Matthew J. Kapelis and
Jarett Wilcoxen*
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Wisconsin- Milwaukee, Milwaukee, WI 53211, USA. E-mail: Jarettw@uwm.edu
First published on 7th August 2025
Molybdenum containing enzymes play a pivotal role in the global carbon and nitrogen cycles using a common molybdopterin cofactor. Mechanistic studies have revealed a great deal about molybdenum enzymes but have yet to detail the impact the secondary binding interactions have on catalysis. Herein, we describe a double variant of formate dehydrogenase from Cupriavidus necator (CnFds) that changes the electrostatic and hydrogen bonding to the ligands to molybdenum resulting in a complete loss of formate oxidation activity, which occurs by outer sphere hydride transfer, and gain of nitrate reduction activity, which is proposed to follow an inner sphere oxygen atom transfer mechanism. We have assigned these observed changes to the stability of the terminal ligand which in turn directs the catalytic outcome. The results here illustrate the importance of the secondary sphere interactions in directing oxygen atom transfer vs. hydride transfer mechanisms in molybdenum containing enzymes.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Proposed mechanism for NapA (top) and formate dehydrogenase (bottom). NapA catalyzes an oxygen atom transfer mechanism where nitrate displaces a bound water and oxygen from nitrate is transferred to Mo followed by reduction of Mo and protonation of the terminal oxo.21 Fdh follows a hydride transfer mechanism where the hydride is proposed to originate from the terminal sulfido ligand.19 The structure of the pyranopterin dinucleotide has been simplified to the dithiolene moiety. The full lignad is shown with an “R” group that is typically guanosine bound through the phosphate group. |
The impact of the primary and secondary coordination sphere can be highlighted by two structurally related enzymes with fundamentally different reactivities, periplasmic nitrate reductase (NapA) and formate dehydrogenase (Fdh). In general, Mo-containing enzymes typically catalyze oxygen atom transfer reactions to (or from) a variety of substrates.1 This is not the case for Fdh which catalyzes an intrinsically different reaction, reversible hydride transfer between formate and the MoPDT to yield CO2.2,16–18 The hydride transfer mechanism requires a terminal sulfido in place of the terminal oxo typically found in the Mo coordination sphere DMSOR family, Fig. 1.19,20 In contrast to the generally agreed upon mechanism and coordination sphere of Mo in Fdh, there has been considerable debate over the primary coordination environment and mechanism of NapA. Recent efforts investigating NapA from Campylobacter jejuni using a variety of spectroscopic and kinetic techniques have demonstrated a terminal oxo is found in the functional enzyme.21–24 This difference in the terminal ligand, sulfido in the case of Fdh and oxo in the case of NapA, is likely a key feature that facilitates the very different reactivates observed in the respective enzymes.
Despite the different chemistries catalyzed by NapA and Fdh, the enzymes share a superimposable protein structure, Fig. SI1, a conserved [Fe4S4] cluster adjacent to the MoPDT, and share a nearly identical binding pocket for the MoPDT that includes many highly conserved residues that include hydrogen bond donors and acceptors, and aromatic π-stacking to the PDT ligands.25,26 While not a substrate for Fdh, nitrate is commonly used as a protectant during purification to limit the inactivating effect of oxygen on the active site.27 Nitrate, which is also a competitive inhibitor during formate oxidation, is thought to bind near the Mo center limiting oxygen access.28 Phylogenetically, NapA is described as more closely related to formate dehydrogenase and arsenite oxidase than other DMSOR family members.29 Recent work investigating variants to a conserved lysine in both NapA and Fdh impairs or inhibits catalysis depending on the variant.22,30 The lysine hydrogen bonds one of the two pyranopterins and a conserved [Fe4S4] cluster that shuttles electrons to or from the MoPDT in both enzymes and is thought to affect the electron transfer between the two cofactors in a similar way. These similarities highlight that it is subtle differences between the two enzymes that stabilize a differentiated terminal ligand and the intrinsic mechanism catalyzed by these two enzymes.
Previous investigations of the residues in the secondary coordination sphere of Fdh from Rhodobacter capsulatus (RcFdsDABG) identified three residues: His387Met, Arg597Thr, and a deletion of Arg597 that were able to impart nitrate reductase activity to RcFdsDABG when changed to the corresponding residues in NapA.25 His387 is likely to be involved in hydrogen bonding interactions with the Cys ligated to Mo, Fig. 2. Arg587 and Arg597 are located further away near the substrate access tunnel and likely orient the substrate or participate in transition state stabilization. Unfortunately, these variants also retained formate dehydrogenase activity resulting in an unclear model for what drives the stability of the terminal ligand (oxo or sulfido) that is necessary to drive the different reactivities. Here, we describe a double variant of formate dehydrogenase from Cupriavidus necator (CnFdsDABG) which changes the intrinsic reactivity from a formate oxidation to a nitrate reduction with complete loss of detectable formate oxidation activity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Active site of RcFdsA (PDB: 6TGA) in orange and NapA (PDB: 3ML1) in gray highlighting residues in this study. The residues are within hydrogen bonding distance of the ligating Cys (His and Met in FdsA and NapA respectively) or the thiol in the ligating proximal dithiolene (Asn and His in FdsA and NapA respectively). The structures were aligned in Pymol according to sequence and fold which resulted in with overlapping MoPDT, only the MoPDT from NapA is shown for clarity. Distances between residues and coordinating sulfurs are in angstroms. |
While the secondary structure of NapA and Fdh are highly conserved there are a few residues that differ between Fdh and NapA but remain conserved within the two enzyme types. One of the residues discussed above, the His proximal to the ligating cysteine is highly conserved in Fdh while this residue is a highly conserved methionine in NapA, Fig. 2 and Fig. SI2. In CnFdsDABG, His379 (equivalent to His387 in R. capsulatus) makes a hydrogen bond with the ligating Cys while the lone pair on the sulfur of the conserved Met of NapA points toward the cysteine sulfur in an electrostatic interaction, Fig. 2. A second residue that is highly conserved in NapA is a His that hydrogen bonds with one of the ligating dithiolene sulfurs of the proximal pyranopterin (relative to the conserved [Fe4S4] cluster), Fig. 2. In Fdh, the interacting residue is not strictly conserved but tends to be polar (glutamine, serine, or asparagine), suggesting an electrostatic interaction, likely from the ketone or alcohol oxygen of the residue. When both His379 and Asn827 in the FdsA subunit of CnFdsDABG are changed to Met and His respectively, as is found in NapA, the enzyme loses its ability to oxidize formate with no apparent reaction when using NAD+, benzyl viologen, or methyl viologen as an electron acceptor monitoring the reduction of the electron acceptors over several hours. Conversely, the enzyme is active in nitrate reduction when using methyl viologen cation radical (MV) as an electron donor. Steady-state assays monitoring the observed rate of MV oxidation against nitrate concentration can be fit with the Michaelis–Menten equation to yield a turnover rate (kcat) of 0.68 s−1 and Michaelis constant (Km) of 1.57 mM, Fig. 3. The reaction rate varies slightly with pH with a maximum near pH 8, similar to the optimum Fdhs and NapA, SI Fig. 3. We note dithionite (reduction potential of ∼−400 to −600 mV) can act as an electron donor with a turnover rate monitoring the bleaching of the dithionite absorbance at 314 nm that is similar to MV (−446 mV) while assays monitoring the consumption of NADH (−320 mV) are active but ∼10× slower.31 Next, considering nitrate is an effective inhibitor in the wild-type enzyme against formate oxidation, we examined if formate could act as an inhibitor to the reduction of nitrate by varying the concentration of formate and nitrate. While we observe no significant effect on the overall rate with increasing formate concentrations, we observe a more pronounced impact on the Km for nitrate which decreases in the presence of formate, Fig. 3, to approximately 0.3 mM suggesting cooperative binding. Further investigations to clarify the role of formate in this mechanism are ongoing.
As discussed above, previous investigations of the residues in the secondary coordination sphere of RcFdsDABG identified three residues (H387M, R587T, and a deletion of Arg597) that were able to impart nitrate reductase activity when changed to the corresponding residues in NapA.25 The turnover rates (kcat) of these individual and combination variants ranged from 0.06 min−1 (0.001 s−1) in the case of H387M to 2.23 min−1 (0.037 s−1) for the R587T/R-597* variant. These variants also retained significant formate dehydrogenase activity with rates that approximated the wild-type in the case of the H387M variant. It was noted that desulfo RcFdsDABG, which has a terminal oxo in place of the terminal sulfido required for the hydride transfer during formate oxidation, is active to nitrate reduction at a rate of 0.31 min−1 (0.005 s−1). We investigated the CnFdsDABG for nitrate reductase activity in the as-purified enzyme and do indeed detect trace activity that varies on the enzyme purification, consistent with what was observed in the RcFdsDABG homolog. Under the proposed nitrate reductase mechanism, a terminal oxo is required for catalysis, not the terminal sulfido present in the wild-type enzyme. To remove the terminal sulfido we incubated the wild-type enzyme with KCN which is known to remove the terminal sulfido to yield a terminal oxo, similar to the primary coordination sphere of nitrate reductase.17,27,32 Following inactivation with 2 mM KCN for two hours, we observe a loss of formate dehydrogenase activity, but gain significant nitrate reductase activity compared to the inactivated RcFdsDABG at a rate of 0.41 s−1. This suggests that indeed the oxo, and not sulfido, form of the enzyme is needed to reduce nitrate. We attribute the varying trace nitrate reductase activity in the as-purified enzyme to some population of the desulfo enzyme, inactivated by air.27 While the wild-type enzyme requires KCN inactivation to gain nitrate reductase activity, we observe no change in the rates of the H379M/N827H double variant suggesting the terminal ligand is present as an oxo upon purification of the double variant enzyme. We note the expression vector used here for the wild-type and double variant are the same, both possessing FdsC which sulfurates the Mo prior to the cofactor insertion into the enzyme suggesting the double variant is intrinsically less stable at the terminal ligand site and prone to exchange with water.
Our working model to rationalize these observed changes, keeping the respective proposed mechanisms for formate oxidation or nitrate reduction in mind, is that the residues highlighted here serve an important role in the stability of the terminal ligand and the resulting mechanism the enzyme facilitates, Fig. 4. We propose that the residues under investigation act as modulators to sulfur ligands of Mo. By changing the hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions we envision a pseudo-Jahn Teller effect where shortening of the sulfur bonds (increased bonding character) of the cysteine thiol and one of the PDT thiols, which happen to be roughly trans from each other in the Mo coordination sphere would then weaken the bonding interaction of the terminal ligand allowing for displacement during the oxygen atom transfer reaction that takes place for nitrate reduction. Conversely, in wild-type Fdh, the hydrogen bonding interactions allow for a more stable bonding interaction with the terminal ligand which is necessary to stabilize the terminal sulfur required for formate oxidation and CO2 reduction via outer sphere hydride transfer.
To summarize, we have identified two key residues that work synergistically to direct the catalytic outcome in two highly similar molybdenum enzymes, NapA and Fdh. The double variant removes the ability of Fdh to catalyze the oxidation of formate by hydride transfer and allows for nitrate reduction by oxygen atom transfer. The oxygen atom transfer mechanism in all Mo-containing enzymes requires substrate to displace a terminal water ligand at Mo. We propose these residues impact the lability of the terminal ligand to Mo thus shifting catalysis from the outer sphere native hydride transfer to inner sphere oxygen atom transfer. Our results here highlight the importance of secondary sphere, non-covalent, interactions in tuning the MoPDT to accommodate the impressive substrate scope of Mo-containing enzymes and the intrinsic activity (oxygen atom transfer vs. hydride transfer) of the enzyme.
SI includes structural and sequence comaprisons of NapA and Fdh homologs, pH dependence of the steady state kinetics, and sequence information of the expression vector. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5dt01559f.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |