Sk
Sakir Hossain
a,
Veerappan
Karthik
b,
Amarajothi
Dhakshinamoorthy
*bc and
Shyam
Biswas
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, Guwahati, 781039 Assam, India. E-mail: sbiswas@iitg.ac.in
bSchool of Chemistry, Madurai Kamaraj University, Madurai-625 021, Tamil Nadu, India. E-mail: admguru@gmail.com
cDepartamento de Química, Universitat Politècnica de València, C/Camino de Vera, s/n, 46022, Valencia, Spain
First published on 2nd November 2023
Developing a robust, reliable, fast-detecting sensor is a significant challenge for present-day researchers. Hence, a dual-functional fluorometric sensor was designed to detect heavy metal ions (e.g., Hg2+) and anti-histamine drugs (e.g., ranitidine) at the nanomolar level in the aqueous medium. A stable and efficient thiourea-functionalized aluminum−based metal-organic framework (MOF) was prepared and its guest-free form was applied for the selective detection of the above-mentioned analytes with a low detection limit (Hg2+ = 7.3 nM and ranitidine = 3.4 nM). The MOF was exceptionally sensitive to Hg2+ and ranitidine detection with a fast response time of 10 s and 5 s, respectively. Our probe has the highest KSV values for these targeted analytes among the sensors documented to date (i.e., 1.29 × 106 M−1 for Hg2+ and 7.99 × 105 M−1 for ranitidine). This work reports the first MOF-based sensor for ranitidine detection. About 93% and 98% fluorescence quenching was observed after introducing Hg2+ and ranitidine, respectively. The probe has excellent selectivity toward detecting Hg2+ and ranitidine, even in the presence of interfering analytes. The sensing capability of the probe was explored in different media, including serum, urine, wastewater, different pH, etc., which indicates the real-field applicability of the sensor. A cost-effective, highly efficient, long-lasting MOF@polymer thin-film composite (MOF@PVDF-PVP) was employed for the on-field qualitative detection of Hg2+ and ranitidine. The mechanistic insights into the sensing were well explored with the help of different modern analytical techniques. The ground-state complexation and inner filter effect were responsible for fluorescence quenching in the presence of Hg2+ and ranitidine, respectively. Furthermore, the catalytic performance of 1′ was investigated in the Friedel–Crafts alkylation reaction between indole and β-nitrostyrene in toluene at 70 °C and the product was observed in 98% yield. The solid maintained its activity up to four cycles. The integrity and morphology of the four times used 1′ are identical to those of pristine 1′. The catalyst was also active to prepare a series of products under the optimized conditions.
Ranitidine is a widely used medication belonging to histamine-2 receptor antagonists. It is commonly prescribed to individuals suffering from gastrointestinal disorders, such as acid reflux, peptic ulcers, and heartburn.6 The primary function of ranitidine is to alleviate these conditions by reducing the production of stomach acid. Ranitidine sensing in different biological media (plasma and serum) is vital for therapeutic drug monitoring. By measuring the levels of ranitidine in a patient's blood or plasma, healthcare professionals can determine the drug's concentration and ensure that it falls within the optimal therapeutic range. This information allows for dosage adjustments, ensuring patients receive the appropriate medication to manage their gastrointestinal condition effectively.
Ranitidine can have adverse effects on the environment. It can enter water bodies through sewage systems and wastewater treatment plants, causing aquatic toxicity and disrupting the growth and survival of aquatic organisms. Ranitidine also has the potential to bioaccumulate in organisms, leading to higher concentrations in predators. Its improper disposal or presence in wastewater can contaminate groundwater, posing risks to drinking water sources. Additionally, the use of ranitidine has been associated with the development of antimicrobial resistance.7 Proper management and disposal practices are essential to mitigate the environmental impact of ranitidine.
In aqueous media, detecting Hg2+ ions has been challenging due to the interference from other metal ions and the low concentration of Hg2+ ions. Similarly, detecting ranitidine in biological medium is also quite difficult due to other components in a complex medium. Several techniques have been introduced for detecting these analytes, including chromatography,8 electrochemical,9 and fluorometric1 based sensing. Among these methods, the fluorescence-based method is one of the most popular techniques due to its simple and easy handling processes.10 Different fluorescent probes have been designed to detect Hg2+ ions and ranitidine, including organic molecular probes, quantum dots, carbon nanotubes, and MOFs.11–14 Among them, MOFs are potential materials for sensing applications owing to their high surface area, tunable pore sizes, and easily functionalized structures.15,16
After going through several reported works, we found that sulfur-containing fluorophores could respond to the presence of Hg2+ ions, following the HSAB principle. We observed the UV-vis absorption maximum of ranitidine at 325 nm. Hence, a probe with an excitation maximum near 325 nm could detect ranitidine through a non-radiative energy transfer pathway. This idea was explored by synthesizing a thioureido containing fluorophore-based Al-MOF (Scheme 1). Our probe can detect Hg2+ and ranitidine in aqueous and HEPES buffer (pH = 7.4) media. The fluorescence quenching efficiencies of Hg2+ and ranitidine were 93% and 98%, respectively. Different modern analytical techniques were employed to investigate the mechanism of sensing thoroughly. The sensing ability of the probe towards the targeted analytes was explored in different real water samples and in different pH media. A polyvinylidene difluoride-polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVDF-PVP) thin film-based MOF composite was also introduced for qualitative point-of-care detection of these analytes. The real-field applicability, selectivity, and ultralow detection limit make our designed probe distinct for detecting Hg2+ and ranitidine.
The Friedel–Crafts alkylation reaction between β-nitrostyrene (NS) and indole (IND) is one of the reactions often employed as a prototypical reaction to screen the catalytic activity of MOF solids.17–20 Besides, this reaction can also be considered as a straightforward reaction to access a series of heterocyclic compounds exhibiting a wide range of biological activities. In addition, this reaction is also used by many researchers to demonstrate the influence of different functionalities embedded within the framework and to establish size-selective catalysis.21 The Friedel–Crafts alkylation reaction between IND and NS has been reported by using a series of MOFs that include CSMCRI-17,22 La(III)-MOF,23 urea-modified MOFs,24 urea-modified UiO-67,25 UiO-66(Ce),26 amide functionalized MOFs,27 Cu3(BTC)228 and squaramide functionalized Zr-MOF.29 Thus, the present work aims to address the influence of the thioureido functionality on Al-based MOFs as well as size-selective catalytic behavior. Beside these primary objectives, catalyst stability and substrate scope were also investigated.
The sharp peaks in the PXRD profile of 1 revealed the high crystallinity of the synthesized MOF material. The PXRD patterns of 1 and 1′ are almost similar to that of the parent MOF (Fig. 1b). These findings confirm the high structural similarity of 1 with the parent MOF. This structural similarity was further supported by Pawley refinement of PXRD profile of 1′ (Fig. 1c). The obtained lower values Rp = 5.3% and Rwp = 3.4% suggest the high similarity between the observed and simulated PXRD profiles of 1′.
The FE-SEM images were collected to investigate the morphology of the synthesized MOF. A homogeneous distribution of nano-rod shaped particles was observed in the FE-SEM images of 1′, a common morphology of the pristine MOF (Fig. 1d). The average diameter of the particles, observed from DLS measurement, was 589 nm (Fig. S3†). Apart from these findings, the EDX spectrum (Fig. S4†) of 1′ was also recorded to confirm the presence of the desired elements i.e. C, O, N, S and Al in the MOF. The EDX elemental mapping (Fig. S5†) signified the homogeneous distribution of the above elements in 1′.
O stretching frequency for carboxylate is observed at 1595 cm−1 in 1 and 1′, whereas the same for the linker is noticed at 1643 cm−1. Another common peak is observed at 1705 cm−1 for the linker, 1 and 1′, which verifies the presence of the amide functionality and supports the intact nature of the desired functionality in the synthesized MOF. Apart from these peaks, a peak at around 1204 cm−1 suggests the existence of the –C
S functional group appended with the linker molecule. Moreover, the 1H NMR spectrum (Fig. S7†) of digested 1′ revealed the retention of the desired functionality in the synthesized MOF.
The TG analysis of 1 and 1′ was conducted under N2 atmosphere to determine their thermal stability (Fig. S9†). For compound 1, a weight loss of 4.9% was observed in the 30–300 °C temperature range due to the loss of one water molecule per unit formula of 1 (calculated weight loss was 4.9%). After 300 °C, a continuous weight loss was observed, which implies the breaking of the framework. A similar weight loss step was followed for 1′, except for the weight loss due to the elimination of water molecules. Hence, both the samples were stable up to 300 °C.
Overall, the results from PXRD and TG analyses highlight the high chemical and thermal stabilities of 1′ in diverse chemical environments, making it a promising sensor for various applications.
A systematic volume-dependent fluorescence sensing experiment was executed to determine the volume of 10 mM Hg2+ solution required for the maximum possible fluorescence quenching. This experiment was performed upon the incremental addition of 25 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ solution to the aqueous MOF suspension (3100 μL). Upon gradual addition of Hg2+ solution, the fluorescence emission intensity of the probe showed gradual reduction, as depicted in Fig. 2a. There was no further fluorescence quenching after the addition of 100 μL of Hg2+ solution (10 mM concentration).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Change in the fluorescence intensity of 1′ after incremental addition of (a) 10 mM Hg2+ and (b) 5 mM ranitidine solutions in aqueous and HEPES buffer media, respectively. | ||
In a similar way, the volume-dependent fluorometric titration experiment was executed for ranitidine sensing in HEPES buffer medium with incremental (50 μL for each step) addition of 5 mM ranitidine solution. For ranitidine recognition, the maximum fluorescence quenching occurred after the addition of 200 μL of 5 mM ranitidine solution, as depicted in Fig. 2b. The quenching efficiency for both analytes were calculated using the formula (1 − I/I0) × 100, where I0 and I represent the fluorescence intensity of 1′ before and after the addition of the targeted analyte, respectively. It was found that the probe's 93% and 98% fluorescence intensity was quenched after introducing 100 μL and 200 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ and 5 mM ranitidine solution, respectively.
We also conducted the time-dependent fluorescence titration experiment in order to determine the response time of our synthesized probe 1′. For time-dependent fluorescence titration experiment, 100 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ solution was added at a time to 3100 μL MOF suspension. The fluorescence data were recorded with a time interval of 5 s. There was 93% fluorescence quenching of the probe within 10 s after introducing 100 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ solution and no further quenching was observed after 10 s (Fig. 3a). This was confirmed by performing kinetic experiment. In fluorescence kinetic experiment, the fluorescence intensity of the MOF at 388 nm was recorded with respect to time (up to 50 s) upon excitation at 320 nm. After 50 s, we added 100 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ solution and recorded the fluorescence intensity for up to 200 s. The result shows that 93% quenching took place within 10 s (Fig. 3b). Similar protocols were adopted to determine the response time of 1′ toward ranitidine sensing. It was observed that the fluorescence intensity was quenched by 98% within 5 s upon introduction of 200 μL of 5 mM ranitidine solution (Fig. 3c and d). Therefore, it can be concluded that our probe has ultrafast detection time for both the analytes in comparison to other fluorescent sensors reported to date (Table S7†).
An ideal sensor should respond to a target analyte in the presence of other interfering analytes. In this regard, the selectivity of 1′ towards Hg2+ was investigated in the presence of different metal ions like Cu2+, Ag+, K+, Na+, Cd2+, Zn2+, Mg2+, Mn2+, Pb2+, Ni2+, Fe2+, Pt2+, Pd2+, Al3+, Cr3+ and Co2+. We have used different counter anions for different metal ions (Cl−, SO42−, NO3−, NO2−, F−, CH3COO−, etc.). The interference study was also conducted by using the sodium salts of these counter anions (Fig. S14–S37†). To examine the selectivity towards Hg2+, 100 μL of each competitive analyte solution (10 mM concentration) was added to the probe suspension. Subsequently, 100 μL of 10 mM Hg2+ solution was added. As depicted in Fig. 4a, no analyte had a quenching efficiency more than 30%, except Hg2+ which showed a quenching efficiency of 93%. Moreover, the interfering analytes did not alter the quenching efficiency of the probe considerably (Fig. 4c).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Selectivity of 1′ towards (a) Hg2+ and (c) ranitidine over other analytes and selectivity of 1′ towards (b) Hg2+ and (d) ranitidine in presence of other analytes. | ||
In order to examine the selectivity towards ranitidine, 200 μL solution of individual competitive analyte solution (5 mM concentration) was added to the dispersion of the MOF and subsequently 200 μL of 5 mM ranitidine solution was added. The competitive analytes of ranitidine included glucose, alanine, phenylalanine, histidine, K+, Na+, Mg2+, aspartic acid, glutamic acid, serine, tartaric acid, ascorbic acid, creatinine, glutathione, uric acid and urea (Fig. S38–S53†). As depicted in Fig. 4b, all the analytes showed less than 25% quenching efficiency except for ranitidine, which exhibited a quenching efficiency of 98%. Furthermore, the quenching efficiency of ranitidine was not hampered by the presence of different analytes (Fig. 4b–d).
Stern–Volmer constant (KSV) is directly related to the quenching efficiency of a quencher. A higher value of KSV signifies higher quenching and vice versa. We plotted I0/I as a function of analyte concentration for both Hg2+ and ranitidine to evaluate the KSV values for both the targeted analytes (Fig. S54 and S55†). The obtained KSV values are 1.29 × 106 M−1 and 7.99 × 105 M−1 for Hg2+ and ranitidine, respectively. These values are higher than those of reported sensors for fluorometric detection of both analytes (Table S7†). From the large values of KSV, it can be inferred that both Hg2+ and ranitidine exert strong interactions with the probe. The 3D Stern–Volmer plots of both the targeted analytes are also shown in Fig. 5a and b, which imply that our sensor is highly selective to the targeted analytes in the respective medium.
An ideal sensor should be able to detect very low concentration of an analyte. To estimate our sensor's limit of detection (LOD), we performed fluorescence experiments for both analytes in concentration ranges as low as possible. The formula 3σ/k was utilized to find out the LOD values for both analytes, where k is slope of the linearly fitted plot of the fluorescence intensity of 1′versus the concentration of analytes (Fig. S56 and S57†) and σ is standard deviation of 10 blank fluorescence readings of MOF suspension. The LOD values are 7.3 nM and 3.4 nM for Hg2+ and ranitidine, respectively. The LOD value for Hg2+ is comparable to those of previously reported MOF-based sensors (Table S7†). As per our knowledge, this is the first MOF-based ranitidine sensor. The LOD for ranitidine is the lowest amongst the fluorescent sensors reported to date (Table S8†).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Fluorescence quenching efficiency of (a) Hg2+ and (c) ranitidine in different real water specimens and sensing ability of 1′ in different pH media for (b) Hg2+ and (d) ranitidine. | ||
Our probe can detect ranitidine in HEPES buffer medium, different water specimens and a wide pH range. The ranitidine sensing ability of 1′ in various media was investigated in a previously mentioned way as for Hg2+. The obtained results are depicted in Fig. 6c and d. These findings suggest that our probe can be used for real-field monitoring of Hg2+ and ranitidine.
000 rpm for 10 min. The obtained supernatant was used for fluorescence experiments. The experimental results (Fig. S60†) imply that our probe can detect ranitidine even in pharmaceutical samples.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 Detection of various concentrations of (a) Hg2+ and (b) ranitidine using the MOF@PVDF-PVP thin film composite. | ||
The obtained PXRD patterns of 1′ (Fig. S63†) before and after detection experiments were analogous, implying the retention of the structural integration of 1′ after sensing. Then, we executed the time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) experiment of 1′ before and after the addition of targeted analytes to evaluate the excited-state fluorescence lifetime of 1′. The experimental results are displayed in Fig. S66 and S67, and Tables S3 and S4.† It was observed that there were no significant changes in the lifetime of 1′ in the presence of targeted analytes. These results omitted the possibility of PET or FRET-based quenching.
In the case of ground-state complexation, there should be a change in the position of maximum absorbance (λmax) after the addition of analyte, whereas this is unaltered for IFE-based quenching.37 We observed that the addition of Hg2+ to the aqueous suspension of 1′ caused a significant change in the λmax value (Fig. S68†). However, no such variation in the λmax value happened in the case of ranitidine. Ground-state complexation is the most probable reason behind Hg2+ sensing as 1′ contains a soft donor S atom and Hg2+ is a soft acceptor. We have performed various experiments to establish the feasibility of ground-state complexation between Hg2+ and S atoms, including EDX, fluorescence, UV-vis spectrophotometry, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), XPS analysis, etc.
The EDX spectrum and elemental mapping (Fig. S69 and S70†) of 1′ after treating with Hg2+ (without washing) confirmed the presence of Hg2+. The reusability of our probe (Fig. S61†) after thoroughly washing with water implies the presence of weak interaction between Hg2+ and 1′. There was a significant change in both the excitation and emission spectra of 1′ upon introducing Hg2+ (Fig. S68†). We have also executed solid-state UV-vis spectroscopy of 1′ before and after treating with Hg2+ (Fig. S71†). We found a red shift (32 nm) in the UV-vis spectrum of 1′ after Hg2+ addition. These results indicate the formation of a complex between 1′ and Hg2+.
A systematic ITC experiment was performed to further investigate the mechanism of sensing. Various thermodynamic parameters such as binding constant (Ki), enthalpy change (ΔH) and entropy change (ΔS), etc., could be obtained from this experiment. In this experiment, Hg2+ solution was used as the titrant while the linker solution was used as the titrate. Both of them were taken in water. A certain amount of Hg2+ solution was injected into the linker solution with a constant time interval and the heat change was recorded upon each injection. The obtained results are depicted in Fig. S72 and Table S5.† The negative values of ΔH and ΔS confirmed that the exothermic complexation reaction occurred after adding Hg2+ to the linker solution. These observations again support our mechanistic assumption.
The soft–soft interaction between the ‘S’ atom and ‘Hg2+’ was further proved by XPS analysis. The 2s orbital binding energies of sulphur shifted significantly to higher energy after introducing Hg2+ in 1′ (Fig. S73†). Apart from this, the shifting of binding energies for all elements was observed before and after the addition of Hg2+ (Fig. S74–S78†). These shifts imply the electron transfer from 1′ to Hg2+ and the fluorescence quenching of 1′ resulted from it.
In the case of ranitidine, there was no change in lifetime after the addition of ranitidine (Fig. S67 and Table S4†). This result omitted the possibility of dynamic quenching: either FRET or PET. No considerable overlap between the emission spectrum of 1′ and the absorption spectrum of ranitidine (Fig. S79†) excluded the probability of the FRET mechanism.
The possibility of PET behind fluorescence quenching was further investigated by comparing the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) and the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) energies of the free linker and ranitidine. Density functional theory (DFT) was utilized to obtain the HOMO–LUMO of the free linker and ranitidine. All calculations were performed using the Pople diffuse basis set 6-31G+(d, p) and B3LYP functional. The LUMO of the linker has much lower energy than that of ranitidine (Fig. S80†). Therefore, the probability of electron transfer from the excited state of the linker to the LUMO of ranitidine was negligible, which diminishes the possibility of PET behind the detection of ranitidine.
A large overlap was noticed between the excitation spectrum of 1′ and the absorption spectrum of ranitidine (Fig. S79†). This observation suggested that the IFE might be a probable reason behind the fluorescence quenching of the MOF after ranitidine inclusion. We performed UV-vis spectroscopy of the targeted analyte along with all the interfering analytes to prove it. It was observed that the normalized absorption spectrum of ranitidine highly overlapped with the normalized excitation spectrum of 1′ and this did not occur in the cases of other analytes (Fig. S79†). The IFE-based sensing mechanism was further investigated by introducing the IFE correction factor. Here, the quenching efficiency was calculated after removing the contribution of IFE for quenching. The obtained results are depicted in Fig. S81 and Table S6.† After removing the IFE contribution, the considerable drop in quenching efficiency suggested that the IFE is the most probable mechanism for ranitidine sensing. Although IFE was previously considered an error in fluorescence measurements, it is well established now as a non-irradiative mechanistic model for energy transfer in the spectroscopic technique. It has been used to develop various photoluminescence-based sensors.39,40 From all the above experimental results, we can conclude that the ground state complexation and IFE are the most plausible reasons behind the fluorescence quenching of 1′ in the presence of Hg2+ and ranitidine, respectively.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 Time–yield plots for Friedel–Crafts alkylation between IND and NS using (a) 1′ as a solid catalyst, (b) MIL-53(Al)-NH2 as a catalyst and (c) leaching test in the absence of 1′. | ||
A mandatory experiment in heterogeneous catalysis is to perform leaching and reusability tests to ascertain catalyst integrity under the optimized conditions. Leaching experiment was conducted under the optimized reaction conditions and the solid was filtered after 1 h. The remaining reaction mixture was continued without the solid catalyst and the reaction rate was compared with the reaction rate in the presence of the solid catalyst. Comparison of the product yields between these two reactions clearly indicates that the reaction did not proceed further after the removal of the solid catalyst. Hence, the reaction occurs via a heterogeneous manner without leaching of any active site into solution. The solid catalyst was recovered after the reaction through filtration. After washing and proper drying, it was used again in successive cycles. Fig. 9 shows that 1′ could retain its performance up to four cycles without any decay in its yield. Furthermore, FE-SEM images and PXRD patterns also suggest that the particle morphology and crystallinity of the used solid were not affected with respect to the fresh solid catalyst (Fig. S82 and S83†). Thus, these results imply the stability of 1′ under the present experimental conditions.
Considering the activity achieved with 1′ as a catalyst for the Friedel–Crafts alkylation reaction between IND and NS, a possible mechanism is proposed and it is shown in Scheme 2. As can be seen in Scheme 2, the thioureido moieties in 1′ interact with NS by establishing hydrogen bonding. This is one of the important intermediates to alter electron density in NS and such intermediates have been reported in the literature due to the involvement of hydrogen bond donating sites.41–43 Thus, the activity of 1′ was significantly higher compared to that of MIL-53(Al)-NH2 as a catalyst under similar conditions. This interaction of NS with hydrogen bonding sites creates electron deficiency in the C
C double bond of NS. Furthermore, IND attacks NS through the C3 carbon to afford the desired product. Thus, the catalyst can be regenerated and recycled in subsequent cycles.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Proposed mechanism for the Friedel–Crafts alkylation between IND and NS using 1′ as a catalyst. | ||
The catalytic activity of 1′ with different substrates as well as the size-selective catalytic behaviour was investigated (Table 1 and Fig. S84–S95†). The above optimized conditions were considered to prepare a series of heterocyclic compounds. In this aspect, the reaction of IND with NS afforded 98% yield utilizing 1′ at 70 °C in toluene after 24 h. Under identical conditions, the reaction of 1-methylindole and NS resulted in 96% yield using 1′ as a solid catalyst. A similar activity was also observed for the reaction between 2-methylindole and NS with 1′ as a catalyst under identical conditions. The reaction of 5-methoxyindole and 5-bromoindole with NS gave 97 and 54% yields using 1′ as a catalyst under the same conditions. The coupling between pyrrole and NS was also efficient to achieve 93% yield using 1′ as a catalyst. Under the same conditions, no product was obtained when 5-nitroindole was reacted with NS. Furthermore, efforts to perform the reaction between N-Boc protected IND and NS using 1′ as a solid catalyst also failed. This is a suitable example to illustrate size selective catalysis. It suggests that the diffusion of the larger substrates towards the active sites is hindered due to their larger kinetic dimensions and thus no reaction occurred.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Linker synthesis details, 1H NMR, mass, and 13C NMR spectra of free linker, ATR-IR spectra of MOF and free linker, TGA plot, EDX spectrum, BET isotherms, fluorescence spectra, TRPL plot, UV-vis spectra, recyclability plot, and catalytic data. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3qi01890c |
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2024 |