Jiaqi Wang‡
ab,
Yang Li‡ab,
Haiyang Tianab,
Junlu Shengbc,
Jianyong Yub and
Bin Ding*abc
aState Key Laboratory for Modification of Chemical Fibers and Polymer Materials, College of Material Science and Engineering, Donghua University, Shanghai 201620, China. E-mail: binding@dhu.edu.cn
bNanomaterials Research Center, Modern Textile Institute, Donghua University, Shanghai 200051, China
cKey Laboratory of Textile Science & Technology, Ministry of Education, College of Textiles, Donghua University, Shanghai 201620, China
First published on 7th November 2014
Creating an efficient and cost-effective approach that can provide advanced microporous membranes with high waterproofness and good breathability has proved to be tremendously challenging. This work responds to these challenges by designing, fabricating and evaluating an electrospun polyacrylonitrile (PAN) fibrous membrane which was modified with waterborne fluorinated polyurethane (WFPU) to achieve high waterproof and breathable performances. By employing the WFPU modification, the pristine PAN fibrous membranes possessed remarkable superhydrophobicity with an advancing water contact angle of 159° as well as adjustable pore structure. Significantly, the waterproofness was confirmed to depend on the maximum pore size and surface wettability, in good agreement with the Young–Laplace equation, and a geometric coefficient A was introduced as a geometric factor to evaluate the torturous pore structure in electrospun fibrous membranes. Furthermore, the resultant membranes could present a high waterproofness up to 83.4 kPa, large water vapor transmission rate over 9.2 kg per m2 per day, good air permeability over 5.9 L m−2 s−1, suggesting them as promising candidates for a variety of potential applications such as protective clothing.
Currently, a variety of strategies have been developed to fabricate waterproof and breathable microporous membranes, including mechanical fibrillation,7 phase separation,8 template methods,9 and melt blown.10 Unfortunately, these methods suffer from the complicated procedures or high cost, and in the meantime, the difficulties in regulating pore size and porosity make the fabricated membranes unable to satisfy the requirement in waterproof and breathable application.
Electrospinning has been proved to be an efficient method to fabricate microporous membranes with interconnected and controllable porous structure constructed by fibers accumulating, which could be facilely regulated by tuning fiber diameter and packing density.11,12 Up to now, electrospun microporous membranes with waterproof and breathable performances have been prepared, including polyurethane,13 polypropylene,14 and polyamide.15 Also reported is that the preparation of electrospun polyurethane microporous membranes containing low surface energy content, which resulted in enhanced water resistance with a hydrostatic pressure of 39 kPa, and elevated breathability with a water vapor transmission (WVT) rate of 9 kg per m2 per day.16 However, the membranes still could not satisfy the demand of waterproof and breathable performances due to their relatively large pore size and low porosity, and the poor mechanical properties remain a limitation in the practical application.
To achieve electrospun microporous membranes with excellent waterproof and breathable performances and high tensile strength, the fabrication of composite fibrous membranes by modified with desirable materials is urgently needed. Waterborne fluorinated polyurethane (WFPU) as a class of low surface energy and environmental friendly material for fabrics finishing, could induce a variety of desirable properties to the substrates such as hydrophobicity, adjustable pore structure and reinforced mechanical properties, contributing to good waterproof and breathable performances.17,18 To date, scarcely effort has been devoted to the development of WFPU modified electrospun fibrous membranes with waterproof and breathable performances.
In this study, we demonstrate a fabrication of waterproof and breathable PAN fibrous membranes by modified with WFPU emulsion on electrospun PAN fibers. The wettability, pore size and adhesion structure of the membranes were finely controlled by tuning PAN and WFPU concentrations. Moreover, on the basis of the above characters, the waterproof, breathable and mechanical performances were thoroughly investigated. Significantly, Young–Laplace equation was used to evaluate the waterproofness depending on the maximum pore size and surface wettability with the introduction of a geometric coefficient. Eventually, PAN fibrous membranes modified with WFPU exhibiting superhydrophobic surface, minimum pore size and optimized adhesion structure was fabricated, which exhibited excellent waterproof, breathable and mechanical performances.
The chemical structure of WFPU was presented in Scheme 1a, and the detail procedures for preparing of WFPU emulsion were shown in the ESI (Fig. S1†). The polymeric backbone of the WFPU was designed composing of soft, hard, hydrophilic and hydrophobic segments. The matrix of soft segments (PTMEG groups) and hard segments (urethane segments based on the MDI and TEG groups) would exhibit microphase separation and result in the superior mechanical properties. The carboxyl groups on DMPA was introduced as hydrophilic segments to disperse the polymer in aqueous medium. The low surface energy perfluoroalkane segments was situated on the head of the chain could facilely migrate to the surface region that would endow the polymer with promising hydrophobicity.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Schematic illustration of (a) chemical structure of WFPU particles and (b) the strategy for fabrication of WFPU@PAN fibrous membranes. |
The structure confirmation by 1H and 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and group affirmations by Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy were also showed in the ESI (Fig. S2, S3, and S4†). The particle size of the WFPU emulsion was determined by a particle size & zeta potential analyzer (Nano ZS, Malvern Instruments Ltd., UK). The distribution curve of particle size was showed in Fig. S5† revealing an average diameter of 26.6 nm. The molecular weight was characterized by the gel permeation chromatography method (GPC, PL-GPC 50, Polymer Laboratories Ltd., UK). The GPC curve of the WFPU was presented in Fig. S6† indicating that the molecular weight (Mw) is 31120 and the polydispersity was 1.43.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 FE-SEM images of (a) PAN-6, (a′) WFPU-5@PAN-6, (b) PAN-8, and (b′) WFPU-5@PAN-8 fibrous membranes. |
Intended to investigate the effect of WFPU modification on the porous structure, pore size distribution was measured through capillary flow porometer (Fig. 2b). The maximum pore size (dmax) of the PAN fibrous membranes increased remarkably from 1.3 to 6.1 μm, which is due to the increase of fiber diameter.23,24 Moreover, after modified with WFPU emulsion, the dmax of WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes fabricated from various PAN concentrations were 1.1, 1.2, 1.6, 2.5, and 4.3 μm, respectively. Comparing with the corresponding unmodified PAN membranes, all the samples exhibit a significant reduction in dmax, which is due to the formation of the adhesion structure among adjacent fibers that filled the voids.25
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) dmax and (b) θadv of PAN and the corresponding WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes fabricated from various PAN concentrations. |
On the other hand, the wetting behavior of both PAN and WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes was evaluated by measuring the θadv of water on the membranes, as shown in Fig. 2b. The PAN fibrous membranes showed superhydrophilicity due to the presence of polar cyano group in the skeletal chain.20,26 After WFPU modification, a tremendous transition in wetting behavior has been observed here, the θadv which increases from 0 to higher than 140°, which is due to the high fraction of coverage on the PAN fibers by WFPU with low surface energy fluorinated segment.16,27 Furthermore, the θadv of the WFPU@PAN membranes increased from 147 to 159° with PAN concentrations increasing from 6 to 14 wt%, which is attributed to the increased roughness by larger fiber diameter.28,29
As expected, the dmax and wettability would highly influence the waterproofness through a synergetic effect. The waterproofness of the WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes was investigated by evaluating the hydrostatic pressure (Fig. 3a). An increase of hydrostatic pressure from 40 to 54.4 kPa was observed when the PAN concentration increased from 6 to 8 wt%, owing to the disappearance of bead-on-string structure, which lead to enhanced tensile strength and reduced deformation of the pores under external water pressure. However, with further increasing of PAN concentrations to 14 wt%, an obvious decrease of hydrostatic pressure from 44.9 to 16.1 kPa was emerged, which is due to the remarkable increase of dmax (Fig. 2a). Moreover, the hydrostatic pressure of porous membranes could be determined using the Young–Laplace equation, which is commonly used to express the liquid enter pressure of a cylindrical capillary:
![]() | (1) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a) Hydrostatic pressure, and (b) dependence of hydrostatic pressure on dmax and θadv of WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes fabricated from various PAN concentrations. |
On the basis of the excellent waterproofness, the breathable performance of WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes was studied by measuring WVT rate and air permeability (Fig. 4). WVT rate would be highly influenced by porosity of the membranes. As shown in Fig. 4a, the porosity decrease from 77.8 to 57.3% towards increasing of PAN concentrations, which result in a decrease of WVT rate from 13.1 to 9.8 kg per m2 per day. This is attributed to that more WFPU emulsion would be adsorbed in the membranes with larger pore size resulting in more adhesion structure formation. Moreover, since the air permeability was measured under a pressure drop of 100 Pa, the mean pore size was the foremost parameter that affect the air permeability.32,33 Therefore, a remarkable increase in air permeability from 2.8 to 17.9 L m−2 s−1 was observed with the increasing of PAN concentrations, which is attributed to the increase of mean pore size (Fig. 4b).
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) Porosity and WVT rate, and (b) mean pore size and air permeability of WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes fabricated from various PAN concentrations. |
Mechanical property is another important factor in practical application, which could be tremendously enhanced during the WFPU modifying process. Generally, the mechanical behaviors of electrospun fibrous membranes are closely related to the geometric arrangement and the bonding structure among the fibers.34,35 As shown in Fig. 1 and S7,† the PAN and WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes exhibited randomly oriented geometry, thus the bonding structure becomes the key factor that affect the mechanical behaviors. Typical tensile stress–strain curves of PAN-8 and WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes (Fig. 5a). It is clearly observed that all the membranes exhibited a linear elastic deformation in the first region under a stress lord before reaching the yield point, then, the stress–strain curves showed a nonlinear increase with the continuous loaded stress until break.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Stress–strain curves of PAN-8 and WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes. (b) Proposed break mechanism of tensile fracture process upon external stress. |
This mechanical behavior could be explained by the two-step break mechanism, as illustrated in Fig. 5b.36,37 When a small external stress was loaded, the randomly oriented fibers tend to align along the strain direction, and the fibers between bonding points would undertake the stress on intermolecular level, resulting in the liner deformation with an elongation less than 3%. After reaching the yield points, the curves showed a nonlinear elasticity which is related to the slipping and stretching of individual fiber along stress direction. Finally, the PAN-8 fibrous membranes broke due to the non-bonding fibers slipped apart, which exhibited a nonlinear decrease with the minimum tensile strength (3.7 MPa) and elongation (21.2%) at break. All the PAN fibrous membranes exhibited similar mechanical properties (Fig. S8†). However, the break of WFPU-5@PAN membranes with numerous bonding structure resulted from the break of fibers between bonding points, thus displayed enhanced tensile strength and elongation. The tensile strength of WFPU-5@PAN fibrous membranes formed from 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14 wt% PAN solutions were 8.5, 12.1, 13.5, 16.7, and 18.8 MPa, respectively, indicating that the tensile strength increases with the disappearance of the beads and the increase of fiber diameter.38,39 Considering the practical application, the membranes should not only possess good mechanical properties, but also exhibit high waterproofness and breathability PAN-8 fibrous membranes was carried out in the following study.
In order to explore the real waterproofness and breathability of WFPU@PAN fibrous membranes, the PAN-8 fibrous membranes modified with various concentrations of WFPU emulsions were investigated. The representative FE-SEM images of WFPU@PAN-8 fibrous membranes modified with various WFPU concentrations are presented in Fig. 6, revealing that more adhesion structure was formed between the voids of fibers with increasing of the WFPU concentrations. Besides that, the pore size distribution of the membranes showed in the range of 0.2 to 1.3 μm, and the mean pore size decreased gradually with the increasing of WFPU concentrations, which is due to more adhesion structure formed among fibers (Fig. S9†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 FE-SEM images of (a) WFPU-1@PAN-8, (b) WFPU-3@PAN-8, (c) WFPU-7@PAN-8, and (d) WFPU-9@PAN-8 fibrous membranes. |
Since the WFPU@PAN fibrous membranes were influenced by two opposite characteristics, including the hydrophilicity of PAN and the hydrophobicity of WFPU emulsion, the wettability was studied by estimating θadv and water absorption rate. As can be seen in Fig. 7a, only using low WFPU concentration (1 wt%) would obtain a tremendous increase in θadv from 0 to 146°, confirming that a critical concentration of WFPU could induce the hydrophobicity among the hydrophilic PAN fibrous membranes. Moreover, the use of 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, and 1 wt% WFPU resulted in a liner increase in θadv of 56, 101, 124, and 146° (inset of Fig. 7a). Additionally, further increase of WFPU concentrations to 9 wt% have revealed a continued increase in θadv to 159°, owing to more fluorinated segments enriched on the surface of fibers. On the other hand, the water absorption rate decrease gradually from 40 to 0.8% with the WFPU concentrations increasing from 1 to 9 wt%, indicating that membranes modified with higher WFPU concentration would exhibit much better hydrophobicity, as shown in Fig. 7b. The increase in θadv and the decrease in water absorption rate would contributed to higher waterproof and breathable performances.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) θadv and (b) water absorption rate of WFPU@PAN-8 fibrous membranes modified with WFPU emulsions of various concentrations. |
The effect of WFPU emulsion modification on the performances of the WFPU@PAN-8 fibrous membranes was confirmed by measuring hydrostatic pressure, WVT rate, air permeability, and mechanical properties, as shown in Fig. 8. The hydrostatic pressure increased from 6.6 to 83.4 kPa, revealing that the waterproof properties increased regularly towards increasing of WFPU concentrations, which is due to the increase of θadv and the decrease of the water absorption rate. However, the WVT rate decreased from 12.9 to 9.2 kg per m2 per day, which is due to the increased adhesion structure that filled more voids between fibers. Nevertheless, with the decreasing of mean pore size, the air permeability decrease from 5.9 to 1.2 L m−2 s−1. Furthermore, the tensile strength increased from 7.1 to 14.4 MPa with the increasing of WFPU concentrations, which is due to more formation of adhesion structure, as shown in Fig. S10.† These results illustrated that the hydrostatic pressure, WVT rate and air permeability could be regulated simultaneously by diversifying WFPU concentrations, which provide a facile and efficient method to produce membranes with various waterproofness and breathability.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) Hydrostatic pressure and (b) WVT rate and air permeability of WFPU@PAN fibrous membranes modified with various concentrations of WFPU emulsions. |
Above all, the WFPU@PAN fibrous membranes which combined hydrophobicity, diminutive pore sizes and good mechanical properties, demonstrated excellent water resistance and breathability. Two typical tests in Fig. 9 were performed as proofs of waterproof and breathable performances of WFPU-9@PAN-8 fibrous membrane. As shown in Fig. 9a, the WFPU-9@PAN-8 membrane was covered on a beaker with water, and three droplets of colored water were dripped upon the membrane. Abundant vapor was produced after heating the water to 100 °C, and facilely transmitted through the membrane, indicating an outstanding transmission rate of water vapour (Movie S1†). Moreover, a severe but interesting test was performed as a further confirmation of the waterproof and breathable performances, as shown in Fig. 9b. The self-standing WFPU-9@PAN-8 fibrous membrane were fixed between a close chamber (with an air inlet pipe, left panel of Fig. 9b) and an open tube, and 2 kg water were lorded upon the membrane. The membrane could afford the weight of water without penetration, while air could transmit through by pump compressing (middle panel in Fig. 9b). Close observation (right panel in Fig. 9b) showed that the air bubbles that formed from the permeated air were generated on the surface of the membrane, revealing an extremely high air permeability (Movie S2†). Additionally, a comparison with performance of the conventional waterproof and breathable art systems was presented in Fig. 9c and d, indicating that the WAFPU-9@PAN-8 membranes exhibited high hydrostatic pressure and WVT rate. Consequently, the WFPU@PAN fibrous membrane exhibited excellent waterproof and breathable performances, suggesting a promising candidate for a variety of potential applications in protective clothing, membrane distillation, pharmaceutical industry, tissue engineering and filtration/separation process, etc.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details synthesis and structure confirmation of WFPU, FE-SEM, stress–strain curves of PAN and WFPU@PAN-8 membranes, pore size distribution and maximum pore size of WFPU@PAN-8 membranes, and Movies S1 and S2. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra09129a |
‡ These authors have contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |