Open Access Article
Alexander A.
Fadeev
and
Martin
Kotora
*
Department of Organic Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Albertov 6, 128 43 Praha 2, Czech Republic. E-mail: kotora@natur.cuni.cz; Fax: +420 221 951 053; Tel: +420 221 951 326
First published on 11th July 2023
Photoreactions of quinones with alkynes under catalytic and non-catalytic conditions were studied. In contrast to recent reports, simple irradiation with blue light is sufficient to trigger [2 + 2] photocycloadditions, which afford either fused cyclobutenes or reactive para-quinone methides (p-QMs) depending on the quinone structure. Revision of the chemo- and regioselectivity of the uncatalyzed photoreactions provided useful insight into their overlooked relatedness to the recently developed catalytic protocols. Experimental evidence indicates that the reactivity of the photochemically generated p-QMs is sufficient to perform uncatalyzed reactions with nucleophiles, which can help to explain the existing transformations and develop new cascade transformations involving quinones and alkynes.
Quinones play an important role in chemistry and biology, largely due to their redox and photoredox properties. Since the discovery of [2 + 2] photodimerization of thymoquinone by Liebermann in 1877,5 the photochemistry of quinones has received considerable attention and continues to grow.6 Reactions of quinones with alkynes have attracted increased interest due to the accessibility of the starting materials and the structural diversity of the products, which was later broadened with the aid of catalysis.
Uncatalyzed photoreactions of quinones with alkynes have been reported since the 1960s, yielding either fused cyclobutenes or p-quinone methides (p-QMs) via π–π* or n–π* quinone triplet states, respectively (Scheme 1).7 The reaction outcome strongly depends on the electronic properties of the used quinone: electron-poor p-benzoquinones give p-QMs, while electronically richer methoxy-p-benzoquinones and naphthoquinones give cyclobutenes as main products. Notably, highly polar substrates reportedly react even in the absence of light.8 In recent years, such reactions have found application in the synthesis of push–pull chromophores and spiro-systems,8 caged compounds,9 and activators of mRNAs.10
Over the past decade, several catalytic photoreactions involving quinones and alkynes have been developed, enabling the synthesis of structurally diverse products: aryl ketones,11,12 indoles,13 naphthofurans14 and various carbonyl compounds with a sterically hindered quaternary stereocenter in the α-position.15 Given that these photocatalytic methods have already demonstrated high potential in diversity-oriented synthesis and target-oriented synthesis aimed at pharmaceuticals and their precursors, the development of purely photochemical versions of such processes may help to minimize the generated waste, synthesis costs, and the risks associated with product contamination by transition metals. To achieve this, some of the aforementioned catalytic transformations relied on uncatalyzed photointeraction between quinones and alkynes to generate p-QMs as intermediates,15 although the subsequent uncatalyzed reactions with nucleophiles were found problematic.15a,e,f However, other reports excluded12,13 or did not consider11,14 such an interaction as part of the primary or secondary reaction pathway. Nevertheless, establishing pathways and conditions for product formation without a catalyst is important not only for the mechanistic understanding of such processes, but also for developing their enantioselective variants.15b,c
Herein, we report the possibilities of uncatalyzed [2 + 2] photocycloadditions of quinones with alkynes, compare their chemo- and regioselectivity with the recent catalytic versions and revise the structures of three reported cycloaddition products. In addition, we establish the conditions for an efficient uncatalyzed addition of nucleophiles to the photochemically generated p-QMs, highlighting its reversibility and utility in the development of synthetically useful cascade transformations using easily accessible quinones and alkynes.
C bonds. Thus, when phenylacetylene reacted with 1,4-naphthoquinone or with 2,6-dimethylbenzoquinone, p-QMs 1c and 1d were obtained in lower yields (32% and 40%) due to the concurrent formation of cyclobutenes 2c and 2d (12% and 29%). In fact, 1c was obtained as a mixture of stereoisomers Z-1c and E-1c in a 6/1 ratio. Pure Z-1c (Z/E > 20/1) was obtained by crystallization of the isomeric mixture from DCM/hexanes and its structure was confirmed by X-ray diffraction analysis (see the ESI, Section 3†). Prolonged exposure of photosensitive Z-1c to blue light caused its isomerization into E-1c and aromatization of the latter.7d,10a In contrast to electron-rich quinones, electron-poor tetrachloro-1,4-benzoquinone and 2,6-dibromo-1,4-benzoquinone reacted with diphenylacetylene chemoselectively to give p-QMs 1e and 1f as main products. Finally, several p-QMs were found to be unstable in the pure state but sufficiently stable in solution. For example, 1g was generated in solution from p-benzoquinone and 4-octyne in 70% yield. Unsymmetrical alkynes, such as 1-pentyne, phenylacetylene, and methyl phenylpropiolate, regioselectively reacted with p-benzoquinone to give respective solutions of labile p-QMs 1h, 1i and 1j in comparable yields.
![]() | ||
Scheme 3 Photoreactions affording fused cyclobutenes 2a–2n. a MeCN was used as the solvent, b based on the 1H NMR analysis of the crude mixture, c unreacted diphenylacetylene was recovered (56%). | ||
According to the earlier reports, photocycloadditions of terminal alkynes to monosubstituted quinone double bonds proceed regioselectively to give predominantly syn-products.7c,e Shah, however, suggested an unusual reversal of regioselectivity in persulfate-mediated photoreactions of 2-methoxynaphthoquinone with cyclopropylacetylene and 1-ethynylcyclohexene based on the comparison of J-coupling in the 1H NMR spectra.12 When we conducted these photocycloadditions in a purely photochemical setup, the formed cyclobutenes 2j and 2k appeared spectrally identical to those reported by Shah et al. (the authors described cyclobutene hydrogens as singlets, yet we observed small J-coupling (<1 Hz)). To ascertain the structure, we obtained a single crystal of 2k, X-ray diffraction analysis of which disproved the proposed anti-arrangement in favor of the syn-arrangement (see the ESI, Section 3†). Compiled NMR data of compounds 2 showed that the reversal of syn-selectivity in the reactions with other terminal alkynes is also unlikely (see the ESI, Table S2†). Besides that, analysis of NMR data revealed that the spectra of cyclobutene 2d coincide with those of the recently reported 4-benzoyl-2,6-dimethylcyclohexa-2,5-dien-1-one11 – a product of a copper-catalyzed photointeraction between phenylacetylene and in situ generated 2,6-dimethylbenzoquinone. However, the structure of this reported product entails a rapid equilibrium shift to the fully aromatic tautomer. More likely, this compound possesses the structure of cyclobutene 2d and could be formed by the classical [2 + 2] photocycloaddition.
15a afforded 3f in a comparable yield of 87% at room temperature). Similarly, microwave-assisted addition of methanol to 1a provided 3g in 47% yield (98% based on recovered 1a). Treatment of 1a with potassium thiocyanate at room temperature led selectively to isothiocyanate 3h in 93% yield, although a sacrificial amount of trifluoroacetic acid was used to promote the reaction. However, this approach did not furnish the corresponding isocyanate when potassium cyanate was used instead. The lack of reactivity of potassium thiocyanate without the acid promoter is reflected in the reversibility of the addition: attempts to form the potassium phenoxide salt of 3h caused rapid elimination, reforming 1a. Likewise, the problem of isolating the pure aniline adduct 3c15a and its inability to form the hydrochloride salt can be attributed to the prominent elimination as well, which was confirmed by NMR monitoring of this process (see the ESI, Fig. S1†).
Studying the nucleophilic addition of water to the photochemically generated p-QMs 1 revealed that the use of transition metal catalysis can be avoided not only for addition, but also for triggering the reorganization of the newly formed quaternary carbon center. First, the addition of water to p-QMs 1 can be easily achieved by switching from copper catalysis15d,e to either Brønsted-acid catalysis or simple heating, as exemplified by the formation of 4a from 1a (Scheme 5a). This reaction can also be performed in a one-pot fashion by generating p-QMs 1in situ from a quinone and an alkyne (Scheme 5b). Next, the thus obtained products from both terminal (4i) and internal (4a) alkynes undergo oxidation by p-benzoquinone under essentially the same conditions, forming p-hydroxybenzophenone in good yields and acylated hydroquinones as minor products (Scheme 5c). Notably, the formation of aryl ketones from 2,2-diaryl-2-hydroxyacetaldehydes was previously observed under different conditions.19 When p-benzoquinone was used in excess in the photoreaction with phenylacetylene, p-hydroxybenzophenone was formed directly (Scheme 5d), indicating that no additional reagents11,12 are principally necessary to perform such a transformation. The increased yield of the acid-catalyzed reaction (51%) compared to the catalyst-free reaction (27%) can be explained by a faster conversion of the labile p-QM intermediate 1i.
Another example of a cascade reaction involving a photochemically formed p-QM is the acid-catalyzed interaction of Z-1c with 1-naphthol, which only afforded the unexpected rearranged compound 5 in 27% yield. Mechanistically, its formation could involve a 1,2-phenyl shift in the initial product of 1,6-conjugate addition followed by isomerization, as depicted in Scheme 6. Interestingly, compound 5 was also obtained by Shah and co-workers in a photochemical reaction between 1-naphthol and phenylacetylene mediated by thiophenol and trifluoroacetic acid.14 Possibly, the formation of 5 under Shah's conditions could represent a cascade process involving the oxidation of 1-naphthol into 1,4-naphthoquinone followed by the photoreaction with phenylacetylene to give 1c as an intermediate, which could then react with a second molecule of 1-naphthol to form 5.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 6 Unexpected outcome of the acid-catalyzed reaction of Z-1c with 1-naphthol and its plausible mechanism. | ||
In general, mechanistic pathways for the catalyst-free light-triggered reactions involving quinones and alkynes can be outlined as shown in Scheme 7. First, the irradiation of quinone BQ in the presence of alkyne A can either afford the [2 + 2] carbocycloaddition product 2 or proceed as [2 + 2] Paternò–Büchi cycloaddition followed by electrocyclic ring opening of the spirocyclic oxetene intermediate to form p-QM 1.7 The ion-radical pair [BQ˙−A˙+] was found to play a pivotal role in the Paternò–Büchi photocycloaddition process and may be involved in the concurrent formation of cyclobutenes 2 as well. Next, the photochemically generated electrophilic p-QMs 1 can undergo reversible addition of nucleophiles present in the reaction mixture. The products of the addition of water as a nucleophile can be oxidized by the photoexcited quinone to the final product – p-hydroxyaryl ketone. The loss of the acyl group during this step is reflected in the formation of the acylated byproducts (Scheme 5c), possibly by the photo-Friedel–Crafts reaction pathway.20 Finally, the oxidation of the formed hydroquinone HQ into the starting quinone BQ by a sacrificial oxidant can close the cycle. A distinctive feature of the overall process is that visible light alone allows a quinone to play the role of a starting material in the beginning and an oxidant in the end, yet allowing the control of reaction chemoselectivity by the quinone substitution character and the ratio of the reactants.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 7 Summarized mechanistic pathways for the uncatalyzed light-triggered reactions involving a quinone (BQ), a hydroquinone (HQ) and an alkyne (A). | ||
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2240461 and 2240462. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ob00636k |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |