Maoqiu
Li
a,
Lei
Hua
a,
Junteng
Liu
*b and
Zhongjie
Ren
*a
aState Key Laboratory of Chemical Resource Engineering Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China. E-mail: renzj@mail.buct.edu.cn
bBeijing Key Laboratory of Membrane Science and Technology, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China. E-mail: liujt@mail.buct.edu.cn
First published on 23rd August 2023
A detailed overview of thermally activated delayed fluorescence conjugated polymers reported from 2015 to present is provided, with a focus on their molecular structures, excited-state properties, and organic light-emitting diode performance. In addition, the rules for regulating the excited-state properties of these TADF conjugated polymers are summarized. By carefully designing the molecular structures of conjugated TADF polymers, their excited-state properties and the energy gaps between the lowest singlet excited states and the lowest triplet excited state can effectively be adjusted. Furthermore, the reverse intersystem crossing rate of conjugated polymers can be increased by enhancing the spin–orbit coupling effect between the triplet and singlet states, and thus optimizing the collection of triplet excitons and improving the device performance, including external quantum efficiency and efficiency roll-off.
The EQE of PLEDs refers to the ratio of the number of photons emitted per unit time to the injected electron–hole pairs and is related to the efficiency of converting electricity into light.14 It is one of the main performance indicators used to measure PLED devices because it directly determines the brightness and energy efficiency of PLEDs. Recently, in the field of full-colour light, the efficiency of PLEDs has achieved remarkable progress comparable to that of small molecule OLEDs and phosphorescent OLEDs.15 The 25.4% EQE mentioned above pertains to yellow-emitting PLEDs, and the EQEs of orange-red and blue-green emitting PLEDs have also reached 24.8%13 and 24%.16 In addition to pursuing high efficiency, the efficiency roll-off of PLED devices is also one of the performance indicators that researchers pay special attention to. Most PLEDs experience rapid efficiency roll-off at high brightness, which affects device performance and severely hinders commercial applications. The efficiency roll-off of PLEDs originates from the accumulation of emitter triplet excitons.17 For TADF materials, increasing the reverse intersystem crossing rate (kRISC) and reducing the triplet exciton quenching are effective ways to reduce the efficiency roll-off.18
The typical molecular structure of conjugated TADF polymers usually consists of donor–acceptor,19 or donor–acceptor–donor,20 which promotes the formation of intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) states between the donor and acceptor, so is the conjugated TADF polymer. Correspondingly, the lowest singlet excited state (S1) of the molecule is often the charge transfer state (1CT). For the triplet excited state, it usually displays the charge transfer triplet state (3CT) and localized excited triplet state (3LE). In order to improve the EQE of PLEDs and reduce the efficiency roll-off, there are many in-depth studies on the regulation of molecular excited states related to luminescence.15
According to Fermi's golden rule, larger kRISC requires higher spin orbit coupling (SOC) matrix element values and smaller ΔEST.21
![]() | (1) |
As shown in Fig. 1, based on Fermi's golden rule, two approaches to improving the kRISC of conjugated polymers can be easily made: one is to obtain a suitable ΔEST; the other is to enhance the spin coupling between singlet and triplet states. From the perspective of enhancing SOC, it can be divided into the 3LE auxiliary strategy and the hyperfine coupling (HFC) strategy.
It has been proven through numerous studies that the upconversion process from the T1 to S1 state requires TADF molecules to have a small ΔEST, which is a fundamental requirement for achieving efficient TADF emission. The small ΔEST can be controlled through the selection of donor and acceptor pairs and the type of connectivity between the donor and acceptor. For conjugated polymers, attention should also be paid to the triplet energy level (ETs) of the main chains, which can also affect the upconversion process of the TADF unit.
In 2016, Marc K. Etherington et al. demonstrated that ISC between 1CT and 3CT involves a more complex second-order process.22 This second-order process is mediated by the vibration coupling between 3CT and 3LE, which allows SOC to the 1CT state. Additionally, a reasonable energy level model was proposed, where the relative energy ordering and the energy gaps between CT and LE states [ΔE(3LE–3CT), ΔE(3LE–1CT)] control the efficiencies of ISC and reverse intersystem crossing (RISC) of TADF emitters. The energy gap between 3LE–3CT and 3LE–1CT states serves as the key activation barrier for efficient RISC. This leads to a rapid equilibrium between the two triplet states through internal conversion, followed by coupling of 3CT to 1CT state through the second-order perturbation theory under the mediation of 3LE.
In fact, the wave function of the spin triplet state is usually not a pure 3LE, but a mixture state involving 3CT and 3LE components. Some studies have also proved that when the proportion of 3LE components is low, satisfactory kRISC can also be obtained. Although the SOC is weak when the proportion of 3LE components is low, molecular vibration coupling has proved to play a key role in promoting the 3CT–1CT transition. When the energy gap between 1CT and 3CT becomes very small, the HFC between them may become active.23
Therefore, through molecular design, adjusting the properties and energy levels of molecular excited states, and enhancing the SOC between excited states are considered to be important methods to improve the kRISC of TADF materials. It is also an important strategy to improve the performance and stability of PLED devices and reduce the efficiency roll-off. However, there is also a complex relationship between the properties of TADF-conjugated polymers and their excited states. In this article, from the perspective of excited state regulation of conjugated polymers, the relationship between their molecular design, excited state properties and PLEDs performance is summarized. In addition, the molecular design and development direction of high-efficiency and high-stability PLEDs are outlined.
Common monomers used for the polymer backbones include carbazole, fluorene, diphenylthiophene, and tetramethylbenzene. They provide good carrier transport properties for conjugated polymers and promote the emission of TADF units. Fig. 2 shows some polymer structures related to suitable ΔEST.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Molecular structures of the selected high-efficiency TADF conjugated polymers related to suitable ΔEST. |
Because of the excellent hole-transporting ability, carbazole is a common backbone structure of conjugated polymers. The ET of the main chain formed by the copolymerization of carbazole and other units is sufficient to satisfy most of the visible light regions from blue-green to orange-red. Therefore, such polymers can be easily extended from small molecules and maintain a small ΔEST without worrying about the influence of the main chain on the excited state. Recently, Yang et al. combined the pure carbazole backbone with multiple resonance TADF (MR-TADF) molecules to design and synthesize a series of polymers, PCzBNx.12 The high ETs of polycarbazole ensure that the extremely small ΔEST of the side chain MR-TADF unit is not affected. And the weak electron-donating ability of carbazole will not produce long-range CT to MR-TADF units and affect the narrow emission of MR-TADF. On solution-processed OLEDs performance, PCzBN1 achieved an EQEmax of 17.8% and an impressive full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the electroluminescence spectrum of 27 nm. This is the first reported conjugated MR-TADF polymer, which fully demonstrates the versatility of the carbazole backbones.
Furthermore, carbazole can also work together with fluorene and tetramethylbenzene as polymeric main chains. Praetip Khammultri et al. designed and synthesized a series of TADF conjugated polymers (PCTXO/PCTXO-Fx (x = 25, 50, and 75)),24 which possess a conjugated backbone with TPA-carbazole/fluorene moieties as the donor and a pendent 9H-thioxanthen-9-one-10,10-dioxide (TXO) as the acceptor, forming a twisted donor–acceptor structure. The ΔEST values of four polymers are 0.15, 0.13, 0.12 and 0.12 eV, respectively, which are comparable to the ΔEST values of the original TADF small molecule. The similar design principles have been demonstrated in the CP-PLEDs field. In 2022, two novel chiral conjugated polymers, R-P and S-P, with small ΔEST values and thus excellent TADF properties are designed and synthesized.25 A series of CP-PLEDs using R-P and S-P as light-emitting layers show EQEmax values of 14.9% and 15.8%, respectively. Furthermore, CP-PLEDs based on R-P and S-P present strong mirror CPEL signals at maximum emission wavelengths of 546 nm and 544 nm, respectively. The work provides a new and successful strategy for the design of chiral TADF polymers to achieve the CPEL.
However, the ETs of the above types of carbazole backbones limit the application of blue-emitting conjugated polymers. To solve this problem, Wang et al. introduced tetramethylbenzene with carbazole to effectively increase the ETs of the main chains. In 2023, poly(DOPAcDSCz-TMP), poly(DOPAcBPCz-TMP) and poly(DOPAcNICz-TMP) were designed and synthesized, in which TADF units with different electron-withdrawing abilities are located into the side chains.26 The ΔEST for all polymers is as low as 68–165 meV. The corresponding PLEDs display sky-blue, green, and red electroluminescence with EQEmax values of 12.5%, 16.5%, and 3.6%, respectively. The Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage (CIE) coordinates are (0.22, 0.43), (0.37, 0.57) and (0.62, 0.38), respectively. This indicates that the polymeric backbone with high triplet makes it almost applicable to TADF polymers with a full-colour spectrum except deep blue light.
Carbazole and acceptor units can also be used for the main chains of red light-emitting polymers. Wang et al. proposed a strategy for constructing red TADF conjugated polymers by embedding quinoxaline-6,7-dicarbonitrile (QC) acceptors into the polycarbazole backbones and linking 9,10-dihydroacridine donors as side chains to the main chains.27 Non-doped electroluminescent devices achieve an EQEmax of 12.5% at 620 nm, representing the highest performance for solution-processed PLEDs based on red TADF polymers. When combining blue TADF materials and PCzAQC0.5 in a single emissive layer, bright white OLEDs with the entire visible-near infrared range (400–900 nm) are obtained with a record-high EQEmax of 22.4% at this time. By further controlling the molecular weight of PCzAQC0.5, the EQEmax of its red-emitting device can reach 21.2%.28
In addition to the carbazole unit as a donor, the dibenzothiophene sulfone mentioned above can also form the main chains of the conjugated polymers together with other units, for example, diphenylthiophene and fluorene. A series of conjugated polymers with the backbone-donor/pendant-acceptor architecture, PFSOTTx are designed and synthesized.29 The polymers inherit the inherent TADF characteristics of small molecules. Besides, diphenylthiophene and acceptors are copolymerized to form a main chain. In 2021, a backbone-acceptor and pendant-donor TADF conjugated polymer PSAQFx is reported, which is similar to PCzAQCx but has a smaller ΔEST and a faster kRISC than PCzAQCx.13 Based on PSAQFx, the doped devices achieve an EQEmax of 24.8% with an emission peak at 608 nm. This is the first example of achieving EQE over 20% with an emission peak over 600 nm in TADF polymer-based OLEDs.
Molecular excited state control is closely related to the molecular structure, and it can be achieved by adjusting the structure of conjugated TADF polymers to reduce ΔEST. For instance, optimizing the molecular excited state energy levels can be achieved by selecting appropriate donor–acceptor units and tuning the conjugation between them. In 2015, Adachi et al. developed a new class of conjugated polymers based on benzophenone, pCzBP and pAcBP, which consist of an alternating electron donor and acceptor unit in their main chains.30 When the donor units are replaced with acridan units, the ΔEST of the conjugated polymer decreases from 0.16 eV (pCzBP) to 0.004 eV (pAcBP). The EQEmax values of OLEDs prepared via solution processing of the donor–acceptor polymers increase from 8.1 ± 0.7% of pCzBP to 9.3 ± 0.9% of pAcBP, significantly surpassing the theoretical limit of traditional fluorescent OLEDs.
In 2016, the Cheng group adjusted the ΔEST of conjugated polymers by introducing donors into the main chains.31 The carbazole and 9,10-dihydroacridine derivatives are alternately copolymerized to obtain the conjugated main chains with high T1, in which the acceptors are either phenyl units containing electron-withdrawing cyanogen or triazine groups. The side chains are connected to the nitrogen atoms of the 9,10-dihydroacridine group at large dihedral angles, forming a twisted intramolecular charge-transfer (TICT) structure, and thus resulting in the efficient TADF conjugated polymers PAPCC and PAPTC. In PAPCC, HOMOs and LUMOs are well separated in space to achieve a smaller ΔEST. In solution-processed PLEDs, EQEmax achieves 12.6% with the emission peak at 521 nm. This is the first report of a fully conjugated polymer with efficient TADF.
Besides, in 2020, Rao et al. prepared the efficient TADF polymers with a donor–acceptor conjugated structure,32 in which triphenylamine (TPA) as a donor and dicyanobenzene as an acceptor are developed by changing the connection positions. When the connection position changes from the para-position to the meta-position, the ΔEST significantly decreases from 0.44 eV to 0.10 eV due to the increased hole–electron separation. As a result, compared to the para-connected polymer poly(TPAp-DCBp) without TADF features, the meta-connected polymer poly(TPAm-DCBm) shows strong delayed fluorescence characteristics. The corresponding solution-processed OLEDs achieve an EQE of 15.4% at 532 nm. This is the first report on donor–acceptor type conjugated TADF polymers, whose performance is comparable to that of backbone-donor/pendant-acceptor and TSCT polymers. Then, they proposed a novel steric locking strategy by introducing different numbers of methyl groups into donor–acceptor conjugated polymers to obtain three polymeric emitters, poly(TPAp-DCBp), poly(DMTPA-DCB) and poly(TMTPA-DCB).16 Due to the steric hindrance, the twisting angle between the donor and acceptor can be well-tuned, suppressing planar relaxation and conjugation elongation, thereby promoting hole–electron separation. Correspondingly, as the number of methyl groups increases, the twisting angle enlarges, and ΔEST decreases from 0.44 eV to 0.22 eV and 0.09 eV, respectively. The resulting donor–acceptor conjugated polymers achieve extremely low ΔEST (0.09 eV), enabling efficient TADF emission. The corresponding doped and undoped devices show record-high EQEs of 24.0% and 15.3%, respectively. During this period, other researchers also utilize this rule of reducing ΔEST to report many efficient TADF conjugated polymers.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Molecular structures of the selected high-efficiency TADF conjugated polymers related to 3LE assisted reverse intersystem crossing. |
Reineke's group reported a method for constructing TADF polymers from non-TADF units.33 Due to the smaller ΔEST of the prepared polymer P1 than the individual repeat unit and sufficiently high radiative decay rate, P1 achieves a PLQY of up to 71%. Density functional theory calculations confirm that the 3LE plays a key auxiliary role in promoting the up-conversion process, enabling the polymer to exhibit TADF properties. This work provides an encouraging strategy for producing efficient TADF oligomers and polymers from completely non-TADF units through coupling interactions. In later studies, they also reported the impact of host materials on OLEDs based on polymer P1.34 Delayed fluorescence is hardly observed in pure films or CzSi host, but replacing the host material CzSi with mCP increases delayed fluorescence by more than three orders of magnitude. The cyan blue device based on mCP as the host material exhibits an EQEmax of 4.26%, while the device based on the pure P1 film displays an EQEmax of only 0.87%. In the context of conjugated TADF polymer based PLEDs, this work proposes that the 3LE property in polymer excited states plays an important role in achieving TADF performance. Rao et al. reported a “TADF + Linker” strategy, where small-molecule TADF units are coupled together through a methyl-substituted phenyl linker group (phenyl, dimethylphenyl or tetramethylphenyl) to form three different polymers, poly(AcBPCz-P), poly(AcBPCz-DMP) and poly(AcBPCz-TMP), respectively.35 Analysis of the excited state energy levels for these polymers reveals that with an increase in the number of methyl groups on the linker, the CT emission (i.e., 3CT and 1CT) remains almost unchanged, but the local excited triplet (3LEb) of the polymeric backbones gradually increases in energy from poly(AcBPCz-P) to poly(AcBPCz-DMP) and poly(AcBPCz-TMP), with the 3LEb energy level rising from 2.27 eV to 2.58 eV and 2.74 eV, respectively. The 3LEb energy level of poly(AcBPCz-TMP) is even close to that of 1CT and 3CT. Therefore, the conjugation of the main chains could be adjusted by methyl substitution to modulate the energy levels of triplet, resulting in high-efficiency poly(AcBPCz-TMP)-based OLEDs with an EQE as high as 23.5% and CIE coordinates of (0.25, 0.52). Additionally, when combined with an orange-red TADF emitter, bright warm white electroluminescence is obtained with an EQEmax of 20.9% and CIE coordinates of (0.36, 0.51). The efficiencies of both monochromatic and warm white devices were the highest values reported for TADF polymers at that time. These results demonstrate the importance of the 3LE component in the auxiliary conversion process from 3CT to 1CT.
According to the second-order perturbation theory, 3LE plays an important auxiliary role in the RISC process. Two sets of conjugated polymers with anthraquinone moieties as pendant acceptors have been designed and prepared by Zhan et al. The acceptors are connected to the diphenylamine groups through a phenyl bridge to form TADF units, which are embedded in the polymer main chains through their donor segments, while the main chains are composed of dibenzothiophene-S, S-dioxide and 2,7-fluorene or 2,7-carbazole groups.36 The model compounds 2FSO-TAQ and 2CzSO-TAQ exhibit calculated ΔEST values of 0.20 eV and 0.16 eV, respectively, which match well with the experimental values of the polymers PFSOTAQ2 and PCzSOTAQ2 in thin films. Compared with PFSOTAQx, PCzSOTAQx exhibits a smaller ΔEST due to the stronger electron-donating ability of the carbazole groups. Excited-state energy level information reveals that when ΔEST is smaller (1CT and 3CT are close), there is a 3LE component close to 1CT to assist the SOC process. Non-doped OLEDs achieve efficient red emission at 625–646 nm. When the molar content of the TADF unit is 2%, the EQEmax is 13.6% with CIE coordinates of (0.62, 0.37), indicating saturated red electroluminescence. Similarly, two sky-blue TADF polymer emitters, PCzDD-50 and PTDD-50 are designed and synthesized.37 In these polymers, deep blue TADF molecule DMOTX-DMAC is used as a guest unit, and carbazole and triphenylamine derivatives (TPAs) are used as the host units for PCzDD-50 and PTDD-50, respectively. Molecular simulation and photophysical analysis reveal that PCzDD-50 possesses much more 3LE component in the T1 state than PTDD-50, and thus the increased 3LE component tends to promote SOC interactions between S1 and T1 according to the El-Sayed rule. Therefore, the potential enhancement of SOC interactions in PCzDD-50 can effectively accelerate the RISC process, resulting in a higher luminescence efficiency than PTDD-50. Finally, PCzDD-50 and PTDD-50 based PLEDs present EQEmax values of 8.2% (λEL = 488 nm) and 5.3% (λEL = 468 nm), respectively.
Then, pNAI37 series and pNAI28 series orange-red TADF polymers are synthesized with joint backbones of dibenzothiophene (DBT) and carbazole (Cz).38 By adjusting the connecting position of the DBT unit, the polymeric performance is successfully optimized. Meanwhile, the 1CT and 3CT levels of pNAI37 series are both 17 meV higher than those of the pNAI28 series, however, the pNAI37 series presents a smaller energy gap between the 1CT and 3LE levels [ΔE(1CT–3LE)] than the pNAI28 series. Since the 3LE state can act as a medium to help excitons spin flip from triplets to singlets, a smaller ΔE(1CT–3LE) enables better performance due to the second-order oscillator coupling mechanism. Finally, pNAI3705 exhibits the better excited-state properties with the OLED EQEmax of 20.16%, which is maintained at 10.61% at 500 cd m−2, ranking first tier among orange-red polymers. This work also demonstrates that optimizing excited-state properties by controlling the polymer chain structure is an effective way to improve device performance.
By summarizing this series of works, it is found that the properties of the excited state energy levels and the energy level differences are crucial. Specifically, according to the El-Sayed rule, when both excited states of conjugated TADF polymers display different properties (including 3LE and 1CT), 3LE or 3LEb can assist in completing the SOC process, achieving efficient RISC, improving the utilization efficiency of triplet excitons, and thus obtaining higher luminescence efficiency. However, it should be noted that the smaller the energy level difference between 1CT and 3LE [ΔE(1CT–3LE)], the better the RISC rate.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Molecular structures of the selected high-efficiency TADF conjugated polymers related to HFC. |
For example, the carbazole derivatives are combined with TADF unit, 2-(10H-phenothiazin-10-yl)dibenzothiophene-S,S-dioxide (DBTO2-PTZ) to construct three conjugated polymers, Homo, Cop-50 and Cop-10.39 The results show that the content of carbazole derivative units not only effectively suppresses the exciton annihilation and non-radiative transitions but also manipulates the molecular orbital distribution and ΔEST value, and even regulates the properties of excited states. Through the analysis of natural transition orbitals (NTOs) of the three polymers, it is concluded that although RISC between 1CT and 3CT may be inhibited due to weak SOC according to the El-Sayed rule, under certain conditions, RISC can also be achieved between 1CT and 3CT, which is attributed to the HFC of spins.40,41 Therefore, rational control of excited state properties may help guide the synthesis of efficient TADF polymers. Among the three polymers, COP-10 exhibits a higher kRISC and PLQY in the thin film state. The optimized OLEDs achieve an EQEmax of 15.7% with a turn-on voltage of only 3.2 V. Then, two double-emissive TADF polymers PTDP-5 and PTDP-10 are reported by replacing the carbazole derivatives on the polymeric main chains with TPAs,42 in which TPAs served as the main chains and blue emitters, while the alkylated TADF small molecules (DBTO2-PTZ) served as orange-yellow emitters. Due to the strong fluorescent emission characteristics and non-planar structure of TPAs in the main chains of TADF polymers, double-emissive polymers have been obtained by utilizing the emission of TPAs and DBTO2-PTZ TADF units. Increasing the proportion of TPA units enhances the relative intensity of blue emission. Therefore, in solution-processed OLEDs, as the percentage of TPAs units in the polymeric main chain increases, not only the CIE coordinates of PTDP-10 shift from (0.44, 0.43) to (0.38, 0.35) of PTDP-5, achieving warm-white emission, but also the EQEmax value increases from 4.8% of PTDP-10 to 7.1% of PTDP-5. The excited-state characteristics of the two polymers, PTDP-5 and PTDP-10, are also analyzed and found to follow the same rules as COP-10. It is shown that if the two excited states have the same properties (3CT and 1CT), the RISC between 1CT and 3CT may be suppressed due to weak SOC. However, when the energy level difference between 3CT and 1CT is very small, the HFC can be activated to break the El-Sayed rule, achieving upconversion and thus improving device performance. The OLED performance and the excited state energy levels of the selected TADF conjugated polymers with high efficiency are summarized in Table 1.
Polymers | k RISC (105 s−1) | ΔEST(exp)a (eV) | ΔEST(cal)b (eV) | λ EL (nm)/CIE | EQEd (%) | Typee | Ref. | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Calculated from fluorescence and phosphorescence spectra. b Calculated by TD-DFT at the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level. c Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage (CIE) coordinates. d The maximum EQE. e ΔEST, 3LE, 3LEb and HFC represent the strategy of controlling suitable ΔEST, triplet localized excited state, triplet localized excited state of main chains, and hyperfine coupling assisted reverse intersystem crossing, respectively. | ||||||||
pAcBP | 1.3 | 0.10 | 0.004 | 548/(0.38, 0.57) | 9.30 | ΔEST | 30 | |
PAPTC | — | 0.13 | 0.14 | 521/(0.30, 0.59) | 12.6 | ΔEST | 31 | |
PFSOTT2 | — | 0.26 | 0.09 | 406, 566/(0.42, 0.45) | 9.90 | ΔEST | 29 | |
PFSOTT2 | — | 0.26 | 0.09 | 592/(0.51, 0.47) | 19.4 | ΔEST | 29 | |
P1 | — | 0.023 | 0.12 | 480/(0.24, 0.37) | 4.30 | 3LE | 34 | |
Cop-10 | 14.4 | 0.043 | 0.022 | 578/(0.46, 0.49) | 15.7 | HFC | 39 | |
PTDP-5 | 0.14 | 0.060 | — | 428, 600/(0.38, 0.35) | 7.10 | HFC | 42 | |
Poly(AcBPCz-TMP) | — | 0.12 | 0.19 | 507/(0.25, 0.52) | 23.5 | 3LEb | 35 | |
Poly(AcBPCz-TMP) | — | 0.12 | 0.19 | 510, 552/(0.36, 0.51) | 20.9 | 3LEb | 35 | |
PCzDD-50 | 2.00 | 0.042 | 1.00 | 488/(0.22, 0.35) | 8.20 | 3LE | 37 | |
PTDD-50 | 1.12 | 0.047 | 0.86 | 468/(0.17, 0.22) | 5.30 | 3LE | 37 | |
PNAI3705 | 7.20 | 0.04 | 0.008 | 610/(0.57, 0.38) | 20.16 | 3LE | 38 | |
PCzSOTAQ2 | - | 0.12 | 0.16 | 642/(0.62, 0.37) | 13.6 | 3LE | 36 | |
PCzAQC0.5 | 2.90 | 0.18 | 0.18 | 620/(0.56, 0.42) | 12.5 | ΔEST | 27 | |
PCzAQC0.5 | 2.90 | 0.18 | 0.18 | 454, 632/(0.52, 0.38) | 22.4 | ΔEST | 27 | |
PSAQF10 | 8.60 | 0.20 | 0.05 | 608/(0.48, 0.49) | 24.8 | ΔEST | 13 | |
Poly(TPAm-DCBm) | 1.01 | 0.10 | 0.16 | 532/(0.34, 0.57) | 15.4 | ΔEST | 32 | |
poly(TMTPA-DCB) | 3.53 | 0.09 | 0.08 | 532/(0.34, 0.57) | 24.0 | ΔEST | 16 | |
PCTXO-F75 | — | 0.12 | — | 611/(0.55, 0.44) | 1.54 | ΔEST | 24 | |
PCTXO | — | 0.15 | — | 603/(0.56, 0.43) | 10.4 | ΔEST | 24 | |
poly(DOPAcDSCz-TMP) | 3.23 | 0.17 | 0.01 | 488/(0.22, 0.43) | 12.5 | ΔEST | 26 | |
poly(DOPAcBPCz-TMP) | 21.5 | 0.07 | 0.006 | 530/(0.37, 0.57) | 16.5 | ΔEST | 26 | |
poly(DOPAcNICz-TMP) | 13.5 | 0.07 | 0.007 | 620/(0.62, 0.38) | 3.60 | ΔEST | 26 | |
R-P | 6.28 | 0.045 | 0.047 | 546/(0.41, 0.57) | 14.9 | ΔEST | 25 | |
S-P | 6.31 | 0.061 | 0.047 | 544/(0.40, 0.57) | 15.8 | ΔEST | 25 |
Polymers | CIEa/λEL (nm) | EQE (%) | ΔESTc | Typed | Ref. | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maximum values | 1000 cd m−2 | Roll-offb | |||||
a Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage (CIE) coordinates. b The roll-off value with respect to the maximum EQE. c Measured in toluene solution. ΔEST = ES − ET. d ΔEST, 3LE, VC and IMS represent the strategy of controlling suitable ΔEST, triplet localized excited state, vibronic coupling and intermolecular sensitization assisted reverse intersystem crossing, respectively. | |||||||
PCzATD5 | (0.41, 0.55)/560 | 15.5 | 14.5 | 6.45 | 0.09 | ΔEST | 44 |
PABPC5 | (0.40, 0.56)/545 | 18.1 | 17.8 | 1.66 | 0.12 | ΔEST | 45 |
PCzAPT10 | (0.36, 0.55)/- | 16.9 | 15.6 | 7.69 | — | ΔEST | 46 |
PCzAB2Py5 | (0.48, 0.51)/573 | 11.9 | 11.3 | 5.04 | 0.10 | ΔEST | 47 |
PCzABA10 | (0.39, 0.57)/545 | 10.6 | 10.3 | 2.83 | 0.22 | ΔEST | 48 |
PCzBPF-10 | (0.38, 0.56)/542 | 20.0 | 18.2 | 9.00 | 0.01 | 3LE | 49 |
pBP-PXZ | (0.52, 0.48)/584 | 13.7 | 8.86 | 35.4 | 0.028 | 3LE | 50 |
HCP-7.5% | (0.55, 0.45)/600 | 8.39 | 7.43 | 11.4 | 0.038 | VC | 51 |
TCCP-3 | (0.34, 0.54)/535 | 17.8 | 16.0 | 10.1 | 0.017 | IMS | 55 |
P5 | (0.42, 0.55)/553 | 25.4 | 24.2 | 4.72 | 0.007 | IMS | 9 |
From 2017 to 2018, a series of studies on the conjugated polymers with low efficiency roll-off were conducted by Cheng and co-workers.44–48 These polymers have an identical backbone consisting of 3,6-carbazolyl and 2,7-acridinyl rings. One acridine ring and each acceptor group pendant constitute a definite TADF unit with the twisted donor–acceptor structure, which is incorporated into the polymeric main chains through 2,7-position of the acridine ring with the varied contents.
With the development of study on the conjugated TADF polymers, since 2020, our group has reported several TADF conjugated polymer-based OLEDs with low efficiency roll-off. In 2020, we designed and synthesized the fluorinated and chlorinated π-conjugated TADF polymers and their non-halogenated analogues, respectively.49 The halogenation can aggrandize the 3LE component of T1, which is favourable to enhancing SOC and RISC processes. Eventually, the halogenated emitter-based PLEDs can reach a high EQEmax of over 20%, and extremely low efficiency roll-off sustaining over 18% EQE at a luminance of 1000 cd m−2. This study opens a way to design high-efficiency TADF materials by halogenation and thus guides the future research on the high-performance PLEDs. The excited states of halogenated TADF polymers also abide by the El-Sayed rule, wherein the S1 and T1 states featuring the different excited natures generally possess the impressive SOC matrix element values. The auxiliary role of 3LE in the excited state for RISC is proved again.
Besides, some studies have shown that when S1 and T1 have the same excited state properties, in some specific cases, lower efficiency roll-off can also be obtained. On one hand, Yersin et al. recently demonstrated that the RISC process with a minimal ΔEST, extremely similar geometries, and energetically nearby lying states for SOC and configuration interaction can be carried out quickly via vibronic coupling between the lowest 1CT and 3CT states.21 This rule has also been proven by our newly prepared TADF conjugated polymer pBP-PXZ.50 pBP-PXZ shows the close energy levels of 1CT and 3CT, moreover, 1CT and 3CT have extremely similar geometries, negligible ΔE(1CT–3CT) (8 meV), and with a high proportion of 3LE features in T2. With the assistance of 3LE, pBP-PXZ can complete the rapid RISC process. Finally, the EQEmax of OLEDs based on pBP-PXZ neat films is 13.71%. Even the OLEDs based on pBP-PXZ-doped films can achieve an EQEmax of 23.11%, exhibiting no roll-off when the luminance is less than 200 cd m−2 and show only a 3% EQE decrease at 500 cd m−2. The EQE remains above 19% under 1000 cd m−2, which is the highest device efficiency among TADF polymer-based OLEDs under high luminance. On the other hand, Serdiuk et al. have recently demonstrated that the activated SOC by molecular vibrations plays a key role in facilitating direct RISC with a high rate of 3CT–1CT transition via the same CT states of different multiplicities.23 We also confirmed that the similar molecular vibrations and electronic structures between 1CT and 3CT states could minimize reorganization energy in the hyperbranched conjugated polymer (HCPs) system.51 The RISC process can be performed quickly via vibronic coupling between the lowest 1CT and 3CT states with a minimal ΔEST, extremely similar geometries, and energetically nearby lying states. Accordingly, the transitions forbidden by the El-Sayed rule can be activated due to vibrational coupling perturbations. Especially, the degenerated states of the HCPs with D–A–D type TADF characteristics would be strongly coupled owing to their energetic proximity and establish a multiple-CT vibrationally enhanced SOC for a fast RISC. Coupling with the efficient energy transfer process generated by advantageous structural features of HCPs, the strongly electron-withdrawing oxygen atoms located on the TADF cores further accelerate hole transportation from the host chains to the TADF cores. Under a rational regulation of the TADF core ratio, the related non-doped red-emitting device performs an outstanding performance with an EQEmax of 8.39% and exhibits no roll-off while the luminance is less than 100 cd m−2 and only 3.3% decrease at 500 cd m−2. Simultaneously, the EQE can be maintained at 7.4% under 1000 cd m−2.
As mentioned earlier, the TADF conjugated polymers can be directly used as light-emitting layers of PLEDs. In order to further improve device performance, the TADF polymer can also be used as the host material in host–guest PLEDs to suppress triplet–triplet annihilation. Based on the existing works,52–54 it can be concluded that the ETs of the conjugated polymer must be higher than that of the guest TADF material to prevent energy backflow from the guest material to the host material. From the perspective of regulating excited state energy levels, in order to achieve low efficiency roll-off, researchers have developed TADF sensitizers. TADF sensitizers have a high kRISC and can transfer the singlet excitons in the sensitizer unit through Förster resonance energy transfer to the singlet excitons of the emitter unit, thus avoiding the inefficient RISC process of the emitter itself. It is easy to understand that traditional intermolecular sensitization (IMS) strategies are prone to phase separation between the TADF sensitizer and the emitter. In this case, our group proposed a new intramolecular sensitization strategy by covalently binding the TADF sensitizer to the conjugated polymer luminescent material.55 By properly adjusting the ratio of the sensitizer and luminescent unit in the polymer, the intramolecular sensitized conjugated TADF polymer TCCP-3 is obtained, with a kRISC value greater than 106 s−1 and simultaneously suppressing the non-radiative transition of triplet excitons. Therefore, its PLQY can reach nearly 90%. The EQEmax of the solution-processed OLEDs reaches 17.8% with extremely low efficiency roll-off. Subsequently, we modified the light-emitting TADF unit with the electron-transporting material triphenylphosphine oxide to achieve the balanced charge carrier transport.9 By carefully adjusting the proportions of each components, we obtained P1-P5, among which P5 demonstrates a remarkable PLQY up to 90% and an exceptionally high kRISC of 3 × 106 s−1. The solution-processed PLEDs exhibit an EQE value of 25.4% with an emission peak at approximately 550 nm, representing record-breaking high-performance PLEDs. Additionally, significant suppression of efficiency roll-off was achieved, maintaining an EQE value of 24.2% at 1000 cd m−2, with the efficiency roll-off below 5%. This work provides an effective strategy for achieving high EQE and low efficiency roll-off. The energy transfer path of the excited state in the intramolecular sensitization strategy is shown in Fig. 6. These results demonstrate the importance of the intramolecular sensitization strategy in designing highly efficient conjugated TADF polymer emitters in molecular electronics.
After reviewing the regulation of the excited state energy level in high efficiency and low efficiency roll-off conjugated TADF polymers, it was found that the regulations were basically consistent. In fact, both high efficiency and low efficiency roll-off are important performance indicators for evaluating PLEDs, and they are inseparable and complementary in applications. Therefore, by carefully designing materials with appropriate excited state energy levels, both high efficiency and low efficiency roll-off can be achieved, simultaneously. In order to compare the performance of the reviewed TADF conjugated polymers, we summarize the OLED efficiency of TADF polymers based on the emission colour as shown in Fig. 7. As shown in Fig. 7, green TADF conjugated polymers have the most abundant types and highest efficiency, and the types of red TADF conjugated polymers need to be further enriched. Importantly, it is quite difficult to gain conjugated TADF polymers with blue and even deep-blue emissions, due to the limitation of the ETs of the main chains. Currently, the bluest TADF-conjugated polymer, PTDD-50, shows only sky-blue emission.
From the perspective of regulating the excited states of conjugated TADF polymers, it is necessary to minimize the ΔEST between S1 and T1 to ensure effective RISC, which depends on the separation of HOMOs and LUMOs. Therefore, in the early days, the most common design strategy for TADF materials was based on highly twisted (or nearly orthogonal) donor–acceptor structures with strong ICT characteristics to fully separate the spatial distribution of these frontier orbitals. Following this basic principle of regulating excited states, reducing the ΔEST of conjugated TADF polymers has led to significant progress in the development of efficient TADF materials. As research continues to deepen, researchers have begun to look for rules for regulating excited state energy levels by manipulating the excited state natures and energy gaps of luminescent materials. Based on a review of the excited-state energy level information of the existing high-performance conjugated polymer electroluminescent materials, it is concluded that excited states have different properties (1CT and 3LE), and the 3LE state assists in completing the SOC process during the efficient thermal conversion of T1 into S1. Additionally, the energy gap between 3LE and 1CT is more important, as a smaller value helps ensure rapid RISC and high efficiency devices. If the excited states have the same properties (1CT and 3CT), then the energy gap between 3CT and 1CT becomes more important because when this value is small enough, it can break the El-Sayed forbidden 3CT–1CT transition, achieving upconversion. Of course, the regulation of excited states in conjugated TADF polymers is not limited to these rules, and there are many deeper rules worth exploring for researchers.
From the perspective of molecular design, the high ETs of polymeric main chains are an important factor to ensure the suitable ΔEST of TADF conjugated polymers. Common host units include carbazole, fluorene, diphenylthiophene, tetramethylbenzene and so on. A suitable ΔEST for TADF conjugated polymers can be achieved by selecting appropriate donor–acceptor units and tuning the conjugation between them. For example, steric hindrance is introduced to adjust the twisting angle between the donor and acceptor. Besides, by summarizing the molecular structures of the selected high-efficiency TADF conjugated polymers related to 3LE assisted RISC and related to HFC, we found that the copolymerization of carbazole/carbazole derivatives with donors of TADF units as polymeric main chains might be a general molecular design strategy. Surprisingly, TADF conjugated polymers with low efficiency roll-off also follow this strategy.
Indeed, achieving high efficiency and low roll-off simultaneously is a major challenge faced by TADF conjugated polymers and is also the direction for future development. To achieve this, researchers will need to continue developing new design strategies and exploring more in-depth rules for regulating excited-state properties. Additionally, further advancements in theoretical modelling and simulation techniques could help researchers predict the performance of TADF materials more accurately before they are synthesized, saving time and resources. Overall, the goal is to develop TADF materials that can be used in a wide range of applications, from displays and lighting to sensing and biomedical imaging, providing a more sustainable and cost-effective alternative to traditional optoelectronic materials.
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |