Open Access Article
Busarakham Ngokphoa,
Pattarawadee Therdkatanyuphongb,
Panot Krukkratokeb,
Tanatorn Khotavivattana
c,
Apichat Boontawand and
Kamonwad Ngamchuea
*a
aSchool of Chemistry, Institute of Science, Suranaree University of Technology, 111 University Avenue, Suranaree, Muang, Nakhon Ratchasima 30000, Thailand. E-mail: kamonwad@g.sut.ac.th; Tel: +66 44 224 637
bInstitute of Research and Development, Suranaree University of Technology, 111 University Avenue, Suranaree, Muang, Nakhon Ratchasima, 30000, Thailand
cCenter of Excellence in Natural Products Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, 10330, Thailand
dSchool of Biotechnology, Institute of Agricultural Technology, Suranaree University of Technology, 111 University Avenue, Suranaree, Muang, Nakhon Ratchasima 30000, Thailand
First published on 12th September 2025
Lignin, a highly abundant yet underutilized biopolymer, holds significant potential as a renewable source of aromatic chemicals. Herein, we present a sustainable electrochemical approach for lignin valorization, in which oxidative pathways are tunable via halide redox chemistry. Using boron-doped diamond electrodes, chosen for their wide potential window, high current efficiency, and fouling resistance, we elucidate the roles of halide (Cl−, Br−, I−) and membrane configuration in governing electrochemical reactivity, selectivity, and surface stability. Cyclic voltammetry and extended electrolysis reveal distinct regimes: chloride and bromide mediate direct electrode-driven oxidation which suffers from surface passivation, whereas iodide enables solution-phase oxidation via electrogenerated iodine species, minimizing fouling and delivering the highest yield of aromatic products. Product analysis confirms β-O-4 cleavage as the dominant depolymerization route, with vanillin as the primary product. Incorporation of a cation-exchange membrane substantially enhances yields and promotes deeper oxidative transformations, such as the formation of isovanillic and furan carboxylic acids. These findings define key parameters for achieving sustainable and tunable electrochemical lignin conversion without the need for sacrificial oxidants.
Structurally, lignin is a complex, amorphous macromolecule composed of 4-hydroxyphenyl (H), guaiacyl (G), and syringyl (S) units linked by a heterogeneous array of ether (e.g. β-O-4) and carbon–carbon (e.g. β–β, β-5) bonds.3 Among these, β-O-4 linkages are the most prevalent and represent key targets for depolymerization. Their cleavage yields high-value aromatic monomers such as vanillin, guaiacol, and 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde, relevant to the pharmaceutical, flavor, fragrance, and polymer industries.
Converting lignin into value-added chemicals, however, remains a formidable challenge. Its structural heterogeneity, extensive cross-linking, and chemical recalcitrance have historically impeded its efficient transformation.4 Conventional approaches, including pyrolysis, enzymatic treatment, and chemical catalysis, have achieved partial success by cleaving key interunit bonds or introducing functional groups at the α- and β-positions.5,6 However, these methods typically require harsh reaction conditions, including high temperatures and pressures, as well as stoichiometric or non-recyclable metal catalysts. These approaches are frequently constrained by catalyst deactivation, scalability issues, and environmental or economic concerns, limiting their industrial applicability.
Electrochemical depolymerization has emerged as a promising and sustainable approach for lignin valorization. By employing electrons as clean and tunable redox agents, electrooxidation facilitates bond cleavage under mild conditions. At the molecular level, anodic oxidation of lignin can activate Cα sites, cleave C–O linkages, and trigger retro-aldol reactions at Cβ positions, thereby generating a diverse array of high-value products including ketones, aldehydes, carboxylic acids, and phenolic monomers.7 Crucially, electrochemical systems allow precise modulation of redox environments via applied potentials or currents, enabling control over reaction pathways and product selectivity with a level of tunability that is difficult to achieve by conventional catalytic methods.
Two principal strategies have been employed for lignin electrooxidation: direct oxidation at the electrode interface and indirect oxidation mediated by solution-phase redox shuttles.8 Direct oxidation, typically using catalytic metal or carbon-based electrodes, offers operational simplicity and direct electron transfer to lignin functional groups.9–12 However, this approach is frequently constrained by electrode fouling, limited selectivity, and the use of hazardous or cost-prohibitive materials (e.g. Ni, Pb, Pt).13 Indirect electrooxidation, on the other hand, decouples lignin oxidation from the electrode surface through the use of redox-active mediators such as polyoxometalates,14 Fe(III) salts,15 and nitro-aromatic species.16 These mediators undergo reversible redox cycling at the electrode and subsequently oxidize lignin in solution, thereby mitigating surface passivation and enabling access to alternative oxidative pathways. Importantly, the continuous regeneration of mediators under mild electrochemical conditions presents a sustainable and tunable platform for lignin depolymerization.
Halide ions (Cl−, Br−, I−), despite being ubiquitous in electrochemical systems, have received surprisingly little attention as mediators in lignin depolymerization. Upon anodic activation, they generate reactive halogen species capable of promoting oxidative bond cleavage,17 yet their distinct reactivities and influence on product selectivity within complex lignin matrices remain insufficiently understood. Beyond mediator identity, parameters such as electrode composition, electrolyte, and electrochemical cell design critically shape depolymerization outcomes.
In this work, we present a comprehensive electrochemical strategy to address these gaps in lignin valorization. By systematically examining the roles of electrode material, electrolyte composition, redox mediator identity, and cell architecture, we uncover key parameters that govern reactivity and product selectivity. Particular emphasis is placed on halide-mediated oxidation and the influence of membrane compartmentalization (Scheme 1), both of which are shown to critically impact depolymerization efficiency and aromatic monomer yield. Real-time kinetic analysis further reveals how electrochemical conditions shape lignin degradation pathways. These findings offer mechanistic insight and design principles to support the development of scalable, sustainable approaches for converting lignin into high-value aromatic chemicals.
Alkali lignin was obtained from TCI Chemicals and is derived from needle-leaved and broad-leaved trees. According to the supplier, it was processed via sodium sulfite pulping, followed by partial desulfonation, oxidation, hydrolysis, and demethylation. The reported pH range is 8.0–10.0 (50 g L−1, 20 °C).
:
70 (v/v) acetonitrile/0.1% trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) mixture, was used as the matrix. The instrument was calibrated with PEG600, and the analysis was performed using a laser intensity of 67%, laser frequency of 250 Hz, and a total of 4250 laser shots. Key voltages included 20 kV for the target plate and −1625 V for the detector. The system operated under high vacuum with analyzer pressure maintained at 2.1 × 10−5 Pa.
NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker AVANCE III 500 MHz spectrometer equipped with a CPP BBO 500S1 BB-H&F-D-05 Z probe head with z-gradients. Lignin samples were prepared by dissolving 60 mg of material in 0.5 mL of DMSO-d6, and chemical shifts were referenced to the residual solvent peaks at 2.49 ppm for 1H and 39.5 ppm for 13C. The spectrometer operated at 500.36 MHz for 1H and 125.82 MHz for 13C, with all experiments conducted at a constant temperature of 25 °C. HSQC spectra were acquired using the Hsqcetgpprsisp2.2 pulse program, with spectral widths of 3.0 kHz (1H) and 9.3 kHz (13C). A relaxation delay of 1.5 seconds was employed, and 90° pulse widths were set to 12.0 μs for 1H and 9.5 μs for 13C.
:
1 volume ratio.18,19 The organic layer was collected, dried over anhydrous sodium sulfate, and filtered. The resulting extract was analyzed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS, Agilent Technologies 7000, USA). To improve the volatility and detectability of phenolic compounds, the samples were derivatized with N,O-bis(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide (BSTFA) prior to injection. Separation was performed using an HP-5MS capillary column (60 m length, 0.25 mm inner diameter, 2 μm DB-WAX stationary phase) with helium as the carrier gas at a flow rate of 5 mL min−1. The oven temperature program was as follows: initial hold at 150 °C for 5 min, ramp at 15 °C min−1 to 250 °C, and hold for 20 min. The injector temperature was maintained at 280 °C, and mass spectrometric detection was conducted in electron impact (EI) mode with an ionization voltage of 70 eV. For quantitative analysis, 1,4-dihydroxybenzene was used as an internal standard.20,21
The MALDI-TOF MS spectrum (Fig. 1a) displays a series of peaks in the range of m/z 191–473. The low-mass peaks at m/z 191 and 221 are assigned to G-type and H-type monomers, respectively, while higher-mass peaks correspond to dimers and trimers with β-O-4 and β–β linkages. Representative structures matching these masses are shown in Fig. 2. It should be emphasized, however, that each m/z peak may correspond to multiple isomeric structures, and the proposed structures serve as plausible, literature-supported assignments rather than definitive identifications.22,23 Additionally, signals above m/z 500 were not observed, which is commonly reported in MALDI-TOF MS analysis of lignin.24 This is primarily attributed to the lower ionization efficiency of high-molecular-weight oligomers and the tendency of labile ether linkages to undergo fragmentation during laser desorption/ionization. Nevertheless, the observed low-mass region provides valuable structural information, capturing the dominant monomeric and oligomeric units and enabling the identification of key interunit linkages such as β-O-4 and β–β. These observations highlight the dominant interunit linkages and provide structural insight relevant to lignin's reactivity and valorization.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) MALDI-TOF MS spectrum of lignin in positive ion mode. (b) and (c) HSQC spectra of lignin in the aromatic and aliphatic regions, respectively. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Representative structural components and interunit linkages of lignin. Structures (a–p) correspond to MALDI-TOF MS peaks in Fig. 1a and are grouped by linkage type (not alphabetical order). | ||
The HSQC spectrum provides detailed correlations between 1H and 13C nuclei, enabling identification and semi-quantitative analysis of lignin substructures. In the aromatic region (Fig. 1b), signals at δC/δH of 112/6.9 ppm, 115/6.8 ppm, and 121/6.7 ppm correspond to G2, G5/G6, and G5/G6,25–27 arising from protons at C2, C5, and C6 positions on the guaiacyl (G) ring. An additional signal was observed at 130/7.3 ppm, characteristic of the 4-hydroxyphenyl (H) unit. Integration of cross-peak volumes reveals a G
:
H ratio of approximately 7
:
1, indicating the guaiacyl-rich nature of the lignin sample. No cross-peaks indicative of S units were observed.
In the aliphatic region (Fig. 1c), cross-peaks at ∼60/3.4 ppm correspond to Cγ–Hγ in etherified structures, while signals associated with β–β linkages (∼53–54/3.0–3.2 ppm) appear only as minor components.25,26,28,29 These observations confirm that β-O-4 is the predominant interunit linkage in the lignin polymer.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Cyclic voltammograms (10 mV s−1, 25 °C) of 2.0 g per L lignin in 1.0 M NaOH with 18 mM KCl at (a) Pt, (b) Au, (c) Ag, (d) GC, (e) graphite, and (f) BDD electrodes. | ||
The CVs of lignin at all electrodes revealed irreversible oxidation behavior, as evidenced by the absence of reduction peaks in the reverse scans, consistent with the multistep, non-reversible oxidation of phenolic and ether-containing structures in lignin.33 On noble metal electrodes, Pt (Fig. 3a) and Au (Fig. 3b) exhibited single oxidation peaks at Ep = 0.37 V (ip = 0.78 A m−2) and Ep = 0.70 V (ip = 1.54 A m−2), respectively. Similarly, carbon-based electrodes, GC (Fig. 3d) and graphite (Fig. 3e), showed irreversible oxidation peaks at Ep = 0.69 V (ip = 4.67 A m−2) and Ep = 0.58 V (ip = 5.54 A m−2), respectively. In contrast, no oxidative signal attributable to lignin was observed on the Ag electrode (Fig. 3c) due to competing surface reactivity and parasitic reactions involving silver itself which suppress or obscure the electrochemical response associated with lignin oxidation.
Among all the electrodes tested, BDD (Fig. 3f) demonstrated the most distinct and promising behavior. Two well-defined anodic peaks were observed at Ep,1 = 0.36 V and Ep,2 = 0.80 V, with current densities of 1.68 and 3.10 A m−2, respectively. The appearance of two anodic features is consistent with sequential oxidation steps of lignin. While we refrain from assigning a unique, electrode-specific mechanism on the basis of CV alone, the sharper peak definition and broad accessible potential window on BDD motivate its selection for detailed investigation in the remainder of the study.
In contrast, iodide-containing systems (Fig. 4c) exhibited markedly different behavior. Increasing I− concentration led to a significant suppression of the net oxidation current of lignin. As shown in Fig. 4d, increasing I− concentration significantly suppressed the net oxidation current of lignin, with the net peak current density (ip,lignin − ip,blank) decreasing progressively. This trend suggests that electrogenerated iodine species, such as IO3−,36 engage in chemical reactions with lignin in solution, thereby depleting the local lignin concentration near the electrode. These chemical pathways reduce the flux of electroactive lignin to the electrode surface, leading to diminished current responses.
These findings therefore highlight distinct roles for halides in lignin electrooxidation: Cl− and Br− exhibit mild interfacial effects that modestly enhance electron transfer, while I− acts as a chemically reactive mediator that consumes lignin prior to its electrochemical oxidation. These contrasting behaviors underscore the importance of mediator identity and concentration in tailoring oxidative pathways and current efficiency during lignin valorization. The implications of these behaviors are further explored under prolonged electrolysis conditions in Section 3.4.
The sublinear response suggests that factors beyond bulk lignin availability begin to influence the observed current at elevated concentrations. Most notably, partial electrode fouling likely plays a significant role. Lignin and its oxidation products, particularly quinones and aromatic oligomers, are known to adsorb onto electrode surfaces and form passivating layers.37 At higher lignin loadings, the accumulation of these species on the BDD surface may progressively reduce the number of available electroactive sites, thereby limiting the current response despite increasing lignin concentration in solution. In addition, at high concentrations, increased solution viscosity or potential lignin aggregation may hinder mass transport within the diffusion layer and reduce effective access to the electrode surface. Careful control of lignin loading is therefore essential for optimizing current response and minimizing electrode fouling in electrochemical valorization processes.
In the Cl−-containing system, a notable decrease in peak current was observed with each successive cycle, indicating progressive surface passivation which results from the accumulation of lignin-derived residues or polymeric oxidation products that adhere to the electrode and impede electron transfer. Br− exhibited improved current retention relative to Cl−, suggesting an enhanced ability to preserve electrode activity, although signs of surface deactivation remained evident in both cases.
In contrast, the I− systems exhibited substantially greater retention of current across successive cycles (<4% signal loss by the third cycle), indicating superior surface stability. This minimal decline suggests that iodide effectively mitigates electrode fouling. The in situ generation of reactive iodine species may facilitate the oxidative degradation of adsorbed lignin residues, preventing their accumulation on the electrode. Moreover, the strong solution-phase reactivity of these species likely shifts lignin oxidation away from the electrode interface, reducing the formation of passivating surface films, consistent with the results discussed in the previous sections. These observations highlight the advantageous role of iodide in preserving electrochemical activity during repeated voltammetric cycling, a key consideration for sustained lignin valorization. The implications for long-term electrode performance under controlled-potential electrolysis are further discussed in Section 3.4.
![]() | (1) |
485 C mol−1), n′ is the number of electron transfer before the rate determining step (RDS), βn′+1 is the anodic transfer coefficient of the RDS, R is the molar gas constant (8.314 J K−1 mol−1), and T is the absolute temperature.The extracted n′ + βn′+1 values for the first oxidation peak were 0.293 ± 0.001 in Cl−, 0.287 ± 0.001 in Br−, and 0.284 ± 0.001 in I−, indicating that the first electron transfer step is rate-determining (n′ = 0), and thus these values correspond directly to the transfer coefficient of the RDS.
Kinetic analysis of the absorbance decay revealed that the degradation followed a pseudo-first-order kinetics. The data fit well to the following expression:41
| ln(A/A0) = −kt | (2) |
However, it is important to note that lignin degradation products, particularly oxidized phenolics and aromatic acids, may also exhibit significant absorbance in the same UV region as native lignin. This spectral overlap complicates interpretation of absorbance decay, especially at 280–350 nm, where many lignin-derived compounds also absorb.42 Several prior studies have applied pseudo-first-order kinetic models based on UV-vis absorbance decay to quantify lignin degradation rates, often assuming that the observed signal exclusively corresponds to unreacted lignin.40,43 Such assumptions may lead to overestimation of degradation efficiency and underestimation of product complexity. Caution is thus warranted in using UV-vis data alone to draw mechanistic conclusions. Nonetheless, the comparable degradation rates across halide systems suggest that, under prolonged electrolysis, differences in voltammetric behavior (Section 3.2) have limited impact on the kinetics of lignin oxidative breakdown in bulk solution. These findings are revisited in Section 3.4 through analysis of product composition and electrolysis efficiency.
A range of lignin-derived aromatic products were identified, including aldehydes (e.g. vanillin, benzaldehyde), ketones (apocynin), carboxylic acids (isovanillic acid, 2-furancarboxylic acid, benzoic acid, homovanillic acid), and rearranged phenolic species (2-propoxyphenol, 2-methoxyphenol), as summarized in Table 1. Vanillin was the predominant product under all tested conditions, consistent with its formation from guaiacyl (G) units, the principal monomeric component of lignin as characterized in Section 3.1, via oxidative cleavage of β-O-4 linkages (Scheme 2).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Proposed mechanism for the conversion of the guaiacol (G) unit to vanillin (4-hydroxy-3-methoxybenzaldehyde), adapted from the reported mechanism for the model compound 1-(4-hydroxy-3-methoxyphenyl)-2-(2-methoxyphenoxy)-1,3-propanediol.44 | ||
Other products, such as isovanillic acid and homovanillic acid, also derive primarily from G units and suggest further side-chain oxidation or rearrangement of aldehydic intermediates. Notably, deeper oxidation products, particularly carboxylic acids and furan-type compounds, were observed predominantly under conditions involving both halide mediators and membrane confinement. This behavior is indicative of more aggressive oxidation regimes or localized accumulation of highly reactive species, such as hypohalites, facilitated by halide presence and membrane-induced spatial confinement.
Low-molecular-weight compounds such as benzaldehyde likely result from cleavage of more condensed lignin linkages, such as β–β, which yield smaller aromatic aldehydes upon fragmentation. The appearance of 2-propoxyphenol, a noncanonical product, may be attributed to alkylation or solvolytic side reactions occurring under electrochemical conditions.
Collectively, these structure–product relationships support a mechanistic pathway in which lignin depolymerization proceeds primarily via cleavage of β-O-4 linkages, followed by stepwise side-chain oxidation (alcohol → aldehyde → acid) and, in some cases, ring oxidation or fragmentation. The relative abundance of each product class was strongly influenced by the electrochemical environment, particularly halide identity and membrane configuration, as discussed in the following section.
Compared to recent electrochemical lignin valorization reports (summarized in Table 2), our system (particularly the iodide/cation-exchange membrane configuration) demonstrates strong performance in both product yield and operational simplicity. Under mild conditions (room temperature and atmospheric pressure with 1.0 M NaOH and 18 mM KI), we achieved a vanillin yield of 13.5 g kg−1 within 4 hours. This is comparable to or exceeds the performance of other systems operating at room temperature, such as Ni–Co/Pt (≈1.3 g kg−1 over 4 h)45 and NiOOH (≈1.2 g per kg vanillin, total aromatics ≈ 12.3 g kg−1).46 While higher vanillin yields have been reported using Pb-based anodes at elevated temperatures, these approaches often rely on toxic materials, high temperatures, or extended reaction times. In contrast, our system employs a safer anode material, operates under ambient conditions, and achieves selective production of valuable aromatics (e.g. vanillin, apocynin) without requiring multi-step processing or elevated temperatures.
| Anode | Electrolyte | Lignin type | Temperature/time | Products | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PbO2/NiMoCo | 1 M NaOH | Corn stover lignin | 40 °C/1.5 h | trans-Ferulic acid (22.40 g kg−1), vanillin (11.09 g kg−1), 3-hydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl-ethanone (2.37 g kg−1), syringaldehyde (10.04 g kg−1), acetosyringone (6.95 g kg−1), 4-methoxy-3-methylphenol (38.83 g kg−1) | 13 |
| Pb/PbO2 | 1 M NaOH | Bamboo lignin | 40 °C/2 h | Vanillin (36.06 g kg−1), syringaldehyde (57.30 g kg−1), and p-coumaric acid (29.64 g kg−1) | 47 |
| Pb/PbO2 | 1 M NaOH | Cornstalk lignin | 30 °C/4 h | Toluene (36.1 g kg−1), m-xylene (10.3 g kg−1), o-xylene (12.1 g kg−1), anisole (9.5 g kg−1) | 48 |
| Ti/SnO2–Sb2O3/α-PbO2/β-PbO2 | 1 M NaOH | Rice straw lignin | 35–55 °C/5 h | Aromatic ketones (4.09 g kg−1), aromatic aldehydes (1.53 g kg−1), aromatic acids (23.92 g kg−1) | 49 |
| Ni–Co/Pt | 1 M NaOH | Alkali lignin | RT/16 h | Vanillin (0.316 g kg−1 h−1), 3-methylbenzaldehyde (0.152 g kg−1 h−1) | 45 |
| NiOOH | 1 M NaOH | Soda lignin | RT/4 h | Sinapic acid (0.32 wt%), acetovanillone (0.15 wt%), vanillin (0.12 wt%), vanillic acid (0.12 wt%) with the total aromatics of ∼1.23 wt% | 46 |
| BDD | 1 M NaOH/18 mM KI | Alkali lignin | RT/4 h | Vanillin (13.5 g kg−1), apocynin (1.8 g kg−1), 2-propoxyphenol (1.2 g kg−1), isovanillic acid (0.9 g kg−1), 2-furancarboxylic acid (0.9 g kg−1), benzaldehyde (0.3 g kg−1) | This work |
To quantitatively evaluate the relative contributions of competing electrochemical processes, including oxygen evolution reaction (OER), halide oxidation, and direct lignin oxidation, the charge distribution was quantified using the following definitions:
| Qlignin = Qtotal − Qblank | (3) |
Based on this, the faradaic efficiency for lignin oxidation was calculated by:
![]() | (4) |
Faradaic efficiency for oxygen evolution (FEO2) was derived from the amount of O2 detected experimentally and converted to charge assuming a 4-electron process:
| QO2 = 4FnO2 | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
The residual fraction of the charge, not attributable to either lignin or oxygen oxidation, was assigned to halide oxidation:
| FEhalide = 100% − (FElignin + FEO2) | (7) |
In this context, two parallel oxidation pathways are therefore considered: (1) direct oxidation of lignin at the electrode quantified by FElignin, and (2) indirect oxidation via electrogenerated iodine species approximated by FEhalide.
As shown in Table 3 for the iodide-containing systems, all three configurations (membrane-free, AEM, and CEM) exhibited high FEhalide, suggesting that the mediated pathway dominates the charge distribution in each case (further discussed in the next section). The consistently low FEO2 values highlight the advantage of BDD electrodes, which effectively suppress oxygen evolution even at high anodic potentials.50
| Membrane | Qtotal (C) | Qblank (C) | Qlignin (C) | FEO2 | FEhalide | FElignin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | 231 | 218 | 13 | 1.1 | 93.3 | 5.6 |
| Anion-exchange | 338 | 245 | 93 | 1.4 | 71.1 | 27.5 |
| Cation-exchange | 330 | 265 | 65 | 1.0 | 79.3 | 19.7 |
However, when comparing FE values and total charge with the product yields in Table 1, no clear relationship was observed. For example, although the AEM and CEM systems exhibited similar total charges (338 vs. 330 C), the CEM yielded significantly more aromatic products. Likewise, the AEM system showed the highest FElignin (27.5%) but lower yields than the CEM, while the membrane-free system had the highest FEhalide (93.3%) but the lowest product yields overall.
These findings imply that neither high direct oxidation (FElignin) nor high halide turnover (FEhalide) alone guarantees effective lignin depolymerization. Instead, the efficiency of mediated oxidation depends on whether oxidants generated through halide cycling are retained and react productively with lignin, rather than being lost to side reactions or physical crossover. The superior performance of the CEM system arises not from the absolute magnitude of FEhalide or FElignin, but from the selective confinement of redox-active iodine species, which improves the utilization efficiency of the mediated pathway and enhances net aromatic product yields. This interpretation is further supported by the presence of more deeply oxidized products, such as isovanillic acid and 2-furancarboxylic acid, which were detected only in CEM conditions. These findings highlight the critical role of membrane architecture in directing the electrochemical fate of lignin. The CEM configuration not only increased the total yield of aromatic products but also shifted the product profile toward deeper oxidative conversion.
| Halide | Qtotal (C) | Qblank (C) | Qlignin (C) | FEO2 (%) | FEhalide (%) | FElignin (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cl− | 176 | 20 | 156 | 2.7 | 8.7 | 88.6 |
| Br− | 158 | 41 | 117 | 3.3 | 22.6 | 74.1 |
| I− | 330 | 265 | 65 | 1.0 | 79.3 | 19.7 |
In contrast, the iodide system displayed a markedly different charge partitioning. Although it passed the highest total charge (330 C), only 65 C was associated with direct lignin oxidation (FElignin = 19.7%), while FEhalide = 79.3% dominated. This shift points to a mechanism governed by solution-phase mediated oxidation, where I− is electrochemically converted to reactive species such as I2, IO3−, and possibly IO4−, which oxidize lignin in bulk solution. This pathway is further supported by the suppression of electrode fouling (as the reaction takes place away from the electrode surface) and the higher aromatic product yields observed for the iodide system.
Efforts to directly quantify iodine intermediates under operando conditions proved analytically intractable in the present study. Ion-selective electrodes, while responsive under calibration, lacked sufficient resolution to detect the small changes in free iodide concentration anticipated during electrolysis. The expected shifts (<5%) correspond to less than 1 mV, falling within the instrumental drift and rendering the measurements inconclusive. UV-vis spectroscopy was also unsuitable as the strong absorbance of lignin and its oxidation products in the 280–350 nm range overlapped with the diagnostic bands of triiodide and other iodine species, compromising spectral deconvolution. Attempts to use classical iodometric titrations (e.g. with thiosulfate) were unsuccessful due to uncontrolled redox reactions with phenolic moieties in the lignin matrix, which interfered with iodine chemistry and precluded selective quantification. More advanced analytical approaches such as operando spectroscopy may offer the ability to resolve individual iodine species and are recommended for future investigations.
Nevertheless, the convergence of multiple independent lines of evidence, namely, the exceptionally high faradaic efficiency for iodide oxidation, the sharply reduced direct electron transfer to lignin, the suppression of electrode fouling, and the enhanced monomer yields, collectively support the operation of a homogeneous, iodine-mediated oxidation pathway.51,52 To the best of our knowledge, no alternative mechanism can reconcile these observations. Accordingly, while the identity and dynamics of the transient iodine intermediates remain unresolved, the mechanistic conclusion that I− acts as a redox shuttle in this system is robustly supported.
These results therefore suggest distinct oxidation regimes depending on halide identity. The chloride and bromide systems promote more direct electrochemical oxidation of lignin at the electrode surface, which can lead to significant electrode fouling and ultimately lower product yields. In contrast, the iodide system operates primarily through mediated oxidation pathways: iodide is electrochemically oxidized to I2, which disproportionates in alkaline solution to form IO3−, and under extended oxidation, potentially IO4−.36 These species are capable of oxidizing lignin in the solution phase without requiring direct contact with the electrode, thereby minimizing electrode fouling and resulting in high product yields.
It is worth noting that halide salts are often employed as supporting electrolytes under the assumption that they are electrochemically inert or used without a clear understanding of their mechanistic role.53–55 However, in oxidative environments, especially under galvanostatic conditions in two-electrode systems, where potentials are not and cannot be precisely controlled, the redox activity of halides can significantly alter reaction pathways and outcomes. Our findings highlight the critical role of halide redox chemistry in dictating the course of electrochemical lignin depolymerization to optimize reactivity and selectivity.
The environmental behavior of electrogenerated iodine species also warrants consideration. While reactive iodine species are inherently oxidizing and can be mildly corrosive at high concentrations, the alkaline and dilute conditions employed here (18 mM I−) help stabilize these species. Under these conditions, I2 is rapidly and efficiently converted to IOx−,56 which are less volatile. In addition, the reactive iodine species generated are consumed through lignin oxidation, further limiting their accumulation. The use of a cation-exchange membrane confines iodide and its oxidation products within the anodic compartment, reducing the risk of uncontrolled release. Moreover, no iodinated aromatic compounds were detected in post-electrolysis solutions by GC-MS, supporting the safe and contained use of iodide as a redox mediator under the conditions studied.
This mediated system exhibited characteristics that may be favorable for future scale-up. Operating under mild aqueous conditions at ambient temperature and pressure, with modest energy requirements (ca. 0.08–0.11 kW h per kg lignin), the platform is compatible with continuous flow configurations. The use of BDD electrodes provides long-term chemical stability and resistance to fouling, especially in iodide-containing systems, while mediator regeneration and product extraction are straightforward. These attributes collectively highlight the feasibility of translating this process to larger-scale lignin valorization.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |