Open Access Article
Aleksandra
Nilova‡
,
Michael D.
Mannchen‡
,
Abdias N.
Noel
,
Evgeniya
Semenova
and
Alexander J.
Grenning
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Florida, PO Box 117200, Gainesville 32611, FL, USA. E-mail: grenning@ufl.edu
First published on 14th February 2023
An asymmetric allylic alkylation/Cope rearrangement (AAA/[3,3]) capable of stereoselectively constructing vicinal stereocenters has been developed. Strategically integrated 4-methylation on the 3,3-dicyano-1,5-diene controls stereoselectivity and drives Cope rearrangement equilibrium in the forward direction. The AAA/[3,3] sequence rapidly converts abundant achiral and racemic starting materials into valuable (hetero)cycloalkane building blocks bearing significant functional and stereochemical complexity, highlighting the value of (hetero)cyclohexylidenemalononitriles as launching points for complex heterocycle synthesis. On this line, the resulting alkylidenemalononitrile moiety can be readily converted into amides via Hayashi–Lear amidation to ultimately yield amido-piperidines, tropanes, and related scaffolds with 3–5 stereocenters and drug-like functionality.
:
1.5 er) and diastereomeric- (8
:
1 dr) mixtures (from AAA reaction) ultimately yield α-3°-amine-containing products with diminished enantiopurity due to stereodivergent Cope rearrangement mechanisms. Despite the value of these methods, they illustrate the effects of incomplete stereocontrol in the AAA/sigmatropic rearrangement sequence as well as the energetic challenges associated with this approach to vicinal stereocenter construction.18–21 Further, the aforementioned AAA/2-aza-Cope rearrangements (Scheme 1A) have yet to bear reports on diastereoselectivity about the [3,3] step, potentially due to these stereochemical issues or [3,3] energetic challenges.
Herein we report an enantio- and diastereoselective AAA/Cope rearrangement sequence between alkylidenemalononitriles and 1,3-disubstituted allylic electrophiles to yield functionally and stereochemically complex building blocks (Fig. 1C). Strategically integrated 4-methylation on the 3,3-dicyano-1,5-diene both controls stereoselectivity and drives Cope rearrangement equilibrium in the forward direction thus favoring the construction of the vicinal stereocenters at various temperatures (rt – 110 °C). The products contain two different alkene functional groups: the alkylidenemalononitrile can be mildly converted to amides diastereoselectively by NaBH4 reduction and Hayashi oxidative amidation/esterification.22,23 To maximize the impact of our work, we focused on the convergent coupling of functionalized starting materials, thus showcasing the tolerance of the sequence to structural modification and the potential value of the sequence for accessing functionally and stereochemically rich pharmaceutical leads. Therefore, this work yields complementary access to functionally- and structurally-complex piperidines, cyclohexanes, and related saturated heterocycles.24 Recent state of the art approaches to complex piperidines include C–H functionalization,25–28 from pyridine derivatives by hydrogenation or nucleophilic dearomatization,29–36 and other methods.37–40 A standout route to related cyclohexanes was described by Baran whereby Diels–Alder cycloaddition, desymmetrization, and decarboxylative coupling chemistry are impactfully harnessed.41
:
47 er (Table 1, entry 2). These findings suggest the reaction proceeds by a Pd-catalyzed kinetic resolution42–45 rather than a dynamic kinetic asymmetric transformation (DYKAT).46–49 Further increasing the equivalents of the electrophilic component did not improve the enantiomeric ratio (Table 1, entry 3), neither did switching to the Pd/naphthyl-Trost complex (Table 1, entry 4). However, we did see some impact with respect to the leaving group, as the allyl acetate (Table 1, entries 6–7) resulted in a slightly increased enantiomeric ratio compared to the methyl carbonate. Additionally, the residual allylcarbonate (2a) was found to be highly enantioenriched (92
:
8 er) (Table 1). Considering 2.5 equivalents of rac-2a were initially used, the 92
:
8 er was somewhat unexpected. This potentially suggests that in situ generated reagents (e.g., carbonate anion, hydrogen methyl carbonate, or methanol) could be acting as a nucleophile or base to further consume the reactive enantiomer of 2a. Additional experimentation is required to better understand this enantioselective transformation.
| Entry | Equiv. rac-2a | LG | Base | Ligand (5 mol%) | % Conv. (yield) | er |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The excess electrophile 2a was isolated in 40% yield (of a maximum 50%; kinetic resolution) and 92 : 8 er.
|
||||||
| 1a | 2.5 | OCO2Me | — | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 100% (67%) | 94 : 6 |
| 2 | 1 | OCO2Me | — | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 98% | 53 : 47 |
| 3 | 5 | OCO2Me | — | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 100% | 88 : 12 |
| 4 | 2.5 | OCO2Me | — | (S,S)-DACH-naphthyl | 100% | 83 : 17 |
| 5 | 2.5 | OBoc | — | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 100% | 93 : 7 |
| 6 | 2.5 | OAc | DIPEA | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 100% (55%) | 95 : 5 |
| 7 | 2.5 | OAc | K3PO4 | (S,S)-DACH-phenyl | 100% (74%) | 97 : 3 |
We next examined the scope of a tandem catalytic-asymmetric 3,3-dicyano-1,5-diene synthesis/Cope rearrangement for preparing enantioenriched building blocks 4 diastereoselectively. As evidenced in Scheme 1, the sequence is extremely tolerant to structural modifications and is generally high yielding and stereoselective (up to 99
:
1 er). This is due to the mild conditions for both the catalytic-asymmetric allylic alkylation and the Cope rearrangement. This approach allows access to N-tosyl-piperidine alkylidenemalononitriles bearing N-Boc-piperidyl (4b), N-Boc-azetidinyl (4c), benzyl (4d), 4-chlorophenyl (4a; Table 1), fluorophenyl (4e–4f), differentially substituted pyridyl groups (4g–4i), and indole (4j).
A decrease in er was observed for several (hetero)aromatic examples (e.g., 4a, 4e, 4h, 4i), yet this could be improved by exchanging the allyl carbonate for the corresponding allyl acetate electrophiles (e.g., 4a, 4i, and 4j). The incorporation of a nitrile functional group (4k) was not particularly selective under conditions of asymmetric allylic alkylation via kinetic resolution. However, allylic alkylation of crotyl cyanohydrin can be achieved in high er via stereospecific allylic alkylation.19,50 The N-tosyl protecting group common to products 4a–4k can be exchanged for a more easily removable N-Boc group (4l) without notable changes to yield or er. Similarly, we examined various (hetero)cyclohexylidenemalononitriles 1c–1e. On this line, substituted tetrahydropyran (1c to 4m–4n), thiopyran (1d to 4o–4p), and ketal-protected cyclohexanone (1e to 4q–4r) analogs were accessed in high er.
We also targeted difluorocyclohexyl products (Scheme 2A). Interestingly, these substrates had poor thermodynamic profiles for Cope rearrangement, and the respective Cope isomers 3 and 4 were inseparable by column chromatography. To yield the targeted building blocks, we employed our previously reported “reductive Cope rearrangement” to drive forward the [3,3] process.19,51,52 As such, promoting Cope rearrangement in the presence of Hantzsch ester resulted in full conversion and good yields and stereoselectivity for products 5a and 5b.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 (A) Application of the reductive Cope rearrangement for substrates with unfavorable energetic profiles. (B) Scalability of Pd-catalyzed kinetic resolution/Cope rearrangement. | ||
Importantly, the enantioselective synthesis of products 4 is scalable; as shown in Scheme 2B, we efficiently prepared gram quantities of a representative building block 4b. The catalyst loading could also be reduced tenfold, though the efficiency decreased slightly (69% yield, 95
:
5 er). Overall, these results suggest that large quantities of these functionally and stereochemically dense building blocks can be efficiently generated for diverse downstream modification.
In addition to the exploration of achiral alkylidenemalononitriles 1a–1f (Schemes 1 and 2), prochiral alkylidenemalononitriles 1g–1i were also investigated (Scheme 3).53,54 For these substrates, we observed a high degree of enantioselectivity with respect to asymmetric allylic alkylation, but an ∼50
:
50 mixture of 1,5-diene diastereomers: the chiral-racemic carbanions generated by deprotonation of 1g–1i couple at equivalent rates with the chiral-nonracemic Pd-π-allyl intermediates, thus yielding enantioenriched diastereomers epi-3u–3ee and 3u–3ee (Scheme 3A). These diastereomers were resolved through a Cope rearrangement to yield products 4u–4ee (maximum theoretical yield of 50%). The prepared compounds exhibit a high degree of structural diversity. Specifically, we accessed N-tosyl-tropinones bearing N-Boc-piperidyl (4u), N-Boc-azetidyl (4v), 4-chlorophenyl (4w), fluoroaromatic (4x and 4y), and differentially substituted pyridyl groups (4z–4cc). The structure of the products was confirmed by an X-ray crystallographic analysis of enantiopure compound 4y. While the stereoselectivity in this series was generally good (86
:
14 er–95
:
5 er), some modestly selective examples were observed in the pyridyl series (e.g., 4cc). In addition, we assessed the reactivity of aza- and oxo-[3.2.1]cyclooctene-based alkylidenemalononitriles. The corresponding products (4dd and 4ee) were isolated in high yields and good er. Finally, this reaction could be performed on the gram scale (Scheme 3B), though a slightly diminished enantiomeric ratio was observed (98
:
2 vs. 86
:
14).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 (A) Meso-bicyclicalkylidenemalononitriles react via Pd-catalyzed AAA and Cope rearrangement kinetic resolution. | ||
In addition to meso-bicyclic alkylidenemalononitriles 1g–1i (e.g., tropane derivatives; Scheme 3), we also examined meso-4-substituted cyclohexylidenemalononitrile 1j (Scheme 4). This substrate displayed some practical challenges but could still be converted to valuable, enantioenriched polysubstituted and functionalized cyclohexanes. Like the chemistry described in Scheme 3, the AAA-step here yielded two diastereomeric 1,5-dienes, epi-3ff and 3ff. In contrast, the [3,3] kinetic profiles for both diastereomers were similar resulting in a major product and minor product diastereomeric mixture via [3,3]. For the case examined, the Cope starting material 3ff and Cope product 4ff diastereomers were inseparable via silica gel chromatography. Thus, to access characterizable products, we opted to chemically separate the isomers via NaBH4 reduction and oxidative amidation with morpholine. This was effective and yielded product 6ff as a single diastereomer (88
:
12 er) in 14% overall yield from 1j. This sequence also showcases a key challenge in need of addressing in future studies: there are currently no methods to desymmetrize meso-alkylidenemalononitriles. Such a development would address the stereoselectivity challenges present in Schemes 3 and 4.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 4 Meso-4-substituted cyclohexylidenemalononitriles as reactants for Pd-catalyzed AAA and Cope rearrangement. | ||
While the Pd-catalyzed kinetic resolution of substrates like rac-2 has been disclosed in the past, previous reports had limited examples of diverse electrophiles.42–45 Our work thoroughly establishes the types of allylic electrophiles that are highly efficient (the methyl/aliphatic allylic electrophiles; 93
:
7 er–99
:
1 er), reasonably efficient (the methyl/aryl allylic electrophiles including 3-pyridyl; 86
:
14 er–93
:
7 er), and modestly efficient (methyl/2- and 4-pyridyl allylic electrophiles; 70
:
30 er–85
:
15 er) (Fig. 2).
This efficient enantioselective coupling of alkylidenemalononitriles and racemic allylic electrophiles yields diverse vicinally stereogenic building blocks with orthogonal alkene functional handles. We envisaged that the alkylidenemalononitrile moiety could be converted to amides/esters via NaBH4 reduction and Hayashi oxidative amidation or esterification,22,23 and the neutral alkene could be utilized in olefin metathesis55 and ozonolysis56 as summarized in Scheme 4. On this line, the alkylidenemalononitrile can be consistently converted to carboxylate derivatives (Scheme 5A). This transformation gives access to amide and ester products derived from 2° amines (6a), 1° amines (6b), methoxymethyl amine (yielding a Weinreb amide) (6c), and methanol (6d). High compatibility of this protocol was confirmed through the presence and persistence of various functional groups on products 6e–6j.
We examined the metathesis reactivity of 6j, which resulted in ring-opening/cross-metathesis57,58 to 2,3,4,6-tetrasubstituted N-Boc-piperidine 9 (Scheme 5B). Under no circumstance was the formation of a product analogous to 8 observed. We speculate that the N-Boc group is either sterically blocking the initiation of ring-closing metathesis (RCM) or chelating the necessary ruthylidene to an unreactive conformer preventing RCM. Compound 7 was prepared via a telescoped asymmetric allylic alkylation/Cope rearrangement/NaBH4 reduction sequence. This scaffold, by a tandem ring-rearrangement metathesis (RRM)59–61/oxidative amidation, yielded highly substituted pyran-fused cyclopentene 8. Altogether, a rigid-bicyclic framework 8 decorated with various functional groups (alkenes, chloroarene, morpholine–amide) can be prepared efficiently from the alkylidenemalononitrile and the racemic allylic electrophile. The alkylidenemalononitrile moiety of tropanes 4v, 4w and 4z was surprisingly resistant to NaBH4 reduction. However, it was found that treatment of these scaffolds with ozone followed by NaBH4 yields products 10a–10c. It is proposed that the neutral alkene undergoes chemoselective ozonolysis, and upon NaBH4 reduction, the alcohol is generated which directs and allows the otherwise sterically blocked alkylidenemalononitrile reduction. Finally, it was found that substrates 10a–10c undergo intramolecular oxidative esterification to 11a–11c. Notably, while Hayashi has reported intermolecular conversion of malononitriles into amides and esters, this work establishes the first report of an intramolecular variant of this effective chemistry (Scheme 6).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 6 This method can uniquely populate piperidine, tropane, and cyclohexane pharmaceutical space. | ||
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2193763 and 2193762. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc07021a |
| ‡ Equal contribution. These authors reserve the right to list their names first. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |