Sahil
Kohli†
*a,
Garima
Rathee†
b,
Indrani
Jha
a,
Lakshita
Phor
c,
Harsh
Sable
d and
Vishal
Chaudhary
*e
aDepartment of Chemistry, School of Engineering and Technology, Manav Rachna International Institute of Research and Studies, Faridabad, Haryana-121004, India. E-mail: sahilkohli41@gmail.com; sahil.set@mriu.edu.in
bDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain
cCentre for Research Impact & Outcome, Chitkara University Institute of Engineering and Technology, Chitkara University, Rajpura 140401, Punjab, India
dSchool of Life and Applied Sciences, Maya Devi University, Dehradun, Uttarakhand-248011, India
eCentre for Theoretical Physics and Natural Philosophy, Nakhonsawan Studiorum for Advanced Studies, Mahidol University, Nakhonsawan, 60130, Thailand. E-mail: vishal.cha@mahidol.ac.th
First published on 4th August 2025
The exponential growth of the global population in the digital era has accelerated urbanization and industrialization, leading to severe complex water pollution from the discharge of toxic dyes into aquatic ecosystems. Two dimensional (2D) MXene-based nano-adsorbents recently emerged as promising candidates for developing sustainable wastewater remediation technologies due to their tunable physicochemical properties, including a high negative zeta potential, a large specific surface area, exceptional adsorption capacity, superior electrical and thermal conductivity, hydrophilicity, and rich surface chemistry. Strategic optimization approaches for MXenes, encompassing interlayer spacing modification, surface engineering, stoichiometric tuning, morphological control, bandgap engineering, membrane fabrication, hybridization, and functionalization, have significantly enhanced their adsorptive performance and dye removal efficiency for real-time wastewater treatment applications. This comprehensive review examines the latest advances in MXene-based nano-adsorbent engineering and their implementation as key components in wastewater treatment strategies for efficient dye removal from industrial effluents, providing fundamental insights into dye–MXene interactions to elucidate underlying complex removal mechanisms. The review highlights the sustainable characteristics of MXene-based nano-adsorbents, including their dye removal capacity, regeneration potential, recyclability, catalytic efficiency, and enhanced physicochemical properties, while addressing critical challenges, such as toxicity concerns, biocompatibility issues, and scalability limitations, that currently hinder their translation from the laboratory to the market. Innovative solutions are proposed through the integration of digital-age technologies, particularly artificial intelligence and machine learning approaches, with the implementation of these recommendations facilitating the establishment of MXene-based nano-adsorbents as sustainable alternatives to conventional commercial adsorbents. This aligns with the UN's Sustainable Development Goals and contributes to the principles of One Health, promoting global welfare.
Various technologies have been established in the past few years to effectively remove dye pollutants from water, including advanced oxidation,14–16 catalytic ozonation,17 flocculation and coagulation,18 Fenton oxidation and electrocoagulation,19 ion exchange,20 membrane separation,21 and photocatalysis.22,23 These approaches have certain drawbacks (Fig. 1), including the production of contaminated sludge, difficulties with disposal and handling, scaling up problems, high energy consumption, increased colouration of effluents, financial constraints, intricate and complex removal mechanisms, clogged membranes, restricted flow rates, and the production of byproducts.24
Among these methods, adsorption is considered to be an effective substitute technique for de-colorizing wastewater owing to its easy handling, affordability, sustainability, and quick water treatment.25–32 Furthermore, during the regeneration process, adsorption stops the creation of hazardous chemicals, which result in prevention from secondary contamination. For efficient adsorption, adsorbents with appropriate functionality and large surface areas are usually utilized for the adsorption process. A few porous materials such as MOFs, activated carbon, zeolites, chitosan, and kaolinite were prepared as adsorbents for environmental contaminants.33,34 Hydrogel materials are also used as a superior adsorbent for the elimination of water-based contaminants.35,36
The research community has shown substantial interest in 2D materials owing to their distinct chemical and physical properties, which set them apart from their bulk counterparts. This difference became particularly evident after the groundbreaking discovery of graphene through mechanical exfoliation into single layers.37 Following graphene's discovery, various 2D materials, including metal oxides, metal hydroxides, hexagonal boron nitrides, and TMDs, have been identified and their capability across various applications has been demonstrated.38–42 These 2D materials are low-dimensional materials possessing enormous surface areas and have been recognized as the best adsorbents for a variety of contaminants. Examples of these materials include carbon-based nanomaterials such as graphene, ordered mesoporous silica, and phosphorenes.43–45
A number of nanomaterials have lately shown great potential in water purification due to their notable physicochemical properties. Among them, MXenes is an innovative family of cutting-edge nanomaterials with promising applications in water remediation. They are also referred to as 2D transition metal carbides, carbonitrides or nitrides. MXene's unique design, fine structure, remarkable stability, notable oxidation and chemical resistance, high conductivity, and environmental friendliness increased the curiosity of researchers recently.46 They are ideal candidates for use in wastewater treatment applications due to their enhanced surface area and the availability of several functional groups, such as –OH and –O, on the MXene surface.47 Their varied chemical composition, photocatalytic capabilities, 2D layered architecture, and active metallic hydroxide sites have made these materials stand out as excellent candidates for use in water purification systems.48 MXene-based materials are also very useful in the adsorption of various organic dyes, which are toxic to the environment. Additionally, MXenes serve as raw materials for the fabrication of nanostructured MXene membranes, demonstrating beneficial usage in wastewater treatment methods.49,50
This review article addresses the potential use of MXenes, 2D transition metal carbides and nitrides in improving dye adsorption for wastewater treatment. MXenes are characterized by their unique surface chemistry, increased surface area, and superior conductivity, which make them a vital choice for eliminating hazardous dyes from industrial effluents. In this article, advancements in MXene-based adsorbents, including their physicochemical features, adsorption mechanisms that improve the efficacy of MXenes in dye removal operations, and the design and techniques for synthesizing for these adsorbents are discussed. Additionally, it highlights recent progress in integrating MXenes into composite materials and membrane systems to optimize performance. Furthermore, the regeneration, recyclability, challenges and recommendations are also addressed for a sustainable environment. This review explores the viability of MXenes as an eco-friendly and sustainable approach for water remediation, paving the way for future investigations and the expansion of sustainable wastewater management technologies.
The fundamental MAX phase and MXenes have the same hexagonal crystal structure. Typically, MAX phases are expressed as Mn+1AXn (n = 1–3), which yields M2AX (211), M3AX2 (312), and M4AX3 (413) (Fig. 2a).52,53 The “X” atoms fill the octahedral spaces created by the arrangement of “M” atoms of the transition metal organizing into octahedra in all MAX phases, resulting in M6X interspersed with “A” element sheets and M6X overlapping with “A” element sheets.54 The only thing that separates the (211), (312), and (413) phases are the numbers of M atom layers between A atom layers. Conclusively, the MAX phase consists of alternating layers of MX and A. Ti3AlC2 has a unit cell that resembles a hexagon and a five-atomic sheet structure. Among the five atomic sheets, three Ti sublayers containing carbon atoms are located at the “octahedral interstitial sites”, and a reactive Al layer links the two adjacent layers. The zone of surface terminating groups, the intralayer skeleton, and the interlayer make up the structure of Ti3C2Tx.55
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) The structural arrangement of MAX phases and their associated MXenes. Reproduced with permission from ref. 53. Copyright (2013) John Wiley & Sons. (b) Various examples of different MAX phases. | ||
This mechanical robustness is coupled with excellent flexibility due to their layered structure, which enables MXenes to bend and deform without compromising their structural integrity. Such properties are advantageous in wastewater treatment, where maintaining functionality under different conditions is essential. Flexibility is another essential aspect of mechanical behavior. MXenes have a layered structure that imparts a degree of flexibility, allowing them to bend and distort. The specific mechanical properties of MXenes can vary based on factors such as composition, doping, production methods, and the existence of defects or functional groups. Owing to their versatility, MXenes are appealing prospects for application in the adsorption of dyes.68
The electrical conductivity of Ti3C2Tx ranged from 850 to 9880 S cm−1, which could be attributed to variations in (i) defect concentration, (ii) surface functional groups, (iii) delamination yield, (iv) d-spacing between MXene flakes, and (v) lateral diameters influenced by the etching technique used.73,74 Generally, reduced HF content and etching durations produce MXenes with fewer flaws and larger lateral dimensions, resulting in enhanced electronic conductivity (for instance, bigger flake sizes yielded conductivities five times greater than those of smaller MXenes).75 Furthermore, environmental humidity may affect their conductivities,76 indicating potential application for relative humidity sensing materials.77,78 An effective method to improve electrical characteristics is surface modification using alkaline and thermal treatments. They demonstrate conductivities that rise by up to two orders of magnitude. This augmentation results from the modification and/or elimination of functional groups and embedded molecules.79–81 Also, the functional groups present on the surface might result in localized electronic states, which boost adsorption capacity via enhanced chemical interactions. The ability to control these electrical properties via chemical modifications or by changing the composition of MXenes enables tailored performances under various dye removal conditions. Overall, the favorable electrical properties of MXenes contribute to their potential as excellent adsorbents in wastewater treatment applications.
Surface termination chemistry significantly influences MXene biocompatibility profiles. Fluorinated Ti3C2Tx synthesized via conventional HF etching exhibits enhanced cytotoxicity due to fluoride ion release, which promotes ROS generation.98 Halogen-free Ti3C2Tx produced through NaOH-based etching demonstrates superior biocompatibility with no noticeable cytotoxicity even at high concentrations. PEGylation alters protein corona formation and cellular take up mechanisms, with PEGylated MXenes showing modified biocompatibility profiles.99
Environmental persistence studies reveal Ti3C2Tx stability in aquatic media for at least 4 days at concentrations of 5–20 mg L−1, with no dissolution detected over 42 days.100 Aquatic organism studies using zebrafish embryo models indicate LC50 values of 257.46 μg mL−1, classifying Ti3C2Tx as “practically non-toxic” under acute exposure conditions.101 However, chronic exposure effects including developmental abnormalities and behavioral changes remain poorly characterized. Metabolomic analysis in Daphnia magna reveals metabolic disruption at sublethal concentrations, indicating potential ecosystem-level impacts.102 The environmental behavior of MXenes involves complex transformation pathways influenced by water chemistry and redox conditions. Aggregation processes in natural waters alter bioavailability, while photodegradation generates titanium dioxide nanoparticles with unknown ecological implications.100 Oxidative degradation over weeks to months may produce metabolites with different toxicity profiles compared to parent materials.
Comprehensive safety assessment using the safe and sustainable by design (SSbD) framework suggests Ti3C2Tx can be safe and sustainable when properly designed and applied.100 Life cycle assessment (LCA) studies identify synthesis impacts as major environmental concerns, particularly titanium precursor production and hazardous chemical usage.103 Green synthesis alternatives using electrochemical etching reduce the environmental impact but require systematic toxicity evaluation. Current regulatory frameworks lack MXene-specific guidelines, creating knowledge gaps for commercial applications. Standardized testing protocols addressing unique physicochemical properties are needed for comprehensive risk assessment. Risk mitigation strategies include surface engineering for reduced toxicity, biocompatible coating systems, and real-time monitoring for environmental release detection. Critical research needs include long-term exposure studies, mechanistic toxicology investigations, and ecosystem-level impact assessments. Predictive toxicology models incorporating machine learning approaches can accelerate safety evaluation while reducing animal testing requirements. Integration of advanced characterization techniques will provide mechanistic insights that are essential for safe-by-design approaches.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 (a) Illustration of the process of etching and delamination of MXene. Reproduced with permission from ref. 105. Copyright 2019, Elsevier. (b) Schematic diagram for synthesizing the Co–MoS2/Mo2CTx nanohybrids. Reproduced with permission from ref. 107. (c) CVD growth of large-area α-Mo2C thin layer on Cu substrate. Reproduced with permission from ref. 112. Copyright 2015, Springer Nature. (d) Schematic of the synthesis of 2D MoN. Reproduced with permission from ref. 113. Copyright 2015, American Chemical Society. | ||
Many attempts have been made to create safer and milder production methods for HF due to its significant toxicity and high danger. Using a combination of HCl and LiF rather than HF solution allowed for the production of few-layer MXene with fewer surface flaws and greater interlayer spacing in 2014.114 H+ and F− were liberated during the etching process to create HF in situ. Al atoms were replaced by intercalated metal ions and H2O molecules, which encouraged the interlayer gap to expand and the interlayer interaction to diminish. Significantly, by adjusting the quantity of LiF and HCl, this new technique made it possible to regulate the size and quality of sheets.115 The original etchant is also substituted with mixtures of acid (H2SO4) and other fluoride salts (KF, NaF, and CaF2). The presence of –F groups further restricts the application of MXene in electrochemical fields, and the generation of HF cannot be entirely prevented by using these fluorinated salts.116 Furthermore, a variety of organic compounds, including tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAOH) and dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO), was used as an intercalation agent for converting the multi-layer MXene into a few-layer MXene. The intercalants enable stacked multi-layer MXene to delaminate into a few-layer or monolayer sheet through subsequent shaking or ultrasonication treatment.71,117
:
1, and heated at 550 °C for 30 min under an Ar atmosphere. After that, more washing with H2SO4 and deionised water was needed to eliminate the fluorides that contained aluminum. The prominent broad peak (002) of Ti4N3Tx shifted from 7.6° to 6.3°, as corroborated by XRD data, showing an extended interlayer distance. The EDX results also showed that no Al atoms were seen, indicating that nitride MXenes were successfully etched using the molten salt.
Chloride ions functioned as the Ti–Al bond breaker at a constant applied potential of 5 V, and NH4OH that was produced assisted in extending the edges. Compared to conventional HF-etched MXene, the exfoliated sheets had an average lateral size of nearly 2 μm and were primarily single or double layers. Furthermore, Ti3C2Tx sheets synthesized through electrochemical etching often have a stacked architecture that is comparable to that of bulk Ti3AlC2 without exhibiting any obvious expansion. This is due to the fact that the reaction process does not include the release of a significant amount of gas. It should be mentioned that the outcome of etched MXene is also greatly influenced by the choice of electrolytes. For instance, electrochemical treatment in solutions containing NaCl and HCl invariably produces amorphous carbon, which obstructs additional etching.123 Sun and colleagues discovered that when MAX was treated with 2 M HCl aqueous electrolyte, a three-layer structural composite was produced.124 The components of this hybrid were unetched MAX, carbon-derived carbides (CDCs), and MXene, which required additional purification in order to get pure MXene sheets.
Above all, using particular etching techniques such as molten salt etching, HF etching, and other fluorine-free approaches, MXenes could be extracted from bulk MAX phases by exploiting the difference in intensities between M–X and M–A bonds. It should be mentioned that the M–A bond energies had a significant impact on the etching conditions, with longer etching times and higher etchant concentrations needed for stronger M–A bonds. Furthermore, the etching rate and reaction conditions are significantly influenced by the size of the MAX particles.106 Attrition milling of the MAX powder beforehand could significantly cut down on the etching time while maintaining the overall yield.
| MXene | Dye | Adsorption capacity/% removal efficiency | Experimental conditions | Isotherms/kinetics | Regeneration | Toxicity evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ti3C2Tx 128 |
MB | 39 | C 0 (MB) = 0.05 mg mL−1, 25 °C, 20 h | Freundlich | • Ti3C2Tx gradually oxidises to TiO2 and Ti(OH)4 in water, limiting reusability | • No direct cytotoxicity or ecotoxicity tests were reported |
| • Structural changes (layer expansion and disorder) occur after 20 h in dye solution | • Possible formation of TiO2 NPs and fluoride leaching may raise concerns | |||||
| • Material is not stable for long-term aqueous applications or storage | • Additional studies needed to assess environmental and biological safety | |||||
NaOH–Ti3C2Tx 129 |
MB | 189 | 25 °C, pH = 6–6.5 | Langmuir/PSO | • No regeneration or reuse tests were conducted | • No cytotoxicity, ecotoxicity, or leaching tests were included |
LiOH–Ti3C2Tx 129 |
MB | 121 | 25 °C, pH = 6–6.5 | Langmuir/PSO | • Material performance stability over multiple cycles not studied | • Alkaline treatment may reduce fluoride (–F) groups, potentially improving biocompatibility |
KOH–Ti3C2Tx 129 |
MB | 77 | 25 °C, pH = 6–6.5 | Langmuir/PSO | • Suggests need for future work on recyclability | • Safety and environmental impact not evaluated |
h-Ti3C2 130 |
MB | 24 | 2 h | — | • No regeneration, desorption, or reuse cycles were tested or discussed | • No direct toxicity, cytocompatibility, or environmental safety evaluations made |
| • Long-term stability of the MXenes in dye removal applications not evaluated | • Indirect benefit: hydrothermal route avoids toxic HF, reducing synthesis hazards | |||||
| • Future studies should assess recyclability to validate practical applicability | • Leaching or stability of AlF3 by-products not assessed | |||||
Nb2CTx 131 |
MB | 526.32 | C 0 = 100–500 mg L−1, 25 °C, pH = 7, dose = 1 g L−1, 700 rpm | PSO | • No regeneration/reusability cycles tested | • No toxicity (cytotoxicity or ecotoxicity) or leaching studies reported |
| • Long-term performance stability and recyclability are not addressed | • HF used for etching may pose safety concerns unless thoroughly washed and neutralised | |||||
| • Future studies should focus on desorption efficiency and material durability | • Environmental and biological safety remain unexplored | |||||
| PAA2 alk-MXene132 | MB | 193.92 | C 0 = 60–90 mg L−1, 25–55 °C, pH = 2–10 | Langmuir/PSO | • The adsorbent AA2-alk-MXene maintained over 85% dye removal efficiency after five adsorption–desorption cycles | • No direct cytotoxicity or ecotoxicity tests were reported in the study |
| PAA2 alk-MXene132 | CR | 264.46 | C 0 = 60–90 mg L−1, 25–55 °C, pH = 2–10 | Langmuir/PSO | • Ethanol was used as the desorbing agent | • Use of mild reagents like AA and NaOH suggests potentially low toxicity, although this was not experimentally verified |
| • Good reusability and structural stability | • Biocompatibility and environmental safety remain unexplored | |||||
| Ti3C2–SO3H133 | MB | 111.11 | T = 25 °C, pH = 7, dosage = 10 mg, C0 = 50 mg L−1 | Langmuir/PSO | • Regeneration or reuse experiments were not conducted | • Did not evaluate toxicity, cytotoxicity, or leaching risks |
| • Long-term adsorbent stability was not assessed | • Use of NaF and arenediazonium salts may pose safety concerns | |||||
| • No adsorption–desorption cycles reported | • Environmental impact and biocompatibility remain unexplored | |||||
MXene-COOH@(PEI/PAA)n 134 |
MB | 81.9672 | C 0 = 0–3 mg L−1, 25 °C, dose = 10 mg per 50 mL | Langmuir/PSO | • The removal efficiency decreased from 85.6% to 64.4% after 8 cycles | • Environmental safety and leaching of components were not assessed |
| • The material showed good stability and reusability | • The synthesis avoids heavy metals, but toxicity remains unevaluated | |||||
| PHGC/MXene135 | MB | 555.56 | C 0 = 50–100 mg L−1, 298–308 K, pH = 11 | Langmuir/PSO | • PHGC/MXene hydrogel maintained over 90% removal efficiency for AB93 and MB after 12 regeneration cycles | • No in vivo or in vitro toxicity studies were reported |
| • NaHCO3 and HCl were effective desorption agents for AB93 and MB, respectively | • Environmental impact and cytocompatibility were not evaluated | |||||
| • The material showed excellent reusability and economic regeneration | • Safety validation is lacking for biomedical or large-scale applications | |||||
| Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified multi-layered Ti3C2Tx MXene (CMM)136 | MO | 213 | C 0 = 10–500 mg L−1, 298 K, pH = 3–12, dose = 0–3.33 g L−1 | Langmuir/PSO | • Adsorption capacity decreased slightly from 25.52 mg g−1 to 14.3 mg g−1 after 5 cycles | • No direct toxicity assessment (e.g., cytotoxicity, ecotoxicity) was conducted in the study |
| • Ethanol used for desorption demonstrated effective dye elution | • Implicit safety suggested via use of ethanol in desorption and absence of harmful leachates | |||||
| • CMM maintained commendable reusability and structural integrity | ||||||
| ABC/MX composite137 | CR | 1103.7 | C 0 = 50–500 mg L−1, pH = 1–11, 300 K–330 K, dose = 0.4 g L−1 | Freundlich model | • CR: high stability and reusability; >95% removal retained after 5 cycles | • No in vitro, in vivo, or ecotoxicity tests were performed |
| • Cr(VI): performance dropped significantly from 88.44% to 55.53% after 1 cycle | • However, authors emphasised that: | |||||
| • Bacterial cellulose (BC) is a renewable, biodegradable, and non-toxic biopolymer | ||||||
| • Desorbed Cr(VI) is treated with Fe(II) to form precipitates, reducing secondary pollution risk | ||||||
| • Suggests low environmental burden under controlled usage but lacks direct toxicity proof | ||||||
| MXene-PEI138 | MO | 909.1 | C 0 = 120–300 mg L−1, 328 K, pH = 3 | Langmuir/PSO | • High stability and reusability over 5 cycles: | • No in vitro or in vivo toxicity tests |
| • MB: removal decreased from 89.7% → 85.3% | • Materials (MXene, chitosan, alginate) are described as biocompatible and eco-friendly | |||||
| • Cr(VI): removal decreased from 93.4% → 87.2% | • No harmful by-products or leaching reported | |||||
| • Structural integrity: maintained porous architecture and adsorption capacity | • Indicates low environmental impact but lacks formal toxicological validation | |||||
| MX-PAN membrane139 | MB | — | C 0 = 10 mg L−1, 25 °C, pH = 7 | — | • Reusability: | • No explicit cytotoxicity or environmental toxicity tests conducted |
| • After 5 adsorption–desorption cycles: | • Components (MXene, lignocellulose, CNF) are natural or biocompatible | |||||
| • Cr(VI): removal decreased from 91.7% to 86.3% | • Emphasis on green synthesis and biodegradability | |||||
| • MB: removal declined from 95.4% to 89.5% | • Suggests low toxicity potential, but lacks empirical toxicology evidence | |||||
| • Retained adsorption capability and structure, demonstrating excellent recyclability | ||||||
| SA/MXene nanofiber membranes140 | MB | 440 | C 0 = 50–220 mg L−1, 98 K–323 K, pH = 2–11, dose = 1–5 mg | Langmuir/PSO | • Performance over cycles: | • No direct cytotoxicity or environmental toxicity data |
| • After 5 adsorption–desorption cycles: | • MXene and attapulgite considered relatively biocompatible materials | |||||
| • Cr(VI): decreased from 93.6% → 84.7% | • Use of mild regenerants (ethanol, NaOH) supports low environmental burden | |||||
| • MB: decreased from 91.2% → 85.2% | • Long-term stability of MXene against oxidation not discussed in toxicological terms | |||||
| • Observation: slight decline but excellent reusability and structural robustness | ||||||
| Ti3C2Tx bound with terephthalate (T-MX)141 | MB | 209 | pH = 7, RT, 100 mg L−1 | PSO | • Unique regeneration method: spent T-MX (after MB adsorption) is reconverted into MAX phase by adding only Al powder and applying mechanochemical (MC) ball milling | • No cytotoxicity or environmental safety data were presented |
| • The MAX phase is then re-etched into MXene, confirming the closed-loop recyclability of the material | • Concerns noted: | |||||
| • Pollutants and terephthalate pillars are carbonised and reused as the carbon source in the MAX phase | • Potential contamination from milling tools (Fe, alloying metals) under acidic HF etching | |||||
| • These may bind to reactive Ti sites, requiring further toxicological investigation | ||||||
| • Materials used (MXene, terephthalate) are otherwise not inherently toxic, and MC synthesis is solvent-free and greener | ||||||
| TMAOH delaminated Ti3C2Tx MXene nanosheets142 | MB | 1026 | C 0 = 20–80 mg L−1, 318 K, pH = 6, dose = 0.01–0.06 g L−1 | Freundlich/PSO | • Reusability was tested over 5 cycles using 1 M NaOH for desorption | • No direct cytotoxicity or ecotoxicity tests were reported |
| • Stable performance for 3 cycles with no significant loss in adsorption capacity | • Regeneration using NaOH and sedimentation by flocculation suggest potential for safe separation, but further biological evaluations are necessary for real-world application | |||||
| • Slight drop after 3rd cycle likely due to material loss and structural degradation (ultrathin layers disrupted) | ||||||
| MXene/PEI modified sodium alginate aerogel (MPA)143 | CR | 3568 | Adsorbent dose: 10 mg | Langmuir/PSO | • MPA demonstrated excellent recyclability with 16.3% capacity loss for Cr(VI) after 5 cycles and only 4.29% loss for CR after 5 cycles | • No toxicity assessment or environmental impact evaluation was conducted in this study |
| • The adsorbent maintained 83.7% Cr(VI) removal capacity and 95.71% CR removal efficiency after five regeneration cycles using NaOH/NaCl and ethanol desorption methods, respectively | • MPA exhibited outstanding antibacterial properties with 99.99% bacterial killing efficiency against both E. coli and S. aureus after 2 h exposure | |||||
| alk-MXene/CoFe2O4/CS144 | MB | 537.63 | C 0 = 17–50 mg L−1, 22–47 °C, pH = 2–12, dose = 10 mg per 25 mL | Langmuir/PSO | • The adsorbent demonstrated excellent recyclability with >80% removal efficiency maintained for RhB and MG dyes after 5 cycles, while CR retained ∼66% efficiency | • No toxicity assessment or environmental impact evaluation was conducted in this study |
| alk-MXene/CoFe2O4/CS144 | RhB | 1333.86 | C 0 = 5–10 mg L−1, 22–47 °C, pH = 2–12, dose = 10 mg per 25 mL | Langmuir/PSO | • Magnetic separation using NdFeB magnet enabled easy recovery from aqueous solutions, with ethanol used as a desorption agent for regeneration cycles | • The paper focused solely on adsorption performance without investigating potential environmental or health impacts of the synthesized materials |
| alk-MXene/CoFe2O4/CS144 | CR | 2095.9 | C 0 = 5–10 mg L−1, 22–47 °C, pH = 2–12, dose = 10 mg per 25 mL | Langmuir/PSO | ||
MXene (Ti3C2)/Fe3O4 145 |
MB | 9.85 | C 0 = 1–40 mg L−1, 25–55 °C, dose = 1 g L−1 | Freundlich isotherm | • No regeneration or recyclability studies were conducted in this research | • No toxicity assessment or environmental impact evaluation was performed in this study |
| • The study focused solely on adsorption performance at different temperatures without investigating the reusability of the 2D-MX@Fe3O4 adsorbent | • The research concentrated on adsorption mechanisms and temperature effects without addressing potential health or environmental risks | |||||
| Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel146 | CR | 588.24 | C 0 = 50–300 mg L−1, 298–328 K, pH = 3–9 | Freundlich/PSO | • The composite demonstrated excellent recyclability with 74.94% and 71.72% removal efficiency maintained for Cr(VI) and CR, respectively, after 5 cycles | • A comprehensive leaching test was conducted using the ICP-MS technique to detect potential metal leaching (Ni, Fe, Mn) over pH range 3–9 |
| • Regeneration was achieved using 1 M NaCl/methanol solution with continuous stirring for 2 h, followed by drying at 50 °C for 8 h before reuse | • Results showed almost constant metal content after adsorption processes, confirming the stability and safety of the composite for practical applications without significant metal leaching | |||||
| AMXGO147 | MG | 1111.6 | C 0 = 100–400 mg L−1, 298 K–328 K, pH = 2–12 | Freundlich/PSO | • The composite maintained >70% removal efficiency for both MG and CR after 5 cycles | • Zeta potential analysis showed stable surface charge (−20.54 to −52.00 mV, pH 2–12) without harmful ion leaching |
| • Regeneration used 5 mL detergent + 100 mL DI water, stirred for 3 h, washed to neutral pH, then freeze-dried | • XRD and FTIR confirmed no structural degradation after multiple cycles, ensuring material safety | |||||
| MXene/COF148 | MB | 96.4% | Effective membrane area ∼ 8.0 cm2 | — | • The membrane maintained >96% rejection and >243 L m−2 h−1 bar−1 water permeance after 45 h of continuous operation | • XRD analysis confirmed no structural degradation with d-spacing remaining stable at ∼1.46 nm after extended operation |
| MXene/COF148 | CR | 98.2% | Effective membrane area ∼ 8.0 cm2 | — | • No specific regeneration process described – membrane showed excellent stability without requiring regeneration protocols | • Membranes showed excellent anti-swelling properties under pH 3–10 conditions, maintaining structural integrity without toxic leaching |
| MXene/COF148 | MO | 97.2% | Effective membrane area ∼ 8.0 cm2 | — | ||
| alk-MXene/ZIF composites149 | CR | 539.7 | 298–318 K, pH = 8 | Elovich/PSO | • The composite maintained >85% removal efficiency for all three pollutants (CR, TC, MG) after 5 cycles | • XRD analysis confirmed stable crystalline structure with no significant peak shifts after air exposure for 45 days |
| alk-MXene/ZIF composites149 | MG | 7111.3 | 298–318 K, pH = 8 | Elovich/PSO | • Regeneration achieved using anhydrous ethanol stirring for 2 h, followed by deionized water washing and freeze-drying | • Membrane filtration tests showed >90% removal maintained after 5 cycles, demonstrating material safety without toxic leaching |
| DSP-M150 | RhB | 678.19 | C 0 = 2–100 mg L−1, 30 °C–60 °C, pH = 7 | Langmuir/PSO | • The composite maintained a stable performance with no specific regeneration protocol described, showing structural integrity after multiple adsorption–desorption cycles | • XPS analysis confirmed no harmful metal leaching or toxic byproduct formation during adsorption processes |
| DSP-M150 | CR | 754.41 | 5–200 mg L−1, 30 °C–60 °C, pH = 7 | Langmuir/PSO | • Material stability confirmed through XRD and FTIR analysis showing no structural degradation after repeated use | • Statistical physics modeling confirmed physical adsorption processes (E < 8 kJ mol−1) involving safe hydrogen bonding, electrostatic forces, and van der Waals interactions |
| ZnS/CuFe2O4/MXene (ZSCFOM)151 | DBM | 377 | 0.02–4 g L−1, 12 h, 75 rpm, 20 °C | Langmuir/PSO | • Good reusability with no significant reduction in DBM removal rate after three cycles | • Successfully applied to real environmental waters (tap, pond, river) with 100% removal of 0.05 g L−1 dyes |
| ZnS/CuFe2O4/MXene (ZSCFOM)151 | DBRN | 390 | 0.02–4 g L−1, 12 h, 75 rpm, 20 °C | Langmuir/PSO | • Excellent thermal stability with minimal weight loss (0.23–0.38%) at 25–600 °C | • Photocatalytic process generates environmentally benign products through complete mineralization |
| • Magnetic separation capability for easy recovery using CuFe2O4 component | • Magnetic properties enable easy separation and recovery, preventing secondary contamination | |||||
| PHGC/MXene135 | AB93 | 207.47 | C 0 = 50–100 mg L−1, 298–308 K, pH = 2 | Langmuir/PSO | • Excellent reusability with removal rates remaining above 90% for AB93 and above 97% for MB after 12 cycles | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the PHGC/MXene composite material itself was conducted |
| • Regeneration achieved using 0.1 mol L−1 NaHCO3 solution for AB93 and 0.1 mol L−1 HCl solution for MB | • Effective removal of toxic anionic (AB93) and cationic (MB) dyes from contaminated water | |||||
| • Minimal decrease in performance (less than 3% compared to highest removal rate) demonstrating excellent stability | • Successfully tested over different pH ranges (2–12) without significant material degradation | |||||
| • Both acidic and alkaline regeneration solutions proved effective for respective dye systems | • Non-toxic regeneration process using environmentally acceptable desorption agents (NaHCO3 and HCl) | |||||
| • No adverse effects on hydrogel structure during multiple regeneration cycles | ||||||
| • Material demonstrated biocompatibility based on constituent components | ||||||
| ZIF-8@IL-MXene/PNIPAM152 | CV | 325.03 | C 0 = 0.4–2 mg L−1, 25–45 °C, pH = 7 | Freundlich/PSO | • Good reusability with adsorption capacities decreasing to 79%, 91%, and 29% for 4-NP, CV, and Cu2+, respectively, after five cycles | • Environmentally friendly synthesis and desorption processes without organic solvents |
| • Desorption achieved via volume phase transition in deionized water at 35–40 °C (environmentally friendly process) | • Successfully applied to multifunctional removal of phenols, dyes, and metal ions from industrial wastewater | |||||
| • Decline in Cu2+ adsorption due to strong chelation bonds, which are difficult to break through phase transition | • VPTT range 33–35 °C enables safe temperature-responsive desorption process | |||||
| • No toxic byproducts reported during adsorption/desorption cycles | ||||||
| AMXGO153 | CR | 1133.7 | C 0 = 100–400 mg L−1, 298 K–328 K, pH = 2–12 | Freundlich/PSO | • Good reusability with removal efficiencies gradually decreasing over five cycles | • No significant effects from common cations (Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2+) and anions (Cl−, NO3−, CO32−, SO42−) on dye removal |
| CMC composite153 | AO7 | 367.9 | C 0 = 50–500 mg L−1, 25–45 °C, pH = 3–11 | Sips/PSO | • AO7 showed least decrease in efficiency, followed by MO and CR after five cycles | • Successfully tested in different water matrices (deionized, tap, and lake water) |
| CMC composite153 | MO | 294.2 | C 0 = 50–500 mg L−1, 25–45 °C, pH = 3–11 | Sips/PSO | • Gradual decrease attributed to incomplete desorption and loss of surface functional groups during the regeneration process | • Slightly reduced performance in tap and lake water due to competing ions and organic matter |
| CMC composite153 | CR | 628.5 | C 0 = 50–500 mg L−1, 25–45 °C, pH = 3–11 | Sips/PSO | • Effective removal of carcinogenic, mutagenic, and toxic anionic azo dyes from contaminated water | |
| • No specific toxicity assessment of the CMC composite material itself was conducted | ||||||
| SC-PLA/PDA/MXene membrane154 | MB | 434.8 | C 0 = 0.5–2 g L−1 | Langmuir/PSO | • Good cycling stability demonstrated over 10 consecutive separation cycles for oil/water separation | • Biodegradable PLA-based composite material providing eco-friendly alternative to conventional polymer membranes |
| • Water flux remained stable at 1429.0 L (m2 h)−1 even after 10 cycles for E-N/W separation | • Eliminates potential secondary pollution from plastic debris entering water systems | |||||
| • Oil flux maintained at ∼1862.0 L (m2 h)−1 for the first 4 cycles in E-W/N separation, then declined to 1563.3 L (m2 h)−1 (84.6% retention) after 10 cycles | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the composite material conducted | |||||
| • Alcohol regeneration treatment used between cycles with good recovery performance | • Effective removal of toxic organic pollutants (MB) from contaminated water | |||||
| • Excellent reusability for simultaneous oil and MB removal with water flux maintaining high levels after 6 reuse cycles | • Biocompatible polylactide substrate reduces environmental impact compared to non-degradable polymer membranes | |||||
| • Minor performance decline attributed to porosity blocking by residual oil during separation process | • Polydopamine and MXene components generally considered biocompatible based on the literature | |||||
| Fe2O3/BC/MXene155 | MB | 899.03 | C 0 = 15–45 mg L−1, 293–313 K, pH = 1–11 | Langmuir/PSO | • Pb2+ sorption capacity: 99.91% → 90.99% after 5 cycles; MB: 98.63% → 89.47% | • Biochar-based composite provides sustainable wastewater treatment |
| • Desorption efficiency: Pb2+: 96.8% → 78.32%; MB: 95.08% → 77.40% after 5 cycles | • Effectively removes highly toxic lead and MB from water | |||||
| • Easy separation using external magnetic field | • Composite material itself not assessed for environmental/health impacts | |||||
| • Generally considered safe based on the literature | ||||||
| TiVCTx/GAs156 | MB | 319.67 | 298–338 K, pH = 1–13 | Langmuir/PSO | • Excellent cycling stability demonstrated over 5 successive adsorption–desorption cycles | • Leaching experiments confirmed that TiVCTx/GAs adsorbent did not produce secondary pollution during the adsorption process |
| TiVCTx/GAs156 | RhB | 303.45 | 298 K–338 K, pH = 1–13 | Langmuir/PSO | • MB removal rate remained at around 95.8% after five cycles | • Effectively removes highly toxic organic contaminants including dyes and antibiotic drugs from wastewater |
| TiVCTx/GAs156 | CR | 229.97 | 298 K–338 K, pH = 1–13 | Langmuir/PSO | • High absorption capacity maintained even after five cycles of absorption–squeezing for oil/solvent removal | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the composite material itself conducted |
| TiVCTx/GAs156 | MO | 217.87 | 298 K–338 K, pH = 1–13 | Langmuir/PSO | • Easy regeneration through simple mechanical squeezing due to excellent elasticity of TiVCTx/GAs | • Biocompatible components generally considered safe for environmental applications |
| MCF hybrid aerogel157 | MB | 356.97 | C 0 = 3–100 mg L−1, 303 K–333 K, pH = 11 | Langmuir/PSO | • Limited regeneration assessment mentioned in the study | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the MCF composite material conducted |
| MCF hybrid aerogel157 | CR | 647.75 | C 0 = 3–200 mg L−1, 303–333 K, pH = 6 | Langmuir/PSO | • No comprehensive cycling stability evaluation provided | • Focuses on removing highly toxic contaminants: MB causes DNA structure damage, cancer risk, heart rate acceleration, shock, and tissue necrosis |
| • Brief mention that physical adsorption is beneficial for reversible processes and adsorbent regeneration after desorption | • CR degradation produces benzidine, a recognized human carcinogen | |||||
| • Statistical physics modeling suggests physical interaction enables regeneration potential | • MCF designed as environmentally-friendly technology for hazardous dye elimination | |||||
| • No secondary pollution production during adsorption process confirmed through leaching experiments | ||||||
| Ni3(HITP)2/MXene/CS158 | MB | 424.99 | 10–400 mg L−1, 298 K, pH = 2–9 | Langmuir/PSO | • Five consecutive adsorption–desorption cycles conducted for reusability evaluation | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the composite material conducted |
| • Composite maintained excellent adsorption rate after five cycles for both Pb(II) and MB | • Composite uses biocompatible chitosan biopolymer as the base material | |||||
| • Chemical adsorption nature may pose challenges for complete regeneration | • No secondary pollution or leaching studies reported | |||||
| • Detailed regeneration protocols not clearly presented in the main text | ||||||
| MXene with biomass activated carbon (CMAC)159 | CR | 1264.032 | C 0 = 0–400 mg L−1, 25–75 °C, pH = 6, dose = 10 mg per 100 mL | Langmuir/PSO | • Desorption and recyclability studies conducted using ethanol as the desorbing agent | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the CMAC composite material conducted |
| • CMAC mixed with 100 mL ethanol and stirred at 25 °C for 24 h | • Focus on removing highly toxic anionic azo dyes that are carcinogenic and mutagenic | |||||
| • Good adsorption effect maintained for all three dyes after multiple desorption cycles | • CMAC composite uses biomass activated carbon as environmentally friendly base material | |||||
| • No significant loss of performance after several cycles | • No secondary pollution or environmental impact studies reported | |||||
| • Economic benefit and high stability demonstrated for wastewater treatment applications | ||||||
| Macroporous cellulose nanocrystals (CNC)/MXene/PVA (C-CMP)160 | MB | 239.92 | pH = 6, 338 K, 250 mg L−1 | Langmuir/PSO | • Adsorption–desorption experiment conducted for three cycles using 0.1 mol L−1 HCl for desorption | • No comprehensive toxicity assessment of the C-CMP composite material conducted |
| • MB removal efficiency maintained above 80% after three cycles | • Focus on removing highly toxic MB, which severely affects water transparency and dissolved oxygen | |||||
| • Good recyclability of C-CMP composite foam confirmed | • MB is difficult to degrade due to benzene ring structure and accumulates in drainage systems | |||||
| • Slightly decreased efficiency attributed to strong interaction between MB and C-CMP | • Even 1 mg L−1 concentration severely impacts water quality | |||||
| • Residual dye from previous cycles may affect subsequent performance | • Composite uses biocompatible materials: cellulose nanocrystals and polyvinyl alcohol | |||||
| • No environmental impact or secondary pollution studies reported | ||||||
| Co: concentration of dye | ||||||
O) create reactive sites for various chemical modifications, allowing the addition of specific functional groups that can greatly enhance their selectivity, capacity, and stability for dye removal. These methods aim to modify the surface features of MXenes without significantly altering their layered structure, thus maintaining their unique 2D properties while adding new functionalities. Surface functionalization techniques include chemical modifications through covalent bonding of organic groups, alkali treatments to change surface terminations, organic coupling reactions to attach complex molecular structures, and surfactant modifications to adjust surface charge and hydrophilicity. Each approach provides distinct benefits, such as boosting electrostatic interactions, hydrogen bonding, π–π interactions, and other molecular interactions that affect dye adsorption. Successful surface functionalization not only improves adsorption performance but also enables the creation of pH-responsive materials, selective adsorbents for specific dyes, and systems with better regeneration ability, making them highly useful for practical water treatment.
Li and co-authors effectively synthesized Nb2CTx MXene with a particular surface area by etching Nb2AlC with hydrofluoric acid (Fig. 5a). The Nb2CTx MXene produced is highly effective at adsorbing methylene blue (MB) and methyl orange (MO) dyes, achieving maximum capacities exceeding 500 mg g−1. For starting concentrations of 100 and 200 mg g−1, ∼99% MO dye may be removed in ∼30 min (Fig. 5d and e). However, MB dye removal requires just 5 min of contact time. Furthermore, the adsorption process of Nb2CTx MXene is governed by a pseudo-second-order kinetics model (Fig. 5b and c), with chemisorption at the surface absorption active sites serving as the rate limiting factor.131
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 (a) Schematic diagram of Nb2CTx MXene preparation by etching Nb2AlC with HF solution. (b) and (c) Pseudo-second-order kinetics analysis for MO and MB adsorption by Nb2CTx at room temperature. (d) and (e) Relationship between the adsorption capacity of Nb2CTx and contact time at different initial MO and MB concentrations at room temperature, pH = 7, and 1 g L−1 Nb2CTx powder dose. Reproduced with permission from ref. 131 Copyright 2021, American Chemical Society. | ||
The elimination of MB and Congo red (CR) dyes from wastewater was accomplished by Li et al. by the fabrication of the AA-alk-MXene-based adsorbent. This was accomplished by attaching acrylic acid (AA) to alkalized single or several layered MXene nanosheets. The influence of pH, temperature, concentration of dye, contact time and AA dosage on adsorption was examined. The process of adsorption used the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir isotherm adsorption model. The highest adsorption capacity of an AA-modified sample (2 mL) for MB and CR was found to be 193.92 mg g−1 and 264.46 mg g−1, respectively. Furthermore, hydrogen bonding, electrostatic attraction, and interlayer forces are likely the primary driving forces behind the adsorption mechanism of AA-alk-MXene (Fig. 6a and b).132
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 (a) Schematic diagram for preparing AA-alk-MXene; (b) diagram of the adsorption mechanism of AA-alk-MXene for MB and CR. Reproduced with permission from ref. 132. Copyright 2022, Elsevier. | ||
By modifying Ti3C2 to incorporate sulfonic groups through aromatic coupling–diazotization, Wei et al. achieved the fabrication of 2D MXenes. This was accomplished by removing the Al layer from Ti3AlC2 through a simple process. A further investigation into the adsorption behavior of functionalized Ti3C2 against MB was conducted under various experimental conditions, including pH, solution temperature, initial MB concentration, and contact time. The results demonstrated that Ti3C2–SO3H achieved an adsorption performance of 111.11 mg g−1. Kinetic and isotherm analyses revealed that the pseudo-first-order and Langmuir isotherm adsorption models were appropriate for explaining the experimental data. The deposition of MB onto adsorbent surfaces was endothermic, while dye adsorption was most effective when the aqueous solution was alkaline (Fig. 7).133
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 (a) Schematic diagram for the preparation of Ti3C2–SO3H for MB removal. (b) The kinetic curves of Ti3C2–SO3H adsorption MB. (c) Effect of pH on the adsorption of MB onto Ti3C2–SO3H. Reproduced with permission from ref. 133. Copyright 2019, Elsevier. | ||
Kelishami et al. designed a cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB)-modified multi-layered Ti3C2Tx MXene (CMM) from Ti3AlC2 precursor and was employed to remove MO (Fig. 8a and b). This material adsorbent resulted from an electrostatic combination of the cationic surfactant solution (CTAB) and negatively charged Ti3C2Tx nanosheets. The accessible active sites were exposed as a result of this, which resulted in an increase in the spacing between the nanosheets and an increase in adsorption efficiency. The adsorbents were analyzed by using a few analytical techniques, and the impact of various parameters (contact time, pH, loading adsorbent, and initial concentration of dye) was investigated. The results of this study demonstrated that MO adsorbed CMM to its maximum capacity at an adsorbent dosage of 0.83 g L−1, a contact time of 90 min, and a solution pH of 3. The results of the adsorption experiment were most accurately represented by the pseudo-second-order kinetic model (R2 = 0.9924) and the Langmuir isotherm (R2 = 0.9990). Approximately 213.00 mg g−1 was the maximum adsorption capacity that MO possessed. There is a possibility that the MO adsorption mechanism on CMM involves many interactions, including electrostatic adsorption, π–cation interactions, and hydrogen bonding.136
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 (a) Illustration of the intercalation of CTAB in MXene (CMM) for the adsorption of MO; (b) CTAB monolayer and bilayer formation on MXene (Ti3C2Tx) sheets and adsorption mechanisms of MO by MXene sheets. Reproduced with permission from ref. 136. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. | ||
Gogotsi et al. tested Ti3C2Tx stacked sheets bound by hydrogen bonds and/or van der Waals interactions for the adsorption of MB dye. Ti3C2Tx showed an adsorption capacity of 39 mg g−1 for MB. The adsorption of MB on Ti3C2Tx was most closely related to the Freundlich isotherm model.128
Through the use of an alkali solution, ZhengMing et al. described a straightforward method for increasing the interlayer gap of Ti3C2Tx while modulating the surface functional groups of the material (Fig. 9a).129 Using LiOH, the approach is able to enhance the spacing between layers in Ti3C2Tx MXene by 29%. Additionally, the modification of functional groups involves the transformation of –F into –OH. NaOH–Ti3C2Tx and LiOH–Ti3C2Tx MXenes are able to adsorb MB more quickly compared to other types of MXene adsorbents. Notably, NaOH–Ti3C2Tx has the ability to adsorb maximum MB, with a capacity of 189 mg g−1; this is attributed to the combination of intercalation adsorption and surface adsorption of the MXene (Fig. 9b). High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) images (Fig. 9c–e) reveal significant structural modifications following alkaline metal ion intercalation in LiOH–Ti3C2Tx, NaOH–Ti3C2Tx, and KOH–Ti3C2Tx systems. The intercalation process involves alkaline metal ions (Li+, Na+, K+) inserting between MXene layers, causing interlayer spacing expansion through electrostatic interactions and hydration shell formation. Structural expansion mechanisms include: direct ion insertion where alkaline cations occupy interlayer galleries, creating physical separation between Ti3C2Tx sheets; hydration-induced swelling as intercalated ions attract water molecules, forming hydration shells that further increase interlayer distance; and surface functionalization changes where alkaline treatment converts surface –F terminations into –OH groups, enhancing hydrophilicity and water take up. The measured interlayer spacings show progressive expansion: LiOH–Ti3C2Tx (∼1.22–1.65 nm), NaOH–Ti3C2Tx (∼1.16–2.0 nm), and KOH–Ti3C2Tx (∼1.40–1.73 nm), correlating with ionic radius differences (Li+ < Na+ < K+) and hydration characteristics. This structural expansion directly contributes to enhanced adsorption capacity by increasing the accessible surface area and creating larger pore channels for dye molecule accommodation, explaining the superior MB adsorption performance observed in alkaline-modified MXene systems.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 (a) Illustration of the fabrication of different alkali-Ti3C2Tx towards the adsorption of MB dye. (b) Adsorption isotherms of MB on Ti3C2Tx, LiOH–Ti3C2Tx, NaOH–Ti3C2Tx and KOH–Ti3C2Tx. HRTEM images of (c) LiOH–Ti3C2Tx, (d) NaOH–Ti3C2Tx and (e) KOH–Ti3C2Tx. Reproduced with permission from ref. 129. Copyright 2017, Elsevier. | ||
Yu and co-workers developed a novel hydrothermal method utilizing less toxic etching agents such as NaBF4, HCl for the synthesis of Ti3C2 MXene (h-Ti3C2). Because of the slow-release mechanism during hydrothermal treatment, h-Ti3C2 has a higher lattice parameter c, and a longer interlayer distance, as well as a better SSA than t-Ti3C2. The hydrothermal etching method avoids high-concentration HF and is more effective at synthesizing Ti3C2 flakes. Furthermore, the etching method can be used for other MXene compositions, for example, Nb2C and h-MXenes show superior adsorption performances for MB, with a capacity of 24 mg g−1.130 Cagnetta and colleagues synthesized Ti3C2Tx MXene layers pillared with terephthalate using an innovative MC etching approach that involved exfoliating a titanium MAX phase with a small volume of concentrated hydrofluoric acid using a high-energy ball mill. The obtained material has a larger SSA and strong adsorption capability of MB of 209 mg g−1 because of wider interlayer spaces between free carboxylate groups of terephthalate and MXene sheets. Also, dye adsorption with the material is best explained by a pseudo-second-order model.141
Yang et al. produced a suspension of Ti3C2Tx MXene nanosheets using the intercalation and delamination of multi-layered Ti3C2Tx utilizing TMAOH. The prepared material showed excellent adsorption of cationic MB dye. The highest adsorption capacity, noted at 318 K, reached 1026 mg g−1. This performance best fits with pseudo-second-order kinetic and Freundlich isotherm models. The mechanism of adsorption is mainly attributed to ion exchange and electrostatic attraction for MB removal.142 By intercalating GO into an Alk-MXene layer, Li and co-workers were able to report a novel AMXGO absorbent. This absorbent demonstrated a high level of efficiency in the elimination of MG and anionic CR (Fig. 10). The results of FTIR, XRD, and SEM investigations showed that the AMXGO absorbent possessed a characteristic 3D layer-by-layer structure with plentiful oxygen-bearing groups, and that its heat stability had greatly improved. Based on the results of the BET analysis, it was determined that the AMXGO1 adsorbent possessed a larger SSA (16.686 m2 g−1) and pore volume (0.04733 cm3 g−1). It was found that the adsorption performance was dependent on the mass ratio of Alk-MXene to GO, the starting dye concentration, pH, contact time, and temperature. The AMXGO1 absorbent, which had a mass ratio of 3
:
1, had a maximum capacity to adsorb 1111.6 mg g−1 of MG and 1133.7 mg g−1 of CR, and it had dye removal rates that were greater than 92%. Both pseudo-second-order kinetic and Freundlich isotherm models are utilized to describe the adsorption behaviour of AMXGO1 for both CR and MG.147
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Diagram for the preparation of AMXGO. Reproduced with permission from ref. 147. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. | ||
Peng et al. effectively synthesized MXene-based core–shell composites, MXene–COOH@(PEI/PAA)n, using a layer-by-layer technique. Furthermore, these nanocomposites were studied using spectral and morphological techniques, revealing that they contained more reactive sites and mesoporous structures. The composites fabricated were able to efficiently adsorb MB dye after approximately 200 min, showing that the composites synthesized might be used as a highly efficient adsorbent. The observed data are well matched with a pseudo-second-order model and show a significant correlation coefficient of R2 > 0.99, indicating that the core–shell composites have outstanding adsorption capabilities.134
PHGC/MXene, which was reported by Zhang et al. (Fig. 11a and b), exhibited a remarkably strong selectivity and cycling stability for ionic dyes across a range of pH values. PHGC/MXene showed exceptional adsorption selectivity and great pH-responsiveness in the mixed dye system. It was able to adsorb MB at a pH of 11.0, and methyl blue (AB93) at pH 2.0, achieving maximum adsorption capacities of 555.56 mg g−1 and 207.47 mg g−1, respectively. The adsorption kinetics for these dyes were found to be in agreement with the two-level kinetic model that was proposed, while the Langmuir model demonstrated a good fit for the adsorption isotherms being studied. It was determined that electrostatic adsorption and hydrogen bonding were the primary processes responsible for the adsorption process, with van der Waals forces also making a contribution. Despite undergoing 12 rounds of desorption and regeneration, the clearance rates for MB and AB93 remained more than 90%.135
![]() | ||
| Fig. 11 (a) Schematic preparation of PHGC/MXene hydrogel; (b) adsorption mechanism diagram of PHGC/MXene for AB93 or MB. Reproduced with permission from ref. 135. Copyright 2019, Elsevier. | ||
The amino-functionalized bacterial cellulose/Ti3C2Tx MXene (ABC/MX) composites were synthesized by Wen and his colleagues by the utilization of an electrostatic self-assembly technique that comprised modifications with polydopamine (PDA) and polyethyleneimine (PEI) (Fig. 12a). Based on the findings of this research, the effective insertion of amino groups strengthens the interfacial contacts between nanofibers of BC and nanosheets of Ti3C2Tx; it also enhances the number of active sites for adsorption. With a maximal ability to adsorb 1103.7 mg g−1 of CR, the results demonstrate that the composite possesses a remarkable removal efficiency.137 Using a chemical etching approach, Wang et al. reported a few-layer MXene. Subsequently, PEI was grafted onto the surface of the MXene through glutaraldehyde-assisted crosslinking (Fig. 12b). The adsorption properties of water-soluble dyes were extensively studied. The results indicated that grafting with PEI might improve MXene exfoliation and adsorption capacities. The modified MXene showed a remarkable ability to adsorb 909.1 mg g−1 of MO. Fig. 12c reveals the binding mechanism between the components of the MPEI composites. The pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir isothermal adsorption models are the most appropriate for the adsorption processes of MO, which are spontaneously endothermic and chemisorption.138
![]() | ||
| Fig. 12 (a) Schematic diagram of the preparation of ABC/MX composite. Reproduced with permission from ref. 137. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (b) Synthesis procedure for the MPEI composites and (c) diagram of the inter-component microscopic combination mechanism in MPEI composites. Reproduced with permission from ref. 138. Copyright 2023, Royal Society of Chemistry. (d) Adsorption capacity of different dyes onto alk-MXene/CoFe2O4/CS composite. Reproduced with permission from ref. 144. Copyright 2023, Elsevier. | ||
Wang and co-authors synthesized a novel CoFe2O4/CS composite supported on alk-MXene magnetic adsorbent via a hydrothermal and self-assembly approach (Fig. 12d). Adding CoFe2O4/CS to alk-MXene can significantly increase the capacity for adsorbing anionic and cationic dyes. The prepared material showed a high adsorption capacity of up to 1333.9, 537.6, and 2095.9 mg g−1 for rhodamine B (RhB), malachite green (MG), and CR dyes, respectively. The higher adsorption performance of the composites is attributed to the synergistic effect of hydrogen bonding, π–π interactions, and electrostatic interactions.144
Zhang et al. used an in situ growth technique to synthesize a new 2D MXene coated with Fe3O4. The prepared material was analyzed for MB dye adsorption at different temperatures. This material exhibits superparamagnetic characteristics and a typical 2D lamellar structure. The elimination of MB occurred as an endothermic process, as evidenced by a maximum elimination capacity of 11.68 mg g−1 and 91.93% decolorization efficiency at 55 °C, considerably surpassing the performance at lower temperatures. Additionally, at high temperatures (40 and 55 °C), the adsorption isotherm demonstrated that the model which best fit for the removal method of MB was the Freundlich isotherm, but at low temperatures (25 °C), the Langmuir isotherm fit best. Through electrostatic attraction and hydrogen bonding at high temperatures, Ti–OH groups on the material's surface enhance MB decolorization. At 25 °C, surface adsorption by electrostatic interaction aids in the elimination of MB (Fig. 13).145
![]() | ||
| Fig. 13 (a) SEM, (b) TEM, (c) HRTEM, (d) SAED pattern of 2D-MX@Fe3O4 nanocomposites. (e) The removal capacity of MB over 2D-MX@Fe3O4 at 25, 40 and 55 °C. (f) Adsorption isotherms of 2D-MX@Fe3O4 for MB removal. Reproduced with permission from ref. 145. Copyright 2019, Elsevier. | ||
Eltaweil et al. fabricated Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel composites in order to remove organic CR dye synthesized via a cross-linking reaction by incorporating Ti3C2Tx MXene and NiFeMn-LDH into gelatin (Fig. 14a). The results showed that the adsorption ability of Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel towards CR was significantly enhanced by raising the Ti3C2Tx content in the matrix to 10%. With a qmax value of 588.24 mg g−1, the Freundlich model offered the best explanation for the adsorption of CR. Moreover, the pseudo-second-order model was determined to be best for studying the adsorption kinetics of CR. The remarkable recyclability over multiple cycles confirms the composite's sustainability.146
![]() | ||
| Fig. 14 (a) A schematic presentation of the synthesis of Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel composite. Reproduced with permission from ref. 146. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (b) Schematic illustration of the separation mechanism of MXene/COF in the dye wastewater purification process. Reproduced with permission from ref. 148. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (c) Schematic preparation process for the alk-MXene/ZIF composite. Reproduced with permission from ref. 149. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (d) Schematic illustration of the step-wise synthesis of DSP-M composite. Reproduced with permission from ref. 150. Copyright 2023, Elsevier. | ||
Using a macroporous polymeric support, Yang et al. were able to effectively fabricated a flexible, rigid, and porous MXene/COF hybrid flake. This flake is characterized by the presence of three 2D COF flakes that are bridged covalently on the surface of the MXene by an in situ growth process. COFs (TpTAPB, TpBD, TpPa) were synthesized via Schiff-base reactions using 1,3,5-triformylphloroglucinol with 1,3,5-tris(4-aminophenyl) benzene, benzidine and p-phenylenediamine monomers (Fig. 14b). Furthermore, interlayers of MXene (Ti3C2Tx) nanosheets expand adjacent interlayer spacing and introduce numerous sieving pores when COFs are intercalated into it. The optimized MXene/TpTAPB hybrid membrane, when utilized for eliminating organic dyes, exhibits a removal efficiency of 96.4% for AB93, 98.2% for CR, 97.2% for MO and 98.7% for chrome black T.148
Wang et al. synthesized the alk-MXene/ZIF composite, with small ZIF particles in situ synthesized on interlayer and on the alk-MXene surface (Fig. 14c). In the meantime, a stable intercalation framework is produced, allowing dye molecules to transfer mass more quickly. Adding ZIF particles increases the adsorption functional groups and SSA in the alk-MXene/ZIF composite. The composites achieved excellent adsorption values, with maximum capacities of 7111.3 and 539.7 mg g−1 for MG and CR, respectively. The impact of coexisting ions, temperature, concentration, contact time, and pH on the adsorption performance were studied. Adsorption kinetics studies demonstrated that dye adsorption onto the composite surface was consistent with the Elovich and pseudo-second-order kinetic models. Additionally, the adsorption mechanism of the adsorbent is mainly due to chemisorption.149
By integrating few-layer MXene and the hydrophilic biomaterial DASNP, followed by immobilization of DASNP onto few-layer MXene through a dialdehyde-based cross-linking technique, Li et al. were able to synthesize a novel environmentally friendly composite material known as DSP-M (Fig. 14d). The findings indicated that DSP-M had an outstanding adsorption efficiency for both adsorbates. Furthermore, the Langmuir maximum adsorption capacity for monomer adsorption for RhB was found to be 678.19 mg L−1, while the capacity for CR was found to be 754.41 mg L−1. These results were in agreement with the pseudo-second-order, intraparticle diffusion, and Langmuir models. For the purpose of conducting additional research on the adsorptive mechanism, the physics statistical model was utilized. The DSP-M characteristics post-adsorption and findings of the simulation suggested that RhB and CR removal by DSP-M occurred predominantly through a physical adsorption mechanism involving van der Waals interactions, electrostatic forces, and hydrogen bonding.150
Wang and co-authors designed ZnS/CuFe2O4/MXene (ZSCFOM) composites featuring ternary heterostructures via a solvothermal approach to efficiently adsorb azo dyes. The composite primarily achieved azo dye adsorption via electrostatic interactions and hydrogen bonding, with a maximum adsorption capacity of 377 mg g−1 for DBM and 390 mg g−1 for DBRN. The pseudo-second-order and Langmuir models were used to characterize the adsorption properties of ZSCFOM, suggesting that the adsorbate formed a monolayer on the ZSCFOM surface.151
Moreover, green methods have also been adopted to design MXene-based nanoadsorbents. Ijaz et al. synthesized an efficient and rapid Fe2O3/BC/MXene composite by functionalizing Shorea faguetiana biochar with Fe2O3 and MXene for selective adsorption. XPS and FTIR revealed that the Fe2O3/BC/MXene composites had more surface functional groups (F−, C
O, CN, NH, and OH−) than the original biochar. Characterization studies revealed that the intended modified BC had a high MB adsorption capacity in wastewater. At 293 K, MB showed a qm value of 899.03 mg g−1. The adsorption followed a pseudo-second-order model (R2 = 1) and the Langmuir isotherm. Surface electrostatic forces and hydrogen bonding helped to remove MB more efficiently. This demonstrates monolayer adsorption on the Fe2O3/BC/MXene composite, which is regulated by chemical adsorption.155
An effective, fast, and selective adsorption of MB was achieved by Imtiaz et al. through the development of Ni3(HITP)2/MXene/CS. This was accomplished by functionalizing chitosan biopolymer with MXene and 2D MOFs (Ni3(HITP)2). The TEM image clearly shows irregularly-shaped MOFs and spherical CS particles adhered to the MXene surface. At 298 K, MB had a maximum adsorption capability of 424.99 mg g−1, 400.59 mg g−1 at 308 K, and 305.80 mg g−1 at 318 K. The adsorption of MB on the Ni3(HITP)2/MXene/CS composite followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir models. The composite has –OH, –F, –O, and N groups, which enable effective MB absorption via hydrogen bonding, electrostatic attraction, and complexation interaction.158
Dhar Purkayastha and co-author used vacuum filtering to produce 2D Ti3C2Tx MXene on a porous PAN membrane, demonstrating its effective adsorption of MB. MX-PAN had an adsorption effectiveness of 85%, compared to 12% achieved by the PAN membrane. Adsorption efficiency increased dramatically after manufacturing the PAN membrane along with Ti3C2Tx MXene nanoflakes.139 Zhang et al. combined SA with d-Ti3C2Tx nanosheets (MXene), then employed electrospinning and subsequent Ca2+-mediated crosslinking for the production of various SA/MXene NMs. The impact of MXene in NMs on the MB adsorption ability was examined. SA/MXene NMs exhibited the ability to adsorb 440 mg g−1 of MB at an optimal MXene concentration of 0.74 wt%, surpassing electrospun SA NMs, pristine MXene, or SA/MXene composite beads with an equivalent MXene content. Moreover, the optimal SA/MXene NMs demonstrated high reusability. The Langmuir and pseudo-second-order models were in good agreement with the results, indicating that monolayer adsorption aligned with the mechanism of chemical adsorption.140
By using cross-linking approaches to incorporate PEI and amino-functionalized Ti3C2Tx into the SA aerogel matrix, Wang et al. synthesized the MXene/PEI-modified SA aerogel. The plentiful active PEI groups, together with the reduction capabilities of MXene, considerably enhance the adsorption capacity of 3568 mg g−1 for CR; this is attributed to robust electrostatic attraction along with the synergistic effects of intercalation and surface adsorption. The results showed that the adsorption process for CR aligned well with the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir isotherm models. The mechanical strength of the aerogel was greatly enhanced by the double-network structure composed of polymeric PEI and SA, allowing for easy recycling without secondary contamination, with only a slight reduction in capacity following five cycles.143
The innovative nanocomposite hydrogel of ZIF-8@IL-MXene/poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (NIPAM), which was fabricated by Xiong and his co-authors, was capable of successfully adsorbing crystal violet (CV) from wastewater (Fig. 15a). The formation of the composite hydrogel IL-MXene/PNIPAM was accomplished through in situ polymerization by grafting IL onto the MXene surface and subsequently introducing solutions of NIPAM monomer. This process was completed in a single step. Utilizing the in situ formation of ZIF-8 on pore walls of composite hydrogels, ZIF-8@IL-MXene/PNIPAM was produced. The prepared nanocomposite hydrogel displayed a maximum adsorption capacity for CV of 325.03 mg g−1 at ambient temperature, with a reduction to 91% following five cycles of adsorption–desorption. The results are in accordance with Freundlich and pseudo-second-order kinetics models, based on several interactions between molecules of adsorbent and hydrogel.152
![]() | ||
| Fig. 15 (a) Schematic illustration of ZIF-8 grown in situ in composite hydrogels. Reproduced with permission from ref. 152. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (b) Scheme of the preparation process for the CMC composite. (c)–(e) Effect of adsorbent dosage on the removal efficiency and adsorption capacity (qe) of AO7, MO, and CR. (f) Effect of pH on the adsorption and zeta potentials of the CMC composite at different pH values. Reproduced with permission from ref. 153. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (g) Fabrication procedures for composite fibers. Reproduced with permission from ref. 154. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (h) Preparation process for TiVCTx/Gas. Reproduced with permission from ref. 156. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. | ||
By self-assembling CNTs, CTAB and MXene nanosheets, Ding et al. were able to synthesize a unique CMC three-dimensional composite. In order to determine whether or not the material produced could adsorb AO7, CR, and MO, the material was tested. In comparison with CNTs and MXene, the CMC composite had a greater capacity for the adsorption of AO7, CR, and MO with maximum adsorption capacities of 367.9, 628.5, and 294.2 mg g−1, respectively. As the temperature increased, the adsorption capabilities of the CMC composite for AO7 and MO reduced, whereas the adsorption capabilities for CR increased. When it comes to the process of adsorption, the hydrogen bonding, π–π electron–donor–acceptor, and electrostatic interactions were all crucial contributors. The energy distribution of site analysis revealed that the CMC composite possessed more adsorption active sites than MXenes and CNTs. As a result, CMC composites possessed better adsorption capabilities for the anionic dyes that were being studied. It is possible that the changes in adsorption patterns for the anionic dyes can be attributed to the availability of adsorption sites as well as changes to the heterogeneity of the sites on the CMC surface. Based on the findings from the approximate site energy distribution analysis, it was found that the CMC composite had a greater number of adsorption active sites compared to MXene and CNTs. This indicates that the CMC composite possesses a superior adsorption capability for specific anionic dyes. The amount of accessible adsorption sites and the change in site heterogeneity on the CMC surface are two factors that can be attributed to the differences in adsorption behaviors that occur between three anionic dyes from different compounds (Fig. 15b–f).153
Wang and co-authors developed an innovative approach for modifying the electrospun polylactic acid fibrous membrane, improving its adaptability for the treatment of wastewater under challenging conditions. PLA fibre membranes were initially coated with PDA, followed by the deposition of MXene facilitated by PDA (Fig. 15g). The as-prepared SC-PLA/PDA/MXene membranes proved effective at MB adsorption, with a maximum adsorption capacity of 434.8 mg g−1. MB adsorption by the membrane aligns closely with the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir models. The above circumstance also indicates that chemisorption predominates in the MB elimination process. In essence, the membrane and MB molecules exhibit π–π interactions and electrostatic attraction.154
Xing et al. fabricated TiVCTx MXene/graphene nanosheet-based aerogels, named TiVCTx/GAs, via a simple self-assembly hydrothermal process, followed by freeze-drying (Fig. 15h). Combining bimetallic MXene and graphene aerogel in TiVCTx/GAs provides a remarkable broad-spectrum dye removal capability from wastewater. TiVCTx/GAs effectively adsorb different dyes, with capacities of 319.67, 229.97, 303.45, and 217.87 mg g−1 for MB, CR, RB, and MO, respectively. Kinetics and thermodynamics studies confirm that the process of adsorption follows the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir adsorption models.156
MXene/carbon foam (MCF) hybrid aerogel was synthesized by Li and co-authors using Ti3C2Tx-MXene and MF. Both cationic and anionic dyes were used to investigate the removal properties of MCF. Several different methods of characterization were utilized in order to examine the physicochemical properties of MCF. Additionally, statistical physics models were utilized in order to gain a deeper comprehension of the dye adsorption mechanism it possessed. MCF was shown to have outstanding adsorptive efficiency against the harmful dyes CR and MB, with adsorption capacities of 647.75 mg g−1 and 356.97 mg g−1, respectively. According to the findings, these capacities were better suited for the Langmuir and pseudo-second-order kinetic models. In addition, the saturated multilayer model was utilized in order to explore the molecular process underlying the adsorption systems of MCF-MB and MCF-CR components. Through a process that involved multi-anchoring (303 and 318 K), single connection (333 K), and mixed adsorption orientation, the findings of the numerical simulation demonstrate that MCF adsorbs the MB molecules in the form of dimers. In contrast, CR molecules were adsorbed as monomers through a process that included the mixed adsorption orientation (333 K), multi-anchored and pure non-parallel adsorption directions (303 K and 318 K), and adsorption directions that were not parallel to one another.157
Electrostatic self-assembly of 2D MXene nanosheets and biomass-activated carbon was used by Li et al. to reported a heterostructure adsorbent that they referred to as CMAC composite. This was accomplished in the presence of CTAB. This method prevented the re-stacking of MXene nanosheets, which resulted in a reduction in the multilayer plate structure of MXene and an increase in the layer spacing. This resulted in an increase in exposure of accessible active sites, which even more significantly improved the adsorption performance. As a consequence of the tests, it was shown that CMAC possessed an exceptional adsorption efficiency for CR, with adsorption capacities of 1264.032 mg g−1. The Langmuir, intraparticle diffusion and pseudo-second-order kinetic models suit the dye adsorption data well. The adsorption mechanism is attributed to the combination of hydrogen bonding, physical adsorption, and electrostatic interactions.159
Li et al. developed a straightforward and eco-friendly foaming technique in order to produce a macroporous cellulose nanocrystal (CNC)/MXene/polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) (C-CMP) foam that possessed exceptional adsorption capabilities. Glutaraldehyde was utilized as a crosslinker to enhance the adsorption effectiveness of MB dye. The adsorption experiment revealed that MB had a maximum adsorption capacity of 239.92 mg g−1. The adsorption performance corresponded well to the Langmuir isotherm and pseudo-second-order kinetic models. Thermodynamic studies showed that the process of adsorption was spontaneous and endothermic. The study demonstrated that the adsorption between MB and C-CMP was due to electrostatic interactions.160
![]() | ||
| Fig. 16 (a) Schematic illustration of the adsorption mechanism of TiVCTx/Gas. Reproduced with permission from ref. 156. Copyright 2024, American Chemical Society. (b) Molecular structure of MB. Reproduced with permission from ref. 139. Copyright 2023, Elsevier. (c) Schematic illustration of electrostatic interactions between Ti3C2Tx MXene nanosheet and MB dye molecules. Reproduced with permission from ref. 139. Copyright 2023, Elsevier. (d) Schematic diagram of the adsorption mechanism of the alk-MXene/ZIF adsorbent. Reproduced with permission from ref. 149. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (e) Adsorption mechanism of AMXGO adsorbents for MG and CR. Reproduced with permission from ref. 147. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. | ||
Furthermore, Purkayastha and co-authors produced MX-PAN membranes that might bind MB molecules to both F and OH/
O terminating groups of MXene. The molecular structure of MB dye is shown in Fig. 16b. The sulfur (S) or nitrogen (N) atoms in MB, carrying a positive charge, classify it as a cationic dye. After the aluminum atoms are removed from Ti3AlC2 (parent powder) via etching, various functional groups (–F and –OH/
O) attach simultaneously on the surface of Ti3C2Tx, resulting in a negative charge. These negative charges [Ti–F]−1 and [Ti–O]−1 can be cationic species sensors. As shown in Fig. 16c, MB molecules can interact with both F and OH/
O terminal groups. Therefore, a key mechanism for the adsorption of MB dye is electrostatic interaction between positively charged MB molecules and negatively charged Ti3C2Tx MXene.139
Wang et al. explained that the adsorption of MG and CR on alk-MXene/ZIF composite could be ascribed to the hydrogen bonding, π–π, and electrostatic interactions. Additionally, the proposed adsorption mechanism is schematically illustrated in Fig. 16d.149 To further understand the adsorption phenomenon, Li et al. explained the adsorption process of AMXGO for CR and MG, as shown in Fig. 16e. AMXGO dye adsorption involves various phenomena, including π–π conjugates, electrostatic forces, intercalation adsorption, as well as pore adsorption. Among the most significant impacts is the electrostatic force, which is generated by the negative hydroxyl and carboxyl groups present on GO lamellae and Alk-MXene surfaces, which mix with cationic molecules. π–π conjugates have a considerable effect on CR adsorption because their structure contains six benzene rings, which is more than the three rings in the structure of the MG molecule. This also describes why AMXGO has superior adsorption efficacy toward anionic CR. Furthermore, the layer-by-layer structure of Alk-MXene and GO flakes in AMXGO favors intercalation adsorption of either CR or MG molecules. Furthermore, the AMXGO samples include numerous mesopores, which ultimately promote pore adsorption of CR and MG.147
While the fundamental adsorption mechanisms have been identified, a comprehensive mechanistic framework reveals the relative contributions and synergistic interactions among different adsorption pathways in MXene-based systems.61 Electrostatic interactions represent the primary driving force for cationic dye adsorption, with mechanistic efficiency directly correlated to surface charge density and zeta potential values. Ti3C2Tx MXenes exhibit highly negative surface charges due to abundant –OH, –O, and –F terminations, creating strong electrostatic fields capable of attracting cationic species over significant distances.106 Quantitative analysis reveals that the electrostatic contribution accounts for the majority of the total adsorption energy for MB and rhodamine B, while representing a smaller fraction for anionic dyes like CR. pH-dependent studies demonstrate the optimal electrostatic interactions occur at near-neutral pH, where MXene surface deprotonation maximizes the negative charge density while maintaining structural stability. π–π stacking mechanisms show high selectivity toward aromatic dye molecules, with an interaction strength proportional to the aromatic ring number and electron density distribution. Computational studies using density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal significant binding energies for benzene ring interactions with Ti3C2Tx surfaces, with substantially higher energies for multi-ring systems like CR. Distance-dependent analysis shows that optimal π–π interactions occur at specific separations, with a parallel orientation providing maximum orbital overlap. MXene surface hybridization enhances π-electron delocalization, creating favorable interaction sites for aromatic dye molecules.161
Hydrogen bonding exhibits remarkable complexity in MXene–dye systems, involving multiple donor–acceptor combinations and cooperative strengthening effects. Surface –OH and –O groups serve as hydrogen bond acceptors, while dye amino groups (–NH2) and hydroxyl functionalities act as donors.162 Spectroscopic analysis (FTIR and NMR) reveals moderate hydrogen bond strengths for individual interactions, with significantly enhanced cumulative effects for dyes with multiple bonding sites. Temperature-dependent studies show that hydrogen bonding contributions decrease substantially at elevated temperatures, indicating entropy-driven weakening of directional interactions. Ion exchange processes demonstrate high specificity toward charge-to-size ratios and hydration energies of exchangeable species.163 Ti3C2Tx interlayer cations exhibit different exchange affinities for organic cations, with the following selectivity series: quaternary ammonium > primary ammonium > metal cations. Kinetic analysis reveals two-stage exchange processes: rapid surface exchange followed by slower interlayer diffusion. Stoichiometric studies confirm equivalent exchange ratios for monovalent dye cations, while multivalent species show complex exchange behaviors involving charge compensation mechanisms.
Physical adsorption through pore filling becomes dominant for microporous MXene derivatives and high molecular weight dyes. Pore size distribution analysis reveals optimal dye accommodation in mesopores, where molecular diffusion remains unrestricted while surface interactions are maximized. Molecular dynamics simulations demonstrate size-selective adsorption, with larger dye molecules showing reduced diffusion rates and surface-limited adsorption.64 Multiple mechanisms operate simultaneously in real adsorption systems, creating cooperative enhancement effects that exceed individual contributions. Electrostatic pre-concentration brings dye molecules into proximity with MXene surfaces, facilitating secondary interactions including π–π stacking and hydrogen bonding. Computational analysis reveals cooperative binding energies significantly higher than additive individual contributions, indicating synergistic stabilization. Sequential mechanism analysis shows that electrostatic interactions dominate initial adsorption, followed by π–π stacking at intermediate saturation and pore filling at high saturation. Solution pH dramatically influences the mechanism prevalence and adsorption efficiency through surface chemistry modifications and dye speciation changes.164
Acidic conditions enhance protonation of the MXene surface groups, reducing electrostatic attractions but increasing hydrogen bonding opportunities. Alkaline conditions maximize electrostatic interactions but may destabilize MXene structures through excessive deprotonation. Thermal analysis reveals differential temperature dependencies among adsorption mechanisms, with electrostatic interactions showing minimal temperature dependence, while hydrogen bonding decreases significantly at elevated temperatures. Multi-component systems reveal mechanism-dependent selectivity patterns, with different dyes competing for specific interaction sites, indicating moderate to intense competition depending on the degree of overlap between mechanisms. This comprehensive mechanistic framework offers quantitative insights into MXene–dye interactions, facilitating the rational design of high-performance adsorbents through targeted mechanism optimization and synergistic enhancement strategies.
For instance, the recyclability of Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel was demonstrated after recycling five times and it was observed that the removal ratio of Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel for CR adsorption remained at 71.72%, displaying the effective regeneration property for Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel, as shown in Fig. 17a.146 Likewise, the cycling stability of TiVCTx/GAs, as illustrated in Fig. 17b, highlights its remarkable performance in dye adsorption applications. Over five cycles of the absorption–squeezing process, the material consistently maintains a high absorption capacity, indicating its durability and effectiveness at removing contaminants from wastewater.156 The utilization of NaHCO3 solution as a desorption agent for PHGC/MXene/AB93 results in a negligible reduction in the adsorption capacity of PHGC/MXene for AB93, even following 12 cycles of adsorption and desorption. The elimination rate is around 94% (Fig. 17c), with variations not exceeding 1.5%. Upon utilizing hydrochloric acid solution as a desorption agent for PHGC/MXene/MB, the PHGC/MXene's adsorption capacity for MB decreases by a minimal amount after 12 cycles of adsorption and desorption, while the efficiency of removal remains consistently higher than 97% (Fig. 17d). The results suggest that the removal rate decreases by at least 3% throughout the course of twelve cycles in comparison with its highest value. This suggests that PHGC/MXene hydrogel excels in both alkaline and acidic environments, demonstrating its versatility. In the case of PHGC/MXene/AB93 and PHGC/MXene/MB, respectively, solutions of sodium bicarbonate and hydrochloric acid demonstrate effective desorption characteristics. As a result, PHGC/MXene hydrogel is a stable, efficient, and renewable adsorbent that may be utilized for the treatment of wastewater that contains AB93 or MB.135
![]() | ||
| Fig. 17 Reusability tests for (a) Ti3C2Tx/NiFeMn-LDH@Gel against Cr(VI) and CR. Reproduced with permission from ref. 146. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. (b) TiVCTx/Gas against CCl4. Reproduced with permission from ref. 156. Copyright 2024, American Chemical Society. Studies on the regeneration of (c) AB93 and (d) MB by PHGC/MXene. Reproduced with permission from ref. 135. Copyright 2024, Elsevier. | ||
| MXene | Positive insights | Negative insights |
|---|---|---|
Ti3C2Tx 128 |
• First report on MXene for dye removal & photocatalysis | • Poor stability in water; oxidises to TiO2 |
| • High MB adsorption via electrostatic interactions | • No toxicity or environmental safety data | |
| • Effective UV-driven dye degradation (MB & AB80) | • Moderate adsorption capacity (∼39 mg g−1) | |
| • Strong binding (irreversible adsorption) | • Complex mechanisms; needs further clarification | |
| • Good fit with Freundlich model (heterogeneous sites) | • No real wastewater or reuse tests | |
NaOH/LiOH/KOH–Ti3C2Tx 129 |
• Alkali treatment (NaOH, LiOH) increased interlayer spacing (up to 29%) | • No data on reusability or long-term performance |
| • Surface functionalisation (–F → –OH) improved adsorption capacity | • Lack of toxicity and safety assessment | |
| • NaOH–Ti3C2Tx showed highest MB adsorption capacity (189 mg g−1) | • Some variants (e.g. KOH–Ti3C2Tx) showed lower capacity due to agglomeration | |
| • Follows Langmuir model, indicating monolayer adsorption | • Intercalation effects not uniform; morphology-dependent performance | |
| • Faster dye removal rates compared to untreated MXene | ||
h-Ti3C2 130 |
• Developed a fluoride-free, HF-free hydrothermal synthesis route using NaBF4/HCl | • No reusability or recyclability tests conducted |
| • Resulting MXenes (h-Ti3C2, h-Nb2C) had higher surface areas and better exfoliation | • No quantification of maximum adsorption capacity (only removal % shown) | |
| • Improved adsorption performance for MB over HF-etched MXenes | • Performance tested only for MB; limited scope (e.g. no heavy metals, real water) | |
| • Larger interlayer spacing and higher BET surface area (44.6 vs. 8.9 m2 g−1) | • No mechanistic insight into selectivity or adsorption modelling (e.g. isotherms) | |
| • Broader applicability: method extended to Nb2C MXene synthesis | • Adsorption only moderate (∼24 mg g−1 for MB) compared to other MXenes | |
Nb2CTx 131 |
• High specific surface area (∼44.69 m2 g−1) and layered morphology support efficient adsorption | • No data on regeneration, recyclability, or real wastewater testing |
| • Very high adsorption capacities: MB = 526 mg g−1, MO = 500 mg g−1 | • Adsorption isotherms (Langmuir, Freundlich) did not fit well; mechanistic modelling limited | |
| • Follows pseudo-second-order kinetics, indicating chemisorption at active sites | • Slight surface oxidation observed; long-term MXene stability not assessed | |
| • Faster adsorption for MB (99% removal in 5–11 min) | ||
| • Excellent efficiency for both cationic and anionic dyes | ||
| PAA2 alk-MXene132 | • Adsorbent showed high adsorption capacities of 264.46 mg g−1 for CR and 193.92 mg g−1 for MB | • The study did not evaluate performance in real wastewater or multi-component dye systems |
| • Adsorption followed the Langmuir isotherm and pseudo-second-order kinetics | • Toxicity or leaching of components was not assessed | |
| • The material retained its adsorption efficiency after multiple cycles | • Only two dyes (MB and CR) were tested, limiting the generality of the findings | |
| • Surface functionalisation introduced beneficial –COOH and –OH groups and increased interlayer spacing | ||
| Ti3C2–SO3H133 | • Functionalisation with sulfonic groups increased adsorption capacity from 21.10 mg g−1 to 111.11 mg g−1 | • No regeneration or recyclability testing was conducted |
| • Adsorption followed Langmuir isotherm and pseudo-second-order kinetics | • The study only tested MB; no multicomponent or real wastewater systems | |
| • Adsorption capacity reached 723.35 mg g−1 with increased MB concentration | • Safety and environmental aspects were not addressed | |
| • Surface chemistry and interlayer spacing were enhanced through diazonium modification | • Adsorbent stability and scalability were not discussed | |
MXene-COOH@(PEI/PAA)n 134 |
• Adsorption followed pseudo-second-order kinetics and Langmuir isotherm (monolayer adsorption) | • Adsorption tested only in single dye systems, not in complex wastewater |
| • Good selectivity and performance across three dyes (MB, ST, NR) | • Decline in adsorption capacity upon recycling may limit long-term use | |
| • Composites are easily separable and structurally stable | • Synthesis and LbL process may be time-consuming on the industrial scale | |
| PHGC/MXene135 | • PHGC/MXene hydrogel exhibited pH-responsive selectivity, with adsorption capacities of 555.56 mg g−1 for MB and 207.47 mg g−1 for AB93 | • No real wastewater or multi-dye solution testing was conducted |
| • High reusability and performance across acidic and alkaline conditions | • Potential biodegradability or leaching behaviour of MXene was not assessed | |
| • The system demonstrated rapid adsorption and strong ionic dye interaction | • Toxicity and environmental compatibility remain unexplored | |
| Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-modified multi-layered Ti3C2Tx MXene (CMM)136 | • High adsorption capacity: up to 213.00 mg g−1 | • Surface area decreased after CTAB modification (from 5.02 to 2.06 m2 g−1) |
| • Effective in a broad pH range, especially at pH 3 | • No biological toxicity or environmental risk data provided | |
| • Adsorption follows Langmuir isotherm and pseudo-second-order kinetics | • Decreased adsorption efficiency after multiple reuse cycles | |
| • Mechanisms include electrostatic attraction, π–cation interaction, and hydrogen bonding | ||
| • Maintains functionality in the presence of common co-existing ions | ||
| ABC/MX composite137 | • Electrostatic attraction, reduction, chelation, hydrogen bonding | • Cr(VI) regeneration is limited due to MXene oxidation |
| • Excellent selectivity and ion interference resistance | • No cytotoxicity or leaching data; safety in biomedical or food applications not assured | |
| • Thermally enhanced adsorption (endothermic; capacity ↑ with temperature) | • Performance slightly affected by HPO42− due to competitive adsorption | |
| • Stable for real-world application: minimal impact from co-ions and long-term storage | • MXene's known susceptibility to oxidation may limit long-term use in oxidative environments | |
| • Complex DFT-supported adsorption models require experimental validation in multicomponent matrices | ||
| MXene-PEI138 | • Fast adsorption kinetics: equilibrium within 20–60 min | • No biological toxicity evaluation for MXene oxidation products or long-term exposure |
| • Mechanisms: electrostatic attraction, redox reaction (Cr(VI) → Cr(III)), π–π stacking, hydrogen bonding | • Oxidation of MXene over cycles not deeply discussed | |
| • Thermally and mechanically stable structure | • Desorption agents (ethanol, NaOH) could impact cost or scalability | |
| • Effective even in the presence of competing ions | • No real wastewater or multi-contaminant system testing | |
| • Easy handling and reusability due to aerogel form | ||
| MX-PAN membrane139 | • Fast kinetics: equilibrium achieved in 30–60 min | • No biological or environmental toxicity validation of MXene degradation products |
| • Mechanisms: electrostatic interactions, hydrogen bonding, π–π interactions, redox transformation | • Oxidation stability of MXene during long-term use not addressed | |
| • Excellent mechanical strength and porosity from aerogel architecture | • Real wastewater validation not included | |
| • Effective in the presence of co-existing ions (Cl−, SO42−, CO32−) | • Performance slightly decreased with coexisting PO43− ions | |
| • Scalable and sustainable fabrication method using wood waste and green chemistry | ||
| TMAOH delaminated Ti3C2Tx MXene nanosheets142 | • Exceptional adsorption capacity of 1026 mg g−1 at 318 K, among the highest reported for MXenes | • Performance decreases in the presence of multivalent cations (Ca2+, Al3+) due to competition and electrostatic shielding |
| • Fast adsorption kinetics, reaching equilibrium in 10 min | • Adsorption capacity decreases slightly after several reuse cycles due to partial loss and delamination damage | |
| • Mechanism confirmed: electrostatic interaction and ion exchange (TMA+ ↔ MB+) dominate | • No real wastewater or biological testing provided, performance in complex matrices remains unproven | |
| • Highly dispersible suspension prevents restacking, ensuring active surface availability | • Freeze-drying reduces performance, dry-state materials are less effective due to aggregation | |
| • High performance in MNM (membrane form): up to 96% removal efficiency with good dye flux (52 L m−2 h−1 at 0.6 mg cm−2 loading) | ||
| • Good tolerance to pH range (2–10) and monovalent salts | ||
| alk-MXene/CoFe2O4/CS144 | • Ultra-high adsorption capacities achieved: 2095.9 mg g−1 for CR, 1333.9 mg g−1 for rhodamine B, and 537.6 mg g−1 for Malachite Green, among the highest reported for similar adsorbents | • Limited recyclability scope with significant capacity loss for anionic dyes (34% loss for CR vs. <20% for cationic dyes) indicating preferential performance toward cationic species |
| • The system demonstrated versatility in removing both cationic and anionic dyes simultaneously with rapid kinetics (equilibrium within 60–120 min) and excellent magnetic separability | • No environmental safety assessment conducted, and complex multi-step synthesis process involving multiple components (alkalized MXene, CoFe2O4, chitosan) may limit practical scalability and cost-effectiveness | |
| • Multiple synergistic mechanisms including electrostatic interactions, π–π stacking, and hydrogen bonding provided comprehensive dye removal capability with good structural stability after cycling | ||
MXene (Ti3C2)/Fe3O4 145 |
• Temperature-enhanced performance with 91.93% removal efficiency at 55 °C compared to lower temperatures, demonstrating excellent high-temperature adsorption capability (11.68 mg g−1 maximum capacity) | • Limited scope with testing only on single cationic dye (MB) and no comprehensive evaluation across different dye types or real wastewater conditions |
| • The system exhibited superparamagnetic properties (20.3 emu g−1) enabling easy magnetic separation and recovery from aqueous solutions with good stability (zeta potential −48 mV) | • No recyclability assessment conducted, leaving questions about long-term performance, stability, and practical applicability, with potential concerns about magnetic material leaching and structural integrity over multiple cycles | |
| • Multiple adsorption mechanisms identified including electrostatic attraction, hydrogen bonding (Ti–OH⋯N), and surface interactions, with temperature-dependent mechanism shifts from physisorption (25 °C) to chemisorption (55 °C) | ||
| AMXGO147 | • Ultra-high adsorption capacities: 1111.6 mg g−1 for MG and 1133.7 mg g−1 for CR, among highest for MXene-based adsorbents | • Limited real-world testing – only synthetic single-dye solutions, not actual industrial wastewater |
| • Excellent versatility with >92% removal for both cationic and anionic dyes, plus selective separation capability | • Complex multi-step synthesis and long equilibrium times (24–48 h) limit scalability and cost-effectiveness | |
| • Multiple adsorption mechanisms with 3.5× surface area increase compared to pristine MXene | ||
| ZIF-8@IL-MXene/PNIPAM152 | • First hydrogel achieving simultaneous high-efficiency adsorption of phenols, dyes, and metal ions (198.40, 325.03, and 285.65 mg g−1, respectively) | • Complex multi-step synthesis requiring precise control of ZIF-8 growth conditions and IL grafting |
| • Excellent mechanical properties withstanding ten repeated compressions without damage | • Significant decrease in Cu2+ regeneration efficiency (29% after 5 cycles) due to irreversible chelation | |
| • 100× increase in specific surface area through ZIF-8 incorporation | • Limited scalability due to multiple synthesis stages and specialized materials (ionic liquids, ZIF-8 precursors) | |
| • Novel ionic liquid grafting approach for MXene stabilization and functionality | • Reduced swelling ratios with ZIF-8 growth potentially limiting accessibility to binding sites | |
| SC-PLA/PDA/MXene membrane154 | • Outstanding dual functionality combining excellent oil/water separation and organic dye adsorption capabilities | • Complex multi-step synthesis involving electrospinning, polydopamine self-polymerization, and MXene deposition requiring precise control |
| • High flux performance with maximum water flux of 3009.2 L (m2 h)−1 and oil flux of 6397.9 L (m2 h)−1 for pure liquids | • Limited long-term stability assessment under continuous industrial operating conditions | |
| • Exceptional MB adsorption capacity of 434.8 mg g−1 following the Langmuir model | • Gradual performance decline in oil flux during extended cycling due to irreversible pore blocking by residual oil | |
• Excellent photothermal conversion ability enhancing separation efficiency under light irradiation (water flux: 9428.4 L (m2 h)−1, oil flux: 12 498.1 L (m2 h)−1) |
• Temperature and light dependency for optimal performance may limit operational flexibility in varying environmental conditions | |
| • Superior amphiphilic properties enabling effective separation of different emulsion types (oil-in-water and water-in-oil) | • No comprehensive economic analysis or cost-effectiveness evaluation compared to conventional separation methods | |
| • Novel polydopamine-assisted MXene deposition strategy ensuring uniform distribution and stable attachment | • Limited testing on real industrial wastewater with complex compositions – most studies conducted using synthetic solutions | |
| • Simultaneous removal capability for both oil and organic pollutants in single-step process | • Potential scalability challenges for large-scale industrial applications not thoroughly addressed | |
| • Ultrahigh oil/water separation efficiency of 99.12% with excellent selectivity | • Performance optimization requires specific conditions (pH, temperature, light irradiation), which may complicate real-world implementation | |
| • Good mechanical properties with tensile strength above 4.5 MPa maintaining structural integrity | • Incomplete removal during regeneration treatment leading to gradual accumulation of contaminants affecting long-term performance | |
| TiVCTx/GAs156 | • Outstanding broad-spectrum removal capabilities: 319.67, 303.45, 229.97, 217.87, and 283.38 mg g−1 for MB, RhB, CR, MO, and TCH, respectively | • Complex multi-step synthesis involving hydrothermal treatment, freeze-drying, and hazardous HF acid for MXene preparation |
| • Superior performance compared to other adsorbents in comparative analysis | • Limited long-term stability assessment with only 5-cycle regeneration study | |
| • Excellent compatibility with harsh environments including wastewater containing multiple dyes/drugs and inorganic salts | • Performance dependency on pH, temperature, and light conditions may limit operational flexibility | |
| • Remarkable photothermal conversion ability reaching 95.0 °C within 1 min under sunlight irradiation | • No comprehensive economic analysis or cost-effectiveness evaluation provided | |
| • Large absorption capacity for oils and solvents ranging from 40–90 g g−1 | • Mostly tested on synthetic wastewater rather than real industrial effluents | |
| • Spontaneous and endothermic adsorption process following Langmuir model and pseudo-second-order kinetics | • Endothermic nature requires higher temperatures for optimal performance, which may increase operational costs |
Photocatalytic versatility emerges as a distinctive advantage, with Ti3C2Tx exhibiting effective UV-driven dye degradation for both MB and AB80, demonstrating dual functionality beyond conventional adsorbents. The heterogeneous adsorption behavior, confirmed through excellent Freundlich model fitting, indicates the presence of multiple binding sites with varying energies, providing flexibility in accommodating diverse dye molecules. This multi-site adsorption mechanism contributes to the material's broad applicability across different dye classes and concentrations.128 Performance enhancement through strategic modifications demonstrates remarkable capabilities through surface functionalization strategies that dramatically amplify the Ti3C2Tx performance. Alkali treatments using NaOH, LiOH, and KOH achieve remarkable improvements, with NaOH-treated Ti3C2Tx demonstrating an exceptional adsorption capacity of 189 mg g−1 for MB, representing a nearly five-fold increase over the pristine material. This enhancement stems from interlayer spacing expansion (up to 29% increase) and surface chemistry modification through fluoride-to-hydroxyl group conversion (–F → –OH), creating more favorable binding sites.129 Fluoride-free synthesis approaches using NaBF4/HCl represent a significant advancement,130 producing h-Ti3C2 with a superior surface area (44.6 vs. 8.9 m2 g−1) and enhanced exfoliation characteristics. This environmentally safer synthesis route eliminates hazardous HF usage while achieving better performance for MB adsorption, addressing both environmental concerns and performance requirements. The compliance of modified systems with the Langmuir model indicates a transition to monolayer adsorption, suggesting a more uniform distribution of binding sites.
Chemical functionalization through sulfonic acid modification (Ti3C2–SO3H) showcases a dramatic capacity enhancement from 21.10 to 111.11 mg g−1, with a concentration-dependent performance reaching 723.35 mg g−1 under optimized conditions. This diazonium-mediated surface modification enhances both surface chemistry and interlayer spacing, creating highly active adsorption sites.133 Surfactant modification using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) achieves a capacity of 213.00 mg g−1 while maintaining broad pH tolerance, particularly effective at pH 3.136 Critical performance limitations and stability challenges reveal that oxidative instability represents the most significant limitation of Ti3C2Tx systems, with poor stability in aqueous environments leading to oxidation to TiO2.128 This fundamental degradation pathway compromises long-term performance and material integrity, which is particularly problematic for continuous water treatment applications. The oxidation susceptibility extends across all Ti3C2Tx variants, indicating a material-level challenge requiring protective strategies or alternative compositions.
The limited adsorption capacity in its pristine form presents significant competitive disadvantages, with the baseline Ti3C2Tx achieving only ∼39 mg g−1, substantially lower than that of high-performing adsorbents.128 Even modified variants like h-Ti3C2 show a moderate performance (∼24 mg g−1), indicating inherent capacity limitations that require extensive modification for competitive performance.130 Surface area reduction following certain modifications, such as CTAB treatment (5.02 to 2.06 m2 g−1), demonstrates trade-offs between functionalization and accessible surface area.136 Mechanistic complexity across Ti3C2Tx systems requires further clarification,128 with multiple interaction pathways including electrostatic attraction, π–cation interactions, hydrogen bonding,136 and ion exchange contributing to overall performance. This complexity makes performance prediction and optimization challenging, particularly in multi-component systems where competing interactions may alter dominant mechanisms. Scalability and practical implementation barriers pose significant challenges, particularly due to the complexity of synthesis, which requires multi-step modifications. Alkali treatments,129 chemical functionalization,133 and surfactant modifications136 introduce additional processing steps, chemical consumption, and potential environmental concerns. The time-consuming nature of layer-by-layer assembly and precise control requirements for modification procedures limit industrial scalability and cost-effectiveness.134
Regeneration limitations across Ti3C2Tx systems present economic and environmental concerns. Decreased adsorption efficiency after multiple reuse cycles, observed in CTAB-modified systems, indicates structural degradation or irreversible binding.136 Desorption agent requirements (ethanol, NaOH) increase operational costs and waste generation, while incomplete regeneration leads to a gradual decline in performance. Real-world validation gaps represent critical knowledge deficits, with most studies conducted using synthetic single-dye solutions rather than complex industrial wastewaters. Performance degradation in the presence of multivalent cations (Ca2+, Al3+) and competing anions highlights selectivity challenges in realistic water matrices. The lack of comprehensive real wastewater testing limits practical applicability assessment.
Environmental and safety considerations highlight critical research gaps, with the assessment of toxicity and biocompatibility representing urgent needs. No systematic evaluation of Ti3C2Tx's environmental impact or human health effects exists, while the toxicity of oxidation products, leaching behavior, and long-term environmental fate remain uncharacterized, raising concerns about its widespread deployment. Surface modification agents, such as CTAB and sulfonic acid groups, introduce additional chemical complexity, requiring safety evaluation. Environmental concerns surrounding HF-based synthesis necessitate safer alternatives, with fluoride-free routes showing promise but requiring further optimization.130 Waste generation from synthesis processes and regeneration procedures requires a comprehensive life cycle assessment to evaluate their overall environmental impact. Challenges associated with disposing of spent MXene materials and their oxidation products necessitate a systematic investigation.
Future directions and innovation opportunities suggest that enhancing oxidative stability represents the highest priority research direction, requiring protective coating strategies, alloy composition optimization, or control of operational conditions. Encapsulation approaches, such as those using protective polymer layers or composite formation with stable matrices, could address degradation issues while maintaining functional performance. Performance optimization strategies should focus on synergistic modification approaches combining interlayer engineering, surface functionalization, and morphological control. AI-guided design can accelerate composition–structure–property relationship discoveries, enabling the rational optimization of Ti3C2Tx variants for specific applications. Scale-up engineering focusing on continuous flow systems, automated synthesis procedures, and regeneration optimization will bridge the laboratory-to-industry gap. Economic feasibility studies incorporating material costs, processing requirements, and performance benefits are essential for commercial viability assessment. Comprehensive environmental impact evaluation through life cycle assessment will guide sustainable development and regulatory compliance for Ti3C2Tx-based water treatment technologies.
O, –F), and adjustable surface chemistry that fosters strong electrostatic interactions with both cationic and anionic dyes. MXenes show quick kinetics, reaching equilibrium in 5–120 min versus 60–300 min for traditional adsorbents, and they can be reused with over 90% efficiency after multiple cycles. Although MOFs and COFs perform well in some cases, like TpStb–SO3Na COF achieving high capacities for certain cationic dyes, MXenes offer greater versatility, faster kinetics, and wider applicability across diverse dye types and conditions, making them the most promising new adsorbents for sustainable wastewater treatment.170
| Adsorbent material | Dye | Adsorption capacity (mg g−1) | Contact time | pH | Temp. (°C) | Initial conc. (mg L−1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MXenes (2D transition metal carbides) | ||||||
TMAOH–Ti3C2Tx 142 |
MB | 1026 | Rapid | 7 | 45 | 100 |
| Ti3C2Tx@sodium alginate171 | MB | 969 | 60 min | 10 | 25 | 300 |
| Ti3C2Tx/carbon foam157 | MB | 357 | 120 min | 7 | 30 | 200 |
| Ti3C2Tx/carbon foam157 | CR | 648 | 120 min | 7 | 30 | 300 |
| MXene/biomass AC159 | CR | >1400 | 180 min | 7 | 25 | 500 |
NaOH–Ti3C2Tx 129 |
MB | 189 | 120 min | 7 | 25 | 100 |
| Ti3C2Tx/loofah carbon169 | MB | 175 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 200 |
| Ti3C2Tx/loofah carbon169 | CR | 93 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 150 |
| Activated carbon | ||||||
| Commercial PAC (Norit)168 | MB | 400 | 120 min | 6–7 | 25 | 200 |
| Commercial PAC (Norit)168 | CR | 500 | 120 min | 6–7 | 25 | 250 |
| Tea seed shell AC172 | MB | 325 | 180 min | 6–7 | 25 | 200 |
| Water-activated AC173 | MB | 149 | 5 min | 6.5–7 | 25 | 100 |
| Palm kernel shell AC174 | MB | 15 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 100 |
| Ashitaba waste AC175 | CR | 200–300 | 180 min | 7 | 25 | 200 |
| Walnut shell AC175 | MB | 150–200 | 180 min | 7 | 25 | 150 |
| Graphene-based materials | ||||||
| Graphene oxide176 | MB | 250–300 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 100 |
| Graphene oxide175 | Rhodamine B | 200–250 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 100 |
| GO–AC composite177 | MB | 300–400 | 120 min | 7 | 25 | 200 |
| CNTs | ||||||
| Multi-walled CNTs168 | MB | 400 | 120 min | 6–7 | 25 | 200 |
| Multi-walled CNTs168 | CR | 500 | 120 min | 6–7 | 25 | 250 |
| Functionalized CNTs178 | MB | 350–450 | 90 min | 7 | 25 | 150 |
| Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) | ||||||
| ZIF-67/GO composite179 | Malachite green | 250–350 | 180 min | 7 | 25 | 200 |
| Al-based MOF180 | MB | 180–250 | 120 min | 7 | 25 | 100 |
| MOF-199181 | Various odorants | 22.6 ± 42.3 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | Variable |
| Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) | ||||||
| TpStb–SO3Na COF170 | Cationic dyes | 400–500 | 60 min | 7 | 25 | 200 |
| Various COFs182 | MB | 200–400 | 120 min | 7 | 25 | 100–300 |
Current MXene-based dye removal technologies operate at Technology Readiness Level (TRL) 3–4, as characterized by laboratory-scale proof-of-concept and component validation in controlled environments.61 While fundamental adsorption mechanisms are well-understood and performance optimization has been demonstrated in synthetic solutions, significant gaps remain in real-world validation, system integration, and scalable manufacturing processes.183 Real wastewater performance presents the most critical challenge, as industrial effluents contain complex mixtures of organic contaminants, salts, suspended particles, heavy metals, and fluctuating pH that can drastically reduce MXene's adsorption capacity and selectivity compared to single-component laboratory studies. Fouling mechanisms from biological waste, organic matter, and inorganic scaling result in surface deactivation and pore blockage, reducing the recyclable capacity over operational cycles.90 Cost and scalability barriers arise from expensive, hazardous synthesis methods using HF or LiF/HCl, with material costs of $50–200 kg−1 compared to $1–10 kg−1 for conventional adsorbents.184 Environmental impact assessment through life cycle analysis (LCA) reveals carbon footprints of 5–15 kg CO2 equivalent per kg MXene, primarily from energy-intensive synthesis processes.103 Advancement to TRL 6–7 requires pilot-scale demonstrations, comprehensive techno-economic analysis, and the development of green synthesis alternatives to establish commercial feasibility.
Several vital areas require attention to fully harness the capabilities of MXene-based materials in dye removal and other applications:
1. Improvements in the etching procedure: traditional etching methods for synthesizing MXenes often employ hazardous chemicals that can harm the environment. Therefore, exploring and creating more ecologically friendly techniques for the etching process are critical. This transition could make MXene production safer and more sustainable and increase its appeal for industrial applications in which environmental restrictions are growing more stringent.
2. Research on toxicity: another critical area of exploration is the potential toxicity of MXene-based materials. Understanding how these materials interact with the environment and human health is essential, especially for therapeutic applications. Comprehensive studies assessing the biocompatibility and environmental impact of MXenes will help establish safety protocols and regulatory frameworks, ensuring their responsible use in various applications, including medicine and environmental remediation.
3. Surface characterization: the surface characteristics of MXene-based materials play a significant role in their adsorption abilities. Gaining a deeper understanding of these properties, including surface area, functional groups, and morphology, can lead to modifications that enhance their performance in dye removal. Tailoring the surface chemistry of MXenes could optimize their interaction with various dye molecules, thereby improving their efficiency as adsorbents (Fig. 18).
4. Lifespan of recycled materials and advanced integration strategies: finally, further research is needed to evaluate the lifespan and reusability of recycled MXene-based materials in real applications. Understanding how these materials degrade over time and how they operate after several cycles of usage is critical to determine their feasibility in long-term applications. Investigating and creating methods for the regeneration of MXenes could considerably improve their use in various applications, including wastewater treatment, energy storage, and sensing technologies. Integrating AI and ML can transform the development of MXene materials. These technologies may be utilized to forecast material degradation trends, enhance synthesis procedures, and formulate more effective recycling methods. ML models may evaluate massive datasets to discover trends and recommend ideal settings for material regeneration, therefore eliminating trial-and-error experimentation.
5. Performance in real wastewater: the majority of MXene research has been carried out using artificial dye solutions in controlled lab settings. Real wastewater streams, on the other hand, are far more complicated and frequently include a combination of organic contaminants, salts, suspended particles, heavy metals, and fluctuating pH. These conflicting elements have the potential to drastically lower MXenes’ adsorption capability and selectivity. Therefore, assessing MXene-based systems in realistic wastewater environments must be a top priority for future research in order to confirm their resilience, effectiveness, and longevity.
6. Fouling and long-term stability: MXenes are prone to fouling from biological wastes, organic matter, and other wastewater particles, which can result in surface deactivation, pore blockage, and decreased recyclable capacity. To ensure constant performance over several cycles, fouling must be addressed via surface functionalization, hybrid coating techniques, or integration with antifouling polymers. Additionally, MXene degradation under extended exposure to aquatic environments, particularly under variable redox conditions, remains a significant but little-studied problem.
7. Cost and scalability: top-down etching techniques that use dangerous chemicals like HF or LiF/HCl are among the current MXene production methods that are expensive, dangerous, and challenging to scale. Additionally, purification and post-synthesis delamination processes require a lot of energy and time. To move MXene manufacturing from the laboratory to commercial scale, it will be essential to develop low-cost, scalable, and environmentally friendly synthesis methods, such as electrochemical etching, green exfoliation processes, and continuous flow systems.
8. Environmental impact and sustainability: MXenes are intriguing prospects for green remediation solutions, but their total environmental impact must be carefully evaluated. To assess energy use, chemical use, emissions, and end-of-life disposal or recyclability, LCA studies are crucial. To guarantee environmental and regulatory compliance, issues with leaching, nanoparticle release, and ecotoxicity should also be addressed using thorough risk assessment frameworks. Furthermore, performing a LCA is essential for identifying the environmental impacts of MXene-based materials throughout their life span, from synthesis to disposal. Such a technique guarantees that the materials are sustainable and effective, in agreement with the overall green chemistry initiatives. Evaluating the LCA would make MXenes more attractive for firms embracing eco-friendly technology.
For biomedical and environmental applications, in vivo cytotoxicity analysis is significant in determining the toxicity of MXenes. Such tests would ensure the safer use of MXenes in real-world applications, such as sensing and wastewater treatment, and guarantee no risk to human health or ecosystems. Advanced characterization solutions including real-time monitoring capabilities, molecular docking studies, and computational simulation technologies, combined with emerging force measurement techniques and advanced X-ray methodologies, could significantly improve the activity and reusability assessment of the MXene system. Force measurement approaches, particularly atomic force microscopy (AFM) and nanoindentation techniques, enable precise quantification of interfacial interactions between MXene surfaces and target molecules, providing critical insights into adsorption mechanisms at the nanoscale. These force-based methodologies can map surface heterogeneity, measure adhesion forces, and characterize the evolution of mechanical properties during cycling processes, offering an unprecedented understanding of structure–property relationships in MXene systems.185
Although MXene-based materials hold great promise for environmental applications, addressing these challenges through focused research will be crucial for translating theoretical advancements into practical solutions. By improving synthesis methods, assessing toxicity, understanding surface properties, and evaluating lifespan, the full potential of MXenes can be realized, paving the way for innovative approaches for dye removal and other environmental challenges. Despite years of investigation of MXenes, these materials are still in their early phases of development. Standardization is still required to produce MXene, an attractive material with stable characteristics, including higher biocompatibility, uniform dispersion, prolonged strength, and higher efficiency compared to other 2D materials.61 Industry–academia collaboration is essential for developing large-scale MXene-based materials, including encapsulated adsorbents, membranes, and electrodes, with increased hazardous removal efficiency. This will enable the production and deployment of low-cost MXene-based adsorbent solutions for wastewater treatment in residential and commercial areas.
Artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML) and complex physics based data modelling technologies offer transformative potential for advancing MXene-based water treatment systems through multiple specific applications.186 ML algorithms can predict optimal MXene compositions and surface functionalization strategies by analyzing structure–property relationships from experimental datasets, with density functional theory (DFT) calculations combined with ML models enabling the screening of thousands of potential MXene variants to identify high-performance candidates before experimental synthesis.187 Gaussian process regression and random forest algorithms have been successfully applied to predict adsorption capacities based on surface area, functional group density, and interlayer spacing parameters,188 while neural network models can optimize synthesis conditions, including etching time, temperature, and chemical concentrations to achieve target material properties.189 Support vector machine (SVM) and artificial neural network (ANN) models demonstrate capability for predicting dye removal efficiency based on water quality parameters including pH, ionic strength, competing ions, and dye concentrations,190 with ensemble learning methods such as XGBoost and random forest showing superior accuracy at predicting breakthrough curves and saturation points for MXene-based filtration systems.191
Real-time process optimization represents another critical application area, where adaptive control algorithms integrated with IoT sensor networks enable dynamic optimization of treatment parameters.192 Reinforcement learning agents can continuously adjust flow rates, pH levels, and regeneration cycles based on real-time performance feedback, while digital twin models combining physics-based simulations with ML algorithms provide predictive maintenance capabilities and optimal operational strategies.193,194 Deep learning architectures including convolutional neural networks (CNNs) can analyze microscopy images to predict material degradation and performance decline over operational cycles,195 with computer vision systems powered by deep learning enabling effluent quality analysis through spectroscopic data interpretation. Time-series forecasting models using LSTM networks predict treatment system performance and identify potential failures before critical thresholds are reached,196 while anomaly detection algorithms monitor unusual patterns in adsorption behavior that may indicate material degradation or system malfunction.
5G technology enables ultra-low latency communication between distributed sensor networks and central control systems, facilitating real-time optimization of multiple treatment units, while edge computing capabilities enable on-site ML inference for immediate decision-making without cloud dependency.197,198 IoT sensors equipped with selective dye detection capabilities provide high-resolution monitoring of specific contaminants, enabling precision treatment protocols that automatically adjust based on real-time water quality parameters.199 Cloud-based platforms integrate multi-site data for comprehensive performance analysis and predictive modeling, with blockchain technology ensuring data integrity and traceability for regulatory compliance and performance verification. Specific implementation examples include predictive maintenance models that analyze pressure drop patterns, flow rate variations, and energy consumption trends to schedule optimal regeneration cycles, and multi-objective optimization algorithms that balance treatment efficiency, energy consumption, and operational costs to minimize total system expenses.200
Future prospects include quantum machine learning algorithms that may accelerate the discovery of materials by exploring vast chemical spaces more efficiently than classical computers, automated laboratory systems guided by AI algorithms conducting high-throughput synthesis and screening experiments with minimal human intervention, and integration of genomics data with ML models to predict ecological impacts and optimize MXene designs for environmental compatibility.201 Federated learning frameworks enable collaborative model training across multiple treatment facilities while preserving data privacy and proprietary information, while augmented reality interfaces provide operators with real-time system status and maintenance guidance through smart glasses and mobile applications.202 This comprehensive AI/ML integration represents a paradigm shift toward intelligent water treatment systems that continuously learn, adapt, and optimize their performance, ultimately enabling more efficient, cost-effective, and sustainable MXene-based environmental remediation technologies capable of autonomous operation and predictive performance optimization across diverse water treatment scenarios.
This review has highlighted substantial developments in the design and fabrication of MXene-based adsorbents, their adsorption capacity, their physicochemical properties, and adsorption mechanisms of MXenes, including chemical, physical, and electrostatic interactions for the removal of toxic dyes from the aqueous environment. Overall, MXenes are a cutting-edge advance in water treatment, providing an alternative route to more sustainable and effective solutions for dye-contaminated water. Furthermore, with the integration of modern technologies such as IoT, AI, ML, complexities science, network analysis and 5G communications, MXene-based nanosorbents have the potential to be next-generation material-based intelligent environmental technologies that form smart and connected societies and cities.
| 2D | Two dimensional |
| 3D | Three dimensional |
| AA | Acrylic acid |
| AB93 | Methyl blue |
| AI | Artificial intelligence |
| BC | Bacterial cellulose |
| BD | Benzidine |
| BET | Brunauer–Emmett–Teller |
| CDCs | Carbon-derived carbides |
| CNTs | Carbon nanotubes |
| COF | Covalent organic framework |
| CR | Congo Red |
| CTAB | Cationic surfactant solution |
| CVD | Chemical vapor deposition |
| DASNP | Dialdehyde starch nanoparticles |
| DBM | Direct brown M |
| DBRN | Direct black RN |
| DMSO | Dimethyl sulphoxide |
| EDX | Energy-dispersive X-ray |
| FTIR | Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy |
| GPa | Gigapascals |
| GO | Graphene oxide |
| HRTEM | High-resolution transmission electron microscopy |
| IL | Ionic liquid |
| LCA | Life cycle assessment |
| LDH | Layered double hydroxides |
| MB | Methylene blue |
| MG | Malachite Green |
| ML | Machine learning |
| MO | Methyl orange |
| MOF | Metal–organic framework |
| MPa | Megapascals |
| NMs | Nanofiber membranes |
| PA | p-Phenylenediamine |
| PAN | Polyacrylonitrile |
| PDA | Polydopamine |
| PEI | Polyethylenimine |
| PEPLD | Plasma-enhanced pulsed laser deposition |
| PLA | Polylactic acid |
| rGO | Reduced graphene oxide |
| RhB | Rhodamine B |
| ROS | Reactive oxygen species |
| SA | Sodium alginate |
| SAED | Selected area electron diffraction |
| SEM | Scanning electron microscopy |
| SSA | Specific surface area |
| SSbD | Safe and sustainable by design |
| TAPB | 1,3,5-Tris(4-aminophenyl) benzene |
| TMAOH | Tetramethylammonium hydroxide |
| TP | 1,3,5-Triformylphloroglucinol |
| UN | United Nations |
| XPS | X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy |
| XRD | X-ray diffraction |
| ZIF | Zeolitic imidazolate framework |
Declaration of generative AI in scientific writing: while preparing this work the author(s) used ChatGPT and Claude to improve the readability and language of the manuscript. After using this tool/service, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content as needed and take(s) full responsibility for the content of the published article.
Footnote |
| † Equal authorship: SK and GR. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |