Xiaohui
Liu‡
a,
Xianli
Li‡
b,
Jie
Li
a,
Xin
Lian
a,
Yonghong
Xiao
a,
Ruosheng
Zeng
c,
Shao-Fei
Ni
a,
Ke
Xu
d,
Yan
Kuai
*e,
Wen-Xiu
Ni
b and
Binbin
Luo
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry and Key Laboratory for Preparation and Application of Ordered Structural Materials of Guangdong Province, Shantou University, Shantou 515063, P. R. China. E-mail: bbluo@stu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Medicinal Chemistry, Shantou University Medical College, Shantou 515041, P. R. China
cSchool of Physical Science and Technology, State Key Laboratory of Featured Metal Materials and Life-Cycle Safety for Composite Structures, Guangxi University, Nanning 530004, P. R. China
dMultiscale Crystal Materials Research Center, Shenzhen Institute of Advanced Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shenzhen 518055, P. R. China
eInformation Materials and Intelligent Sensing Laboratory of Anhui Province, Anhui University, Hefei 230601, P. R. China. E-mail: yankuai@ahu.edu.cn
First published on 5th April 2023
A full understanding of the excimer formation and structure–property relationship is essential to their development in organic electronics. Herein, we propose a template strategy for finely modulating the stacking configuration of 9-dimethylaminomethyl-10-chloroanthracene (DCAn) dimers in two-dimensional (2D) (DCAn)4Pb3Br10·2CH3(CH2)X−1OH (1-CX, 1 ≤ X ≤ 8). By introducing alcohol guests with varied carbon lengths from methanol to octanol, 1-CX with different stacking motifs of (anthracene) An dimers are obtained. The fine control on stacking parameters, including interplanar distance, overlap ratio, offset along long (dx) and short (dy) axis and intersection angle of An allows a deep insight into the key factors of excimer formation. The experimental and computational results confirm that the excimer interaction is strongly determined by the excimer types (anthracene or naphthalene) and interplanar overlap. An anthracene-type excimer is formed for 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) once dx locates in the range of 1.08–1.23 Å, while 1-CX (1 ≤ X ≤ 5) adopts the naphthalene-type excimer for 1.55 ≤ dx ≤ 1.75 Å. Due to the stronger anthracene-type excimer interaction, a great bathochromic shift of photoluminescence is observed for 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8). Additionally, rod-like 1-CX exhibits a high aspect ratio of ∼72, thereby generating an excellent performance on optical waveguide with an optical loss coefficient of ∼3 dB mm−1. This work not only reveals the key factors on An excimer formation, but also provides an effective strategy for better understanding the structure–property of molecular excimers.
Low-dimensional metal halide hybrids (MHHs) have been intensively assembled with diverse organic cations for optoelectronic applications due to their unique band structure and outstanding optical properties.15–24 As an anionic layer, the periodic and planar nature of the two-dimensional (2D) metal halide layer makes it a well-suited template for the ordered arrangement of organic cations, which is highly desirable for the deep understanding of molecular aggregates. Moreover, by engineering the band alignment between organic and inorganic layers, interlayer charge or energy transfer can be realized, resulting in distinct emissive behaviors. For instance, room temperature phosphorescence and triplet excimer emission of π-conjugated molecules are successfully observed through interlayer energy/electron transfer in 2D MHHs.18,25–27 These results indicate that the anionic metal halide layer can function as a substrate for assembling π-conjugated cations to understand the structure–properties of molecular aggregates. Simultaneously, the presence of halogen ions provides enriched hydrogen binding sites for incorporating guest molecules, which can play the role of the modulator in controlling the dimeric configuration.
In this work, the anthracene (An) derivative 9-dimethylaminomethyl-10-chloroanthracene (DCAn) has been successfully synthesized and adopted as an organic countercation to construct 2D single-layered (DCAn)4Pb3Br10·2CH3(CH2)X−1OH (1-CX, X represents the number of carbon atoms in alcohol guest). Due to the template effect of 1-CX, An dimers are orderly arranged and isolated through the interval of alcohol guests. By replacing with different alcohols (from methanol to octanol), the stacking configuration of An dimers, including the interplanar distance, overlap and intersection angles are finely modulated, which allows a comprehensive understanding of the structure–properties relationship and excimer formation.
Fig. 1 Crystal structures of (a) 1-C1, (b) 1-C2, (c) 1-C3, (d) 1-C4, (e) 1-C5, (f) 1-C6, (g) 1-C7 and (h) 1-C8. Pb (orange), Br (dark red), Cl (green), N (blue), O (red), and C (gray). |
The host–guest structural features of 1-C1 highlight the important role of methanol guests in the configuration of An dimers, which inspired us to reveal the effect of alcohol guests on tuning the configuration of An dimers. Upon replacing methanol with other saturated linear alcohol species, the structural features of the inorganic layer remained except for the occurrence of interlayer slippage in van der Waals interfaces for accommodating longer alcohol guests. Unexpectedly, water guest is simultaneously implanted into monoclinic 1-C6, 1-C7, and 1-C8 with a different space group of P21/c (Fig. 2), possibly attributed to the expanding space induced by the insertion of longer alcohol molecules (Fig. S6†). Compared to water-free samples, water molecules in 1-C6, 1-C7, and 1-C8 act as hydrogen-bond-mediators that strengthen the interplay between alcohol guests and hybrid hosts (Fig. S3b†).
Fig. 2 Arrangement of DCAn cations in the organic layers of (a) 1-C1, (b) 1-C2, (c) 1-C3, (d) 1-C4, (e) 1-C5, (f) 1-C6, (g) 1-C7 and (h) 1-C8. Cl (green), N (blue), O (red), and C (gray). |
Because of the template effect of the inorganic layer, discrete parallel-packed An dimers spaced by alcohol guests (Fig. 2) are obtained in 1-CX. With the increase in the number of carbon atoms in alcohol guests, the configuration of An dimers is greatly affected and the stacking parameters are shown in Table 1. As expected, the average interplanar distance (Table 1) of An dimers decreases gradually from 3.549 Å (1-C1) to 3.516 Å (1-C5) and then increases slightly from 3.440 Å (1-C6) to 3.463 Å (1-C8). Interestingly, a turning point of interplanar distance occurs from 1-C5 to 1-C6 (Fig. S7†). The initial reduction of interplanar distance is caused by the increasing volume of alcohol guests, while the subsequent increase is caused by the displacement of guests to the cavity surrounded by four dimers (Fig. 2h). Different from the alcohol guests with shorter lengths (1 ≤ X ≤ 5), the longer alcohol guests (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) insert into the adjacent organic layers (Fig. S6†), which expands the cavity between An dimers and induces the rotation of An dimers (Fig. 2e and f). Upon increasing the length of alcohol guests from hexanol to octanol, the inter-dimer cavity is too small to accommodate the guests including two alcohol molecules and one water molecule. As a result, the guests are forced to move into the cavity surrounded by four dimers.
Since the perpendicular distance of 1-CX is close to 3.3 Å as in graphite, a typical π–π interaction is anticipated for these samples. Previous works have also shown that An dimers with such a distance range usually exhibit strong excimer interaction.5,11,31–38 These series of 1-CX samples with similar configurations allow a deep insight into the key factors that affect the excimer formation. The phase purity of all samples was determined by XRD (Fig. S8†), in which the diffraction peaks of all the samples coincide well with the simulated patterns. Note that the diffraction peaks of 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) obtained at room temperature (RT) shift by only ∼0.1° towards lower angle direction compared to the corresponding simulated patterns obtained at 100 K, indicating the nearly identical structures of 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) at RT and 100 K.
Interestingly, the 1-C6 single crystal with a homogeneous distribution of all elements shows a rod-shaped morphology despite the 2D stacking feature of these samples (Fig. S9†). Upon 365 nm UV irradiation, rod-like 1-CX presented guest-dependent emission tuning from cyan to yellow-green, indicating the significant effect of alcohol guests on the optical properties of 1-CX (Fig. 3). To reveal the underlying mechanism, UV-vis, and photoluminescence (PL) spectra were conducted as shown in Fig. S10† and Fig. 3. The absorption spectra of both DCAn and (DCAn)Br methanolic solutions show fine-structured bands from 325 to 400 nm (Fig. S10a and b†), which are assigned to the π–π* transition of the An core.39 Correspondingly, identical emissive behavior with peaks at 405, 426, 450, and 482 nm generated from the DCAn monomer is observed for DCAn and (DCAn)Br methanolic solutions. Different from the optical properties of monomers in the solution, solid-state DCAn and (DCAn)Br containing isolated An dimers show an absorption step at ∼450 nm and a broadband emission centered at 567 and 515 nm (Fig. S10c and d†), respectively. With respect to the PL of methanolic solution, such a great bathochromic shift is caused by the strong An excimer interaction in the solid state.
In accordance with the UV-vis spectra of DCAn and (DCAn)Br powders, similar absorption behavior with an onset at ∼450 nm is observed for all 1-CX samples (Fig. 3a). The small step located at ∼390 nm derives from the absorption of lead bromide inorganic layers according to the previous study.30 Contradictory to the similar absorption behavior, 1-CX exhibits guest-dependent broadband emission (Fig. 3b) spanning the nearly whole visible range. The main peak gradually blue-shifts from 510 nm (1-C1) to 493 nm (1-C5), and then greatly red-shifts to ∼550 nm when the water guest molecules are involved (1-C6, 1-C7, and 1-C8). To understand the influence of the dimeric configuration on the evolution of PL emission, the structure parameters including interplanar distance and overlap area are correlated with PL, as shown in Fig. 3c and d. Consistent with reported works,37,40,41 the interplanar distance of An dimer shows unclear effects on the excimer formation in our case. Since a decent overlap of aromatic planes is required for excimer formation, a large overlap is expected to benefit the excimer formation.37 As shown in Fig. 3d, the main peak blue shifts gradually from 510 nm (1-C1) to 493 nm (1-C5) concurrent with a decrease of overlap from 53.7% to 45.9%. This evolution is also observed for 1-C6, 1-C7, and 1-C8 with water guests. Nevertheless, this conclusion seems contradictory to the experimental results once taking all 1-CX samples into account since 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) with a greater bathochromic emission show a smaller overlap relative to that of water-free 1-CX (1 ≤ X ≤ 5). This motivates us to take a closer look into the overlap motifs (Fig. 3e), which can be indicated by the offset along the long (dx) and short (dy) axis of An molecules. The values of dx are clustered into two groups including the range from 1.08 to 1.23 Å for 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) and 1.55–1.75 Å for 1-CX (1 ≤ X ≤ 5). It has been calculated that a double-potential-well will be formed once An dimer is excited at the optimal geometry of ground states (S0) with dx = 1.3 Å.4,39 As for 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) compounds with smaller dx (1.08 Å ≤ dx ≤ 1.23 Å), all three anthracene rings participate in the π–π interaction, anthracene-type excimer is expected upon excitation, while naphthalene-type excimer is preferred for compounds with a larger dx (1.55 Å ≤ dx ≤ 1.75 Å). Compared to naphthalene-type excimer, a larger charge-transfer (CT) contribution occurs for anthracene-type excimer, thereby leading to a greater bathochromic shift. Our experimental data are in good agreement with the calculated models.4 Moreover, this conclusion is also applicable to solid-state DCAn and (DCAn)Br, further confirming the reasonability of this model.
Based on the above model, the value of dy cannot change the types of the excimer, but tune the overlap. Therefore, dy shows a similar effect as that of the overlap on the emission of An dimer, i.e., smaller dy results in a larger overlap and greater bathochromic shift (Fig. 3f). The PL lifetime tests further provide evidence to our speculation, as shown in Fig. S11.† All samples show a monoexponential decay and the time constants can be separated into two groups including ∼21 ns for 1-CX (1 ≤ X ≤ 5) and 30 ns for 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8), indicating the difference in excimer-types. Due to the larger CT contribution in anthracene-type excimer, 1-CX (6 ≤ X ≤ 8) exhibits a larger degree of charge carrier delocalization, thus longer radiative lifetimes are expected.42
As a T-shaped molecule, the tertiary amine group of [DCAn]+ is fixed through coulombic interaction and hydrogen bonding with inorganic layers, which only allows the fan-like swing of DCAn once increasing the intermolecular repulsion. As a result, the intersection angle of An dimer increases progressively from 1.502° (1-C1) to 8.742° (1-C8) upon decreasing the interplanar distance from 3.549 to 3.459 Å (Fig. 3g). It has been reported that H-aggregate (slide pitch angle > 54.7°) dimer will result in large energy splitting into the excited states, in which the lower one is optically forbidden.43 In our case, the An dimers adopt the H-aggregated type for all 1-CX samples, as evidenced by the low PL quantum yield (QY). Nevertheless, with the increase of the intersection angle, H-aggregated dimers gradually transform into X-aggregated type concurrent with the breaking of optically forbidden transition.38 Therefore, PL QY (Fig. 3g) of 1-CX monotonically increases from 3.5 (1-C1) to 15.4 (1-C8). DCAn seems to be an exception, which is probably ascribed to the unprotonated state.
Considering the weak interaction between the alcohol guest and 1-CX host, we tried removing guest molecules by vacuum or heating activation to obtain a guest-free phase (1-CX-act.). As shown in Fig. 4a, the XRD pattern of 1-C1-act. shifts slightly towards a lower angle direction, verifying the increasing interlayer distance. The T-dependent XRD (Fig. S12†) also confirmed the generation of a new phase with a longer interlayer distance. Upon heating, a new diffraction peak rises on the left of the (002) peak until the complete transformation at 80 °C. Simultaneously, the removal of methanol guest causes a bathochromic shift of emission (Fig. 4b) from 510 (1-C1) to 543 nm (1-C1-act.), as evidenced by the color change of the logo pattern under UV irradiation (Fig. 4c). The guest-induced phase transformation and red-shift of emission are also observed for 1-C2 and 1-C3. As shown in Fig. S13a,† both 1-C2-act. and 1-C3-act. show nearly identical PL spectra as that of 1-C1-act., indicating the same stacking motif after activation. This result is consistent with the XRD patterns (Fig. S13b†), in which all diffraction peaks are well matched. However, the alcohol guests with longer lengths (4 ≤ X ≤ 8) cannot be removed through vacuum or heating activation, possibly attributed to the stronger guest–host interaction, higher boiling points, and larger volumes.
To understand the effect of methanol removal on the crystal structure and emission, the structure of guest-free 1-C1-act. is optimized through density functional theory (DFT) calculation, as shown in Fig. 4d. Consistent with the XRD result (Fig. 4a), the crystal structure obtained through DFT calculation exhibits an apparent increase of interlayer distance from 19.073 to 19.941 Å after activation (Fig. 4d), confirming the reasonability of the optimized 1-C1-act. structure. After removing methanol molecules, the interplanar distance of An cores increases to 4.016 Å (Fig. 4e). However, the variation of perpendicular distance looks contradictory to the great bathochromic shift of emission since the interplanar distance with 4.016 Å usually generates weaker excimer interaction.11,37 Although the interplanar distance of An cores is increased, the removal of methanol guest also helps the transformation of An aggregates from dimeric to long-range stacking, which enhances the π–π interaction and exciton delocalization. This speculation can be confirmed by the T-dependent PL test of 1-C1-act. and 1-C4. As shown in Fig. S14,† the PL spectra of 1-C1-act. gradually shift to a blue direction, while a red shift is observed for 1-C4 upon decreasing T. Such opposite behavior is ascribed to the different stacking motifs of the An aggregates. Since the butanol guest of 1-C4 cannot be removed through vacuum activation, lowering T will enhance the dimeric interaction of An, but weaken the long-range π–π interaction of 1-C1-act.
DFT calculations (Fig. S15†) were conducted to better understand the electronic and band nature. Due to a large number of atoms and the limitation of computing resources, 1-C5, and 1-C7 were chosen and compared. Although 1-CX possesses similar structural features and components, a great difference in bandgap is observed for 1-C5 (1.41 eV) and 1-C7 (1.81 eV) with an indirect nature (Fig. S15a and c†). The total density of states (TDOS) of 1-C5 (Fig. S15b†) and 1-C7 (Fig. S15d†) show that the top of the valence band (VB) is primarily contributed by the inorganic components, while the bottom of the conduction band is mainly composed of C p states from An core. Since 1-CX (X = 6, 7, 8) adopt a non-parallel orientation of An dimers, a weaker inter-dimer coupling of π-electrons and a more discrete energy level is expected. Therefore, the difference in bandgap possibly results from the various stacking modes of dimers in organic layers.
1-CX with rod-like morphology show bright emissive spots on the tips (Fig. 3a), indicating their potential in the optical waveguide.44–47 As shown in Fig. 5a and b, both 1-C5 and 1-C7 show a high aspect ratio up to ∼72 and the tips of all rod-shaped crystals exhibit much brighter spots under the irradiation of unfocused UV light. Such easily observed optical waveguide behavior motivates us to evaluate the optical loss coefficient. By varying the excitation laser beam (λ = 405 nm) at different positions of an individual 1D microcrystal (Fig. 5c), the spatially resolved PL images were obtained through near-field scanning optical microscopy (Fig. 5d and e). The intensity ratio between the tips and bodies (Itip/Ibody) against the propagation distance is fitted with a single-exponential function Itip/Ibody = Aexp(−RD), where A is a constant, R is optical loss coefficient and D is the distance between the excited site and the emitting tip.48,49 The R values were calculated to be 3.11 and 2.68 dB mm−1 for 1-C5 and 1-C7 (Fig. 5f and g), respectively, which are significantly smaller than most of the previously reported values for hybrid materials (Table S5†). Such excellent performance is possibly ascribed to the high crystallization and emission with a large Stokes shift, which diminishes the effect of light scattering and reabsorption during propagation.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: The experimental section, synthetic route of DCAn, crystal structure, crystal data, XRD, absorption, and PL spectra. CCDC 2240927 ((DCAn)Br), 2240928 (1-C3), 2240929 (1-C5), 2240930 (1-C4), 2240931 (1-C2), 2240932 (1-C7), 2240933 (1-C1), 2240934 (1-C8), 2240935 (1-C9), 2240936 (1-C6) and 2240942 (DCAn). For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3qi00289f |
‡ X. Liu and X. Li contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |