Jingwei
Lv
a,
Jianxin
Wang
a,
Lin
Yang
a,
Wei
Liu
a,
Haihao
Fu
a,
Paul K.
Chu
b and
Chao
Liu
*a
aSchool of Physics and Electronic Engineering, Northeast Petroleum University, Daqing 163318, P.R. China. E-mail: msm-liu@126.com; liuchao@nepu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Physics, Department of Materials Science & Engineering, and Department of Biomedical Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China
First published on 8th June 2024
Optical fiber biosensors based on the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) phenomenon are generating increasing interest due to their capability of real-time monitoring of analytes in a biocompatible, label-free, stable, and cost-effective manner. In fact, SPR optical fiber biosensors are becoming very popular in environmental science, clinical diagnosis, disease detection, and food safety. This review provides a comprehensive overview of optical fiber biosensors that utilize SPR. The principles and recent developments of optical fiber sensors are described. Different SPR optical fiber biosensors, including traditional optical fiber SPR biosensors, microstructured optical fiber (MOF) biosensors, grating-assisted plasmon fiber SPR biosensors, and others, are reviewed and the capabilities of common biosensors are compared. This overview aims to provide guidance for future research and development of this important and burgeoning field.
Recently, optical fiber sensing technology has gained attention in biosensing due to distinctive features such as high sensitivity, fast detection speed, non-destructive detection, and immunity to electromagnetic interference.4 Optical fiber biosensors typically utilize sensing and biorecognition elements to achieve biological detection.5–7 They have diverse structures, including unclad and etched fibers,8,9 tapered and polished fibers,10,11 D-type fibers,12–14 photonic crystal fibers,15–17 fiber Bragg gratings (FBGs),18,19 and so on. Sensing is accomplished by generating a signal related to the analyte, for instance, refractive index (RI), intensity, amplitude, and phase.20,21 The biorecognition elements, which are the key components, are usually antigens, antibodies, enzymes, microorganisms, nucleic acids, and whole cells, which can recognize and bind to target molecules with high sensitivity and specificity.22–25 As a specific type of optical sensor, plasmonic sensors boast high sensitivity and multiplexing capacity while not requiring expensive equipment. Therefore, several types of plasmonic sensors based on (localized) surface plasmon resonance (LSPR, SPR),26,27 long-range surface plasmon polariton (LRSPP),28,29 and surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)30,31 have been developed. Among them, optical fiber biosensors based on SPR are particularly attractive due to their large commercial potential in chemistry, life sciences, and other fields.32,33
There have been a number of studies on SPR fiber biosensors.34–36 Fiber-optic SPR sensors, created using various post-processing techniques, combine the miniaturization and interference resistance of optical fibers with the high sensitivity and specificity of SPR technology. These sensors are applied in areas such as protein–protein,37,38 protein–DNA,39–41 and protein–small molecule drug42,43 interactions, clinical biomarker monitoring, and microorganism detection. For example, Zhang et al. have designed an SPR biosensor to detect DNA hybridization. The biosensor consists of a graphene/gold film (G/Au) on a D-shape plastic optical fiber (D-POF).44 Luo et al. have coated Au nanoparticles on Staphylococcal protein A to augment the affinity of anti-NDV monoclonal antibodies toward NDV.45 Lee et al. have proposed an LSPR biosensor prepared by side polishing and coating with ochratoxin A (OTA) aptamer, which is capable of detecting OTA with a low detection limit and high selectivity.46 The integration of SPR with optical fiber sensing has spurred the development of biosensing. In spite of their unique merits, optical fiber-based biosensors are still not widely accepted commercially due to some practical obstacles. Fortunately, recent advancements in optical fiber biosensors have overcome some of these constraints rendering the technology practical and competitive.
In this review, we first summarize the recent progress of optical fiber-based SPR biosensors as illustrated in Fig. 1. The sensing principles of optical fiber-based SPR sensors are introduced, and different optical fiber-based SPR biosensors are described. Finally, the present challenges and prospects are discussed.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Overview of optical fiber-based SPR biosensors. (a) Biorecognition elements, (b) optical fiber sensing mechanism, and (c) different optical fiber-based SPR biosensors. |
When light diffuses to the boundary between the prism and metal, the evanescent wave (EW) generated by the incident light at the prism–metal interface excites the surface plasmon wave (SPW) at the metal–dielectric interface.49 Owing to the gradual attenuation of the SPW propagating along the interface, the light intensity at the resonance angle or the resonance wavelength position corresponding to the matched wavevector in the total reflected light increases significantly. This phenomenon leads to the appearance of SPR resonance peaks in the reflection spectrum. The SPW propagating at the interface of a dielectric film and metal film has a propagation constant (ksp) that can be defined as:50
![]() | (1) |
In 1993, Jorgensen et al. introduced the concept of optical fiber SPR sensing.52 By removing a part of the fiber cladding, the SPR effect is observed by depositing a gold coating onto the surface of the bare fiber core with silica normally being the bulk material. Since then, various fibre post-processing techniques including bending, polishing, etching, taper stretching, periodic gratings and MOFs have been developed over the last 30 years to improve the performance of fibre optic SPR biosensors. The fundamental optical fiber sensor comprises a light source, sensing element, and spectrometer. Similar to prismatic SPR sensors, the design of the optical fiber sensing element must allow a portion of light in the fiber core to leak to the metal surface to couple with the plasmonic modes, as shown in Fig. 3. Changes in RI monitored by the sensor are translated into changes in analyte concentration by analysing the LOSS spectrum. This is followed by a review of multiple classes of fiber optic sensors, including a comparison of table-based designs and response characteristics.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Schematic diagram showing the interactions between the plasmonic optical fiber biosensor and external analyte. |
An optical fiber SPR immunosensor functionalized with MoS2 nanosheets has been proposed for the detection of Escherichia coli (E. coli) down to 94 CFU mL−1 by Kaushik et al., as shown in Fig. 5(a).55 Polychromatic unpolarized light is used as a light source, and the dark and blank reference readings are noted to eliminate noise. Fig. 5(b) shows the UV-vis absorption spectra of the exfoliated MoS2 nanosheets to provide complementary information on the different vibration transitions and vibrational bands. As shown in Fig. 5(c), 2D contact-mode atomic force microscopy (AFM) is employed to determine the MoS2 nanosheet thickness and homogeneity. Graphene is frequently used to enhance the sensing properties due to its optical transparency, low resistance, high carrier mobility, and tunability.56 Hossain et al. have proposed a graphene-coated optical fiber SPR biosensor for breast cancer biomarker detection, and the sensing properties with and without graphene are compared.57 Both experimental results show that the high refractive index of the functionalized nanosheets can increase the electric field strength of SPR and improve the refractive index sensitivity of the sensors, and that the large surface area can increase the binding density of antibodies and improve the specific recognition ability. However, the fabrication process and cost of 2D materials limit the large-scale application of this type of SPR sensor.
Wei Peng et al. used block copolymer (BCP)-templated AuNR membranes on the surface of optical fibres to prepare LSPR biosensors for highly sensitive IgG antigen–antibody detection, as shown in Fig. 6(a).58Fig. 6(b) and (c) demonstrate the ability of different aspect ratios of AuNRs for antigen–antibody detection with excellent spectral characteristics, higher RI sensitivity and lower biosensing LOD compared to PS-b-PAA templated CTAB-AuNR membranes. In addition, the different aspect ratios brought about the ability to vary the detection range, and the LSPR sensing wavelength can be 650 to 900 nm, which is promising for applications in real-time biosensing without cytotoxicity.
In 2023, Dillen et al. reported a very interesting work on cis-duplexed aptamers (DAs) realised on FO-SPR sensors, where spatial position reconstruction of Au-NPs occurs upon target binding, as shown in Fig. 7(a).59 It was expected that when the resonance conditions of the surface plasmons (SPs) on the FO-SPR sensor match those on the AuNPs, the SPs will couple and generate an enhanced signal that decays with the distance between the AuNPs and the gold film on the nm scale. The results show that the sensor is capable of specific quantitative detection of ssDNA targets with a detection limit of 230 nM and high reversibility. As shown in Fig. 7(b), by placing the sensor in repeated cycles at 95 °C and 25 °C, cis-DAs switches between “proximal” and “distal” states over multiple cycles. This avoids the need for complex steps to obtain a reversible signal.
Q. Wang et al. have fabricated an SPR immunosensor composed of graphene oxide (GO) and staphylococcal protein A (SPA) co-modified photonic crystal fibers.62 The sensor is made by splicing a segment of the photonic crystal fiber between two segments of multimode fiber as shown in Fig. 9(a) and the detection system is depicted in Fig. 9(b). The wavelength response to human IgG at a concentration of 30 μg mL−1 is presented in Fig. 9(c), and the human IgG detection limit is 10 ng mL−1. The sensitivities of the sensors without GO and SPA modifications were compared in the experiments, and the results showed a 30-fold difference in their detection limits.
Hetero-core optical fiber probes are used as the recognition elements in biosensing. Santosh Kumar et al. have proposed the MoS2-functionalized multicore fiber probes for selective detection of Shigella bacteria.63 As shown in Fig. 10(a), light from the tungsten-halogen source is launched at the 1st end of the bifurcated cable and coupled with the sensing probes through an adapter connected to the 2nd end of the bifurcated cable. Light interacts with the functionalized probe and the reflected light from the tip of the sensor goes to the spectrometer through the 3rd end of the bifurcated cable. The investigation of NPs is performed by measuring the dependence between the absorbance spectrum and wavelength, as shown in Fig. 10(b). The peak wavelengths of the synthesized AuNPs and MoS2-NPs are 519 nm and 330 nm, respectively.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (a) Experimental setup for the detection of Shigella bacteria and (b) UV-vis spectra of the AuNPs, and (c) MoS2-NPs solutions and corresponding photographs. |
The experimental results showed that multi-core fiber-optic excitation of LSPR with specific probe-modified nanostructures obtained a LOD as low as 1.56 CFU mL−1 against Shigella bacteria. The results show that the sensing structure of heterocore optical fibres can be improved in terms of sensitivity by increasing the polishing angle of the fibre or the refractive index of the medium, and that the partially probed sensor design is more practical for application. However, it is noted that higher processing accuracy poses limitations on further improvement of sensing sensitivity, and multiple fusion splices are not conducive to large-scale fabrication.
In addition to metals such as gold and silver, other materials are also used as the sensitive layers in side-polished fiber sensors. An SPR biosensor based on the D-type optical fiber coated with the Al2O3/Ag/Al2O3 film has been investigated numerically by Du et al.,66 and the performance pertaining to gas and aqueous sensing is analyzed and compared. The transmission spectra for different Al2O3 thicknesses are shown in Fig. 11(a). Cennamo et al. have proposed a D-shape plastic optical fiber aptasensor for the detection of thrombin which is a clinical marker of the blood coagulation cascade and homeostasis,67 as shown in Fig. 11(b). Detection can be accomplished in a short time (5–10 min) and the detection limit is about 1 nM in the range of 1.6–60 nM. The relationship between the resonance wavelength and normalized transmitted light in Fig. 11(c) shows that while THR with increasing concentration comes into contact with the nonspecific aptamer sequence, the resonance wavelength exhibits a bathochromic shift.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 (a) Transmission spectra of the SPR sensor with different Al2O3 thicknesses, (b) functionalization process,66 and (c) SPR transmission spectra for different concentrations of thrombin (1–80 nM). |
Xu et al. have presented an Au-graphene structure D-type fiber surface plasmon resonance biosensor to detect the nucleotide bonding between the double-stranded DNA helix structures.68 To produce the structure, graphene is placed on copper. A gold layer with the optimal thickness is deposited by sputtering and the copper foil is etched to produce the structure. The transmission spectra are displayed in Fig. 12(a) and the fabrication process is illustrated in Fig. 12(b). R. Zakaria et al. have proposed an optical fiber sensor utilizing the single mode and incorporating MgF2 as the sensing medium together with silver and gold.69 The mode field distributions (core mode, coupling mode, and SPP mode) are shown in Fig. 12(c). The x and y polarizing sensitivities of the sensor for Ag in Fig. 10d show that they vary from 5.34 × 103 nm per RIU−1 to 8.34 × 103 nm per RIU−1 and the sensitivity in the Y direction is higher.
![]() | ||
Fig. 12 (a) Transmission spectra, (b) fabrication process, (c) mode field distributions for Ag, and (d) sensitivities of the combined models. |
In addition to conventional SPR (cSPR) sensors, long-range surface plasmon resonance (LRSPR) D-type sensors deliver good sensing performance. Cheng et al. have proposed a side-polished fiber LRSPR biosensor with Au nanoshells to detect human immunoglobulin G (hIgG).28 The results of Au nanoshell modification and simulation by the finite element analysis (FEA) are shown in Fig. 13(a) and (b), respectively. The study reveals that the interactions between the Au nanoshells and Au film, known as the plasmonic coupling effect, may amplify the electric field intensity on the sensor surface. This enhancement increases the sensitivity and yields lower detection limits of 1.84 nm/(μg mL−1) and 0.20 μg mL−1. The experimental results for hIgG detection by the LRSPR sensor and Au-nanoshell-modified LRSPR sensor are shown in Fig. 13c and d.
Compared to the heterocore structure, the D-shape fiber structure simplifies sensor fabrication and eliminates the need for complex preparation processes or special handling techniques, which reduces the experimental cost and increases the popularity of applications. Moreover, through the modification of multilayer plasma films or nanostructures, it is possible to selectively excite LSPR and LRSPR, potentially achieving both high sensitivity and low LOD for biosensing.
The effects of different sensing materials have been studied, and the influence of the structural parameters, such as the taper ratio and taper profile, on the sensing properties has been investigated. Many tapered optical fibers have been applied to biosensing due to the enhanced sensitivity. Cennamo et al. have proposed a biosensor based on MIP and SPR for the tapered plastic optical fibers in the selective and fast detection of L-nicotine.71 The sensor can differentiate between L- and D-nicotine. The sensitivity, which is closely related to the characteristics of the tapered optical fiber, is determined by experiments. A protein sensor based on tapered optical fibers has been modified by Au coatings using two deposition methods.72 The fibers are tapered by heating with a CO2 laser and pulling on a rotational stage. Gold deposition proceeds by DC sputtering73 layer-by-layer (LbL) electrostatic self-assembly as shown in Fig. 15(a). The sensitive protein biosensor can detect streptavidin below 2.5 nM and the transmission spectra for different SV concentrations are shown in Fig. 15(b).
![]() | ||
Fig. 15 (a) Schematic illustration of the coating process based on the layer-by-layer method and (b) transmission spectra for different SV concentrations. |
In addition to the conventional tapered fibers, an S-tapered optical fiber biosensor has been proposed for low-concentration human IgG detection.74 As shown in Fig. 16(a), it is bent at the taper transition, where the high-order modes are excited. A multifunctional adhesion platform is created by oxidative polymerization of the dopamine aqueous solution as shown in Fig. 16(b). The lower limit is 28 ng ml−1 and the influence of different stretches and axial offset lengths on the transmission characteristics of STF is studied. Fig. 16(c) shows the transmission spectra of STFS for different stretch lengths and axial offsets, revealing that the number of resonant peaks and dips decreases gradually with increasing S-tapper fiber stretch length from 500 to 800 μm.
![]() | ||
Fig. 16 (a) Schematic of the STF sensor, (b) protein A-IgG binding reaction, and (c) transmission spectra of STF. |
Tapered optical fibres enhance the excitation of plasma thin films by dramatically reducing the diameter of the fibre and have a very significant fabrication cost advantage, making them easier to fabricate on a large scale by mechanical tapering or chemical etching. However, the simplicity and fixed sensing structure limit the way in which the sensitivity can be increased. The fragile conical region is highly susceptible to damage, which affects the sensitivity and performance stability of the sensor.
An SPR system with 250 μm diameter optical fibers has been prepared to gauge the activation of living cells.76 The end cladding of the multimode fiber is removed with an acid and a 1 cm long gold film is deposited by vapor deposition. The RBL-2H3 cells are fixed on the sensor tip surface and observed under a phase-contrast microscope, as shown in Fig. 18(a). The dependence of peak movement on the period of DNP–HSA perfusion is shown in Fig. 18(b). The experimental results show that the peak wavelength increases for RBL-2H3 cells sensitized with anti-DNP IgE to 50 ng ml−1 DNP–HSA. A graphene oxide silver-coated polymer cladding formed on the silica optical fiber has been designed for SPR human IgG detection.77 Graphene oxide enhances the confined electric field surrounding the sensing layer, and the spectral sensitivity of the sensor with graphene oxide/silver is higher than that of the silver film sensor. Santosh et al. have proposed a selective optical fiber-based enzymatic biosensor for the detection of uric acid (UA) in human serum.78Fig. 18(c) shows the experimental setup and AuNPs and GO are synthesized and characterized. The SEM image of the uricase/GO/AuNPs-immobilized micro-ball fiber is depicted in Fig. 18(d), and the reflectance plots of the uricase/AuNPs coated micro-ball fiber are shown in Fig. 18(e). Utilizing the high local electric field enhancement capability of the LSPR, the biosensor can measure different uric acid concentrations from 10 μM to 1 mM.
Sensing devices based on end-face reflection simplify the detection process for real-time biosensing, and the flexible design of the structure provides more ways to improve sensor performance. Fiber-optic end-face configurations have a significant impact on sensor performance, including planar, spherical, and prismatic configurations to modify the angle of incidence of light striking the plasma film surface. The higher fabrication complexity reduces the repeatability and stability of the sensor.
As shown in Table 1, many biosensors incorporated with metals (e.g., Cr, Ni, and Al) have promising potential in DNA hybridization detection and other applications.
Ref. | Sensitive material | Sensitivity | Sensing medium | Str. Diagram |
---|---|---|---|---|
53 | Ag | 37 nm mM−1 | Uric acid |
![]() |
79 | Au/MoS2 | 2.9 nm/1000 CFU mL−1 | Escherichia coli |
![]() |
57 | Au/graphene | — | Breast cancer biomarker |
![]() |
80 | ITO/Cu | 4583.4 (nm per RIU−1) | Bovine serum albumin (BSA) |
![]() |
81 | Graphene/Au | 3030 (nm per RIU−1) | DNA hybridization |
![]() |
82 | Ag/MoS2/graphene | 105.71 deg per RIU−1 | DNA hybridization |
![]() |
83 | Cr/Au/MoSe2 | 2793.36 nm per RIU−1 | Goat anti-rabbit IgG |
![]() |
84 | Au | 1.857 nm UL−1 | Pancreatic amylase |
![]() |
85 | Ag/Ta2O5 | 8.709 nm μM−1 | Acetylcholine |
![]() |
38 nM | ||||
86 | Au/Cr | 2793.36 nm per RIU−1 | Prostate specific antigen |
![]() |
87 | Ag/SnSe | 3475 nm per RIU−1 | DNA hybridization |
![]() |
88 | Ag/Al | — | Pathogenic bacteria |
![]() |
58 | AuNRs | 989 nm per RIU−1 | Antigen–antibody of IgG |
![]() |
Microstructured optical fibers are mainly fabricated by the stack-and-draw method, as shown in Fig. 19.92 The method typically involves assembling glass capillaries according to the desired fiber design, followed by heating and stretching the stack (filled in a clamp sleeve) to the fiber. The manufacturing process provides great flexibility in designing MOFs. In addition, the transmission mode of light waves in PCF mainly depends on the photonic bandgap effect or total internal reflection (TIR) mechanism.93 In this way, light waves are able to propagate through the fiber core enabling precise optical control. MOFs are highly suitable for sensing applications as they offer high density, robustness, and cost-effectiveness over traditional sensors based on single-mode fibers or prisms. MOFs with their unique design and superior performance open new possibilities for optical sensing, communication, and other fields.
In SPR sensing technology, the microstructured fiber as the sensing base has structural advantages, and the flexible and controllable air holes in the cladding improve the coupling efficiency between modes. The momentum and energy matching between photons and the surface of the plasmonic medium is enhanced. Therefore, MOF-SPR sensors have attracted much attention, especially in biosensing, as the mechanism depends on the SPR effect related to the substrate and surface plasmonic materials such as Au and Ag and 2D functional materials for improved biocompatibility and molecular specific recognition (graphene, MoS2, etc.).74,94 MOF-SPR biosensors based on metal and 2D materials play a key role in medical diagnostics and body fluid detection such as cancer cell screening, DNA detection, enzymatic reactions, and identification of protein and glucose molecules.95–97 Currently, the primary obstacle in the advancement of optical fiber SPR sensors is the need to integrate and miniaturize devices while simultaneously enhancing the sensitivity and reliability for microscopic applications. Studies have shown that microstructured fibers have great potential.
![]() | ||
Fig. 20 Recently reported PCF biosensors for cancer detection: (a) M. Abdelghaffar et al.,98 (b) Md. Aslam Mollah et al.,98 (c) Mehdi fazeli et al.,99 and (d) Mahmoud M. A. Eid et al.100 |
The process of protein synthesis requires a large amount of energy, and glucose, the main source of energy in organisms, can also be detected by the SPR effect. Recently, PCF-SPR sensors have played a key role in human body fluid detection. Ayyanar Natesan et al. have proposed a glucose sensor with high sensitivity using tricore PCF that is analysed by FEM, as shown in Fig. 21(a).102 The sensitivity is 23267.33 nm per RIU−1 at 470 nm of wavelength shift based on the coupling theory. Bending has an impact on the overall performance of optical fiber sensors. Ahmet Yasli et al. have designed an SPR biosensor based on the effects of bending (Fig. 21(b)).103 The spectral interrogation method is chosen to calculate the sensitivity and resolution. The blood components (water, cytoplasm, blood plasma, white blood cell (WBC)) are used, and the numerical results show that the overall performance of the sensor can be improved by up to 63% by bending and the resonance wavelength can be tuned by bending.
![]() | ||
Fig. 21 SPR sensors in fluid monitoring applications: (a) Ayyanar Natesan et al.102 and (b) Ahmet Yasli et al.103 |
In the process of immune regulation, the specific recognition of antigen–antibody and the interactions of biological molecules such as DNA are essential to the normal operation of living organisms. DNA determines the genetic characteristics of an organism through genetic coding and synthesises the corresponding proteins through transcription and translation. It is important to note that the SPR effect can also be used for the detection of DNA. Xia et al. have researched a surface plasmon resonance (SPR) fiber biosensor using multi-layer gold nanoparticles (Au NPs)/Au film to enhance the sensitivity (Fig. 22(a)).104 The experimental results showed that SPR was able to excite the LSPR of gold nanoparticles and this coupling phenomenon between vertically aligned multilayered nanoparticles increased the depth of the outwardly propagating electric field, which induced a stronger localised electric field, obtaining a high refractive index sensitivity of 25642 nm per RIU−1. The addition of graphene oxide on the outer surface of the nanoparticles increased the number of biomolecules adsorbed and reduced the LOD to 4.6 ng mL−1, which is a high sensitivity without specific modification. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is a biochemical macromolecule, which is the carrier of most biological genetic information and can provide specific biological information. The method of measuring target DNA is similar to that of the bio-immunosensor based on antibody–antigen interaction. The probe DNA is combined with the target DNA and attached to the sensor to measure the probe–target binding signal. DNA is smaller than antigens and antibodies, and sensors for the detection of DNA-related interactions require a higher sensitivity. J. Roether et al. have designed a microfluidic platform based on the LSPR principle for the real-time detection of DNA and polymerase reactions.105 The platform consists of densely arranged mushroom-like nanostructures and PDMS channels (Fig. 22(b)). All the reactions are detected in situ inside the microfluidic LSPR chip and the sensitivity of this sensor is 54 ± 6 nm per RIU−1.
λFBG = 2ncoreΛ | (2) |
λiclad = (niclad + ncore)Λ/cos![]() | (3) |
Ref. | Structural features | Detectable biochemical analytes | Performance parameters | Str. diagram |
---|---|---|---|---|
112 | D-shaped titanium coated | Cancer cells | Sensitivity: 18![]() |
![]() |
DL: 0.025 RIU | ||||
DR: 1.36–1.401 | ||||
WR: 500–2000 nm | ||||
113 | Circular-shaped gold and titanium dioxide coated | Blood compositions like red blood cells (RBCs), hemoglobin (HB) and white blood cells (WBCs) | Sensitivity: 12![]() |
![]() |
DL: 0.02 RIU | ||||
DR: 1.33–1.40 | ||||
WR: 600–1100 nm | ||||
114 | Circular-shaped gold coated | Malaria in human body | Sensitivity: 14![]() |
![]() |
DL: 0.029 RIU | ||||
WR: 700–1000 nm | ||||
115 | D-shaped Au/Ti3C2Tx MXene hybrid coated | Protein, viruses, cancer, and blood cells | Sensitivity: 13![]() |
![]() |
DR: 1.33–1.39 | ||||
116 | PBGF Alexa Fluor 700–labeled DNA Oligo | Biomolecules in ultra-small sample volumes | Volume: 1 μL |
![]() |
LOD: 0.2 μM | ||||
117 | Circular-shaped gold coated with TiO2 | Biochemical sensing, medical testing | Sensitivity: 10![]() |
![]() |
Amplitude sensitivity: 1115 RIU−1 | ||||
DR: 1.35–1.40 | ||||
WR: 500–1350 nm | ||||
118 | Convex fiber-tapered gold NPs/Nb2CTx MXene | Creatinine detection in aquaculture | Sensitivity: 6701.03 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
DR: 1.3246–1.3634 | ||||
WR: 1400–2200 nm | ||||
119 | D-shaped silver coated with graphene and ZnO | Biochemical analytes, food quality, and medical diagnosis | Sensitivity: 4485.7 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
DR: 1.36–1.41 |
Due to the confinement of light within the fiber core, sensors with gold nanofilms fabricated on the cladding surface generally exhibit low sensitivity (20–74 nm per RIU−1).120,121 Post-processing, such as partial or complete removal of the cladding to expose the transmitted beam inside the fiber core to the external refractive index (including etching, grinding, and refinement of the cones), is required.
Arasu et al. have investigated FBG-SPR sensors with the cladding etched by performing numerical simulation.122 Incorporation of FBG into the fiber-based SPR structure leads to a high sensitivity above 500 nm per RIU−1 and 4-fold increase in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Burgmeier et al. have etched the cladding with hydrofluoric acid and modified the surface with gold nanoshell particles to excite SPR, as shown in Fig. 25.123 The sensor which operates based on intensity modulation exhibits a high sensitivity of −4400%/RIU in the refractive index range of 1.333–1.346. Although the sensor is exclusively used in replicate experiments with anhydrous ethanol aqueous solution, the study shows the capability of FBG for biosensing. Bekmurzayeva et al. have reported an SPR biosensor based on etched FBG for thrombin detection.124 The sensor with the cladding etched to 25 μm can selectively detect thrombin.
![]() | ||
Fig. 25 (a) SEM image of etched FBG with a nanoshell coating and an increased particle density in the microstructured fiber grating area; (b) reflecting spectra of the unetched and etched FBG; SRI-dependent sensing response of the bare and nanoshell coated fiber tip: (c) Bragg wavelength and (d) amplitude.123 |
However, the post-processing approach diminishes the robustness and standardized fabrication capability of the sensor. To achieve SPR excitation without compromising the cladding structure, Chah et al. have fabricated gold-plated FBG sensors with biased cores using a femtosecond laser.125 These gratings which make the fiber core highly birefringent generate a large number of cladding modes. While this approach preserves the intact cladding structure, the maximum refractive index sensitivity is limited to 50 nm per RIU−1. Candiani et al. have proposed a DNA sensing approach based on peptide nucleic acid (PNA)-functionalized MOF Bragg gratings, as illustrated in Fig. 26.126 The inner surface of the ‘grapefruit’ geometry MOF is functionalized with a PNA probe. After the penetration of the DNA solution into the fiber capillaries and hybridization, the oligonucleotide-functionalized gold nanoparticles (ON-Au NPs) are added. Spectroscopic assessment of the reflected signals reveals a significant wavelength shift of the 100 nM DNA solution in higher-order modes. The feasibility of this sensor for biomolecular measurements is demonstrated.
![]() | ||
Fig. 26 (a) Scanning electron micrograph of a microstructured optical fiber (MOF); (b) basic profile and (c) first-order beam profile; (d) schematic showing the linkage of the peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probe to the fiber internal surface and sandwich-like system used for DNA detection; (e) spectra after hybridization with 100 nM full-match DNA solution and gold nanoparticles.126 |
Arasu et al. have proposed an FBG sensor coated with graphene oxide and utilized gold as the plasmonic medium.127 Experimental results show that the sensitivity is 500 nm per RIU−1 in the refractive index range of 1.332–1.357, which is 2.5 times higher than that of the sensor without the graphene oxide film. The FBG requiring no additional post-processing renders the sensor highly robust and easy to handle. Rusyakina et al. have designed additional cladding modes to excite surface plasmon resonance using FBGs fabricated based on PCF, as shown in Fig. 27.128 The effects of PCF lattice spacing and pore diameter on the resonance spectra are discussed, and the wavelength sensitivity and amplitude sensitivity of the sensor in aqueous solutions for the refractive index range of 1.3158–1.3177 are experimentally verified. Although the detection range of the sensor is limited, this study highlights the biosensing potential of FBGs based on MOF.
![]() | ||
Fig. 27 (a) Transmission spectra of FBG in PCF (micrographs of cross-sections shown); (b) resonance wavelengths for the selected modes showing different dependence on the temperature variations in water; (c and d) transmission spectra of modes 1 and 2 after immersion of the gold-coated PCF gratings in solutions with 17 refractive indexes; modes showing the largest shifts in wavelength and amplitude in the SPR-excited state.128 |
Shevchenko et al. have designed a TFBG-assisted SPR sensor for the detection of biomolecular targets at various concentrations, as shown in Fig. 28(a).131 The sensor shows robust detection of thrombin in serum with an SNR of 194.51 and LOD of 22.6 nM. By coating the surface with a linker protein, the TFBG-SPR sensor is capable of real-time analysis of the cellular behavior.132,133 Voisin et al. have achieved a low LOD of 2 pM in the detection of streptavidin pairs.134 Guo Tuan et al. have proposed the utilization of TFBG and SPR excitation for highly sensitive protein detection (sensitivity up to 5.5 dB/(mg ml−1) with an LOD of 1.5 × 10−3 mg ml−1). As shown in Fig. 28(c), by precisely controlling the thickness of the metal film to about 30 nm, some of the cladding modes can be excited by SPR using the cladding mode through the metal layer.135 Compared with other biosensors, the sensor has the inherent temperature-sensitive property that can be eliminated by experimental processing.
![]() | ||
Fig. 28 (a) Monolayer of thrombin aptamer probes (shown in red) immobilized on the gold coating interacting with the cognate thrombin protein targets (shown in blue);131 (b) sensor response measured in the aptamer solution (red arrow indicating the most sensitive SPR-coupled cladding resonance.); (c) TFBG with 20–30 nm Ag coating (hybrid “cut-off” and “plasmonic” resonances achieved simultaneously over a single TFBG);135 (d) transmission spectra of the sensor in aqueous solutions (red stars indicating the corresponding positions of the “cutoff” and “plasmonic” resonances). |
Ribaut et al. have achieved a significant milestone by demonstrating that the TFBG-SPR sensor can accurately monitor biomarkers in biological tissues and detect cancer markers in human lung biopsies.136 The sensor is enclosed in a specialized package made of a biocompatible polymer, which is employed as an impregnated probe for the detection of cytokeratin CK17 encapsulated in an acrylamide gel matrix, as shown in Fig. 29(a). The experimental results demonstrate the existence of a stable optical response of TFBG-SPR despite the non-liquid nature of the sample. The TFBG-SPR sensor has the capability of sensitive non-invasive measurement in situ and online monitoring of tumors. Furthermore, Zhang et al. have realized online monitoring of glucose in human serum using TFBG coated with a nanoscale silver film on the surface.137 The sensor utilizes the etching effect of hydrogen peroxide to achieve highly sensitive monitoring of glucose. A hydrogen peroxide concentration as low as 0.2 μM can be detected by monitoring the amplitude changes in selected cladding patterns. González-Vila et al. have performed direct sensing of different gases without the need for adaptive and sensitive coatings, as shown in Fig. 29(d).138 The metal coating on the sensor is about one-third the thickness normally used for liquids, and the sensitivity of direct measurement of the refractive index of gases is 78 nm per RIU−1.
![]() | ||
Fig. 29 (a) Picture of the immunosensor incorporated into the tumoral tissue of human lung biopsy; (b) TFBG-SPR spectrum recorded when the immunosensor is inserted in the tissue; (c) amplitude monitoring of the most sensitive mode obtained on the tumoral tissue of the biopsy;136 (d) transmitted spectra of the TFBGs coated with a gold film 18 nm thick for SPR excitation in air;138 (e) refractive index sensitivity of the sensors in the presence of different gases. |
Wang et al. have performed the detection of heavy lead ions (Pb2+) by constructing gold nanoparticle (GNP) films on the surface of TFBG using DNAzyme and the substrate chain.139 As Pb2+ cleaves the ribonucleotide adenosine linked to the DNAzyme containing the substrate strand, the GNPs linked to the DNAzyme fall onto the sensor surface, as shown in Fig. 30. The ‘hot spot’ effect enhances spectral signal response, enabling direct monitoring of the Pb2+ concentration. The experimental results show that the sensor has fine selectivity for Pb2+ against other environmentally relevant metal ions due to the specific recognition of DNAzyme. Qu et al. have fabricated an 18° TFBG-SPR biosensor for esophageal cancer diagnosis.140 By fabricating the NY-ESO-1 antigen as a bioreceptor on a metal surface, the sensor has an LOD of 2 × 10−7 μg ml−1 with good linear monitoring of the antibody in the range of 2 × 10−7 to 2 × 10−5 μg ml−1. The sensor shows the hook effect if the concentration of the NY-ESO-1 antibody is higher than 2 × 10−3 μg ml−1.
![]() | ||
Fig. 30 (a) Schematic showing lead detection by the TFBG-SPR sensing system; (b) amplitude responses of the TFBG-SPR sensing cladding modes; (c) electric field distributions of the gold nanoparticles on the Au film with gap distances of 16.02 nm and 1.52 nm; (d) effects of gold nanoparticles with different sizes on the signals.139 |
As shown in Fig. 31(a), conventional TFBG-SPR sensors are not able to achieve effective sensing for a relatively small number of base pairs (e.g., 20 base pairs to form a chain of approximately 6.8 nm long nucleic acids (NAs)).141 In order to detect ultra-low concentrations of NAs, optical fibre sensing structures with ultra-high RI sensitivity are often required, a goal that often requires the fabrication of complex plasma structures/materials on the fibre surface. In 2023, Peng et al. reported a TFBG-SPR-based NA sensor with ultra-low LOD, utilising a relatively simple method to amplify RI changes, as shown in Fig. 31(b). The SPR enhancement on the Au surface was obtained by binding AuNPs to DNA strands, due to which the LSPR was excited. The TFBG-SPR NA sensor was shown to have a LOD of 1.0 × 10−18 mol L−1 (1 aM) over an ultra-wide NA detection range of 1 × 10−18 mol L−1 to 1 × 10−17 mol L−1.
Tang et al. have demonstrated a biosensor based on the long-period fiber grating.145 The gold nanoparticles with a diameter of 8 nm form a self-assembled monolayer gold colloid on the grating surface, and the colloidal gold surface is modified with the dinitrophenyl compound (DNP).146 An LOD as low as 9.5 × 10−10 M is achieved by measuring the transmission spectra of the sensing fiber grating. Marques et al. have coated SiO2:Au NPs on the surface of LPFG for protein detection, as shown in Fig. 32.147 The SiO2 NPs serve two important functions. Firstly, they confer higher porosity to the sensitive layer of the sensor, thus providing a larger surface area. Secondly, they optimize the efficiency of the interactions between the swift wave and the sensitive layer by optimizing the thickness of the sensitive layer. Biotin–streptavidin is directly attached to the Au shell layer of silica NPs, and the selectivity of the sensor for specific proteins can be tailored simply by changing the nature of the ligand. Streptavidin can be detected at a minimum concentration of 2.5 nM, with a sensitivity of 6.9 nm (ng mm−2)−1 and a detection limit of 19 pg mm−2. Subsequently, Wei et al. have increased the strength of the surface electric field by coating a layer of graphene on the surface of the Ag membrane of the LPFG-SPR sensor.148 The experimental results show that the interactions between the SPR wave and the molecule are significantly enhanced, and the sensitivity of the sensor for methane reaches 0.344 nm%−1, which is 1.31 times higher than that of the conventional LPFG-SPR sensor.
Liu et al. have adopted a similar approach in preparing SiO2:Au NPs on LPFG by a layered method, as shown in Fig. 33(a).149 The Au NPs (2–5 nm in diameter) are covalently attached to the silica nanoparticles by chemisorption forming a shell structure. Biotin is covalently bound to the gold shell surface by forming amide bonds and utilized for the detection of streptavidin with a sensitivity of 3.88 nm/(ng mm−2) and a LOD of 0.86 pg mm−2. Heidemann et al. have also prepared cysteamine-functionalized AuNPs on LPFG for online monitoring of glyphosate molecules, as shown in Fig. 33(c).150 The LPFG operating near the dispersion turning point exhibits a highly sensitive wavelength shift, and the LOD of glyphosate in water is approximately 0.02 μM. Li et al. have theoretically investigated the excitation and sensing properties of the surface waveguide modes excited by gold–silica thin-film-coated LPFG, as shown in Fig. 33(d–f).151 The surface waveguide modes originating from the intermode jumps of two neighboring EH cladding modes are produced by the surface silicon film, while the HE cladding modes remain stable. Highly sensitive refractive index sensing is accomplished by tracking the wavelength shift of the double resonance of the EH surface waveguide modes, with the insensitive HE cladding modes providing the additional advantage of self-referencing measurements. A high sensitivity of 7267.7 nm per RIU−1 is observed in the refractive index range of 1.315 to 1.335, which is 76 times higher than that of the bare LPFG sensor and 4 times higher than that of the common LPFG-SPR sensor. Although limited to theoretical investigation by numerical simulation, this study showcases the potential in highly sensitive biosensing (Table 3).
![]() | ||
Fig. 33 (a) TEM image of SiNPs with a gold shell;149 (b) cross-sectional image of the optical fiber with three layers of PAH/SiNPs and gold shell; (c) schematic drawing of the LPG-AuNP-Cys fiber sensor;150 (d) LPFG coated with gold–silicon films; (e) transmission spectrum for the 225 um grating period; (f) wavelength variation and sensitivity of the EH1,8 modes.151 |
Ref. | Design specifications | Analyte parameters | Performance parameters | Str. diagram |
---|---|---|---|---|
122 | FBG (cladding diameters: 5.8 um) + Au(40 nm) | RI (1.33–1.44) | Sensitivity: 522 nm per RIU−1 (1.33–1.38)/1246.7 nm per RIU−1 (1.38–1.44) |
![]() |
SNR: 0.24 (1.33–1.38)/0.46 (1.38–1.44) | ||||
125 | FBG (Eccentric) + Au(30 nm) | RI (1.33–1.36) | Sensitivity: 50 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
123 | FBG (cladding diameters: 6um) + SiO2:Au NPs(diameters: 155 nm) | RI (1.3329–1.3422) | Wavelength sensitivity: 13.5 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
Amplitude sensitivity: −4400%/RIU | ||||
127 | FBG + Au(45 nm) + GO | RI (1.345–1.3550) | Sensitivity: 486 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
RI (1.3550–1.3597) | SNR: 1.85 | |||
Sensitivity: 1340 nm per RIU−1 | ||||
SNR:1.76 | ||||
128 | FBG (PCF cladding diameters: 86um, air hole diameters: 1um, ∧ = 2.5um) (∧ = 541 nm,) + Au(35 nm) | RI (1.3158–1.3177) | Wavelength sensitivity: 40.3 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
Amplitude sensitivity: −801 dB/RIU, SNR: 1.02 × 10−4 RIU | ||||
131 | TFBG (θ = 10°) + Au(50 nm) | Thrombin (0–5 μM) | SNR: 2.11–194.51 |
![]() |
Aptamers (0–20 μM) | LOD: 22.6 nM | |||
SNR: 8.58–36.97 | ||||
LOD: 2 nM | ||||
137 | TFBG (θ = 18°) + Ag(30 nm) | Glucose concentrations (0–12 mM) | Sensitivity: 0.5 dB mM−1 |
![]() |
LOD: 0.2 μM | ||||
140 | TFBG (θ = 18°) + Au(50 nm) | NY-ESO-1 antibody (2 × 10−7 − 2 × 10−5 μg ml−1) | LOD: 2 × 10−7 μg ml−1 |
![]() |
145 | LPFG (∧ = 550 um) + Au NPs with an average diameter of 8.4 ± 2.8 nm | Dinitrophenyl (DNP) antibody | LOD: 1.4 × 10−8 g mL−1 or 9.5 × 10−10 M |
![]() |
144 | LPFG (∧ = 47.57399 um, number of periods N = 39) + Au film | Analyte refractive index from 1.395 to 1.405 | Sensitivity = 27![]() |
![]() |
148 | LPFG (∧ = 600um)(cladding diameter of 125 μm) + Ag(50 nm) + graphene | 0–3.5% methane gas | Sensitivity = 0.344 nm%−1 |
![]() |
151 | LPFG (∧ = 225um) + Au(40 nm) + Si(45.5 nm) | Around 1.315 RIU | Sensitivity = 7267.7 nm per RIU−1 |
![]() |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |