Open Access Article
Param Punj
Singh
a,
Dhyanesh
Baskaran
a,
Omar
Adjaoud
b,
Karsten
Albe
b and
Raghavan
Ranganathan
*a
aDepartment of Materials Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Gandhinagar, Gandhinagar, 382355, Gujarat, India. E-mail: rraghav@iitgn.ac.in
bInstitute of Materials Science, Technische Universitat Darmstadt, Otto-Berndt-Str.3, 64287, Darmstadt, Germany
First published on 20th March 2026
Understanding the structure–property relationships in glasses is challenging due to their inherent structural disorder and non-equilibrium nature. Among these, secondary (β) relaxation plays a vital role in dictating mechanical behavior, yet its structural origins remain elusive. In this study, we employ molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the temperature-dependent viscoelastic properties of Cu64Zr36 in both metallic glass and nanoglass forms. Our results demonstrate that nanoglasses exhibit pronounced β relaxation, manifested as an additional wing near the α peak. String-like atomic motions indicative of β relaxation are prominent in nanoglass, but largely suppressed in metallic glass despite observed correlated displacements. Analysis of local short-range icosahedral and polyheral motifs shows that regions with reduced structural order correspond to greater energy dissipation. These findings provide new atomistic insights into the microscopic mechanisms governing β relaxation and their implications for the mechanical performance of metallic glasses.
Metallic glasses, similar to other glassy materials, demonstrate a wide range of viscoelastic and relaxation behaviors, which are characterized by structural changes at the molecular and atomic scales in a broad spectrum of temperatures and frequencies.11–13 In glasses, relaxation processes are traditionally categorized into two main types: the primary (α) relaxation, which arises from large-scale irreversible atomic rearrangements responsible for the glass transition, and the Johari–Goldstein secondary (β) relaxation,14,15 which is attributed to localized atomic rearrangements.
Recent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have demonstrated that, in metallic glasses, β relaxations are facilitated by atomic motions characterized by string-like cooperative atomic rearrangements within the slow-moving matrix.15–17 In Dynamic Mechanical Spectroscopy (DMS), the β relaxations observed in the loss modulus plots can manifest in various forms. They may appear as well-defined peaks in certain glassy materials, as excess wings extending from the tail of the α relaxation, or, in some cases, they may be completely absent.18–20
Numerous studies have demonstrated that β relaxations in metallic glasses are primarily governed by the local atomic order, which is influenced by both physical treatments and chemical composition, as evidenced by diffraction techniques such as neutron and X-ray scattering experiments.21 The local atomic configuration defining the icosahedral structures forms the fundamental building blocks of metallic glasses, with atoms within these structures exhibiting rigid local structure, high shear resistance, and slower relaxation.22,23 The structural inhomogeneities inherent to these materials give rise to damping effects associated with structural relaxation, commonly referred to as anelastic relaxation, which can be understood as a form of viscoelastic damping.14–26 These damping responses occur due to the out-of-phase nature of stress and strain during DMS deformation cycles that are highly temperature and frequency-dependent.27,28 Therefore, a comprehensive understanding of viscoelastic behavior is essential for elucidating the relaxation and mechanical properties of NGs, as these aspects are closely interconnected.
500 atoms. Model structures from the resulting protocol are shown for the Cu64Zr36 MG and the NG in Fig. 1(a) and (b). For all the MD simulations in this study, we used periodic boundary conditions and a timestep of 2 fs. The Nosé–Hoover thermostat and barostat, as implemented in LAMMPS, were used to control temperature and pressure.
To investigate the temperature-dependent viscoelastic properties, a non-equilibrium oscillatory shear deformation was applied,27,41–43 and the resulting shear stress was analyzed. The equations of motion were integrated according to the SLLOD algorithm,44,45 equivalent to the Lees–Edwards 'sliding brick' boundary conditions. The shear strain during oscillatory shear deformation was determined by a sinusoidal function, which can be expressed as
γxy = γ0 sin(ωt) | (1) |
τxy = τ0 sin(ωt + δ) | (2) |
δ) are calculated as![]() | (3) |
It is well known that the relaxation and damping in glasses are functions of temperature and frequency of deformation.27 As we are primarily interested in understanding temperature-dependent relaxation processes, we use two oscillatory shear frequencies corresponding to time periods of 0.1 and 1 ns. For each shear frequency, a temperature-sweep simulation was conducted spanning 120 K to 1000 K for a total simulation time of 20 ns. The virial shear stress and τxy were measured at intervals of every 0.1 ps, and the stress response was averaged over the last 20 cycles to determine the viscoelastic behavior.
Fig. 2 illustrates the temperature-dependent G′ and G″ moduli of MG and NG for the two shear frequencies. Fig. 2(a) and (b) compares the G′ of MG and NG, respectively. For both models, it is evident that at shorter oscillation periods (higher frequencies), G′ is higher compared to lower frequencies, as atoms have less time to respond to the applied deformation. At higher frequencies, the material exhibits more elastic, solid-like behavior than at lower frequencies. Additionally, a transition in G′ is observed near the onset of Tg, which shifts to higher temperatures with increasing frequency, similar to other amorphous materials.47,48 Compared to NG, the G′ of MG is higher at all shear frequencies, consistent with the higher shear modulus and shear strength of MG observed in the simple shear simulations, as shown in Fig. 1d.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) and (b) Storage modulus (G′) and (c) and (d) loss modulus (G″) of Cu64Zr36 MG and NG for shear oscillation periods of 0.1 and 1 ns. | ||
While G′ characterizes the non-dissipative elastic response, G″ provides insight into the material's energy dissipation under oscillatory shear. Fig. 2(c) and (d) compares the G″ of MG and NG, respectively. It is important to note that G″ remains small at low temperatures due to limited atomic mobility. As the temperature increases, G″ rises as atomic rearrangements become more pronounced, leading to enhanced viscous flow. A peak appears near Tg corresponding to the α-relaxation, where structural relaxation dominates. Beyond Tg, the material flows more readily, and decreases G″ accordingly. However, Tα shifts to larger temperatures at higher frequencies, consistent with the G′. Despite the structural heterogeneity of the NG, no difference is observed in the temperature corresponding to the G″ peak Tα between the two structures. The Tα values were determined to be 760 K and 880 K for oscillation periods of 1 ns and 0.1 ns, respectively. But across the entire temperature range shown here, NG exhibits higher G″ than MG at equivalent shear frequencies. However, the G″ in NG exhibits a distinctive shoulder-like feature in the temperature range of 400–740 K, commonly referred to as 'excess wings', which correspond to β-relaxations, as evident in Fig. 2d. Of particular importance is the difference in β-relaxations observed in NG, which arises from its structural heterogeneity. The excess volume and the absence of structurally stable short-range motifs, such as icosahedral clusters at the glass–glass interface, enhance atomic mobility, resulting in greater stress dissipation even at intermediate and low temperatures. Fig. S1, supplementary material, shows the evolution of potential energy over 20 cycles of oscillatory deformation with a time period of 0.1 ns at 640 K, 680 K, and 720 K within the β-relaxation range. NG exhibits a monotonic decrease in potential energy at all temperatures, whereas the potential energy of MG remains nearly constant. This reduction indicates enhanced relaxation in NG, facilitating energy dissipation and enabling the system to attain a lower-energy atomic configuration during shear deformation.
To understand the atomic mechanisms underlying the relaxation behavior in MG and NG, the spatio-temporal atomic dynamics were analyzed using the intermediate scattering function (ISF) for both MG and NG at temperatures of 680 K and 880 K, respectively. The ISFs were computed using atomic trajectories recorded at a temporal interval of 0.02 ps to accurately capture particle displacements. Fig. 3 presents ISF at temperatures of 680 K and 880 K, corresponding to the presence of β- and α-relaxations, respectively, in both MG and NG. The wave vector k was varied to probe the system dynamics across different length and time scales. For instance, low k values capture long-range collective dynamics, whereas high k values focus on short-range vibrations and atomic diffusion. The plots exhibit an initial ballistic regime, followed by the cage motion of atoms (β-relaxation) at intermediate times and, subsequently, the escape of atoms from the cage, characterized by a stretched exponential behavior. The temperature dependence of the ISF is evident, as the cage motion persists for a longer duration at the lower temperature of 680 K compared to 880 K. At both 680 K and 880 K, while MG and NG share broadly similar relaxation behavior, NG demonstrates a more rapid initial relaxation phase, particularly at k = 0.8 Å. Nevertheless, the total relaxation times for both systems remain largely equivalent, as shown in Fig. 3(a) and (c). This is consistent with the G″ peaks observed at a similar temperature (i.e., at T = 760 K and t = 1 ns). However, Fig. 3(b) and (d), which presents the ISF of NG, shows a separate comparison of the relaxation behavior in the grain interiors and the glass–glass interfaces. It is evident from the plots that Cu and Zr atoms at the interfaces relax faster than those in the grain interiors at 680 K and 880 K, respectively. Overall, the ISF analysis indicates that, in addition to the relaxation behavior of the glassy interiors present in both MG and NG, the interfaces in NG play a vital role in its relaxation mechanism.
The atomic mechanisms underlying the observed relaxation phenomena in MG and NG are elucidated by further analyzing atomic rearrangements during oscillatory shear simulations. Firstly, the atomic displacements in MG and NG are considered. Fig. 4a shows the distribution of the magnitude of atomic displacements at T = 680 K, where β-relaxation is prominent in both NG and MG for an oscillatory time period of 0.1 ns. The plot reveals a noticeable peak at short displacements (≈ 1 Å) followed by a distinguishable hump for both MG and NG systems. At the range of 2–4 Å, NG dicpict a larger fraction of atomic jumps to its nearest neighbors. This position of the hump in the displacement histogram directly corresponds to the first peak in the pair distribution function g(r), see Fig. 4b, which signifies the likelihood of atomic hopping to the first nearest neighbor shell. Upon analyzing the atomic displacements, it is observed that some atoms tend to move rapidly, following a cooperative string-like motion. These string-like motions in MG and NG were analyzed by computing atomic displacements relative to an initial reference configuration. A suitable cutoff distance, corresponding to the position of the first peak in the g(r) plot (i.e., here 2.75 Å), indicative of the typical nearest-neighbor distance, was employed to identify clusters of atoms exhibiting string-like motion. Fig. 4c highlights the string-like motion of fast-moving atoms in NG at T = 680 K, observed at the end of 20 shear cycles. The left panel in Fig. 4c shows displacement vectors, marked in red, within a 2D sliced representation of MG and NG, respectively. Interestingly, these fast-moving atoms were observed to be concentrated in the interfacial regions of the NG (see SI, Fig. S3). The right panel depicts a 3D representation of atoms, color-coded according to clusters involved in cooperative string-like motion. At 680 K (during β-relaxation), NG clearly exhibits a larger number of fast-moving atoms, resulting in more clusters participating in string-like motion. It is also noted that this phenomenon is observed exclusively in NG at the relatively lower temperature range of 400–500 K, and is absent in MG (see SI, Fig. S2). Fig. 4e, presents the histogram of string lengths (Nstring) for MG and NG at T = 680 K. It is observed that the string lengths in Cu64Zr36 MG and NG are not significant, with the longest string comprising five atoms. Comparatively, NG contains a larger number of such atoms than MG, implying enhanced relaxation in NG, as also evidenced by the excess wing in the plot G″ plot. To further analyze the effect of structural heterogeneity in NG, the non-affine displacement (Dmin2)49,50 was computed for MG and NG over the temperature range of 640–720 K. Fig. 4d, presents the probability distribution of Dmin2 for the systems. It is evident that the non-affine displacement in NG (shown in red) exhibits relatively larger atomic displacements, leading to more shear compared to MG (shown in blue) as a function of temperature. The contoured map of the spatial distribution of Dmin2 is also provided in the SI, Fig. S4, depicting more number of soft spots formed by small groups of atoms in NG that are most prone to shear transformation under oscillatory deformation.
To further understand the effect of local short-range structures on viscoelastic behavior, the evolution of the most prominent Cu-centered (〈0,0,12,0〉) full icosahedra and (〈0,2,8,2〉) polyhedra atomic configurations was analyzed by Voronoi tessellation. In Cu64Zr36 MG, the short-range structure predominantly consists of Cu-centered icosahedral clusters, whereas in NG, the presence of interfaces leads to the distortion of these full icosahedra into polyhedra, a phenomenon that has been widely studied.31,35,40,51 These local clusters form stable atomic arrangements with a relatively high local atomic packing density. Under deformation, they contribute significantly to shear resistance by forming rigid atomic configurations. As a result, the density of Cu-centered icosahedral clusters exhibits an inverse correlation with energy dissipation.52Fig. 5(a) and (b) depicts the Cu-centered 〈0,0,12,0〉 and 〈0,2,8,2〉 fractions for both MG and NG before and after the oscillatory shear cycles. The initial fraction of these short-range structures is consistent with previous studies on Cu64Zr36 MG and NG.31,35 In Fig. 5a, at temperatures well below the glass transition temperature, MG exhibits the highest fraction of 〈0,0,12,0〉 full icosahedral structures, owing to the presence of bulk amorphous regions. This is also reflected in MG having a higher G′ compared to NG. This fraction gradually decreases with increasing temperature. As the system approaches the glass transition temperature, the icosahedral fractions in both MG and NG converge, as expected, due to their structural similarity in the liquid state. The lower prevalence of Cu-centered icosahedral configurations in NG is associated with enhanced energy dissipation, arising from the limited presence of rigid local atomic structures, as reflected in NG's behavior. Similarly, the 〈0,2,8,2〉 polyhedra fraction with respect to temperature is analyzed in Fig. 5b. A similar fraction of 〈0,2,8,2〉 polyhedra in MG and NG arises from their energetically favorable dominant local structure. As a function of temperature, the polyhedra exhibit a trend similar to that of Cu-centered full icosahedra, with their fraction gradually decreasing until a pronounced change occurs near Tg.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 (a) Fraction of Cu-centered 〈0,0,12,0〉 full icosahedra and (b) fraction of Cu-centered 〈0,2,8,2〉 polyhedra in MG and NG at the start and at the end of 20 oscillatory shear cycles. | ||
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |