Alexandra
Males‡§
a,
Ken
Kok§
b,
Alba
Nin-Hill
cd,
Nicky
de Koster
b,
Sija
van den Beukel
b,
Thomas J. M.
Beenakker
e,
Gijsbert A.
van der Marel
e,
Jeroen D. C.
Codée
e,
Johannes M. F. G.
Aerts
b,
Herman S.
Overkleeft
e,
Carme
Rovira
*cd,
Gideon J.
Davies
*a and
Marta
Artola
*b
aYork Structural Biology Laboratory, Department of Chemistry, The University of York, York YO10 5DD, UK. E-mail: gideon.davies@york.ac.uk
bDepartment of Medical Biochemistry, Leiden Institute of Chemistry (LIC), Leiden University, P. O. Box 9502, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands. E-mail: m.e.artola@lic.leidenuniv.nl
cDepartament de Química Inorgànica i Orgànica (Secció de Química Orgànica), Institut de Química Teòrica i Computacional (IQTCUB), Universitat de Barcelona, Martí i Franquès 1, 08028 Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: c.rovira@ub.edu
dFundació Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA), Passeig Lluís Companys 23, 08010 Barcelona, Spain
eDepartment of Bio-organic Synthesis, Leiden Institute of Chemistry (LIC), Leiden University, Einsteinweg 55, 2333 CC Leiden, The Netherlands
First published on 17th November 2023
Class I inverting exo-acting α-1,2-mannosidases (CAZY family GH47) display an unusual catalytic itinerary featuring ring-flipped mannosides, 3S1 → 3H4‡ → 1C4. Conformationally locked 1C4 compounds, such as kifunensine, display nanomolar inhibition but large multigene GH47 mannosidase families render specific “isoform-dependent” inhibition impossible. Here we develop a bump-and-hole strategy in which a new mannose-configured 1,6-trans-cyclic sulfamidate inhibits α-D-mannosidases by virtue of its 1C4 conformation. This compound does not inhibit the wild-type GH47 model enzyme by virtue of a steric clash, a “bump”, in the active site. An L310S (a conserved residue amongst human GH47 enzymes) mutant of the model Caulobacter GH47 awoke 574 nM inhibition of the previously dormant inhibitor, confirmed by structural analysis of a 0.97 Å structure. Considering that L310 is a conserved residue amongst human GH47 enzymes, this work provides a unique framework for future biotechnological studies on N-glycan maturation and ER associated degradation by isoform-specific GH47 α-D-mannosidase inhibition through a bump-and-hole approach.
Decades of work on diverse glycosidases (including α-D-mannosidases,14–16 reviewed by Williams and collaborators3,17) has shown that the substrates undergo specific conformational fluctuations to accommodate their steric and electronic features. Indeed, conformational mimicry of the ligands along the reaction coordinates, Michaelis complex, transition state or product complexes, has been demonstrated to be of key relevance when designing inhibitors for specific carbohydrate hydrolases. GH47 mannosidases are Ca2+-dependent metalloenzymes that follow a one-step inverting mechanism with a 3S1 (Michaelis complex) → 3H4‡ (transition state) → 1C4 (product) conformational itinerary (Fig. 1A).18,19 Kifunensine 1 is one such conformationally restrained compound that achieves selective inhibition of the GH47 α-D-mannosidase family by virtue of mimicry of the mannose configuration and 1C4 conformation of the enzyme-product state (Fig. 1).15 Similarly, mannoimidazole 2 and 1-deoxymannojirimycin (DMJ) 3 also inhibit GH47 α-D-mannosidases, but do so by mimicking the oxocarbenium transition state (3H4‡) or both the Michaelis complex (3S1) and product (1C4) conformations, respectively (Fig. 1). However, all are incapable of inhibiting individual GH47 α-D-mannosidases selectively which means they cannot be used for specific inhibition of single enzymes in cells.
GH47 Class I inverting α-D-mannosidases hydrolyse 1,2-mannosidic linkages and are responsible for the processing of N-glycans, ultimately regulating the maturation and quality control of glycoproteins in the secretory pathway.20 GH47 mannosidases can be divided into three subfamilies within the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi apparatus. The cleavage of α-1,2-mannoside linkages in Man9GlcNAc2-Asn substrates is initiated by ERMI (first subfamily) followed by Golgi-α-1,2-mannosidases GMIA, GMIB, and GMIC (second subfamily), hydrolysing subsequent α-1,2-mannoside branches and affording Man5GlcNAc2-Asn (Fig. 2). The third subfamily comprises of ER degradation enhancing α-mannosidase-like (EDEM) enzymes (EDEM1, EDEM2 and EDEM3) that target misfolded proteins and mark them for degradation via the ER-associated degradation (ERAD) machinery.
Given the success of generic conformational mimicry for enzymes of this family15,19,21 (notwithstanding the fact that humans have a large multigene family of seven GH47 enzymes) we sought to test if cyclic sulfates and sulfamidates might possess similar conformational attributes. Recently, we demonstrated that a cyclophellitol analogue bearing a cis-cyclic sulfate electrophile is a selective nanomolar covalent α-glucosidase inhibitor by virtue of its 4C1 Michaelis complex mimicry.2 Substitution of this cyclic sulfate by an unreactive 1,6-cyclosulfamidate yielded diverse α-glucosidase22 and α-galactosidase23 competitive inhibitors with great potential as enzyme stabilizers for the treatment of lysosomal storage disorders such as Pompe or Fabry disease. In this work, we sought to build upon the capability of cis-cyclic sulfates and sulfamidates to lock their compounds in a 4C1 chair conformation2,22–24 and hypothesize that trans-cyclic sulfate 5 and sulfamidate 6 may instead invert this chair, yielding a new class of 1C4 locked conformational glycosidase inhibitors (Fig. 1B).
Here, we present the design and synthesis of an α-D-mannose configured 1,6-trans-cyclic sulfamidate as a potential inhibitor of the GH47 α-D-mannosidase family. We show, using QM calculations of free energy landscapes, that cyclosulfamidate 6 favours a 1C4 chair conformation consistent with the GH47 conformational itinerary. We demonstrate that a steric clash in the enzyme active centre enables the implementation of a bump-and-hole methodology for GH47 inhibition. Mutation of a leucine, conserved across the family, to serine unlocks the dormant inhibition of 6 realising a 574 nM inhibitor specific for the mutant enzyme only. The work, combining conformational mimicry and bump-and-hole yields the opportunity for specific inhibition of individual, but closely related, α-D-mannosidases within the GH47 family. This proof of concept offers a singular system for future biotechnological investigations into N-glycan maturation and ER-associated degradation in diverse species.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Conformational free energy landscapes (FELs, Mercator projection) contoured at 1 kcal mol−1 of (A) 1,6-cis-manno-cyclosulfate 4, (B) 1,6-trans-manno-cyclosulfate 5 and (C) 1,6-trans-manno-cyclosulfamidate 6. Symbols plot the observed conformations of known GH47 inhibitors in their respective enzyme complexes. Kifunensine bound to human ER I or CkGH47 α-mannosidases (1, PDB 1FO3 or 1′, PDB 5NE5). Manno-imidazole bound to Caulobacter strain K31 α-mannosidase (CkGH47) (2, PDB 4AYQ). DMJ bound to CkGH47 (3 & 3′, PDB 5MEH). Further information on the most stable conformers and the corresponding Stoddart representations are provided in Fig. S1–S3.† |
1,6-Cis-manno-cyclosulfate, 4, and 1,6-trans-manno-cyclosulfate, 5, were synthesized from mannose-configured cis-diol and trans-diol, respectively (ESI, Scheme S1†). Though the final compounds 4 and 5 could be characterized, their storage for a week at room temperature led to compound degradation probably by intramolecular attack of the 2-OH pseudoanomeric position and opening of the cyclic sulfates. The synthesis of the potentially more stable cyclosulfamidate 6 started with the addition of sodium azide to tetra-O-benzyl-cyclophellitol 7 which resulted in a mixture of diastereomers 8 and 9. Azide 9 was subsequently reduced using PtO2 to obtain amine 10. Cbz-protection of the amine gave intermediate 11 which was treated with SOCl2 followed by RuCl3/NaIO4-mediated oxidation of the formed sulfites, resulting in the formation of fully protected trans-sulfamidate 12. Trans-sulfamidate 12 was then exposed to hydrogenation conditions to obtain cyclosulfamidate 6 which proved to be chemically stable (Scheme 1).
To our surprise, no significant inhibition of the GH47 model enzyme (whose active centre is identical to the human enzymes) from Caulobacter K31 strain was observed even at high inhibitor concentrations; 82% of α-1,2-mannobiose was hydrolysed by the WT GH47 mannosidase to mannose after the addition of 1 mM 6 (Fig. S4†) (in contrast to kifunensine (KD of 39 nM),15 mannoimidazole (KD of 47 nM),19 and DMJ (KD of 481 nM)21). Accordingly, crystal soaks revealed no binding. Simple overlay of 6 over published complexes of the Caulobacter GH47 enzyme revealed a likely steric clash between one of the oxygen atoms of the sulfamidate group of 6 with the Cδ2 atom of the leucine side chain L310 in the active centre of the enzyme (Fig. S5†).
Although this initial observation was fortuitous, it immediately presented a solution to the problem of specific inhibition of individual enzymes. In contrast to other known GH47 inhibitors, we could exploit the clash to formulate a “bump-and-hole” strategy allowing selective individual α-mannosidase GH47 inhibition, otherwise not possible through chemical knockdown. Originally developed for kinases by Shokat,25,26 bump-and-hole engineering is best applied to large multigene families where isoform-specific inhibition (sometimes described as “allele specific”, reflecting the inhibition of one of a panel of closely related proteins encoded by closely related genes) is challenging. This strategy relies on introducing a “bump” on the inhibitor/ligand/substrate that is accommodated specifically by enzyme variants into which a complementary “hole” has been created through mutagenesis. Within the context of glycoscience, while Karanicolas's team expanded the approach to incorporate new allosteric pockets into the catalytic sites of several glycosidases,27,28 Hou et al. capitalized on the bump and hole strategy to precisely deliver nitric oxide using alkylated β-galacatosyl NONOates29 and Schumann et al. incorporated chemically tagged sugars into the cell surface glycome of living cells using “holed” glycosyltransferases.30,31 Since, despite conformational matching, 6 failed because of encountering a “bump” with L310, we hypothesized that exchanging the leucine for a smaller amino-acid would form an appropriate “hole” to accommodate 6 in a variant-specific manner. Importantly, L310 is an entirely conserved residue across all seven human GH47 enzymes (Fig. S7 and S8†). To demonstrate proof-of-concept, mutation to a serine was selected because of the potential to form a hydrogen bond to the inhibitor in addition to removing the steric clashing distance: a hole with benefits.
The L310S variant was created and shown to be catalytically viable in the degradation of α-1,2-mannobiose (Fig. 4A, B and Table S1†). The Vmax value of 0.15 μM s−1 and the KM value of 403 μM for the mutant were 10× and 6× lower than those of the WT.32,33 Similar loss in enzyme catalytic activity has also been observed in protein kinase bump and hole approaches.25,26
Building on this kinetic assay, we obtained an inhibition constant by pre-incubation of the enzyme and 6 for 30 minutes and then following the same time-point procedure as for the Michaelis–Menten assay. Following the approach described by Suits et al.,34 a 574 nM Ki was obtained for 6 with the L310S mutant specifically (Fig. 4C and Table S1†). Similarly, a dissociation constant of 970 nM was obtained using isothermal titration calorimetry (Fig. S6†). To understand the interactions between 6 and CkGH47 L310S regarding the introduced hole, a crystal structure complex was obtained (statistics in Table S2†). Trans-cyclic sulfamidate 6 binds similarly to other conformationally restricted GH47 inhibitors, with additional interactions between the sulfamidate and active site residues, for example, the nitrogen and oxygen, and D249 and R363 side chains. Additionally, the introduced serine residue is indeed now in a position to hydrogen bond to the oxygen of the sulfamidate with a distance of 3.1 Å. Also validating the initial design hypothesis, overlaying the L310S structure with 6 with that of the WT CkGH47 native enzyme revealed 1.3–1.9 Å steric clashes of 6 to leucine 310 (Fig. 5B and S5†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Structure of CkGH47 L310S in complex with 6. (A) Active site residues (dark red) within hydrogen bonding distance to 6 (pink) in the −1 subsite. The maximum-likelihood/σA-weighted 2Fobs − Fcalc map, shown in purple, is contoured at 1.3 e Å−3. (B) Superposition of CkGH47 WT crystal structures highlighting the flexibility of residue 310; native leucine is shown in gold (PDB 4AYO) and CkGH47 in complex with kifunensine is shown in orange; there are 2 alternate conformations of Leu at 50% occupancy each (PDB 5NE5). |
Finally, selectivity versus a panel of related exo-mannosidases was investigated. We first tested inhibition against all five human GH38 retaining α-mannosidases in overexpressed cell lysates using 4-methylumbelliferyl-α-mannoside (4-MU-α-man): Golgi mannosidase II and IIx (MAN2A1 and MAN2A2), cytosolic MAN2C1 and lysosomal MAN2B1 and MAN2B2. This α-mannosidase family follows a different conformational itinerary than GH47: 0S2 → B2,5 → 1S5.35 Cyclic sulfamidate 6 showed no inhibition of this panel of enzymes up to 1 mM with the exception of MAN2C1, for which an apparent IC50 value of 3.5 μM was observed when using cobalt as the metal ion (Table 1). Intriguingly, no IC50 value could be determined for MAN2C1 when the buffer was supplemented with 1 mM ZnCl2 instead of CoCl2, and compound 6 showed no activity in the other tested GH38 α-mannosidases when the buffer was enriched with CoCl2. Of note, the presence of cobalt has been associated with conformational changes in the active site of some GH38 α-mannosidases, which might affect the binding interaction with inhibitors.36 Nevertheless, additional research is required to explore which specific metal ion is present in the MAN2C1 active site in its in vivo state. As expected, when looking at the representative GH2 α-mannosidases Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron BtMan2A, compound 6 was also inactive at 1 mM concentration.
Enzyme | Species | IC50 |
---|---|---|
GH38 exo-α-mannosidases | ||
MAN2A1 (Zn2+) | Human | >1 mM |
MAN2A2 (Zn2+) | Human | >1 mM |
MAN2B1 (Zn2+) | Human | >1 mM |
MAN2B2 (Zn2+) | Human | >1 mM |
MAN2C1 (Co2+) | Human | 3.5 ± 1.2 μM |
MAN2C1 (Zn2+) | Human | >1 mM |
![]() |
||
GH2 exo-β-mannosidase | ||
BtMan2A | Bacterial | >1 mM |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc05016e |
‡ Current address: Biomolecular Sciences Research Centre, Sheffield Hallam University, Howard Street, Sheffield, S1 1WB, UK. |
§ A. M. and K. K. contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |