Jingcheng
Zhao
ab,
Mengqi
Cao
ab,
Yulu
Liu
ab,
Panpan
Wang
ab,
Xiaofu
Wu
a,
Hui
Tong
*ab and
Lixiang
Wang
*ab
aState Key Laboratory of Polymer Science and Technology, Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun, 130022, China. E-mail: chemtonghui@ciac.ac.cn
bUniversity of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, 230026, China
First published on 22nd August 2025
Polymerized small molecular acceptors (PSMAs) now represent a class of promising organic photocatalysts for efficient photocatalytic hydrogen evolution due to their outstanding visible and near-infrared (NIR) light absorption. Although the isomerization strategy has been recognized as a simple yet effective method to modulate photovoltaic properties of PSMAs, the effects of isomerization on the performance of photocatalytic hydrogen evolution have never been reported so far. Herein, two isomeric thiophene-fused electron-withdrawing end groups with different fused sites are applied to construct isomeric PSMAs without π-linking units, namely PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN. Despite possessing identical molecular formulas, their π-conjugation and charge distribution are highly sensitive to the substitution patterns of thiophene-fused terminal units. Combined with experimental analysis and theoretical calculation, PY-α-CPTCN exhibits more efficient light absorption and charge transport than that of PY-β-CPTCN, ascribed to its stronger intramolecular π-conjugation effect. The resulting photocatalyst based on PY-α-CPTCN displays an average hydrogen evolution rate of 252.2 mmol g−1 h−1 under AM 1.5 G sunlight (100 mW cm−2), which is 3.2 times higher than that of PY-β-CPTCN with 79.7 mmol g−1 h−1. These results not only reveal the isomerization strategy as an effective method for the design of high-performance PSMA-based photocatalysts, but also emphasize the relevance between the intramolecular π-conjugation and photocatalytic properties.
Overcoming the current bottleneck in photocatalytic water splitting systems requires optimizing light harvesting across the visible and near-infrared (NIR) spectral regions, which constitute approximately 70% of the solar spectrum.14 Organic semiconductors have extended π-conjugation and tunable donor–acceptor (D–A) configurations, which can modulate optical absorption properties efficiently.15,16 From this perspective, polymerized small-molecule acceptors (PSMAs) are highly competitive candidate materials in application of photocatalytic hydrogen evolution. PSMAs integrate π-conjugated main chains and multiple intramolecular D–A interactions, exhibiting outstanding performance in visible and NIR light-driven photocatalytic hydrogen evolution. For instance, Chou et al. reported that PSMA-based photocatalysts could broaden light absorption in the NIR region while maintaining efficient charge separation via regulating π-linkers between the small-molecule acceptors (SMAs) to achieve a high-performance photocatalytic reaction.17 Recently, we synthesized a series of PSMA-based photocatalysts featuring varied π-linker lengths (thiophene, bithiophene, and terthiophene) and found that increasing the number of thiophene units can modulate the intramolecular charge transfer, which is a key factor for governing photocatalytic hydrogen evolution performance.18 Overall, most of the research about PSMA-based photocatalysts primarily focuses on designing π-linker units and investigating their linker-dependent photocatalytic activity. Compared with PSMAs with π-linkers, simple PSMAs without π-linkers can reflect the role of SMA units in PSMAs more intuitively, which helps to understand the influence of intramolecular charge transfer and π-conjugation effect of SMA units on the intrinsic properties of PSMAs. However, the relationship between the structure and the photocatalytic performance of PSMAs without any linking units remains inadequately explored so far.
The electron-withdrawing end groups of SMAs play a crucial role in determining their electron affinity, light absorption, energy levels and intermolecular interactions.19,20 Phenyl- or thienyl-fused end groups with bromine atoms on benzene or thiophene rings are frequently employed in the construction of PSMAs.21,22 Compared to the phenyl-fused end groups in PSMAs, thienyl-fused end groups can reduce steric hindrance, leading to enhanced electron delocalization and intermolecular interactions for PSMAs. Among various strategies for modulating end groups, the isomerization of end groups is convenient and popular in the development of PSMAs for efficient all-polymer solar cells.23,24 Altering the spatial arrangements or linking positions within the homologous molecular skeleton significantly influences the molecular orbital distribution, thereby exerting substantial effects on the intrinsic electronic structures and intermolecular interactions. Specifically, the unique regio-isomeric phenomenon was often presented by the non-centrosymmetric thiophene rings due to the substitution-pattern and fused-site sensitivity, stemming from the high electron density and polarization on the sulfur atom.25–27 The effect of isomeric thienyl-fused end groups of PSMAs has been demonstrated to regulate the photovoltaic performance efficiently, however, such an effect in photocatalytic hydrogen evolution has never been explored until now.28–31
In this context, two PSMAs without a π-linker unit (namely, PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN) based on two isomeric SMAs featuring different thienyl-fused end groups are designed and synthesized, which offer an opportunity to study systematically and gain a deep insight into the roles of isomeric PSMAs in photocatalytic hydrogen evolution for the first time. As revealed by experimental results and theoretical calculation, although PY-β-CPTCN possesses a more rigid and planar molecular backbone, PY-α-CPTCN exhibits more delocalized and efficient intramolecular π-conjugation, leading to its improved light absorption and charge transport. In the photocatalytic experiment, the average hydrogen evolution rate (HER) of the PY-α-CPTCN photocatalyst is up to 252.2 mmol g−1 h−1 under simulated sunlight irradiation, while the HER of the PY-β-CPTCN catalyst is only 79.7 mmol g−1 h−1. This work highlights the effectiveness of the isomerization strategy in the design of PSMA-type photocatalysts.
The UV-vis absorption spectra of the two PSMAs were surveyed in dilute solution and nanoparticle aqueous dispersion to investigate their photophysical characteristics (Fig. 1b, c and Table S1). As shown in Fig. 1b, the solution absorption maxima (λmax) are located at 742 nm for PY-α-CPTCN and 760 nm for PY-β-CPTCN. PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN exhibit absorption onsets at 806 nm and 802 nm, corresponding to the optical band gaps of 1.54 eV and 1.55 eV, respectively. It is observed that the absorption spectra of their nanoparticle aqueous dispersions afford some changes in water when these PSMAs are blended with sodium 2-(3-thienyl)ethyloxybutylsulfonate (TEBS) (Fig. 1c). The absorption peak of PY-α-CPTCN NPs is located at 688 nm with a low-energy absorption at 744 nm, while PY-β-CPTCN NPs maintains the low-energy absorption peak at 742 nm. Moreover, the values of full width at half maximum (FHWM) at the strongest absorption band were measured to be 210 nm for PY-α-CPTCN NPs and 129 nm for PY-β-CPTCN NPs (Table S1), suggesting that PY-α-CPTCN NPs hold a broader absorption band in both visible and near-infrared regions. It is also clearly shown in Fig. 1c that the absorbance of PY-α-CPTCN NPs is integrally higher than that of PY-β-CPTCN NPs at the same concentration. The highest maximum extinction coefficients are 7.6 × 104 g−1 cm−1 for PY-α-CPTCN NPs and 5.4 × 104 g−1 cm−1 for PY-β-CPTCN NPs, respectively. Compared to the absorption spectra of PSMAs in chloroform solution, the PSMA nanoparticles in aqueous dispersion exhibit shifted absorption peaks with enhanced shoulder peaks, which may be attributed to changes in intermolecular aggregation originating from alterations in the solvent environment as well as the interactions between PMSAs and the stabilizing surfactant. In principle, the improved light absorption capacities of PY-α-CPTCN in both solution and NP states indicate its greater potential in photocatalytic hydrogen evolution.
Cryo-transmission electron microscopy (Cryo-TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) imaging of PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN NPs provide similar morphology with the particle size ranging from 10 to 110 nm (Fig. S4a, b and S5). The hydrodynamic diameter of nanoparticles was measured by dynamic light scattering (DLS), and the peak values of the Z-average particle size were estimated to be 78.8 nm for PY-α-CPTCN NPs and 91.3 nm for PY-β-CPTCN NPs (Fig. S6a). The zeta-potentials of PY-α-CPTCN NPs and PY-β-CPTCN NPs are −32.3 mV and −31.2 mV, thereby ensuring their good dispersity in water. As shown in Fig. S4c and d, the Pt-cocatalyst was deposited on the surface of nanoparticles as small dark particles with almost uniform particle size. The hydrophobic property of these PSMAs results in weak interactions between the photocatalysts and water molecules. The Pt particles on the nanoparticle surface may not only trap electrons from the light harvesting in PSMAs, but also provide the effective catalytic proton reduction sites. Interestingly, the Pt-particles were distributed evenly on the PY-α-CPTCN NPs, while uneven and patchy distribution of Pt-particles on the surface of PY-β-CPTCN NPs was observed. Considering the same nucleation and growth mechanism, the different morphology of Pt-particle deposition may also reflect that the PSMA phases exposed on the surface of PY-α-CPTCN NPs and PY-β-CPTCN NPs are different.36
To evaluate the catalytic activity, photocatalytic hydrogen evolution experiments of PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN photocatalysts were conducted initially under simulated sunlight irradiation (AM 1.5G, 100 mW cm−2). In a typical photocatalytic process, the reaction medium consisted of 50 mL water with 0.2 M sacrificial electron donor (ascorbic acid). As shown in Fig. S8, the PY-α-CPTCN catalyst demonstrates better photocatalytic performance as expected. And there is no doubt that the contents of surfactant, photo-deposited Pt and nanoparticles of the sample have great impacts on the catalytic activity (Fig. S9–S11). Under optimized conditions of 0.1 wt% TEBS and 30 wt% Pt ratio loadings, the PY-α-CPTCN catalyst provides an average HER of 252.2 mmol g−1 h−1, which is 3.2 times higher than that of the PY-β-CPTCN catalyst (79.7 mmol g−1 h−1) (Fig. 2a). As shown in Fig. 2b, the absolute HER is initially elevated when increasing the catalyst mass, and reaches 174.0 μmol h−1 by using 1 mg PY-α-CPTCN NPs (20 μg mL−1). However, a further increase of catalyst mass diminishes photocatalytic performance owing to the almost saturated light absorption and increased scattering.37 As shown in Fig. S12, the apparent quantum yields (AQYs) of PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN catalysts were investigated under monochromatic incident light. The measured values of the PY-α-CPTCN catalyst comprehensively surpass those of the PY-β-CPTCN catalyst, further confirming its superior photocatalytic hydrogen evolution capability. Moreover, the PY-α-CPTCN catalyst maintains exceptional stability, showing negligible activity loss over six consecutive photocatalytic cycles (Fig. 2c), and its stable nanostructure could still be demonstrated by DLS even after prolonged reaction periods (Fig. S6b).
Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was conducted to estimate the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) energy levels of the two PSMAs. As shown in Fig. 3a, the HOMO/LUMO levels of PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN were calculated to be −5.69/−3.83 eV and −5.77/−3.86 eV by analyzing their oxidation and reduction potentials (Fig. S13), confirming the ability of electron transfer between the PSMAs and co-catalyst. Their photoelectrochemical properties were evaluated by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and transient photocurrent measurements. As shown in Fig. 3b, PY-α-CPTCN has a smaller semicircle radius than PY-β-CPTCN in the EIS spectra, indicating a lower charge transfer resistance in PY-α-CPTCN. As proof, the PY-α-CPTCN photoelectrode exhibits a higher photocurrent response upon periodically switching the photoirradiation on and off, which is attributed its better exciton dissociation and charge transport (Fig. 3c). In addition, time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) spectra were obtained to estimated their fluorescence lifetimes. As shown in Fig. 3d, the PL decay profiles indicate that the average fluorescence lifetimes of PY-α-CPTCN NPs (1.00 ns) and PY-β-CPTCN NPs (0.81 ns) are comparable. Furthermore, the steady-state photoluminescence (PL) spectra (Fig. S14) demonstrate comparable emission intensities for both PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN NPs, indicating their similar radiative recombination characteristics. Consequently, the enhanced photocatalytic hydrogen evolution efficiency of PY-α-CPTCN is likely to be attributable to its superior light absorption capacity and charge transport properties.
To gain an in-depth understanding of the substantial difference between PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN, density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations are performed. The calculated HOMO/LUMO levels are −5.68/−3.66 eV and −5.73/−3.70 eV for PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN, respectively (Table S1), which are consistent with the experimental results. Furthermore, the oscillator strengths (f) of S0 → S1 transition were estimated to be 3.08 for PY-α-CPTCN and 2.59 for PY-β-CPTCN. These results are responsible for the stronger absorption of PY-α-CPTCN in the low-energy region. The potential energy surface scans of the model of end groups reveal that the adjacent end groups in PY-α-CPTCN have a lower rotational barrier and energy difference (ΔE) between the most stable and unstable form than those in PY-β-CPTCN, which makes the backbone of PY-α-CPTCN rotate more easily (Fig. S15). The large rotational barrier and ΔE of PY-β-CPTCN may be attributed to intramolecular hydrogen bonds between the O atom on the carbonyl group and the α-H atom on the thiophene of adjacent terminal units and steric constraints imposed by adjacent rigid fused rings.38,39 According to the optimized molecular geometries shown in Fig. S16, the dihedral angles between the adjacent CPTCN units in PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN are calculated to be 14.52° and 1.58°, respectively. The smaller rotational barrier and the more twisted conformation of PY-α-CPTCN may foster energetic disorder, contributing to its broader absorption spectrum compared to PY-β-CPTCN.40 Their frontier molecular orbital (FMO) distributions were further visualized by using Multiwfn and VMD software.41,42 As shown in Fig. 4a and b, PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN both exhibit delocalized HOMO/LUMO distributions along the π-conjugated chains. Their HOMO distributions are mainly located on the fused-ring cores of SMA fragments and display similar patterns. However, the LUMO distributions are presented with different π-conjugation extension on the joint of two isomeric terminal units. PY-α-CPTCN holds a continuous π-bonding character between the two C atoms, ensuring the effective π-conjugation within the skeleton. Although PY-β-CPTCN also exhibits a delocalized LUMO orbital, the β-substituted pattern noticeably decreases the π-bonding character on the linked bond.43 Moreover, the delocalization of electrons could be intuitively observed by electron localization function (ELF) (Fig. 4c and d).44 It is evaluated by the equivalent surface surrounded by the iso-surface which decreases as the iso-value increases. At the joint of two CPTCN units, PY-α-CPTCN holds a continuous π-conjugation iso-surface until the iso-value is increased to 0.52, while the π-conjugation of PY-β-CPTCN was interrupted at the iso-value of 0.42. Thus, PY-α-CPTCN has stronger intramolecular π-conjugation effect than PY-β-CPTCN, which not only is consistent with the stronger and red-shifted absorption of PY-α-CPTCN, but also may facilitate more efficient charge transport.45–48
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a and b) Frontier molecular orbital (FMO) distributions and (c and d) electron localization function (ELF) iso-values of PY-α-CPTCN and PY-β-CPTCN. |
Based on the above results, the mechanism of PSMA-based photocatalytic systems could be proposed. During the process of light absorption, the electrons in PSMAs were excited to generate electron–hole pairs. The enhanced π-conjugation effect of PY-α-CPTCN, combined with the pull–push electronic interaction between donor and acceptor units, facilitates the efficient intramolecular charge delocalization and separation, underpinning its exceptional optoelectronic properties. When these photogenerated species migrate to the surface of NPs, the excited electrons would transfer to the cocatalyst Pt, and the holes were consumed by ascorbic acid to reduce the recombination of the electron–hole pairs. Finally, the H2 evolution reaction was accomplished on the active catalytic sites which was afforded by the electron sink Pt.49–51
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reason able request
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |