Open Access Article
Baptiste
Maillot
a,
Haroon
Rashid
a,
Roxanne
Bercy
b,
Jean Frédéric
Audibert
a,
Manuel J.
Llansola-Portoles
b,
Isabelle
Leray
a,
Fabien
Miomandre
a and
Vitor
Brasiliense
*a
aUniversité Paris-Saclay, ENS Paris-Saclay, CNRS, PPSM, 4 avenue des sciences, 91190 Gif-sur-Yvette, France. E-mail: Vitor.brasiliense@ens-paris-saclay.fr
bUniversité Paris-Saclay, CEA, CNRS, Institute for Integrative Biology of the Cell (I2BC), 91190 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
First published on 24th June 2025
The association of operando monitoring methodologies with micro and nanoscale surface modification strategies has recently been shown to enable the preparation of complex yet highly precise organic functional surfaces. While promising, such demonstrations have so far been limited to model systems, consisting on minimally functionalized aryl radicals. With a growing demand for more sophisticated surfaces, bearing multiple functions, a demonstration of the generality of the strategy, including chemically complex moieties and surfaces is deeply needed. In this work, we aim to fill this gap by preparing tetraphenyl porphyrin derivatives modified to become radical precursors that can be activated with light. Operando optical monitoring is used to non-invasively analyze their grafting behavior in different conditions, optimizing the reaction and enabling modification of inert glass surfaces with high precision (30 atto L). We demonstrate that the methodology is compatible with direct laser writing technologies, and use it to prepare photophysically active surfaces with high resolution. We demonstrate that the instrinsic emissive properties of Tetraphenylporphyrin derivatives are well preserved, and that several surface modifing steps can be sequentially stacked, leading to the preparation of surfaces with multiple functions. By controlling the microscale distribution of chemical groups with different photophysical properties, we demonstrate that complex chemical designs can be readily and reliably implemented. This work therefore shows that light activated radical pathways can be broadly used to modify surfaces, opening interesting new perspectives for the implementation of functional materials.
While lithographic techniques remain the golden standard when it comes to scalability, a strong demand for more flexible methodologies exists, particularly for fast preparation of chemically complex prototypes and proofs-of-concept studies. Indeed, lithography materials are limited, and their use to locally pattern complex surfaces relies on multistep procedures which are prone to generating defects, requiring critical alignments steps that can only be applied to regular surfaces. In such context, microscale additive manufacturing based on direct laser writing methods associated with organic radical reactions has recently emerged as a versatile option for preparing geometrically complex surface distributions of different molecules.7,8 Highly reactive radical intermediates enable wide scope reactions, consequently allowing different chemical functions to be anchored to a variety of surfaces (metals, carbon, glasses, etc.).7–11 Among different radical precursors, diazonium salts are particularly appealing, as diazonium groups are easily activated through several routes (electrochemical reduction, photochemical, temperature, etc.), ultimately generating inert N2 molecules and reactive aryl radicals. Moreover, since radical diazonium salts can be prepared in a single step from widely available aniline substrates, a large array of chemical functionalities can be easily reached with minimal synthetic efforts.
Recently, our team has shown that surface nanometrology can be combined with direct laser writing to implement extremely precise photografting operations,7 paving the way towards preparation of microstructured functional surfaces. While promising, these methodologies have only been demonstrated for aryl-radical intermediates with relatively small substituents, primarily modifying surfaces with only one reactant. It remains to be shown that such photochemical methods can be transposed to larger molecules, bearing more complex electronic structures and solvation properties or to surface patterns containing different chemical groups.
However, as the chemical complexity of the grafting molecules and their environment is increased, the challenge of precisely engineering surfaces grows. For instance, difficulties can arise due to: (i) interaction of the grafting precursors with surface functions, (ii) intrinsic properties of the grafting groups and its intermediates, (iii) hindered ability of radicals to attach to surfaces, etc. For example, the complex electronic and solvation properties found in species used as catalysts and sensors can be accompanied by propensity to aggregate, or by introduction of deexcitation pathways, disfavoring the formation and stability of radical intermediates.
This work therefore aims at demonstrating that nanometrology assisted laser fabrication can indeed enable preparation of multifunctional surfaces, primarily focusing on tetraphenyl porphyrin derivatives containing photoactivable anchoring groups based on aryldiazonium salts. This class of molecules are examples of radical precursors that present complex photochemical structure and functions, finding a wide range of applications in catalysis,12,13 energy conversion,14 sensors,1,15 photodynamic therapy,16,17etc. Therefore, by demonstrating the direct photografting of porphyrins onto complex surfaces, we directly highlight the potential of our approach to more advanced applications. For instance, local control of the TPP distribution on a surface enables the optimal placement of optical sensors, designed to respond to different concentrations of analytes. Similarly, in contexts where porphyrins are used as catalysts, high-resolution photografting can be used to optimize catalytic coverage and maximize substrate accessibility.
Existing strategies for immobilizing porphyrins onto surfaces, can be broadly categorized in two groups: (i) self-limiting methodologies which rely on the surface properties to control reactivity18–23; or (ii) formulation of composite films, on which porphyrins either associate with different components of the film,24 or constitute the film forming material themselves.16,25,26 In both cases, microscale patterning with high resolution cannot be easily achieved, often requiring multistep lithographic procedures carried out in clean room facilities. Moreover, most traditional methods fail to quantitatively control the layers dimensions when thick yet precise layers are targeted. Therefore, a single step methodology to enable precise direct laser writing of porphyrins would considerably widen the perspectives for preparing functional surfaces, particularly regarding the association with other functional molecules.
In this paper, we show how nanometrology approaches can be implemented to control the photografting of TPPs derivatives on inert surfaces. The methodology is compatible with a wide range of substrates, but we emphasize here the modification of borosilicate glass surfaces to underline the unique optical properties of the grafted TPP. Indeed, owing to their chemical inertness and low absorption in the visible range, glass surfaces only weakly affect the photophysical properties of the grafted molecules, differently from conductive surfaces, which could quench them. After designing a strategy to convert amino-tetraphenylporphyrin (TAPP) precursors into well dispersed photograftable diazonium porphyrins, we identify and optimize their photografting behavior with the help of operando analysis, using quantitative phase imaging as a noninvasive optical nanometrology technique. Finally, the possibility of preparing chemically and geometrically complex structures is explored, associating moieties with different emission properties in a single microscale pattern.
:
1 volume proportion, or as indicated in the text. The pH of all aqueous solutions used in this paper was adjusted to 2.0 ± 0.1 using a 1 M hydrochloric acid solution (Sigma Aldrich), with the help of a pH meter (Fisher Scientific Accumet, AE150). Dz-TPP Grafting solutions are prepared in situ with a one-pot protocol, by adding 4 equivalents of NaNO2 (Acros Organics) to the TAPP solutions (one equivalent for each amine function). For photosensitized grafting experiments, Rhodamine 6G (Rh6G) was dissolved in the grafting solution after completing the diazotization protocol. Aryldiazonium grafting solutions were prepared from either 4-nitrobenzenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (Sigma Aldrich, 97%), dissolved in pH 2.0 Milli-Q, or by preparing the diazonium in situ from 4-ethynylaniline (Sigma Aldrich, 97%), with addition of 1 eq. NaNO2. In these diazotization experiments, 5 vol.% DMSO was added as a co-solvent to minimize solubility issues. Solutions in all grafting experiments were freshly prepared, and used within 2 h.
, where σ is the unweighted standard deviation of the measurements. Rinsing operations are systematically carried out after each photografting experiment, using water–DMSO mixtures (ca. 5 mL, with the help of a Pasteur pipette) followed by abundant rinsing with milliQ water (ca. 20–30 ml, dispensed with pissette for a few seconds). The stability of samples was tested by additionally rinsing them with methanol, ethanol and acetonitrile, solvents which easily solubilize any unreacted species, leading no observable changes in the layer morphology, as characterized with atomic force microscopy.
![]() | (1) |
n
medium is measured at the observation wavelength (λobs = 633 nm) using an Abbe refractometer (Bausch & Lomb), leading to the value of 1.335 ± 0.001 for aqueous grafting solutions and 1.415 ± 0.001 for the 1
:
1 DMSO
:
H2O pH 2.0 ones. A large number (N > 15) of grafting experiments is conducted, leading to the average values and scatter reported in the paper.
First, TAPP is dissolved in DMSO. The absorption spectrum of 10 μM TAPP solution is shown in Fig. 1A, showcasing a Soret band at 439 nm and three smaller absorption peaks at 529, 580 and 668 nm (the Q bands), in good agreement with literature data.30 The molar absorptivity of the Soret band, determined by varying the solution concentration, was ε = 70
250 M−1 cm−1. This value is notably smaller than the one obtained in a weakly coordinating solvent such as DCM (ε = 93
100 M−1 cm−1, ESI S1†). Such variation can be explained by different phenomena, such as incomplete solubilization, interaction between the solvent and TAPP, or presence of small aggregates.31,32 To further characterize TAPP in DMSO, we analysed the fluorescence decay rates obtained from time resolved fluorescence experiments. The presence of supramolecular species is supported by these measurements (ESI S3†): while dissolution in DCM leads to a mono-exponential decay (τ = 7.5 ns, χ2 = 1.26), a biexponential decay is observed in DMSO (τ1 = 3.6 ns, τ2 = 6.3 ns, χ2 = 1.29), suggesting the presence of two emissive populations consistently with the formation of dimers. The solution remains emissive, with a well-defined peak at λem = 701 nm, enabling measurement of an excitation spectra (dashed line). Comparison between the excitation and absorption spectra (Fig. 1A) reveals that emissive species are essentially in a single form in DMSO, as absorption/excitation peaks appear in the same position in both spectra.
The situation drastically changes once pH 2.0 water is introduced as a co-solvent, as shown in Fig. 1B, with a split Soret band (λ = 426 nm, εapp ≈ 41 000 M−1cm−1 and λ = 470 nm, εapp ≈ 49
000 M−1 cm−1), disappearance of the original Q bands and appearance of a broad NIR Q band centred at 730 nm, associated with hyperporphyrinic behaviour, as previously observed for TAPP.30,33 These spectral changes are probably the result of more than a single phenomenon, as put forth by monitoring the spectra of TAPP DMSO solution during progressive addition of different amounts of water (ESI S2†). At low water concentrations (since 20 μM, or 2 eq.), asymmetric splitting of the Soret band is observed, leading to a small blue-shifted peak (λ = 390 nm) and a larger red-shifted one (λ = 467 nm), concomitantly with the disappearance of the Q bands structure and emergence of a large broad band in the NIR (>800 nm). Similar features are observed if the solution is titrated with an organic proton donor instead of water(ESI S2†), suggesting that protonation of the cycle is responsible for these changes, in good agreement with literature.33,34 At much higher water contents (>100 mM), the blue-shifted Soret satellite increases in intensity and progressively moves towards higher wavelengths, concomitantly with the blueshift of the NIR band, reaching an approximatively symmetrically split Soret band, and a NIR band centered at 730 nm for 50 vol.% H2O. The emission of the porphyrins is also clearly impaired during the process, with almost complete absence of emission bands at 50 vol.% H2O, except for a faint emission band at 654 nm. Using this band to stablish an excitation spectrum leads to the dashed line in Fig. 1B, which bears little resemblance with the absorption spectrum. This discrepancy suggests that several photoactive species are present, leading to complex energy transfer processes, which is consistent with the presence of small aggregates.35 If indeed present, however, aggregates are not sufficiently large to provoke noticeable precipitation, even at much larger concentrations (up to 5 mM). This conclusion is also supported by resonant Rayleigh spectra, a popular methodology to analyse aggregation of porphyrins,36,37 which does not display any clear features (ESI S4†). Small supramolecular species are nevertheless probably present, as photoluminescence decay curves in the presence of 50 vol.% water indicate at least three different decay rates (χ2 = 1.22, ESI S3†).
As the NaNO2 diazotization agent is added to the solution, its spectral properties once again undergo sharp modifications (Fig. 1C), with re-emergence of a well-defined Soret band at 446 nm, disappearance of the broad NIR feature, and reappearance of the Q band structure. These results suggest that the amino phenyl groups are successfully converted into aryldiazoniums (Ph-N2+), forming tetra diazonium phenyl porphyrins (Dz-TPP). The transformation is also accompanied by the reappearance of an emission band at 693 nm, whose excitation spectrum reasonably resembles the absorption, indicating that much less (if any) aggregates are present. Using this band, an excitation spectrum can be obtained and compared to absorption spectrum. As more clearly shown in the final spectra (Fig. 1D) the excitation and absorption bands do not exactly overlap, particularly in the Q bands region, indicating the presence of more than one species. Based on the fact that four charges per molecule are expected to be generated during the diazotization reaction, we hypothesize that this behaviour is related to H2O higher ability to solubilize the newly formed cationic porphyrins. We support this hypothesis by redissolving the Dz-TPP in mixtures of higher water content, leading to the absorption spectra which closely resemble excitation ones (ESI S5†). Determination of the ε of the Soret band in water reveals a value of 95
000 cm−1 M−1 (ESI S1†), very close to the value observed in DCM for the TAPP precursor, suggesting that a single species is again present. Taken together, these results clearly indicate that once the diazonium species are formed, a solution containing majorly well dispersed species is obtained.
Comparison between the final OPD image and ex situ atomic force microscopy enables estimation of the average refractive index of the layer, yielding nlayer = 1.455 ± 0.005 (N = 19). Such value is rather low when compared to that of the layers formed with smaller diazonium salts derivatives,7 or to dense porphyrin films,38–40 indicating that the grafted layers are not compact. Low density layers were expected on the basis of the highly reactive radical intermediates generated upon activation of the diazonium groups, associated with the structure of the molecule. Indeed, since several positions can be attacked by radicals during addition of new porphyrin units to the layers, no particular organization is expected, leading to a highly branched structure connected through the phenyl rings. Low refractive indexes suggest that ππ stacking contributions are negligible to the layer structure, as dense stacks would be expected to present optical constants closer to crystalline layers.
We evaluate our ability to control the volume of the grafted layers by using the operando measurement to dynamically adapt the exposition time, as indicated in detail elsewhere.7 After setting the target optical volume to 10 aL (corresponding to a target physical volume V = OVDtarget/Δn of ∼250 aL), we perform several repetitions (N = 18) of the experiment and measure physical volumes ex situ with atomic force microscopy. This data is resumed in the histogram in Fig. 2C (the corresponding AFM images are provided in ESI S7†). The operation precision is estimated by fitting the distribution with a Gaussian function, leading to an average volume of 247 aL, in excellent agreement with the 250 aL target. Defining the operation precision as 2σ (σ being the standard deviation of the gaussian distribution) yields a precision of 36 aL, confirming our ability to control the photografted volumes.
The concentration of Rh6G with respect to the photografting entity was first optimized in a series of experiments using a reaction mimic, p-nitrobenzenediazonium (pNBD). In addition to the structural similarity to the diazonium phenyl groups and Dz-TPP, pNBD was previously shown to optimally graft onto glass, and to present very high refractive index (1.68 ± 0.02),11 facilitating its operando observation. In this experiment series (ESI S8†), we have monitored the grafting rate of 5 mM pNBD solution in the presence of different sensitizer concentrations. Addition of small amounts of Rh6G (<0.5 eq.) leads to a substantial increase in the surface modification efficiency, as measured by the apparent efficiency ηapp. Such tendency saturates as [Rh6G] approaches 1 eq. [4NBD], with almost no increase beyond this threshold. When 4NBD is replaced by the porphyrin derivative, a very similar behaviour is observed: significant acceleration of the grafting reaction at low [Rh6G], which saturates as the sensitizer concentration approaches [Dz-TPP], (Fig. 2D). Typical evolution of the modified zone is indicated in yellow in Fig. 2A and B, revealing a limiting efficiency ηapplim (= 3 × 1013 nm3 J−1) which is roughly 4 times larger than the observed efficiency in the absence of sensitizer (ηapp0 = 0.7 × 1013 nm3 J−1), therefore allowing surface modification at significantly higher rates.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Characterization of grafted layer, (A) AFM image of the “ENS Paris-Saclay” pattern, along with FLIM images (inset). (B) Vibrational spectroscopy analysis of the grafted layer, obtained by collecting Raman spectra after excitation at λexc = 405 nm. A total of 20 spectra is collected (gray curves), demonstrating the stability of the measurement. The average Raman spectrum is shown in red, and main vibrational bands are highlighted (assignment in ESI S9†). (C) Emission spectra of the grafted layer, excited in widefield configuration at λ = 474 nm, the average (N = 98) spectrum is shown in red, while the individual spectra are shown in gray (1s acquisition time). (D) Photoluminescecnce decay curves, showing the substrate intrinsic emission (black curve), the layer decay (orange), along with a multiexponential fit (3 terms, dashed lines), and the experiment pulse width (gray). | ||
We confirm the chemical identity of the resulting patterns through a combination of local microscale Raman spectroscopy and surface X-ray photonelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis. First, a focused laser is used to extract the Raman signal with high spatial resolution (typ. 1 μm), allowing local characterization of the layer. The excitation wavelength (λexc = 405 nm) is selected to maximize the overlap with the Soret band of the porphyrin, triggering Resonant Raman mechanisms that significantly increase the signal. The resulting spectrum (Fig. 3B) shows several high intensity bands characteristic of tetraphenyl porphyrins, such as the 1553cm−1 (pyrrolic β carbons stretching), and the 1236 cm−1 (meso-carbon-phenyl stretching).42–44 In fact, assignment of all observed bands to normal modes of TPP molecules was possible on the basis of literature data (ESI S9†), unequivocally confirming the chemical identity of the layer. Noteworthy, such excellent agreement between solution data and the grafted layer Raman bands is consistent with the observed refractive index, both suggesting that the grafted layer has a low density.
We further corroborate these findings by performing an extensive surface analysis of the sample combining SEM/EDS and XPS analysis. Using a sacrificial sample, we use SEM/EDS data to show that all organic content of the sample is concentrated on the photomodified area, as EDX spectra collected from the background reveal no N or C contributions. Then, the “ENS Paris-Saclay” sample is analysed using XPS. We observe that (i) that most (ca. 94%) of the nitrogen content of the sample experiences the same chemical environment, showcasing a 399.98 eV binding energy consistently with the TPPs45 and; (ii) that measurements of N to C ratios reveal a value of 0.092 ± 0.01, indicating an average of 4.0 ± 0.4 nitrogen atoms per TPP molecule. These results, fully described in ESI section S9,† demonstrate that the contribution of any eventually unreacted NH2 groups to the chemical can be safely neglected, and that the layer is majorly composed of TPPs.
We complete the characterization of the layer emission properties with the help of a fluorescence lifetime imaging camera (FLIM), leading to the average lifetime (τPL) image shown in the inset of Fig. 3A, and to the decay curves shown in Fig. 3D. The resulting emission lifetimes are relatively low, between 0.9 and 1.2 ns, and complex, requiring at least 4 discrete exponential terms to fit the decay curve (fit procedures and results are shown in ESI S11†). Complex emission properties are characteristic of solid layers,48–51 and often arise as a result of complex energy transfer pathways in the solid state, especially for materials with highly overlapping emission and absorption bands within an amorphous structure.
First, the alkyne layer is prepared from a 5 mM 4-ethynylbenzene diazonium solution. We adjust the incident power (P = 600 μW) to compensate for the weak absorption of the 4-ethynylbenzene radical precursor, leading to an easily observable layer by moving the piezo stage at constant speed of 4 μm s−1. After preparation of the circle, we show that the alkyne functions remain intact by post functionalizing them with azide-modified fluorescein (Az-Fl) fluorophores. For that, a click chemistry procedure was employed, consisting in the incubation of the circle in a 1 mM Az-Fl solution in the presence of catalytic amounts of Cu(I) for 12 h (the full protocol is detailed in ESI S12,† along with the synthesize of Az-Fl). The procedure leads to covalent attachment of fluorescein to the grafted layer, as confirmed by its characteristic green emission upon excitation at 474 nm (control spectra are shown in ESI S13†). Next, we carefully rinse the sample and insert it in a 5 mM 4-nitro-benzenediazonium solution (H2O pH 2.0), grafting a second cycle (P = 600 μW, V = 4 μm s−1), which is not expected to be emissive, as indeed observed. Finally, the rinsing process is re-iterated before using a 5 mM Dz-TPP solution (in 50 vol.% DMSO/H2O), to graft a third cycle containing the porphyrins (P = 250 nW, V = 3 μm s−1), which displays the expected bright red emission, consistently with the data shown in Fig. 3C. The thickness of the final structure is characterized by AFM, as shown in Fig. 4A. Noteworthy, these experiments clearly demonstrate the stability of the grafted layers, able to withstand rinsing with the grafting solutions, its solvents, and several others (ethanol, methanol, acetonitrile, etc.), with no detectable structural changes.
Preliminary inspection of the final structure through fluorescence imaging, as shown in the RGB image Fig. 4B, confirm the anticipated trends: the TPP-based layer appears red, while fluorescein-modified can be seen in green and the p-NBD is not visible. Interestingly, in spite of its favourable intrinsic properties, the fluorescein layer emission appears weaker than the TPP. This can be explained by (i) the layers average thickness, (ii) the fact that only a thin layer of fluorophores is grafted by post functionalization, while the whole TPP layer is emissive.
The emission properties are further analysed by FLIM, leading to the image shown Fig. 4C. After spatial filtering of the data on the basis of the layers distribution (ESI S11†), the normalized decay curves shown in Fig. 4D are obtained (see also ESI†), enabling a better observation of decay rates. While it is clear that all three layers present complex decays dominated by small lifetime values (<2 ns), subtle differences can still be spotted, enabling the formation of the lifetime image contrast (Fig. 4C). The pNBD layer has no significant emission, as the detected value in the grafted regions (〈τDZPL〉 <0.7 ns) rather suggests elastic scattering of photons from the excitation pulse. The TPP circle presents a low but significant lifetime, with 〈τTPPPL 〉 ∼1.1 ns. In the regions grafted with fluorescein, a clearer distinction from the other layers is observed, notably due to the presence of a longer component (τFlPL ∼ 1.6 ns), which becomes predominant for t > 3 ns, generating the contrast shown in Fig. 4C.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: S1: Determination of molar absorptivity coefficients of TAPP in different solvents. S2: Evolution of UV Vis Spectrum of TAPP with the addition of acidic H2O and organic acid. S3: Fluorescence decay of TAPP in different solvents. S4: Resonant Rayleigh spectra of TAPP and Dz TAPP in different solvents. S5: Characterization of TAPP Dz structure in solution by spectroscopy. S6: Effect of laser power on Dz-TAPP grafting efficiency. S7: AFM measurements of grafted TAPP. S8: Optimization of sensitizerto diazonium ratios with 4-nitrobenzenediazonium. S9: Analysis of the chemical properties of the grafted layers. S9.1: Raman Data. S9.2: SEM/EDS data. S9.3: XRay Photoelectron spectroscopy data. S10: Influence of sensitizer on emission spectra of grafted layers. S11: Grafted Layers lifetime analysis and FLIM data treatment. S12: Synthesis of fluorescein azide derivative (Az-Fl) and Click reaction S13: Photophysical properties of polymer layers functionalized by fluorescein derivatives. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5nr00765h |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |