Julianna
Palotás
,
Francis C.
Daly
,
Thomas E.
Douglas-Walker
and
Ewen K.
Campbell
*
School of Chemistry, University of Edinburgh, Joseph Black Building, Kings Buildings, David Brewster Road, Edinburgh EH9 3FJ, UK. E-mail: e.k.campbell@ed.ac.uk
First published on 10th January 2024
We present the low temperature gas-phase vibrational spectrum of ionised 1-cyanonaphthalene (1-CNN+) in the mid-infrared region. Experimentally, 1-CNN+ ions are cooled below 10 K in a cryogenic ion trapping apparatus, tagged with He atoms and probed with tuneable radiation. Quantum-chemical calculations are carried out at a density functional theory level. The spectrum is dominated by the CN-stretch at 4.516 μm, with weaker CH modes near 3.2 μm.
One problem encountered with the analysis of spectra in the 5–15 μm range is due to the plethora of molecular structures capable of emitting at similar frequencies. A consequence is that association with individual members of the PAH or similar carbonaceous family is near impossible. An exception to this is the case of C60, which due to its high Ih symmetry possesses just four IR active modes, facilitating its detection in a young planetary12 and reflection nebula.13 Changes to the symmetry upon ionisation,14 protonation,15 or addition of other atoms to the outside of the C60 cage16,17 lead to significant changes in the IR spectra, and make unambiguous assignment to observational data more challenging.
Prior to 2018, the only purely aromatic molecular structure detected in the interstellar medium (ISM) was benzene, and this was achieved via association of just one IR feature at 14.85 μm to a bending mode.18–21 However, recently, its polar analogue benzonitrile was identified in TMC-122 based on its laboratory rotational spectroscopy.22–26 Follow-up observational studies of the same cloud have revealed the presence of larger aromatic structures such as 1- and 2-cyanonaphthalene.27,28 One motivation for radio-astronomical studies of these cyclic structures is due to the PAH hypothesis29 and the hitherto lack of detection of polycyclic aromatics in the ISM. McGuire et al. suggests that the benzonitrile itself may contribute to the PAH emission through its IR active CH- and CN-stretching modes near 3.3 and 4.5 μm, respectively.22,30,31
Recently, measurement of the dissociation rate of cyanonaphthalene cations at the DESIREE storage ring facility were reported.32 These experiments revealed a high stability of 1-CNN+ against dissociation, attributed to inverse internal conversion and recurrent fluorescence. This competitive route for radiative relaxation led Stockett et al. to suggest that the general consensus that small PAHs will undergo dissociation in the diffuse ISM should be revisited.32 This motivated a study of the electronic absorptions of 1-CNN+ in the laboratory under conditions relevant for comparison with astronomical observations of diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs).33 The D2 ← D0 electronic transition possesses an oscillator strength f = 0.075 and has an origin band at 7343 Å, falling in the wavelength region of interest for the DIBs. In observational data, the spectral region is polluted by telluric water lines and the study concludes that space-based observations are require to assess its abundance in the diffuse ISM.
In terms of astronomical observations in the IR, aside from the aromatic CH-stretching wavelength, the intermediate/mid-IR region from 1–5 μm is less explored than the >5 μm spectral range. However, emission bands at 4.4 and 4.65 μm have been reported originating from the ionisation bar in Orion and suggested to be caused by deuterated PAHs, whose CD-stretching modes fall in this part of the spectrum.34 An alternative explanation for emission at this wavelength may be the CN-stretch of PAHs containing cyano-groups, such as benzonitrile or cyanonaphthalene. This proposal is of contemporary interest given their identification in TMC-1 as mentioned above. Surprisingly, there appears to be a paucity of gas-phase laboratory data on the mid-IR spectra of cyano-substituted PAHs necessary to test this hypothesis. Spectra of argon tagged benzonitrile cation in the CH-stretching region were reported in ref. 35. More recently, vibrational spectra of neon tagged benzonitrile cation, and fragments produced by electron impact, were reported in ref. 36.
The charge state of PAHs is known to significantly affect the absolute and relative intensities of their infra-red active modes. For example, compared to their neutral counterparts, the intensities of the CH-stretch in PAH cations is drastically reduced, while the in-plane CC-stretching and CH-bending modes are stronger.37
In this contribution, low temperature gas-phase vibrational spectra of 1-CNN+–He are reported in the region 3.1–5 μm. These data were obtained following buffer gas cooling in a cryogenic ion trapping apparatus. Section 2.1 describes the experimental methods, and computational procedures are outlined in Section 2.2. The experimental data and its comparison with theory is presented in Section 3. Finally, the astrochemical implications are given in Section 4, and conclusions in Section 5.
The ion cloud was irradiated by an OPO/OPA (LaserVision) pumped by a Nd:YAG (Amplitude Laser Inc.), producing nanosecond pulses at a repetition rate of 10 Hz. The ion cloud was exposed to 4 pulses of radiation per trapping cycle (1 Hz), with energies up to 20 mJ per pulse. Mid-IR radiation was focused into the ion trapping apparatus by a CaF2 positive meniscus lens (f = 1 m). The ion counts on the m/z 157 channel were detected on alternate trapping cycles with (Ni) and without (N0) interaction with OPO/OPA radiation. Exposure to radiation was controlled using a mechanical shutter. The detected attenuation was corrected for the number of background ions (NB) on this mass channel that did not dissociate following excitation of the D2 ← D0 electronic transition with high laser power as described in ref. 33. The presented spectra are corrected for changes to the OPO/OPA power with wavelength and plotted in terms of the relative cross-sections, σrel = −ln((Ni − NB)/(N0 − NB))/Φ, where Φ is the relative OPO/OPA fluence. To generate the spectra plotted in this article, the number of ions at each wavelength was averaged over 20 trapping cycles, and spectra are typically averaged over 5 individual scans.
To determine the accurate mid-IR wavelength of the OPA (2.128–5 μm), the wavelengths of the Nd:YAG and OPO signal output were recorded with a wavemeter (HighFiness Gmbh). The OPO/OPA was operated in two different modes: with a linewidth of either 1.7 or 3.7 cm−1, as noted in the Figure captions. Band maxima are reported with an uncertanity of ±0.8 cm−1.
All stick spectra were convoluted by a Lorentzian lineshape function with 4 cm−1 full width at half maximum (FWHM). All calculations used the Gaussian 16 software package installed at Eddie, the University's research compute cluster.41
Quantum chemical calculations were performed at the DFT level, and compared to the experimental IR spectrum in the bottom panel of Fig. 1. The computed IR spectrum of the bare ion is in good agreement with the experimental data: it places the CN-stretch at 2227.6 cm−1 and predicts a number of transitions in a narrow frequency range leading to CH-stretches at 3085.1, 3099.1 and 3109.1 cm−1. The theoretically projected ratio between the intensity of the vibrational modes is consistent with the experimentally observed IR bands.
In Table 1, the experimental and convoluted theoretical band positions are listed. Shifts between experiment and theory in the order of 10 cm−1 are found for the CN-stretch, while those for the CH features are up to a factor of 2 larger and opposite in sign.
Experiment | B3LYP/6-311+G(d,p) | |
---|---|---|
1-CNN+–He | 1-CNN+ | 1-CNN+–He |
2214.7 | 2227.6 | 2229.2 |
2226.7 | — | — |
— | 3085.1 | 3082.2 |
3114.6 | 3099.1 | 3096.6 |
3131.1 | 3109.1 | 3108.0 |
In Fig. 2, the vibrational bands of the 1-CNN+–He complex are shown with higher spectral resolution by using 10−5 μm step size in the measurements. The top panel shows the absorptions originating from the CH-stretching modes. Besides the peaks at 3114.6 cm−1 and 3131.1 cm−1, a shoulder appears in the lower frequency region, and there may be a weaker band in between the two notable peaks. Due to the low signal-to-noise ratio in this part of the experimental spectrum, it is difficult to assess whether they are real IR features. Additionally, the CN-stretch is measured using a narrower bandwidth setting of the OPO (1.7 cm−1) and plotted on the bottom panel of Fig. 2. The experimental data are fitted with Lorentzian functions as these best reproduce the experimental shape. This may be due to lifetime broadening in the dissociation process. The fit places the stronger band at 2214.7 cm−1 with 4.0 cm−1 FWHM, and a weaker peak appears at 2226.7 cm−1 with 4.5 cm−1 FWHM. Additional anharmonic calculations were performed to analyse the vibrational features that cannot be explained by harmonic calculations. The side band of the CN-stretch could be attributed to anharmonic effects, like combination modes of fundamental vibrations or overtones. We explored this option as shown in the ESI.† The calculated combination modes of 1-CNN+ cannot explain the low intensity shoulder of the CN-stretch observed in the experiment. Alternatively, as it has been suggested for weak side bands in earlier reports on the IR spectrum of the aniline+− Ar complex,42 a mode arising from the van der Waals interaction between the tag and the bare ion could be responsible for the peak at 2226.7 cm−1. Higher level anharmonic calculations on the He complex may give further insight.
To investigate the effect of He tagging on the vibrational spectrum, measurements were performed with 2 He atoms attached to 1-CNN+. For this experiment, the m/z 161 mass channel was monitored. In Fig. 3, the CN-stretch is plotted using one and two He tags. From 1-CNN+–He to 1-CNN+–He2 a blueshift of 0.4 cm−1 is observed. Helium atom as a tag is known to perturb the spectrum of the bare ion relatively mildly when compared to other tags such as Ar or Ne.43,44 If the shift is linear with the number of He atoms, this would imply that the bare 1-CNN+ absorbs at 2214.3 cm−1.
The effect of He tagging is further studied theoretically and the vibrational spectra of the bare ion and complex are plotted in Fig. S3, ESI.† The vibrational spectrum of 1-CNN+–He was calculated at the same level of theory as the bare ion, but in order to account for the weak interaction between the He atom and 1-CNN+, empirical dispersion was added manually to the computation. The He atom and 1-CNN+ ion can have many possible configurations, but in this article we only present the lowest energy isomer. The geometry optimized structure of the complex is presented in Fig. S3, ESI.† The He is likely to be placed on top of the aromatic ring containing the N atom. Higher energy configurations include the He placed on top of the other aromatic ring and in the molecular plane. Interestingly, placing the He atom in the vicinity of the N atom does not produce a stable configuration. We notice a slight blue shift (1.6 cm−1) in the CN-stretch band position from 1-CNN+ to 1-CNN+–He as an effect from the He tag. The computed shift is slightly larger but the same order of magnitude as the experimental value of 0.4 cm−1 observed from 1-CNN+–He to 1-CNN+–He2 in Fig. 3. Further quantitative analysis of the shift using theoretical methods is beyond the scope of this study.
Based on a recent study by Stockett et al., small cationic cyano-PAHs may also be able to survive in the ISM by stabilisation due to recurrent fluorescence, a radiative relaxation process via ergodically populated electronic excited states.32
The characteristic absorption range for the CN fundamental transition of neutral aromatic nitriles has been reported in literature as 4.46–4.50 μm.48 In contrast, harmonic DFT calculations of cyano-PAHs in neutral and cationic forms with 2–3 aromatic rings have predicted the CN-stretch falls in the 4.74–4.79 μm region, as catalogued in the NASA Ames PAH IR Spectroscopic Database.49–51 In the case of large PAHs containing 35–45 C atoms, with a singly-substituted CN group, the CN-stretch has been proposed to fall in the 4.34–4.39 μm range.52
There is a drastic change in the vibrational spectrum of 1-CNN upon ionisation. The calculated vibrational spectrum of 1-CNN+ is compared to 1-CNN in the ESI.† As highlighted in the Introduction, in the case of 1-CNN, we observe a relatively intense CH-stretch and weak CC-stretching features. Compared to 1-CNN, the already weak CH-stretch is halved in intensity in the case of 1-CNN+. The CN-stretch is a prominent peak in both spectra, however, it is twice as intense in the spectrum of ionised 1-CNN.
The gas-phase laboratory measurements presented here indicate the CN-stretch for 1-CNN+ is at 4.516 μm, outside the predicted wavelength range for CN-stretching frequencies. Observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) are now facilitating higher-resolution measurements in the 1–5 μm region.52 There is evidence of emission features in the 4.51–4.52 μm region in observation toward young planetary nebulae BD+303639 and NGC7027.52 In previous studies, some strong emission lines in this region were observed from M17 and from Orion Bar.34,53 It should be noted that our measurement concern the absorption of cold 1-CNN+–He, and therefore differences between the band profiles of this complex and emission of UV pumped 1-CNN+ are expected. See, for example, modelling an infrared emission band attributed to PAHs, reported recently in ref. 54.
One complication toward unambiguous CN-stretch assignments are the aromatic and aliphatic CD-stretching modes that have been calculated at 4.30–4.54 μm and 4.54–4.75 μm, respectively.53 Observation of a 4.65 μm band in M17 is attributed to CD-stretch, but interestingly no companion CD-stretch that has been predicted to be at 4.40 μm is seen.34,52 PAHs are predicted to become enriched with deuterium via H-exchange reactions in UV-rich environments due to the lower zero-point energy of C–D bonds compared to C–H bonds.55 However, in CSE and PNe regions, deuterium will be in low abundance since it is readily consumed by stars during nucleosynthesis.34,56 Therefore, emission features in the 4.5 μm region from measurements in CSE and PPNe regions, where deuterium is in low abundance, would likely be dominated by cyano-PAHs rather than deuterated-PAHs.
The CH-stretch peaks for 1-CNN+ have been observed between 3.19–3.22 μm. This is in contrast to the location of the CH-stretch of other PAHs which has been located at 3.29 μm.52 Previous theoretical studies comparing neutral and cationic PAHs have shown changes in both the intensity and peak positions of the CH-stretch.57 In the laboratory spectrum, the CH-stretches of 1-CNN+ appear as very weak features that would be difficult to distinguish in an observational data set and are probably not worth investigating further for detection.
In the astronomical context, the CN-stretch of nitogen containing PAH derivatives could be responsible for IR features in the emission spectra observed by JWST in PAH-rich regions in the 1–5 μm region.52 Previous studies predicted the CN-stretch of small cyano-PAHs in the 4.34–4.39 μm wavelength range.52 In this contribution, we show that for low temperature, gaseous 1-CNN+ the wavelength of the CN-stretch is in fact at 4.516 μm. The peak position coincides with the frequency range predicted for CD-stretches of deuterium containing aromatic molecules. If cyano-PAHs are responsible for emission attributed previously to deuterated PAHs, it would explain the absence of aromatic CD-stretches in observational studies.
Therefore, this may motivate further studies of the mid-IR spectrum of PNe, in particular the region of 4.51–4.52 μm where the CN-stretch frequency has been shown to be the dominant feature of the mid-IR spectrum of 1-CNN+.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3cp05784d |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2024 |