Open Access Article
Po-Hsiang
Wang†
*,
Zann Yi
Qi Tan†
,
Choy Eng
Nge
,
Nurhidayah
Basri
,
Lina Xian
Yu Lee
,
Aaron
Thong
,
Mario
Wibowo
,
Elaine Jinfeng
Chin
,
Sharon
Crasta
,
Geraldine
Chan
,
Yoganathan
Kanagasundaram
and
Siew Bee
Ng
*
Singapore Institute of Food and Biotechnology Innovation (SIFBI), Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*STAR), 31 Biopolis Way, Nanos, Singapore 138669, Singapore. E-mail: tommy_wang@a-star.edu.sg; ngsb@a-star.edu.sg
First published on 7th November 2025
Microalgae represent a sustainable food source with exceptional CO2 fixation efficiency; however, their integration into the food chain is hindered by undesirable organoleptic properties. This study establishes a green biotransformation platform using Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS) bacterium Lactiplantibacillus plantarum to ferment Chlorella vulgaris biomass. This fermentation process operates without the use of harsh chemicals and organic solvents, enabling the full utilization of the biomass while improving sensory quality. Notably, the L. plantarum fermentation maintained dried biomass weight, in contrast to ∼15–40% loss seen with Bacillus spp., further enhancing the carbon-negative profile of microalgae. Tiered olfactory analysis and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry revealed selective reduction of polyunsaturated fatty acid-derived aldehydes and accumulation of flavor-active volatiles, including pyrazines and phenylethyl derivatives. Electronic tongue and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry confirmed elevated umami taste, via increased glutamate and nucleotide levels. Additionally, the fermentation of microalgae with L. plantarum converted aromatic amino acids into antioxidant aromatic lactates, exemplifying catalytic, rather than stoichiometric efficiency. Overall, this renewable fermentation strategy converts photoenergy-fuelled, CO2-derived microalgal biomass into direct functional food ingredients under mild, organic solvent-free conditions, while bypassing conventional downstream extraction and purification steps.
Sustainability spotlightThis work establishes a transformative probiotic fermentation platform using GRAS-certified Lactiplantibacillus plantarum to bio-transform CO2-derived Chlorella vulgaris biomass into functional food ingredients without organic solvents, harsh chemicals, or energy-intensive processing. Operating under mild conditions (37 °C, 72 hours), the platform achieves net-zero waste generation while maintaining biomass integrity—contrasting with 15–40% losses from alternative methods. The biotransformation catalytically converts aromatic amino acids into antioxidant lactates while enhancing umami compounds and eliminating off-flavors, producing ready-to-use functional foods without downstream purification. This sustainable approach directly advances UN SDG 2 (zero hunger) by creating scalable alternative protein sources, SDG 12 (responsible consumption) through complete biomass utilization and waste minimization, and SDG 13 (climate action) by amplifying the carbon-negative impact of microalgal CO2 fixation within circular bioeconomy frameworks. |
Microalgae such as Chlorella can fix CO2 while utilizing solar energy, with photosynthetic efficiency rates substantially higher than terrestrial crops (10–20% versus 1–2%).6 Their rapid life cycles, minimal land footprint, and high fertility, coupled with their rich biochemical composition, render them valuable for producing a wide array of chemicals.7 Additionally, although differences between and within species exist, microalgae generally produce nutrient-dense biomass containing complete protein profiles and valuable bioactive compounds, such as ω-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs), polysaccharides, carotenoids, vitamins, phenolics, and phycobiliproteins.8 Despite their nutritional and environmental merits, challenges related to consumer acceptance hinder the integration of microalgae into mainstream food systems. A key factor among these barriers is the undesirable sensory attributes of microalgae, including intense colour and unpleasant flavours which are commonly described as “fishy,” “grassy,” or “pond-like”, significantly impeding palatability.9 Additionally, the rigid cell walls of many microalgae species limit nutrient bioavailability and digestibility, further reducing their nutritional efficiency.10 These factors have restricted the widespread adoption of microalgae as primary food ingredients despite their exceptional nutritional profiles and environmental credentials.
Biotransformation via microbial fermentation presents an elegant green chemistry solution to these challenges. While microalgae-microbial consortia have been explored for industrial applications, their use for direct food enhancement through probiotic fermentation remains underexplored. By employing carefully selected GRAS edible microorganisms as biocatalysts, the biotransformation of microalgae biomass proceeds without requiring harsh chemicals, high temperatures, or energy-intensive processes. Furthermore, microbial metabolism has the potential to modify the negative organoleptic qualities of microalgae while simultaneously enhancing their nutritional aspects by producing additional bioactive compounds. In this study, we investigate the biotransformation of Chlorella vulgaris microalgal biomass using selected GRAS probiotic bacteria to address the primary limitations hindering the mainstream adoption of microalgal food through a comprehensive platform approach. We employed an enzymatic-based systematic screening pipeline to identify bacterial strains capable of reducing unpleasant sensory attributes while enhancing functional properties, nutrient bioavailability, and bioactive compound profiles. The selected probiotic strain increased the dried biomass weight by 5%, contrasting with the 15–40% weight reduction observed with Bacillus species. Comprehensive analyses using an electronic tongue (E-tongue), olfactory evaluations, liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) confirmed the attenuation of unpleasant flavors and the generation of desirable umami taste and aroma compounds. Collectively, these findings establish a foundation for developing microalgae-based functional foods with improved sensory and nutritional qualities via sustainable biotransformation strategies.
000 plant specimens and 123
000 microbial strains.11 Fermentations were conducted under submerged conditions at 37 °C, followed by freeze-drying and sample extraction for comprehensive chemical and sensory profiling. Analytical outputs were generated using a combination of colorimetric enzyme activity assays, olfactory evaluations, E-tongue measurements, GC-MS and LC-MS. This integrated approach enabled rapid dereplication and high-resolution phenotyping of bacterial fermentates, facilitating the identification of strains and resulting fermentates with desirable nutritional and sensory attributes within the microalgal matrix.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Integrated biotransformation platform showcasing the pipeline for food-grade strain selection, microalgae fermentation, and multi-modal sensory and chemical profiling. | ||
The selected strains were subsequently tested in several enzymatic activity assays, including protease, lipase, β-glucosidase, and cellulase assays. Among the tested strains, Bacillus amyloliquefaciens, Bacillus subtilis, and Lactiplantibacillus plantarum demonstrated the highest levels of enzymatic activities (Fig. 2C and Table S1). Even though B. amyloliquefaciens demonstrated superior enzymatic assay results across the board it also produced strong, undesirable odours that would significantly limit its inclusion rate and consumer appeal in a food matrix. Similarly, B. subtilis showed high enzymatic activity but was associated with biomass degradation and potential off flavours. On the other hand, while the selected L. plantarum strain displayed moderate enzymatic activity and did not show strong protease activity, it excelled in sensory attributes and well-documented health benefits crucial for functional food application. Furthermore, the absence of strong proteolytic activity is fairly advantageous, as excessive protein hydrolysis can lead to bitter peptide formation and off-flavors that compromise product acceptability. Moreover, microalgal proteins—such as those from Chlorella and Spirulina—are highly digestible and exhibit favourable amino acid profiles comparable to conventional protein sources.12 Crucially, this allows greater incorporation of the microalgal ingredient into food products, providing nutritional and functional health benefits without compromising sensory quality.
Given that the enzymatic activity profiles and preliminary sensory evaluation (in-house sniff tests) yielded divergent results regarding optimal strain performance, we decided to use dried weight yield analysis to evaluate the scalability and economic viability of the biotransformation platform by the shortlisted strains. We analysed the variations in dried weight during fermentation, a critical parameter often overlooked in microbial fermentation strategies, where substrate loss can undermine sustainability gains. The dry biomass yield of Chlorella vulgaris was monitored over 72 hours of fermentation with the three bacterial strains. Remarkably, L. plantarum fermentation resulted in a progressive biomass increase, gaining ∼5% by 72 hours, while B. subtilis and B. amyloliquefaciens caused substantial biomass losses of ∼15% and ∼40%, respectively (Fig. 2D). This contrasting behaviour likely reflects fundamental differences in metabolic strategies: while Bacillus species catabolize algal biomass as the electron donor for respiration, L. plantarum demonstrates biomass-preserving metabolism for biosynthetic processes during aerobic fermentation, as previously reported for phylogenetically close Lactobacilli.13 The 45% differential in final biomass between L. plantarum (+5%) and B. amyloliquefaciens (−40%) represents a substantial economic advantage for industrial implementation, where feedstock costs typically dominate operational expenses. This biomass enhancement by L. plantarum reflects multiple synergistic mechanisms: (i) accumulation of non-volatile fermentation metabolites including lactic acid, exopolysaccharides,27,28 and aromatic lactates that are retained during lyophilization; (ii) biomass-preserving facultatively heterofermentative metabolism that preferentially utilizes simple nutrients from the medium rather than catabolizing structural microalgal components; and (iii) catalytic biotransformation of aromatic amino acids into bioactive compounds without degrading the bulk biomass as an energy source. Under aerobic fermentation conditions, L. plantarum maintains redox balance through NADH oxidase-mediated NAD+ regeneration, where oxygen serves as an electron acceptor to produce water or hydrogen peroxide rather than supporting complete oxidative catabolism of the biomass. This contrasts fundamentally with Bacillus species, which employ aerobic respiratory metabolism that oxidizes algal biomass to CO2, resulting in substantial weight losses. The dried weight enhancement by L. plantarum thus transforms the fermentation from a degradative process to an accumulative one, where the microalgal biomass serves as a scaffold for functional metabolite production while maintaining its structural integrity. This effectively amplifies the carbon-negative impact of the microalgae feedstock while generating value-added bioactive compounds.
To confirm this, we used a two-way repeated measures ANOVA—a statistical test that examines how two factors (here, fermentation treatment and time) influence an outcome (odour intensity), while accounting for repeated measurements from the same panellists. There was a significant interaction between treatment and time (P = 0.0188) for grassy odour between the fermented and unfermented samples (declining more in fermented ones). There were no significant main effects for time alone (P = 0.0845) or treatment alone (P = 0.6531), indicating neither factor independently drove the changes without the other. Panellists showed notable differences in their ratings (P < 0.0001), reflecting natural variability in smell perception. Since the data violated the sphericity assumption (a requirement for ANOVA accuracy), we applied the Geisser–Greenhouse correction (ε = 0.8204) to adjust the results. Fermentation also increased sour notes over time. The same ANOVA test also revealed a significant interaction between treatment and time (P = 0.0287) for sour notes, showing that sourness evolved differently based on whether samples were fermented. No significant main effects appeared for time (P = 0.0607) or treatment (P = 0.3431) in isolation (Tables S8–S11). Again, panellist variability was high (P < 0.0001), and we used Geisser–Greenhouse correction for sphericity violation (ε = 0.5751). As negative controls, we assessed fishy and earthy odours, which showed no significant differences (P > 0.05) (Tables S12–S15) between fermented and unfermented samples (Fig. S3), ruling out non-specific effects and strengthening the specificity of grassy and sour changes.
GC-MS analysis corroborated the sensory findings, providing molecular insights into the aroma transformation (Fig. 3C). The volatile profile of microalgae fermented with L. plantarum revealed a significant decrease in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs)-derived aldehydes such as hexanal, 2-octenal, and 4-heptanol, which are typically associated with lipid oxidation and the undesirable “fishy” and “grassy” odours characteristic of microalgae.14 This reduction in off-flavours was accompanied by an increase in more desirable aroma compounds. Fermentation led to the accumulation of flavour-active compounds, including benzaldehyde, phenylethyl alcohol, pyrazines, and ionone derivatives. The increased production of pyrazines contributed to nutty and roasted notes,15 while phenylethyl compounds introduced floral aromas.16 Notably, pyrazines and ionone derivatives have also been identified as key volatiles in matcha, where they contribute to its roasted and floral-violet-like notes, respectively,17 highlighting their potential role in enhancing the sensory appeal of fermented microalgae. By 96 hours of fermentation, however, the aroma began to develop tangy sour notes of L. plantarum-fermented microalgae. PCA analysis, a technique that visualizes data clustering to show differences, of the volatile compounds showed a clear separation between control and fermented samples over time, indicating a dynamic shift in the volatile metabolome induced by bacterial activity. This separation became more pronounced with extended fermentation, highlighting the progressive nature of the sensory transformation. Together, these beneficial volatile profile modifications substantiate L. plantarum's role in enhancing the sensory qualities of Chlorella, providing the foundation for subsequent taste and metabolite analyses.
Additionally, the accumulation of three aromatic acids—indole lactic acid, phenyl lactic acid, and hydroxyphenyl lactic acid—was observed, with concurrent decreases in their amino acid precursors phenylalanine, L-tyrosine, and D-tryptophan (Fig. 4C). These aromatic acids are known for their antioxidant and antimicrobial properties,19 suggesting that L. plantarum fermentation may confer ancillary functional benefits alongside sensory improvements. The metabolite profiles revealed by LC-MS analysis provided mechanistic explanations for the taste changes detected by the E-tongue. The increase in umami compounds in L. plantarum-fermented microalgae likely contributed to the umami-associated PCA shifts, while the production of organic acids possibly influenced the sourness dimension. Altogether, the taste and metabolite enhancements validate the ability of the probiotic-fermented microalgae to produce health-promoting, palatable food ingredients, supporting its sustainability evaluation.
| Green chemistry principle | Probiotic fermentation | Chemical processing | Enzymatic processing | Green advance & literature support |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Data adapted from ref. 20–26. | ||||
| (1) Prevention | Minimal organic waste | High chemical waste (e.g., acidic/alkaline streams, salts) | Moderate enzyme waste | Reduced waste streams |
| (2) Atom economy | >95% theoretical yield | ∼60–70% yields (with losses due to byproducts) | 80–85% yields | Higher atom incorporation |
| (3) Less hazardous synthesis | Water and minerals only | Strong acids/bases (HCl, NaOH, KOH) | Mild enzyme solutions | Eliminates corrosive chemicals |
| (4) Safer solvents | Water-based system | Organic solvents required | Aqueous systems | Zero organic solvents |
| (5) Energy efficiency | 25–45 °C | Often 100–370 °C for thermal–chemical methods | 40–60 °C | Mild temperature operation |
| (6) Catalysis | Whole-cell biocatalyst | Chemical/thermal treatment | Isolated enzymes | Self-contained biocatalysis |
The demonstrated biomass enhancement improves process economics by eliminating typical feedstock losses, while mild fermentation conditions (37 °C, 72 hours) are compatible with existing food fermentation infrastructure. Key scale-up considerations include maintaining consistent inoculum quality and optimizing aeration strategies to preserve the observed biomass-enhancing metabolism across different microalgae batches. In conclusion, through microalgae fermentation by L. plantarum, we achieved a reduction in off-flavour aldehydes, enhancement in umami compounds, and generation of bioactive metabolites—all without chemical additives or complicated downstream processing—thereby advancing microbial fermentation as both a sustainable bioprocessing platform and a practical route to circular food innovation.
Footnote |
| † These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |