Junjun
Ge‡
a,
Tengyue
Yin‡
a,
Haoyang
Zhang
a,
Yue
Cao
b,
Juan
Liu
cd,
Jun-Jie
Zhu
a,
Yang
Zhou
*b and
Yuanyuan
Wang
*a
aState Key Laboratory of Coordination Chemistry, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, China. E-mail: wangyy@nju.edu.cn
bKey Laboratory for Organic Electronics & Information Displays, Institute of Advanced Materials, Nanjing University of Posts & Telecommunications (NJUPT), Nanjing 210023, PR China. E-mail: iamyangzhou@njupt.edu.cn
cState Key Laboratory of Pollution Control and Resource Reuse, School of the Environment, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China
dSchool of Environmental & Chemical Engineering, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Zhenjiang 212100, China
First published on 22nd January 2025
Semiconductor magic-sized nanoclusters (MSCs) possess atomic-level compositional precision and ultrasmall dimensions, allowing accurate modulation of electrochemiluminescence (ECL) properties, essential for advanced bioanalytical applications. However, low intrinsic ECL intensity and poor stability in bipolar electrode (BPE)-ECL systems hinder their broader use. In this work, we addressed these limitations through doping and direct optical crosslinking strategies, achieving a 24-fold boost in the ECL signal and a fivefold stability increase for doped (CdS)34:Ag MSCs compared with original (CdS)34 MSCs. The resulting BPE-ECL biosensing platform was used for the sensitive detection of glucose with a linear detection range of 10 μM to 1 mM and a detection limit of 3.64 μM. This approach provides a robust strategy to enhance MSC-based ECL biosensing, paving the way for ultrasensitive, stable biosensors for clinical diagnostics and bioanalysis.
In the BPE-ECL system, the emitter plays a pivotal role, with its careful selection and design being essential to achieving optimal ECL performance. Magic-sized nanoclusters (MSCs), which are ultrasmall, monodisperse nanomaterials with countable atoms, exhibit discrete growth characteristics and unique, size-dependent optical properties.14–16 Given their small size (<2 nm) and tunable optical properties, MSCs are considered ideal emitters for ECL detection.17,18 In our previous work, we established that the ECL intensity in (CdS)34 and (CdSe)34 MSCs could be modulated by surface interface modifications.19 However, despite these enhancements, the ECL intensity of these MSCs remains comparatively low, limiting their sensitivity in application. Furthermore, the inherent instability of MSCs on the electrode surface, where they tend to detach during detection, poses practical challenges. Thus, addressing both the signal intensity and the film stability of MSCs remains essential for advancing their use in high-sensitivity ECL detection.
Doping technology offers a promising approach to enhancing the ECL emission through several mechanisms. Key among these are the improvement of emitter conductivity, fine-tuning of energy level alignment, and increased efficiency of reactions between the emitter and co-reactants.20–22 In addition, doping can reinforce emitter stability and reduce quenching effects, collectively boosting the ECL signal intensity. However, achieving effective doping while maintaining the structural stability of MSCs remains a major challenge in this field.23 Photo-crosslinking alternatively provides a viable means to enhance the stability and adhesion of materials to their substrates, critical factors for reliable ECL performance.24,25 This method strengthens interactions between the material and substrate, improving mechanical stability.26 Yet, MSCs, due to their extremely small size and high surface energy, are particularly sensitive to environmental changes. Conventional photosensitive additives, such as photoacid generators (PAGs), can potentially damage MSCs. While widely used in nanocrystal patterning, applications of photo-crosslinking in MSC-based systems are still relatively unexplored, indicating a need for further investigation to adapt these techniques in cluster-based systems.25
In this work, we introduced a crosslinked doped-MSC strategy to construct an advanced BPE-ECL sensing platform, significantly enhancing ECL performance for glucose detection (Scheme 1). Specifically, silver-doped (CdS)34 MSCs ((CdS)34:Ag MSCs) were synthesized by incubating (CdS)34 MSCs with silver trifluoromethanesulfonate (Ag(OTf)). This doping approach amplified the ECL intensity of (CdS)34 MSCs by 24-fold compared to their undoped counterparts, making the MSCs potential emitters for ECL applications (Scheme 1a). To improve emitter stability, we introduced photosensitive molecules to crosslink MSCs, which anchored them securely onto the electrode surface. In addition, crosslinked Ag NPs served as catalysts, further stabilizing the BPE-ECL devices (Scheme 1b). Using these strategies, we constructed a robust BPE-ECL system with (CdS)34:Ag MSCs as primary emitters for highly sensitive glucose detection (Scheme 1c). The platform achieved an ECL signal intensity of 8000 a.u., a 20-fold increase over traditional MSC-based ECL systems. The ECL demonstrated excellent stability over five consecutive scans. With a broad linear detection range from 10 μM to 1 mM and a low detection limit of 3.64 μM for glucose, this BPE-ECL biosensor showcased outstanding analytical performance. Our doping and crosslinking strategy effectively addresses the limitations of traditional MSC-based ECL, expanding MSC functionality and advancing the design of high-performance ECL biosensors. This approach opens new avenues for future biosensor development and innovation.
To confirm the successful doping, several experiments were conducted. The fluorescence photographs showed a color change from blue to green under UV light upon doping (Fig. 1a). Correspondingly, the photoluminescence (PL) emission peak of (CdS)34 MSCs at 515 nm red-shifted by 35 nm compared to the undoped MSCs (480 nm), with a 13-fold increase in the photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY). This enhancement and redshift were attributed to the introduction of Ag ions, which affected electron localization and altered the energy level structure of (CdS)34 MSCs.32,33 Meanwhile, the UV-visible absorption spectrum of (CdS)34:Ag MSCs exhibited a 6 nm redshift relative to the undoped MSCs (Fig. 1b), indicating an increased effective radius due to Ag atom incorporation.23 As the Ag feeding ratio increased, both UV-visible and fluorescence spectra exhibited a gradual redshift, with the PLQY reaching a maximum at a (CdS)34:
Ag(OTf) ratio of 1
:
3 (Fig. S2†).
ICP-OES was employed to determine the doping level of silver in (CdS)34 MSCs. Table S1† shows that 12–13.8% silver was successfully incorporated into the (CdS)34 MSCs. To further investigate the bonding interactions of silver within the MSCs, Raman spectroscopy was conducted. As shown in Fig. 1c, both undoped (CdS)34 MSCs and Ag-doped (CdS)34 MSCs exhibited three prominent peaks at approximately 298 cm−1 (1LO), 598 cm−1 (2LO), and 899 cm−1 (3LO). These peaks correspond to longitudinal optical (LO) phonon modes characteristic of Cd–S bonding, and their presence in both doped and undoped samples suggests that silver doping does not disrupt the intrinsic Cd–S bonding structure of the MSCs. Furthermore, no peaks associated with Ag2S (typically observed at 1297 and 1435 cm−1) were detected in the Raman spectrum of (CdS)34 MSCs. This absence confirms that silver does not form Ag–S bonds within the MSC matrix. These findings imply that Ag is incorporated into the (CdS)34 MSCs through doping rather than through the formation of Ag2S. X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) determined the forms of the elements present in the (CdS)34:Ag MSCs. The Ag 3d electron binding energy spectrum (Fig. 1d) exhibits a doublet at 367.4/373.2 eV, characteristic of Ag(I), indicating that silver does not form Ag nanoclusters or nanocrystals but instead exists as ionic species.34,35 Additionally, the XPS spectra of Cd 3d and S 2p confirm that Cd and S in the (CdS)34:Ag MSCs samples are present as Cd2+ and S2−, respectively (Fig. S4†). This suggests that Ag+ ions are likely doped into the (CdS)34 MSCs through electrostatic interactions.
Verifying the integrity of the host nanomaterials following doping is essential for evaluating the reliability and functionality of the modified materials. ICP-OES results (Table S1†) demonstrated that the ratio of Cd:
S in the doped (CdS)34 MSCs remained unchanged, consistent with the stoichiometry of the original (CdS)34-OTA MSCs. This result confirms that the doping process preserved the overall composition of the MSCs. Furthermore, the photoluminescence excitation (PLE) and UV-visible absorption spectra of the doped MSCs exhibited similar peak shapes to those of the undoped MSCs. This observation indicates that the fundamental bandgap structure of the (CdS)34 MSCs remained intact following doping. The slight red-shift observed between the PLE and absorption spectra was attributed to the contribution of different fine structure states to each signal. This behavior aligns with previously reported findings for other MSCs, such as (CdSe)13 (Fig. 1b).23
The incorporation of heteroatoms into nanoclusters often leads to changes in their structure and morphology. However, our MSCs proved to be an exception.36 The XRD patterns of (CdS)34 and (CdS)34:Ag MSCs, as shown in Fig. S3c,† exhibited only minimal variations, strongly indicating that the structural integrity of (CdS)34 MSCs remained unchanged despite the doping process. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images confirmed that the morphology of (CdS)34 MSCs was preserved, with no observable changes in shape or size (approximately 3 nm) following the introduction of Ag (Fig. S3a and b†). These combined findings provide strong evidence for successful silver doping in (CdS)34 MSCs while maintaining their structural and elemental stability.
TPA-e− → TPA˙+ | (1) |
TPA+˙ → TPA˙ + H+ | (2) |
(CdS)34:Ag-e− → (CdS)34:Ag+ | (3) |
(CdS)34:Ag+ + TPA˙ → (CdS)34:Ag* | (4) |
(CdS)34:Ag* → (CdS)34:Ag + hv | (5) |
(CdS)34:Ag+-e− → (CdS)34:Ag2+ | (6) |
(CdS)34:Ag2+ + TPA˙ → (CdS)34:Ag+ | (7) |
(CdS)34:Ag+ + TPA˙ → (CdS)34:Ag* | (8) |
(CdS)34:Ag* → (CdS)34:Ag + hv | (9) |
Importantly, the ECL intensity of (CdS)34:Ag MSCs enhanced significantly with a higher level of Ag doping, reaching a maximum at a (CdS)34 to AgOTf feed ratio of 1:
3. At this point, the ECL2 value peaked at 16
800 a.u., representing a 24-fold enhancement compared to that of the (CdS)34-OTA sample (ECL2 of 700 a.u.). This improvement was attributed to the synergistic effect of the bimetallic system (Fig. 2d and S5†). Therefore, based on these findings, we selected the (CdS)34 MSCs prepared at this doping ratio as the luminophore for subsequent detection experiments. However, the high resistance of the BPE system posed a challenge, as the (CdS)34 MSCs exhibited a luminescence potential of up to 10 V, exceeding the available potential window of conventional ECL measurements. To address this limitation, we introduced Ag NPs as catalysts to promote electron transfer and reduce the ECL potential of MSCs. The catalytic mechanism was proposed based on the higher affinity of Ag NPs for H2O2, which favored the generation of OH- and 1O2 to further facilitate electron transfer processes. This catalytic effect not only lowered the luminescence potential but also further increased the ECL intensity of the (CdS)34:Ag MSCs, enabling improved performance in the subsequent experiments (Fig. S6†).
Direct optical lithography is a photo-patterning technique that does not rely on polymer photoresists.24,25 By introducing photosensitive molecules and utilizing radical polymerization, it enables the crosslinking of MSCs. This photoresist-free and amplifier-free crosslinking strategy could minimize the potential damage, preserving the structural and functional integrity of MSCs.42 We investigated the impact of crosslinking on the stability of MSC films. The (CdS)34:Ag MSCs were mixed with a photosensitive molecule and spin-coated on ITO. Then, the crosslinked samples were exposed to UV light, while a non-crosslinked sample was not. Following this, all films were immersed in toluene and dried. The stability of the films was assessed by examining the presence of residual nanomaterials on the surface under different conditions.
We utilized a mixture of the MSCs and photosensitive molecule as a photosensitive ink for optical lithography. Under deep UV (254 nm) irradiation, photogenerated carbene radicals initiated nonspecific C–H insertion with the native ligands on MSCs, facilitating crosslinking between adjacent MSCs.26 This process rendered the MSCs in the exposed regions insoluble in nonpolar solvents, while the unexposed areas remained soluble and could be washed away with toluene to form precise patterns (Fig. 3a).
The patterning quality is demonstrated in Fig. 3b, where a 100-micron stripe pattern exhibited high fidelity with sharp and clean edges. It is worth noting that the patterning of semiconductor MSCs is considered highly challenging. This difficulty arises from the extremely small size and high surface energy of the MSCs, rendering them highly susceptible to external factors and resulting in pronounced instability. Conventional lithography processes, such as exposure, development, and etching, demand materials with high stability, making this achievement noteworthy. In this approach, UV-triggered radicals generated by the photosensitive molecule effectively couple the MSCs through their native ligands, enabling nondestructive and gentle patterning.26 Similarly, Ag NPs were successfully patterned using the same technique, as shown in Fig. 3e. The resulting 100-micron stripe patterns demonstrate high contrast, sharp edges, and excellent fidelity, underscoring the versatility of the photosensitive molecule as a universal crosslinking agent for nanomaterial patterning.
Fig. 3 and S7† reveal that the crosslinked MSCs remained intact at the micron scale after rinsing, showing no signs of breakage or detachment (Fig. S7a†). Zoomed-in images further confirmed a dense and well-defined film structure, indicating excellent stability of the crosslinked films (Fig. 3c). Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) mapping shows uniformly distributed elements. Meanwhile, the Ag element is much less abundant than both Cd and S elements (Fig. S8†). In contrast, the non-crosslinked (CdS)34:Ag MSC film showed a significant material loss after immersion in the electrode detection solution, highlighting its instability without crosslinking (Fig. 3d and S7b†). The EDS mapping reveals a uniform distribution of elements exclusively on the residual film, while the detached portion exhibits no detectable elemental attachment (Fig. S9†). A similar trend was observed for the Ag NP film. The crosslinked Ag NP films remained intact, with no signs of breakage or detachment, whereas the non-crosslinked film exhibited substantial detachment (Fig. 3f, g, S7c and d†). In addition, images of Ag NPs on the ITO surface after immersion revealed that the crosslinked Ag NPs were uniformly and stably distributed across the entire surface, with no noticeable detachment. In contrast, the non-crosslinked Ag NPs dissolved and detached. The above experiments were sufficient to demonstrate that the crosslinking strategy significantly improved the stability of MSCs and Ag NPs on ITO.
One of the most critical advantages of stable nanomaterial film formation is its ability to ensure consistent and reliable ECL signals. As both the emitter (CdS)34:Ag MSCs and catalyst Ag NPs are firmly attached to the electrode surface, the ECL intensity decays more slowly. Fig. 3i shows the ECL intensities of the BPE system under different crosslinking conditions. When neither (CdS)34:Ag MSCs nor Ag NPs are crosslinked, the ECL intensity dropped sharply by the second scan cycle. Crosslinking only the Ag NPs helps moderate the rate of decay, but a gradual decline still occurs. In contrast, when both the (CdS)34:Ag MSCs and Ag NPs are crosslinked, the ECL intensity remained stable even after five consecutive scan cycles. The enhanced stability can be explained by the fact that the stability of the film contributes to the formation of a homogeneous electrode interface, reduces non-specific adsorption and degradation, and ensures the reproducibility of the ECL reaction after prolonged use. Such improved stability plays a crucial role in optimizing the performance of electrochemical luminescence systems, making them more effective for various applications in sensing and imaging.
As shown in Fig. 4a, the ECL signals of the BPE-ECL system increase proportionally with rising glucose concentrations, demonstrating the biosensor's high efficacy for glucose detection. Fig. 4b further confirms a linear relationship (R2 = 0.997) between ECL intensity and glucose concentration over a range of 10 μM to 1 mM, achieving a detection limit (LOD) of 3.64 μM. A comparison of our approach with other reported methods in Table S2† revealed that our method exhibited markedly enhanced sensitivity for glucose detection. In this system, glucose oxidase (GOD) catalyzes the oxidation of glucose to gluconic acid, releasing hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) as a byproduct (Scheme 1a). Under voltage excitation, H2O2 decomposes into H2O and O2, accelerating electron transfer within the BPE-ECL system. This enhanced electron transfer amplifies the ECL intensity of (CdS)34 MSCs, enabling highly sensitive and reliable glucose detection.
The reproducibility and selectivity of ECL biosensors are essential metrics for evaluating their performance. High reproducibility ensures that the sensor's responses remain consistent over time and across different batches, a crucial requirement for routine clinical diagnostics and research applications. Fig. 4c presents the ECL stability of the BPE system in potential scans for 5 different electrodes. It was found that the biosensor displayed good ECL stability and reproducibility, and the calculated RSD was 1.25%, which made it applicable for glucose-related disease monitoring. Selectivity, on the other hand, determines the biosensor's ability to distinguish the target analyte from potential interfering substances in complex sample matrices. A selective biosensor minimizes cross-reactivity and false positives, thereby enhancing the accuracy of measurements. The selectivity of the BPE system for glucose detection in the presence of some biomolecules was tested. It was observed that the ECL signal response for glucose (150 μM) was significantly higher than that to other substances (0.5 mM) (Fig. 4d), which proved that our proposed biosensor showed high selectivity to glucose and could meet application requirements. Together, high reproducibility and selectivity not only enhance the credibility of the ECL biosensor but also expand its applicability in diverse fields, including medical diagnostics, environmental monitoring, and food safety testing.
The application of ECL biosensors for glucose detection in real samples, such as human serum, demonstrates their practical relevance in clinical diagnostics by a standard addition method. The samples were spiked with a standard glucose solution at concentrations of 0.01, 0.1, and 1 mM, respectively, to assess the recovery rate. The accuracy of the results was evaluated by relative standard deviation (RSD). The measured results are displayed in Table 1, and the recovery and RSD values were in the ranges of 92.21–105.96% and 4.2–6.3%, respectively, indicating that the ECL biosensor leverages its sensitivity and selectivity to provide accurate measurements despite the complex composition of biological fluids. This development highlights the versatility and effectiveness of the BPE-ECL system in addressing practical analytical challenges in the field of biosensing.
Sample | Add/mM | Recovery/% | RSD/% |
---|---|---|---|
1 | 0.01 | 99.35 | 5.7 |
2 | 0.1 | 92.21 | 4.2 |
3 | 1 | 105.96 | 6.3 |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc07800d |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |