Raquel
Gonzalez de Vega
*a,
Thebny Thaíse
Moro
ab,
Bernhard
Grüner
ac,
Tatiane
de Andrade Maranhão
b,
Maximilian J.
Huber
d,
Natalia P.
Ivleva
d,
Etienne
Skrzypek
e,
Jörg
Feldmann
a and
David
Clases
*f
aTESLA-Analytical Chemistry, Institute of Chemistry, University of Graz, Graz, Austria. E-mail: raquel.gonzalez-de-vega@uni-graz.at
bDepartamento de Química, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Campus Trindade, Florianópolis, Brazil
cInstitute of Inorganic and Analytical Chemistry, University of Münster, Münster, Germany
dInstitute of Water Chemistry, Chair of Analytical Chemistry and Water Chemistry, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany
eDepartment of Petrology and Geochemistry, NAWI Graz Geocenter, University of Graz, Graz, Austria
fNanoMicroLab, Institute of Chemistry, University of Graz, Graz, Austria. E-mail: David.Clases@uni-graz.at
First published on 17th June 2024
Fluoropolymers, such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), have unique properties, which enable versatile applications in industry and make them useful for various consumer products. However, it is known that these polymers may degrade over time and form small particles with possible implications for the environment and health. Building on previous reports for the detection of fluorine (F) via inductively coupled plasma-tandem mass spectrometry (ICP-MS/MS) using a barium-based plasma modifier, this study presents a design of experiments approach (DoE), which optimised plasma parameters, ion optics, mass filtering and collision/reaction cell conditions systematically. The resulting method was capable to detect micro-scaled PTFE particles and to determine number concentrations as well as size distributions. Validation was carried out in two steps: first, micro-scaled PTFE standards were characterised via microscopy and Raman spectroscopy and second, carbon-selective single particle (SP) ICP-MS was employed to corroborate results obtained via the F-selective method. The developed F-selective method has a high utility to characterise the degradation of bulk PTFE into microplastics, which was demonstrated in a proof-of-concept. Here, bulk PTFE material was stirred in simulated seawater under UV-light illumination for 6 days. After this incubation period, a microplastic number concentration of 2.35 × 105 F-based particles per gram immersed bulk PTFE was detected. PTFE particles had a mean mass and size of 28 pg and 2.7 μm, respectively.
One relevant polymer class is per- or polyfluorinated polyethylene, from which polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) is the most prominent. These fluoropolymers are characterised by their strong carbon–fluorine (C–F) bonds. PTFE, like other fluoropolymers, present unique properties with a high utility for diverse applications. For example, PTFE is known for its “non-sticky” behaviour as well as its ability to withstand high temperatures and harsh chemical conditions. These properties make it predestined for various industrial and consumer applications.9 However, in view of the widespread application of fluoropolymers and the increasing levels of MPs in the environment, we need to understand the degradation of fluoropolymers as well as the formation, distribution, and fate of corresponding MPs.
Several techniques have been suggested for the analysis of MPs including Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Raman spectroscopy, thermal analysis and mass spectrometry (MS).10,11 Especially the latter becomes increasingly relevant and offers unique modes allowing highly selective and sensitive analyses. While molecule-selective methods such as pyrolysis gas chromatography (GC)-MS were described previously,12–14 the recent advances in elemental mass spectrometry promise new avenues to characterise MPs. A recent relevant method is here inductively-coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), which can be operated in its “single particle (SP)” mode to count individual particles as well as to establish models on mass- and size distributions.15 While this method is most commonly used for inorganic nanoparticles, Bolea-Fernandez et al.16 proposed the detection of MPs via SP ICP-MS by targeting the integral 13C+. Laborda et al. subsequently showed that this approach can be used to characterise MPs in consumer products17 and more recently in river water.18 Gonzalez de Vega et al.19 investigated various strategies to improve figures of merits for the detection of MPs in complex matrices, such as seawater, and proposed to target 12C+ instead of 13C+ to improve the size detection limit. Recently, it was further suggested that SP ICP-MS can be coupled to optical traps and Raman spectroscopy, which allows both the elemental and molecular analysis of single particles.20 While C is becoming the obvious choice to characterise MPs with elemental mass spectrometry, heteroelements in the polymers may be targeted instead. Especially when targeting fluoropolymers, analysing F would offer a complementary perspective and would be more selective for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS)-based polymers.
Unfortunately, the direct detection of F by conventional ICP-MS is not possible due to its high first ionisation potential (17.42 eV), which is significantly higher than the first ionisation potential of Ar (12.75 eV). One viable strategy to bypass this issue was introduced by Yamada21 and is based on the online addition of a Ba solution to the F-containing sample solution. The co-presence of Ba2+ and F− in the plasma allows the formation of BaF+ (m/z 157) and therefore allows the analysis of the latter as a proxy for F. One limiting factor for this approach is the high abundance of polyatomic interferences (e.g.138Ba18O1H+, 138Ba16O1H3+, and 138Ba17O2H+), which however, could be mitigated using a dedicated method for the collision/reaction cell (CRC). Jamari et al.22 demonstrated that it is possible to use this method in a HPLC-ICP-MS set-up enabling speciation analysis with a high utility for PFAS compounds. Recently, Clases et al.23 adapted this approach for elemental bioimaging and demonstrated the possibility to map F in biological and geological specimens via LA-ICP-MS. Furthermore, Gelman et al.24 proved the feasibility of SP ICP-MS to detect F in MPs, which opens new avenues to pinpoint fluoroplastic-based microparticles in the presence of other fluorine-free polymers and even in the presence of dissolved fluorinated molecular compounds.
In this work we systematically investigated and optimised SP ICP-MS of F-based particles using a design of experiment (DoE) approach. To make F analysis via ICP-MS feasible, Ba2+ was added as plasma modifier to analyse F as its mass shifted Ba-adduct. For validation, we parallelly interrogated PTFE standards via microscopy and Raman spectroscopy and additionally, targeted C for a complementary size distribution model for corroboration. This F-selective method offers opportunities to follow the degradation of bulk PTFE and to consider the generation of small particles in different scenarios. In a proof of concept, we used the F-selective method to investigate the degradation of bulk PTFE in simulated seawater. Seawater is one of the most relevant environmental matrices and we stimulated degradation by immersing bulk PTFE and subjecting it to constant motion and UV radiation.
To study the degradation of PTFE and the size distribution of resulting particles, bulk PTFE (1.6 g of PTFE septa often used to seal vials) was cut into pieces between 5 and 50 mm3 and immersed into 50 mL of artificial seawater.25 A 90 mm diameter round quartz Petri dish without lid was used as container. The mixture was placed under UV light (G8T5 light bulb, 8 watts, 254 nm) at a distance of approximately 7 cm and kept at 21 °C. The PTFE was exposed for 6 days during which evaporated water was refilled with ultra-pure water. After 6 days, the PTFE chunks were visually almost unchanged. Big pieces were removed manually and a cut-off of 15 μm was chosen to avoid the clogging of the nebuliser using a paper filter (VWR®, Qualitative Filter Paper 415). Aliquots of the remaining seawater were collected and analysed to search for PTFE particles. To guarantee the absence of contamination, a blank solution (artificial seawater) without bulk PTFE was prepared under the same experimental conditions and used as control. All seawater samples were diluted 1:
50 with ultrapure water containing 1.5% Triton X-100 to stabilise PTFE microparticles. The direct analysis of diluted seawater decreased ion transmission and required matrix-matching for accurate size calibration. Blanks, ionic F standard and 3 μm PTFE standard were prepared in diluted seawater to compensate for matrix effects.
For SP detection, an 8900 series ICP-MS/MS system (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) was equipped with platinum cones and s-lenses and operated with MassHunter software (Agilent Technologies). A Scott-type double-pass spray chamber was cooled to 2 °C and a MicroMist™ concentric nebuliser (Elemental Scientific Inc., Omaha, NE, US) was used for sample nebulisation. The inner diameter of the torch's injector was 1.5 mm. The instrument was operated in MS/MS mode and the dwell time of the quadrupole was set to 100 μs. Data analysis was performed using the open-source python-based data processing platform “SPCal”.26 Here, Poisson statistics were used to distinguish ionic background and noise from SP events with an α value of 10−3. The RF power was set to 1.6 kW, the sample depth (z-position) was set to 4.5 mm with a nebulizer gas flow of 1.4 L min−1. Sample uptake rate was calculated gravimetrically to be 0.52 mL min−1. The gradual optimisation to enhance signal to noise ratios and transmission required modification of the plasma, ion optics, quadrupole mass filter and collision/reaction cell (CRC) parameters. A 100 μg mL−1 Ba solution was added continuously through a T-piece. One limiting factor in the BaF+ approach was the generation of polyatomic interferences which however, could be mitigated using different gases in the collision/reaction cell (CRC). Here He (99.9999%), H2 (99.9999%) and O2 (20% in argon) were tested in order to evaluate the removal of these interferences while obtaining the best signal to noise ratio (SNR). Optimised parameters are shown in Table 1.
ICP-MS parameters | Value |
---|---|
Forward power | 1600 W |
Nebulizer gas | 1.4 L min−1 |
Sample depth | 4.5 mm |
Extraction 1 | −196.5 V |
Extraction 2 | −5 V |
Deflect | 5 V |
AMU offset (Q1) | 10 |
AMU gain (Q1) | 130 |
Energy discrimination | −10 V |
Octopole bias | −9.2 V |
He | 0.8 mL min−1 |
O2 | 5% |
Axial acceleration | 1 V |
Ionic response factors for Au and F were calculated with ionic standards, and transport efficiencies were calculated using 80 nm Au NPs to be 5.0%. Size calibrations were carried out via two different strategies: (1) using the transport efficiency calculated for the Au NPs, (2) Using pre-characterised polystyrene and PTFE standards.
The 3 μm PTFE microparticles standard was further investigated by microscopy and Raman spectroscopy to obtain additional information on purity, shapes and sizes as well as polydispersity. Raman micro-spectroscopy was performed with an alpha 300R (WITec GmbH, Germany) equipped with a Zeiss microscope and a 100× objective (numerical aperture 0.90). The 532 nm emission line of a diode-pumped solid-state laser was used to excite the sample (10 mW on the sample) at room temperature. The Raman scattered light was diffracted on a 600 grooves per mm grating plate and measured with a charge-coupled device camera. Further data analysis was performed with ImageJ software (version 1.54d).27
A response surface method (RSM) with Doehlert design (DD) was used to optimise the instrumental conditions of the plasma and (first) quadrupole. The Doehlert design is usually applied to optimise two variables,28 which are investigated in three and five experimental levels, respectively. For the plasma optimisation, the variables investigated in three and five levels were sample depth and nebuliser flow, where the experimental conditions investigated were 3.0, 4.5, 6.0 mm, and 1.30, 1.35, 1.40, 1.45, 1.50 mL min−1, for sample depth and nebuliser flow, respectively. The transmission characteristics of the first quadrupole were modulated to tune the mass bandpass and ion flux into the CRC according to strategies previously published by Clases et al.29–32 Briefly, the AMU gain and offset were varied and signal to noise ratios for the BaF+ signal were compared analysing the 3 μm PTFE standard. More information is available in Fig. 1 and the full DD is shown in Table S1.† For the optimisation of the ion optics, extraction lens 1 and 2 as well as the deflect parameters were found to influence signal to noise ratios significantly and therefore, were selected for the DoE approach. Due to the possibility to investigate both factors with 5 experimental levels, a RSM with Central Composite Design (CCD) was chosen to optimise the conditions for “extract 2” and “deflect” lenses. Results are comprised in Table S2 and Fig. S1.† The aim of all optimisations was to achieve the best signal to noise ratios, which was here determined as the ratio of the mean SP signal heights divided by the determined Poisson-based detection threshold.26
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Colorimetric maps obtained from the Doehlert experimental design for (A) plasma and (B) bandpass optimisations. Selected conditions are marked as a white circle. |
Due to the high number of parameters that can affect the CRC performance, a 25 factorial design (32 experiments) was used as screening method to evaluate the significance of the following variables: octopole bias, energy discrimination, He, H2 and O2 flows (Table S3†). Once concluded, according to the Pareto chart (Fig. S2†) the significant factors (p < 0.05) were selected and a RSM with a 3-level Box–Behnken design was further applied to determine the optimal conditions for the significant factors (energy discrimination, O2 and H2 flows). The investigated levels were −5, −10, −15 V; 5, 10, 15%; and 0, 0.5, 1.0 mL min−1, for energy discrimination, O2 and H2 flows, respectively (Table S4 and Fig. S3†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (A) Raman spectrum obtained from the 3 μm PTFE standard, (B) size histogram and optical image of the detected particles. |
Subsequently, sizes of PTFE particles were determined with the developed F-selective SP method monitoring the BaF+ adduct. The experimental mean PTFE particle size was 2.9 μm ± 0.9 μm, which was in line with the expected theoretical size of 3 μm. Additionally, size calibrations were carried out targeting C in single PTFE particles via SP ICP-MS. The interested reader will find more information on the C-selective method in a previously published study.19 For the C-selective method, no Triton X-100 was used to limit the mean background signal and consequently, to decrease the C-based size detection limit for MPs. Analysing and calibrating the 12C+ signal, an average PTFE particle size of 2.9 ± 0.8 μm was determined. Fig. 3A and B show both the raw BaF+ and 12C signals, respectively, and Fig. 3C and D show the calibrated size distributions. For the F-selective method, the size detection limit of PTFE particles was determined to be 1.1 μm. At particles sizes above 15 μm, nebuliser clogging occurred frequently and filter paper with a cut-off of 15 μm was used to remove larger particles and agglomerates. Compared to a previous report, the lower detection limit was increased,24 which was likely due to a more conservative approach to define the detection threshold in this study. As size detection limits for PTFE particles using the C-selective method were lower,19 a manual decision limit was set to the F-based size detection limit to enable a direct comparison of the mean size and size distribution. Both the F and C-selective methods determined similar mean values and standard deviations (2.9 ± 0.9 μm and 2.9 ± 0.8 μm, respectively) and were furthermore in line with the optical sizing approach (3.1 ± 1.5 μm).
It is worth mentioning that SP ICP-MS cannot distinguish F-based particles containing different species and that mass and size models are restricted to particles with known density and F-mass fraction. While this is the case for targeted degradation experiments, real and unknown environmental samples may contain other F-based species challenging current approaches. One way to address this issue is an additional characterisation via a complementary (molecule-selective) particle detection paradigm. For example, previous Raman analysis coupled on-line to SP ICP-MS may offer a viable solution as recently demonstrated for polystyrene particles.20
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ja00101j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |