Open Access Article
Thi-Kim-Chi Huynh
*ab,
Thi-Hong-An Nguyen†
a,
Cong-Hau Huynh†c,
Xuan-Ngoc Nguyenad,
Thi-Cam-Thu Nguyen
a,
Hoang-Phuc Nguyena,
Anh-Khoa Tonae,
Thanh-Danh Nguyena,
Thi Be Ta Truongc,
Nguyen Thi Thanh Tu
f,
Chien Phuong Trang and
Thi-Kim-Dung Hoang
a
aInstitute of Advanced Technology, Vietnam Academy of Science and Technology, No. 1B, TL29 Street, An Phu Dong Ward, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. E-mail: maihuynh1224@gmail.com
bGraduate University of Science and Technology - Vietnam Academy of Science and Technology, No.18, Hoang Quoc Viet Street, Nghia Do Ward, Hanoi, Vietnam
cGroup of Applied Research in Advanced Materials for Sustainable Development, Faculty of Applied Sciences, Ton Duc Thang University, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
dHo Chi Minh University of Technology-Vietnam National University, Vietnam
eFaculty of Health Sciences, Mekong University, Vinh Long Province, Vietnam
fFaculty of Applied Technology, Van Lang School of Technology, Van Lang University, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
gInstitute for Tropical Technology, Vietnam
First published on 18th May 2026
The discharge of dye-laden effluents from textile industries poses serious environmental and health risks, necessitating the development of efficient and sustainable adsorbents. In this study, a novel bio-based composite adsorbent (SPCA) was rationally designed and fabricated via the valorization of Opuntia dillenii-derived pectin combined with sodium alginate, chitosan, activated carbon, and eco-friendly additives. The composite was synthesized under mild conditions through dual crosslinking, involving Zn2+-mediated ionic coordination and glutaraldehyde-induced covalent bonding, while sodium bicarbonate served as a green pore-forming agent to generate a hierarchical porous structure. Structural characterization (FT-IR, PXRD, SEM) confirmed the formation of an amorphous, interconnected polymeric network enriched with abundant oxygen- and nitrogen-containing functional groups. BET analysis revealed a well-developed mesoporous architecture with high surface area, and thermal analyses (TGA-DSC) demonstrated enhanced structural stability resulting from synergistic intermolecular interactions. Under optimal conditions (pH 4 and 4 h contact time), SPCA exhibited a maximum adsorption capacity of 18.55 mg g−1 at an initial MO concentration of 200 mg L−1, while achieving 96.0% removal efficiency with a capacity of 14.38 mg g−1 at 150 mg L−1. Kinetic studies indicated that adsorption follows a pseudo-second-order model (R2 = 0.9985), suggesting chemisorption-dominated interactions, and equilibrium data were best described by the Freundlich isotherm (R2 = 0.9945), confirming heterogeneous multilayer adsorption. Notably, SPCA retained 83.62% of its initial adsorption efficiency after six regeneration cycles using ethanol as a benign desorbing solvent. Overall, this work demonstrates an effective strategy for transforming underutilized cactus biomass into a reusable, environmentally benign adsorbent for dye-contaminated wastewater treatment.
000 tons of synthetic dyes are discharged into natural water bodies, posing a serious and persistent threat to aquatic ecosystems and human health.1 Since the introduction of the first synthetic dye in 1856, the rapid expansion of dye manufacturing, particularly driven by the textile, paper, leather, and plastic industries, has led to the large-scale release of highly colored, chemically stable effluents into the environment.2 These dye-containing wastewaters are among the most challenging industrial pollutants to treat due to their complex aromatic structures, high visibility even at low concentrations, and resistance to biodegradation. Once released, dyes significantly impair water quality by reducing light penetration, suppressing photosynthetic activity, and disturbing the ecological balance of aquatic systems.3
Beyond their ecological impact, synthetic dyes have been widely reported to exert detrimental effects on human health.4 Prolonged exposure to dye-contaminated water has been associated with kidney, liver, and brain dysfunction, central nervous system disorders, contact dermatitis, allergic reactions, and potential carcinogenicity.5 Among various dye classes, azo dyes constitute the largest group, accounting for more than 70% of global dye production.6 Of particular concern is the fact that approximately 10–15% of azo dyes are lost during synthesis, processing, and application, leading to their uncontrolled release into wastewater streams. Due to the presence of azo (–N
N–) bonds and conjugated aromatic systems, these dyes exhibit high chemical stability and persistence, rendering conventional biological treatment processes largely ineffective.7 Notably, methyl orange (MO), a representative anionic azo dye widely used in textile dyeing, printing, and analytical applications, is frequently detected in industrial effluents and aquatic environments.8 Owing to its sulfonate group and extended aromatic structure, MO exhibits high water solubility and strong resistance to biodegradation, while its reductive cleavage may generate toxic aromatic amines.9 Consequently, the development of efficient, cost-effective, and environmentally benign strategies for azo dye removal remains an urgent scientific and technological challenge.
In recent decades, adsorption has emerged as one of the most promising approaches for dye removal owing to its operational simplicity, high removal efficiency, adaptability to a wide range of pollutants, and minimal generation of secondary waste.10,11 However, the widespread application of adsorption technology is still limited by the high cost, limited regenerability, and environmental concerns associated with conventional adsorbents such as commercial activated carbon. This has prompted increasing research interest in the development of sustainable, bio-based adsorbent materials derived from renewable resources. Natural polysaccharides, including pectin, chitosan, and alginate, have attracted considerable attention as environmentally friendly alternatives for wastewater treatment. These biopolymers are abundant, biodegradable, non-toxic, and rich in functional groups such as hydroxyl (–OH), carboxyl (–COOH), and amino (–NH2) moieties, which can interact strongly with dye molecules through electrostatic attraction, hydrogen bonding, and other physicochemical mechanisms.12,13 Among them, pectin has demonstrated notable potential in the adsorption of heavy metals and organic pollutants, as well as in the fabrication of biodegradable films and gels.14–16 Nevertheless, the direct use of single-component biopolymers often suffers from drawbacks such as poor mechanical strength, limited surface area, and insufficient stability under varying environmental conditions.
To overcome these limitations, composite materials based on natural polysaccharides have been widely proposed. By integrating multiple biopolymers with complementary properties and incorporating porous fillers, composite adsorbents can achieve enhanced surface area, improved mechanical robustness, and increased density of active adsorption sites.17,18 Importantly, such composites also offer the advantage of regenerability, allowing adsorbents to be reused over multiple adsorption–desorption cycles. This regenerability not only reduces operational costs but also significantly improves the economic and environmental sustainability of adsorption-based wastewater treatment systems, aligning with the principles of green chemistry and circular economy.
Despite these advances, the selection of sustainable and underutilized biomass sources for pectin extraction and composite fabrication remains an important research gap. Cactus plants, particularly Opuntia dillenii, represent a promising yet largely unexplored resource in this context. Opuntia dillenii is a cladode-type cactus that thrives in arid and semi-arid regions, requires minimal agricultural input, and is widely available in many parts of the world. The plant is known to contain a high pectin content, making it an attractive candidate for bio-based material development.19 Moreover, the use of cactus-derived pectin offers multiple sustainability advantages, including biodegradability, non-toxicity, and the valorization of low-cost biomass that is often underutilized or discarded.
Although previous studies have investigated pectin extracted from various plant sources for environmental applications,20,21 research focusing on Opuntia dillenii-derived pectin remains scarce. Existing studies on this cactus species have primarily concentrated on phytochemical extraction and biomedical aspects, with very limited exploration of its potential as a functional material for environmental remediation. To the best of our knowledge, no systematic study has yet reported the fabrication of a multi-component composite adsorbent based on Opuntia dillenii pectin combined with other natural polymers and porous additives for dye adsorption, nor has the adsorption mechanism, reusability, and structural stability of such composites been comprehensively evaluated.
The SPCA composite developed in this study holds several compelling advantages over conventional and emerging adsorbents. The primary feedstock – pectin extracted from Opuntia dillenii cladodes-is derived from a fast-growing, drought-tolerant cactus that requires minimal agricultural input and is widely available in tropical and semi-arid regions, constituting a virtually zero-cost and abundantly renewable raw material.19 This approach directly parallels the philosophy of industrial waste valorization advocated in zeolite–activated carbon (Ze–AC) composites, where lithium–silicon-powder (LSP)-a solid by-product generated at approximately 10 tons per ton of lithium carbonate produced—was repurposed as the primary silica–alumina source to avoid resource waste and landfill disposal.22 However, unlike LSP-derived Ze–AC, which requires acid pretreatment with hydrochloric acid, alkaline hydrothermal synthesis at 100 °C in NaOH solution, and multi-step washing procedures, the fabrication of SPCA proceeds entirely under mild aqueous conditions at ambient temperature via ionotropic gelation, without recourse to corrosive reagents, elevated temperatures, or pressurized reactors. The remaining components of SPCA – sodium alginate, chitosan, glycerol, and sodium bicarbonate-are either naturally occurring biopolymers or inexpensive commodity chemicals of low toxicity, further minimizing the overall material cost.12,13 The environmental contrast becomes even more pronounced when SPCA is compared with metal–organic framework (MOF)-based adsorbents. Although MOFs exhibit outstanding porosity and tunability, their large-scale synthesis remains critically hampered by the use of toxic organic solvents such as DMF or DEF, corrosive metal precursors including metal nitrates and chlorides, and energy-intensive solvothermal conditions requiring pressurized reactors operating above the solvent boiling point.23 In sharp contrast, SPCA was fabricated without any organic solvent, without environmentally hazardous metal precursors, and under ambient conditions that consume minimal energy, rendering its synthesis process inherently greener and more scalable. The use of sodium bicarbonate – a non-toxic, food-grade pore-forming agent – eliminates hazardous templating agents, while glutaraldehyde was employed at a minimal effective concentration of only 1 wt%, limiting crosslinker-associated toxicity and chemical waste.24–26 Furthermore, the selection of air drying over freeze drying as the final processing step significantly reduces energy consumption while preserving satisfactory adsorption performance, an important consideration for large-scale deployment.27 From an operational standpoint, the demonstrated reusability of SPCA over six consecutive adsorption–desorption cycles using ethanol – a relatively benign and readily recoverable solvent – substantially lowers the long-term operational cost per unit of dye removed, a metric of critical importance in practical wastewater treatment.28 This regeneration stability is comparable to that reported for Ze–AC composites, which retained appreciable adsorption capacity for both NH4+-N and methylene blue across multiple cycles, while avoiding the high-temperature activation and inorganic regenerant protocols typically required for conventional carbon- and zeolite-based systems.29
In this context, the present study aims to bridge this research gap by developing a novel bio-based composite adsorbent derived from Opuntia dillenii pectin for the efficient removal of methyl orange (MO), a representative and widely used azo dye, from aqueous solutions. To the best of our knowledge, the integration of Opuntia dillenii-derived pectin with alginate, chitosan, and activated carbon through a dual ionic–covalent crosslinking strategy has not been previously reported for dye adsorption applications. Specifically, this work focuses on (i) the rational design and green synthesis of a multi-component composite using cactus-derived pectin, complementary biopolymers, and eco-friendly additives; (ii) comprehensive physicochemical characterization to elucidate the structural, thermal, and morphological properties of the composite; (iii) systematic investigation of adsorption performance, kinetics, and isotherm behavior toward MO; and (iv) evaluation of the regenerability and reusability of the composite over multiple adsorption–desorption cycles. By converting underutilized cactus biomass into a functional, reusable adsorbent, this study offers a sustainable approach to azo dye wastewater treatment while advancing biomass valorization and circular bio-based material development. Combined with a solvent-free, mild synthesis process, low chemical consumption, and multi-cycle reusability, SPCA emerges as a cost-effective and environmentally friendly material that meets both sustainability and economic requirements, in alignment with green chemistry and circular economy principles.
:
30 (w/v), adjusted to pH 4.0, and heated at 100 °C for 1 h. Continuous stirring was applied during heating to ensure uniform extraction. After extraction, the mixture was cooled to room temperature and filtered through a cloth filter bag to remove solid residues. The filtrate was subsequently centrifuged to eliminate any remaining insoluble materials. The supernatant was then precipitated with 90% ethanol at an extract-to-ethanol ratio of 1
:
4 (v/v), followed by filtration and washing with 70% ethanol. The obtained pectin was dried at 60 °C for approximately 4 h, finely ground, and stored in glass containers for subsequent use.
Sodium alginate (Alg, C6H7O6Na, purity ≥99%, analytical grade) was supplied as a brown powder by Tianjin Fuchen (China). Chitosan (average molecular weight ≈ 150
000 g mol−1, degree of deacetylation ≥85%, purity ≥95%), sodium bicarbonate (purity ≥99%), activated carbon and methyl orange were obtained from Xilong (China). Glutaraldehyde solution (25 wt%, purity ≥98%) was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (USA). Methyl orange (MO, purity ≥99%) used in adsorption experiments was supplied by Nanjing Reagent (China). Double-distilled water was used throughout all experiments, unless otherwise specified. Unless otherwise stated, all chemicals were of analytical grade and were used as received without further purification.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Schematic representation of the stepwise fabrication process of SPCA composite beads derived from Opuntia dillenii biomass. | ||
![]() | (1) |
The swelling behavior of the prepared material was systematically investigated to evaluate its structural stability and water uptake capacity under different pH environments. Briefly, 0.5 g of the dried sample was accurately weighed and immersed in 50 mL of either 0.1 M HCl solution or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, 0.1 M, pH 7.4). The suspensions were continuously agitated at a stirring speed of 200 rpm at room temperature to ensure uniform contact between the material and the swelling media. The samples were periodically removed from the solution at predetermined time intervals, gently blotted with filter paper to eliminate excess surface liquid, and weighed. The swelling process was monitored until noticeable morphological changes, such as cracking, fragmentation, or structural collapse of the particles, were observed, indicating the limit of structural integrity under the tested conditions. The swelling ratio (SR) was calculated according to the following equation:30
![]() | (2) |
Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy was conducted to identify the surface functional groups of the composites before and after MO adsorption. The spectra were recorded in the wavenumber range of 400–4000 cm−1 using a Bruker Tensor 27 spectrometer. The crystalline structure of the composites was analyzed by X-ray diffraction (XRD) using a Bruker D8 Advance diffractometer with Cu Kα radiation. The XRD patterns were recorded over an appropriate 2θ range, and phase identification was performed based on the diffraction angles and peak positions corresponding to the crystalline and amorphous components of the materials. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed on a Mettler Toledo thermogravimetric analyzer to assess the thermal stability and decomposition behavior of the composites. The measurements were carried out from room temperature to 600 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 under a nitrogen flow. Thermal properties of the composites were evaluated by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Approximately 10 mg of sample was placed in an aluminum crucible and heated from 25 to 300 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 under a nitrogen atmosphere using a differential scanning calorimeter. The specific surface area and pore size distribution of the composites were determined by nitrogen adsorption–desorption measurements using the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) method. The morphology and microstructural features of the composite particles were examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM, JEOL JSM-IT200).
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
The Langmuir isotherm model assumes monolayer adsorption on a structurally homogeneous surface with a finite number of identical adsorption sites, where each site accommodates only one adsorbate molecule and no interactions occur between adjacent adsorbed species. The linearized Langmuir equation is expressed as follows:32
![]() | (5) |
The Freundlich isotherm model is an empirical equation that describes adsorption on heterogeneous surfaces with non-uniform distribution of adsorption energies and the possibility of multilayer adsorption. The linearized Freundlich equation is given by:32
![]() | (6) |
The Temkin isotherm model considers adsorbent–adsorbate interactions and assumes that the heat of adsorption of all molecules in the layer decreases linearly with surface coverage due to these interactions. The linear form of the Temkin equation is expressed as:32
qe = B ln(At) + B ln(Ce)
| (7) |
In which R (8.314 J mol−1 K−1) is the universal gas constant, T (K) is the absolute temperature, and b (J mol−1) represents the Temkin isotherm constant associated with adsorption energy.
The pseudo-first-order (PFO) kinetic model is commonly applied to adsorption systems in which the rate of occupation of adsorption sites is proportional to the number of unoccupied sites, and mass transfer is predominantly governed by surface adsorption rather than intraparticle diffusion. The linearized form of the PFO model is expressed as follows:32
![]() | (8) |
The pseudo-second-order (PSO) kinetic model is widely used to describe adsorption processes controlled by chemisorption mechanisms involving valence forces through electron sharing or exchange between the adsorbent and adsorbate. The linear form of the PSO model is given by:32
![]() | (9) |
The intraparticle diffusion model, proposed by Weber and Morris, is employed to evaluate whether pore diffusion is the rate-limiting step in the adsorption process. This model is described by the following equation:33
| qt = kp·t0,5 + C | (10) |
The Elovich kinetic model is applicable to heterogeneous adsorption systems and is often used to describe chemisorption processes involving surface and intraparticle diffusion simultaneously. The simplified linear form of the Elovich equation is expressed as follows:33
![]() | (11) |
Excessive CO2 generation under these conditions likely induces rapid pore expansion and coalescence, leading to irregular pore morphology, partial pore collapse, and weakened mechanical stability of the beads. Such structural defects elevate diffusion resistance and limit the effective utilization of internal adsorption sites, thereby diminishing overall adsorption efficiency despite increased porosity. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that judicious control of SBC content is essential for effective pore engineering. When optimally dosed, sodium bicarbonate enables the green fabrication of mechanically robust, hierarchically porous composites with superior adsorption performance, highlighting its suitability for sustainable adsorbent design and large-scale environmental applications.
The swelling behavior of SPCA beads was systematically investigated in 0.1 M HCl to simulate acidic environments commonly encountered in dye-containing wastewater. As summarized in Fig. 3, the swelling process followed a characteristic three-stage kinetic profile, reflecting the progressive interaction between the polymer network and the surrounding medium. During the initial stage (0–1.5 h), the beads exhibited rapid swelling, driven by the immediate wetting of the surface and fast penetration of water molecules into the interconnected porous structure. This phase is governed primarily by capillary forces and osmotic pressure gradients, allowing water to diffuse readily into accessible voids and hydrophilic domains. In the intermediate stage (1.5–2.5 h), the swelling rate gradually decreased as internal pores became increasingly saturated. At 2.5 h, the swelling degree reached 159.58%, indicating that the polymer chains had undergone substantial relaxation and expansion. At this stage, resistance from the crosslinked network counterbalanced further water uptake, signaling an approach toward equilibrium swelling. In the final stage (3–4 h), the system attained a stable swelling equilibrium, with swelling ratios fluctuating narrowly between 162.79% and 163.67%, confirming full saturation of the polymer matrix. The stable plateau suggests that the network structure effectively accommodates water without undergoing structural damage or dissolution. The pronounced swelling capacity of SPCA in acidic media can be attributed to its highly hydrophilic polymer framework, composed of sodium alginate and pectin rich in hydroxyl (–OH) and carboxyl (–COOH) groups. Under acidic conditions, partial protonation of carboxyl groups reduces electrostatic repulsion while preserving hydrogen bonding with water molecules, thereby promoting controlled swelling without compromising network stability.38,39 In contrast, when immersed in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, 0.1 M, pH 7.4), the SPCA beads underwent complete dissolution.
PBS represents a salt-rich, mildly alkaline environment in which ionic strength is sufficiently high to disrupt electrostatic interactions and hydrogen bonding within the polymer matrix. Specifically, phosphate ions and sodium ions effectively screen ionic crosslinks and weaken intermolecular associations between polymer chains, leading to the breakdown of the crosslinked network and subsequent bead disintegration.30,40 Overall, these results demonstrate that SPCA beads exhibit excellent mechanical stability and controlled swelling behavior in acidic environments, which is advantageous for the adsorption of anionic dyes such as methyl orange. At the same time, their susceptibility to dissolution in alkaline, high-ionic-strength media highlights a stimuli-responsive behavior, which may be strategically exploited for material regeneration or environmentally benign disposal after use.
The FT-IR spectra provide compelling evidence for the successful integration of alginate, Opuntia dillenii pectin, chitosan, and activated carbon into a chemically interactive composite rather than a simple physical mixture (Fig. 4A). For sodium alginate and cactus pectin, the characteristic broad absorption band in the range of 3400–3440 cm−1 is attributed to the stretching vibration of hydroxyl groups (–OH), arising from abundant polysaccharide chains and adsorbed water molecules.41,42 In the SPCA spectrum, this band becomes noticeably broader and slightly shifted, consistent with observations on Opuntia ficus-indica-based adsorbents where abundant hydroxyl groups from pectin, cellulose, and mucilage give rise to a broad, unresolved O–H envelope that broadens further upon composite formation due to the formation of an extensive hydrogen-bonding network among –OH groups of alginate, pectin, glycerol, and chitosan.43,44 Such hydrogen bonding contributes significantly to the structural cohesion and hydrophilicity of the composite. The absorption bands observed at ∼2923 cm−1 correspond to asymmetric C–H stretching vibrations of aliphatic –CH2 and –CH3 groups,45 which are common to all polysaccharide components and glycerol. The persistence of these bands in SPCA confirms that the polymer backbones remain chemically intact during composite fabrication. A key feature of alginate and pectin is the presence of carboxylate groups. In the spectra of pure alginate and pectin, the asymmetric and symmetric stretching vibrations of –COO− groups appear at approximately 1629–1631 cm−1 and 1408–1416 cm−1, respectively.46,47 In the SPCA composite, the asymmetric –COO− band shifts to ∼1627 cm−1, accompanied by changes in intensity and band shape. This shift provides strong evidence for ionic coordination between carboxylate groups and Zn2+ ions, leading to the formation of the classical “egg-box” structure.48 Such coordination restricts polymer chain mobility and stabilizes the three-dimensional network, which is essential for mechanical robustness and reusability during adsorption–desorption cycles. Chitosan incorporation is evidenced by the presence of an absorption band at ∼1648 cm−1, assigned to the amide I vibration (C
O stretching).49 Compared to pure chitosan, this band in SPCA exhibits slight shifting and broadening, suggesting strong intermolecular interactions between chitosan amino groups (–NH2/–NH3+) and the carboxylate groups of alginate and pectin. Although the –OH and N–H stretching vibrations of chitosan in the 3000–3600 cm−1 region are well known to overlap and produce a broad, unresolved absorption band—a spectroscopic limitation inherent to chitosan-containing systems—the successful incorporation of chitosan into the SPCA composite was unambiguously confirmed by the characteristic amide I band at ∼1648 cm−1 and its discernible shift and broadening in the composite spectrum, which are attributable to strong intermolecular interactions between chitosan amino groups and the carboxylate moieties of alginate and pectin. These interactions are further reinforced by hydrogen bonding and, under acidic conditions, electrostatic attraction, which collectively enhance the density of adsorption-active sites for anionic dye molecules. The intense band appearing at ∼1031–1056 cm−1 in the SPCA spectrum is attributed to C–O–C and C–O stretching vibrations characteristic of polysaccharide glycosidic linkages, confirmed also by the porous carbon FTIR fingerprint region documented for potassium-citrate-derived activated carbons50 and for cellulose-chitosan-alginate composite beads.51,52 The presence and intensity of this band confirm that the polysaccharide framework is preserved while actively participating in network formation. Additionally, weak and broadened bands in the region of ∼1500–1600 cm−1 and ∼1200–1000 cm−1 can be associated with surface functional groups of activated carbon, including aromatic C
C, C–O, and C
O vibrations.53 Although these bands are relatively subtle due to the carbonaceous nature of activated carbon, their presence indicates successful incorporation and surface exposure, which is crucial for π–π interactions with the aromatic rings of methyl orange.54 Overall, the FT-IR analysis demonstrates that SPCA is stabilized through a combination of ionic crosslinking (Zn2+–COO−), hydrogen bonding, and secondary interactions involving chitosan and activated carbon.
These synergistic interactions generate a chemically integrated, multifunctional adsorption network with abundant accessible functional groups, providing a strong structural basis for the high adsorption efficiency and reusability observed in subsequent adsorption studies.
The crystalline structures of alginate, cactus pectin, chitosan, activated carbon, and the SPCA composite were investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD), as shown in Fig. 4B. The diffractograms reveal distinct structural characteristics of the individual components and provide clear evidence for the formation of an integrated composite with reduced crystallinity. Pure alginate (curve a) exhibits a sharp diffraction peak at 2θ ≈ 29.4°, which is characteristic of its semi-crystalline nature and is commonly attributed to the ordered arrangement of polymer chains stabilized by inter- and intramolecular hydrogen bonding.55 The high intensity and narrow width of this peak indicate a relatively high degree of structural ordering within the alginate matrix. Cactus pectin (curve b), in contrast, displays a predominantly amorphous pattern, characterized by a broad and low-intensity halo centered around 2θ ≈ 20–22°.55 This broad diffraction feature reflects the disordered arrangement of pectin chains, which is typical for highly branched polysaccharides containing abundant galacturonic acid units and flexible side chains. Chitosan (curve c) shows a broad diffraction peak centered at 2θ ≈ 19.8–20.5°, corresponding to the (110) crystalline plane. The broadness of this peak suggests a semi-crystalline structure with limited long-range order, arising from partial crystallization induced by hydrogen bonding between –OH and –NH2 groups along the chitosan backbone.56 Activated carbon (curve d) exhibits a largely amorphous diffraction pattern, with a very broad and weak peak around 2θ ≈ 26–26.5°, which is associated with the (002) plane of turbostratic carbon.57 The absence of sharp diffraction peaks confirms the disordered, non-graphitic structure of activated carbon, which is advantageous for adsorption due to its high surface defect density and porosity. Notably, the SPCA composite (curve e) presents a markedly different diffraction profile compared to the individual components. The sharp crystalline peak of alginate at ∼29.4° disappears completely, while the broad polysaccharide-related peaks around 20–22° become significantly weakened and broadened. This pronounced reduction in peak intensity and increase in peak width indicate a substantial decrease in crystallinity, confirming that strong intermolecular interactions occur during composite formation. The suppression of crystalline features in SPCA can be attributed to the synergistic effects of ionic crosslinking between Zn2+ ions and carboxylate groups (–COO−) of alginate and pectin, electrostatic interactions between protonated chitosan (–NH3+) and carboxylate groups, and extensive hydrogen bonding among all polysaccharide components. These interactions disrupt the regular packing of polymer chains, thereby preventing recrystallization and promoting the formation of an amorphous three-dimensional network. From an application perspective, the reduced crystallinity of SPCA is highly beneficial for adsorption processes. Amorphous structures provide greater chain mobility, higher accessibility of functional groups, and increased diffusion pathways for adsorbate molecules, all of which contribute directly to enhanced dye uptake—consistent with the superior methylene blue removal capacity reported for amorphous, porous cactus-based adsorbents relative to their more crystalline counterparts.43,44 Consequently, the XRD results strongly support the enhanced adsorption performance observed for SPCA, particularly toward organic dye molecules such as methyl orange.
The thermal behavior of the pristine polymers and the SPCA composite was systematically elucidated by the combined analysis of thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), providing complementary insights into mass loss phenomena, phase transitions, and polymer chain dynamics.
As shown in Fig. 5A, the thermal decomposition of pectin, chitosan, sodium alginate, and SPCA can be divided into three characteristic stages. The first stage (150–300 °C) corresponds to the initial thermal degradation of labile functional groups, dehydration of bound water, and cleavage of weak intermolecular interactions. In this temperature range, the pristine polysaccharides exhibit noticeable weight loss, whereas SPCA shows a delayed onset of degradation, indicating improved resistance to thermal activation. This observation is consistent with the DSC results (Fig. 5B), where sodium alginate and pectin display endothermic transitions at 100–150 °C and chitosan at 150–200 °C,58,59 attributed to polymer relaxation and partial disruption of hydrogen bonding. In contrast, SPCA does not exhibit sharp transitions in this region, reflecting suppressed segmental mobility due to effective crosslinking. The second stage (300–500 °C) represents the main decomposition region, involving backbone scission of polysaccharide chains and extensive depolymerization.60 In this stage, the individual raw materials undergo rapid and severe mass loss, while SPCA maintains a significantly lower weight loss of only ∼30–40%, demonstrating superior thermal stability. Correspondingly, the DSC curve of SPCA shows a broad and smooth endothermic behavior extending up to approximately 250 °C, rather than the sharp thermal events observed for the pristine polymers. This broadened transition reflects a highly integrated polymer network in which thermal energy is dissipated over a wide temperature range, delaying catastrophic chain breakdown. The enhanced thermal resistance of SPCA in this regime can be attributed to the dual crosslinking mechanism. Ionic coordination between Zn2+ ions and carboxylate groups of alginate and pectin (egg-box structure), together with covalent crosslinking between glutaraldehyde and chitosan amino groups, significantly restricts polymer chain motion.61 As a result, higher thermal energy is required to initiate backbone decomposition, effectively extending the primary decomposition window to approximately 200–400 °C. In the final high-temperature stage (>500 °C), SPCA retains a substantial residual mass (20–25%), whereas the pristine polysaccharides are almost completely decomposed. This residual mass is associated with the formation of a stable carbonaceous structure reinforced by activated carbon.29 The DSC data further support this interpretation, as the strong exothermic peak observed for activated carbon around 250–270 °C becomes attenuated and broadened in the SPCA composite, indicating strong interfacial interactions and homogeneous dispersion within the polymer matrix. Overall, the combined TGA-DSC analysis clearly demonstrates that the synergistic incorporation of polysaccharides, activated carbon, and dual crosslinking agents results in a thermally robust composite. The delayed decomposition onset, reduced mass loss, broadened thermal transitions, and increased char yield collectively confirm that SPCA possesses enhanced thermal stability and structural durability, which are critical for repeated adsorption–desorption cycles and long-term application in wastewater treatment.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) (A) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) (B) of SPCA and related materias: (a) activated carbon, (b) chitosan, (c) pectin cactus, and (d) alginate. | ||
The textural properties of SPCA before and after MO adsorption were systematically evaluated using N2 adsorption–desorption measurements (Fig. 6) and the corresponding BET/BJH parameters summarized in Table S1. Prior to adsorption, SPCA exhibits a relatively high BET specific surface area of 255.88 m2 g−1, confirming the presence of a well-developed porous framework favorable for adsorption processes. After MO uptake, the surface area decreases slightly to 254.21 m2 g−1, indicating partial occupation of accessible adsorption sites by MO molecules rather than structural collapse of the porous network. More pronounced changes are observed in the pore volume parameters. The BJH pore volume derived from N2 adsorption decreases from 0.119 to 0.099 cm3 g−1, while the desorption-derived pore volume declines from 0.178 to 0.159 cm3 g−1 after MO adsorption. This reduction provides strong evidence that MO molecules preferentially infiltrate and occupy the internal pore space, particularly mesopores and smaller interconnected pores, leading to a decrease in available void volume. Such behavior is characteristic of adsorption governed by pore-filling mechanisms rather than mere surface coverage.
Consistently, the average pore diameter also decreases after adsorption, from 25.45 to 22.17 Å (adsorption branch) and from 19.33 to 17.12 Å (desorption branch). This shrinkage in effective pore size further supports the conclusion that MO molecules are retained within the pore channels, narrowing the accessible pore width without fundamentally altering the pore geometry. The N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms of SPCA, both before and after MO adsorption, can be classified as type IV according to IUPAC standards, which is typical of mesoporous materials. The presence of a distinct hysteresis loop in the relative pressure range of P/P0 ≈ 0.4–0.9 confirms the occurrence of capillary condensation within mesopores. Notably, the hysteresis loop persists after MO adsorption, although with a slightly reduced adsorbed volume, demonstrating that the mesoporous framework remains structurally intact. The loop shape resembles H3/H4-type hysteresis, suggesting slit-like pores associated with plate-like or layered structural units, which are particularly advantageous for the adsorption of planar aromatic dye molecules such as methyl orange. Overall, the combined BET, BJH, and isotherm analyses reveal that MO adsorption induces measurable but moderate reductions in surface area, pore volume, and pore diameter, all of which are attributable to effective pore filling rather than pore destruction.
As shown in Fig. 7, the surface morphology of SPCA particles prior to adsorption (Fig. 7A–C) reveals a highly irregular and heterogeneous structure characterized by abundant pores, voids, and surface asperities distributed over multiple length scales. At low magnification (×10), the particles exhibit a nearly spherical morphology with a rough outer surface, suggesting successful bead formation and structural integrity. At higher magnifications (×1000 and ×5000), a well-developed porous network composed of interconnected micro- and mesopores becomes evident. This hierarchical porosity is expected to significantly enhance the specific surface area and facilitate rapid mass transfer of dye molecules from the bulk solution to internal adsorption sites.
After MO adsorption (Fig. 7D–F), pronounced morphological changes are observed. The surface appears notably smoother and more compact, with a substantial reduction in visible pores and voids. At higher magnification, the pore openings and interstitial spaces are partially or completely filled, indicating that MO molecules have penetrated and occupied the internal porous network rather than merely adsorbing on the external surface. The coverage of pore walls and surface asperities by adsorbed species suggests strong interactions between MO molecules and the functional groups (–OH, –COO−, and –NH2) distributed throughout the SPCA matrix. Notably, the absence of structural collapse or particle fragmentation after adsorption demonstrates the mechanical robustness of the SPCA beads, which can be attributed to the dual crosslinked polymer network formed via Zn2+ ionic coordination and glutaraldehyde covalent bonding. These SEM observations are in good agreement with the BET surface area reduction after adsorption and the kinetic results indicating rapid uptake followed by intraparticle diffusion-controlled equilibrium. Overall, the SEM analysis provides direct visual evidence that MO adsorption proceeds through pore filling and surface coverage within a stable, hierarchical porous architecture, confirming the suitability of SPCA as an efficient and structurally durable adsorbent.
Moreover, Fig. 7B and F presents SEM images of the cross-sectional morphology of the SPCA particles before and after methyl orange (MO) adsorption. Prior to adsorption (Fig. 7B), the SPCA particles exhibit a relatively rough and heterogeneous surface with numerous irregular protrusions and fragmented structures distributed across the particle surface. The composite bead displays a compact but hierarchically textured morphology, suggesting the successful integration of the polymeric matrix with the activated carbon component. Such a morphology likely originates from the partial collapse of the polymer network during the drying process, which generates microvoids and surface asperities. These structural irregularities are beneficial for adsorption because they increase the effective surface area and provide abundant accessible active sites for dye molecules. In addition, the presence of loosely aggregated flake-like and granular features on the surface indicates that the composite contains exposed carbonaceous domains embedded within the biopolymer matrix. These domains may contribute to adsorption through multiple interaction mechanisms, including π–π stacking interactions between the aromatic rings of MO molecules and the graphitic structures of activated carbon, as well as electrostatic interactions with protonated functional groups of the polymeric components. After adsorption (Fig. 7F), the overall morphology of the SPCA particles remains largely preserved, indicating that the composite possesses good structural stability during the adsorption process. However, several noticeable morphological changes can be observed.
The surface appears partially covered by aggregated deposits and layered structures, which are likely associated with the accumulation of adsorbed MO molecules within surface cavities and on exposed adsorption sites. In addition, some of the initially visible surface irregularities appear smoother or partially masked after adsorption, suggesting that dye molecules occupy surface defects, pores, and adsorption-active regions. Furthermore, the presence of clustered deposits on the particle surface after adsorption may indicate the formation of localized adsorption domains, where dye molecules accumulate through intermolecular interactions and surface complexation. This observation supports the multilayer adsorption behavior inferred from the Freundlich isotherm model. Importantly, no obvious structural collapse, cracking, or fragmentation of the SPCA. Particles is observed after adsorption, confirming the mechanical robustness and stability of the composite material in aqueous environments. Overall, the SEM observations provide direct morphological evidence supporting the adsorption process. The rough and heterogeneous surface of SPCA offers abundant adsorption sites and facilitates mass transfer of dye molecules from the bulk solution to the internal structure of the composite. The morphological changes observed after adsorption further confirm the successful uptake of MO molecules while demonstrating that the composite retains its structural integrity, which is essential for practical adsorption and regeneration applications.
Overall, the adsorption parameter optimization was conducted systematically by varying pH, adsorbent dosage, contact time, and initial MO concentration. It should be noted that the pH, dosage, and contact-time experiments were performed at an initial MO concentration of 50 mg L−1, whereas the concentration-dependent study was carried out over a wider range of 50–200 mg L−1. Although slightly higher removal efficiencies were observed at alkaline pH values (pH 8–9), noticeable structural instability and partial dissolution of the composite beads were detected under these conditions. Therefore, pH 4 was selected as the optimal operational pH, as it ensured high adsorption performance while maintaining excellent structural integrity and analytical reliability. Similarly, while the highest adsorption capacity was achieved at 200 mg L−1, the condition of 150 mg L−1 was selected for subsequent kinetic, isotherm, and regeneration studies.
This concentration provides a balanced compromise between high adsorption capacity (14.38 mg g−1) and high removal efficiency (96.00%), avoiding excessive site saturation and ensuring stable adsorption behavior. Under the selected optimal conditions (pH 4, 0.5 g adsorbent, 50 mL solution, 4 h contact time, and 150 mg L−1 MO), SPCA demonstrated robust adsorption performance without compromising structural stability.
Although this model captures the general energetic trend of MO adsorption, its relatively lower correlation coefficient suggests limited applicability in describing the full complexity of SPCA, particularly its structural heterogeneity and pore-filling effects. Overall, comparative analysis of the three isotherm models clearly identifies the Freundlich model as the most appropriate descriptor of MO adsorption on SPCA. This conclusion is supported by its highest correlation coefficient and physically meaningful parameters, which collectively indicate heterogeneous surface adsorption with variable binding energies. The isotherm behavior of SPCA is in good agreement with previously reported results for porous carbon-based and biomass-derived adsorbents used for anionic dye removal.62,63 While the Langmuir and Temkin models contribute complementary insights, the Freundlich model most accurately reflects the dominant adsorption mechanism of SPCA, confirming its suitability for efficient and stable adsorption of MO from aqueous solutions.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Pseudo-first-order kinetic model (A), pseudo-second-order kinetic model (B), intracellular diffusion model (C) and Elovich kinetic model (D). | ||
Although the Elovich model is often applicable to highly heterogeneous systems, its lower fitting accuracy compared to the PSO model indicates limited relevance for quantitatively describing the MO adsorption process on SPCA. The intraparticle diffusion model exhibits the lowest correlation coefficient (R2 = 0.8361), indicating that intraparticle diffusion is not the sole rate-limiting step. This implies that adsorption proceeds through multiple stages, including external surface adsorption followed by gradual diffusion into internal pores. However, since the model does not pass through the origin, intraparticle diffusion acts as a secondary or supportive mechanism rather than the primary kinetic control. Overall, the kinetic study unequivocally indicates that the pseudo-second-order model most precisely characterizes the adsorption behavior of MO onto SPCA. This verifies that chemisorption is the prevailing mechanism, likely due to robust electrostatic attraction between protonated amino groups and sulfonate groups of MO, in conjunction with hydrogen bonding and π–π interactions, whereas physical diffusion and intraparticle transport play a contributory role but do not govern the overall adsorption rate.
(i) Electrostatic attraction. The dominant interaction driving MO uptake onto SPCA at pH 4 is direct electrostatic attraction between the protonated amino groups (–NH3+) of chitosan and the anionic sulfonate group (–SO3−) of MO. At pH values below the pKa of chitosan (∼6.3–6.5), the primary amine functions are quantitatively protonated, generating a high surface density of positively charged sites.34 These –NH3+ species form a stable ionic pair with the –SO3− moiety of MO, constituting a chemisorption-type interaction that is fully consistent with the pseudo-second-order kinetic behavior observed experimentally (R2 = 0.9985) – a hallmark of charge-transfer-mediated surface binding.32 The pH-dependence of the adsorption capacity – with a clear maximum at pH 4 and progressive decline toward alkalinity – corroborates the central role of protonated amino groups: as pH increases beyond the pKa of chitosan, –NH3+ undergoes deprotonation to –NH2, reducing the density of cationic sites and consequently diminishing the electrostatic driving force for MO uptake. Furthermore, the systematic enhancement in adsorption capacity as chitosan content increases from 1% to 4% provides additional direct evidence that –NH3+ group density is the primary determinant of MO removal efficiency.34 Importantly, as demonstrated in analogous composite adsorbent systems, electrostatic attraction constitutes one component of a broader physicochemical synergy in which multiple simultaneous mechanisms collectively determine adsorption performance.64
It is essential to clarify that the carboxylate groups (–COO−) of alginate and pectin, while structurally abundant in SPCA, do not contribute directly to electrostatic MO uptake: the anionic character of both –COO− and –SO3− precludes attractive electrostatic interaction between these groups and the MO anion. Instead, –COO− groups fulfill a dual structural and adsorption-assisting function. Structurally, they coordinate with Zn2+ ions to form the classical “egg-box” crosslinked network, as evidenced by the characteristic shift of the asymmetric –COO− stretching band from ∼1631 cm−1 in the pristine polymers to ∼1627 cm−1 in SPCA.48 In terms of adsorption, they contribute indirectly through hydrogen bonding (mechanism ii, below) and by maintaining the open, swellable pore architecture that supports intraparticle transport.12
(ii) Hydrogen bonding. A secondary yet significant contribution to MO retention arises from multiple hydrogen bonding interactions between the oxygen-containing functional groups of the biopolymer matrix and the structural features of MO. The hydroxyl groups (–OH) present in the pyranose rings of alginate, pectin, and chitosan function as both hydrogen bond donors and acceptors toward the azo linkage (–N
N–), the dimethylamino group (–N(CH3)2), and the sulfonate group (–SO3−) of MO.12,13 Partially protonated carboxylate groups (–COOH) at pH 4 further contribute as strong hydrogen bond donors toward the nitrogen and oxygen atoms of the dye molecule.14 Spectroscopic evidence for hydrogen bond formation is provided by the FTIR analysis of SPCA after MO adsorption: the –OH stretching envelope (3300–3450 cm−1) exhibits measurable broadening and a slight bathochromic shift relative to the pre-adsorption spectrum, consistent with the formation of new intermolecular hydrogen bonds between adsorbent surface groups and adsorbed MO species.41,42 Hydrogen bonding is also mechanistically compatible with the multilayer adsorption behavior described by the Freundlich isotherm (R2 = 0.9945): once the first monolayer of MO is anchored to SPCA surface sites through electrostatic attraction, subsequent MO molecules may interact with the already-adsorbed layer through intermolecular hydrogen bonds and dipole–dipole interactions, generating the heterogeneous multilayer stacking captured by the Freundlich model.32 The important role of surface hydroxyl groups in facilitating hydrogen bond-mediated pollutant retention has been highlighted in mechanistic studies of bio-composite adsorbent systems.64
(iii) π–π Stacking interactions. The incorporation of activated carbon (AC) introduces a third adsorption pathway through non-covalent π–π electron donor–acceptor interactions between the graphitic micro-domains of AC and the extended aromatic conjugation system of MO. The molecular structure of MO features two phenyl rings connected through an azo bridge (–N
N–) with a dimethylamino electron-donating substituent and a sulfonate electron-withdrawing group, constituting a highly polarized, delocalized π-electron system. The turbostratic carbon structure of AC, confirmed by the broad XRD reflection at 2θ ≈ 26° corresponding to the graphitic plane,57 provides a complementary π-electron-rich surface that engages in face-to-face or edge-to-face π–π stacking with the aromatic rings of MO.54 The presence of graphitic C
C stretching and aromatic C–O vibrations in the FTIR spectrum of SPCA (1500–1600 cm−1) confirms that the carbonaceous domains are surface-exposed and accessible for this interaction.53 The quantitative contribution of this mechanism is demonstrated by the systematic increase in adsorption capacity from 4.66 to 4.91 mg g−1 as AC loading increases from 1% to 4%, an enhancement that exceeds what would be expected from surface area expansion alone and thus reflects a genuine chemical affinity contribution.29 π–π stacking between carbonaceous domains and the aromatic rings of azo dyes has been extensively documented as a key secondary adsorption mechanism in AC-containing bio-composite systems, augmenting the primary electrostatic driving force.54,65 This synergistic interplay between surface electrostatics and π–π stacking is mechanistically analogous to the co-occurrence of chemisorption and physical adsorption (Freundlich n > 1) reported in multi-mechanism composite adsorbent systems,64 underscoring the generality of this physicochemical synergy across different pollutant–adsorbent pairs.
(iv) Sureface adsorption. Textural analysis provides direct quantitative evidence for a pore-filling mechanism as the fourth adsorption pathway. BET analysis reveals that MO adsorption induces a statistically significant decrease in BJH pore volume from 0.119 to 0.099 cm3 g−1 (adsorption branch) and from 0.178 to 0.159 cm3 g−1 (desorption branch), and a contraction of the average pore diameter from 25.45 to 22.17 Å (adsorption branch), while the specific surface area remains essentially unchanged (255.88 vs. 254.21 m2 g−1), collectively indicating that MO molecules preferentially penetrate and occupy the internal mesopore channels rather than adsorbing exclusively on the external particle surface. The type IV N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms with H3/H4-type hysteresis loops, which persist after MO adsorption with a reduced adsorbed volume, confirm that the mesoporous framework remains structurally intact while partially filled with retained dye.10,11 The multi-stage intraparticle diffusion kinetics—evidenced by the non-zero intercept (C > 0) of the Weber–Morris plot and the three distinct linear regions33 — confirms that adsorption proceeds through sequential stages: rapid film boundary diffusion and external surface adsorption (Stage 1), followed by slower intraparticle diffusion into the mesopore network as the rate-limiting step (Stage 2), and finally attainment of equilibrium at deeply embedded adsorption sites (Stage 3).32 SEM morphological analysis provides complementary direct visual evidence: the surface of SPCA after MO adsorption exhibits reduced roughness, partial occlusion of visible pore openings, and the formation of localized dye deposits within surface cavities (Fig. 7D–H), fully consistent with a pore-filling mechanism. The critical role of pore structure and interlayer/pore spacing in accommodating adsorbate species through multilayer mechanisms has been identified as a governing factor in optimized composite adsorbent systems,64 reinforcing the conclusion that textural optimization is as important as surface chemistry in determining the ultimate adsorption capacity.
The four mechanisms described above do not operate independently but evolve in their relative contributions across the adsorption timeline. During the initial rapid phase (0–2 h), adsorption is dominated by electrostatic attraction and hydrogen bonding at the readily accessible external surface and large mesopore openings, driven by a high MO concentration gradient (removal efficiency: 85.15% → 95.56%). As the contact time extends (2–4 h), intraparticle diffusion becomes rate-limiting as MO molecules migrate progressively deeper into the porous composite structure,32 and π–π stacking interactions with AC domains become increasingly relevant at internal adsorption sites.54 At equilibrium (4 h), all four mechanisms collectively determine the total adsorption capacity, with the heterogeneous multilayer distribution of retained MO described by the Freundlich model (R2 = 0.9945).32 These findings are in good agreement with previously reported adsorption kinetics for porous, biomass-derived composite adsorbents used in dye removal systems32,63 and with multi-mechanism characterizations of optimized bio-composite adsorbents,64 further validating the effectiveness and mechanistic consistency of SPCA as an efficient and structurally durable adsorbent for the removal of anionic azo dyes from aqueous media. The mechanistic schematic incorporating all four pathways and the temporal sequence of their activation is presented in Fig. 11.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 12 The effect of different solvents on the MO desorption process of SPCA (A) NaOH 0.1 N; (B) NaHCO3 0.05 M, (C) HCl 0.1 N, (D) MeOH 96% và (E) EtOH 96%. | ||
The quantitative results are summarized in figure insert Fig. 13. For methanol, the adsorption efficiency decreased from 96.51% in the first cycle to 80.99% in the third cycle, with an average efficiency of 89.54%. The corresponding adsorption capacity declined from 9.64 to 8.09 mg g−1 (average 8.95 mg g−1). The slightly superior performance of ethanol compared to methanol suggests that ethanol better preserves the adsorption-active functional groups and crosslinked network structure during regeneration. Overall, these results demonstrate that ethanol is an effective, mild, and environmentally benign regenerating solvent for SPCA, enabling high desorption efficiency while maintaining structural stability and adsorption performance. This finding highlights the suitability of SPCA for repeated use in wastewater treatment applications.
| Adsorbent | Composition/description | qmax (mg g−1) | Optimal pH | Kinetic model | Isotherm model | Reuse cycles (%) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chitosan–alginate composite (Cs-F-An)-G-Al | Aniline-modified chitosan crosslinked with alginate via glutaraldehyde | 198.09 | 6.0 | PSO | Langmuir | — | 66 |
| Chitosan–biochar microspheres (CS-PABC) | Chitosan encapsulating palmer amaranth biochar; batch adsorption | 495.0–554.3 (25–45 °C) | 3.0 | PSO | Langmuir | — | 67 |
| Chitosan-modified biochar (CSBC) | Shrimp-shell chitosan coating on rice husk biochar hydrogel beads | 17.58 | 3.0 | PSO + intraparticle diff | Langmuir | — | 68 |
| Poultry manure-derived biochar (PM-BC) | Slow pyrolysis at 550 °C; SBET 16.09 m2 g−1 | 20.80 | 4.0 | PSO | Langmuir | — | 69 |
| Nitrogen-rich biomass-derived carbon (N-BC) | Enteromorpha-derived biochar; multi-stage adsorption; DFT-supported | 269.58 | 3–4 | PSO | Langmuir/Freundlich | — | 70 |
| PAAM/chitosan hydrogel | Semi-IPN of polyacrylamide and chitosan; photo-polymerization | 202.02 | 3.0 | PSO | Langmuir | Reusable | 71 |
| CS-EGDE biofilm | Crosslinked chitosan–ethylene glycol diglycidyl ether biofilm on glass | 131.2 | — | PSO | Langmuir | Reusable | 72 |
| SPCA composite | Opuntia dillenii pectin + alginate + chitosan + activated carbon; dual Zn2+ ionic + glutaraldehyde covalent crosslinking; hierarchical mesoporous; air-dried beads | 18.55/14.38 | 4.0 | PSO (R2 = 0.9985) | Freundlich (R2 = 0.9945) | 6 cycles (83.62%) | This work |
Compared with other materials in the table, SPCA in this study exhibits a relatively lower adsorption capacity (qmax ∼18.55 mg g−1) than several advanced systems such as chitosan–biochar (∼495–554 mg g−1) or PAAM/chitosan hydrogels (∼202 mg g−1), indicating that it is not optimized for maximum adsorption performance. However, the key strength of SPCA lies in its renewable bio-based feedstock (pectin from Opuntia dillenii) and green, mild synthesis conditions, whereas many other materials rely on intensive chemical modification or more complex fabrication processes. In addition, SPCA follows a Freundlich isotherm, suggesting heterogeneous multilayer adsorption consistent with its composite structure, in contrast to the Langmuir behavior commonly reported for other systems.
In terms of applicability, SPCA achieves high removal efficiency (∼96%) at practical concentrations and demonstrates reusability over six cycles (83.62%), which is comparable to or clearer than several materials that only report being “reusable” without detailed cycling data. Its granular structure also facilitates separation and handling, offering an advantage over powder or hydrogel systems. Nevertheless, limitations remain, including moderate adsorption capacity, reduced stability under alkaline conditions, and gradual performance decline upon reuse, whereas some inorganic or nanostructured materials exhibit superior durability. Overall, this work stands out for its sustainability, cost-effectiveness, and practical potential, although further improvements in adsorption capacity and long-term stability are needed to compete with high-performance engineered adsorbents.
Footnote |
| † These authors contributed equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |