Natalie
Saenz
a,
Leslie S.
Hamachi
a,
Anna
Wolock
b,
Berit H.
Goodge
c,
Alexis
Kuntzmann
e,
Benoit
Dubertret
e,
Isabel
Billinge
a,
Lena F.
Kourkoutis
cd,
David A.
Muller
cd,
Andrew C.
Crowther
b and
Jonathan S.
Owen
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA. E-mail: jso2115@columbia.edu
bDepartment of Chemistry, Barnard College, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
cSchool of Applied and Engineering Physics, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
dKavli Institute at Cornell for Nanoscale Science, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
eEcole Supérieure de Physique et de Chimie Industrielle, Paris, France
First published on 16th October 2023
A mixture of N,N,N′-trisubstituted thiourea and cyclic N,N,N′,N′-tetrasubstituted selenourea precursors were used to synthesize three monolayer thick CdS1−xSex nanoplatelets in a single synthetic step. The microstructure of the nanoplatelets could be tuned from homogeneous alloys, to graded alloys to core/crown heterostructures depending on the relative conversion reactivity of the sulfur and selenium precursors. UV-visible absorption and photoluminescence spectroscopy and scanning transmission electron microscopy electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS) images demonstrate that the elemental distribution is governed by the relative precursor conversion kinetics. Slow conversion kinetics produced nanoplatelets with larger lateral dimensions, behavior that is characteristic of precursor conversion limited growth kinetics. Across a 10-fold range of reactivity, CdS nanoplatelets have 4× smaller lateral dimensions than CdSe nanoplatelets grown under identical conversion kinetics. The difference in size is consistent with a rate of CdSe growth that is 4× greater than the rate of CdS. The influence of the relative sulfide and selenide growth rates, the duration of the nucleation phase, and the solute composition on the nanoplatelet microstructure are discussed.
We recently reported a synthesis of quasi-spherical alloyed nanocrystals (CdS1−xSex) whose microstructure could be tuned using pairs of sulfide and selenide precursors with controlled conversion kinetics (Scheme 1). By adjusting the relative precursor reactivity (Qsvs. QSe), the solute composition during the growth can be controlled and used to influence the relative growth rates (Gsvs. GSe) and the final microstructure. Core–shell and alloyed nanocrystals were synthesized across a range of sizes and wavelengths and used to produce spherical quantum wells for solid state lighting applications.10,11 In the present manuscript we explore a similar approach to synthesize laterally graded nanoplatelets.
Scheme 1 Solute supply kinetics (Q) and growth kinetics (G) on the microstructure of CdS1−xSex nanocrystal alloys prepared from a pair of chalcogenoureas. |
To tailor the composition of nanoplatelets using the framework depicted in Scheme 1 two conditions must be met: (1) the crystallization kinetics must be limited by the precursor conversion kinetics and (2) the nucleation process must occur in a burst and prior to any changes in the evolving solute composition. While previous descriptions of nanoplatelet formation indicate that growth proceeds by lateral extension of a nanoplatelet nucleus,12,13 the supply of monomers is typically thought to arise from Ostwald ripening,13,14 rather than rate limiting conversion of precursor reagents.15 Hence, we sought novel precursor reactivity to access a precursor conversion limited growth regime.
Although it is widely accepted that a burst of nucleation is required to obtain narrow size distributions, recent work on the nucleation of InP,16 PbS and PbSe,17,18 CdSe,19 and Ir20 provide clear examples where this assumption is incorrect. Instead nucleation kinetics can be slow and occur over a significant fraction of the total reaction without compromising the monodispersity.16,18 However, if the ratio of S:Se solutes evolves during the nucleation phase, those crystals nucleated at early times can have different S:Se compositions than those nucleated at later times. Such behavior could explain the broad polydispersity of quasi-spherical CdS1−xSex nanocrystals prepared from pairs of thio- and selenoureas whose conversion reactivity differs less than 10×.11 On the other hand, a short burst of nucleation at the beginning of the synthesis could allow the composition of the entire ensemble of crystals to evolve with a changing solute composition.
Nanoplatelets appear to nucleate in a shorter period than spherical quantum dots. This hypothesis is consistent with the low polydispersity of typical nanoplatelet edge lengths, (which we reason is less likely to result from size dependent growth kinetics) and their large dimensions (nanoplatelets studied herein are composed of 5000–100000 CdE units versus 200–1000 CdE units for spherical quantum dots). Nanoplatelet nucleation may, therefore, be better suited to the mixed precursor approach described in Scheme 1.
Nanoplatelet optical properties provide a useful tool to investigate the relationship between the solute composition and the microstructure. When monitoring the growth of quasi spherical CdS1−xSex quantum dots from mixtures of sulfur and selenium precursors, quantum confinement and the alloy composition both influence the absorption and luminescence spectrum. The conflation of these effects makes it challenging to study the correlation between the solute supply kinetics and alloy microstructure. The optical absorption spectrum of CdS1−xSex nanoplatelets, on the other hand, is insensitive to changes in the lateral dimensions, producing spectra that are primarily determined by the alloy composition. As a result, the alloy microstructure is more readily ascertained from the optical spectrum.
The elemental composition of nanoplatelets has previously been graded in the thickness direction by the slow injection of tri-n-octylphosphine-chalcogenides21 and layer-by-layer methods such as colloidal atomic layer deposition (c-ALD).22,23 Only one report describes the formation of laterally graded alloys from elemental sulfur and selenium dissolved in octadecene.9 However, it is unclear how the relative reactivity of those chalcogens with octadecene influence the solute composition over time and the difficulty of characterizing the spatial distribution of elements makes it challenging to relate the optical properties to the nanoplatelet microstructure.
Here we use precisely controlled precursor conversion kinetics to infer the steady state solute concentration and predict the nanoplatelet composition. The framework illustrated in Scheme 1 captures the evolution of the nanoplatelet composition with time, allowing the spectral properties and nanoplatelet composition to be correlated.
Fig. 1 (A) Synthesis conditions used to prepare 3 ML nanoplatelets of CdSe (B) and CdS (C). Legend displays time with units of seconds at which quantitative aliquots were taken. |
E | R1 | R2 | R3 | R4 | k obs (s−1) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Conversion kinetics too rapid to measure. | ||||||
1 | S | H | n-C6H13 | H | n-C12H25 | |
2 | S | H | n-C6H13 | n-C8H17 | n-C8H17 | |
3 | S | H | Cy | –(CH2)4– | ||
4 | S | H | n-C6H13 | –(CH2)4– | ||
5 | S | H | Ph | –(CH2)4– | 0.0329 | |
6 | S | H | Bn | –(CH2)4– | 0.0179 | |
7 | S | H | Ph | n-C4H9 | n-C4H9 | 0.0176 |
8 | S | H | Ph | CH3 | Ph | 0.00668 |
9 | S | H | 3,5-Me2Ph | CH3 | Ph | 0.0145 |
10 | S | H | 4-MePh | CH3 | Ph | 0.0129 |
11 | S | H | –CH2CH2– | H | 0.00525 | |
12 | S | H | –CH2CH2– | Ph | 0.00121 | |
13 | S | H | –CH2CH2– | Me | 0.00167 | |
14 | S | H | –CH2CH2– | Et | 0.00124 | |
15 | Se | H | –CH2CH2– | Ph | ||
16 | Se | H | –CH2CH2– | Et | 0.0134 | |
17 | Se | H | –CH2CH2– | iPr | 0.0101 | |
18 | Se | Ph | –CH2CH2– | Ph | 0.0149 | |
19 | Se | Me | –CH2CH2– | Me | 0.00169 | |
20 | Se | Et | –CH2CH2– | Et | 0.00047 |
The precipitation kinetics are measured using UV-vis absorption spectroscopy and an extinction coefficient (λ = 350 nm) that is known to be independent of the nanocrystals size for CdSe or the band edge absorption for CdS.22,23,28 By assuming the rate of semiconductor formation is equal to the rate of precursor conversion, a single exponential fit to the absorbance data is used to extract a conversion reactivity coefficient (kobs) analogous to an observed rate constant (Fig. S1, S2† and Table 1). However, the evolution of the absorbance appears more complex than single exponential in some cases (see Fig. S1 and S2†). Nonetheless, the kobs provides a convenient method of distinguishing the relative reactivity of the precursors over the ∼1000-fold range of coefficients measured here. The large range of growth kinetics indicates that the chalcogenourea conversion reactivity limits the formation of the nanoplatelets, as was also observed in a recent study on quasi-spherical nanocrystals.29 The reactivity trends observed here are similar to those reported by us earlier and are consistent with a Lewis acid activation mechanism that leads to CE bond cleavage.25,26
Precursors that provide controlled conversion reactivity produce single populations of 3 ML nanoplatelets in good yields. The most reactive selenourea precursors lead to mixtures of 2 ML and 3 ML platelets that slowly evolve into a pure sample of 3 ML platelets. Less reactive selenourea precursors and long reaction times eventually led to small amounts of 4 ML and 5 ML nanoplatelets visible in the photoluminescence emission spectrum of aliquots, presumably via a ripening process.
The synthesis of CdS nanoplatelets was less selective for the 3 ML thickness. The most reactive trisubstituted thioureas form mixtures of nanoplatelets with different thicknesses. For example, syntheses beginning from 1 and 2 form 4 ML, and 5 ML CdS nanoplatelets as impurities within 5 minutes of reaction. Less reactive precursors such as the monosubstituted cyclic thiones (11–14) cleanly form 3 ML CdS nanoplatelets. The 3 ML CdS nanoplatelets slowly convert to 4 ML CdS nanoplatelets at much longer reaction times than those used in our kinetics measurements, presumably by a ripening mechanism. The lower selectivity of rapid reactions suggests that the nucleation of the 4th and 5th layers is more rapid at high supersaturation. Nonetheless, in all cases, ripening is much slower than precursor limited growth, and 3 ML nanoplatelets are the major product.
The lateral dimensions of nanoplatelets were measured throughout the reaction using high angle annular dark field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) (Fig. 2, see ESI† for error analysis). These measurements indicate that nanoplatelets grow via lateral extension (see ESI†). Example nanoplatelet dimensions observed in aliquots are shown in Fig. 2. The theoretical volume of nanoplatelets measured with HAADF-STEM and the yield measured by UV-vis absorption spectroscopy were used to estimate a nanoplatelet concentration at each time point (Fig. S6†). The nanoplatelet concentrations are stable over the course of the reaction, which is consistent with the formation of a single population of nanoplatelets at early times that is slow to ripen or aggregate. The slow kinetics of ripening/aggregation simplifies our analysis of the spectral evolution of alloyed platelets described below.
Fig. 2 CdSe nanoplatelets from a NPL reaction using 18. (A–D) STEM images of aliquots at reaction time indicated. (E) Histogram of the average nanoplatelet length measured from STEM images. |
The influence of kobs on the final nanoplatelet dimensions and nanoplatelet concentration is shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen that the concentration of nanoplatelets increases with the conversion reactivity. The relationship is consistent with a homogeneous nucleation and growth mechanism as described using nucleation mass balance models.32 Interestingly, at a given value of kobs, the number of CdS nanoplatelets is ∼4 times greater than the number of CdSe nanoplatelets. Similar behavior is observed when synthesizing CdS and CdSe quasi-spherical nanocrystals in the absence of cadmium acetate.11
Fig. 3 Theoretical nanoplatelet concentration (yellow = CdS, red = CdSe), determined from the nanoplatelet size as measured by TEM and assuming 100% yield of CdE (10 mM) as nanoplatelets, versus the associated precursor kobs. The average edge length of CdS nanoplatelets as measured by TEM is shown on the right axis. Error in the nanoplatelet concentration is propagated from the standard deviation in the average length as measured by TEM (see ESI†). Note, that the right hand axis only applies to the edge length of CdS. CdSe nanoplatelets are 4% larger than the axis indicates. |
In the absence of Ostwald ripening or aggregation, the number of nanoplatelets is determined by the relative kinetics of growth and nucleation. These two manifolds compete for solutes. Faster growth kinetics effectively divert solutes from the nucleation manifold leading to fewer and larger nanoplatelets. A 4× difference in the growth kinetics of CdSe and CdS can explain their relative extents of nucleation shown in Fig. 3. The lower amount of CdSe nanoplatelets produced at a given solute supply rate suggests that CdSe nanoplatelets grow more rapidly than CdS nanoplatelets under otherwise identical conditions. A similar observation was made in our study of spherical QDs.11
A difference in growth kinetics could impact the solute evolution and microstructure in mixed precursor synthesis (Scheme 1). Under conditions where the solute is composed of both sulfide and selenide a 4× faster rate of CdSe attachment will cause CdSe to concentrate toward the nanoplatelet core. While it has been reported that cadmium sulfide attaches more readily than zinc sulfide,33 less is known about the relative rate of sulfide and selenide attachment. Detailed measurements of the nanoplatelet composition could, in principle, be used to address this issue.
For example, phase segregated CdSe/CdS core/crown nanoplatelets form when combining precursors with >10× relative kobs (Fig. 4A). At early times the absorption spectrum of a relatively pure phase CdSe core nanoplatelet is observed that slowly adds spectral features of the CdS crown material. In these cases, the energy and width of the photoluminescence spectrum is similar to what is observed from pure phase materials.34
The growth of alloyed compositions, however, display broadened spectra that are shifted relative to the spectra of pure phase materials. By combining precursors with nearly matched conversion reactivities, homogeneous solid solutions can be synthesized, which were verified with powder X-ray diffraction (Fig. S14†). Fig. 4B displays the temporal evolution of aliquots during the formation of a homogeneous solid solution (CdS1−xSex, X = 0.5) produced from 8 and 18 whose conversion reactivity differs 2×. Absent any competitive inhibition between precursors or attachment kinetics that are selective for one of the chalcogenides, identical conversion reactivity results in a S/Se solute composition set by the initial ratio of the precursors. The slow increase in intensity and lack of spectral shifting throughout the course of the nanoplatelet growth is consistent with this picture. This evolution supports the formation of a homogeneous composition that is relatively stable to ripening and phase segregation. STEM EELS mapping of Cd, Se, and S support a homogeneous distribution of these elements across the nanoplatelet (Fig. S15†). Similar results were obtained with several pairs of precursors with matched reactivity (see ESI†).
The luminescence from homogeneous alloy nanoplatelets occurs near the tail of the absorption onset, particularly in CdSe poor alloys (Fig. 5). These characteristics are distinct from pure phase and core/shell and core/crown architectures where the Stokes shift and linewidths are known to be much smaller.35 The spectral width of the band edge luminescence from alloyed nanoplatelets is also nearly twice that of pure phase CdSe or CdSe/CdS core/crown and core/shell microstructures (Fig. 5C).23,36 The relatively large breadth and apparent Stokes shift is to be expected from fluctuations of the alloy microstructure, and the increased electron phonon coupling caused by localization of excitons on impurities ions (e.g. Se substitution in CdS).37 Such effects are most significant in selenium poor alloys, where the FWHM and the apparent Stokes shift are greatest (Fig. 5B and C). The photoluminescence may be further broadened by heterogeneity in the distribution of nanoplatelet microstructures.
Pairs of sulfur and selenium precursors whose reactivity is <10× result in graded heterostructures. The phase segregation or extent of gradation from core to shell depends on the similarity of the kobs and the ratio of precursors injected. Fig. 4C shows the spectral evolution of a graded CdS/CdSe nanoplatelet during growth. The simulated composition evolves from a mixed CdS1−xSex core rich in sulfur to a nearly pure phase CdSe region, which is consistent with the observed spectral shifting and narrowing of the absorption and photoluminescence linewidths. These changes are consistent with the localization of excitons to CdSe rich regions at nanoplatelet edges.
While sulfur and selenium rich regions of 4 ML core–crown nanoplatelets can be imaged using transmission electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (TEM-EDX),38 3 ML nanoplatelets prepared in this study were unstable to beam damage unless measurements were conducted at 100 K or lower. At low temperatures it was possible to distinguish sulfide rich and selenide rich regions using scanning transmission electron microscopy and electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS) (Fig. 6 and S16–S19†). However, the signal to noise was not sufficient to study the gradation in detail. Fig. 6 shows STEM-EELS 2D maps and linescans of a CdS1−xSex/CdSe graded core/crown nanoplatelet. The distribution of selenium and sulfur is consistent with the spectral evolution. However, the signal to noise was insufficient to measure the slope of the gradation between CdS and CdSe in graded alloys and prevented more detailed analysis of the microstructure.
However, our Raman measurements were performed at 77 K where anharmonic phonon–phonon coupling shifts these bands to higher frequencies.41 This effect can explain why our low temperature measurement is ∼4 cm−1 greater than a similar measurement conducted at room temperature (ν(CdSe)LO (298 K) 199.5 cm−1).40 The magnitude of this temperature dependent shift is similar to previous studies on 5 ML CdSe nanoplatelets.42
In the Raman spectra of homogeneous alloys (CdS1−xSex, x = 0, 0.2, 0.5, 0.7, and 1), both the ν(CdSe)LO and ν(CdS)LO frequencies decrease as their mole fraction decreases (Fig. 7 and S8†). The ν(CdSe)LO shifts from 203.7 cm−1 for pure CdSe, to 194.9 cm−1 for CdS0.8Se0.2, and the ν(CdS)LO shifts from 298.8 cm−1 for pure CdS to 292.6 cm−1 for CdS0.3Se0.7. The frequency changes induced by the alloy variation are consistent with the two mode behavior of bulk and quantum dot alloys of CdSe and CdS11,43 and strongly support the intermixing of sulfur and selenium on the atomic scale. We can compare these frequency shifts to spherical quantum dots composed of homogeneous CdS1−xSex alloys reported by us earlier.11 Those ν(CdSe)LO frequencies are 2–5 cm−1 higher than in nanoplatelets of comparable composition. We attribute the lower nanoplatelet values to the stronger phonon confinement in the ∼0.9 nm thickness direction. In contrast, the quantum dot ν(CdS)LO frequencies are 5–16 cm−1 lower than in nanoplatelets of comparable composition, suggesting that Cd–S stretches in alloyed nanoplatelets have more in-plane character than Cd–Se stretches.
Core–crown nanoplatelets whose interfaces have graded compositions display a ν(CdSe)LO that shifts from 199.9 cm−1 to 196.7 cm−1 to 196.1 cm−1 as the interface becomes more diffuse: CdS/CdSe to CdS/CdS1−xSex/CdSe to CdS0.5Se0.5 (Fig. S7†). The corresponding shift in ν(CdS)LO is also to lower frequency: from 298.1 cm−1 to 294.7 cm−1 to 294.2 cm−1. For both LO modes, the phase segregated core/crown frequency is distinct from the graded alloy and homogeneous alloy, but the alloy structures (i.e. graded and homogeneous) cannot be distinguished on the basis of ν(CdE)LO alone. Interestingly, for CdS/CdSe core/crown nanoplatelets, ν(CdS)LO matches the frequency of the pure CdS nanoplatelet sample, while ν(CdSe)LO is shifted to lower frequency relative to the pure material. Strain plays a role in heterostructure phonon frequencies. Past experiments on CdSe/CdS core/shell quantum dots show that when CdS has the dominant impact on the lattice constant for CdSe, the CdSe LO frequency will increase.44 As a result, our observations indicate that confinement has a larger effect on ν(CdSe)LO than strain, possibly due to the relatively narrow crown region.
UV-visible absorbance spectra were obtained using a PerkinElmer Lambda 950 spectrophotometer equipped with deuterium and halogen lamps. Photoluminescence measurements were performed using a Fluoromax 4 from Horiba Scientific.
Ground cadmium acetate dihydrate (0.250 g, 1.08 mmol, 6.25 eq.) and 1-octadecene (14 mL) are added to a three neck round bottom flask equipped with a stir bar, a glass thermocouple well, and sealed with a septum. The flask is attached to a Schlenk line and degassed with vigorous stirring for 15 minutes before replacing the atmosphere with argon and heating the mixture to 195 °C. When the temperature reaches 100 °C, oleic acid (60.0 μL, 0.0537 g, 0.19 mmol) (1.26 eq.) of oleic acid are injected. When the temperature reaches 195 °C, the chalcogen precursor stock solution (1 mL) is immediately and swiftly injected. Aliquots for UV-vis absorption and photoluminescence measurements are removed throughout the reaction and diluted 35-fold with toluene.
After the reaction is complete, oleic acid (0.5 mL) is injected and the flask is removed from heat. When the reaction mixture has cooled under argon for approximately an hour, the mixture is cleaned by centrifuging at 7200 rpm for 3 minutes to remove any precipitate. The supernatant is diluted with acetone (10 mL) and the cloudy suspension centrifuged for 4 minutes. The nanoplatelet gel is then dispersed in toluene (5 mL) and acetone (10 mL) is added and the cloudy suspension centrifuged. The resulting nanoplatelets can then be suspended in toluene or hexanes (10 mL).
Nanoplatelet imaging and sizing by STEM was performed on an FEI Talos F200X at 200 kV. STEM energy dispersive spectra were measured with a SuperX-EDS system using spectra mode. Elemental weight percentages were calculated from SKα: 2.23–2.48 keV; SeLα,β: 1.16–1.60 keV; SeKα: 11.00–11.40 keV; SeKβ: 12.36–12.68 keV; CdLβ: 3.00–3.65 keV. Detailed discussion of nanoplatelet dimension measurements and error is found in the ESI.†
STEM-EELS was performed on an aberration-corrected FEI Titan Themis 300 operating at 120 kV equipped with 965 GIF Quantum ER to access the cadmium M4,5 edge at 404 eV, the selenium L2 and L3 edges at 1476 and 1436 eV, and the sulfur L2,3 edge at 165 eV. The sulfur K edge at 2472 eV proved to be inaccessible. Spectra were recorded on either a Gatan K2 direct electron detector operating in electron counting mode or an UltraScan 1000 CCD detector with DualEELS recording to probe the sulfur L2,3 and selenium L2,3 edge simultaneously. DualEELS cycles between the high loss and low loss regions46 so that the maps can be overlaid (Fig. 4B). All data was collected at −140 °C to minimize radiation damage under the electron probe. Data was analyzed using Cornell Spectrum Imager Toolkit in FIJI/ImageJ.47
We measured two 3 ML nanoplatelet series with Raman spectroscopy. In the first series, nanoplatelets are made with precursors with matched reactivities and varying Se:S ratios and thus constitute homogeneous alloys CdS1−xSex, with x = 0, 0.2, 0.5, 0.7, and 1. In the second series, the composition ratio of selenium to sulfur of each nanoplatelet is held constant at 50% Se and 50% S, while the morphology of the interfacial region is varied: phase segregated core/crown nanoplatelets (CdS/CdSe), nanoplatelets with a more diffuse interfacial region (CdS/CdS1−xSex/CdSe), and a homogeneous alloy (CdS0.5Se0.5). For all of the samples, other than pure CdS (i.e. CdS1−xSex, with x = 0), the excitation laser is resonant with the lowest energy excitonic transitions or just above. All data were fit using Lorentzian line shapes and suggest fit uncertainties in the peak frequencies lower than ±1 cm−1, and measurement to measurement variability of the peak frequencies closer to ±1.5 cm−1.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc03384h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |