiency of the emission intensity of CdPNMI (Fig. 4a and Fig. S18, S19†). In addition, high-poisonous 4-nitro aniline (4-NA) was attempted as a probed nitroaromatic compound. Surprisingly, the CdPNMI emulsion shows conspicuous fluorescence quenching and is almost completely quenched upon the addition of 114 μM of 4-NA, which is nearly the same as the quenching efficiency of TNP. Likewise, the addition of 29.4 μM of 4-NA caused 54.6% and 43.6% fluorescence quenching at 425 nm and 468 nm, respectively. A detailed analysis of fluorescence quenching for TNP and 4-NA was conducted. As shown in Fig. S20 and S21,† the different fluorescence quenching by TNP and NA follow the nonlinear behavior in the concentration range of 0–114 μM, which is fitted by the empirical equation of I/I0 = 1 + a × exp(K[Q]). Based upon the above fitting results, a linear quenching plot was acquired, and their quenching constants (KSV) are 4.4 × 104 and 3.8 × 104, respectively.45 The limit of detection (LOD) for TNP was estimated to be 0.42 ppm, which was a lower value,46 and the LOD of NA was 0.49 ppm, which were calculated according to the 3σ criteria. The high value of KSV and low LOD indicates the high sensitivity of CdPNM for the detection of TNP over other nitro analytes.
To verify the reusability of CdPNMI sensing for TNP, cycling experiments were conducted for TNP detections. As shown in Fig. S22,† CdPNMI exhibits excellent regenerative stability to TNP. After five cycles, the fluorescent intensities and quenching efficiencies of CdPNMI only exhibited slight decreases. More importantly, the PXRD of CdPNMI crystal retains the original structure in Fig. S9,† indicating the good stability of CdPNMI. Meanwhile, the anti-interference experiments were also carried out. The selective sensing ability of CdPNMI for TNP was not disturbed by toluene (PhMe), NB, and 4-NT competitors (Fig. S23 and S24†). High selectivity, stability, and reusing capability endow CdPNMI with the potential for subsequent practical applications.
The fluorescence quenching mechanism needs to be further explored for interpreting the aforementioned experimental results. As shown in Fig. S25,† the Stern–Volmer plot of TNP and 4-NA shows linear growth at low concentrations and an upward curve with increasing concentrations, however, that of NB and 4-NT display a linear change. The nonlinear trends indicate the energy transfer between CdPNMI and TNP, which may be caused by static and dynamic quenching mechanisms. The static quenching mechanism can be due to a ground-state and non-fluorescent complex formed by analytes diffusing into the pores of CdPNMI. Dynamic quenching can relate to photo-induced electronic transfer (PET) and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). To further confirm the PET mechanism, a DFT calculation was executed for the HOMO–LUMO energy level of analytes. As depicted in Fig. 4d, the LUMO energy level of CdPNMI is obviously higher than that of the probed NACs, which means photo-induced electron transfer from the CdPNMI framework to the electron-deficient NACs. It is well known that the lower the LUMO level of analytes, the easier the electron transfer. For the probed NACs, the order of their LUMO level is 4-NA > 4-NT > NB > TNP, so TNP has the highest fluorescence quenching efficiency among all the probed NACs. Although the LUMO level of 4-NT and NB is lower than that of 4-NA, the experiment results display that the quenching efficiency of 4-NA is clearly higher, which indicates that there lies another quenching mechanism. From Fig. 4c it can be seen that the UV absorption spectra of TNP and 4-NA partly overlap with the emission spectra of the CdPNMI emulsion, suggesting energy transfer from CdPNMI from its excited state to NACs. This is a typical FRET mechanism. In general, the more the spectral overlap between the UV absorbance spectra of NACs and the emission spectra of MOF, the greater the chance of energy transfer and therefore higher fluorescence quenching. Therefore, TNP displays the highest quenching efficiency, and there is not much difference between TNP and 4-NA. For NB and 4-NT, there lies no FRET mechanism. In conclusion, the combination of PET and FRET mechanisms explicitly supports the fluorescence quenching of these NACs.
In recent years, the widespread utilization of some synthetic organic dyes, including Rhodamine B (RhB) and fluorescein (FITC), has resulted in their elevated discharge into the environment, posing a significant threat to life and the environment due to their toxic nature at higher concentrations.47,48 Procedures utilized for dye removal from the environment encompass membrane filtration, biological treatment, and adsorption.49 Among these, adsorption is the most widely used technique for dye remediation in the environment, attributed to its efficacy and impressive color removal capabilities. The advent of MOFs can be an excellent candidate because of their adjustable porous structure and designable and modifiable functionality.50 However, the promising research on the removal of dyes from waste liquid using MOFs has received less attention. In view of the structural characteristics of CdPNMI with 46% porosity and the abundant N and O sites in the pores, CdPNMI may exhibit a certain dye absorption ability. Due to the pore size of 15.39 × 11.90 Å, the confinement effect of CdPNMI pores results in the selection of the dye molecules with the fit size. Rhodamine B and fluorescein possess sizes of 15.8 × 10.4 Å and 13.1 × 11.2 Å, respectively (Fig. S28†). Therefore, these two dyes were selected as adsorbates.
The CdPNMI crystals (each 5 mg) were individually added to different concentrations of RhB or FITC in 20 mL acetone solution. The solution was shaken, and allowed to stand. Subsequently, the UV-vis spectra of the solution were measured according to the duration of shaking. As shown in Fig. 5, UV-vis spectra display that CdPNMI crystals rapidly adsorb near 70% FITC dyes in 2 minutes, whereas only 60% RhB dye was adsorbed at the same time, and after 4 h, reaching complete absorption. Obviously, the rate and dose of FITC absorption are faster and more than those for RhB absorption, which indicates that CdPNMI exhibits not only the selective absorption capability of these dyes but also the potential for rapid absorption applications.
To precisely quantify the dye uptake capacities of CdPNMI, an equal amount of adsorbents (5 mg) was added to different concentrations of the organic dyes RhB (from 5 mg L−1 to 100 mg L−1) or FITC (from 50 mg L−1 to 550 mg L−1) in 20 mL acetone. UV-vis spectra were used to monitor the uptake capacity of CdPNMI (Fig. S29†). The adsorbent dosage for the adsorption process was determined, and the absorbance before and after the adsorption process was measured to calculate the quantity (qe) of RhB (64 mg g−1) and FITC (1000 mg g−1) adsorbed at the equilibrium (ESI†). To our knowledge, the uptake capacity of FITC by CdPNMI is the highest among all of the reported absorption materials (Table S4†), although CdPNMI is a neutral network. Meanwhile, the PXRDs of CdPNMI crystal after adsorbing different concentrations of RhB or FITC in acetone solution were measured, which essentially showed the intact structure, as shown in Fig. S10 and S11,† further confirming the stability of the CdPNMI crystal.
The absorption difference between RhB and FITC dyes motivated us to explore the absorption mechanism. First, from the size confinement, FITC molecules could be easier to accommodate into the 1D pores of CdPNMI compared to the RhB molecules; secondly, the carboxyl group of RhB and two hydroxyl and carbonyl groups of FITC can generate hydrogen bonds with the exposed oxygen of the carbonyl group in CdPNMI pores, leading to the enlargement of adsorption. As shown in Fig. 6, IR spectra of RhB@CdPNMI and FITC@CdPNMI show peaks of CdPNMI and dyes, suggesting these dyes are completely encompassed by the CdPNMI crystal. The peak of RhB@CdPNMI at 3411 cm−1, derived from the 3446 cm−1 peak of RhB, is attributed to the O–H stretching vibration of –COOH in RhB. Upon absorption of the RhB molecules, the peak position of CdPNMI undergoes a shift towards the lower wavenumber, accompanied by a broadening effect. Meanwhile, the peak of CdPNMI at 1669 cm−1 shifts to 1663 cm−1 in RhB@CdPNMI, which is ascribed to the vibration peak of CO, along with the increase of peak intensity. These peak changes suggest the existence of a hydrogen bond between the CO of CdPNMI and –COOH of RhB. Similarly, for FITC@CdPNMI, the change of the 3426 cm−1 peak of the hydroxyl group and the 1659 cm−1 peak of the carbonyl group can show the presence of hydrogen bonds between the two groups. Furthermore, the more the formed hydrogen bonds, the stronger the interaction of CdPNMI and dyes, resulting in an increasing absorption dosage of CdPNMI for dyes. This is consistent with our experimental conclusions.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experiment section, structure description and computation details, etc. CCDC 2336490. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qi00747f |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2024 |