Tiago C.
Barbosa
ab,
André J.
Chaves
c,
Raul O.
Freitas
d,
Leonardo C.
Campos
*ab and
Ingrid D.
Barcelos
*d
aDepartamento de Física, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG), Belo Horizonte, MG 31270-901, Brazil
bCentro de Tecnologia em Nanomateriais e Grafeno, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, MG 31270-901, Brazil
cDepartment of Physics, Aeronautics Institute of Technology, 12228-900, São José dos Campos, SP, Brazil
dLaboratório Nacional de Luz Síncrotron (LNLS), Centro Nacional de Pesquisa em Energia e Materiais (CNPEM), Campinas, SP 13083-970, Brazil. E-mail: Ingrid.barcelos@lnls.br
First published on 12th February 2025
This work investigates the plasmonic properties of a twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) and talc heterostructure. Talc, a naturally occurring phyllosilicate, promotes p-type charging of graphene, supporting high charge mobility and strong interaction between graphene plasmons and talc's phonon polaritons. This interaction results in the formation of surface plasmon–phonon polariton (SP3) modes, which are detected using infrared scattering-type scanning near-field optical microscopy (IR s-SNOM) at room temperature. Notably, without the need for electrostatic gating, our study reveals confinement of SP3 modes in a TBG–talc heterostructure and a transition from surface plasmonic waves to the emergence of moiré superlattices, characterized by reflections at domain walls. These findings provide fresh insights into the coupling mechanisms in hybrid materials and suggest promising applications in nanoscale optoelectronics.
Recently, it was shown that several properties of a graphene heterostructure can be tailored by selecting specific stacking materials3 and controlling the relative twist angle (θ) between them.23 For example, when two graphene layers form twisted bilayer graphene, their lattices create a new periodic array, called the moiré pattern, introducing twist-angle-dependent features in the electronic, optical, and mechanical properties.24 Remarkable phenomena occur when the twist angle is close to 1.1°, known as “magic angle”, at which the TBG turns into a strongly interacting system, revealing interesting phenomena such as enhanced many-body interactions, phase transitions from Mott insulators, metallic conductors, and unconventional superconductivity.24–28 For TBG below the magic angle, the system undergoes a self-organized lattice reconstruction resulting in periodic triangular areas of alternating Bernal (AB and BA) stacking domains, separated by shear soliton regions (SP), with AA-stacked regions at the vertices of the triangles29,30 (for further details on the TBG's reconstruction regime, refer to section S1 of the ESI†). At even lower angles, i.e. minimally twisted samples with θ < 0.5°, the band structure of the TBG is reconfigured activating very interesting physical phenomena such as topologically protected quantum valley Hall edge states,31,32 moiré domain reconstruction30 and topological transport in the network of domain boundaries.33
TBG's moiré patterns and its reconstructed form can be investigated through various techniques, including transmission electron microscopy (TEM),30 scanning microwave impedance microscopy (sMIM),34,35 tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS)29 and infrared s-SNOM.36 In plasmonics, the altered electronic structure due to TBG's moiré superlattices can enhance or tune plasmonic behavior, with plasmon wavelengths in TBG matching those of monolayer graphene but with reduced damping due to Fermi-velocity renormalization.25 With the reduction of the twisting angle, enhanced layer interactions strengthen many-body effects, modifying plasmonic properties.20,25 Moiré patterns modulate the electronic properties and significantly impact plasmonic wave dispersion and confinement.37 Previous studies have imaged surface plasmon–phonon polaritons launched in graphene-based heterostructure devices, at low temperature20 and by controlling their charge density through electrostatic gating.20,38–40 High mobility pristine graphene requires doping to increase free-carrier density and enable SPP observation, achieved through substrate engineering or electrostatic gating.20,38–40 However, IR s-SNOM systems with temperature control are rare and still under development, while electrostatic gating methods often involve complex fabrication steps that require delicate operation to avoid damage to the devices. This highlights the need to explore dielectric materials for graphene stacking to support plasmon–phonon polariton formation while addressing these limitations.
In that context, dielectric environments can modulate the plasmonic phenomena;41–43 thus, understanding the behavior of polaritons at the substrate interface is crucial to unlock the potential of hybrid optoelectronic devices for modern applications. Talc, a naturally abundant phyllosilicate,44,45 has shown intriguing properties when combined with graphene as a heterostructure,46,47 including spontaneous p-type doping while preserving excellent charge mobility.47 Additionally, a strong interaction between graphene plasmons and talc's phonon polaritons gives rise to hybrid modes,46 specifically surface plasmon–phonon polaritons (SP3), resulting from the coupling between graphene's electron density oscillations and talc's lattice vibrations.46 Here, we report SP3 modes in a twisted bilayer graphene–talc (TBG–talc) heterostructure observed using IR s-SNOM at room temperature without any back-gate voltage. We experimentally demonstrate the transition from SP3 waves on the surface of the TBG to the emergence of the TBG moiré pattern, evidenced by reflections at the superlattice domain walls. Analysis of the extracted SP3 wave's profiles unveils confinement factors of approximately 180, obtained by the equation:
fcon = λIR/λp, | (1) |
The IR s-SNOM system is an atomic force microscope (AFM) operating in semicontact (tapping) mode, equipped with optics to focus and collect both incident and scattered light. The IR light illuminates the tip, which oscillates at its fundamental mechanical frequency Ω (∼250 kHz), inducing effective polarization of the tip that enhances light interaction with the sample. The near-field optical signal (Sm), originating from an area comparable to the tip radius (∼25 nm), is extracted from the detected back-scattered light by demodulating the signal at harmonics (m) of Ω, with m ≥ 2, with a lock-in amplifier, and the backscattered light interferes with the reference IR beam from a scanning mirror. The Fourier transform of the resultant interferogram yields the IR amplitude |Sm(ω)| and phase ϕm(ω) spectra of the complex optical near-field signal Sm(ω) = |Sm(ω)| × eiΦm(ω). All nanoimages here are measured with third harmonic demodulation (m = 3) to yield S3(ω) and ϕ3(ω).
The IR s-SNOM measurements were conducted in the IMBUIA beamline at Sirius (LNLS, Campinas, Brazil) using a commercial s-SNOM instrument (neaSCOPE, neaspec/attocube systems AG). Nanoimaging was performed with a quantum cascade laser (QCL) model MirCat from Daylight Solutions, covering the spectral range of 930–1730 cm−1, with a minimum frequency step of 1 cm−1 and a pseudo-heterodyne detection scheme demodulated at the third harmonic. Post-processing of the nanoimages and s-SNOM profiles was carried out using the free software Gwyddion (https://gwyddion.net).
To obtain the plasmon–phonon polariton dispersion, we calculated the TBG–talc–SiO2 heterostructure loss function, defined as L = −Im[rp], where rp is the Fresnel reflection coefficient for transverse magnetic (TM) polarized waves, calculated using the transfer matrix method.50 For TBG, we considered a 2D optical conductivity obtained from the hydrodynamic model for graphene,51 as explained in sections S2 and S3 of the ESI.† We used the talc infrared dielectric function from a parallel work.52 For the SiO2, we used the dielectric function of ref. 53. Details about the derivation of the hydrodynamic model and justification for the used approximations can be found in the ESI.†
λp = 2π/qp, | (2) |
The TBG–talc heterostructure was investigated across a broad range of IR frequencies to probe SP3 modes and explore the impact of moiré patterns on plasmonic behavior. Fig. 1 shows a summary of the main phenomena observed, which will be described in detail in the following sections. Specifically, Fig. 1d and e show the IR s-SNOM nanoimages obtained at different laser frequencies. At a laser frequency of 940 cm−1 (Fig. 1d), SP3 modes are visible, demonstrating the capability of the TBG–talc structure to support ultra-confined plasmonic waves, behaving coherently, at room temperature. On the other hand, at the laser frequency excitation of 1021 cm−1 (Fig. 1e), moiré patterns emerge within the heterostructure, characterized by distinct reflections at the superlattice domain walls revealing a moiré period of approximately 150 nm, corresponding to a twist angle of 0.1°.
In an IR s-SNOM experiment, the SP3 propagation appears as interference fringes, resulting in periodic modulation of the near-field signal across the sample, as shown in Fig. 1d, for the 3rd harmonic of the optical phase signal (ϕ3(ω)). This modulation strongly depends on the density of charge in the material and on the frequency of the incident light.20 Consequently, different frequencies produce fringes with varying wavelengths. To investigate the SP3 frequency dependency, we performed IR s-SNOM nanoimaging with excitation frequencies ranging from 920 cm−1 up to 1060 cm−1.
At 920 cm−1, characteristic plasmonic interference fringes appear in the ϕ3(ω) signal (Fig. 2a), showing minimal damping and indicating that the SP3 can propagate over several micrometers without losing coherence.54 The dotted lines trace the line profiles of the confined SP3, allowing us to determine their wavelengths (λp) as a function of laser frequency. These line profiles demonstrate a decreased SP3 wavelength with increasing frequency, indicating strong frequency dependence of plasmon–phonon polariton confinement within the TBG–talc heterostructure. From the extracted profile, we measured a wavelength of 75 nm, corresponding to a confinement factor on the order of 145 (eqn (1)). We performed the same analysis for excitation frequencies of 940 cm−1 (Fig. 2b), 960 cm−1 (Fig. 2c) and 980 cm−1 (Fig. 2d) obtaining wavelengths of 72 nm, 57 nm and 58 nm, respectively. These values yield confinement factors up to 180, establishing a new benchmark for polariton confinement in TBG samples at room temperature.20 This high degree of confinement is attributed primarily to the spontaneous p-type doping induced by talc,47 which enhances charge density and strengthens the coupling between graphene plasmons and talc phonon modes. This coupling is evidenced by the clear standing waves observed within the SP3 modes, as seen in the line profiles.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Near-field images of ϕ3(ω) signals observed at selected frequencies: (a) 920 cm−1, (b) 940 cm−1, (c) 960 cm−1 and (d) 980 cm−1 revealing highly confined surface plasmon–phonon polaritons (SP3) – the dotted lines reveal the line profiles of the confined SP3 with its wavelength (λp) – scale bars: 25 nm. (e) Dispersion relation (ω(q)) for plasmon–phonon polariton in a TBG–talc–SiO2 heterostructure obtained from the plot of the Fresnel reflection coefficient, calculated using the transfer matrix method (ESI section S2†), on a logarithmic scale (log|rp|). The blue crosses were experimentally obtained from the measured λp by using eqn (2); the white dashed line marks the beginning of the talc's Reststrahlen band.52 |
Fig. 2e presents the theoretical dispersion relation of the SP3 modes and experimental data (blue crosses) derived from the measured wavelengths (λp) in Fig. 2a–d. Below the frequency of 948 cm−1, which corresponds to the talc z-polarized transverse optical phonons, the frequency of the plasmon–phonon branch increases with the wavenumber. Above this phonon frequency threshold, the peak of the loss function spreads out and approaches a horizontal line (see the ESI in sections S2 and S3†). This dispersion relation reveals key characteristics of SP3 propagation in TBG, where increasing frequency leads to a shorter wavelength and, thus, stronger confinement of the plasmon–phonon polaritons. Also, the observed dispersion behavior is consistent with theoretical models for SP3 modes in graphene–talc heterostructures,25,55 where the moiré superlattice created by the twist angle modulates the electronic structure.25,55 This modulation affects the momentum (qp) and wavelength of SP3 modes, allowing for tunable dispersion properties. The frequency-dependent behavior observed in Fig. 2 demonstrates the potential for tuning SP3 propagation characteristics in TBG–talc systems through frequency adjustments, offering an additional layer of control for nanoscale optoelectronic applications. The ability to achieve ultra-confined SP3 modes at room temperature in TBG–talc, without the need for back-gating, opens new avenues for applications in nanoscale optics. The highly confined SP3 waves and their tunable dispersion make this heterostructure a promising candidate for use in plasmonic sensors, modulators, and photodetectors. By leveraging the natural p-type doping from talc and the moiré superlattice effect, it may be possible to create devices with fine control over plasmonic behavior at sub-wavelength scales.
Beyond 980 cm−1, the SP3 propagation in the TBG–talc heterostructure largely vanishes, indicating plasmonic losses and a transition to the emergence of a distinct moiré pattern. This shift marks a transformation from surface plasmonic waves to the formation of hexagonal moiré patterns, which appear with periodicities that match those of the TBG superlattice, as revealed in Fig. 3. The visualization of these moiré patterns through IR s-SNOM highlights the power of this technique in probing local conductivity and optical modulation at the nanoscale. This approach has proven valuable in studying twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) and similar 2D systems.32,56
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Near-field images of S3(ω) signals observed at frequencies (a) 1000 cm−1 and (b) 1021 cm−1, revealing moiré patterns of the twisted bilayer graphene in the reconstruction regime, as depicted in (e). The inset in figure (a) is an AFM profile showing a thickness difference of approximately 1.5 nm between the left and right regions of the sample, which changes talc's vibrational modes,46 impacting the SP3 formation. Figures (c) and (d) are zoomed-in images of the hexagonal superlattice shown in (a) and (b), respectively. |
Fig. 3a presents S3(ω) near-field images obtained at 1000 cm−1, showing a moiré pattern on the right side of the sample, highlighted in the zoomed-in view in Fig. 3c. The observed superlattice shows a moiré period of approximately LM = 150 nm, corresponding to a minimal twist angle of 0.1°, estimated from the expression θ = 2·arcsin(aG/2·LM), where aG = 0.246 nm is the graphene's crystal lattice constant.57 At this twist angle, the TBG enters the reconstruction regime,29,30 as depicted in Fig. 3e. However, the expected triangular domains are less prominent in the S3(ω) images obtained at 1000 cm−1 than those obtained at 1021 cm−1 (Fig. 3b and d).
At the excitation frequency of 1021 cm−1 (Fig. 3b), a well-defined formation of the triangular Bernal stacking areas is observed on the right side of the sample, with an increase in the intensity of the amplitude signal at the soliton regions, indicating increased IR reflectivity at the domain walls. Additionally, a moiré pattern forms on the left side of the sample, which is absent at 1000 cm−1 (Fig. 3a and c). A closer AFM examination of these regions reveals a difference in talc thickness of approximately 1.5 nm (inset in Fig. 3a), corresponding to about one monolayer of talc.58 The thickness variation affects talc's vibrational modes,46 impacting the SP3 formation. These results highlight the clear frequency dependence of SP3 coupling with the TBG superlattice and confirm the influence of talc's vibrational modes on SP3 behavior as a function of thickness, consistent with previous studies.46
In TBG, solitons are sharp and localized changes in the stacking configuration that separate regions with different atomic alignments.30 These soliton regions often form a network of domain walls in the moiré pattern, typically separating Bernal-stacked (AB/BA) domains. Solitons in TBG are particularly interesting because they give rise to unique electronic, optical, and plasmonic properties that can also be imaged by s-SNOM.30Fig. 4a illustrates the mechanism underlying the double-line features observed in the ϕ3(ω) images (Fig. 4b–d), specifically highlighting the interaction between SP3 and soliton boundaries in the reconstructed twisted bilayer graphene.
The phenomenon described above can be experimentally observed in the ϕ3(ω) images in Fig. 4b–d, obtained at excitation frequencies of 1000 cm−1, 1021 cm−1, and 1060 cm−1, respectively. These images provide a real-space view of the interference pattern, exhibiting double-line features aligned along the soliton boundaries. This behavior is consistent with previous studies,30,56 which demonstrated that soliton boundaries in TBG alter local optical conductivity and act as plasmonic reflectors. The robustness of this effect across a range of frequencies is evident, as the double-line features remain visible at each frequency. However, the distance between the double lines varies with frequency, as shown in the line profiles for 1000 cm−1 (Fig. 4e) and 1021 cm−1 (Fig. 4f). This frequency-dependent separation suggests that the spacing between the lines is governed by the SP3 wavelength, which decreases as the excitation frequency increases. Consequently, at higher frequencies, the double-line separation narrows, reflecting the tunable plasmonic response within the TBG–talc heterostructure.
As the frequency exceeded 980 cm−1, SP3 propagation largely vanishes due to plasmonic losses, revealing the underlying TBG moiré patterns. The observed superlattice exhibited distinct periodic triangular domains separated by shear soliton regions, characteristic of the TBG reconstruction regime, with moiré periods reaching up to 150 nm, corresponding to a minimal twist angle of 0.1°. Variations in the intensities of the S3(ω) near field images were observed at the triangular domains, which were influenced by frequency and thickness variations within the talc flake. Additionally, the ϕ3(ω) signal unveiled double-line features centered at the soliton boundaries in the reconstructed TBG structure, highlighting the coupling between SP3 modes and domain walls. These double lines indicate that soliton boundaries can act as reflective barriers, creating interference between forward- and backward-propagating SP3 waves, thereby modifying local optical conductivity.
Our findings underscore the utility of s-SNOM in exploring soliton-mediated plasmonic phenomena, emphasizing that solitonic boundaries in TBG can serve as frequency-dependent, reflective channels for SP3 modes. The moiré superlattice and soliton networks play a critical role in altering plasmonic wave dispersion and confinement, increasing the strength of plasmonic interactions and enhancing the control over plasmonic confinement and interference. These intricate plasmonic behaviors provide valuable insights into electron–plasmon interactions and offer exciting opportunities for nanoscale photonic and optoelectronic applications that leverage the fine-tuning of moiré superlattices and solitonic boundaries. Overall, our results position TBG–talc heterostructures as a promising platform for advancing nanoscale device technologies where precise control over plasmonic interactions is essential.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4nr04532g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |