Open Access Article
Maximilian D.
Seyfried
a,
Julius
Gemen
a,
Leonard
Wyszynski
b,
Carl L.
Giard
c,
Constantin G.
Daniliuc
a,
Monika
Schönhoff
bd,
Nikos L.
Doltsinis
cd,
Frank
Glorius
a and
Bart Jan
Ravoo
*ad
aOrganic Chemistry Institute, University of Münster, Corrensstr. 36, 48149 Münster, Germany
bInstitute of Physical Chemistry, University of Münster, Corrensstr. 28/30, 48149 Münster, Germany
cInstitute of Solid State Theory and Center for Multiscale Theory and Computation, University of Münster, Wilhelm-Klemm-Str. 10, 48149 Münster, Germany
dCenter for Soft Nanoscience, University of Münster, Busso-Peus-Str. 10, 48149 Münster, Germany. E-mail: b.j.ravoo@uni-muenster.de
First published on 18th September 2025
Replacing one or both phenyl moieties of azobenzene with aromatic heterocycles is a versatile strategy to expand molecular diversity and to customize photophysical properties specifically for the intended application. Numerous mono-heteroaryl azo structures have been explored and characterized, with especially arylazopyrazoles (AAPs) and arylazoisoxazoles (AIZ) finding widespread application in various fields such as material science, photopharmacology and supramolecular chemistry. However, bis-heteroaryl motifs have been sparingly explored, with only a handful of examples known to date. Here, we introduce two previously unexplored classes of bisheteroaromatic structures: azobisisoxazole and isoxazoleazopyrazoles. Both classes readily undergo photoisomerization upon irradiation with UV (E–Z) and green light (Z–E), with half-life times of the Z isomer ranging from a few minutes to multiple months. Notably, some of the compounds combine very long half-life times of the Z isomer with near-quantitative photoisomerization in both directions. Furthermore, sensitized isomerization of these photoswitches under confinement enables rapid E–Z isomerization with selectable lower-energy photons, enabling high conversion even for derivatives performing poorly upon direct excitation. In general, these azobisheteroarenes represent new and easily accessible platforms for the design of light responsive molecules with favorable photophysical properties in photopharmacology and beyond.
In arylazoheteroarenes, one of the phenyl rings of azobenzene is replaced with an aromatic (often five-membered) heterocycle. Over the last two decades, numerous types of azoheteroarenes containing imidazoles,10 benzimidazoles,11 indoles,12 isoxazoles,13 pyrazoles,14 thiazoles,15 and others have been developed. These efforts have led to extensive libraries of heterocyclic photoswitches with a wide range of properties and diverse applications. However, combining accessibility, long half-life times and high photostationary states (PSS) in a single structure remains challenging. Two classes that have attracted significant attention are arylazopyrazoles (AAPs) and arylazoisoxazoles (AIZ). AAPs, introduced by Fuchter and coworkers,14 exhibit near-quantitative forward and reverse isomerization, with half-life times of the Z isomer of more than a week. Alternatively, derivatives exhibiting extremely long half-life times of multiple years but decreased photoconversion can be achieved through small modifications16,17 AAPs have been utilized in various applications such as facilitating light-induced gel–sol transitions in hydrogels,18 modifying the wettability of surfaces,19 storing energy in molecular solar thermal energy storage (MOST) devices,20 modulating drug activity in photopharmacology21,22 and supramolecular chemistry.23 AIZs on the other hand, often undergo a reversible solid-to-liquid phase transition when irradiated and have been successfully applied as light-responsive adhesives24,25 and for reversible surface patterning.26 Additionally, both isoxazoles and azoisoxazoles have found potential applications in medicinal chemistry. They have been shown to act as anti-inflammatory27 and anti-microbial28,29 agents as well as showing some potential in orally active anti-cancer agents.30 In contrast, bis-heteroaryl azophotoswitches have been considerably less explored. Recent reports include multiple azobisthiazole and azobisthiadiazole which demonstrate visible light photoswitching with decent to excellent conversion and half-life times ranging from minutes to days.31 Another notable contribution is the class of azobispyrazoles by Li and coworkers, which offers excellent photophysical properties including near-quantitative photoconversion and a very high Z isomer stability.32 To our knowledge, asymmetric azobisheteroarenes featuring two different types of heteroarenes are rarely documented and azobisheteroarenes containing isoxazoles have not been reported at all.
Here, we present a group of azobisisoxazoles and isoxazoleazopyrazoles as highly promising additions to the azobisheteroarene family and investigate their photophysical properties and thermal stability of the metastable Z isomer using NMR and UV/vis spectroscopy. Additionally, we demonstrate visible light induced E-to-Z isomerization based on the recently introduced concept of ‘disequilibration by sensitization under confinement’ (DESC).33 Sensitized visible light isomerization of these photoswitches not only broadens their applicability in materials and pharmacology but also boosts the performance of some derivatives with respect to photostationary states attainable.
However, it was observed that variations in the amount of acid and base used in this step would lead to significant differences in yield. Insufficient acidity results in the formation of a significant amount of the corresponding triazene side product in the diazotization, whereas an excess of acid considerably impedes the subsequent coupling with acetylacetone (see SI S2 and S3). The final compounds were then synthesized through a ring closure reaction using hydroxylamine hydrochloride, hydrazine or methylhydrazine to produce the azobisisoxazoles, isoxazoleazopyrazoles and methylated isoxazoleazopyrazoles in very good yields between 64% and 93%. Notably, the pyrazoles (4iz-pzH, 3iz-pzH) can easily be further modified on the pyrazole ring using existing methods.34 Details on the synthesis and analysis of all compounds can be found in the SI.
When irradiated with UV light (365 nm), rapid E-to-Z isomerization was observed. This process can be monitored via UV/vis spectroscopy through a decrease in intensity and a hypsochromic shift of the π–π* band, accompanied by an increase in intensity and a bathochromic shift of the n–π* band. The PSS after irradiation was determined using 1H NMR spectroscopy (see SI, S18). Compounds 4iz-4iz, 3iz-4iz, 3iz-pzH and 3iz-pzMe achieved only partial E–Z conversion ranging from 38% to 62% due to a strong overlap of absorption for both isomers and blue-shifted absorption bands resulting in low absorption at the irradiation wavelength. For the azobisisoxazoles, irradiating closer to the absorption maxima with a wavelength of 310 nm achieved higher PSS for E–Z-isomerization, but resulted in degradation of the compound over time. Similar degradation but no improvement in PSS was observed for 4iz-pzMe. A possible cause of this degradation is the previously reported azirine formation from isoxazoles under short-wavelength UV irradiation.36 For the pyrazole derivatives irradiation with 310 nm led to no improvement in PSS compared to 365 nm. Pyrazoles 4iz-pzH and 4iz-PzMe, on the other hand, show nearly complete isomerization to the Z isomer using 365 nm (>86% and 92% respectively). Subsequent irradiation at the tail of the n–π* transition with green light (515 nm) resulted in near-quantitative back-isomerization (93–98%) to the E isomer for all compounds except 3iz-pzMe (84%) due to the near-zero absorption of E isomers at wavelengths above 500 nm. Isomerization with green light for Z-isoxazoleazopyrazoles proceeded quickly, while the lower absorption in the green region for Z-azobisisoxazoles led to comparatively slow isomerization. Irradiating closer to the peak of the n–π* band with blue light (465 nm) resulted in faster isomerization but only limited conversion due to the large overlap in absorption for Z und E isomers in this region. Over three photoswitching cycles, no degradation was observed. With its near-quantitative isomerization in both directions, 4iz-pzMe not only matched the performance of some of the best-performing azobenzene derivatives like 2,2′,6,6′-tetrafluoroazobenzene8 and the ethylene-bridged diazocine9 but also surpasses most representatives of mono- or bisheteroaryl azo photoswitches like arylazoisoxazoles,13 arylazothiazoles, azobisthiazoles and arylazothiadiazoles.31
Subsequently, the thermal Z–E-isomerization in DMSO was studied and half-life times of the Z isomer (t1/2) were determined by following the change in absorbance over time via UV/vis spectroscopy after initial irradiation with 365 nm (see Table 1). For compounds with t1/2 greater than one day, half-life times were measured at multiple elevated temperatures (70–90 °C) and extrapolated to 25 °C using Eyring plots (see Fig. S25). The non-methylated isoxazoleazopyrazoles exhibit thermal relaxation within minutes to hours (t1/2 = 127 min and 24 min for 4iz-pzH and 3iz-pzH, respectively), while the methylated pyrazoles show at least an 1800-fold increase in half-life time to over three months. This large difference between the methylated and non-methylated pyrazoles has been observed previously in arylazopyrazoles and can be attributed to hydrogen bonding and tautomerism to the hydrazone form. This tautomerism is only available to the non-N-substituted pyrazoles and drastically decreases the life time of the Z isomer.10,37 Azobisisoxazoles 4iz-4iz and 3iz-4iz exhibit half-life times in between N-methylated and non-methylated pyrazoles (91 days and 50 hours respectively). For azobisisoxazoles (4iz-4iz, 3iz-4iz) and NH-pyrazoles (4iz-pzH, 3iz-pzH), the half-life times of 3-isoxazoles are considerably shorter than those of the 4-isoxazoles. 4iz-pzMe and 3iz-pzMe on the other hand show only a small difference.
| Molecule | λ maxπ–π (E)/nm | λ max n–π (E)/nm | λ maxπ–π (Z)/nm | λ max n–π (Z)/nm | Photoconversion | t 1/2 (25 °C) | ε max/(cm−1 M−1) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E-to-Z (365 nm) | Z-to-E (515 nm) | |||||||
| a Sample was measured under continuous irradiation. b Sample measured in CDCl3 instead of DMSO-d6 due to limited solubility. c Extrapolated to 25 °C from measurements at 70 °C, 75 °C, 80 °C, 85 °C and 90 °C. d Spectrum shows no distinct n–π* band for the E-isomer due to overlap with π–π* band. | ||||||||
| 4iz-4iz | 311 | 403 | 292 | 418 | 57% | 95% | 91 dc | 17.3 × 103 |
| 3iz-4iz | 303 | 413 | 303 | 420 | 38% | 94% | 50 hc | 14.7 × 103 |
| 4iz-pzH | 335 | n.dd | 296 | 426 | 86 %a |
98% | 127 min | 20.7 × 103 |
| 3iz-pzH | 325 | n.dd | 320 | 431 | 62 %a,b |
99% | 24 min | 22.5 × 103 |
| 4iz-pzMe | 336 | n.dd | 297 | 426 | 92% | 97% | 98 dc | 17.7 × 103 |
| 3iz-pzMe | 328 | n.dd | 316 | 434 | 52% | 84% | 102 dc | 26.2 × 103 |
Different applications of molecular photoswitches often require different solvents. Especially in biology and pharmacology, water is the solvent of choice. Therefore, the performance of the bisazoheteroarenes in aqueous solution was investigated (see Fig. S26). Although poorly soluble in pure water, most compounds readily dissolve in a mixture of water and DMSO with as little as 10% (v/v) DMSO. In this solvent mixture, all compounds exhibit a blue-shift of the absorption bands of 2–10 nm. 3iz-4iz exhibits a very low water solubility and while photoisomerization still occurs, precipitation of the photoswitch was observed in concentrations as low as 25 μM, rendering it basically non-applicable in aqueous media without high concentrations of organic solvents present. For 3iz-pzH, no detectable amount of the Z isomer was observed after irradiation. This can be explained by a significantly increased rate of thermal relaxation via mechanisms such as tautomerism in aqueous media, leading to a near complete relaxation to the E isomer within seconds.374iz-4iz underwent isomerization but reached lower PSS in the solvent mixture compared to pure DMSO due to a strong blue-shift of the n–π* band, decreasing the absorption of the E isomer at 365 nm even further. Meanwhile, 4iz-pzH, 4iz-pzMe and 3iz-pzMe were barely affected by the change in solvent. Even though small changes in UV/vis absorption were observed, photoisomerization similar to a solution in DMSO was demonstrated.
To provide insights into the molecular structure of the synthesized compounds, single crystal X-ray crystallography structures were obtained for E-4iz-4iz and E-3iz-4iz. For the isoxazoleazopyrazoles and all Z isomers, no single crystals could be obtained. Therefore, geometry optimization via density functional theory (DFT) was performed instead (see Fig. 3 and S36–S43). For compounds E-4iz-4iz and E-3iz-4iz the obtained crystal structures are in very good agreement with the calculated lowest energy conformer.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Crystal structures of E-4iz-4iz and E-3iz-4iz and calculated geometries of the lowest energy conformer for E-4iz-pzH, E-3iz-pzH and Z isomers of all compounds. | ||
Interestingly, all E isomers display a perfectly planar structure, independent of the substitution pattern. This finding is in good agreement with the observed UV/vis spectra showing only a weak n–π* transition for the E isomer.38
In comparison, tetra-ortho-methylated azobenzenes and arylazopyrazoles rotate away from coplanarity with the azo group to reduce steric repulsion, resulting in a twisted geometry.32 However, the two smaller five-membered rings offer enough space to accommodate the four ortho-methyl groups without twisting. Similar to azobenzene, the Z isomers adopt a twisted geometry for all compounds. This twisted geometry breaks the symmetry of the molecule and is responsible for a strong increase in the otherwise symmetry-forbidden n–π* transition, which allows the near-complete Z–E-isomerization.38 Other possible geometries, such as the T-shape commonly found in Ph-N-N-Het-type photoswitches without ortho-substituents15,16 or the rare planar Z isomer found in some azobispyrazoles32 were not observed. N-methylation of the pyrazole rings leads to no striking difference in structure in all investigated molecular photoswitches (see Fig. S42/S43). Subsequent calculation of the dipole moments (see Table S4) shows that most compounds only exhibit a relatively small change in dipole moments when irradiated (0.3 D–1.3 D). Interestingly, unlike in azobenzene, the dipole moment slightly decreases for multiple compounds when isomerized, making the Z isomers less polar.
Following a reported procedure,33 we initially screened the responsiveness of all six E derivatives to green light in the presence of host H and the green light absorbing dye G (see Fig. 4a).40 Among the tested derivatives, 4iz-pzMe, 4iz-pzH, and 3iz-pzMe exhibited rapid and near-quantitative isomerization, while 3iz-4iz showed only a limited response. However, the limited response of 3iz-4iz could be drastically improved under more optimized conditions. Using higher concentrations (8 mM, 5 mol% G), over 75% E-to-Z isomerization was achieved using green light (see Fig. S32–S34), roughly doubling conversion in comparison to the directly UV-excited mechanism. The concentration dependency is probably connected with a relatively low binding affinity to host H, slowing the DESC-related E-to-Z conversion and relatively increasing the rate of the competing π–π* excitation of the Z isomer. By increasing concentration or sensitizer loading, the rate of DESC-based isomerization can be increased while the rate of direct excitation remains largely unaffected, favoring accumulation of Z isomer. For 3iz-pzH, heterodimer complex formation with G was observed. However, due to its rapid thermal Z–E-isomerization in aq. solution, no significant amount of Z isomer was detected (see Fig. S29). Compound 4iz-4iz showed no interaction with the host H and is therefore unsuitable for DESC using the host H. Due to its relatively poor response to both 310 nm and 365 nm light (see Fig. 2 and Table 1) but good initial results under DESC conditions, we focused on 3iz-pzMe for a more detailed study.
A sample of 3iz-pzMe in water, solubilized by the addition of 0.5 eq. of host H, was initially irradiated with 310 nm and 365 nm to achieve the respective poor PSS (52% for 365 nm, ca. 45% for 310 nm) via direct excitation. Irradiation with green light (515 nm) in the absence of a photosensitizer resulted in near-quantitative formation of the E isomer. Subsequent addition of 1.0 equivalent of G encapsulated in H (see Fig. 4a) and continued green light irradiation led to rapid accumulation of Z-3iz-pzMe instead (see Fig. 4c). Importantly, while the Z-to-E isomerization of the photoswitch induced by green light remains active, it is significantly outpaced by DESC-based disequilibration mechanism, hence allowing for a high PSS.
To further investigate the supramolecular system, we examined the influence of the applied amount of G on the isomerization. We observed near-quantitative formation of Z-3iz-pzMe down to 0.05 eq. of photosensitizer (see Fig. 4d), with a strong response still evident with only 1 mol% of G (see Fig. S29), although isomerization proceeded slightly slower (5 min at 1 mol% vs. 2 min at 5 mol%). With only 5 mol% of G, a PSS of nearly 80% was achieved on NMR scale (8 mM 3iz-pzMe, see Fig. S35–S37). Reversible switching between the E and Z states using only visible light was possible, as the DESC-based green light isomerization could be reversed with blue light (445 nm; see Fig. 4d inlet). Finally, we explored the use of other photosensitizers absorbing light of lower energy for 3iz-pzMe isomerization. Application of sensitizer Y enabled E-to-Z transformation under yellow light (550 nm; see Fig. 4e). While the behavior was essentially analogous to that of G, higher loadings of sensitizer (0.1 eq. or higher) and longer irradiation times were required to achieve similar PSSs, likely due to Y's lower triplet energy.31
CCDC 2463597 and 2463598 contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.41
The data supporting this article have been included as part of the SI.
Supplementary information: synthesis and spectra of photoswitches and intermediates, spectroscopic data of photoisomerization, computational details, crystallographic data. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc04412j.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |