Open Access Article
Rafał A. Grzelczak†
,
Daniel Wiendlocha†
and
Bartosz Szyszko
*
Faculty of Chemistry, University of Wrocław, 14 F. Joliot-Curie St., 50-383 Wrocław, Poland. E-mail: bartosz.szyszko@uwr.edu.pl; Web: https://www.bszyszko.pl
First published on 25th May 2026
This feature article discusses advances in mechanically interlocked molecules comprising porphyrin or porphyrin-like frameworks, as well as systems in which porphyrinoid structural elements were integrated into interlocked architectures to impart specific functions, such as energy and electron transfer, molecular recognition, catalytic activity, and controlled dynamic operation. The review article traces the field's development from early examples of porphyrin-containing catenanes and rotaxanes to more recent systems in which porphyrinoid stations were deliberately engineered to fulfill defined functional roles. In the final section, the group's contributions to the research area are presented. This includes the progressive development of an iminopyrrole-based self-assembly methodology that enabled the construction of increasingly complex structures – from two-dimensional macrocycles, through capsular assemblies, to metal-stabilized mechanically interlocked molecules. Finally, the synthesis of rotaxanes and catenanes comprising calix[4]phyrins is outlined, demonstrating systems that exhibit a specific type of molecular motion termed fluttering.
Although the fields of pyrrole-based dyes, on the one hand, and mechanically interlocked molecules, on the other, initially developed at different rates and along largely independent trajectories, they began to converge at several key stages.13 This convergence became particularly evident in the context of rotaxane research, where structural motifs were sought that were sufficiently large to function as stoppers, while also fulfilling roles beyond purely structural ones. Porphyrin motifs were intended to impart added value to MIMs by introducing versatile coordination properties and attractive photophysical features.14–16 Owing, in part, to the seminal contributions of Sauvage, Stoddart, Sanders, Hunter, Anderson, and others, the two areas increasingly informed one another, enabling the transfer of concepts and synthetic strategies.17–28
This article focuses on the points of contact between porphyrinoids and the chemistry of rotaxanes and catenanes. Accordingly, mechanically interlocked systems incorporating classic porphyrin macrocycle are discussed only briefly, particularly in light of the extensive reviews and authoritative accounts by Sauvage and others.13–16,29 In contrast, interlocked architectures built from porphyrinoids30,31 – macrocyclic frameworks related to, but distinct from, porphyrins, as well as their derived structural elements – have not yet been systematically reviewed.
This topic has recently become an important line of investigation in our research group at the University of Wrocław. Our interest is motivated by the unusual opportunities that arise from combining pyrrolic macrocycles exhibiting remarkable aromaticity,32,33 conformational flexibility,34 intriguing stereochemistry,35,36 peculiar reactivity,30,37 stabilization of uncommon oxidation states,38–40 chemically robust organometallic motifs,41 and access to multiple electronic states42 – with the defining attributes of mechanically interlocked molecules. Mechanical bonding enables control over molecular motion,43,44 enforces proximity between interacting components,45 and allows tuning of structure, properties, and reactivity that is impossible with conventional covalent design.46
The feature article opens with an overview of the field's historical context and a discussion of the work of research groups that laid the foundations for the area. We then outline what we regard as the most important advances in this field, before presenting selected examples of our recent work on the construction of compounds that may, in a broad sense, be described as mechanically interlocked porphyrinoids (MIPs).
Using their copper(I)-based passive template approach, the Sauvage group constructed [2]rotaxanes featuring a bent axle bearing two metalloporphyrins at its termini (Fig. 1, type A).17 A central 2,9-diphenyl-1,10-phenanthroline recognition site was incorporated into axle 1, enabling the formation of a coordination compound upon reaction with a crown ether 2 functionalized with a complementary phenanthroline motif (Scheme 1). The synthesis required the preformation of a copper(I)-stabilized prerotaxane 3 bearing a benzaldehyde functionality at one end of the thread, followed by its condensation with dipyrromethane and 3,5-di-tert-butylbenzaldehyde in the presence of TFA. Subsequent oxidation of the initially formed porphyrinogen with chloranil, followed by metalation, afforded the conjugated porphyrin stopper in 4. The extension of this methodology afforded higher-order systems, including [3]- 5 and [5]rotaxanes 6 (Fig. 1, types B and C, Scheme 2).18,49 Removal of the Cu(I) template from the [3]rotaxane by complexation with cyanides afforded a molecule featuring a thread terminated with metalloporphyrins.50 The Stoddart group, on the other hand, designed [2]rotaxane 7 composed of the tetracationic blue-box cyclophane assembled around a long polyether chain and terminated with zinc(II) porphyrins connected through their meso-aryl positions (Fig. 1, type D).19 Incorporation of two bis(aryloxo) stations within the thread enabled observation of a shuttling process, characterized by a rate constant of 25 s−1 at −10 °C and a free-energy barrier of 13.6 kcal mol−1 (Scheme 3).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Selected geometric types of rotaxanes and catenanes comprising porphyrin macrocycle(s). Various metals incorporated into the porphyrin cavity were depicted as a red sphere. | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 The synthesis of [2]rotaxane 4.17 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 (A) [3]Rotaxane 5 and (B) [5]rotaxane 6.18,50 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 [2]Rotaxane-based molecular shuttle 7.19 | ||
The affinity of metalloporphyrins toward N-donor ligands has been exploited in the construction of rotaxanes in which a d-block metal coordination compound of a tetrapyrrole acted as a stopper, coordinatively attached to the termini of a rotaxane axle bearing ligand units such as pyridine (Fig. 1, types E and F). The first example of such a system was reported by Branda and coworkers, who designed a self-assembling [2]rotaxane composed of dibenzo[24]crown-8 and a 1,2-bis(4,4′-dipyridinium)ethane dicationic thread terminated with 4-pyridyl groups. Upon introduction of carbonyl (tetraphenylporphyrinato)ruthenium(II), possessing one vacant axial coordination site, into a solution of the pseudorotaxane, end-capping occurred at the termini of the axle, transforming the pseudorotaxane species into a [2]rotaxane 8 through the formation of hexacoordinate Ru(II) complexes. Addition of a competitive Lewis base, such as pyridine, led to dissociation of the resulting [2]rotaxane (Fig. 1, type E, Scheme 4A).51
![]() | ||
| Scheme 4 [2]Rotaxanes (A) 8 and (B) 9 incorporating metalloporphyrin stoppers.51,52 | ||
Axial coordination to metalloporphyrins containing Zn(II), Ru(II), and Rh(III) was also exploited to introduce stopper groups onto the axle of a [2]rotaxane self-assembled from a macrocycle incorporating electron-rich 1,5-alkoxynaphthalene motifs and a linear thread featuring a central naphthodiimide moiety.21 Shimizu systematically examined how variations in the porphyrin macrocycle substitution pattern and the dimensions of the thread influence conformations of [2]rotaxanes stoppered with rhodium(III) porphyrins. One such example is rotaxane 9, which in contrary to 8, is terminated with a rhodium(III) porphyrin only on one side (Fig. 1, type F, Scheme 4B).52
Meso substituents oriented at approximately 90° around the rigid, planar porphyrin core enabled this macrocycle to serve as a platform for constructing higher-order rotaxanes. Sauvage and Sour exploited this design by integrating porphyrin meso-aryl substituents into a crown ether framework containing a phenanthroline unit, yielding a Zn(II) porphyrin that enabled the synthesis of a [3]rotaxane 10 via threading of a long axle through macrocycle pairs at the 5,10 and 15,20 positions, followed by stoppering (Fig. 1, type G, Scheme 5A).53 By contrast, the Loeb group introduced linear secondary amine groups at the meso positions of a porphyrin ring. Using a simultaneous threading-followed-by-stoppering strategy, they obtained a [5]rotaxane 11 based on the tetrapyrrolic scaffold (Fig. 1, type H, Scheme 5B).54
![]() | ||
| Scheme 5 (A) [3]Rotaxane 10 and (B) [5]rotaxane 11.53,54 | ||
Hunter designed a zinc(II) porphyrin bearing a carefully engineered meso substituent incorporating pyridine termini and a pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide motif. In chloroform, this species existed in dynamic equilibrium with a self-assembled dimer, in which the pyridine unit of one porphyrin acted as an axial ligand to the Zn(II) center of the other. Owing to cooperative binding, the dimer displayed a very high association constant (Kd = 2 × 108 M−1). The presence of hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors within the meso-pyridinedicarboxamide unit further enabled this dimer to form [2]rotaxanes 12 with a range of terephthaloyl derivatives, in which the porphyrins constituted part of the self-assembled macrocyclic component and served as stoppers at the termini of the thread (Fig. 1, type I, Scheme 6).26
![]() | ||
| Scheme 6 [2]Rotaxane 12.26 | ||
The Anderson group pushed the concept of using porphyrins as components of large macrocyclic architectures to the extreme by designing a [2]rotaxane 13 with a butadiyne axle terminated by two Zn(II) porphyrin stoppers, further functionalized with alkyne groups (Scheme 7).27 The resulting building block was subjected to Pd-catalyzed Glaser coupling in the presence of a hexapyridyl template 14, affording remarkable [4]- 15 and [7]catenane 16 architectures featuring large ring components composed of cyclic porphyrin hexamers and dodecamers in 62% and 6% yield, respectively. Later, the same group demonstrated several other impressive systems in which the porphyrin was incorporated into the axle or ring component of the interlocked molecule.55,56
![]() | ||
| Scheme 7 Synthesis of [n]catenanes 15 and 16.27 | ||
Multiple systems incorporating C60 fullerene as an electron acceptor were designed, in which photoinduced electron transfer from the excited-state porphyrin led to charge-separated states.63–66 Takata, Ito, and co-workers reported an interesting [2]rotaxane 17 featuring zinc(II) porphyrin donors installed at the termini of the thread and a cyclic component decorated with a C60 fullerene acceptor (Fig. 2). This design enabled the observation of intramolecular electron transfer between the donor metalloporphyrins and the [60]fullerene in benzonitrile.67 Schuster and colleagues reported a [2]rotaxane architecture comprising metalloporphyrin stoppers that acted as electron donors and a macrocycle appended with C60, assembled using the Sauvage bis(phenanthroline)copper(I) motif.68 It was demonstrated that the intramolecular electronic processes observed in this system required the involvement of the [Cu(phen)2]+ complex in the electron transfer events. Later, the role of the same motif was documented for [2]catenanes in which metalloporphyrin and fullerene were spatially significantly separated.69
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Photoinduced electron transfer in C60-appended [2]rotaxane 17.67 | ||
Von Delius and Guldi constructed [2]rotaxane 18 featuring zinc(II) porphyrin stoppers and a C60 fullerene acceptor positioned at the central part of the thread (Scheme 8).70 While electron transfer between the donor and acceptor was observed for the free thread, the introduction of a [10]cycloparaphenylene ring (CPP or its aza-analogue aza[10]CPP) encircling the C60 unit effectively shielded the acceptor. This structural modification suppressed electron transfer and redirected the photophysical pathway toward triplet-state energy transfer between the zinc(II) porphyrin and the fullerene. The Anderson group, on the other hand, described [3]- and [5]-rotaxanes in which multiple energy transfer pathways involving a phenanthroline-based macrocycle, a polyyne thread, and porphyrin stoppers were operative.28
![]() | ||
| Scheme 8 The [10]CPP-based [2]rotaxane 18 comprising a fullerene moiety.70 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 9 Binding of C60 by the tweezer-like [3]rotaxane receptor 19.74 | ||
The Sauvage group further explored the dynamic behavior of [3]rotaxanes featuring two zinc(II) porphyrin plates that interacted with bispyridyl podands differing in linker flexibility between the coordinating units.75 The large accessible amplitude of distance variation between the metalloporphyrin panels (10–80 Å), together with the cooperative axial coordination of a single podand molecule to two metal centers, enabled exceptionally high complex stability constants, reaching values of 106–107 M−1.
The Beer group has extensively studied anion binding by porphyrin-based rotaxanes and catenanes. By exploiting anion-templation strategies, they developed a range of interlocked receptors capable of recognizing multiple anionic guests, with the porphyrin macrocycle serving as both the recognition site and a reporter unit.76 The group also designed a receptor based on a porphyrin-strapped macrocycle in which iodotriazole functionalities were incorporated into the cyclic component of the rotaxane to enable anion binding via halogen bonding.77 Axial coordination between a triazole unit on the [2]rotaxane thread and a zinc(II) bound in the porphyrin cavity preorganized the binding pocket and led to a substantial enhancement of anion binding affinities. Notably, quenching of a BODIPY unit installed as a stopper at one terminus of the thread enabled optical detection of the anion recognition event. A similar design principle enabled the construction of a catenane 20 that acted as a host for anionic guests, in which the anions were stabilized within the cavity through a network of hydrogen bonds (Fig. 3).78
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 The chloride complex 20 of a porphyrin-incorporating [2]catenane receptor.78 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 10 Demetallation-induced co-conformational rearrangement of 21-M.79 | ||
The Beer group designed molecular shuttles based on [2]- and [3]rotaxanes in which a Zn(II) porphyrin unit was positioned at the centre of the axle.81 The macrocyclic component incorporated a pyridyl ring. In the absence of competing ligands, shuttling of the macrocycle along the thread was observed, with the Zn(II) porphyrin station influencing the dynamics through axial coordination with the pyridyl unit of the ring component. Upon the addition of an external base, i.e., pyridine, the shuttling was inhibited.
The coordination properties of metalloporphyrins were also exploited by Terao and co-workers, who designed a remarkable [3]catenane 23 comprising a large, rigid rectangular macrocycle incorporating Ru(II) porphyrins and two smaller rings, each containing two Zn(II) porphyrin units (Fig. 4).82 Upon introduction of carefully selected ligands such as 3,5-dibromopyridine, DABCO, or bisbipyridyls, multistate switching could be reversibly induced.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Coordination-induced multistate switching in [3]catenane 23.82 | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Epoxidation of polybutadiene polymer in a Mn(III) porphyrin-based rotaxane 26-Mn.83 | ||
The Megiatto group, in contrast, demonstrated remarkable reactivity within nanocavities incorporating cobalt(II) porphyrins, forming rotaxanes via an original active-template synthetic approach.88 In the presence of 3,5-diphenylpyridine, half-threads of the rotaxane bearing diazo and styrene functional groups underwent a radical carbene-transfer reaction, affording the interlocked product of the olefin cyclopropanation in 95% yield. Later, the same group exploited the reactivity of a nanoreactor incorporating a Ru(II) porphyrin system to demonstrate N–H bond carbene insertion, affording [2]rotaxanes.89
A particularly interesting concept involving the use of metalloporphyrin-based capsules in tandem active-metal template synthesis of rotaxanes was described by Hayashi, Weiss, and co-workers.90 Using a ditopic Zn(II) porphyrin–phenanthroline–strapped system, it was demonstrated that azide coordination to the Zn(II) centre, enforced by the nanoreactor design, facilitated the Huisgen cycloaddition between azide- and alkyne-functionalized half-threads. This process afforded [2]rotaxanes and opened new avenues for exploring dual-metal catalysis in active-template syntheses of mechanically interlocked molecules.
In 2012, the Ballester group demonstrated that a cage-like species constructed from two calix[4]pyrrole units connected by rigid bisacetylene linkers is capable of encapsulating a linear zwitterionic guest, bis(amidopyridyl-N-oxide), to form a pseudorotaxane 28 (Scheme 11).93 Hydrogen bonding to the pyridinium N-oxide oxygen atom oriented the guest such that the amide functionalities were exposed toward the remaining free space within the cavity. This preorganization facilitated the formation of four-component species upon complexation of tetrabutylammonium cyanate or azide. Installation of bulky stopper groups 29 on the pseudorotaxane 28 using a capping strategy resulted in the formation of a [2]rotaxane 30 in good yield (50%).94 This interlocked receptor was shown to bind a range of anionic guests effectively, including chloride and nitrate.95,96
![]() | ||
| Scheme 11 Synthesis of bis-calix[4]pyrrole [2]rotaxane 30.94 | ||
Aydogan and co-workers exploited the anion-binding properties of calix[4]pyrroles to construct alternating polymers composed of linear segments with pillar[5]arenes bearing chains of varying lengths.97 The supramolecular polymers were further shown to organize hierarchically into a variety of structures, including spherical aggregates, fibers, microporous films, and three-dimensional materials.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 12 (A) The active template synthesis of corrole-incorporating rotaxane 34, (B) [5]rotaxane 35.100 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 13 Synthesis of a conjugated [2]catenane 37.106,107 | ||
In 2025, Zeng, Wu, Ni, and co-workers reported the formation of a [2]catenane 39 composed of two intertwined octaphyrinoid macrocycles incorporating both pyrrole and thiophene units.108 The synthesis began with an α-bromothiophene-substituted dipyrromethene, which, upon coordination to Zn(II), formed a dimeric complex in nearly quantitative yield. Subsequent Suzuki–Miyaura coupling of this intermediate with a dithiophenemethane-derived boronic ester afforded a precursor 38 that was subjected to Yamamoto coupling, yielding the Zn(II)-stabilized catenane 39-Zn in 24% yield (Scheme 14).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 14 Synthesis of octaphyrinoid-based [2]catenane 39.108 | ||
Finally, oxidative dehydrogenation with DDQ followed by demetalation with HCl provided the fully conjugated, metal-free [2]catenane 39. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis of 39 revealed that the core-modified octaphyrinoid macrocycles were arranged in an almost perpendicular orientation, with all bithiophene subunits adopting cis configuration (Fig. 6). The aromatic character of both rings was supported by harmonic oscillator model of aromaticity (HOMA) calculations, anisotropy of the induced current density (AICD) analysis, and three-dimensional iso-chemical shielding surface (ICSS) maps. Intriguingly, oxidation of 39 to the tetracation induced a pronounced structural distortion, leading to the formation of two antiaromatic octaphyrinoid units with close inter-ring contacts. This arrangement enabled strong through-space electronic coupling between the macrocycles.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 X-ray molecular structure of 39.108 | ||
In 1998, Sessler and Vögtle reported a spectacular example of a self-assembling [2]catenane comprising bipyrrole-based macrocycles.109 The reaction of p-xylylenediamine 40 with a bipyrrole diacyl chloride 41 afforded the interlocked product 42 in 2% yield (Scheme 15). However, the same compound could be obtained in a slightly higher yield (4%) when a sequential synthetic route was employed. The formation of an interlocked architecture was likely facilitated by hydrogen bonds between multiple donor and acceptor sites in the assembling parts of the molecule. The dynamic nature of 42, involving circumrotatory motion of the individual macrocyclic components, was inferred from the broadening of the 1H NMR resonance signals. Upon addition of fluoride, the resonances became significantly sharper, consistent with the anion binding within the catenane cavity. Subsequently, the interlocked receptor was shown to effectively interact with other anions as well.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 15 Synthesis of a bipyrrole-based catenane 42.109 | ||
Bozdemir and co-workers exploited the coordination properties of the dipyrrin motif to construct [2]catenanes using Sauvage's passive metal-template methodology.110 Accordingly, a dipyrrin-embedded macrocyclic precursor 43 bearing terminal alkene functionalities appended to ether side chains was synthesized (Scheme 16). Upon treatment with Zn(II) or Cu(II), ligand dimerization around the tetrahedral metal center afforded bis(dipyrrinato)metal complexes 43-M, effectively bringing the terminal double bonds into close proximity. Subsequent ring-closing metathesis catalyzed by the Grubbs 2nd-generation catalyst enabled covalent bond formation between the alkene termini, affording 44-M. Removal of the metal template from 44-M furnished the metal-free [2]catenane, which could subsequently be transformed into bis-BODIPY-like species.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 16 Synthesis of 44-M.110 | ||
An interesting strategy for constructing interlocked structures from expanded porphyrin-like macrocycles was reported by Nabeshima.111,112 The group described several macrocyclic trimers incorporating dipyrrin motifs separated by meta- and para-substituted phenylene units. Their corresponding tris-BF2 complexes were capable of incorporating protonated secondary amines to form pseudorotaxanes, e.g. 45, via non-classical, bifurcated hydrogen bonds, namely BF2⋯H–N interactions (Fig. 7).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 The pseudorotaxane 45 comprising expanded porphyrin-like ring component.111,112 | ||
The BODIPY motif has been incorporated into rotaxane architectures on several occasions to exploit its outstanding optical properties, including large molar extinction coefficients and high fluorescence quantum yields. Importantly, these features are complemented by excellent chemical stability and synthetic versatility, which allow fine-tuning of the luminescent properties. Akkaya and co-workers designed a [2]rotaxane in which suitably functionalized BODIPY units were attached both to the macrocyclic component – dibenzo-24-crown-8 – and installed as stoppers on the axle bearing a secondary amine at its center.113 Protonation of the amine generated the corresponding ammonium species, triggering spontaneous self-assembly of the [2]rotaxane. The resulting interlocked structure exhibited efficient through-space energy transfer via FRET.
Frasconi, Wasielewski, Stoddart, and co-workers reported a bistable [2]rotaxane composed of a tetrathiafulvalene (TTF)-containing thread terminated with a BODIPY stopper and a cyclobis(paraquat-p-phenylene) macrocycle.20 In the initial redox state, in the absence of an applied potential, the macrocycle resided on the TTF station, allowing free rotation of the BODIPY unit around the Cmeso–Cipso bond and resulting in low fluorescence intensity. Upon oxidation of TTF to the dication TTF2+, the macrocycle shifted toward the BODIPY stopper. This movement restricted the rotation, resulting in a 3.4-fold increase in fluorescence.
Trolez and co-workers described an intriguing route toward interlocked dipyrromethene derivatives. They designed a macrocycle incorporating a central 2,2′-biphenol unit.114,115 When the latter was added to a solution of BODIPY, previously treated with aluminum chloride in anhydrous dichloromethane, substitution of the fluorine atoms by the 2,2′-biphenol moiety took place. This transformation yielded an architecture in which the dipyrromethene unit was coordinated to a boron(III) center within the macrocyclic cavity. Notably, the threaded BODIPY exhibited higher fluorescence quantum yields than the corresponding non-interlocked analogues. This strategy, therefore, provided a promising approach to developing novel, highly emissive dyes. The same group also developed a rotaxane architecture featuring threaded BODIPY units acting as stoppers.116 The resulting system exhibited high molar absorption coefficients and fluorescence quantum yields, as well as remarkable brightness.
One of the first projects carried out in the group involved the synthesis of an original class of iminopyrrole macrocycles that combined structural features of crown ethers and porphyrins, termed crownphyrins.118,119 A related concept was proposed as early as the 1980s by Sessler; however, the use of tripyrane building block prevented the formation of a conjugated heterocyclic brace within the macrocyclic ring.120,121 Later, Love and co-workers revisited this idea and reported a series of elegant transition-metal “Pac-Man” complexes based on macrocycles incorporating both porphyrinoid and crown ether elements.122,123
Our approach relied on the use of a meso-pentafluorophenyl-substituted diformyldipyrromethane precursor 47, which, upon condensation with diamines bearing oligo(ethylene glycol) motifs 48, formed macrocycles that underwent spontaneous oxidation of the intermediate crownphyrinogens 49 to the corresponding crownphyrins 50 (Scheme 17A).119
![]() | ||
| Scheme 17 (A) Synthesis and reactivity of crownphyrins.119 (B) Different reactivity of diformylphenanthroline 51 and diformyldipyrromethene 54 in the metal-mediated self-assembly with 53.117,119 | ||
The hybrids turned out to be excellent receptors, as their cavities contain both hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors. As a result, they efficiently bind neutral molecules, such as water, and anions (after reduction), and act as versatile ligands.124 By selecting macrocycles of appropriate size, monomeric mononuclear complexes 50-Pb, dimeric “accordion-type” porphyrinoids,125 as well as figure-eight dimers 55-Zn exhibiting dynamic coordination behaviour in solution, were obtained (Fig. 8). Reactions with Group 1 metal ions were found to engage the ether oxygen atoms only, leading to the formation of intriguing M2(H2O)2-bridged dimers 57-M (M = Na, K).124 Particularly interesting was the reactivity toward Pd(II), which enforced previously unobserved iminopyrrole tautomerism involving proton transfer to a carbon atom. Finally, larger macrocycles displayed Janus-type behaviour: Pd(II) was coordinated within the porphyrinoid core, while alkali metal cation occupied the crown-ether-like pocket.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 The X-ray molecular structure of 56, 50-Pb, 55-Zn, and 57-K.119,124 | ||
Inspired by the work of Nitschke and co-workers,117 who demonstrated that the reaction between phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxaldehyde 51 and 2,2′-(ethane-1,2-diylbis(oxy))bis(ethan-1-amine) 53 in the presence of a Cu(I) afforded a template-stabilized [2]catenane 52, we set out to investigate a similar transformation employing diformyldipyrromethene 54 (Scheme 17B). Copper(I) proved unsuitable under our reaction conditions, as it was readily oxidized to Cu(II), reflecting the tendency of iminopyrrole ligands to stabilize higher oxidation states of metal ions. At this stage, a fundamental difference between the iminophenanthroline and iminopyrrole systems became apparent. In our case, the sole product formed was the figure-eight complex 55-M.
Although we did not succeed at that time in obtaining a mechanically interlocked architecture, ongoing efforts are aimed at exploiting crownphyrin-based systems toward this goal. Importantly, the observed reactivity prompted us to further explore iminopyrrole ligands in subcomponent self-assembly processes. To evaluate the potential of iminopyrroles for constructing molecular systems of increasing complexity, we next examined their applicability in the assembly of capsular assemblies. Although purely organic cages based on iminopyrroles had already been reported at the time we initiated our studies,126–129 metal–organic assemblies derived from iminopyrroles remained largely unexplored.130,131
In our initial approach, we investigated the reactions between 2,5-diformylpyrrole, tris(2-aminoethyl)amine (tren), and silver(I) salts.132 We found that the outcome strongly depended on the nature of the silver salt, more specifically on the coordinating properties of the counteranion. Two principal types of products were obtained: cascade-type cryptates 58-Ag2F, in which two silver ions were located at opposite poles of a [3+2] cage with a central fluoride (or chloride anion(s)), and so-called “plenates”, e.g., 58-Ag5, i.e., cages whose cavities were filled with a silver(I) cluster composed of three to five metal ions (Fig. 9). Interestingly, theoretical studies have shown that the encapsulated silver clusters exhibit dynamic behaviour, with metal ions continuously rearranging their coordination environments and adopting multiple geometries within the cavity.133 Subsequently, we found that the simple [3+2] cage can encapsulate two metal centers of the same type, such as Zn(II), Cd(II), or Hg(II) (58-Hg2), as well as form heterobinuclear assemblies.134 In these complexes, the cage framework stabilized very short metal–metal contacts, resulting in metallophilic interaction.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 The X-ray molecular structures of metal-stabilized iminopyrrole cages 58-Ag2F, 58-Ag5, 58-Hg2, 59-Zn12, 60-Zn4.132,134,135 | ||
An intriguing observation was made during studies of cages assembled in the presence of Zn(II).135 In this case, the products formed by self-assembly were found to depend strongly on the solvent used. When the reaction was carried out in n-butanol, the expected [3+2] cage incorporating two Zn(II) ions was obtained. In contrast, performing the reaction in chloroform led to the formation of a much larger [12+8] system 59-Zn12 stabilized by the coordination of twelve Zn(II) ions (Fig. 9). The formation of the latter required partial tautomerization of the organic ligand from the diiminopyrrole form to an imino–aminoazafulvene in a tautomerism-coupled self-assembly (Scheme 18A).136 The protons located on the amino groups of the latter were strongly engaged in hydrogen bonding, creating an extensive network of stabilizing interactions. Treatment with a competitive pyridine ligand induced transformation of this assembly into a cage 60-Zn4, in which four octahedral Zn(II) centres occupied the vertices of a tetrahedron.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 18 (A) Tautomerism in diiminopyrrole-based ligands.136 (B) Intramolecular dynamics of coordination compounds of diiminopyrroles.139 | ||
Eventually, we sought to determine whether iminopyrroles could serve as building blocks for complex metallo-supramolecular architectures, including mechanically interlocked molecules such as knots and links. To this end, the replacement of 2,6-diformylpyridine by 2,5-diformylpyrrole in the reactions with bipyridyl-containing diamines developed by Stoddart and Trabolsi,137,138 carried out in the presence of Zn(II) or Cd(II), afforded [2]catenane 61-Zn2, trefoil knot 62-Cd3, and Borromean rings 63-Cd6 incorporating diiminopyrrole motif (Fig. 10).139 Interestingly, the X-ray diffraction analysis revealed that, contrary to the high symmetry anticipated based on the 1H NMR spectra recorded at 300 K, the diiminopyrrole motif acted primarily as a bidentate, not a tridentate ligand within the coordination pocket of the assembly. This observation was readily rationalized by considering the intrinsic intramolecular dynamics of the assemblies, including the continuous cleavage and reforming of N–M bonds within diiminopyrrole coordination compound (Scheme 18B). Consequently, such dynamic behavior appeared to be quite a common feature of assemblies incorporating the iminopyrrole coordination motif.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 The X-ray molecular structures of 61-Zn2, 62-Cd3, 63-Cd6.139 | ||
Next, we explored the use of more structurally elaborate pyrrolic ligands in self-assembly processes, going beyond simple iminopyrroles to building blocks reminiscent of those employed in the construction of porphyrins and porphyrinoids.140 In this context, we investigated the reactivity of two aldehydes – diformylbipyrrole 65 and diformyldipyrromethane 67 (Scheme 19). The latter is a direct precursor in the synthesis of porphyrins and numerous other pyrrolic macrocycles; upon oxidation, it forms dipyrrin, often considered as a “half-porphyrin” subunit. In contrast, bipyrrole is found in the frameworks of contracted porphyrinoids such as corroles, as well as in expanded systems including sapphyrins.141 When these aldehydes were subjected to condensation with amine 66 in the presence of Zn(II) or Cd(II) salts, the only products obtained were metal-stabilised [2]catenanes, which we termed catenaphyrins. Interestingly, those two assemblies also demonstrated dynamic behaviour in the solution. Notably, 68-M exhibited interesting optical properties, with an emission centered at 580–620 nm. This exploratory study confirmed that more intricate pyrrole-based building blocks can be successfully employed in self-assembly processes, opening a route to the construction of architectures such as hypothetical knotaphyrins, i.e., molecules that blur the boundaries between molecular knots and expanded porphyrinoids.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 19 Self-assembly of [2]catenaphyrins 64-M and 68-M.140 | ||
In parallel, we investigated self-assembly reactions leading to molecular knots and links stabilized by silver(I) ions. During these studies, the formation of an intriguing molecular motif, namely, a molecular tweezer 69, was detected. The latter formed from the reaction of 2,2′-bipyridyl-based diamine with 2,6-diformylpyridine in the presence of silver(I) acetate (Fig. 11). The structure consisted of two macrocyclic units incorporating a diiminopyridine motif, with dimerization driven by coordination of Ag(I)⋯Ag(I) pairs.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 11 The X-ray molecular structures of 69, 70, and 71.142 | ||
Remarkably, a subtle modification of the amine component used in the self-assembly process enabled the selective formation of a Solomon link 70 stabilized by four Ag22+ units. Further investigations revealed that this silver cluster can serve as an effective template, enabling the formation of [2]catenane 71 and trefoil knot 72 when 2,7-diformyl-1,8-naphthyridine was used as the carbonyl component in the self-assembly reaction (Scheme 20). Although compounds 69–72 did not incorporate pyrrole-based ligands, they represent an extension of our earlier work on silver cluster templation, with potential applicability to pyrrolic and other assemblies.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 20 The Ag(I)⋯Ag(I)-stabilized assemblies 69–72.142 | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 21 (A) Synthesis of a dipyrromethane-stoppered rotaxane 76 and (B) its condensation products – [3]rotaxane 77 and [4]rotaxane 78.143 | ||
Rotaxane 76 proved to be an excellent building block for the synthesis of porphyrinoids. Upon reaction with pentafluorobenzaldehyde under Lindsey condensation conditions, formation of a [3]rotaxane was observed, featuring an unsubstituted porphyrin unit positioned at the center of the axle. Having confirmed the utility of this building block in porphyrinoid-forming reactions, we next investigated its reaction with acetone. This transformation afforded two products: a [3]rotaxane 77 and a Y-shaped [4]rotaxane 78, incorporating calix[4]phyrin and calix[6]phyrin units, respectively (Scheme 21B). The core calix[n]phyrins represent hybrid macrocycles that bridge nonconjugated calix[n]pyrroles and fully conjugated porphyrins, owing to the presence of meso-sp3 carbon bridges separating the dipyrromethene units within the macrocycle.148,149 As a consequence, calix[4]phyrins adopt a roof-like conformation in the solid state, whereas in solution they exhibit dynamic behavior involving interconversion between V-shaped stereoisomers, leading to time-averaged positions of the methyl groups (Fig. 12A).150 Notably, this conformational switching is retained upon incorporation of the calix[4]phyrin unit into the axle of a rotaxane, thereby inducing motion of the entire mechanically interlocked molecule (Fig. 12B).143 Owing to its resemblance to the motion of bird or butterfly wings during flight, we termed this dynamic behaviour as fluttering. Interestingly, the fluttering motion was suppressed when the calix[4]phyrin unit was incorporated into a [2]catenane, most likely due to an insufficient cavity size that restricts the conformational flexibility. Furthermore, the [3]rotaxane, by virtue of its molecular design, exhibited multimodal motion in response to external stimuli. In addition to fluttering – which can be reversibly switched on and off by (de)protonation of the calixphyrin core – the system also undergoes macrocycle shuttling along the thread and rotational motion of the macrocyclic component. Further strategies to control the fluttering motion are currently being explored in our laboratory.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 12 (A) The toggling in calix[4]phyrin.149,150 (B) Fluttering in calix[4]phyrin-incorporating [3]rotaxane.143 | ||
The developed strategy for the synthesis of [2]rotaxanes bearing dipyrromethane units at both termini enabled the design of a series of precursors for the construction of [n]catenanes.151 Under optimized conditions, substrates differing in the length and flexibility of the linear component were expected to undergo condensation to form interlocked products. It was ultimately found that the outcome strongly depended on the thread's geometric features. Rotaxanes with sufficiently long and flexible linear components underwent intramolecular self-condensation in the presence of acetone and a catalyst, affording [2]catenanes. In contrast, shorter and more rigid [2]rotaxanes favored intermolecular condensation, leading to the formation of higher-order [3]- and [4]catenanes. These studies demonstrated that the structure of the starting materials plays a decisive role in determining the topology of the final product. Consequently, this methodology is expected to be extendable to the synthesis of higher-order rotaxanes and catenanes based on diverse scaffolds, not limited to the calixphyrin motif.
Footnote |
| † These authors contributed equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |