Open Access Article
Wen-Hao
Li
a,
Meng-Yao
Niu
a,
Yi-Yun
Zhu
a,
Man
Zhang
a,
Hao-Yu
Gao
d,
Xin-Chao
Zhang
a,
Bo
Yang
*a,
Donghui
Wei
*a and
Xuenian
Chen
*abc
aCollege of Chemistry, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, Henan 450001, China. E-mail: yangbohy@zzu.edu.cn; donghuiwei@zzu.edu.cn; xuenian_chen@zzu.edu.cn
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Henan Key Laboratory of Boron Chemistry and Advanced Materials, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang, Henan 453007, China
cState Key Laboratory of Coordination Chemistry, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, China
dCollege of Science, Henan Agricultural University, Zhengzhou, Henan 450002, China
First published on 4th December 2025
The precise modulation of photophysical properties and elucidation of fluorescence mechanisms are paramount challenges for organic optoelectronic materials. Herein, we present a strategy for achieving robust fluorescence tuning from blue (462 nm) to near-infrared (677 nm) by accurately positioning electron-withdrawing groups relative to phenothiazine donors in cyanobenzene–phenothiazine derivatives, as well as adjusting molecular conformations, noncovalent interactions, and the interplays of aggregation behaviors. Crystallographic analysis and theoretical calculations revealed that 4-phenothiazino-isophthaliconitrile (4-PTZIPN) achieves both the highest solid-state fluorescence quantum yield (39.7%) and the longest fluorescence lifetime (1.26 µs) among the series, which is attributed to J-aggregation sustained by multiple intermolecular interactions. The conformation and rigidified non-canonical J-aggregation suppressed non-radiative decay pathways, leading to a significant increase in the quantum yield of 2,4,6-triphenothiazinobenzonitrile (1CN3PTZ) and a substantial extension of its fluorescence lifetime from 761.47 ns in the solid-state to 1.10 µs. Notably, 2,4,6-triphenothiazino-isophthaliconitrile (2CN3PTZ) demonstrates a pronounced bathochromic shift to 677 nm, driven by its helical columnar packing, which is orchestrated by cooperative π–π, dipole–dipole, and C–H⋯S interactions. This work not only elucidated the structure–photophysical relationships within the cyano-phenothiazine system but also provided a conformation-aggregation dual regulation strategy for the design of innovative organic optoelectronic materials through molecular engineering.
The flexible butterfly-like conformations of phenothiazine enable dynamic control of molecular planarity and packing, and its electron-rich nature confers exceptional charge transport capabilities, resulting in diverse applications across chemical sensing,11 organic optoelectronics,12 bioimaging,13–16 organic photovoltaics,17–21 and organocatalysis.22–37 The cyano group, serving as an electron acceptor, not only participates in the conjugated system through its π* antibonding orbitals to lower the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) energy level,3,38–42 thereby enhancing intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) but also enables precise molecular assembly via directional dipole–dipole interactions (e.g., C
N⋯H–C, C
N⋯π).43–46 To our knowledge, only a few literature reports describe the molecular fluorescence of 4-CN-PTH,47–52 and no studies have extended to investigate structures with increased numbers of donor–acceptor pairs and their properties. In this work, based on the o-PTZBN (1) molecular framework, we maintained the adjacent relative positioning of cyano and phenothiazine groups on the central benzene ring to design and synthesize a series of cyanobenzene phenothiazine derivatives by systematically increasing the total number of adjacent donor–acceptor pairs. Combining X-ray diffraction and photophysical characterization, we implemented a “dual-control strategy for conformation and packing” to achieve full-spectrum visible-light emission in both solution and solid states. Furthermore, we systematically investigated the structure–property relationship between molecular packing modes and fluorescence performance of such D–A systems in rigid crystalline states, providing new insights for structure-guided luminescence regulation (Fig. 1).
Solubility profiling showed complete dissolution of all derivatives 1–12 in nonpolar solvents (dichloromethane, chloroform, toluene) and polar aprotic solvents (acetonitrile, DMSO, DMF), but insolubility in protic solvents (acetic acid, methanol, ethanol). UV-vis absorption spectra of 1-12 in toluene revealed distinct absorption peaks at 305 nm (1), 308 nm (2), 315 nm (3), 320 nm (4), 305 nm (5), 298 nm (6), 294 nm (7), 296 nm (8), 284 nm (9), 357 nm (10), 371 nm (11), and 371 nm (12), suggesting that substituent groups, positions, and quantities profoundly alter optical properties (Fig. S107). To further study their optical properties in solution and in ICT, we measured the fluorescence spectra in various solvents with the same concentration (Fig. S123 and S124) and in toluene with different concentrations (Fig. S125 and S126). Notably, these compounds exhibit significant fluorescence emission only in toluene (under 365 nm UV light). Specifically, in dilute toluene solutions (1 × 10−6 M), only short-wavelength emission peaks (410–420 nm) are observed; however, as the concentration increases (>1 × 10−4 M), long-wavelength emission peaks become dominant. Thus, we conclude that the full-spectrum emission of these compounds in toluene originates from their aggregation behavior. Their maximum fluorescence emission in toluene solution showed bathochromic shifts across a broad range from 503 to 651 nm (Fig. 2a and b), which further confirms the tunability of their structure–activity relationship. Among them, 9 with the highest density of interdigitated donor–acceptor alternations exhibit the most significant emission red-shift.
The Lippert–Mataga plot (Fig. 3) reveals that the solvent-dependent Stokes shift of all derivatives correlates with the solvent orientation polarizability (Δf), where the slope directly reflects the magnitude of the dipole moment difference (Δµ) between the excited state and the ground state. Specifically, PTZBNs (1–3), PTZIPNs (7–9), and PTHBNs (4–6) exhibit comparable slopes, respectively, indicating that derivatives within each series possess similar Δµ due to consistent charge transfer pathways mediated by their conjugated frameworks. In contrast, the PTHIPNs (10–12) series exhibits distinct slope variations, with compound 12, which has a larger molecular size due to the introduction of three PTH moieties on its central dicyanobenzene ring, displaying the lowest slope. This divergence arises because the addition of these three PTH moieties fails to enhance Δµ effectively, as the phenylene bridging group in PTHIPNs may not participate in excited-state electron transfer, thereby restricting the extension of charge delocalization. This constraint prevents an increase in the number of phenothiazine units from amplifying the dipole moment difference, thereby leading to the anomalous slope behavior of 12 within the PTHIPN series. Additionally, a greater number of phenothiazine and cyano groups correlates with a larger Stokes displacement, consistent with the enhanced solvent polarity response induced by stronger intramolecular charge transfer.
Despite comparable emission wavelengths across the series, all synthesized compounds exhibited low solution-phase quantum yields in air-saturated toluene (φ = 0.3–7.5%), indicating efficient nonradiative decay pathways. However, a consistent enhancement in φ was observed when they were measured under a nitrogen atmosphere (0.7–19.4%, Table S14). This collective improvement in photophysical properties under oxygen-free conditions indicates that the emission pathway is susceptible to oxygen quenching, likely involving triplet states. Fluorescence lifetime in toluene ranged from 2.11 to 19.35 ns (Fig. S108–S122).
Theoretical studies were performed using a toluene solution model of cyanobenzene–phenothiazine fluorescent molecules, with the PBE1PBE method employed for structural optimization and TD-DFT calculations under the IEFPCM solvation model. Ground-state optimization was completed at the 6-31G(d,p) basis set level, while excited-state TD-DFT calculations adopted the 6-311G(d,p) basis set. As shown in Fig. 4, the HOMO/LUMO orbital distribution reveals a clear intramolecular separation, with the HOMO localized on the phenothiazine donor and the LUMO on the cyanobenzene acceptor. This is in direct contrast to difluoroboranyl systems, in which the phenylene spacer acts as a secondary donor.55 In PTHBNs and PTHIPNs, the extended benzene ring, coupled with the cyanobenzene, is predominantly involved in the LUMO, exhibiting an electron-withdrawing nature. This demonstrates that the electronic role of a π-spacer is not intrinsic but is critically determined by the chemical environment. Notably, in 3, the para-substituted quasi-axial conformation of the phenothiazine unit contributes to the LUMO but not the HOMO, undercoring the essential role of molecular conformation in modulating the electronic properties.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 The HOMO/LUMO of cyanobenzene phenothiazine derivatives 1-12, calculated by the DFT method at the 6-31G(d,p) basis set level of theory. | ||
A key computational finding is the consistent decrease in both the HOMO–LUMO energy gap and the S0 → S1 vertical excitation energy with an increasing number of donor–acceptor (D–A) pairs. This trend directly correlates with and explains the experimentally observed redshift in the fluorescence emission spectra. Furthermore, the energy gaps between the first singlet and triplet excited states (ΔEST) were found to be less than 0.3 eV for all compounds except for structure 12 (Table S16). This small ΔEST supports the idea that triplet states can undergo reverse intersystem crossing (RISC). Although the lifetime data in toluene solution are not consistent with TADF, the solid-state packing may potentially enable a thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) mechanism.
Additional analyses validated our computational approach. The natural transition orbital (NTO) analysis of the excited state provided a clearer picture of the actual orbital contributions to the transition, distinguishing them from the simple HOMO–LUMO picture (Table S15). Moreover, the ultraviolet absorption spectrum simulated from the optimized ground-state structures successfully reproduced the experimental trend (Fig. S172). The above theoretical results verify that increasing the number of adjacent D–A pairs on the central benzene ring enhances the ICT effect, narrows the energy gap, and ultimately leads to a redshift in the emission spectrum.
Solid-state fluorescence characterization revealed pronounced structure-dependent emission tuning. Analysis of powdered samples revealed marked variations in photophysical properties, governed by the proportion and connectivity of the PTZ and cyano groups. Specifically, structural modifications induced bathochromic shifts across a broad emission range from 462 to 677 nm (Fig. 5, S128, S131 and S132). CIE coordinate analysis (Fig. S136) categorized the compounds into three distinct chromatic groups, namely derivatives 5, 1, and 4 emitted in the blue-green region (λem = 463–489 nm), while compounds 7, 2, 6, 3, 10, and 11 displayed yellow fluorescence (λem = 515–579 nm). Notably, 12, 8, and 9 exhibited orange-to-red emission (λem = 597–677 nm), marking the longest wavelengths within the series. A notable bathochromic shift emerged as the number of cyano substituents increased while maintaining the PTZ donor counts, indicative of reduced S1-state energy levels.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Solid-state maximum emission wavelengths and fluorescence images of cyanobenzene phenothiazine derivatives 1–12. | ||
Varying PTZ donor units while maintaining cyanobenzene acceptors also induced progressive bathochromic shifts in emission wavelengths for all derivatives except 4 and 5 (Δλem = 50–120 nm), with the number of PTZ groups serving as a critical regulator of emission wavelength. Solid-state quantum yields (ΦF) spanned 0.9% (1), 2.9% (2), 4% (3), 1.8% (4), 5% (5), 18.6% (6), 39.7% (7), 2.0% (8), 2.0% (9), 18.1% (10), 15.8% (11) and 20.6% (12) respectively (Fig. S135). As evidenced by photophysical evaluations, structural extension via the phenylene π-conjugation bridge between phenothiazine donors and cyanobenzene acceptors resulted in a 2- to 10-fold enhancement of quantum yields compared to non-extended derivatives. However, the diminished fluorescence quantum yields of cyanobenzene phenothiazine derivatives in both solution and the solid phase may be attributed to intramolecular/intermolecular resonance energy transfer,56–59 with enhanced efficiency in the condensed phase due to molecular packing.
Fluorescence lifetime measurements of solid-state samples revealed a broad distribution spanning 2.70 ns to 1261.32 ns. As shown in Table 1, the incorporation of PTZ or PTH units into the cyanobenzene system significantly enhanced the fluorescence lifetimes: the lifetime of 1 increased from 11.00 ns to 761.47 ns for 3, and that of 4 increased from 2.70 ns to 466.73 ns for 6. In the 1,3-dicyanobenzene system, the introduction of PTH units also improved lifetimes—10 increased from 265.92 ns to 725.71 ns. However, the incorporation of PTZ units in this system drastically reduced the lifetimes, dropping sharply from 1261.32 ns (7) to 3.52 ns (9). Notably, compounds 2, 3, 6, 7, 10, 11, and 12 displayed distinct dual-exponential decays, suggesting TADF properties (Fig. S138–S151). On the other hand, the lifetime of 2 significantly increased from 501 ns in the powder state to 5240.72 ns in the crystalline state, demonstrating the crucial influence of intermolecular interactions and molecular packing on fluorescence lifetimes. For the other compounds, the variation trend of crystalline-state lifetimes with molecular structure was consistent with that in the powder state (Fig. S152–S165).
| Compound | λ em (nm) | φ F (%) | τ (ns) | K r (s−1) | K nr (s−1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a The λex of cyanobenzene phenothiazine derivatives 1–12 is 370 nm. Radiative decay rate constant kr = φ/τ. Nonradiative decay rate constant knr = (1 − φ)/τ. | |||||
| o-PTZBN (1) | 482 | 0.9 | 11.00 | 8.1 × 105 | 9.0 × 107 |
| 2,6-2PTZBN (2) | 529 | 2.9 | 501.50 | 5.78 × 104 | 1.94 × 106 |
| 2,4,6-3PTZBN (3) | 545 | 4.0 | 761.47 | 5.25 × 104 | 1.26 × 106 |
| o-PTHBN (4) | 489 | 1.8 | 2.70 | 6.67 × 106 | 3.64 × 108 |
| 2,6-2PTHBN (5) | 463 | 5.0 | 3.39 | 1.48 × 107 | 2.80 × 108 |
| 2,4,6-3PTHBN (6) | 544 | 18.6 | 466.73 | 3.98 × 105 | 1.74 × 106 |
| 4-PTZIPN (7) | 515 | 39.7 | 1261.32 | 3.15 × 105 | 4.8 × 105 |
| 4,6-2PTZIPN (8) | 630 | 2.0 | 99.41 | 2.0 × 105 | 9.86 × 106 |
| 2,4,6-3PTZIPN (9) | 677 | 2.0 | 3.52 | 5.68 × 105 | 2.78 × 108 |
| 4-PTHIPN (10) | 570 | 18.1 | 265.92 | 6.8 × 105 | 3.08 × 106 |
| 4,6-2PTHIPN (11) | 579 | 15.8 | 589.20 | 2.68 × 105 | 1.43 × 106 |
| 2,4,6-3PTHIPN (12) | 597 | 20.6 | 725.71 | 2.84 × 105 | 1.09 × 106 |
Characterization of crystal structures provides critical insights into molecular conformations, noncovalent interactions, and packing motifs—key factors that together regulate the photophysical properties of organic luminescent materials. For such systems, quantum yield is determined not only by intrinsic molecular structure but also by conformational features and intermolecular arrangements in condensed phases (crystal/powder). Specifically, the rigid framework and dense packing in defect-free crystals impose spatial constraints that limit molecular vibrational/rotational motions, stabilizing thermodynamically favored conformations and suppressing nonradiative relaxation pathways—this partially modulates fluorescence lifetimes and φF.60–62 In this study, X-ray diffraction (XRD) confirmed the structural integrity of all derivatives (Fig. S95–S106), and crystals exhibited distinct φF values compared to their powdered counterparts (Fig. S136).
Canonical J-aggregation is characterized by a head-to-tail dipole alignment of chromophores, which typically results in red-shifted emission, a narrower spectral bandwidth, and enhanced molar absorption coefficients. In contrast, non-canonical J-aggregation motifs deviate from this strict dipole orientation while retaining the aggregation-induced emission enhancement feature associated with J-aggregates. For the cyanobenzene phenothiazine system, 7 maintains high photoluminescent performance in both powdered (φF = 39.7%, τ = 1261.32 ns) and crystalline states (φF = 16.5%, τ = 1151.94 ns), achieving its maximum quantum yield through J-aggregation sustained by four cooperative intermolecular interactions via C–H⋯S contacts (2.976 Å), cyano C
N⋯H–C dipole alignments (2.602–2.705 Å), and edge-to-face π–π stacking (2.875 Å), as structurally resolved in Fig. 6.63,64
Notably, 3 exhibited a large fluorescence lifetime of 1.10 µs, and a doubled quantum yield, with φF increasing from 4.0% in powder to 8.0% in crystal. This phenomenon is attributed to a three-pronged intermolecular interactions assembly comprising PTZ-directed π–π stacking with offset face-to-face distances of 3.381–3.451 Å and edge-to-face distances of 2.879–2.897 Å, cyano C
N⋯H–C dipole alignment at 2.531 Å, and C–H⋯S orbital overlap ranging from 2.999 to 3.323 Å (Fig. 7c). The weak intermolecular forces drive a non-canonical J-aggregation motif with a densely packed pattern (Fig. 7b), which rigidifies molecular conformations to suppress nonradiative decay while promoting radiative recombination,65 thereby extending fluorescence lifetimes and elevating quantum yields.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 (a) Enantiomers of structure 3; (b) arrangement pattern of crystal 3 along the (100) direction; (c) intermolecular weak interactions in the crystal 3. | ||
Beyond packing effects, conformational features in molecules also play a critical role in regulating luminescence properties. Specifically, the PTZ unit not only influences but also indicates molecular packing and exhibits stereochemical features, contributing to the facial chirality observed in the system. As shown in Fig. 7a, single-crystal analysis of 3 revealed the coexistence of enantiomers within the unit cell, confirming the existence of chirality. In the unit cell, PTZ moieties display distinct conformational preferences, namely that the para-cyano PTZ adopts a quasi-axial conformation, which is oriented perpendicular to the cyanobenzene plane, while the ortho-cyano PTZ units adopt quasi-equatorial conformations arranged spirally along the same direction. These stereochemical spatial arrangements result in non-superimposable mirror-image pairs, with intrinsic facial chirality from conformation-driven spatial non-overlap.
Derivative 9 (Fig. 8a) was strategically designed by introducing an additional cyano group on 3. This modification results in a propeller-like molecular architecture, in which all three PTZ units adopt quasi-equatorial conformations, with the sulfur atoms bent uniformly, forming a helical supramolecular assembly (Fig. 8b). As shown in Fig. 8c, the intermolecular edge-to-face π–π stacking (2.848–2.898 Å) between adjacent PTZ moieties and dipole–dipole interactions (2.397–2.832 Å) involving dichloromethane solvent molecules drive columnar cross-stacking. Each column exhibits a six-molecule helical repeat unit forming the P61 space group, where successive molecules rotate 60° along the column axis, completing a 360° cycle after six units. Notably, nitrogen atoms of cyano groups trace intertwined double–helical pathways (Fig. 8b). As shown in Fig. S82, inter-columnar edge-to-face π–π interactions (2.786–2.862 Å) and solvent-mediated dipole alignments (2.397–2.626 Å) further stabilize this columnar helical staggered packing, enhancing transition dipole coupling to promote irradiative decay.66
In terms of fluorescence lifetime, the crystalline state of 9 exhibits a shorter lifetime (3.52 ns) compared to its powder state (11.48 ns). This trend of reduced lifetime in the crystalline phase may be closely related to its unique molecular conformation. Specifically, the adoption of quasi-equatorial conformations by all PTZ units introduces significant steric hindrance to molecular rotation and vibration. Such constrained motion likely narrows the energy gaps between adjacent electronic states, facilitating nonradiative decay pathways through enhanced state mixing. Additionally, the compact columnar helical staggered packing strengthens intermolecular interactions, which may further promote nonradiative energy dissipation via intramolecular vibration–lattice vibration coupling and direct intermolecular energy transfer.67 In contrast, the powder state features looser, more disordered packing with weaker intermolecular interactions and reduced steric constraints on PTZ units, leading to less efficient nonradiative decay and thus a longer lifetime.
To place our findings in the context of existing research, we compared the basic photophysical properties of our non-doped cyanobenzene–phenothiazine dyes with several established high-performance emitters, as summarized in Table 2. While impressive efficiencies have been reported for doped phenothiazine systems68,69 and those incorporating ortho-substituents for conformational control,51 the performance of non-doped phenothiazine donors is highly dependent on the overall molecular structure and the strength of the electron acceptor. For example, when comparing our compounds with the benchmark carbazole-isophthalonitrile series (e.g., 4CzIPN and m-3CzIPN)40,70 and other phenothiazine-based analogues (e.g., 4-PTZBN and Diarylboryl-PTZ),71,72 our derivatives exhibit competitive bathochromic-shift maximum emission wavelength, quantum yield, and emission lifetime. These comparisons underscore that our molecular engineering strategy—focusing on the systematic increase of adjacent D–A pairs and precise conformation-aggregation dual control—effectively enhances the luminescence efficiency and stability.
| Compound | λ em | φ (%) | τ p (ns) | τ d (µs) | k r (107 s−1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Photoluminescence quantum efficiency of the solution sample before/after Ar bubbling. b Measured in toluene. c Measured in film, τphosphorescence = 487.7 µs. d Solid-state luminescence properties. | |||||
| 4CzIPNb | 507 | 21/86 | 17.8 | 5.1 | 1.8 |
| m-3CzIPNb | 426 | 12/86 | 7.9 | 26.1 | 1.5 |
| 4-PTZBNc | 513 | — | 4610 | 44.2 | — |
| Diarylboryl-PTZd | 485 | 20 | 5.11 | 5.07 | 3.9 |
The data supporting this article have been included as part of the supplementary information (SI). Supplementary information is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc06095h.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |