Open Access Article
Andriana
Lymperi
,
Alexandros K.
Bikogiannakis
,
Georgios
Kyriakou
and
Alexandros
Katsaounis
*
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Patras, Caratheodory 1, University Campus, GR-26504, Patras, Greece. E-mail: alex.katsaounis@chemeng.upatras.gr
First published on 12th November 2025
This study explores the electrochemical promotion of dry reforming of methane (DRM) and reverse water–gas shift (RWGS) reactions over a ruthenium (Ru) catalyst supported on yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ). Physicochemical properties were examined using a range of surface and structural characterization techniques. Ru remained metallic after reaction, with minor oxidation under high CO2 concentrations. While carbon was detected under all conditions, only oxidizing environments led to the accumulation of oxidized species, indicating surface-bound intermediates. Catalytic behavior was investigated under reducing (PCH4 = 4 kPa, PCO2 = 1 kPa) and stoichiometric (PCH4 = 1 kPa, PCO2 = 1 kPa) conditions. DRM dominated under reducing conditions, while stoichiometric feeds led to competition between DRM and RWGS, showing inverted volcano behavior. Positive polarization (+1 V) enhanced CO production by improving CH4 adsorption, while negative polarization (−1 V) suppressed DRM and favored RWGS. Electrochemical promotion of catalysis (EPOC) was quantified by measuring the rate enhancement ratios (ρ). Under reducing conditions, positive polarization increased DRM rates tenfold at low temperatures, with reduced effect at higher temperatures. In contrast, negative polarization suppressed DRM and promoted RWGS. Under stoichiometric conditions, both reactions were enhanced, with selectivity determined by the polarity of the applied potential. Transient experiments at 380 °C confirmed reversibility of EPOC and its ability to dynamically steer selectivity. Reactive oxygen uptake provided insight into electrochemically active surface area and promotion mechanisms. These findings demonstrate the potential of EPOC to modulate the H2/CO ratio and tailor selectivity in reforming processes, with relevance to renewable energy and biogas utilization.
Broader contextThe growing demand for sustainable carbon management calls for technologies that can convert CO2 and CH4 – two major greenhouse gases – into valuable fuels and chemicals. Dry reforming of methane (DRM) and the reverse water gas shift (RWGS) are attractive routes, but their high energy requirements and limited selectivity hinder practical deployment. In this study, we show that applying a small potential to Ru/YSZ catalysts enables real-time switching between DRM- and RWGS-dominated pathways under isothermal conditions. We demonstrate that positive potentials promote DRM with high CO selectivity, while negative potentials favour RWGS via formate intermediates. This dynamic electrochemical modulation reveals distinct mechanistic regimes and provides external control over carbon conversion routes without structural catalyst changes. Our findings offer a new paradigm for electrified catalysis that couples renewable electricity with carbon valorisation, paving the way for efficient and flexible power-to-fuel systems. These insights are valuable for catalyst design, reactor engineering, and the broader decarbonization agenda. |
The utilization of carbon-rich greenhouse gases as chemical feedstocks represents a highly promising and economically advantageous approach, as it simultaneously mitigates greenhouse gas emissions and enables the synthesis of valuable chemicals and fuels. Among the various reactions explored for this purpose, the dry reforming of methane (DRM) with carbon dioxide (eqn (1)) has garnered significant attention in recent years. This process exploits two of the most potent greenhouse gases –CO2 and CH4– to generate synthesis gas (syngas), a mixture of hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO) with a molar ratio of approximately 1
:
1. Syngas is an essential intermediate in chemical manufacturing, particularly as a precursor in the Fischer–Tropsch synthesis for the production of higher hydrocarbons and alcohols.7 The H2/CO ratio in syngas significantly influences product selectivity in downstream processes. A hydrogen-rich syngas composition tends to favor the formation of methane, light hydrocarbons, and lower alcohols, whereas a carbon monoxide-rich mixture promotes the synthesis of C5+ hydrocarbons and olefins.8–11
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
Parallel to the DRM, carbon dioxide can also react with H2 produced via the DRM process, yielding additional CO and water through the reverse water–gas shift (RWGS) reaction (eqn (2)). This reaction is mildly endothermic and is favored at lower temperatures, resulting in a decrease in the H2/CO ratio to values below unity. In contrast, the DRM reaction is highly endothermic and requires elevated temperatures, typically above 700 °C, for optimal conversion.12 Although these extreme conditions are advantageous for optimizing selectivity toward the DRM and achieving high reactant conversion, they also introduce significant economic and energy inefficiencies. Additionally, the elevated temperatures required for the DRM process can lead to catalyst deactivation, primarily through mechanisms such as sintering or carbon deposition, which substantially reduce the availability of active metal sites.13–15 In this context, two primary reactions are responsible for carbon deposition: the Boudouard reaction (eqn (3)), which is thermodynamically favored at temperatures up to 700 °C, and the methane decomposition reaction (eqn (4)), which occurs at temperatures above 550 °C.15–17
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
Nickel (Ni) catalysts are widely regarded as the benchmark for the DRM due to their high catalytic activity, excellent selectivity, low cost, and the metal's abundance.16,18 Metal oxides, such as Al2O3, TiO2, CeO2, and SiO2, are commonly employed as supports to enhance catalytic performance, improve dispersion, and mitigate agglomeration phenomena.18–26 Other transition metals, including cobalt (Co) and copper (Cu), have also been utilized as DRM catalysts, yielding similarly favorable results, along with some bimetallic catalyst systems.27–29 However, a significant drawback of these metals is their susceptibility to deactivation over time, primarily due to coke formation.16,17 As a result, considerable research has been directed toward the use of noble metal catalysts.13–15 Despite their higher cost, noble metals such as rhodium (Rh),13,14,30–32 ruthenium (Ru),13,14,30,33,34 and iridium (Ir)13,35 have demonstrated superior reactivity, selectivity, and resilience to carbon deposition, making them highly reliable for the DRM process, even at lower reaction temperatures, and exhibiting remarkable stability in long-duration operation.
The majority of studies on the DRM are conducted in fixed-bed reactors, utilizing metal catalysts supported on metal oxide substrates in the form of powders. However, several investigations have explored the use of solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) reactors for this purpose.36–40 These reactors, operating at temperatures exceeding 700 °C, provide an ideal environment for the DRM reaction, and are primarily designed for energy production. In these systems, nickel (Ni) catalysts are commonly employed, deposited directly onto the solid electrolyte, typically Yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ)41–52 or gadolinium-doped ceria (GDC).41,49,51–54 These solid electrolytes function as oxygen ion (O2−) conductors, and under closed-circuit conditions, the migration of oxygen ions to the catalyst surfaces can help mitigate carbon deposition. Additionally, the direct introduction of methane and carbon dioxide into the reactor obviates the need for an external reformer, enabling the simultaneous production of syngas and electricity.51,52
The proposed mechanisms for the DRM reaction vary depending on the catalyst, the metal oxide support, and the reaction conditions, with two primary reaction pathways commonly cited in the literature. For systems employing redox-active supports, the Langmuir–Hinshelwood–Hougen–Watson (LHHW) kinetic model is typically applied.14,26,55–61 This bifunctional mechanism suggests that CO2 is primarily adsorbed onto the support, while CH4 adsorbs onto the active metal. The redox nature of the support facilitates the molecular adsorption of CO2, leading to the formation of intermediate carbonate species and adsorbed oxygen. These carbonate species subsequently transform into adsorbed CO, while the adsorbed oxygen locally oxidizes the redox support. Methyl species, generated from the dissociative adsorption of methane on the catalyst surface, then react with the oxidized support to produce formate species, which eventually decompose into CO. The remaining hydrogen on the catalyst surface desorbs as molecular hydrogen. In this model, the rate-determining step is the activation of methane through hydrogen abstraction. Alternatively, the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model14,55,56,62 suggests that both CO2 and CH4 are dissociatively adsorbed onto the catalyst surface. In this case, methane is fully dehydrogenated, and the adsorbed carbon reacts with oxygen derived from the decomposition of CO2. However, catalytic systems following this pathway are prone to significant deactivation due to coke formation.
The majority of the experimental studies on the DRM reaction presented in the literature are conducted under high-temperature conditions, as these conditions are thermodynamically favorable. However, catalyst deactivation resulting from coke deposition, agglomeration, and the high operational costs associated with such systems hinder the industrial scalability of the DRM process. Consequently, the development of a catalytic system that can effectively operate at lower reaction temperatures, while achieving optimal H2/CO ratios and efficient reactant conversion, is critical for advancing the DRM process.
A possible solution to the challenges associated with the DRM reaction is the application of the principles underlying the electrochemical promotion of catalysis (EPOC) phenomenon.63,64 Also referred to as non-faradaic electrochemical modification of catalytic activity (NEMCA), EPOC offers an alternative to conventional chemical promotion and can be employed to enhance catalyst performance during polarization.63–68 This technique involves the application of a constant electrical potential or current between a conductive catalyst film and a counter electrode, both deposited on a solid electrolyte. This setup induces the migration of ionic species to and from the catalyst surface. The electropositive or electronegative ions, derived from the solid electrolyte, act as promoting agents, which can be introduced to the catalyst surface in a controlled, predictable, and reversible manner at the three-phase boundary—where the catalyst, solid electrolyte, and reaction mixture interface. The migration of these ions leads to the formation of a neutral effective electrochemical double layer, which significantly modifies the catalyst's work function, Φ, by ΔΦ = e·ΔU.63,69 This change in work function, in turn, alters the strength of the chemisorptive bonds between the reactant and intermediate species and the catalytic surface. Consequently, this alters the surface coverage of the catalyst, ultimately influencing catalytic activity and selectivity for various reactions.
The electrochemical promotion of catalysis (EPOC) phenomenon has been extensively studied for various catalytic reactions,63,67 employing different solid electrolytes with varying ionic conductivities, such as O2− ions for yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ),70–73 titanium dioxide (TiO2),74 ceria (CeO2),75 H+ ions for yttrium-doped barium zirconate (BZY),76,77 and Na+ and K+ ions for β″-Al2O3.78 Additionally, a wide range of catalysts have been investigated, including noble metals,71,78–80 transition metals,70,81 metal oxides,82 bimetallic catalysts,82,83 and nanoparticles.76,80–82 In these studies, two primary parameters are typically used to quantify the EPOC effect,63 as described by the following equations:
| ρ = r/r0 | (5) |
| Λ = Δr/I(n·F) | (6) |
Eqn (5) defines the rate enhancement ratio, ρ, which compares the electropromoted reaction rate, r, under polarization conditions to the catalytic rate, r0, under open-circuit conditions. The apparent faradaic efficiency, Λ, given by eqn (6), quantifies the magnitude of the EPOC phenomenon by comparing the change in the catalytic rate during polarization, Δr = r − r0, to the rate of ion migration to the catalytic surface, I/nF, where I is the applied current, n is the ion change, and F is the Faraday constant.
Based on the reaction rate behavior under negative and positive polarization conditions, four distinct types of behavior can be identified.84 If the reaction rate increases with increasing applied potential, the reaction is classified as electrophobic. Conversely, if the reaction rate decreases with increasing applied potential, it is referred to as electrophilic. When the reaction rate reaches a maximum at a specific applied potential, the reaction is characterized as volcano-type. Finally, when the reaction rate increases for both negative and positive applied potentials, reaching a minimum, the reaction follows an inverted-volcano type behavior.
This study investigates the electrochemical promotion of the DRM reaction under low-temperature conditions. A ruthenium (Ru) catalyst is employed, as previous research has demonstrated its excellent stability and selectivity for the DRM reaction, while successfully suppressing the undesirable parallel RWGS reaction even under low temperature conditions with minimal catalyst deactivation.14,30,55 Furthermore, previous EPOC studies have shown its stability under constant polarization conditions leading to limited electrochemical degradation and catalyst deactivation.68,72,73 It is important to emphasize that Ni-based catalysts are widely acknowledged as the state-of-the-art materials for DRM, particularly under high-temperature conditions, due to their favorable activity and relatively low cost. However, one of the key challenges associated with Ni systems is their propensity toward carbon deposition and deactivation, especially at lower operating temperatures. In contrast, Ru-based catalysts, although more expensive, exhibit significantly higher resistance to coking and maintain high selectivity toward DRM over competing side reactions. In the present study, we emphasize these advantages by operating under comparatively mild conditions, where intrinsic kinetic effects can be directly probed.
The Ru catalytic film is deposited onto an yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) solid electrolyte pellet, enabling the utilization of O2− ions as promoters during polarization. These ions are introduced to the catalytic surface in a predictable and fully reversible way in order to alter the work function of the Ru catalyst resulting in activity and selectivity modifications, as well as protecting the catalyst from deactivation due to carbon deposition.49,51 The primary objective of this study is twofold. First, the reaction is conducted under low-temperature conditions to reduce the high energy demands associated with temperatures above 700 °C. However, under these conditions, CH4 and CO2 conversion is significantly lower, DRM reaction is not thermodynamically favored, and selectivity is substantially shifted towards the RWGS reaction. To address this challenge, both positive and negative polarization potentials are applied to modulate selectivity towards the DRM reaction, suppress the RWGS pathway, and achieve a hydrogen-to-carbon monoxide (H2/CO) ratio as close to unity as possible, while simultaneously increasing overall reactant conversion. A comprehensive kinetic investigation, complemented by both catalytic and electrocatalytic experiments, was conducted to achieve the aforementioned objectives. When benchmarked against reported low-temperature DRM systems, our Ru/YSZ catalyst demonstrates competitive or superior activity while simultaneously suppressing the undesired RWGS pathway, particularly under electrochemical promotion. These findings underscore the potential of Ru/YSZ as a model system for exploring EPOC in DRM, while also providing insight into strategies that could enhance the performance of more economically viable catalysts, such as Ni. To the best of our knowledge, no similar study has been reported in the existing literature.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 XRD pattern of Ru film on YSZ after reduction pre-treatment (fresh sample) (bottom) and after all experiments (used sample) (top). | ||
SEM images of the fresh and used sample, shown in Fig. 2, reveal a highly porous microstructure consisting of Ru particle clusters. The fresh sample after the reduction pre-treatment step (Fig. 2(a) and (b)) appears to be quite uniform showing well-defined Ru particles creating a cohesive metallic film. The line scan analysis of the sample presented in Fig. S1 clearly demonstrates that the surface is composed of Zr and Y, that correspond to the YSZ pellet, and Ru which is the main domain. It is worth noting that even if the surface does not appear entirely uniform, the EDS analysis of the line scan clearly shows that the surface is predominantly covered by Ru particles, while the Zr and Y signals are very weak compared to the Ru one. The corresponding particle size distribution can be seen in Fig. 2(c). After measuring more than 500 particles form multiple SEM images, the mean particle size was 28.9 ± 9.3 nm, while the Ru nanoparticles appear to be mostly spherical.
Fig. S2(a) and (b) demonstrate a representative SEM image of the cross section of the catalytic sample paired with a line scan of the cross section, respectively. The SEM image shows a uniform thin Ru film with a thickness of around 500 nm. Ru nanoparticles seem to have infiltrated to the first few layers of the YSZ pellet, which have been corroborated by the line scan analysis of the cross section. Specifically, moving from right to left in Fig. S2(b), firstly, the Ru signal appears to be as high as 100% with weak signals of Y and Zr corresponding to the YSZ pellet. Moving further into the pellet, the Ru signal weakens and becomes almost comparable to that of Zr, indicating a limited region of metal diffusion into the solid electrolyte. After that, the Zr signal is dominant and there is almost no interaction between the solid electrolyte pellet and the Ru metallic film.
A very similar behavior to that of the fresh sample can be seen in Fig. 2(d) and (e). The used Ru sample maintained its porous nanostructure; however, some structural changes have been induced. The metallic film now consists of larger Ru clusters of small particles showing evidence of limited agglomeration phenomena after all experiments were conducted. Nevertheless, the spherical structure of the particles remains the same and the mean particle size increases only by little, 30.2 ± 11.4 nm (Fig. 2(f)). These observations are in great agreement with the XRD analysis of Fig. 1.
It should be noted here that these minimal structural changes, especially regarding the particle size distribution of Ru nanoparticles, are not consistent with existing literature on metal supported catalysts on redox supports.85–88 Specifically, while in previous work Ru has been reported to undergo dynamic structural changes during the reaction, this was normally attributed to the redox nature of the support and not an inherent property of Ru. Since YSZ does not act as a redox support in the classical sense, only as a means for oxygen ion migration, profound structural changes are unlikely, as shown in the XRD and SEM images of the sample pre and post reaction.
Fig. S3 presents the EDS analysis of the Ru/YSZ sample, which confirms the presence of ruthenium, yttrium, zirconium, and oxygen in the used sample, with minimal carbon content, consistent with expectations after the completion of the experiments. Carbon presence in the sample was further validated through X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis.
Fig. 3 shows the XPS spectra of the Ru 3d region for the Ru catalyst sample after four different treatment conditions. Specifically, Ru/YSZ. 1 corresponds to the fresh after reduction sample, while Ru/YSZ. 2, 3 and 4 were obtained after 10 to 12 hours of experiment under reducing (PCO2 = 1 kPa, PCH4 = 4 kPa), stoichiometric (PCO2 = 1 kPa, PCH4 = 1 kPa) and oxidizing (PCO2 = 2 kPa, PCH4 = 1 kPa) conditions respectively. After the deconvolution of the obtained spectra, one can observe the asymmetric doublet Ru 3d5/2–Ru 3d3/2 at 280.0 and 284.1 eV respectively, confirming the Ru0 metallic state of the catalytic film in all four samples. However, only when the sample is exposed to excess amounts of CO2 (Ru/YSZ. 4), the oxidized state of Ru appears, with two additional peaks appearing at 280.7 and 284.8 eV. These peaks correspond to the RuO2 structure resulting in the broadening of the Ru 3d doublet and its shift to slightly higher binding energies. The formation of these peaks provides evidence of the redox cycles that take place on the catalytic surface during the reaction. Specifically, the excess amount of CO2 is capable of forming stable RuO2 on the catalytic surface, whilst under all other conditions, while it is highly likely that under reaction conditions Ru undergoes redox cycles, these RuOX species are unstable and dissolve under the reaction mixture. Moreover, in the same figure, one can observe the overlapping C 1s region. Comparing the reduced sample with those after reaction conditions, careful deconvolution reveals that the carbon content of the surface does not increase after reducing and stoichiometric conditions, as the intensity of the C 1s peak at 284.8 eV corresponding to C–C, C–H groups remains practically constant. However, after oxidizing conditions, the wider and stronger contribution for the apparent 3d3/2 peak, in combination with the evident tail formed at higher binding energies is evidence of carbon peaks that appear at 286.4 and 288.8 eV due to the formation of C
O and O–C
O groups, as well as the increased intensity of the 284.8 eV peak, confirming the acute carbon formation when excess amount of CO2 is present in the reactant feed. The peaks arising from oxidized carbon species can be attributed to reactant intermediates which remain bonded to the catalytic surface. Finally, high resolution scans of the Cl 2p region (not shown here) revealed no presence of remnant chloride on the catalytic surface, following sample preparation. This extended XPS analysis confirms that Ru remains predominantly metallic under reducing and stoichiometric conditions, with stable RuO2 features forming only under oxidizing conditions. These findings directly highlight the redox behavior of the Ru film during reaction and address the role of Ru oxidation states under different environments.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 XPS spectra of Ru 3d and C 1s region for the Ru film after being subjected to various treatments. | ||
The combined SEM/EDS and XPS analyses confirm that the Ru layer remains structurally uniform and predominantly metallic under reaction conditions, with only limited oxidation observed in strongly oxidizing environments. This stability of Ru0 is directly correlated with the observed high selectivity toward DRM over RWGS, underscoring the crucial role of the Ru/YSZ interface in maintaining catalytic performance during electrochemical promotion.
While the SEM results confirm that morphological restructuring of Ru is minimal under the investigated conditions, the XPS data suggest that dynamic changes in the oxidation state-particularly under electrochemical polarization-may play a more decisive role in governing the catalytic behavior, highlighting the central importance of redox-driven surface dynamics in the manifestation of the EPOC effect.
The data indicate that the reaction rates initially increase with increasing volumetric flow rate, reaching a plateau at a flow rate of 200 cm3 min−1. This plateau suggests that mass transfer effects become negligible beyond this flow rate, and therefore, a flow rate of 200 cm3 min−1 was chosen for subsequent experiments.
Fig. 4(a) depicts the influence of CH4 partial pressure on the rate of carbon monoxide (CO) production via the DRM and the RWGS reactions. In this analysis, the partial pressure of carbon dioxide and the reaction temperature were kept constant at 1 kPa and 400 °C, respectively. The data demonstrate a monotonic increase in CO production via the DRM pathway with increasing CH4 concentration, indicating a positive reaction order with respect to CH4 for the DRM reaction. Conversely, the CO production rate associated with the RWGS reaction initially increases, reaching a maximum at a CH4 partial pressure of 2 kPa, beyond which a gradual decline is observed. This peak suggests that, under low CH4 partial pressure conditions, competitive adsorption of CO2 on the Ru catalyst surface facilitates its reaction with H2 generated from DRM. However, as the CH4 partial pressure continues to rise, the increased surface coverage of the catalyst by CH4 likely inhibits CO2 adsorption, in agreement with mechanistic studies indicating preferential adsorption of CH4 over CO2 on Ru-based active sites.14,55,89 Consequently, the surface CO2/H2 ratio decreases, resulting in a diminished RWGS reaction rate despite the elevated H2 production.
Fig. 4(b) illustrates the dependence of the reaction rates on CO2 partial pressure, with the CH4 partial pressure fixed at 1 kPa. Initially, both DRM and RWGS reaction rates increase with increasing CO2 partial pressure. However, beyond a threshold of approximately 1 kPa, the reaction rates exhibit a negative dependence on CO2 partial pressure, indicative of inhibitory effects at higher CO2 concentrations.
According to the principles of electrochemical and chemical promotion,84 the DRM reaction is predicted to be primarily electrophobic, as its rate is positively correlated with the electron-donor reactant (CH4) and negatively correlated with the electron-acceptor reactant (CO2). Conversely, at low CH4 partial pressures and a stoichiometric reactant ratio, the RWGS reaction is expected to exhibit inverted volcano behavior, with its rate increasing with both electron-donor and electron-acceptor partial pressures. At higher partial pressures of both reactants, the reaction rate is anticipated to follow a volcano behavior, where the rate decreases with further increase in reactant concentrations.
In prior catalytic studies on the dry reforming of methane over noble metal catalysts,41,42,49 typically conducted at temperatures above 600 °C, a decrease in the CO2/CH4 ratio was shown to promote carbon deposition via methane decomposition. This led to the inevitable deactivation of the catalyst due to a significant reduction in the active sites on the catalyst surface. However, since the activation of the methane decomposition reaction occurs at temperatures higher than 550 °C,15,16 the temperature range selected in this study eliminates this issue. The increased methane concentration in the feed mixture enhances the catalyst's surface coverage with methane, thus promoting a shift in selectivity towards the DRM reaction, as observed in the kinetic analysis.
Another important consideration is the availability of biogas, which can serve as the feed gas in similar studies. Biogas, a by-product of anaerobic biological waste treatment, typically contains 50–75% CH4 and 25–50% CO2, depending on the waste source.90–92 Consequently, studying both stoichiometric and reducing conditions is particularly relevant, as biogas could be utilized as a raw material in dry reforming of methane processes, positioning it as a renewable energy source.91
Furthermore, using an inlet mixture with a high CO2 concentration is less viable within the studied temperature range. Catalyst characterization by XPS (Fig. 3) revealed significant carbon deposition and gradual catalyst deactivation after extended experimental durations.
Finally, for the electrochemical promotion of the Ru catalyst, polarization at ±1 V was selected, as this potential was found to induce a pronounced promotional effect on both catalytic reactions, as discussed in the following section. Although the application of potentials significantly exceeding |1| V could, in principle, further enhance the rate of CO formation, such conditions introduce a considerable risk of structural degradation of the YSZ electrolyte, ultimately compromising both its mechanical integrity and its ionic/electronic conductivity.93,94 Therefore, operating at 1 V constitutes an optimal compromise, as it ensures substantial electrochemical promotion of the Ru catalyst while simultaneously preserving the long-term structural and functional stability of the YSZ electrolyte.
Fig. S6(b) and Fig. 5(b) illustrate the temperature dependence of reaction rates under stoichiometric feed conditions. Compared to reducing conditions, the overall conversions are substantially lower, primarily due to the excess methane in the feed, which results in nearly threefold greater conversion of the limiting reactant (CO2). Under open-circuit and positive polarization (U = +1 V), the temperature-dependent trends in reaction rates are qualitatively similar to those observed under reducing conditions. However, under negative polarization (U = −1 V), a markedly different behavior emerges. At temperatures below 360 °C, all reaction rates approach zero, indicating a near-complete suppression of the DRM reaction. Above 360 °C, both CH4 and CO2 consumption rates increase, with CO2 consumption exhibiting a steeper rise. This suggests that both DRM and RWGS reactions are promoted at elevated temperatures under negative polarization, deviating significantly from the trends observed under reducing conditions. This shift indicates a complex interplay between temperature, feed composition, and polarization that modulates catalytic activity.
Fig. 6 presents the steady-state effect of temperature on the H2/CO ratio. Under open-circuit conditions, the H2/CO ratio increases with temperature, reaching values of 0.57 for reducing and 0.37 for stoichiometric conditions at 400 °C. When a positive potential is applied, the H2/CO ratio experiences a substantial increase, achieving values as high as 0.8 and 0.6 for reducing and stoichiometric conditions, respectively, even at the lowest temperatures. Previous thermocatalytic studies13–15,33 on DRM using supported Ru catalysts suggest that such high selectivity toward DRM, reflected in elevated H2/CO ratios, is typically only attainable at temperatures above 600 °C due to thermodynamic constraints. Even in studies95–101 using the state-of-the-art catalyst for the DRM reaction, Ni, on different supports, the selectivity at such low temperatures shifts greatly towards the RWGS reaction resulting in low H2/CO ratio. Similarly to the Ru supported catalysts, elevated temperatures, usually higher than 550 °C depending on the supported Ni catalyst, are suggested in order to achieve H2/CO ratios as high as 0.6 under stoichiometric reaction conditions. However, the modification of the Ru catalyst work function by the migration of oxygen ions to the gas–catalyst–solid electrolyte interface leads to the formation of an adsorbed CH4 “barrier.” This barrier impedes further reaction of the limited CO2 with the H2 produced from the DRM reaction, significantly suppressing the RWGS pathway and thereby enhancing the H2/CO ratio.
In contrast, negative polarization shifts the system's selectivity dramatically, such that the majority of the H2 produced from the DRM reaction is consumed in the RWGS reaction for further CO production, resulting in a reduction in the H2/CO ratio. Under certain conditions, particularly at lower temperatures, the DRM reaction can be nearly completely suppressed, leading to no H2 production, and the RWGS reaction is unable to proceed due to the absence of its limiting reactant. This phenomenon is evident in Fig. 5, where, at temperatures as low as 320 °C for reducing and 340 °C for stoichiometric conditions, no CO is produced under negative polarization, despite lower light-off temperatures observed under open-circuit conditions.
To quantify the electrochemical enhancement of the reaction rates presented in Fig. 5 and Fig. S6, the rate enhancement ratio, ρ, is utilized. Fig. 7 displays the steady-state temperature dependence of the rate enhancement ratio for CO production via the DRM and RWGS reactions.
Under reducing conditions (Fig. 7(a)), the rate enhancement ratio for the DRM reaction reaches a maximum value of 10, indicating a tenfold increase in the reaction rate at the lowest temperature with the application of a positive potential (+1 V). As temperature increases, the rate enhancement gradually decreases, reaching a value of ρCO = 2 at 400 °C. However, as shown in Fig. 6(a), despite the reduced overall promotion of CO production at higher temperatures, the H2/CO ratio remains exceptionally high across the studied temperature range. Application of a negative potential significantly suppresses the DRM reaction, with the rate enhancement ratio approaching zero. At temperatures above 360 °C, the system's selectivity shifts entirely to the RWGS reaction, where the rate enhancement ratio for CO production via RWGS exceeds unity. Regarding the RWGS reaction, application of a positive potential consistently increases the reaction rate compared to open-circuit conditions, although the enhancement never exceeds 50% (ρRWGS < 1.5).
Under stoichiometric conditions (Fig. 7(b)), the rate enhancement of both DRM and RWGS reactions is notably higher, with ρ values of 30 and 10, respectively, at the lowest temperature. As with reducing conditions, the promotion of both reactions diminishes with increasing temperature, with ρDRM = 3.25 and ρRWGS = 1.75 at 400 °C. Interestingly, negative polarization also exerts a beneficial effect on both reactions. Below 360 °C, no CO is produced due to complete suppression of the DRM reaction; however, at higher temperatures, the rate enhancement ratio increases, with a 25% increase in the DRM rate (ρDRM = 1.25) and a 100% increase in the RWGS rate (ρRWGS = 2) at the highest temperature.
Fig. 8 illustrates the transient effect of the continuous application of both positive and negative potentials on the consumption rates and conversion of CH4 and CO2, as well as the total CO production rate, at a constant temperature of 380 °C. The corresponding current response is also shown in the figure.
Under open-circuit conditions (Fig. 8(a), excess CH4), the total CO production rate initially stabilizes at approximately 3 × 10−8 mol s−1, with a corresponding H2/CO ratio of 0.5. At all times, the CO2 consumption rate is higher than that of CH4, as CO2 is also consumed in the parallel RWGS reaction. Upon application of a positive potential (+1 V), which induces the migration of oxygen ions (O2−) onto the Ru catalyst surface, there is a significant increase in CO production, accompanied by higher consumption rates of both CH4 and CO2. This migration of O2− ions increases the catalyst work function (Φ), thereby strengthening the adsorption of CH4 (electron donor) to the catalyst surface. Consequently, CO production increases rapidly, reaching a rate of 7.15 × 10−8 mol s−1, and the reaction system's selectivity shifts toward the DRM reaction, resulting in a H2/CO ratio of 0.75. The corresponding rate enhancement ratios for the DRM and RWGS reactions under these conditions are 2.8 and 1.2, respectively, indicating electrochemical promotion of both reactions.
In contrast, application of a negative potential leads to the migration of oxygen ions away from the catalyst surface, resulting in a decrease in the catalyst's work function. This enhances the Ru–CO2 adsorption bond and shifts the system's selectivity toward the RWGS reaction, resulting in a decrease in the total CO production rate. Under these conditions, the H2/CO ratio is reduced to 0.1, with rate enhancement ratios of 0.44 for the DRM reaction and 1.08 for the RWGS reaction. Upon interruption of the applied potential, all reaction rates return to their initial values, confirming the reversibility of the electrochemical promotion of catalysis (EPOC) phenomenon.
Under stoichiometric conditions (Fig. 8(b)), the application of a positive potential yields results comparable to those observed under reducing conditions. Specifically, the total CO production rate increases from 0.5 × 10−8 to 2.4 × 10−8 mol s−1, with the H2/CO ratio rising to 0.58, relative to the open-circuit value of 0.35. This enhancement reflects a more pronounced promotion of both reactions, with the DRM and RWGS reaction rates increasing by factors of 5.25 and 3.1, respectively.
In contrast, negative polarization induces a distinct behavior. Under these conditions, the equimolar CH4/CO2 feed appears to facilitate a more extensive promotion of CO production via both reaction pathways (ρDRM = 1.25 and ρRWGS = 2.7). Although the product distribution again shifts in favor of the RWGS pathway (as indicated by an H2/CO ratio approaching zero), the increased availability of CO2 allows for more effective adsorption on the Ru catalytic surface. This, in turn, promotes its subsequent reaction with the H2 produced, resulting in an overall increase in CO production.
The potentiostatic transient profiles (Fig. 8) may also be employed to estimate the reactive oxygen uptake (NG) of the Ru catalyst, which serves as a measure of the active catalytic surface area. This estimation is based on the determination of the relaxation time constant (τ), defined as the time required for the rate enhancement (Δr) to reach 63% of its final steady-state value. Assuming a 1
:
1 stoichiometry between surface metal active sites and adsorbed oxygen atoms, the following equation can be applied to calculate the magnitude of τ:
| τ = 2FNG/I. | (7) |
The steady-state effect of the applied potential on CO production via the DRM and RWGS reactions, along with the corresponding H2/CO product ratio at a constant temperature of 380 °C, is presented in Fig. 9. The associated CH4 and CO2 consumption rates, conversions, and product selectivities as a function of applied potential are shown in Fig. S8. The open-circuit potential (OCP) was measured to be approximately −0.2 V. Prior to the onset of CO production in all experiments, the OCP exhibited positive values around +0.1 V. However, as the temperature increased and approached the light-off point, the potential dropped rapidly to a minimum negative value, coinciding with the initiation of CO formation. Ultimately, the potential stabilized at values between −0.4 V and −0.1 V, depending on the reaction temperature-with lower temperatures corresponding to more negative open-circuit potentials.
As shown in Fig. 9(a), the CO production rate via the DRM pathway increases significantly with increasing applied potential under reducing conditions, accompanied by a parallel rise in the H2/CO ratio. In contrast, the RWGS reaction rate displays only minor changes as a function of applied potential, exhibiting a slight decline under both anodic and cathodic polarization. These results suggest that DRM exhibits electrophobic behavior, whereas RWGS follows a volcano-type trend with respect to applied potential. This interpretation is further supported by Fig. 10(a), which illustrates the rate enhancement ratios of the two reactions as functions of the applied potential. Notably, the RWGS reaction shows a peak near the open-circuit potential, with the rate enhancement ratio diminishing as the potential deviates in either direction, thereby reinforcing the characterization of RWGS as displaying volcano-type electrochemical behavior.
Under stoichiometric conditions (Fig. 9(b)), the potential-dependent behavior of the DRM and RWGS reactions exhibits a distinct deviation from that observed under reducing conditions. Although the H2/CO ratio continues to increase with more positive applied potentials, similar to the trend under reducing conditions, the reaction rates of both DRM and RWGS follow a different pattern. Specifically, CO production via the DRM reaction increases under both anodic and cathodic polarization, with a more pronounced enhancement at positive potentials. A comparable trend is observed for the RWGS reaction, where the CO production rate also rises on either side of the potential axis. These findings are further corroborated by the data presented in Fig. 10(b), which illustrates the rate enhancement ratios under stoichiometric conditions. The symmetric increase in reaction rates at both positive and negative potentials indicates an inverted volcano-type behavior for both the DRM and RWGS pathways, suggesting that moderate deviations from the open-circuit potential, regardless of direction, promote surface reactivity under stoichiometric feeds.
Electronic flowmeters from Brooks Instruments were used to regulate the total flow rate and gas feed composition. Certified gas mixtures, including 5% CH4/He (Sol Group), 5% CO2/He (Linde Hellas), and 99.999% He (Linde Hellas), were combined to achieve the desired reactant ratios. All experiments were conducted under reducing (PCO2
:
PCH4 = 1
:
4) and stoichiometric (PCO2
:
PCH4 = 1
:
1) conditions, with a total flow rate of 200 cm3 min−1, at atmospheric pressure and temperatures ranging from 260 to 400 °C. The outlet gas mixture was analyzed using an infrared gas analyzer from Fuji Electric in conjunction with a Shimadzu GC-2010 Plus gas chromatograph, equipped with a ValcoPlot Molesieve column. Constant potentials and currents were applied using an Amel 7050 potentiostat–galvanostat.
Ka= 1.542 Å. The scanning angle ranged between 2θ = 20–80° and the major peaks were identified in comparison with library values (JPCDS). A Zeiss Supra 35 field emission, variable pressure scanning electron microscope was used to obtain SEM images. The microscope was equipped with a Bruker AXS energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS).
The reduced and after reaction treatment samples were swiftly transported from the single pellet reactor to an Ultra high vacuum (UHV) system, in order to minimize exposure to atmospheric conditions. Following incorporation into the main UHV chamber, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements took place, utilizing an AlKα anode (1486.6 eV) at settings of 12 kV potential and 20 mA emission current. Analysis of ejected photoelectrons took place with a Leybold LH EA11 electron energy analyzer, which was operated at 100 eV pass energy. Spectral analysis took place using the XPS PEAK 4.1 software. The Ru 3d peak deconvolution was performed as reported in,102 following the subtraction of a Shirley background.
In contrast to conventional catalytic systems with fixed activity and selectivity, the electrochemically promoted Ru/YSZ catalyst enables dynamic, reversible tuning between DRM and RWGS pathways, offering precise control over product distribution, H2/CO ratio and enhanced performance at lower temperatures. The utilization of a scaled-up monolithic electrochemically promoted type reactor (MEPR)103 can eliminate the low reactants’ conversion problem that was present in this study, leading to a more industrially applicable solution. Moreover, the results highlight the potential of biogas, a renewable and sustainable methane source, as a viable feedstock for low-temperature reforming processes. In contrast to previous EPOC studies, this work leads a pathway to the practical use of a renewable fuel for the on-site production of syngas and its direct integration into industrial processes. The application of electrochemical promotion thus presents a promising avenue for advancing methane reforming technologies toward more energy-efficient and environmentally sustainable solutions.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |