Open Access Article
Joseph O.
Ogar
ab,
E. Stephen
Davies
a,
Asia R. Y.
Almuhana
cd,
Sarah L.
Griffin
c,
Matthew A.
Addicoat
b,
Stephen P.
Argent
a and
Neil R.
Champness
*c
aSchool of Chemistry, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK
bSchool of Science and Technology, Nottingham Trent University, Clifton Lane, NG11 8NS, Nottingham, UK
cSchool of Chemistry, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK. E-mail: n.champness@bham.ac.uk
dKing Faisal University, P.O. 380, Al-Ahsa 31982, Saudi Arabia
First published on 2nd October 2025
The electrochemical and spectroelectrochemical behaviour of metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) using a perylene diimide (PDI) based ligand is reported. Through suitable functionalisation, a PDI-based ligand is made soluble, allowing successful synthesis of two MOFs in combination with cobalt dicarboxylate paddlewheel secondary building units. Spectroelectrochemical techniques are used to probe the electrochemical and optical behaviour of the MOFs demonstrating that the properties of the perylene diimide are maintained by the MOF, facilitating electrochromic behaviour.
An approach to the latter applications is to use organic linkers that undergo colour changes upon an electronically stimulated redox process. In this regard MOFs that contain ligands based on rylene diimides are particularly attractive due to the rich chemistry of such systems and their application in electronic and photoactive materials.14–16 In the context of MOFs, by far the most studied rylene diimides are naphthalene diimides (NDIs).17 NDI-containing MOFs have been extensively developed and include seminal examples of electrochromic materials.10,11 Despite the interesting properties that can be developed using NDI components, alternative rylene diimide analogues such as perylene diimides (PDIs) present distinct properties. PDIs exhibit similarly robust behaviour as NDIs but combine distinct HOMO–LUMO energy gaps, leading to different electro- and photo-chemical properties and colours, along with greater potential for core functionalisation leading to potential adaptability.15
Interestingly, PDIs have received far less attention than NDIs in terms of their incorporation into MOFs.18 Indeed, the examples of PDI-containing MOFs were only reported recently.19–29 PDI-containing MOFs have been developed for a variety of applications including photocatalysis,19–22 photothermal conversion23 and chromatographic separation.24 It is interesting to consider why NDI-containing MOFs are widespread, but PDI-containing MOFs are significantly less studied. Of the previous reports of single crystal structures of PDI-containing MOFs, a high proportion employ ligands based on a 1,2,6,7-tetrachloroperylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic acid diimide core.19,20,23,26–29 Although the other reported examples use ligands with unsubstituted perylene cores, the use of the tetrachloro-PDI, which has a twisted perylene moiety, suggests a primary reason that PDI-MOFs are less studied than their NDI analogues. PDIs exhibit notoriously challenging solubility,15 primarily due to inter-PDI π–π stacking interactions, and, in combination with solvents commonly used for MOF synthesis such as N,N′-dimethylformamide (DMF), the growth of PDI-MOF single crystals, or even crystalline material can be a formidable challenge. An elegant example that illustrates this point was reported by Bein et al.24 in which microcrystalline powders of a PDI-containing MOF was prepared using a linker in which the PDI core was not substituted, and hence remained planar. In this study we demonstrate that functionalisation of the imide substituent of the PDI group with bulky substituents allows enhanced solubility facilitating growth of crystalline MOF materials suitable for characterisation by single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD). Further, we demonstrate the growth of PDI-based MOFs on transparent electrode surfaces that allow (spectro)electrochemical characterisation of the PDI-based MOFs, affording unequivocal interpretation of the phenomena underpinning electrochromic behaviour.
Crystals of L1 suitable for single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) studies were obtained by slow evaporation of solutions of the compounds in CH2Cl2. Analysis of the single crystal data shows L1 crystallising in the monoclinic space group P21/c (Fig. 1) and reveals that the molecule sits on an inversion centre such that the two halves of the molecule are equivalent. Analysis of the structure shows that the PDI core of L1 is slightly twisted, with an angle of 7.0° between the naphthyl rings at either end of the perylene core and forms a dihedral angle of 87.5° with the 2,6-diisopropyl-phenyl rings. The twist of the perylene core compares to significantly larger such angles in other PDI-MOFs, such as 35.2° in a MOF containing 1,2,6,7-tetrachloroperylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic acid diimide cores.23
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 View of the conformation adopted by L1 in solid-state crystal structure. Note the distortion from planarity. C – grey; N – blue; O – red; H – light grey. | ||
Two related PDI-containing MOFs, [Co2(2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate)2(L1)] (1) and [Co2(biphenyl-4,4′-dicarboxylate)2(L1)] (2), were prepared in order to investigate the behaviour of the PDI within a framework material and particularly to probe how the order and organisation of the framework affects the PDI functionality. Both 1 and 2 were prepared by reaction of Co(NO3)2·6H2O, L1, and the corresponding dicarboxylic acid (biphenyl-4,4′-dicarboxylic acid 1, or 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid, 2) in DMF. Crystals suitable for analysis by SCXRD were grown for 1 and 2 by solvothermal methods.
Crystals of 1 were grown which gave good quality diffraction allowing determination of a 3D MOF structure. Co2(O2CR)4 paddlewheels (Fig. 2a) are linked via the 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate ligands into two dimensional sheets, which exhibit the anticipated sql-net, and are pillared by the bipyridyl L1 ligands to create a pillared 3D MOF (Fig. 2b). Topological analysis30–32 reveals a pcu net, a relatively common arrangement in pillared MOFs.33–35 The MOF adopts a doubly interpenetrated structure (Fig. 2c) leading to more efficient packing; despite this, inspection of the crystal structure reveals that the perylene core of the PDI ligand is considerably curved (Fig. 3b). Rectangular channels in 1, excluding interpenetration, have dimensions of 32.0 Å by 13.2 Å.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 PXRD patterns for 2. Experimental pattern (black) revealing poor crystallinity of this sample, and pattern simulated from a calculated model of a doubly interpenetrated pcu framework (red). | ||
In contrast to 1, crystals of 2 were weakly diffracting even using a synchrotron X-ray source. Multiple data sets were collected but none gave rise to reliable solutions and therefore it was decided to use a calculated model of a MOF structurally analogous to 1, i.e. a doubly interpenetrated pcu framework, to predict a powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) pattern for this MOF. PXRD patterns were collected for samples of 2 revealing poor crystallinity for this material (Fig. 3). Comparison of the simulated PXRD data from the calculated MOF structure with the experimental data (Fig. 3) suggests that 2 adopts the same framework structure as 1. The adoption of a doubly interpenetrated structure is supported by calculations of the energy of interaction between two interpenetrating frameworks of −207 kJ mol−1 (see SI for more details). Considering its poor crystallinity, BET measurements were used to assess the residual porosity of 2 using N2 gas as a probe, which yielded a surface area of 297 m2 g−1 indicating that porosity is maintained upon desolvation of the sample.
To investigate the effect of incorporating the PDI moiety into the MOF, electrochemical and spectroscopic measurements were undertaken. For comparison the electronic behaviour of L1 was studied using cyclic voltammetry (CV), UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry (SEC), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy and fluorescence techniques. Most PDIs are known to exhibit two one-electron reversible reductions,15,36,37 as determined by cyclic voltammetry, and L1 is no exception (Fig. S1). UV-visible spectroelectrochemistry (SEC) was used to confirm the reduction of L1 to its mono- and dianionic forms. The conversion of the neutral compound to the charged delocalised radical monoanion (L1˙−) and the interconversion between the mono- and dianionic species, (L1)2−, were successfully probed. L1˙− exhibits intense absorbance peaks at longer wavelengths, as anticipated for PDI monoanions36,37 and the overall profile for the interconversion between the monoanion and dianion agrees well with those that have been reported previously in the literature36,37 (see Fig. S3 and Table S1). To further support evidence for the existence of radical anions as probed by the CV and SEC measurements, EPR studies were employed. (L1)˙− produces a complex 23-line EPR spectrum centred at giso = 2.0035 (Fig. S4). The simulated spectra were generated using the parameters listed in Table S2 and matches the experimentally obtained spectra. These data are in good agreement with those reported in the literature for similar systems.37
The redox behaviour of 1 and 2 were investigated in the solid-state by cyclic voltammetry, and in the case of 2 transmittance mode UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry. Solid-state CV was performed for 1 and 2 by their encapsulation on the surface of a glassy carbon electrode using a LiClO4 intercalated polyvinylchloride (PVC) matrix.38,39 For both 1 and 2 CV studies show two reductions (Fig. S2 and Fig. 4 respectively), each assigned as a one-electron process and PDI based, given the similarity in potentials relative to L1. Hence a PDI moiety incorporated into a MOF framework of 1 and 2 retains the ability to form mono- and di-anionic species. It is notable that the first reduction process occurs at slightly less negative potentials in the case of both 1 and 2 indicating that the first reduction is energetically more favourable when the PDI is incorporated into the MOF rather than in the solution phase (Table 1). Contrastingly the second reduction occurs at very similar potentials whether in a MOF environment or in the solution phase as the free ligand. Although NDI containing MOFs have been studied by electrochemical and spectroelectrochemical methods,10,11,38–45 the study of PDI-containing MOFs remains unusual, as detailed above.
| 1st reduction | 2nd reduction | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CV, E1/2/V | SW/V | CV, E1/2/V | SW/V | ΔE1/2 | |
| L 1 | −0.91 (0.07) | −0.91 | −1.13 (0.07) | −1.13 | 0.22 |
| 1 | −0.85 | −0.86 | −1.11 | −1.13 | 0.26 |
| 2 | −0.86 | −0.86 | −1.12 | −1.14 | 0.26 |
The cyclic voltammetry for L1 in solution follows diffusion control. For solid-state 1 and 2 a different response is anticipated. If the MOF were to interact strongly with the electrode surface, for example through chemical modification, then the current would be proportional to scan rate and ΔE (= Eap − Ecp) = 0 V and a pseudo capacitive response would be observed. This is not observed for the experiments with 1 or 2. Plots of Icp or Iapversus the square root of scan rate and ΔE > 0 V might indicate that the electrochemical response has a diffusive component (Fig. 4c and d). However, unlike standard diffusion dependent solution phase behaviour, the behaviour observed for the MOFs, a ‘diffusion-like’ response, may result from either exchange-like electron hopping, as observed in high porosity MOFs featuring large apertures, or counter-ion motion.46 By comparison with the response for the Fc+/Fc couple, in solution, under these conditions, we note that ΔE (= Eap − Ecp) for the MOFs is larger, and increases with increasing scan rate suggesting that the couples all have a component of kinetic control (Fig. 4).47 It is likely that the electrochemical response results from electron transfers between PDIs located close to the surface, i.e. in close proximity to the electrode. The current response to reduction and re-oxidation appears to correlate with the square root of scan rate and this may result from slow electron hopping between PDIs separated by insulating ‘metal’ layers.48 It should be noted that the slow diffusion of electrolyte through the pores of the MOFs as a result of ionic interactions or blocked pores may also contribute to this response.38,49,50Fig. 4f shows the initial profile and the final profile of the voltammograms demonstrating a change between the initial and final experiments. We assign this difference to the material not being stabilised on the substrate at the onset of the experiment, but stability is achieved after a few cycles to produce the familiar profile of PDI-based redox processes (Fig. 4a and b).
Samples for SEC studies were grown on fluorine-doped tin oxide glass slides as thin films, using similar conditions to those used for the standard MOF synthesis. In a typical synthesis, the FTO glass slide was washed with alconox and water, then rinsed with acetone followed by ethanol. A monolayer of the carboxylic acid linker51 was prepared prior to the MOF reaction using 1 mmol of the corresponding dicarboxylate in DMF and heating in the oven at 100 °C overnight. The glass slide was then removed from the solution, rinsed briefly with DMF, and transferred into a 20 mL vial containing a stirred reaction mixture for MOF synthesis (using the same strategy as used for bulk MOF crystallisation). The vial was tightly capped and heated in the oven for 24 h. On completion of the reaction, the vial was removed from the oven and cooled to room temperature. The resulting FTO glass slide was washed with DMF to remove any unreacted starting materials and any crystals that do not adhere strongly to the surface. Further details of experimental design are described in the SI.
It should be noted that the key to a successful measurement of the SEC is formation of a uniform thin film. We were only able to achieve satisfactory sample preparation for 2, whilst 1 crystallised too quickly to produce a uniform film on the FTO substrate with large crystallites produced. Thus, our studies focussed on 2. Spectra recorded for 2 using the SEC approach (Fig. 5) resemble those of the free ligands, L1. Fortunately, the distinctive features of the spectra observed for 2 and its reduced forms fall within the limits imposed by the FTO glass substrate. The depletion of bands associated with the non-reduced PDI core in 2 to generate a mono-reduced species, (2)˙−, was the expected pathway for reduction. At the onset of reduction, bands associated with a mono-reduced PDI species were formed, visible as structured features in the 600–900 nm region (Fig. 5b, green line), as bands associated with a non-reduced PDI core, in the 450–550 nm region (Fig. 5b, black line), were depleted. As reduction proceeded, the simultaneous growth of bands associated with both mono and di-reduced PDI species (Fig. 5c) was noted, with the di-reduced PDI identified as intense features in the 500–600 nm region (Fig. 5c, red line). Bands of the mono-reduced species were then depleted in favour of bands characteristic of the di-reduced 22−, as reduction progressed toward completion (Fig. 5d, blue line). This behaviour differs from that of the PDI precursor, L1, in solution where distinct generation of mono-followed by di-reduced species was achieved (Fig. S3). Our inability to generate the spectrum of a distinct mono-reduced species may rationalize the apparent disparity in absorbance for bands of the mono- and di-reduced species in 2 compared to L1, noting that for the di-reduced MOF, 22−, the bands appear significantly more intense than those for the mono-reduced species. We hypothesise that the mono reduced species, (2)˙−, is unstable with respect to 22− and hence bands associated with this mono-reduced state are not observed in the absence of those associated with 2 or 22−. Reoxidation reverses the above sequence, with rapid loss of the di-reduced species, the growth and depletion of the mono-reduced species and finally the development of a non-reduced PDI core (Fig. 5e). The difference between the spectral profile obtained before and after the redox cycle is noteworthy (Fig. 5f); the absorbance of the bands associated with the neutral PDI core were less broad, more intense and the baseline position was lower. We interpret this as partial degradation of the film (solid sample remained on the slide following the redox cycle), noting that the electrolyte solution, initially colourless, showed an orange colouration upon completion of the experiment.
CCDC 2353806 and 2353807 contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.54a,b
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |