Open Access Article
Hamed Bahariab,
Mohammad Hasanzadeh
*b,
Soodabeh Davaran*a,
Farzin Ahmadpourc and
Nasrin Shadjou
d
aDepartment of Medical Nanotechnology, Faculty of Advanced Medical Sciences, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, 516661-4733, Iran. E-mail: davaran@tbzmed.ac.ir
bPharmaceutical Analysis Research Center, Tabriz University of Medical Science, Tabriz, Iran. E-mail: hasanzadehm@tbzmed.ac.ir
cDepartment of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Dentistry Faculty, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
dDepartment of Nanotechnology, Faculty of Chemistry, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran
First published on 22nd July 2025
Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) is the most prevalent form of oral cavity cancer and a leading cause of death globally with low survival rates. Early detection of OSCC is crucial for reducing morbidity and mortality. The microRNA-423-5p, a 23-nucleotide non-coding RNA, is a vital biomarker for accurate OC detection due to its high value in the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve, ensuring selectivity for OC. A precise measurement of microRNA-423-5p in human biofluids facilitates accurate OC detection. This research introduces a novel electrochemical platform without the need for labeling, designed for the non-intrusive monitoring of microRNA-423-5p in human saliva samples using a DNA-based bioassay. In this approach, poly(β-cyclodextrin) was fabricated to serve as a biocompatible support on the glassy carbon electrode surface. Furthermore, KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg, featuring a surface area of 104.9 m2 g−1 and a pore volume of 0.83 cm3 g−1, was utilized to enhance the substrate's surface area relative to volume and achieve high loading of probe DNA (pDNA). For the first time, dendritic AuNPs were used to immobilize thiolated DNA sequences (5′-SH-TGTCTCCCCGGTGTCTGGCTCGA-3′) on an electrode surface of electrode via Au–S interaction to detect microRNA-423-5p in human saliva in low limit of quantification of 1 pM. The biosensor successfully detected microRNA-423-5p, demonstrating its potential for OC screening. The genosensor development involved assessing crucial factors such as hybridization time and microRNA concentration. Analytical techniques including cyclic voltammetry, chronoamperometry, and differential pulse voltammetry were used for quantifying MicroRNA-423-5p in human biofluids. The biosensor's performance characteristics were evaluated for stability, repeatability, and suitability for plasma and saliva samples.
000 deaths worldwide each year. This high incidence of OSCC contributes to significant mortality and morbidity rates. The first stages of OSCC have an encouraging outlook, with a cure rate of 80% in the initial stage and 65% in the second stage. Despite significant advancements in treatment, the 5 years survival rate for most malignancies is still around 50% since they are typically discovered at late stages III or IV. Therefore, early detection of OSCC is crucial to lowering its morbidity and mortality.2
Visual inspection and various biopsy4–7 are the mainstays of traditional approaches for the detection of OC and premalignant lesions (such as erythroplakia and leukoplakia). Currently, a tissue biopsy of the affected area is used to make the early analysis of OC. This is followed by additional evaluation using medical imaging techniques, such as expensive and difficult positron emission tomography (PET) scans, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI),8–10 or computed tomography (CT).11–14
Non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs)15 are transcripts that are not involved in the coding of proteins. They are classified into two categories: short non-coding RNAs, which are less than 200 nt, and long non-coding RNAs, which are more than 200 nt.16,17 NcRNAs make up the majority of the transcriptome, and intriguingly, their abundance is inversely correlated with organismal complexity.18
The shorter primordial miRNA (pri-miRNA) transcripts, which have one or more hairpins, give rise to miRNAs, which are RNAs with a length of 22 nucleotides or less. Few miRNA hairpins overlap protein-coding gene exons; the majority come from non-coding introns or transcripts.19
There is a chance that possible disease indicators may enter this fluid given that oral malignancies develop in the oral cavity. In order to do this, new research have proposed using salivary miRNAs as biomarkers for cancer diagnosis. Saliva collection is simple,20 noninvasive, and does not require expensive trained employees or involved processes, which is a benefit.3
MicroRNA-423-5p was chosen as a diagnostic biomarker of oral cancer due to the high level under the chart in the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve based on the ref. 21. ROC curve is used to evaluate the comprehensive diagnostic efficacy of a test and to evaluate the efficacy of two or more diagnostic tests. Additionally, it is employed to choose an ideal threshold for identifying the existence or non-existence of a disease.22 Patients with recently discovered untreated main healthy controls and OSCC had their saliva collected. A microarray method was used to profile salivary miRNAs globally, and quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR) was used to validate the signatures. For the standardization of RT-qPCR data and microarray, a rigorous statistical methodology was used. An extensive analysis was conducted to evaluate the diagnostic efficacy of miRNAs and their association with the prediction of OSCC. Among healthy controls and OSCC patients, 25 miRNAs indicated differential expression, and seven of these were found to be substantially linked with disease-free survival (DFS). Saliva from OSCC patients had significant levels of miR-423-5p, miR-193b-3p and miR-106b-5p expression, and their mixture exhibits the greatest diagnostic efficacy (ROC − AUC = 0.98). Additionally, strong expression of microR-423-5p was an independent predictor of poor DFS when included in multivariate survival analysis with the number of positive lymph nodes, the only significant clinical prognosticator. Finally, they founded that the expression of microR-423-5p was much lower in matching post-operative saliva samples, indicating that it may have originated specifically in malignancy.21 So, microR-423-5p is suitable biomarker for the efficient recognition of OC by analysis of saliva samples of patient.
Recently, biosensor technology was widely used for the bioanalysis of cancer biomarker. Electrochemical biosensors have emerged as very effective and advanced devices in the field of biomedical diagnostics.23 The key components integral to these biosensors are the signal transducer and the biorecognition element.23 When compared to traditional inspecting techniques, electrochemical biosensors supply many advantages such as heightened sensitivity,24 non-invasive means of searching for biomolecules, and improved specificity. Moreover, it is worth noting that these biosensors exhibit little susceptibility to potential obstacles such as optical interference or sample turbidity.25
Electrochemical techniques are used to diagnose oral cancer by identifying certain biomarkers found in saliva. These biomarkers are categorized into three primary groups: DNA biosensors, RNA biosensors, and protein biosensors.26
Wu and colleagues created a dual 3D nanorobot that combines an ISAR-based DNA walker with a Cas12a-based nano-harvester. This nanorobot is designed to quickly and accurately identify salivary miRNA-31 with high sensitivity. The miRNA of interest is trapped by magnetic nanoparticles that have been modified with DNA hairpins. These nanoparticles then undergo a process called walking, facilitated by an ISAR-based walker, to form multiple DNA double helices. These helices are then combined with crRNA-Cas12a to create a 3D nano-harvester. The nano-harvester cuts and releases hairpin probes labeled with methylene blue from the sensing interface, leading to a noticeable change in the signal. The nano-harvester using Cas12a exhibits improved trans-cleavage efficiency. The detection of miRNA-31 in saliva samples demonstrates that this newly created biosensor is a rapid, highly sensitive, and very selective sensing platform. It has significant promise for the early diagnosis of oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC).27
Literature review indicated that, there is no investigation (research work) for the identification of micro-RNA-423-5p in human saliva samples using biosensor technique. In this study, an DNA-based biosensor was developed for the sensitive and specific monitoring of this biomarker by oligonucleotide hybridization. The analysis of the building phases of the constructed genosensor included the examination of many critical factors, including the hybridization time and the concentration of micro-RNA-423-5p. Subsequently, electrochemical techniques such as cyclic voltammetry (CV), chronoamperometry (ChA), and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) were used to determine MicroRNA-423-5p in human real samples. The performance characteristics of the biosensor were assessed in terms of stability, repeatability, and suitability for use in plasma samples and collecting saliva.
For the opening a new horizon on the early-stage diagnosis of OC, a novel selective and sensitive electrochemical label-free biosensor was developed by using dendritic AuNPs-modified GCE (glassy carbon electrode), of poly(β-CD), and KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg for the detection of MicroRNA-423-5p in human saliva samples. As far as we know, there has been no prior development of a biosensor specifically designed to detect MicroRNA-423-5p. Our research presents a groundbreaking synthesis technique, never explored before in the electrochemical synthesis of dendritic AuNPs, opening new strategy for future investigations. To manufacture a high-potential capturing layer, the surface of a GCE was automatically modified by poly-β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) using electropolymerization method. The synthesis and evaluation of KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg nanoparticles were conducted with the specific aim of enhancing the surface-to-volume ratio of modified P (β-CD).
| Name | Sequences (5′ –> 3′) |
|---|---|
| MicroRNA-423-5p | UGAGGGGCAGAGAGCGAGACUUU |
| DNA probe | 5′-SH-TGTCTCCCCGGTGTCTGGCTCGA-3′ |
| 2-Base mismatch DNA | TGGCTCCCCGGTGTCTGGTTCGA |
| Non-complement (MicroRNA-21) | TGTCGGGTTGCTGTCCTCTTC |
Human saliva samples were obtained from the Faculty of Dentistry (Tabriz University of Medical science, Tabriz, Iran, (Ethic code: IR.TBZMED.REC.1401.202)). All experiments were performed in accordance with the guidelines of institute (Tabriz University of Medical science), and approved by the ethics committee at Tabriz University of Medical science, Tabriz, Iran. Informed consents were obtained from human participants of this study. Saliva samples were collected in the fasting state (at least 8 hours have passed since the last eating and drinking). For this purpose, to ensure the cleanliness of the oral cavity before sampling, the oral cavity was rinsed using phosphate buffer (0.1 M) and pH = 7.4 for 30 seconds. After discarding the phosphate buffer, the oral cavity was rinsed with deionized water for 20 seconds. Finally, saliva samples were collected and used after ensuring clarity and absence of suspended particles.
A compelling option to the physically immobilized CD and the covalently coupled CD supramolecules is the electropolymerization of the CDs to produce a cohesive and insoluble CD polymer. While the CD supramolecules that are physically adsorbed onto the surface may dissolve and gradually detach, resulting in a gradual decrease in CD concentration on the surface, the CD polymer that is insoluble remains attached. Furthermore, several investigations have shown the favorable conductive characteristics of this polymer, making it a very suitable contender for the advancement of electrochemical-based sensors.29
The CV technique was used to successfully electropolymerization β-CD onto the GCE surface. This electropolymerization process was conducted within a potential range of −2 to +2 V, including a total of 40 consecutive cycles (Fig. S1 (see ESI†)).
The CV technique was used to successfully electropolymerization βCD onto the GCE surface. This electropolymerization process was conducted within a potential range of −2 to +2 V, including a total of 40 consecutive cycles. In the first cycle, a cathodic peak (peak 1) was observed at the potential of 0.5 discernible. After the second cycle, the anodic peaks (peak 3) and (peak 2) occurred at 1.5 V and 0.5 V, respectively. As of the seventh cycle, a new cathodic peak (peak 4) appeared at −0.5 V. In the following cycles, the peak current increased, indicating the development of P (β-CD) on the CGE's surface. Furthermore, the current increased rapidly until cycle 28 and then progressively decreased in intensity in the following cycles, indicating that the polymeric film could have reached its maximum thickness.
The electropolymerization of β-CD consists of five distinct steps. The electropolymerization is begun by the oxidation of the monomer, resulting in the formation of a radical cation (I). In this scenario, it is feasible to amalgamate two monomers in their oxidized state to produce an oligomer, namely a dimer, which consists of two bound monomer units (II). The oligomer may undergo oxidation to generate a radical cation (III). This oxidized oligomer may react with a previously oxidized monomer to create another oligomer, namely a trimer consisting of three bonded monomer units (IV). Ultimately, the monomer units are added in a sequential manner to the active site, resulting in the formation of an expanding polymer chain (V). The interaction between the radical cations might take place via carbon–carbon bonds, nitrogen–nitrogen, or carbon–nitrogen.30 The Scheme 1 illustrates the whole process of electropolymerization of β-CD.
Thiols have been shown to form self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on the surface of gold electrode.41 “Self-assembly” describes the haphazard creation of distinct nanometer-sized components from more basic subunits or building pieces. The most well-known SAMs are those of thiols and dithiols (and other S headgroup compounds, such as disulfides and sulfides) on various oxide-free metals and, to a lesser degree, on semiconductors, due to their potential and ongoing uses in multiple disciplines of nanotechnology.42
ChA technique was utilized for the generation of AuNPs with dendritic morphology on the surface of electrode. Fig. S2 (see ESI†) presents the ChA of deposition of AuNPs onto the GCE's modified P(βCD)-KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg surface. This deposition process was conducted at a steady potential of 0 V for 300 seconds.43
GCE modified with P(β-CD)-KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg has been transferred as the working electrode into the cell holding the Au nanoparticle solution. Following that, the electrodeposition was done using the ChA approach, with the following parameters: Tequilibration = 2 s, Edc = 0 V, tinterval = 0.1 s, and trun = 300 s.43 CTAB and sulfuric acid were used in the synthesis of Au nanoparticles. After preparing a 10 mM “HAuCl4–3H2O” solution, 200 mM of sulfuric acid was used to dissolve 10% CTAB. Ultimately, the initially produced solution was mixed with 10 mM of the “HAuCl4–3H2O” solution (at a volume ratio of 1
:
1
:
1 V
:
V
:
V). To get a uniform solution, the vessel was softly shaken. The solution had an orange hue shift. To give the AuNPs nanoparticles with consistent shape and prevent them from clumping together, a 10% CTAB solution was used as both a design and a sealant. Sulfuric acid was also employed as a solvent solution. Also, using this combination (HAucl4−, H2SO4, CTAB) and adjustment of electro-synthesis potential in 0 V, AuNPs with dendritic structure was obtained.
Fig. 1E shows the FE-SEM images of the GCE modified with P(β-CD)-KCC-1-nPr-NH-Arg-AuNPs after the hybridization of the DNA sequence with the complementary sequence of the target (microRNA-423-5p). It can be seen that the interaction of DNA with the target analyte has been done successfully, which confirms the completion of the genosensor manufacturing process.
Also, EDX of electrode shows successful preparation of genosensor after different fabrication steps (Fig. S3 (see ESI†)).
According to Fig. 2A, a voltammogram with high anodic and cathodic peak current was obtained for the modified GCE, while for the electrode modified with the probe, the peak current due to the irregular accumulation of the thiolated probe on the electrode surface was significantly reduced, which slows down the electron transfer related to the oxidation and reduction process of Fe(CN)6−3/−4 on the surface of the GCE. In fact, single-stranded probes immobilized on the surface of the GCE (either in a suitable and correct orientation or with a non-specific orientation and with folded and deformed forms) from the presence of the electroactive compound Fe(CN)6−3/−4 is prevented on the surface of the electrode and the peak current of the anodic and cathodic is reduced.
In the continuation of the work, the effect of MCH on the arrangement of single-stranded probes immobilized on the surface of the electrode was investigated. To do this, after immobilizations the single-stranded probes on the electrode surface, the modified electrode was incubated in a 0.1 mM solution of MCH. In the presence of MCH solution, the redox signal related to of Fe(CN)6−3/−4 has increased due to the separation of single-stranded probes that are non-specifically and irregularly placed on the electrode surface.
Then the designed biosensor was incubated in a solution of target (microRNA-423-5p) for half an hour. According to obtained CVs, as a result of the hybridization process and the formation of double-stranded oligonucleotides (probe double strand with target microRNA), the anodic and cathodic peak current related to the oxidation and reduction processes of Fe(CN)6−3/−4 on the surface of the modified electrode were greatly reduced. In fact, the decrease in the signal of the anodic and cathodic processes was a good indication of the proper performance of the hybridization process at the level of the designed biosensor. So, the modified electrode with a self-arranged single-strand probe can be used to perform the hybridization process.
The interpretation of the decrease in anodic and cathodic peak current intensity in the voltammograms can be expressed as follows: immobilizations of single-stranded oligonucleotide probes, as well as the accumulation of hybridized double-stranded oligonucleotides, which have a negatively charged phosphate agent in their chain, as an inhibitory layer, result from the presence of the electroactive anionic compound Fe(CN)6−3/−4, which has a negative charge. As a result, the intensity of the current decreases, and the oxidation of the electrode is greatly reduced.
In addition to the substantial decrease in the intensity of the oxidation peak current and reduction of the electrode in the presence of Fe(CN)6−3/−4, it can be seen that with the increase in the presence of oligonucleotides, both single-stranded and non-arranged single-stranded probes, as well as hybridized double-stranded probes on the surface of the electrode, the anodic and cathodic peaks of the mentioned voltammograms have moved to more positive and negative potential values, respectively. This observation indicates that due to the presence of oligonucleotides on the surface of the electrode, the redox process of the compound Fe(CN)6−3/−4 has become more difficult due to the creation of steric hindrance and the presence of the negative charge of oligonucleotides, and as a result, the oxidation and reduction potentials are shifted towards larger values.
The comparison results of the present voltammograms confirm the correct performance of various steps during the fabrication of the electrochemical biosensor and show the ability of the sensor regarding the hybridization process target microRNA detection.
DPV is exactly according to the process obtained in CV and the results are as follows: Fig. S4 (see ESI†). For the GCE-P(β-CD) conductive electrode, the peak current is 14.10 μA. After adding mesoporous nano-silica, this value reaches to 52.96 μA. The maximum value of current intensity is obtained by depositing AuNPs, which was 84.34 μA. By adding the target microRNA (microRNA-423-5p), the peak current decreased to 11.21 μA, which confirms the hybridization of the target analyte (microRNA-423-5p).
The regression equation in the range of 0.001 nM to 1 nM is as follows:
I(μA) = 3.3829 ln CmicroRNA + 29.73, R2 = 0.9567 |
Its sensitivity is 3.3829 μA nM−1 with LLOQ = 0.001 nM.
According to the obtained results, there is a linear relation between peak current of calibration curve and Napierian Logarithm of microRNA-423-5p concentration. So, it is possible to determine low level of microRNA-423-5p in standard samples. Based on these results, engineered biosensor is able to determine in real samples that spiked by microRNA-423-5p.
Blood was drawn from a 30 year-old healthy non-cancerous individual, collected in an additive-free sample storage tube, and allowed to clot for 60 minutes at room temperature to separate serum from blood. After that, it spent a night at 4 °C. The samples were twice centrifuged, first at 150 g for 5 minutes and again at 350 g for 15 minutes. To inactivate the proteins, the separated serum was collected in a tube containing 0.2 M EDTA solution. Following that, the tubes were often rotated a few times, the samples were separated into equal portions, and they were kept in storage at −20 °C. Freeze-thaw cycles were avoided and fresh or temporarily kept serum (up to three days) was the sole material used for all actual sample experiments. Blood sampling was done from a volunteer who was fully conscious of the purpose of blood sampling. Furthermore, the experiment met with all relevant laws and procedures, and blood sample was carried out in accordance with normal ethical principles.
The regression equation in the concentration range of 0.005 nM to 1 nM of microRNA-423-5p is as follows:
I(μA) = −5.8127 ln CmicroRNA + 17.084, R2 = 0.996 |
Its sensitivity is 5.8127 μA (ng L)−1 with LLOQ = 0.005 nM. According to the obtained results, there is a linear relation between peak current of calibration curve and Napierian Logarithm of microRNA-423-5p concentration. So, it is possible to determine low level of microRNA-423-5p in standard samples. Based on these results, engineered biosensor is able to non-invasive determination of microRNA-423-5p in real samples (human blood plasma).
The DPV technique was chosen as a sensitive diagnostic method (Fig. 4). In this part, 100 μL of human healthy saliva samples were diluted in 900 μL of deionized water and then analyte was added to it in concentrations range of 1, 0.05, 0.01, 0.001 nM. Next, voltammograms were recorded.
The regression equation in the range of 0.001 nM to 1 nM is as follows:
I(μA) = −6.9137 ln CmicroRNA + 12.239, R2 = 0.9183 |
Its sensitivity is 6.9137 μA (ng L)−1 with LLOQ = 0.001 nM.
According to the obtained results, there is a linear relation between peak current of calibration curve and Napierian Logarithm of microRNA-423-5p concentration. So, it is possible to determine low level of microRNA-423-5p in standard samples. Based on these results, engineered biosensor is able to non-invasive determination of microRNA-423-5p in saliva sample of patient of OC.
Cancerous saliva samples obtained from four people with OC along with a healthy person's saliva sample were used as a control to check the performance of the genosensor. Then DPVs of each of them was recorded and repeated 3 times (Fig. S6 (see ESI†)).
The obtained results prove that since there is no microRNA-423-5p in the control sample, the peak of its DPV current intensity graph has increased and reached to 16 μA which indicates the absence of hybridization with the DNA probe.
Unlike the control sample, microRNA-423-5p is present in human saliva samples with OC, and due to hybridization with the DNA probe, the DPV peak current intensity has decreased for all four cancerous saliva samples, and it varies between 2-6 μA.
A paired t-test was performed to check the significance of the data using SPSS Statistics version 20.0 software. With all of the tested drugs, apart from aspirin (p = 0.042), no statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) were obtained between the responses Accuracy shows the closeness of the results obtained from a method after several repetitions which expressed based on the percentage of relative standard deviation (% RSD). For biological samples according to the FDA standard, a % RSD of up to 15% is acceptable.
The RSD obtained for cancer samples is as follows, which confirms the success of this step: cancer-control (SD average = 7.74)
According to the obtained results, it was found that the sensor prepared in the presence of the target analyte has a current intensity distinguishable from ncDNA and 2-base mismatch DNA, which indicates the selectivity of the relevant electrochemical biosensor. The peak current obtained for the target sequence was equal to 11 μA. While for ncDNA, the obtained peak current intensity was about 20 μA. Also, for 2-base mismatch, the obtained peak current intensity value is twice different from the obtained peak current intensity value for ncDNA, and it shows the selectivity of the engineered genosensor.
The low value of the obtained RSD shows the optimal repeatability of the present biosensor and therefore confirms its efficiency in reliable measurements in different samples. In addition to this, the ease and repeatability of the biosensor manufacturing process is one of its very important and valuable advantages.
The CVs of electrode was recoded in different sweep rates (0.2, 0.15, 0.1, 0.09, 0.07, 0.06, 0.05 mV s−1). Based on the acquired CV graph (Fig. S11A (see ESI†)), an increase in scan rate led to a gradual widening of the voltammogram and a considerable change in the anodic peak current. Electrons are very likely to transfer at the interface of the electrode, resulting in the increment of a peak current. This process happens more slowly when the scan rates are reduced. Also, Fig. 5B demonstrates that there is a direct correlation between the scan rate, ranging from 0.2 to 0.05 mV s−1, and the peak current. This correlation suggests that the diffusion process is responsible for controlling mass-transfer.
Two commonly used methods to investigate the reversibility of reactions and determine whether a reaction is regulated by diffusion or adsorption include analyzing the dependencies: Ip vs. v0.5 and ln
Ip vs. ln
v. Fig. S11C and D (see ESI†) shows these trends for the oxidation peak. If there are no kinetic complexities in reversible or irreversible systems, the values of Ip and v0.5 are linked and intersect at the origin of the figure. Fig. S11C (see ESI†) clearly demonstrates that the Ipa and v0.5 curve is linear, with a high coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.9958), and intersects the origin. This relationship is described by the following equation:
| Ipa (μA) = −166.07v0.5 (V s−1)0.5 − 1.3373 (R2 = 0.9958) |
The relationship between these variables originates from the origin, suggesting that the kinetic process of electron transfer is controlled by diffusion.
The dependency between ln
Ipa and ln
v (Fig. S11D (see ESI†)) is linear throughout the chosen sweep rate range of 0.05 to 0.2 mV s−1. This may be explained using the following equation:
ln Ipa (μA) = 0.027157 ln v (mV s−1) + 117.96 (R2 = 0.9989) |
Its slope is 0.027157 and exhibits diffusion-control of the electrode process. Diffusion-controlled systems are predicted to have slopes close to 0.5, while adsorption-controlled systems are predicted to have slopes near to 1.
The relationship between Epa (anodic peak potential) and sweep rate is seen in Fig. S11E (see ESI†). Irreversible electrochemical reactions exhibit independence between the Epa and sweep rate. This suggests that the electron transfer in these reactions is irreversible, since increasing the sweep rate leads to a rise in Epa.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ra03672k |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |