Haixuan
Yu‡
a,
Tao
Zhang‡
a,
Zhiguo
Zhang
a,
Zhirong
Liu
a,
Qiang
Sun
a,
Junyi
Huang
a,
Letian
Dai
a,
Yan
Shen
a,
Xiongjie
Li
*a and
Mingkui
Wang
*ab
aWuhan National Laboratory for Optoelectronics, School of Optoelectronic Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, 1037 Luoyu Road, Wuhan 430074, Hubei, P. R. China. E-mail: xiongjieli@hust.edu.cn; mingkui.wang@mail.hust.edu.cn
bOptics Valley Laboratory, Wuhan, Hubei 430074, P. R. China
First published on 4th July 2024
All-inorganic lead-free CsSnI3 has shown promising potential in optoelectronic applications, particularly in near-infrared perovskite light-emitting diodes (Pero-LEDs). However, non-radiative recombination induced by defects hinders the optoelectronic properties of CsSnI3-based Pero-LEDs, limiting their potential applications. Here, we uncovered that β-CsSnI3 exhibits higher defect tolerance compared to orthorhombic γ-CsSnI3, offering a potential for enhancing the emission efficiency. We further reported on the deposition and stabilization of highly crystalline β-CsSnI3 films with the assistance of cesium formate to suppress electron–phonon scattering and reduce nonradiative recombination. This leads to an enhanced photoluminescence quantum yield up to ∼10%. As a result, near-infrared LEDs based on β-CsSnI3 emitters are achieved with a peak external quantum efficiency of 1.81% and excellent stability under a high current injection of 1.0 A cm−2.
New conceptsWe report for the first time utilizing high defect tolerance tetragonal β-CsSnI3 films for efficient and stable lead-free near-infrared (NIR) perovskite light-emitting diodes (Pero-LEDs). CsSnI3 has emerged as a promising candidate for NIR Pero-LEDs due to its unique electronic configuration, optical property, and excellent intrinsic inorganic stability. However, the defect-induced nonradiative recombination hampers the optoelectronic properties of CsSnI3-based Pero-LEDs. Herein, we propose a crystal phase engineering strategy to induce the formation of high defect-tolerance β-CsSnI3 by introducing cesium formate into the precursor. The introduction of a small amount of CsFa plays a key role in suppressing the tilting of the [SnI6]4− octahedron, thus preventing the transformation of β-CsSnI3 into γ-CsSnI3 at room temperature. In the as-prepared β-CsSnI3 films, electron–phonon scattering is effectively suppressed and non-radiative recombination is reduced, which increases the photoluminescence quantum yield. The highly defect-tolerant β-CsSnI3 thin films introduced in this work offer new prospects for high-performance NIR LEDs and other optoelectronic devices. |
Recently, CsSnI3 has shown promising potential in NIR Pero-LEDs due to its high photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY), optical gain, and carrier mobility as high as ∼585 cm2 V−1 s−1.17–19 Despite its excellent optoelectronic properties, the applications of CsSnI3 in Pero-LEDs still face great challenges, such as uncontrollable crystallization and high-dense defects. Various strategies have been pursued to modulate the crystallization process and suppress the defect-induced non-radiative recombination, including solvent engineering, reductant addition, and molecular passivation.19–21 However, there is a need to explore approaches for further enhancing the light-emission properties of CsSnI3.
In a typical CsSnI3 perovskite structure, the off-center Cs atoms and the distortion of the [SnI6]4− octahedra cuase four different temperature-dependent polymorphs.15 Cubic α-CsSnI3 is found to be stable above 500 K.22 As the temperature decreases to approximately 431.5 K, black tetragonal β-CsSnI3 forms, which further transitions into the stable black orthorhombic γ-CsSnI3 as the temperature reaches about 352 K.22,23 Therefore, CsSnI3-based optoelectronic devices are mostly based on γ-CsSnI3 due to its preferred thermodynamic stability. However, the low crystal structure symmetry of γ-CsSnI3 plays a negative effect on the light-emitting efficiency.
Herein, we propose a crystal-phase method for preparation of tetragonal β-CsSnI3 perovskite films for high-efficiency and stable NIR PeLEDs. The theoretical calculations with density functional theory (DFT) indicate that β-CsSnI3 has higher symmetry and defect tolerance than orthorhombic phase γ-CsSnI3, which allows efficient light-emission. We fabricated β-CsSnI3 perovskite films by incorporating a small amount of cesium formate (CsFa) in the precursor via a facile one-step deposition method. The β-CsSnI3 exhibits an increased radiative recombination and a decreased electron–phonon scatterings than γ-CsSnI3, leading to an enhanced PLQY from 4.0% to 10.0%. The corresponding NIR Pero-LEDs achieved an EQE of 1.81% and demonstrated outstanding operational stability with a T50 (i.e., the time that a device lose 50% luminance) of 6 min under a high injection current density of 1000 mA cm−2.
m space group, the neighboring [SnI6]4− octahedra in the β-CsSnI3 are tilted in the ab plane. However, for the case of γ-CsSnI3, the tilting of the octahedra occurs both along the apical and equatorial directions. Consequently, the symmetry decreases successively from cubic to tetragonal and finally orthorhombic.15,24 A high crystal symmetry is essential for maintaining the defect tolerance of the perovskite.24–26 The slight octahedral tilting in the lattice of β-CsSnI3 with a larger Sn–I–Sn bond angle of 167.9°compared to those in γ-CsSnI3 (157.6° and 166.0°), leads to the strong antibonding state due to significant Sn–I overlap.27 This attribute is crucial for maintaining defect tolerance. The latter is a key factor contributing to the performance of Pero-LEDs.25,27 The PBE band structures and dipole transition matrix elements of three CsSnI3 perovskite phases are shown in Fig. 1b–d. As shown in Fig. 1b, α-CsSnI3 shows characteristics of a direct bandgap semiconductor, featuring the valence band maximum (VBM) and conduction band minimum (CBM) located at the high symmetry point R within the Brillouin zone. The crystal symmetry of β-CsSnI3 is reduced, resulting in spin–orbit and crystal field splitting. Meanwhile, the R point in α-CsSnI3 becomes the Z point in β-CsSnI3 by rotation and folding (Fig. 1c). When the symmetry structure is further destroyed to form γ-CsSnI3, the band can be folded along Z near the midpoint H (Fig. 1d). Despite of these alterations in the band structure, β-CsSnI3 and γ -CsSnI3 still maintain the direct bandgap and the narrow bandgap properties. The sum of the squares of the transition dipole moment elements (D2) at various k points reveals the high optical transition probabilities between the valence and conduction bands.28 The D2 values of different structures were compared in arbitrary units. The square magnitude of transition dipole moment elements indicates the coupling strength between Sn 5s and I 5p orbitals, which is influenced by the transient charge distribution (electrons and holes) within the perovskite structure. This serves as a figure-of-merit for the overlap of electron–hole wave functions.28,29 As shown in Fig. 1b–d, all the perovskite phases exhibit no parity-forbidden transitions, in which α-CsSnI3 and β-CsSnI3 with higher symmetry has larger dipole transition matrix elements compared to γ-CsSnI3 around their high symmetry points. This tunability of the electronic transition and the higher coupling strength make α-CsSnI3 and β-CsSnI3 more promising for efficient light emission than orthorhombic γ-CsSnI3. Theoretically, α-CsSnI3 and β-CsSnI3 have higher symmetry and defect tolerance than orthorhombic γ-CsSnI3, and thus have the potential for efficient light-emission. Unfortunately, α-CsSnI3 is unstable below 500 K and exists only as an intermediate state.22 Therefore, it is a great chance and challenge to experimentally deposit β-CsSnI3 films for efficient and stable near-infrared Pero-LEDs.
A series of precursor solutions were prepared by dissolving equimolar amounts of CsI and SnI2 in the precursor solution, with varying molar ratios of CsFa (0 to 8 mol%) added. The CsSnI3 films were prepared using a single-step spin-coating method, followed by annealing at 110 °C for 10 min. X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements were conducted on the scratched powder of as-deposited CsSnI3 films to assess the impact of CsFa on their lattice structures. Strong XRD peaks at 14.45° and 29.11° are observed for the pristine CsSnI3 (Fig. 2a), which are assigned to the (101) and (202) reflections of orthorhombic γ-CsSnI3 (ICSD#262926). Strong XRD peaks at 14.25° and 28.94° are observed for the CsSnI3 with the 4 mol% CsFa (Fig. 2b), which can be indexed to the (110) and (220) reflections of tetragonal β-CsSnI3 (ICSD#262925). These XRD peaks are observed only above 230 °C.23 High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) characterization was further performed to clarify the formation of the β-CsSnI3 phase. Fig. S1 (ESI†) shows the results. For the pristine CsSnI3, the observed fringe spacing of 3.34 Å corresponds to the (202) plane of γ-CsSnI3 (Fig. S1a and c, ESI†). For the CsSnI3 treated with CsFa, 2-dimensional lattice fringes with inter-plane spacings of 3.42 Å and 6.12 Å indicated in the magnified HRTEM image (Fig. S1b and d, ESI†) are attributed to the (220) and the (002) planes of the β-CsSnI3 phase, respectively. The zone axis is determined to be along the [10
] direction and the angle between the two planes is 89.5° based on the indexed fast Fourier transform (FFT) pattern. The lattice spacing of these two planes and the angle between them are consistent with theoretical values (Table S1, ESI†), clearly indicating the existence of β-CsSnI3 in the sample treated with CsFa.15 The film surface became rough when the concentration of CsFa exceeded 8 mol%. Therefore, we chose 4 mol% as the optimized concentration.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Crystal structure evolution. XRD plots of the scratched powder from (a) the pristine CsSnI3 and (b) the CsFa-treated CsSnI3 films. The standard β and γ-CsSnI3 patterns were calculated for Cu Kα1 radiation determined by Chung et al.15 The temperature-dependent XRD evolution for (c) the pristine CsSnI3 and (d) the CsFa-treated CsSnI3 films. | ||
In situ temperature-dependent XRD measurements were performed to further explore the crystal structure evolutions of CsSnI3. In Fig. 2c and d, both CsSnI3 films exhibit similar XRD peaks at 29.15° at 300 °C, which are assigned to the (200) reflections of cubic α-CsSnI3. As temperature decreases, additional peaks appear at positions between integral values of Miller indices of α-CsSnI3, indicating a decrease in the crystal symmetry due to the tilting of the [SnI6]4− octahedra comprising the perovskite lattice.30 In the pristine CsSnI3 (Fig. 2c), as the temperature decreases, the peak of (200) reflection splits from 29.13° to 29.44°, indicating the phase transition from a cubic to an orthorhombic structure, while in the CsFa-treated CsSnI3 (Fig. 2d), the peak of (200) only turns up from 29.15° to 29.28°, aligning with expectations for the tetragonal β-CsSnI3 phase. The pattern distinctly contrasted with those observed in α- and γ-CsSnI3 systems (Fig. S2, ESI†). These observations suggest that during the cooling process, the pristine CsSnI3 undergoes a phase transition from the cubic phase to its tetragonal isomer. In contrast, introducing CsFa halts the phase transition, resulting in a final tetragonal phase. These results suggested that introducing CsFa can significantly affect the crystal phase of the final CsSnI3 perovskite.
To probe the impact of CsFa on the formation of crystal structures, we focused on the precursor solutions due to their crucial role in crystallization. We utilized UV-vis spectroscopy (Fig. S3, ESI†) to observe each precursor state of CsSnI3 in the solution phase. In the pure CsSnI3 precursor solution, we noted an aggregated feature around 450 nm presumably due to the crystalline solvate interaction. This indicates that the CsSnI3 precursor exhibits robust chemical interactions with the DMF/DMSO mixed solvent, leading to the formation of a solvate complex.31 After incorporating the CsFa, the absorption edge blue-shifted to a smaller edge wavelength of 400 nm, attributing to a lower degree of crystalline solvate interaction in the precursor solution. This may come from the strong coordination interactions between the Fa− and the precursors as evidenced by a strong upward chemical shift (Δδ ≈ 2.3 ppm) of the –C
O functional group in the 13C NMR spectra (Fig. S4, ESI†). We suggest that this strong coordination interactions between the Fa− and the precursors could transform the phase transition path of CsSnI3, which can increase the formation energy of γ-CsSnI3. This is evidenced by the slowdown of the black film forming process (Fig. S5, ESI†). With the increased formation energy of γ-CsSnI3, it would tend to form β-CsSnI3 during annealing. In addition, slower crystallization is beneficial to reduce the lattice distortion in the perovskite crystal, thus avoiding the rattling of Cs+ and the [SnI6]4− octahedral tilting during cooling.32,33 This can effectively prevent the collapse of the highly symmetric β-CsSnI3 into γ-CsSnI3 at room temperature. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) analysis was further applied to rule out the incorporation of any organic X-site anions (Fa−) (Fig. S6, ESI†). As there is no stretching vibration peak of the C
O bond in the final film even with a large incorporated ratio of 10 mol% CsFa, we could conclude that the Fa− functional group acts as a volatile component for the controllable crystal phase of the CsSnI3 perovskite.
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) characterization shows that the CsFa-treated CsSnI3 exhibits a textured and discontinuous morphology with distinct edges and corners (Fig. S7, ESI†). The average crystal size of the CsSnI3 treated with CsFa is 170 nm, being smaller than that of the pristine CsSnI3 (250 nm) (Fig. S8, ESI†). Such a discontinuous perovskite film with a smaller crystal size possesses a larger specific surface area, which is helpful for electron injection and reducing nondirective diffusion of excess holes.1,7 In addition, the proportion of Sn4+ components in the films treated with CsFa (8.5%) is significantly lower than that of the pristine CsSnI3 (18.7%), indicating the improved antioxidant properties (Fig. S9, ESI†). Meanwhile, β-CsSnI3 maintains the unique narrow bandgap properties, with an absorbance edge at ca. 950 nm (Fig. S10a, ESI†). This is consistent with the small band gap difference (0.02 eV) between the β and γ phases as demonstrated by the theoretical calculations.34,35 The photoluminescence (PL) spectra (Fig. S10b, ESI†) show that the perovskite film with CsFa exhibited considerably enhanced spectra intensity and narrowed full width at half maximum (FWHM) values (67.7 and 65.7 nm for the pristine and CsFa-treated CsSnI3, respectively), indicative of β-CsSnI3 with reduced non-radiative recombination sites in the film. In Fig. S11a (ESI†), time-resolved PL measurements show that the β-CsSnI3 film has longer PL lifetimes (∼4.5 ns) than γ-CsSnI3 films (∼1.2 ns). The excitation-intensity-dependent PLQY measurement shows a high PLQY of up to ∼10% for the β-CsSnI3, which is about ∼3-fold higher than the γ-CsSnI3 (Fig. S11b, ESI†), indicating that β-CsSnI3 has more efficient radiative recombination process than γ-CsSnI3. Despite being reported that Sn2+ oxidation17 and morphology34 can affect the luminescence ability of Sn-based perovskites, we suggest that the enhanced defect tolerance of β-CsSnI3 is the main factor for improving the PLQY.
The carrier recombination process can be extracted using the power dependence of the steady-state integrated PL intensity IPL and the exciting laser radiation power density Pex (excitation density) as IPL ∝ Pexk. The normalized PL spectra at 300 K and 50
K under varying excitation densities of 532 nm laser are presented in Fig. 3a and b for γ-CsSnI3 and Fig. 3d and e for β-CsSnI3 films, respectively. The corresponding PL intensity graphs at 300 K and 50 K are given in Fig. 3c and f. In general, the PL intensity dependence with k≈1 was observed for both perovskite films, indicating the characteristics of the monomolecular recombination process. The recombination of photo-generated electrons with the background hole density resulting from unintentional doping in CsSnI3 can explain the linear dependence on the excitation intensity of the PL. This mechanism is referred to as free-to-bound radiative recombination of degenerate holes from the valence band with non-equilibrium electrons in the conduction band tails.36 For the pristine CsSnI3 film, the PL intensity at room temperature exhibits a linear increase with excitation density up to approximately ∼1018 cm−3. This indicates that the quantum yield remains constant within this range. However, as the excitation density surpasses∼1018 cm−3, the power-dependent PL intensity exhibits a sublinear slope (saturation effect) instead of the expected superliner dependence on the injected carrier density, as typically observed in Pb-based perovskites. This phenomenon indicates the presence of significant auger recombination energy loss.37 The CsFa-treated β-CsSnI3 film, on the other hand, exhibits a PL intensity slope that is closer to 1 under both low fluency and high excitation density, indicating the suppressed non-radiative recombination in the films.38
The non-radiative decay rate of excited states is associated with the electron–phonon interaction in perovskites according to the Huang–Rhys parameter.39,40 We further investigated the electron–phonon interaction via temperature-dependent PL to explain the improvement in light emission ability for the high-symmetry phase β-CsSnI3. Fig. 4a and b depict the decrease in PL peak intensity and widening of the spectral linewidth as the temperature increases from 50 to 300 K. This phenomenon can be attributed to the fact that the hot carriers are not only thermalized to the band-edge state but also trapped in deep defect states. The pristine CsSnI3 demonstrates significant thermal quenching even at lower temperatures, confirming that β-CsSnI3 has less defect density than γ-CsSnI3, therefore leading to a high PLQY in β-CsSnI3. The temperature-dependent variation of the FWHM is depicted in Fig. 4c and is fitted using the independent Boson model. In this model, Γ0 is the inhomogeneous broadening coefficient, ΓLO represents the electron-LO phonon coupling coefficient, and ELO denotes the LO phonon energy.41 It is extracted that Γ0 = 80.9 ± 0.2 meV, ΓLO= 380.7 ± 66.3 meV, and ELO = 92.2 ± 5.5 meV for pristine CsSnI3. Accordingly, Γ0 = 79.5 ± 0.4 meV, ΓLO = 167.1 ± 46.9 meV, and ELO = 64.3 ± 7.6 meV were fitted for CsFa-treated CsSnI3. Compared to pristine CsSnI3, β-CsSnI3 shows a notable reduction in electron-LO phonon coupling coefficient ΓLO, indicating that the vibration of the [SnI6]4− octahedra cage involves less energies. The decreased LO phonon energy ELO of β-CsSnI3 suggests that the possibility of placing the non-luminescing energy state above the lowest radiative excitonic state is lower compared to γ-CsSnI3. Consequently, the decreased LO phonon energy confirms that the high symmetry phase CsSnI3 films formed by CsFa treatment can increase the number of excitation-generated electron–hole pairs in luminescing states and mitigate quenching through electron–phonon scatterings. We suggest that the higher symmetry and defect tolerance of the β-CsSnI3 phase are the main reasons for the increased PLQY.
The CsSnI3 based Pero-LEDs were fabricated with a structure of ITO/poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):poly(styrene sulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS)/CsSnI3/4,6-bis(3,5-di(pyridin-3-yl)phenyl)-2-methylpyrimidine (B3PyMPM)/LiF/Al, where light emission occurs when injected electrons and holes encounter in the perovskite layer and recombine radiatively. The J–V curves and radiance–voltage (R–V) curves were measured and are depicted in Fig. 5a. The Pero-LEDs based on β-CsSnI3 possessed higher radiance than the device based on γ-CsSnI3 and reached a high radiance of 54 W sr−1 m−2 at 5.4 V. This indicates that the introduction of CsFa improves the radiative recombination process and crystallization quality of CsSnI3. The peak positions of the PL spectra of both in Fig. S10b (ESI†) are both around 950 nm, while the corresponding peaks of the EL spectra are around 910 nm and 930 nm, respectively (Fig. S12, ESI†). Such a difference between the PL and EL spectra could be mainly ascribed to the tin-related defects involved in recombination processes. Usually, these defects can be found within the bandgap with a low energy level.20 In the PL measurements which are carried out under illumination, some of the photogenerated carriers may not efficiently fill all the trap states, leading to defect-induced radiative recombination and consequently a red-shifting of the PL peak.42 In contrast, in the EL measurements which are carried out in the dark, the defect states may be readily filled by trapped carriers due to the high current injection, and thus a corresponding blue-shifted characteristic spectra peak.43 In addition, current loading induces a change in the EL wavelength (called color-shift), which is mainly due to field-driven ionic migration, stemming from the inherent ionic nature of perovskite materials.20
Fig. 5b presents the current–EQE curves of the Pero-LEDs. The Pero-LEDs based on β-CsSnI3 achieved the maximum EQE value of 1.81%, being twice higher than that of the device based on γ-CsSnI3 (0.99%, Fig. S13, ESI†). We ascribed the EQE enhancement to β-CsSnI3 for increasing radiative recombination and reducing electron–phonon scatterings. In addition, the β-CsSnI3 based devices exhibited excellent EL stability even with increasing current injection, highlighting their immense potential for practical applications. We operated the Pero-LEDs at a high constant current density of 100 mA cm−2 and noted the evolution of radiance (Fig. 5c). The operational lifetime (T50) of the CsFa-treated device is 8.5 h, which is approximately ten times that of the pristine device. Surprisingly, the CsFa-treated device has excellent stability with a T50 of 6 min under a very high injection rate of 1.0 A cm−2 (Fig. 5d). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on β-CsSnI3-based NIR PeLEDs (Table S2, ESI†). Our study provides a fundamental perspective to enhance the near-infrared emission of black-phase CsSnI3 perovskites.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4mh00428k |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |