Oleksii O. Demidova,
Ludmila V. Chepeleva
a,
Svitlana V. Shishkina
bc,
Eugene S. Gladkov
ab,
Alexander Kyrychenko
*ab,
Rostyslav P. Linnik
d and
Alexander D. Roshal
a
aInstitute of Chemistry, V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, 4 Svobody Sq., Kharkiv 61022, Ukraine. E-mail: a.v.kyrychenko@karazin.ua
bInstitute of Functional Materials Chemistry, State Scientific Institution “Institute for Single Crystals” of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, 60 Nauky Ave, 61072 Kharkiv, Ukraine
cInstitute of Organic Chemistry, NAS of Ukraine, 5 Akademik Kukhar Str., Kyiv 02066, Ukraine
d- Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Analytical Chemistry Department, 64/13 Volodymyrska Str., Kyiv 01601, Ukraine
First published on 30th September 2025
Natural flavonols exhibit a wide range of pharmacological activities and possess unique dual ESIPT (Excited-State Intramolecular Proton Transfer) fluorescence, making them sensitive to microenvironments. This sensitivity allows for the detection of metal ions, anions, small ligands, and biomacromolecules. However, the diversity in their structure, including the number and position of hydroxyl groups and potential chemical modifications, complicates the relationship between structure and fluorescence, posing challenges for their practical use as fluorescent probes. In this study, we focus on fine-tuning the ESIPT fluorescence, crystal packing, physicochemical properties, and ADMET (Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism, Excretion, and Toxicity) characteristics of a series of flavonols. We achieve this by introducing hydroxy, methoxy and benzyl groups at the C3′ and C4′ positions of the 2-phenyl side ring. The photophysical properties of the synthesized flavonols were systematically examined by UV-vis and fluorescence measurements in terms of their structure–property relationship. Our findings indicate that the nature and position of the substituent groups in flavonols can significantly influence their crystal packing in the solid state, tuning contributions of intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonding and the ESIPT behavior. Lastly, through fluorescence titration and molecular docking calculations, we explored how the introduction of a bulky benzyl moiety and its alteration between C3′ and C4′ positions can influence the binding interactions of flavonols with β-glucosidases. We believe our findings shed light on the structure–fluorescence relationship in flavonols and open up new opportunities for the design of innovative flavonol-based probes.
All the manifestations of flavonols' reactivity share common characteristics in terms of their spectral and pharmacological effects. These changes in flavonol structures, such as photodissociation, photoisomerization, complex formation, and interactions with surrounding molecules, typically involve the chromone fragment of the molecule.24 The effects of the side phenyl ring and its substituents on the reactivity, spectral, and pharmacological properties have not been thoroughly studied.
The introduction of strong electron-donating and electron-accepting groups, such as alkylamino substituents or nitro groups, into the side ring can result in significant interfragment charge transfer (ICT) between the phenyl and chromone fragments. This transfer leads to the appearance of new long-wavelength absorption bands in the spectra, attributed to the charge–transfer transition, along with changes in the fluorescence characteristics. Natural and many synthetic flavonols typically contain less effective electron-donating substituents, such as hydroxy or various alkoxy groups.8 Their impact on the spectral properties of flavonols, as previously noted, has not been thoroughly studied. Additionally, our recent studies indicate that flavonols with lipophilic alkoxy substituents on the side phenyl ring can effectively bind to hydrolase enzymes, such as glucosidases, and inhibit their catalytic activity.21,26
Physicochemical and pharmacological properties of flavonols have complex interplay on the position and number of hydroxyl groups, as well as their chemical modifications.2 Therefore, in this study, we focus on some flavonols with various combinations of substituents in the C3′ and C4′ positions of the side benzene ring. The introduction of methoxy and benzyl groups and altering their positions aimed to establish the relationship between the structure and fluorescent properties of flavonols. Our study demonstrates how the nature and position of substituents in the side ring affect the structure of flavonol molecules in both gas and crystalline phases. It also discusses how these factors influence the position of bands in absorption spectra, as well as the position and intensity ratio of emission bands for both the original and phototautomeric forms in fluorescence spectra. Finally, we consider how peripheral phenyl ring substitutions can tune the binding interactions with proteins.
Structure of unsubstituted flavonol 3 and synthesized flavonol derivatives 3a–m are summarized in Scheme 1. Unsaturated ketones (2a–c, g–m), used as precursors, were obtained by a modified known methods (Scheme 2).27,28 Preliminary spectral analysis was provided by Enamine Ltd (Ukraine). All solvents and reagents were commercial grade and, if required, purified in accordance with the standard procedures.
Flavonol | 3′ (R1) | 4′ (R2) | Starting material | Solvent | Yield, % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
3a | H | OH | 2a | MeOH | 80 |
3b | H | OCH3 | 2b28 | MeOH | 78 |
3c | H | OBn | 2c | MeOH | 73 |
3d | OH | H | 3k | THF | 85 |
3e | OH | OH | 3l | THF | 76 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | 3m | THF | 90 |
3g | OCH3 | H | 2g28 | MeOH | 69 |
3h | OCH3 | OH | 2h | MeOH | 90 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | 2i | MeOH | 73 |
3J | OCH3 | OBn | 2j | MeOH | 67 |
3k | OBn | H | 2k27 | MeOH | 85 |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | 2l27 | MeOH | 68 |
3m | OBn | OBn | 2m27 | MeOH | 74 |
Transitions | I (S0 → S1) | II (S0 → S2) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Flavonol | λabs, nm (νabs, cm−1) | f | C.I. | Type | ICT | λabs, nm (νabs, cm−1) | f | C.I. | Type |
a λabs, νabs – wavelength and wave number of the electronic transition, f – transition oscillator strength, C.I. – configuration composition of the transition, types of transitions – CHR – local, located predominantly on the chromone fragment, CT – transition with interfragment charge transfer, FL – transition localized on the molecule as a whole, n → π* – forbidden nπ* transition. ICT – value of interfragment charge transfer during the S0 → S1 transition. | |||||||||
H | 349 (28![]() |
0.354 | 0.69χ1→1’ | CHR | 0.102 | 308 (32![]() |
0.000 | 0.70χ4→1’ | n → π* |
3′-OH | 356 (28![]() |
0.308 | 0.68χ1→1’ | CHR | 0.133 | 332 (30![]() |
0.041 | 0.68χ2→1’ | CT |
4′-OH | 361 (27![]() |
0.435 | 0.70χ1→1’ | CHR | 0.152 | 306 (32![]() |
0.000 | 0.70χ4→1’ | n → π* |
3′,4′-OH | 372 (26![]() |
0.421 | 0.70χ1→1’ | CHR | 0.232 | 315 (31![]() |
0.068 | 0.70χ2→1’ | FL |
Transitions | III (S0 → S3) | IV (S0 → S4) | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
λabs, nm (νabs, cm−1) | f | C.I. | Type | λabs, nm (νabs, cm−1) | f | C.I. | Type | |
H | 292 (34![]() |
0.116 | 0.70χ2→1’ | FL | 284 (35![]() |
0.137 | 0.64χ3→1’ | CT |
3′-OH | 306 (32![]() |
0.000 | 0.70χ4→1’ | n→π* | 289 (34![]() |
0.137 | 0.64χ3→1’ | FL |
4′-OH | 298 (33![]() |
0.089 | 0.67χ2→1’ | FL | 282 (35![]() |
0.005 | 0.41χ1→2’ + 0.41χ1→3’ | FL |
3′,4′-OH | 305 (32![]() |
0.000 | 0.70χ4→1’ | n→π* | 290 (34![]() |
0.058 | 0.65χ3→1’ | CT |
The molecular orbitals of unsubstituted flavonol, as well as its monosubstituted derivatives that have hydroxyl groups in the C3′ and C4′ positions, are illustrated in Fig. 1. Meanwhile, the disubstituted derivative, 3′,4′-dihydroxyflavonol, is also included in this analysis. Fig. 2 presents a diagram showing the relative energies of these molecular orbitals. Additionally, Table 2 provides details on the theoretical parameters of long-wavelength transitions observed in the spectra of these compounds. The analysis of configurational interaction reveals that the long-wavelength intense transitions of all flavonols can be characterized by a transition between the highest occupied molecular orbital (MO) φ1 and the lowest vacant molecular orbital φ1′ The MO φ1 is delocalized between the chromone and the side phenyl fragment. However, as the torsion angle between these fragments increases, the localization of MO φ1 increasingly favors the chromone fragment. In contrast, the vacant MO φ1' is primarily localized on the chromone fragment. Therefore, it can be concluded that the long-wavelength electron transition generally exhibits a “chromone” nature (CHR).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Frontier molecular orbitals of flavonol, and substituted flavonol with 3′-OH, 4′-OH, and 3′,4′-OH. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Influence of substituents' positions on MO energies in flavonols obtained using the b3lyp/cc-pVDZ level of theory (see Table 2 for more details). |
This conclusion is supported by the relatively low values of interfragment charge transfer during the transition from the ground state to the Frank–Condon excited state S1, which are approximately 0.1–0.2 electronic charges (e−) only. These low values suggest that the side phenyl ring does not significantly participate in the excitation process.
The Table 2 illustrates that increasing the number of substituents in the phenyl side ring results in a decrease in S0 → S1 transition energy, i.e. to a bathochromic shift of the corresponding absorption band from 350 nm to 370 nm approximately. Adding a substituent at position C4′ enhances the transition oscillator strength f, which in turn increases the intensity of the associated absorption band. Conversely, introducing a substituent at position C3′ has the opposite effect, reducing the intensity of the absorption band.
DFT calculations of the electronic spectrum for the compound featuring an OH group at the C3′ position reveal an additional long-wavelength band in the ∼330 nm range. This band results from an electronic transition between the φ2 orbital, which is localized on the side phenyl ring, and the φ1′ orbital, which is localized on the chromone fragment. This transition is associated with significant inter-fragment charge transfer (ICT). In the spectra of other compounds, similar transitions are observed in the shorter wavelength region of 285–290 nm (see Table 2). This phenomenon occurs due to an increase in the energy of the corresponding occupied molecular orbital when a substituent is introduced at the C3′ position. In Fig. 2, the energies of the molecular orbitals localized on the side phenyl ring are highlighted in red. In the 305–310 nm spectrum range, all compounds have a forbidden n–π* transition from the n-orbital φ4 to the orbital φ1′. The short-wave intense band ranging from 280 to 315 nm in all spectra is attributed to the electronic transition φ2 → φ1′ (with φ3 → φ1′ occurring in the compound substituted at the C3′ position). As illustrated in Fig. 1, the φ2 orbital is delocalized across both fragments of the flavonol molecule. Therefore, the transition from φ2 to φ1′ is not localized and can be understood as the excitation of the molecule as a whole. It should be noted that the results from the DFT method correlate well with semi-empirical methods.49
The impact of the side phenyl ring on the chromone fragment arises from both the electronic effects of its substituents and the extent of their electronic conjugation governed by the torsion angle between the planes of the both fragments. The conformations of flavonol molecules in the gas phase, as well as in dichloromethane and acetonitrile, were investigated by modeling the potential energy curves associated with the rotation of the side ring relative to the plane of the chromone fragment. This rotation was analyzed over an angle range from −30° to 150° for 3′-hydroxy-, 4′-hydroxy-, and 3′,4′-dihydroxyflavonols. As illustrated in Fig. 3, regardless of the substituent's position, the minimum potential energy occurs at angles between −10° and 10°. This observation indicates that over 97% of flavonol molecules are planar in both solutions and the gas phase. Furthermore, the calculations reveal that an increase in the polarity of the medium results in a decrease in the rotation barrier by approximately 0.6 to 0.7 kcal mol−1.
The influence of electronic effects from substituents is quantified by the Hammett constants σpara and σmeta. However, since multiple substituents can simultaneously occupy the para and meta positions in the side ring, and considering the dampening effect of the aromatic π-system, we calculated the overall σpara constants for various RO-phenyl substituents using the web tool outlined in the article.51 The calculated σpara values are presented in Table 3. It is important to note that these σpara values are notably low, indicating a very weak influence of the substituents in the side benzene ring on the electronic structure of the chromone moiety of the molecules.
Flavonol | 3′-R | 4′-R | σpara | Dichloromethane | Acetonitrile | Δνabs | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
λabs | νabs | λabs | νabs | |||||
a σpara – Hammett constants for R-oxyphenyl fragments, λabs – absorption band maxima in nm scale, νabs – absorption band maxima in cm−1 scale, Δνabs– shifts of absorption band maxima on going from dichloromethane to acetonitrile.b Spectral data for unsubstituted flavonol 3 were taken from ref. 50 The data for nonpolar medium are shown for chloroform. | ||||||||
3b | H | H | 0.000 | 344 | 29![]() |
340 | 29![]() |
330 |
3a | H | OH | −0.047 | 351 | 28![]() |
350 | 28![]() |
80 |
3b | H | OCH3 | −0.037 | 352 | 28![]() |
350 | 28![]() |
160 |
3c | H | OBn | −0.007 | 355 | 28![]() |
349 | 28![]() |
485 |
3d | OH | H | +0.007 | 346 | 28![]() |
343 | 29![]() |
255 |
3e | OH | OH | −0.046 | 353 | 28![]() |
355 | 28![]() |
−160 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | −0.040 | 356 | 28![]() |
354 | 28![]() |
160 |
3g | OCH3 | H | +0.017 | 345 | 28![]() |
342 | 29![]() |
256 |
3h | OCH3 | OH | −0.041 | 357 | 28![]() |
355 | 28![]() |
160 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | −0.037 | 361 | 27![]() |
356 | 28![]() |
390 |
3j | OCH3 | OBn | −0.003 | 361 | 27![]() |
356 | 28![]() |
390 |
3k | OBn | H | +0.032 | 346 | 28![]() |
343 | 29![]() |
255 |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | −0.005 | 360 | 27![]() |
356 | 28![]() |
310 |
3m | OBn | OBn | −0.001 | 361 | 27![]() |
355 | 28![]() |
470 |
A comparison of the σpara constants with the positions of the long-wavelength absorption bands in the experimental spectra of flavonols revealed no correlation between them.
This indicates that substituents do not have a significant impact on the spectral parameters of flavonols. For example, substituting a hydroxy group with either a methoxy group or a benzyloxy group in the same position on the aromatic ring does not cause any shift in the absorption band (see Table 3 and Fig. 4a). Additionally, no shifts in the band position were observed with any combinations of substituents in 3′,4′-disubstituted flavonols.
More significant differences in the absorption band parameters are observed depending on the positions of the substituents in the benzene ring (see Fig. 4b). For 3′-R-hydroxyflavonols in dichloromethane, regardless of the type of substituents, the absorption maximum falls within the range of 345–346 nm (28900–28985 cm−1). The σpara constants for these compounds have positive values of +0.01 to +0.03, indicating a very weak electron-withdrawing effect of the benzene ring on the chromone fragment. In contrast, 4′-R-oxyflavonols and 3′,4′-di-R-hydroxyflavonols exhibit long-wavelength band maxima in approximately similar range: at 351–355 nm (28
170–28490 cm−1) and 353–361 nm (27
700–28330 cm−1), respectively. The corresponding σpara constants for these compounds range from −0.01 to −0.05, suggesting that the benzene ring demonstrates weakly expressed electron-releasing properties. When going to a more polar environment, such as acetonitrile, a slight hypsochromic shift of the absorption bands from 80 to 500 cm−1 is observed (see Table 3). Additionally, the effect of substituent position is even less pronounced in acetonitrile.
The σpara values indicate that substituents on the side benzene ring have a very weak effect on the spectral properties of flavonols. In contrast, the introduction of 4′-diethylamino- and 4′-nitro substituents into the side ring results in significant changes to the absorption spectra. In these latter cases, the σpara values are tens of times greater, measuring −0.146 and +0.372, respectively. Natural flavonols commonly contain hydroxy and various alkoxy groups, which typically have low σpara values. Therefore, it can be assumed that natural flavonols with a similar structure in the chromone moiety of their molecules will exhibit approximately the same absorption spectra, regardless of the type or location of substituents in the side phenolic ring.
Due to the ESIPT process, the fluorescence spectra of flavonols can exhibit two distinct fluorescence bands. The first is a short-wavelength emission band corresponding to the excited form of the original flavonol (N*), and the second is a long-wavelength emission band from the phototautomer (T*), which is formed by the transfer of a proton from the 3-hydroxy group to the carbonyl group of the chromone fragment. Proton transfer is typically a very rapid and irreversible process, resulting in the fluorescence spectrum usually displaying only one long-wavelength band of the phototautomer (T*). However, as the polarity of the medium increases, the activation barrier for the proton transfer reaction also increases. Consequently, a band corresponding to the N* form may appear in the fluorescence spectra. In proton-donating solvents or when proton-donating impurities are present, flavonols can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds. This leads to suppressing the excited-state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) and results in the fluorescence of the N* form. Additionally, substituents on the side ring of flavonols can influence the dynamics of phototautomerization. Specifically, introducing an electron-releasing group at the C4′ position may decrease the acidity of the 3-hydroxy group in the chromone ring and slow down ESIPT, which can lead to the emergence of two-band fluorescence.
The experimental fluorescence spectra of all the studied flavonols exhibited a single emission band. This observed emission band is attributed to the T* phototautomer, as indicated by the high Stokes shift values in the range of 8900–10500 cm−1 (see Table 4). A trace amount of fluorescence from the N* form can be detected in the short-wavelength region of the spectra. However, this may be attributed to water impurities that were adsorbed by acetonitrile during the experiment, as well as the formation of trace amounts of flavonol hydrates, which may not undergo proton phototransfer. Considering the low σpara values and the spectral parameters outlined in Table 3, we can conclude that the fluorescence spectra of natural flavonols in aprotic solvents will be single-band, regardless of the nature and position of the substituents in the side benzene ring. The effects of the nature and position of these substituents are illustrated in Fig. 5a and b, while the quantitative parameters of the emission bands are provided in Table 3.
Flavonol | 3′-R | 4′-R | Dichloromethane | Acetonitrile | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
λfl | νfl | ΔνSt | λfl | νfl | ΔνSt | |||
a λfl, νfl – these designations are given in Table 2, ΔνSt – Stokes shifts of fluorescence, cm−1.b Spectral data for unsubstituted flavonol were taken from ref. 50 data for nonpolar medium are shown for chloroform. | ||||||||
3b | H | H | 530 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
526 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3a | H | OH | 528 | 18![]() |
9550 | 547 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3b | H | OCH3 | 530 | 18![]() |
9540 | 532 | 18![]() |
9775 |
3c | H | OBn | 529 | 18![]() |
9265 | 539 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3d | OH | H | 527 | 18![]() |
9925 | 527 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3e | OH | OH | 529 | 18![]() |
9425 | 536 | 18![]() |
9515 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | 534 | 18![]() |
9365 | 538 | 18![]() |
9665 |
3g | OCH3 | H | 524 | 19![]() |
9900 | 528 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3h | OCH3 | OH | 531 | 18![]() |
9180 | 534 | 18![]() |
9440 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | 533 | 18![]() |
8940 | 528 | 18![]() |
9150 |
3j | OCH3 | OBn | 534 | 18![]() |
8975 | 542 | 18![]() |
9640 |
3k | OBn | H | 525 | 19![]() |
9850 | 536 | 18![]() |
10![]() |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | 534 | 18![]() |
9055 | 540 | 18![]() |
9570 |
3m | OBn | OBn | 534 | 18![]() |
8975 | 542 | 18![]() |
9720 |
The analysis of the data in Table 3 indicates that the nature and position of the substituents in the side benzene ring have a lesser impact on the position of the T* emission band compared to the position of the absorption bands. Specifically, the average emission band maxima for 3′-R-oxy-, 4′-R-oxy-, and 3′,4′-R-dioxyflavonols are 525 ± 2 nm, 529 ± 1 nm, and 533 ± 4 nm, respectively. The shifts of the bands when changing the position of the substituent range from 135 to 145 cm−1 on the energy scale, which indicates that these shifts are relatively insignificant.
The energy costs involved in rearranging the geometry of molecules and their solvate shell is characterized by the Stokes shifts of fluorescence (ΔνSt). For the flavonols studied in dichloromethane, the values of ΔνSt range from 9850 to 9925 cm−1 for 3′-R-hydroxyflavonols, 9265 to 9550 cm−1 for 4′-R-hydroxyflavonols, and 8940 to 9425 cm−1 for 3′,4′-R-dihydroxyflavonols. Notably, the lowest Stokes shift values are observed in flavonols that lack hydroxyl groups. Considering the similar mechanism and kinetics of excited-state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT), as well as the larger ΔνSt values for hydroxyl-containing flavonols and the planar geometry of molecules in both the initial and phototautomeric forms (T*), we can conclude that the differences in Stokes shifts arise from the structural characteristics of the solvation shell in the ground state and its subsequent rearrangement during phototautomerization.
The changes in solvent polarity on going from dichloromethane to acetonitrile do not significantly affect the position of the phototautomer emission bands. The observed shifts in the bands are multidirectional, do not exceed a few nanometers, and are statistically insignificant. The Stokes shifts of fluorescence for 3′-R-hydroxyflavonols, 4′-R-hydroxyflavonols, and 3′,4′-R-dihydroxyflavonols in acetonitrile are within the ranges of 10190–10500 cm−1, 9775–10290 cm−1, and 9150–9665 cm−1, respectively. Thus, ΔνSt values of flavonols in more polar acetonitrile are correspondingly 460, 625, and 225 cm−1 higher than those in less polar dichloromethane. A comparison of the spectral characteristics of the absorption and fluorescence bands indicates that the increase in ΔνSt is due to a hypsochromic shift of the absorption bands when going from dichloromethane to acetonitrile solutions. This suggests additional energy costs are associated with the relaxation of the solvate shell of flavonols upon excitation in polar media.
Fluorescence excitation spectra were measured by assessing the luminescence intensity at 450 nm and 550 nm, corresponding to the emission regions of the N* and T* forms, respectively. The refined positions of the maxima of the long-wavelength band in the excitation spectra (λmaxex/νmaxex) were determined through double differentiation of the spectral curves. The differences in maxima positions in the spectra measured at 450 nm and 550 nm did not exceed 3 nm; therefore, averaged values of λmaxex/νmaxex were utilized for further analysis of the obtained data. The spectral characteristics of flavonols in the solid state are presented in Table 5.
Flavonol | 3′-R | 4′-R | Excitation spectra | Fluorescence spectra | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Form N* | Form T* | IN/IT | |||||||||
λex | νex | λN | νN | ΔνSt,N | λT | νT | ΔνSt,T | ||||
a λex, νex – positions of long-wavelength excitation bands in nm and cm−1; λN, νN, λT, νT– positions of emission bands of N* and T* forms in nm and cm−1; ΔνSt,N and ΔνSt,T – Stokes shifts of fluorescence of N* and T* forms in cm−1 calculated relatively long-wavelength excitation bands: ΔνSt,N = νexc − νN and ΔνSt,T = νexc − νT; IN/IT – ratio of intensities of forms N* and T*.b Spectral data for unsubstituted flavonol were taken from ref. 50 data for nonpolar medium are shown for chloroform. | |||||||||||
3b | H | H | 357 | 28![]() |
461 | 21![]() |
6330 | 547 | 18![]() |
9730 | 0.85 |
3a | H | OH | 363 | 27![]() |
453 | 22![]() |
5530 | 553 | 18![]() |
9530 | 1.14 |
3b | H | OCH3 | 364 | 27![]() |
452 | 22![]() |
5400 | 545 | 18![]() |
9180 | 1.73 |
3c | H | OBn | 363 | 27![]() |
467 | 21![]() |
6186 | 557 | 17![]() |
9634 | 1.26 |
3d | OH | H | 363 | 27![]() |
475 | 21![]() |
6530 | 539 | 18![]() |
9030 | 1.13 |
3e | OH | OH | 365 | 27![]() |
453 | 22![]() |
5320 | 539 | 18![]() |
8840 | 1.58 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | 363 | 27![]() |
460 | 21![]() |
5850 | 561 | 17![]() |
9730 | 1.11 |
3g | OCH3 | H | 362 | 27![]() |
450 | 22![]() |
5450 | 537 | 18![]() |
9030 | 1.76 |
3h | OCH3 | OH | 362 | 27![]() |
464 | 21![]() |
6100 | 550 | 18![]() |
9460 | 1.32 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | 364 | 27![]() |
486 | 20![]() |
6910 | 536 | 18![]() |
8800 | 1.57 |
3j | OCH3 | OBn | 365 | 24![]() |
456 | 21![]() |
5475 | 545 | 18![]() |
9083 | 1.62 |
3k | OBn | H | 375 | 26![]() |
457 | 21![]() |
4805 | 555 | 18![]() |
8640 | 2.57 |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | 362 | 27![]() |
454 | 22![]() |
5630 | 542 | 18![]() |
9220 | 1.63 |
3m | OBn | OBn | 357 | 28![]() |
461 | 21![]() |
6330 | 547 | 18![]() |
9730 | 0.85 |
The data presented in the Table 5 indicate that the positions of the fluorescence excitation bands in the solid phase do not correspond with the positions of the absorption bands in flavonol solutions, nor do they align with the Hammett constants of the side ring. When going from the less polar solvent dichloromethane to the more polar solvent acetonitrile, the positions of absorption band maxima shift hypsochromically by an average of 415 cm−1. In contrast, moving to the crystalline phase results in a bathochromic shift of the bands by an average of 730 cm−1, which suggests a decrease in the environmental polarity. Additionally, flavonols in the crystalline state exhibit a smaller variation in the bands' positions.
To understand how substituents on the side benzene ring of flavonols influence their spectral properties, X-ray structural analysis was conducted on compounds 3b and 3k. The structures and geometries of the substances studied, as obtained from X-ray diffraction, are illustrated in Fig. 6. It is important to note that the “crystallographic” numbering of atoms, assigned during structure resolution using the OLEX2 package, does not align with the atom numbering typically used for flavonols. Therefore, when referencing the “crystallographic” atom numbers below, an asterisk will be used to indicate them.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Molecular structure of compounds 3b (on the left) and 3k (on the right) according to the X-ray diffraction data. Thermal ellipsoids are shown at 50% probability level. |
The presence of a phenyl substituent at the C9* atom in molecules 3b and 3k (Fig. 6) suggests conjugation between the π-systems of the chromone fragment and the side benzene ring. The X-ray analysis revealed that, in contrast to their geometry in solution or the gas phase, flavonols in a crystalline state are non-planar molecules. Thus, in molecules 3b and 3k, these fragments are rotated relative to each other (torsion angle C8*–C9*–C10*–C11* in Fig. 6) by 12.3(3)° in molecule 3b and by −17.3(4)° in molecule 3k, and the length of the C9*–C10* bond (1.468(2) Å) in molecule 3b and 1.463(3) Å in molecule 3k) is comparable to the average length of the Csp2–Car bond in conjugated systems 1.470 Å.52
The non-planarity of flavonol molecules in the solid state, i.e. the presence of some non-zero dihedral angles between the molecular fragments additionally diminishes the influence of substituents on the side ring regarding the electron density distribution in the chromone part of the molecule. Thus, the effect of substituents on the spectral properties of flavonols occurs only indirectly, mediated by conformational effects and the polarity of the surrounding environment. The latter is influenced by the parameters of the crystal lattice, which can in turn be affected by the volumetric characteristics and positions of the substituents.
Unlike the fluorescence spectra of flavonol solutions, which show only one emission band from the T* phototautomer, the spectra of flavonols in the solid state exhibit two emission bands (Fig. 7).
The short-wavelength fluorescence bands of the N* form in most flavonols typically range from 450 to 460 nm (approximately 22200–21700 cm−1). However, in compounds 3d, 3e, and 3j, these bands are slightly shifted toward the long-wavelength region. It is important to note the large Stokes shifts of fluorescence, which range from 4800 to 6900 cm−1. This range is approximately 1500 to 2500 cm−1 greater than that observed in most fluorophores. This discrepancy likely results from significant energy costs associated with the structural relaxation of the excited molecule within a rigid crystal lattice.
The fluorescence bands of the T* form are centered between 540 and 560 nm (corresponding to 18550–17850 cm−1). These bands are shifted by 20 to 30 nm toward the long-wavelength region of the spectrum compared to the fluorescence bands of the same form in the solutions. In the solid state, the Stokes shifts of the fluorescence of the flavonol phototautomer are smaller than those in the solutions, measuring between 8800 and 9730 cm−1. This suggests the absence of a significant structural relaxation of the phototautomer in the excited state.
No dependence was found between the positions of the N* and T* bands in the fluorescence spectra of crystalline flavonols and the nature or position of the substituents in the side ring.
The appearance of the short-wavelength N* emission band evidences that the intramolecular proton transfer is partially suppressed. The side ring substituents have weak electronic effects, and the non-planar geometry of the molecules suggests that the side rings have a minimal impact on proton transfer kinetics. Another factor contributing to the reduced efficiency of the excited-state intramolecular proton transfer is the weakening of the intramolecular hydrogen bond necessary for the proton transfer between the carbonyl group and the 3-hydroxy group of chromone.
As illustrated in Fig. 8, the hydrogen atoms of the 3-hydroxy group form bifurcated hydrogen bonds. According to Etter's rules,53,54 the formation of intramolecular hydrogen bonds is preferred over intermolecular hydrogen bonds. However, the hydrogen bond that closes the five-membered ring is not sufficiently effective. This likely leads to the hydroxyl group in all three structures acting as a proton donor in two hydrogen bonds simultaneously: the intramolecular O3*–H⋯O2* and the intermolecular O3*–H⋯O2′*. The O2* atom, in turn, serves as a proton acceptor in both hydrogen bonds.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Crystalline structure of 4′-methoxy (3b) and 3′-benzyloxy (3k) flavonols. Intramolecular and intermolecular hydrogen bonds are shown with green dashed lines. |
The nature of the primary structural motif formed by the intermolecular hydrogen bonds varies. In structure 3b, hydrogen-bonded chains are formed, while in structures 3c and 3k, centrosymmetric hydrogen-bonded dimers are established (see Fig. 8). It is important to note that the formation of bifurcated hydrogen bonds weakens each bond, as demonstrated by their characteristics (refer to Table 6).
Hydrogen bond | Symmetry operation | Geometric characteristics | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
H⋯O, Å | O⋯O, Å | O–H⋯O, deg | ||
Structure 3b | ||||
O3*–H⋯O2* | 2.23 | 2.677(2) | 113.30 | |
O3*–H⋯O2′* | 1 − x,0.5 + y,0.5 − z | 1.98 | 2.753(2) | 153.6 |
![]() |
||||
Structure 3k | ||||
O3*–H⋯O2* | 2.27 | 2.712(3) | 113.5 | |
O3*–H⋯O2’* | −x, −y, 1 − z | 2.01 | 2.751(3) | 146.0 |
Since the formation of multi-center hydrogen bonds weakens the intramolecular hydrogen-bond component, it leads to a decrease in the rate of phototautomerization. Consequently, the rate of the proton transfer becomes comparable to the rate of emission of the original form N*, which results in the appearance of the corresponding short-wavelength band N* in the spectra.
The fluorescence intensity ratio of the initial form (N*) to the phototautomer (T*), represented as IN/IT, indicates that for most compounds, the emission intensity of form N* is greater than that of form T*. In several flavonols, the intensity IN can exceed IT by 10–20%. However, most compounds show low ESIPT efficiency with the luminescence intensity of form N* surpassing that of form T* by 1.5 to 2.5 times. An analysis of the IN/IT values reveals that the ratio of forms N* and T* in the excited state does not depend on the position and nature of the substituents. Nonetheless, a significant slowdown in ESIPT is primarily observed in flavonols with bulky benzyl substituents. This suggests that the spectral properties of these compounds must be determined by the characteristics of their crystal.
In this study, we aimed to investigate the influence of C3′- and C4′-substitutions in flavonols on their protein binding affinity and selectivity. We examined the fluorescence properties of flavonols when interacting with β-glucosidase. Fig. 9 displays the results of fluorescence titration of flavonols 3k and 3l by varying concentrations of β-glucosidase in a phosphate buffer at pH 6.86. Despite their common use in biomedical applications, flavonols have low solubility in water.61 To address this issue, we dissolved them in the buffer by adding small aliquots of their DMSO stock solution. To explore the interaction between flavonols and the enzyme, we followed a fluorescence titration protocol similar to the one used in our recent study.26 In summary, during the titration, we maintained the concentration of flavonols at approximately 1–2 × 10−5 M, while gradually varying the concentration of glucosidase from 0 to 9.5 × 10−4 M.
As shown in Fig. 9, the fluorescence intensity of both flavonols 3k and 3l increases with higher concentrations of β-glucosidase. This phenomenon, which has also been observed with other flavonols, is attributed to a protein-induced “turn-on” effect.26,39,58,59,62 The increase in fluorescence can be explained by the reduction of water-induced fluorescence quenching, which occurs as the probes bind to and penetrate deeper into the water-free hydrophobic regions of biomacromolecules.6,63 In addition to the significant “turn-on” effect observed, there is also a noticeable redistribution of the normal-to-phototautomer emission intensity. Specifically, the contribution of the normal form, represented by the short-wavelength band around 450 nm, gradually increases. This dual-band redistribution is more prominent in the case of flavonol 3l, indicating a possible alteration in its binding mode to the β-glucosidase protein (see Fig. 9b).
The strong fluorescence of the normal form suggests that the ESIPT process is somewhat inhibited in the protein-bound state of flavonols 3k and 3l. Several factors could explain this, including: (i) the formation of intermolecular hydrogen bonds with protein residues, or (ii) the disruption of the intramolecular hydrogen bond between the 3-OH group and the 4O carbonyl oxygen due to steric constraints within the protein-binding pocket. Additionally, it is possible that both mechanisms contribute to the ESIPT-sensitive behavior of the flavonols. This implies that even small modifications in the peripheral side ring of the chromone moiety could significantly influence ligand–protein interactions, including their strength and selectivity.
Probe's lipophilicity affects its permeability across cell membranes, the partitioning and distribution of a drug-like molecule, as well as its metabolism and renal excretion.65 Our fluorescence titration experiments shown in Fig. 9 demonstrated that flavonol binding to the protein was primarily driven by the hydrophobic effect because of their high liphophilicity. Therefore, we first tried to see if there is some correlations between spectral changes seen in Fig. 9 and liphophilicity of the studied flavonols.
Lipophilicity is defined as the logarithm of the octanol–water partition coefficient (logPo/w) that reflects the ability of a molecule to dissolve in the liphophilic environment, such as a lipid membrane.
Table 7 summarizes calculated consensus logP for model flavonol 3 and studied flavonols 3a–m. Table 7 illustrates that the gradual introduction of methoxy and benzoyl groups into the 2-phenyl ring increases the log
Po/w value from 2.84 for the unsubstituted flavonol to as high as 5.87 for the compound 3m. It is also noteworthy that empirical in silico predictions of log
Po/w parameters are not sensitive to the specific positions of substitutions. For instance, both 3j and 3l were predicted to have the same log
Po/w value of 4.33. To thoroughly investigate the molecular-level details of how variations in the C3′ and C4′-substituents fine-tune protein-ligand binding interactions, computational tools, such as molecular docking, that account for the implicit structure of proteins should be utilized.
Flavonol | 3′-R1 | 4′-R2 | Mw (g mol−1) | TPSA (Å2) | Number of H-bond donors | Number of H-bond acceptors | Consensus log Po/w* |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Consensus log![]() |
|||||||
3 | H | H | 238.2 | 50.4 | 1 | 3 | 2.84 |
3a | H | OH | 254.2 | 70.7 | 2 | 4 | 2.77 |
3b | H | OCH3 | 268.3 | 59.7 | 1 | 4 | 3.02 |
3c | H | OBn | 330.3 | 59.7 | 1 | 4 | 4.57 |
3d | OH | H | 254.2 | 70.7 | 2 | 4 | 2.77 |
3e | OH | OH | 270.2 | 90.9 | 3 | 5 | 2.34 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | 284.3 | 79.9 | 2 | 5 | 2.62 |
3g | OCH3 | H | 268.3 | 59.7 | 1 | 4 | 3.02 |
3h | OCH3 | OH | 284.3 | 79.9 | 2 | 5 | 2.62 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | 298.3 | 68.9 | 1 | 5 | 2.85 |
3j | OCH3 | OBn | 360.4 | 68.9 | 1 | 5 | 4.33 |
3k | OBn | H | 330.3 | 59.7 | 1 | 4 | 4.57 |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | 360.4 | 68.9 | 1 | 5 | 4.33 |
3m | OBn | OBn | 422.4 | 68.9 | 1 | 5 | 5.87 |
Fig. 10 illustrates the X-ray structure of the β-glucosidase from Thermotoga maritima (TmGH1). Although there are some variations in the primary structure at the peripheral regions of the protein, all enzymes within the glucosidase family exhibit a high sequence identity of over 90%. The main common features of these enzymes include: (i) the presence of a deep hydrophobic pocket that can accommodate substrate molecules during cellulolytic hydrolysis (Fig. 10a), and (ii) a catalytic active site composed of two glutamate (Glu) residues situated in close proximity to each other (see Fig. 10a and b).
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 The X-ray structure of Thermotoga maritima β-glucosidase (PDB 1OD0)47 shown in a side (a) and top (b) views, respectively. The catalytic Glu166 and Glu351 residues for are shown by color-coded sticks. |
For our molecular docking analysis of flavonol–glucosidase interactions, we selected β-glucosidases from four different sources: Paenibacillus polymyxa β-glucosidase B (BglB),45 Raucaffricine β-glucosidase (rBG),46 Thermotoga maritima β-glucosidase (TmGH1),47 and human cytosolic β-glucosidase (hCBG).48 The X-ray 3D structures of these proteins have been well resolved, so that some of them already used as receptor models for molecular docking calculations.26,39,62,68–70
The structural and energetic characteristics of the interactions between flavonols 3k and 3l, and β-glucosidases were analyzed using molecular docking calculations, which are summarized in Table 8.
Flavonol | 3′-R1 | 4′-R2 | Binding affinity, kcal mol−1 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Human cytosolic β-glucosidase (PDB 2JFE) | Paenibacillus polymyxa β-glucosidase (PDB 2O9R) | Thermotoga maritima β-glucosidase (PDB 1OD0) | Raucaffricine β-glucosidase (PDB 4A3Y) | |||
3 | H | H | −8.8 | −8.3 | −8.5 | −8.7 |
3a | H | OH | −9.2 | −8.5 | −8.9 | −8.5 |
3b | H | OCH3 | −9.3 | −8.9 | −8.6 | −8.8 |
3c | H | OBn | −10.4 | −9.1 | −9.3 | −9.3 |
3d | OH | H | −9.0 | −8.6 | −8.9 | −9.5 |
3e | OH | OH | −9.6 | −9.0 | −8.8 | −9.0 |
3f | OH | OCH3 | −8.6 | −8.4 | −8.2 | −9.0 |
3g | OCH3 | H | −8.9 | −8.9 | −8.7 | −9.4 |
3h | OCH3 | OH | −9.0 | −8.7 | −8.9 | −9.3 |
3i | OCH3 | OCH3 | −8.8 | −8.7 | −8.6 | −8.0 |
3j | OCH3 | OBn | −10.4 | −9.4 | −9.3 | −9.3 |
3k | OBn | H | −10.6 | −10.0 | −9.9 | −9.8 |
3l | OBn | OCH3 | −10.6 | −9.7 | −9.4 | −9.2 |
3m | OBn | OBn | −11.9 | −11.1 | −11.0 | −10.2 |
The results indicate that all examined flavonols exhibit strong binding affinities, with values exceeding −8.5 kcal mol−1. Furthermore, flavonols can penetrate deeply into the central cavity of β-glucosidase and bind closely to the catalytic glutamic acid (Glu) residues.
Examples of binding modes for flavonols are illustrated in Fig. 11, specifically for β-glucosidase TmGH1. Molecular docking studies indicate that the binding affinity of compounds 3kand 3lto β-glucosidase depends on the specific characteristics of the peripheral substituents located at the C3′- and C4′-positions of the flavonol's phenyl ring.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 The best binding mode of flavonols 3k (a and b) and 3l (c and d) to β-glucosidase TmGH1 (PDB 1OD0). The catalytic residues Glu166 and Glu351 are shown as color-coded sticks. Some key enzyme interacting residues are also shown. (b and d) 2D interaction maps of selected flavonols with key protein residues. |
In the case of flavonol 3k, it binds deeper into the enzyme pocket, with the 3OH-chromone moiety favoring a position close to the catalytic residue Glu166. The bulky 3′-benzyl ring protrudes outward from the enzyme pocket (see Fig. 11a). In contrast, the introduction of an additional 4′-methoxy group results in a reversal of the binding mode. For flavonol 3l, the 2-phenyl ring, featuring the bulky 3′-benzyl and 4′-methoxy groups, occupies the catalytic pocket, displacing the 3OH-chromone moiety outwards (see Fig. 11c).
Fig. 11b and d illustrate 2D interaction maps of flavonols with β-glucosidase TmGH1. Flavonol 3k binds to TmGH1 through non-covalent interactions, including π-π stacking of the 2-phenyl ring with TYR295 and TRP324. It also involves short-range π-anion interactions between the aromatic ring of the chromone and GLU405, as well as hydrogen bonding between the 3′-benzyl oxygen atom and ASN222 (Fig. 11b). In contrast, flavonol 3l exhibits much more complex interaction patterns. The major contributions to its binding include classical π-π stacking or π-π T-shaped stacking of the 3′-benzyl ring with TYR295, TRP298, and PHE414. Additionally, there are π-anion interactions of the 3′-benzyl ring with GLU405 and catalytic GLU351, along with hydrogen bonding of the 2O carbonyl oxygen atom with ALA407 and GLU408 (Fig. 11d).
This study aims to clarify the influence of hydroxy, methoxy, and benzyl groups at the C3′ and C4′ positions of the 2-phenyl side ring of flavonols. We focus on examining their ESIPT fluorescence, crystal packing, physicochemical properties, and ADMET characteristics. A series of flavonols were synthesized, and their structures were characterized using NMR and MS analysis. We systematically investigated the fluorescence properties of the synthesized flavonols in aprotic solvents, analyzing the relationships between their structures and properties. Our main findings suggest that the nature and position of substituent groups in flavonols significantly influence their crystal packing in the solid state. We discovered that the molecular arrangement in the crystal lattice could be affected by intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonding ratio, which in turn affects the ESIPT dual-band ratio. Furthermore, by employing fluorescence titration and molecular docking calculations, we explored how the introduction of a bulky benzyl moiety and the alteration of its position between C3′- and C4′- can impact the binding interactions of flavonols with β-glucosidases. We believe our findings shed light on the structure–fluorescence relationship in flavonols and open up new possibilities for the design of innovative flavonol-based probes.
CCDC 2416411 (3b), 2416412 (3c) and 2416347 (3k) contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.73a–c
Supplementary information: the crystallographic data in Table S1, 1H and 13C NMR spectra of 3a–m in Fig. S1–S13 and mass spectra of 3a–m in Fig. S14–26. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ra05790f.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |