Open Access Article
Charline
Sire
a,
Vincent
Meneyrol
b,
Nathalie
Saffon-Merceron
c,
Enzo
Terreno
d,
Francesca
Garello
d,
Lorenzo
Tei
e,
Emmanuelle
Jestin
b,
Raphaël
Tripier
a and
Thibault
Troadec
*a
aUniv. Brest, UMR CNRS 6521 CEMCA, 6 Avenue Victor Le Gorgeu, 29200 Brest, France. E-mail: Thibault.troadec@univ-brest.fr
bCyclotron Réunion Océan Indien CYROI, 2 rue Maxime Rivière 97490 Sainte-Clotilde, France
cInstitut de Chimie de Toulouse (UAR 2599), 118 route de Narbonne, 31062 Toulouse Cedex 9, France
dDepartment of Molecular Biotechnology and Health Sciences, University of Turin, Piazza Nizza 44/bis, 10126 Turin, Italy
eDipartimento di Scienze ed Innovazione Tecnologica, Università del Piemonte Orientale “Amedeo Avogadro”, Viale T. Michel 11, 15121 Alessandria, Italy
First published on 25th July 2024
Macrocyclic chelators play a central role in medical imaging and nuclear medicine owing to their unparalleled metal cation coordination abilities. Their functionalization by fluorinated groups is an attractive design, to combine their properties with those of 18F for Positron Emission Tomography (PET) or natural 19F for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), and access potential theranostic or smart medical imaging probes. For the first time, a compact fluorinated macrocyclic architecture has been synthesized, based on a cyclen chelator bearing additional pyridine coordinating units and simple methyltrifluoroborate prosthetic groups. This ligand and its corresponding model Zn(II) complex were investigated to evaluate the 18F-PET or 19F MRI abilities provided by this novel molecular structure. The chelator and the complex were obtained via a simple and high-yielding synthetic route, present excellent solvolytic stability of the trifluoroborate groups at various pH, and provide facile late-stage 18F-radiolabeling (up to 68% radiochemical yield with high activity) as well as a satisfying detection limit for 19F MRI imaging (low mM range).
Concurrently, in the field of molecular probes for medical imaging and therapy, saturated polyazamacrocycles, such as cyclen (1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane), cyclam (1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane) and tacn (1,4,7-triazacyclononane) are cornerstone for the complexation of metallic and lanthanide cations for MRI,6 PET,7,8 Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT)9 or internal Radiotherapy,7,8 owing to their exceptional coordination properties and in vivo inertness of their complexes. In that context, fluorinated azamacrocycles are highly attractive as they can combine, within a single molecular architecture, the properties of metals or radiometals coordinated within their cavity with the ones of 19F or 18F. In particular, two major applications have been targeted recently: (i) complexes combining radiometals (α or β− emitters) for radiotherapy and prosthetic 18F-radiolabeled units for diagnosis, leading to so-called theranostic tracers that merge therapeutic and diagnostic modalities in a single molecule and provide identical biodistribution in vivo; and (ii) complexes of paramagnetic cations with natural 19F pendants as sensitive or responsive 19F MRI probes.
Several fluorinated polyazacycloalcane scaffolds have thus been described for these two distinct objectives in recent years. First, azamacrocycles were used in 18F-PET as an alternative to conventional 18F-labeling (via C–F bonds formation)10,11 for the tagging of biomolecules. In this case, the macrocyclic cavity of tacn-based chelators was used to accommodate metal-18F synthons: with Al(III) over a decade ago (AlF-NOTA, Scheme 1),12–14 and lately with Ga(III) and Fe(III).15–18 Linear ligands, such as ResCa and analogues, have also been reported since to allow such radiolabeling at low temperature (<37 °C).19–23 However in those cases, the chelating cavity is occupied by innocent metal cations bearing no additional property. Only very recently Boros et al. went a step further and developed the corresponding theranostic version, using the Sc(III)–F synthon that can allow the 47Sc (β− radiotherapy)/18F (PET imaging) theranostic couple.24 Nevertheless, the scope of this strategy is limited in terms of possible metal cations and corresponding radiometals as the strength of the M–F interaction is not sufficient with most relevant metallic cations, as already observed for instance with lanthanides.25,26
In a second strategy, the well-known DOTA chelator ((1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetrayl)tetraacetic acid), that can coordinate a wide range of metal cations and 177Lu (β− emitter) in particular, has been functionalized by branched side chains allowing grafting on a targeting moiety and installation of fluoroborate or fluorosilane prosthetic groups.27,28 These are particularly attractive in this context, as they allow easy late-stage 18F-labeling via19F/18F isotopic exchange processes (Scheme 1),29–31 as an alternative to sometimes tedious C–18F bond forming reactions.10,11 However, the organic frameworks attached to the chelator in this case require challenging multistep syntheses, and result in large branched structures that can be detrimental to the recognition properties of the targeting unit and biodistribution of the radiopharmaceuticals. Therefore, more compact architecture are highly desirable.
Concerning the 19F MRI modality, small trifluoromethyl units have been efficiently used in sensitive or responsive probes based on azamacrocyclic complexes. First, trifluoromethylated cyclen-based chelators (Scheme 2) have proven excellent to coordinate paramagnetic lanthanide cations (Tb3+, Dy3+, Ho3+, Er3+ in particular) that decrease 19F relaxation times and drastically enhance the probes sensitivity.5,32–34 Similarly, CF3-appended cyclam chelators (Scheme 2) have been used with nickel(II) cations as sensitive probes,35,36 or as on–off responsive sensors with redox-active cations (Co2+, Cu2+) that can modulate the 19F MRI signal upon modification of their oxidation state by external stimuli.37,38 However, the lipophilic nature of such trifluoromethylated groups can be detrimental to applications in aqueous media and in vivo in particular.32
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Fluorinated azamacrocyclic complexes as sensitive or responsive probes for 19F-MRI imaging, and versatile Do2py2BF3 ligand presented in this work. | ||
Therefore, we report in this study a novel compact cyclen-based architecture, bearing methyltrifluoroborate units directly supported by the macrocyclic amines (Do2py2BF3, Scheme 2), to target two different applications with the same molecular topology: (i) allow easy 18F-radiolabeling via19F/18F isotopic exchange to allow future theranostic combinations with relevant radiometals; and (ii) present suitable 19F MRI signal, which has never been explored in the case of trifluoroborates, that could be used in responsive or sensitive imaging agents upon coordination with relevant non-radioactive paramagnetic cations. Noteworthy in the field (see AlF-NOTA or ScF-mptacn, Scheme 1), the chemistry of such chelators is first developed without the introduction of grafting functions and targeting molecules that will be necessary for future in vivo targeted applications. Therefore, the bispyridyl-cyclen scaffold has been selected in this proof-of-concept study for its ease of preparation and ubiquitous coordination properties.39–41 Herein, the synthesis and characterization of this novel ligand architecture is presented, as well as the corresponding zinc(II) complex, a convenient diamagnetic model complex that allowed easy NMR characterizations and simple stability studies. The ability of the scaffold to undergo 18F-labeling, as known for other types of trifluoroborates, was investigated on this new structure. Then the potential of BF3 units as 19F MRI reporters was also investigated for the first time on the model Zn(II) complex. Finally, a particular focus was given to the study of the solvolytic stability of the new trifluoroborated scaffolds in water at different pH, which is a crucial parameter to envisage future applications for this new type of chelators.
The new macrocycle was fully characterized by means of High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry (HRMS) and multinuclear NMR. In 1
:
1 D2O/CD3CN (pH 4), the ligand exhibits broad singlets in 19F (δ = −135.6 ppm) and 11B (δ = 2.44 ppm) NMR and a diagnostic quadruplet for the α-methylene group in 1H NMR (δ = 1.80 ppm, 3JH–F = 5.2 Hz) (see ESI† for spectral data). In 13C NMR, this methylenic carbon could not be directly observed owing to multiplicity and broadness induced by neighboring boron and fluorine nuclei, but was assigned thanks to 2D 1H–13C HSQC NMR (47.8 ppm). Single crystals were grown from a water/acetonitrile mixture (1
:
1, pH 4) revealing the neutral H2Do2py2BF3 ligand with both nitrogen atoms holding the BF3 pendants (N2 and N4, Fig. 1a) that are protonated.43 This feature is classical for cyclen-based ligands at this pH, as two amines in trans N1–N3 positions generally have pKas above 9.44
Single crystals were also grown from an acidic aqueous solution (pH 1), revealing a different structure with the ligand under the form H4Do2py2BF32+ displaying additional protonation of the two pyridine units (H5 and H6, Fig. 1b) creating a H-bonding network with fluorine atoms (F3 and F4) from both trifluoroborate pendants (dF4–H5 and dF3–H6 of 1.89 and 1.91 Å respectively). This constrained geometry is also present in solution at acidic pH, as evidenced by a set of 3 broad signals on the 19F spectrum from −136 to −140 ppm (D2O, pH 1), close to the sole chemical shift observed at pH 4 (−135.6 ppm). Similarly, 1H NMR spectrum reveals the different symmetry of the molecule with a complex multiplet centered at 4.16 ppm accounting for the four methylenic pyridyl protons (vs. sharp singlet at 4.49 ppm at pH 4), different multiplicity of the aromatic protons and a set of three broad signals between 1.90 and 2.30 ppm for the methylenic protons linked to the trifluoroborate units.
The corresponding zinc(II) complex was then prepared, from an equimolar mixture of H2Do2py2BF3 and zinc(II) perchlorate in acetonitrile at 60 °C, with potassium carbonate as a base, and purified by crystallization in a water/acetonitrile mixture (3
:
7). Owing to its limited solubility in water at high concentrations, NMR analysis was carried out in a 1
:
1 D2O/CD3CN mixture (pH 6). At RT, the 1H spectrum presents very broad signals for the macrocyclic protons, that could however be resolved at 333 K (Fig. S11, ESI†), and 19F NMR reveals a broad singlet at −137.4 ppm, very close to that of free ligand, as a first indication of the innocent nature of the trifluoroborate pendants upon coordination of the metal. More insight was gained by the structure revealed by X-ray diffraction analysis on single crystals of the complex grown in CH3CN/H2O (7
:
3) solution (Fig. 1c). Zinc(II) cation lies slightly above the cyclen plane (distance with N1–N2–N3–N4 centroid = 0.999 Å, Fig. S13, ESI†) and adopts a distorted trigonal prismatic geometry similar to the Zn(Do2py)2+ complex reported in the literature,40 highlighting again the innocent behaviour of the trifluoroborated groups in the coordination sphere of the metal. Only the Zn–N bonds with cyclen nitrogen atoms are somewhat longer in this complex (by up to 0.07 Å, Fig. S13, ESI†), probably owing to the different steric bulk on two nitrogen atoms from the ring (N–CH2–BF3vs. NH in Do2py).
The solvolytic stability of the new azamacrocyclic motifs was thus investigated for the free ligand and the Zn complex by 19F NMR, at a concentration of 3 × 10−2 M in buffered aqueous solutions at pH 2.0, 7.3 and 9.7 (Fig. S15–S20, ESI†). In these conditions, Do2py2BF3 demonstrated exceptional robustness with no degradation observed in any of the three pH conditions, after up to 3 days at 25 °C (Table 1). In particular, this observation is in contrast with the closest reported ammonium-based structure (Et2NH+CH2BF3) that displays a half-life of 66 hours at physiological pH.46 This enhanced stability in Do2py2BF3 is probably due to the higher basicity of the cyclen tertiary amines providing a poorly labile ammonium proton stabilizing the zwitterionic structure with the trifluoroborate group. On the zinc(II) complex, the stability is slightly different, owing to the loss of the ammonium protons to accommodate the metallic cation. First, at pH 2.0, a fast decoordination of the cation was evidenced by 19F NMR (t1/2(Zn) < 5 min, Fig. S18, ESI†), which is common with such highly basic polyamines at acidic pH. However, no degradation of the BF3 units was observed as only the 19F signals of the free ligand were recovered. At neutral and basic pH, no release of the metal occurred, demonstrating the strong coordination ability of the ligand. However, very slow solvolysis of the BF3 groups appeared (Fig. S19–S20,† ESI). As previously discussed in the literature by Perrin and others,45,47 the kinetics of solvolysis follow a pseudo-first order kinetic rate, with a rate-determining step corresponding to the loss of the first fluoride ion, and the other intermediates towards fully hydrolyzed boronic acid being fast-lived. Very long half-lives (985 and 400 hours at pH 7.3 and 9.7 respectively) could be calculated here for the new BF3 pendants, that are perfectly suited to consider further use in the context of 18F PET imaging when compared to the radioactive half-life of 18F (110 min) or the biodistribution and clearance of radiotracers (from minutes to a few days). Indeed, the stability of these pendants even surpasses the one of the most stable similar trifluoroborate functions described so far in the literature in these pH ranges (366 h for AMBF3 groups at pH 7.5).
| Compound | pH | t | % intact BF3 | t 1/2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Do2py2BF3 | 2.0 | 72 h | 100% | — |
| 7.3 | 72 h | 100% | — | |
| 9.7 | 72 h | 100% | — | |
| Zn(Do2py2BF3)2+ | 2.0 | 8 days | 100% (90% Zn release) | — |
| 7.3 | 22 h | 89% | 985 h | |
| 13 days | 77% | |||
| 9.7 | 18 h | 90% | 400 h | |
| 11 days | 63% |
![]() | ||
| Scheme 4 18F-radiolabeling of H2Do2py2BF3 and Zn(Do2py2BF3) in acetonitrile, and corresponding HPLC (UV) and radioHPLC traces for H2Do2py2BF3. | ||
RadioChemical Yields (RCY) were subsequently measured via radioHPLC analyses, with UV traces of the “cold” ligand or zinc complex as references (Fig. S22–S23, ESI†). In these conditions, highly satisfactory RCY of up to 68% was obtained for the ligand H2Do2py2BF3. RCY for the Zn(Do2py2BF3) complex is somewhat lower, probably owing to its lower solubility in the reaction medium, but is acceptable to envisage future applications in the field. Indeed, these RCY are excellent when compared to analogous isotopic exchange with trifluoroborates in similar conditions (15–30%)42,50 or labeling via metal-fluoride synthons (30–45% with Al,51 65% with Sc (ref. 24)). In addition to these conversions, labeled compounds could also be easily purified on semi-preparative HPLC with a Gemini C18 Column and formulated as injectable aqueous solutions after solubilization in NaCl solutions on C18 Sep-Pak cartridges within the automated system, which is one of the main advantages of such facile isotopic exchange on BF3 units. For the H2Do2py2BF3 radiolabeling, 30.6 GBq μmol−1 at the injection time were associated to the desired product whereas 7.8 GBq μmol−1 were obtained for the radiolabeled Zn(Do2py2BF3). These results on the molar activities are good enough for further in vivo studies and consistent with the reference publications (around 40–110 GBq μmol−1 for high specific activity).48
:
1) solution of Zn(Do2py2BF3) at a concentration of 0.032 M in complex (i.e.19F concentration of 0.192 M owing to the 6 fluorine atoms per molecule). A single peak in 19F modality was detectable at −137 ppm. Longitudinal (T1) relaxivity was measured with an inversion recovery sequence, while the transversal (T2) relaxivity was measured with a CPMG sequence, leading to values of T1 = 383.7 ± 0.01 ms and T2 = 268 ± 0.02 ms. These are reasonably short relaxation times compared to corresponding ligands bearing trifluoromethyl groups (i.e. two to three times lower T1 than cyclam methylene-CF3 analogue with diamagnetic Cu(I) cation),5,38 that allowed a large number of averages to be accumulated in a short time. Then a phantom was prepared with variable 19F concentrations ranging from 1 mM to 150 mM (Fig. 2). Samples with 19F concentration of 50, 100 and 150 mM were clearly detectable already after 10 min of acquisition (corresponding Zn(Do2py2BF3) concentration of 8.3, 16.7 and 25 mM, respectively). After 45 min of acquisition, samples with 15 and 25 mM 19F were barely visible so a different phantom (25–150 mM) was used for detection limit measurement with 10, 45 and 60 minutes acquisition (Fig. 2). From these data, a detection limit between 50 and 75 mM in 19F was observed at t = 10 minutes, and of 40 mM in 19F (6.7 mM in complex) could be determined for acquisition times of 45 and 60 minutes. This value is clearly in the range of perfluorocarbons used in preclinical and clinical studies.52
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, spectroscopic data for characterization and stability studies of the new compounds, and experimental details for 18F labeling and 19F magnetic resonance experiments. CCDC 2314190–2314192. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc02871f |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |