Xuechao
Mo
,
Guohao
Chen
,
Yulan
Li
,
Biao
Xiao
,
Xuefeng
Chen
,
Xiaojun
Yin
* and
Chuluo
Yang
*
Shenzhen Key Laboratory of New Information Display and Storage Materials, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen, 518060, P. R. China. E-mail: xiaojunyin@szu.edu.cn; clyang@szu.edu.cn
First published on 5th October 2024
The advancement of desirable circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) emitters is predominantly constrained by the effective regulation of magnetic and electric transition vectors, particularly within the deep-blue spectral domain. Herein, we present four pairs of novel chiral emitters with systematically varied molecular rigidity, symmetry, and chiral centers to elucidate the intrinsic coupling of key molecular parameters influencing their chiroptical properties. Notably, the incorporation of appropriate intramolecular 3D-interlocking within a natural binaphthyl chirality skeleton offers an effective approach to achieving both significantly narrowed full width at half maximum (FWHM, as low as 18 nm) and substantially enhanced chiroptical activity (luminous dissymmetry factor, gPL, up to 3.0 × 10−3). Additionally, introducing a secondary chiral center closely parallel to the primary chiral plane facilitates strong chiral–chiral interactions, further affording a 50% improvement in their gPL values. As a demonstration, vacuum-deposited circularly polarized organic light-emitting diodes incorporating these pure fluorescent emitters exhibit outstanding electroluminescent performance, with maximum external quantum efficiency exceeding 5.35%, favorable FWHM of approximately 25 nm, and extreme CIEy values below 0.03.
Owing to their inherent chiral donor characteristics, ease of modification, and avoidance of expensive chiral resolution processes, [1,1′-binaphthalene]-2,2′-diamine (BNA) and its derivatives exhibiting natural axis chirality find widespread utilization as chiral emitters for high-performance organic light emitting diodes (OLEDs).13 For instance, Chen et al. exemplify the synthesis of deep-red thermal activation delayed fluorescence molecules (emission peak, λem = 660 nm) through the integration of BNA with a potent acceptor, cyano-substituted phenopyrazine, resulting in a gPL of 1.7 × 10−3 and a maximum external quantum efficiency (ηEQE,max) of 6.2%.14 Zheng and colleagues present a versatile approach to enhance the gPL to 5.3 × 10−3 by incorporating the BNA donor onto the weak ortho-phthalonitrile acceptor, yielding both sky-blue emission (λem = 477 nm) and an improved ηEQE,max of 20.5%.13c Our research group has recently proposed a dual-pronged strategy to reconcile the trade-offs between luminous efficiency and gPL by directly fusing a secondary chiral donor (BNA) onto the multiple resonance (MR) scaffold, resulting in narrow-band pure-green emission along with a substantial gPL (3.3 × 10−3) and ηEQE,max of 36.1%.15 Despite this, the availability of reliable CPL emitters in the deep-blue range and comprehensive studies elucidating factors crucial for determining their chiroptical properties,16 such as configurational stability, molecular symmetry, and chiral–chiral interactions, remains notably limited, yet pivotal for further advancements toward high-quality CPLs.
In this study, four pairs of enantiomers based on BNA backbone with varying molecular rigidity, symmetry, and chiral centers were meticulously designed to elucidate the intrinsic coupling of key molecular parameters involved in chiroptical properties (Scheme 1). Remarkably, all these chiral emitters were synthesized via a straightforward two-step process (Scheme S1†) without requiring additional chiral resolution. Steady-state fluorescence measurements revealed that all these CPLs exhibited bright deep-blue emission with peaks around 416 nm, while the shape and full width at half maximum (FWHM) were significantly influenced by the spatial structure of the frameworks. Compared to the flexible R/S-BNCz-C6, the FWHM of R/S-BNCz-Ph with rigid 3D-interlocking structure was significantly narrowed to 18 nm, attributed to the hybrid localized π-bonding, short-range charge transfer excitation characteristics, as well as reduced vibrational relaxation in the excited states. Additionally, a rigid geometry was essential for maintaining consistent vectors of both electric and magnetic transitions, resulting in more robust chiroptical properties for R/S-BNCz-Ph (1.1 × 10−3) compared to R/S-BNCz-C6 (<1.0 × 10−4). Furthermore, introducing a secondary chiral motif closely parallel to the primary chiral plane afforded potential chiral–chiral interactions, improving the gPL value by 50% to 1.6 × 10−3. Whereas, incorporating a repeating chiral BNCz with C2-symmetry geometry led to an unfavorable vector angle and a decreased gPL of 0.6 × 10−3, but raised fluorescence quantum yield up to 0.92. Theoretical simulations and single-crystal analysis elucidated the key parameters influencing these differentiated chiroptical properties. As a demonstration, vacuum-evaporated OLEDs using these chiral emitters as emitting layers were fabricated, achieving favorable device performances with the maximum external quantum efficiency (ηEQE,max) values all exceeding 4.00% (peaking at 5.35%) and desirable Commission Internationale de L'Eclairage (CIE) y-coordinates (CIEy < 0.05) conforming to the Broadcast Service Television 2020 (BT.2020) standard for blue emitters, representing one of the best results among pure fluorescence blue-OLEDs.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Chemical structures and the molecular design concepts of the four pairs of deep-blue enantiomers. |
Emitters | λ abs [nm] | λ em [nm] | FWHMa [nm] | E HOMO/ELUMOb [eV] | E g [eV] | τ p [ns] | Φ PL [%] | k r,s [107 s−1] | k nr,s [107 s−1] | g PL [×10−3] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The characteristic absorption peaks, emission peaks and full widths at half maximum were obtained in dilute toluene (1 × 10−5 mol L−1).
b
E
HOMOs was evaluated from the half-wave potential of oxidation process of cyclic voltammetry curves with reference to the internal standard of ferrocene, ELUMOs was deduced by EHOMOs and optical gap.
c Calculated from the onset of absorption spectra at long wavelength side.
d Obtained from the transient PL. decay curves.
e The total ΦPL was measured in 20 wt% doped thin films (in mCBP![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
||||||||||
R/S-BNCz-C6 | 299, 321, 410 | 420 | 36 | −5.34/−2.36 | 2.98 | 20.16 | 58 | 6.13 | 4.21 | <±0.1 |
R/S-BNCz-Ph | 292, 322, 404 | 416 | 18 | −5.32/−2.35 | 2.97 | 10.21 | 72 | 7.06 | 2.75 | ±1.1/±3.0 |
R,R/S,S-BBNCz-Ph | 290, 322, 405 | 416 | 19 | −5.30/−2.33 | 2.97 | 10.21 | 92 | 9.02 | 0.78 | ±0.6/±0.8 |
R,R/S,S-BNCz-BN | 293, 387, 409 | 419 | 22 | −5.22/−2.27 | 2.95 | 10.19 | 64 | 6.27 | 3.53 | ±1.6/±1.5 |
The photophysical properties of these chiral emitters were examined in either dilute toluene solution (1 × 10−5 M) or doped thin films (20 wt% in DBFPO:
mCBP matrix, 1
:
1), with the results presented in Fig. 2a–c and Table 1. As anticipated, all compounds exhibited intense π–π* transitions around 300 nm and relatively weaker n–π* transition bands around 380 nm. Additionally, a distinct absorption band over 400 nm was observed in all four emitters, belonging to the characteristic short-range charge-transfer (SR-CT) transition between adjacent atoms with differing electronegativities (Fig. 2a). Notably, compared to the rotatable R-BNCz-C6, the shoulder emission peaks of the other three with 3D-interlocked architectures were significantly weakened (Fig. 2b), resulting in a pronounced narrowing of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) from 36 nm to 18 nm (for R-BNCz-Ph). Such variation can be attributed to the enhanced molecular rigidity, which facilitated to suppress most vibrational and rotational modes, aligning with the intensified SR-CT observed in R-BNCz-Ph as well. Conversely, all four emitters exhibited similar narrow-band emission spectra in doped thin films (inset of Fig. 2c) due to the considerable restriction of molecular relaxation in the aggregate state. Interestingly, R,R-BBNCz-Ph, with its dual fluorescence centers and improved molecular symmetry, displayed a significantly enhanced photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY, 0.92) compared to the single-center R-BNCz-Ph (0.72). Transient PL. spectra recorded in the mCBP
:
DBFPO hybrid matrix showed monoexponential decay profiles for all samples (Fig. S13†), with fitted fluorescence lifetimes (τp) of approximately 10.2 ns. Additionally, the estimated energy gaps (ΔEST) between the lowest triplet (T1) and singlet (S1) states exceeded 0.48 eV (Fig. S11†), suggesting that the reverse intersystem crossing (RISC) process from T1 to S1 is negligible. Furthermore, solvent polarity (f)-dependent absorption and fluorescence spectra (Fig. S12†) showed minimal Stokes shifts across varying f, aligning with typical radiative transitions dominated by local excitation mechanisms.
The chiroptical properties of these axial chirality emitters were investigated in both dilute toluene solutions and doped thin films as well. As shown in Fig. 2d and S14,† all samples exhibited characteristic mirror-symmetric circular dichroism (CD) signals with distinct wavy Cotton effects ranging from 280 nm to approximately 420 nm. Notably, all enantiomers displayed intense CD signals concentrated around 300 nm, attributed to the typical π-bonding type local excitation of BNCz segments. The relative strength of CD signals at longer wavelengths was notably enhanced with the introduction of a secondary chiral motif, which can be attributed to potential chiral–chiral interactions between the two interpenetrated chiral centers. Accordingly, the circularly polarized photoluminescence (CPPL) spectra and estimated gPL values of both R/S-BNCz-Ph and R,R/S,S-BNCz-BN were significantly higher than those of R,R/S,S-BBNCz-Ph, due to the substantial contribution of SR-CT components or broadened π*–π transitions in the radiative S1 state. Interestingly, compared to the R/S-BNCz-Ph pair, the R,R/S,S-BNCz-BN, with its two chiral centers and mutually orthogonal molecular configuration, showed a 50% improvement in gPL values (i.e., 1.6 × 10−3vs. 1.1 × 10−3), as elucidated by following theoretical calculations. However, in the aggregate state, such trend was slightly reversed, with the chiroptical features of R/S-BNCz-Ph being remarkably superior to the others, showing threefold amplified gPL values up to 3.0 × 10−3. This enhancement might be attributed to the contribution of intermolecular chiral–chiral interactions in the highly doped thin films (20 wt%).
To fully understand the diversity of photophysical properties, density functional theory (DFT) calculations were executed for independent molecules using the Gaussian 16 software package. For brevity, all alkyl chains were simplified as methyl groups, and only right-hand (R) models were included. As expected, the highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of these chiral models were predominantly distributed on the BNCz backbones, exhibiting typical π-bonding characteristics (Fig. S16†). In addition, a significant proportion of HOMOs were located on the electron-rich nitrogen atoms and extended to the ortho/para positions of the conjugated carbon atoms, while LUMOs were confined to the electron-deficient carbon atoms at the meta-position of nitrogen, resulting in partially SR-CT participated excited states. Natural transition orbital (NTO) analysis confirmed the hybrid charge-transfer characteristics of the S1 → S0 transition (Fig. 3), especially for R-BNCz-Ph (Fig. 3b), which facilitated enhancements in both spin-orbital coupling (SOC) values between different excited states with different spin multiplicities, and oscillator strength (f) between excited states and ground states. Notably, the calculated SOC matrix element 〈S1|ĤSOC|T1〉 value for R-BNCz-Ph was nearly double (0.456 cm−1) that of the primary R-BNCz-C6 (0.269 cm−1), together with an enhanced f from 0.081 to 0.108, attributed to the increased hybrid ratios of SR-CT in the excited states of the latter than the former. Additionally, for R,R-BBNCz-Ph, with a duplicate chromophore and C2-symmetry, denser and more mixed excited states for interorbital coupling contributed to a further promoted SOC matrix element 〈S1|ĤSOC|T2〉 value of up to 0.935 cm−1.
The vibrational relaxation during the excitation and radiative transition processes was investigated based on the optimized geometrical configurations of S1 and S0. Compared to the nonrestrictive R-BNCz-C6, the 3D-interlocked structure enabled a more rigid and stable architecture, with calculated root-mean-square deviations (RMSDs) decreasing from 0.286 to 0.153 Å. The Huang–Rhys factors (HRFs) associated with different vibrational modes during the S1 → S0 process were systematically simulated and analyzed using the Molecular Materials Property Prediction Package (MOMAP, Fig. 4).17 Both R-BNCz-C6 and R-BNCz-Ph demonstrated relatively large HRFs at low-frequency regions, attributed to the out-of-plane bending and swing of the BNCz plane. Compared to R-BNCz-C6, the calculated HRFs and total reorganization energies (λtotal) for R-BNCz-Ph were significantly reduced, implying improved molecular rigidity via 3D-interlocking (Fig. 4a). With the incorporation of two identical BNCz chiral centers (R,R-BBNCz-Ph), more vibrational modes were predictably involved in the chiral chromophore, resulting in a slight increase in λtotal to 1958 cm−1 (Fig. 4b). For R,R-BNCz-BN, the presence of two orthogonal chiral centers, combined with significant through-space π–π interactions (∼2.91 Å), likely induced additional vibrational modes and intramolecular repulsive forces, consequently leading to a substantial increase in the λtotal value.18 To further elucidate the variation in chiroptical properties due to incremental changes in molecular parameters, theoretical simulations were conducted at the PBE0/Def2-SVP level using the TD-DFT method, providing critical parameters such as magnetic (μm) and electric dipole moments (μe), along with the corresponding transition angles (θe,m) during the S1 → S0 transition (Fig. 5). Despite both R-BNCz-C6 and R-BNCz-Ph exhibited similar calculated CPPL parameters, with g factors (gcal) around 1.5 × 10−3, consistent with results measured in dilute toluene (1.1 × 10−3). Actually, the observed CPPL signal for R-BNCz-C6 was nearly negligible, which can be attributed to the flexible skeleton leading to uncertain or countervailing CPPL signals (Fig. S18†),15a underscoring the significance of 3D-interlocking strategy. With the incorporation of a secondary chiral center, the calculated θe,m values split into two opposite directions depending on molecular symmetry. Specifically, two different chiral chromophores with mutually orthogonal configurations (R,R-BNCz-BN) yielded a favorable θe,m of 129.4°, while two identical chiral motifs with C2-symmetry (R,R-BBNCz-Ph) delivered an almost vertical angle of 93.8°. Consequently, distinct gcal values of 0.86 × 10−3 and 3.44 × 10−3 were obtained for R,R-BBNCz-Ph and R,R-BNCz-BN, respectively, suggesting that the incorporation of a suitably positioned secondary chiral center in close proximity to the primary one can effectively reinforce potential chiral–chiral interactions.
To evaluate the potential application in CP-OLEDs, vacuum-deposited electroluminescence devices incorporating these chiral compounds as emitting layers were prepared, with the detail configuration of “ITO/HAT-CN (5 nm)/TAPC (30 nm)/TCTA (15 nm)/mCBP (10 nm)/emitting layers (25 nm)/DBFPO (15 nm)/ANT-BIZ (30 nm)/Liq (2 nm)/Al (100 nm). The emitting layer composed of R-BNCz-Ph, R,R-BBNCz-Ph or R,R-BNCz-BN (20 wt% doped in DBFPO:
mCBP blended matrix, 1
:
1) were designated as device A, B or C, respectively (Fig. 6a and b). Notably, all devices demonstrated pure deep-blue emission with CIEy < 0.05, and no residual peak from the hybrid host was observed under any bias, indicating an efficient host-dopant energy transfer channel. The FWHM of R-BNCz-Ph, R,R-BBNCz-Ph and R,R-BNCz-BN based devices were slightly broadened to 25, 30 and 33 nm, respectively, compared to the results in toluene (Fig. 6d). Due to the small FWHM and satisfactory emission peaks (423–427 nm), all the devices achieved desirable CIE coordinates aligning with the BT.2020 standard for pure-blue emitters. For example, under the same bias of 6 V, CIE coordinates of (0.157, 0.024) for device A, (0.166, 0.049) for device B, and (0.158, 0.036) for device C were realized. As revealed in Fig. 6d and Table 2, the maximum external quantum efficiency (ηEQE,max) of these devices all exceeded 4.00%, with the highest value reaching 5.35% (device B), which surpasses the theoretical limits of traditional fluorescence-based OLEDs. In addition, the EL performances of R,R-BBNCz-Ph-based device, with the maximum current efficiency (ηc,max) of 2.69 cd A−1 and power efficiency (ηEQE,max) of 2.64 lm W−1, were significantly better than those of the other two, which could be ascribed to the higher PLQY and more favorable horizontal transition dipole orientation of the former compared to the latter two (Fig. 5 and S17†). Nevertheless, all three devices demonstrated very competitive results, delivering some of the optimal values among blue fluorescence emitter-based OLEDs, particularly in the extreme blue region with CIEy < 0.05 and FWHM < 35 nm (Fig. 6e and Table S1†).
Device codes (emitters) | V on [V] | L max [cd m−2] | η c,max [cd A−1] | η p,max [lm W−1] | η EQE,max [%] | ELpeakd [nm] | FWHMd [nm] | CIEd [x, y] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Turn-on voltage at the luminance of 1 cd m−2. b The maximum brightness of the devices. c The ηc,max, ηp,max and ηEQE,max values of these devices. d The electroluminescent emission peaks, FWHM, and CIE coordinates of these devices under the unified bias of 6 V. | ||||||||
A (S-BNCz-Ph) | 3.6 | 2104 | 1.07 | 0.94 | 4.23 | 423 | 25 | 0.157, 0.024 |
B (S,S-BBNCz-Ph) | 3.6 | 4975 | 2.69 | 2.64 | 5.35 | 423 | 30 | 0.166, 0.049 |
C (S,S-BNCz-BN) | 3.6 | 1898 | 1.38 | 1.21 | 4.00 | 427 | 33 | 0.158, 0.036 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detail synthesis and characterization, general information, photophysical, thermal and electrical properties of the chiral emitters, theoretical calculations, and crystal structures. CCDC 2372805–2372808. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc05056h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |