Bohayra
Mortazavi
*ab,
Masoud
Shahrokhi
c,
Xiaoying
Zhuang
*ad,
Timon
Rabczuk
d and
Alexander V.
Shapeev
e
aDepartment of Mathematics and Physics, Chair of Computational Science and Simulation Technology, Leibniz Universität Hannover, Appelstraße 11, 30167 Hannover, Germany. E-mail: bohayra.mortazavi@gmail.com; zhuang@iop.uni-hannover.de
bCluster of Excellence PhoenixD (Photonics, Optics, and Engineering–Innovation Across Disciplines), Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Universität Hannover, Hannover, Germany
cYoung Researchers Club, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran
dDepartment of Geotechnical Engineering, College of Civil Engineering, Tongji University, 1239 Siping Road Shanghai, China
eSkolkovo Institute of Science and Technology, Skolkovo Innovation Center, Bolshoy Bulvar, 30, Moscow, 143026, Russia
First published on 6th December 2021
In two of the latest experimental advances in the field of two-dimensional (2D) materials, penta-PdPS and -PdPSe layered materials have been fabricated. Inspired by these accomplishments, herein first-principles calculations are employed to explore the direction-dependent key physical properties of the PdPX (X = S, Se, Te) monolayers. Our results indicate that the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers are indirect semiconductors, with HSE06 band gaps of 2.13, 1.89, and 1.37 eV, respectively. Optical calculations reveal that the first absorption peaks of these novel monolayers along the in-plane polarizations are located in the visible range of light. Moreover, it is predicted that the PdPSe monolayer yields suitable valence and conduction band edge positions for visible-light-driven water splitting reactions. Our results confirm the decline of elastic modulus, tensile strength, phonons’ group velocity, and lattice thermal conductivity with the increase of the atomic weight of chalcogen atoms in PdPX nanosheets. It is furthermore shown that these novel 2D systems exhibit anisotropic mechanical, optical, and heat conduction properties. The obtained first-principles results provide a comprehensive vision about the critical physical properties of the PdPX (X = S, Se, Te) nanosheets and highlight their prospect for nanoelectronics, optoelectronics, and energy conversion applications.
Density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) calculations are conducted using the VASP package over 3 × 3 × 1 supercells to acquire phonon dispersions and harmonic force constants utilizing the PHONOPY code.11 Moment tensor potentials (MTPs)12 are trained as an accurate class of machine learning interatomic potentials to interpolate the interatomic forces,13 utilizing the MLIP package.14 The datasets for the MTPs training are acquired by conducting ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations with a time step of 1 fs over supercells consisting of 48 atoms using a 2 × 2 × 1 a Monkhorst–Pack K-point grid. For evaluating the 2nd and 3rd order interatomic force constants, two AIMD calculations are conducted within the NVT ensemble, first, from 10 to 100 K and second, from 100 to 1000 K, each for 1000 time steps. For the efficient training of the MTPs, original AIMD trajectories are with equal steps subsampled and around 660 configurations are selected to train MTPs. Phonon dispersions on the basis of trained MTPs are obtained using the PHONOPY code, as elaborately discussed in our previous work.13 Anharmonic 3rd order interatomic force constants are obtained over the same supercells as those employed for harmonic force constant calculations by considering the interactions with eights nearest neighbors. This is equivalent with single-step force calculations over 1152 structures with 192 atoms for a single-layer penta-PdPX lattice, which can be obtained within a negligible time with the MTP-based method and is otherwise computationally extensively demanding with the standard DFT method. The ShengBTE15 package is employed to conduct the full iterative solution of the Boltzmann transport equation (BTE) with force constant inputs, as discussed in our previous study.16 In these calculations, isotope scattering is considered to predict the phononic thermal conductivity of naturally occurring samples.
Fig. 1 Top and side views of the PdPSe monolayer along with the electron localization function (ELF) presented in the side views. ELF isosurface value is set to 0.7. |
After investigating the structural properties of the PdPX (X = S, Se, Te) monolayers, we next study their mechanical response. In Fig. 2, the uniaxial true stress–strain responses of the PdPX monolayers along the x and y directions are compared. The predicted stress–strain relations are uniaxial and such that during the deformation, the structure is under stress only along the loading direction and is stress-free along the two other perpendicular directions of the loading. Since nanosheets can freely move along their thickness direction, upon the geometry minimization, the system's stress component normal to the sheet naturally reaches a negligible value. Therefore in the conducted DFT simulations, the simulation cell size along the other in-plane perpendicular direction of the loading (either x or y) is adjusted to satisfy the negligible stress condition after the geometry minimization. It should also be noted that the stress values are calculated at every strain by considering the real volume of the deformed monolayers. In this regard, the area of the monolayers can be easily obtained using the periodic simulation cell sizes along the planar direction. To calculate the area, the effective thickness at every step is calculated as the normal distance between boundary chalcogen atoms plus their effective van der Waals diameter (vdW). For example, the thickness of the PdPS and PdPSe monolayers according to experimental measurements are 6.6519 and 6.94 Å, respectively. According to the obtained geometry optimized lattices, the normal distances between X–X atoms in the aforementioned systems are 4.19 and 4.41 Å, respectively, which are equivalent with effective vdW diameters of 2.46 and 2.49 Å, for S and Se atoms in these systems, respectively, to satisfy the corresponding monolayers’ thickness. In a consistent way, a thickness of 7.3 Å is estimated for the stress-free PdPTe monolayer. According to DFT-based stress–strain relations, the elastic modulus of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers along the y (x) directions are predicted to be 262 (205), 218 (152), and 181(115) GPa, respectively. Moreover, the Poisson's ratio values of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers for the loading along the y (x) directions are found to be 0.14 (0.18), 0.13 (0.19), and 0.12(0.19), respectively. It is thus revealed that during the deformation, these systems tend to contract more along the width for the uniaxial loading along the x direction than the y direction. The ultimate tensile strength of the PdPS, PdPSe, and the PdPTe monolayers along the y (x) directions are predicted to be 22.0(16.7), 19.6 (14.7), and 15.7 (12.8) GPa, respectively. These results reveal that these nanosheets are remarkably stronger along the y direction than the x direction, and they thus show anisotropic mechanical characteristics. Moreover, these results also confirm a clear decline of the elastic modulus and tensile strength in PdPX nanosheets with the increase in the atomic weight of chalcogen atoms. To better understand the anisotropic mechanical response of these nanosheets, in Fig. 2 the deformed PdPS monolayer at strain levels after the tensile strength points are plotted for the both considered loading directions. It appears that for the loading along the x direction, the failure occurs along the Pd–S bond, those constructing the over surface pentagonal atomic configurations. In fact, for the loading along this direction, only the Pd–S bonds are oriented along the loading direction and yield dominant contribution to the load bearing. In contrast, for the loading along the y direction, both the Pd–S and P–S bonds are oriented along the loading and engage in the load transfer, resulting in a higher strength. It can be seen that the Pd–X bonds play a dominant role in the tensile strength and rigidity of these nanosheets. In addition, the anisotropic mechanical responses can be attributed to the pentagonal atomic arrangement that results in more bonds engagements in the load carrying along the y direction than the other planar counterpart.
We next study the electronic properties of the PdPX (X = S, Se, Te) monolayers. To probe the electronic properties of the free-standing PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers, the band structures and the projected density of states (PDOS) of these systems are calculated within HSE06 approach, as illustrated in Fig. 3. The obtained electronic band structure for the PdPS monolayer reveals a semiconducting behavior and the indirect band gap of 2.13 eV, in which both the valence band maximum (VBM) and conduction band minimum (CBM) lie between the C and Y points. The indirect band gap is predicted to be 1.89 and 1.37 eV for the PdPSe and PdPTe monolayers, respectively, with the VBM appearing along the C–Y wave vector while the CBM locates along Y–Γ. Our estimated band gap of the PdPSe monolayer is in a good agreement with results in the original experimental study by Li et al.4 The calculation of the PDOS indicates that the d orbital from Pd yields the main contribution to form the CBM and VBM of all PdPX monolayers, with a weak hybridization of X p states resulting in the Mott insulator. In order to uncover the capabilities of these novel monolayers for photocatalytic water splitting, the valence band (VB) and conduction band (CB) edge positions of these systems have been calculated using HSE06 and shown in Fig. 4. It can be seen that the VB and CB edge positions generally shift to lower potential energy with the increase in the atomic number of the S, Se, and Te elements. These results show that the PdPSe monolayer possesses suitable band edge positions that correctly bracket the water redox potentials for visible-light-driven overall water splitting reactions. In contrast, the PdPS monolayer is predicted to be a good candidate only for the water oxidation and O2 evolution, and the PdPTe nanosheet can be used only for the hydrogen evolution. These findings however do not guarantee the effectiveness of these novel 2D systems for the efficient photocatalytic water splitting, but may hopefully guide further studies to more elaborately examine this aspect.
Fig. 3 Band structure and partial electronic density of states PDOS of (a) PdPS, (b) PdPSe, and (c) PdPTe monolayers. The dashed black lines indicate the Fermi energy. |
We next discuss the optical response of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers using the RPA method constructed over HSE06 results. Because of the asymmetric geometry along the x- and y-axes, the optical spectra of these structures are also found to be anisotropic for light polarization along the in-plane directions. Hence, the optical properties for both the x- and y-polarized direction (E||x and E||y) are reported. The optical properties of these 2D materials along the light polarization perpendicular to the plane are ignored because of the huge depolarization effect.20 The imaginary and real parts of the dielectric function (Im ε and Re ε) of these 2D monolayers for the in-plane polarized directions versus photon energy are calculated, and the obtained results are illustrated in Fig. 5. The absorption edges of Im ε occur at the energy of ∼2.0, 1.80, and 1.40 eV along the in-plane direction for the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayer sheets, respectively, which are in the visible range. The values of the static dielectric constant (the values of Re ε at zero energy) for the novel PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers were measured to be ∼4.1, 4.6, and 5.5 along E||x and 4.0, 4.4, and 5.2 along E||y, respectively. These results indicate that by decreasing the electronic band gap in these 2D structures, the static dielectric constant increases.
The absorption coefficient α for these novel 2D systems along in-plane polarization as a function of photon energy and wavelength is plotted in Fig. 6. The absorption edge of α for the PdPS monolayer occurs at a wavelength of ∼550 nm along the x- and y-axes, while the corresponding absorption edge for the PdPSe and PdPTe monolayers shifts to the longer wavelengths (red shift), occurring at wavelength of 600 and 700 nm, respectively. In general, contrary to the indirect band gap nature of the studied novel 2D materials, the high absorption coefficients in the visible range of light are attained (∼105 cm−1) for the PdPX monolayers, which are higher than the typical absorption coefficient value for direct-gap semiconductors21 and comparable to those of organic perovskite solar cells.22,23 These results indicate that the PdPX monolayers possess significant light-harvesting capabilities for the solar spectrum in the UV-visible range (300–700 nm) of light. Moreover, the results of anisotropic optical properties along the in-plane directions suggest that they exhibit attractive prospects for the design of novel electronic and optical nanodevices that exploit their anisotropic properties, such as polarization-sensitive photodetectors.
We finally explore the phononic properties of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers. In this regard, firstly the phonon dispersion relations of the PdPX monolayers obtained by DFPT and MTP-based methods along highly symmetrical points of the first Brillouin zone are investigated, as compared in Fig. 7. All the considered lattices show three acoustic modes starting from the Γ point, consistent with other 2D structures. Near the Γ point, the out-of-plane acoustic modes (ZA) show quadratic relation for all the three considered monolayers, whereas the remaining two acoustic modes show linear dispersions.24 Predicted phonon dispersions by both methods reveal that acoustic and optical modes are free of imaginary frequencies, which confirm the dynamical stability of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers. Moreover, the comparison between DFPT and MTP-based results confirm the remarkable accuracy of the developed classical models in reproducing the phonon dispersion relations. As it is noticeable, the MTP model yields an excellent accuracy in describing the acoustic modes, which are usually the main heat carriers in semiconductors. Similarly to the conducted analysis of mechanical and electronic properties, it is visible that the general features of phonon dispersion relations in these 2D systems are also very identical. As a useful preliminary finding, it nonetheless appears that with the increase in the weight of chalcogen atoms, dispersion of phonon modes in the entire frequency range shrink, which is also conspicuous for the case of ZA acoustic mode. As it is clear, two and three rather large gaps appear in the phonon dispersions of the PdPSe and PdPTe monolayers, respectively. The narrower dispersions of phonon bands suggest the suppression of their group velocity, which generally can lead to a lower thermal conductivity.
Fig. 7 Phonon dispersion relations of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers predicted by the DFPT and MTP methods, respectively, illustrated by continuous and dotted lines. |
We now study the predicted lattice thermal conductivity of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers along the two planar directions as a function of temperature, as illustrated in Fig. 8. In these results, the thickness of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers are assumed to be 6.65,19 6.94 and 7.3 Å, respectively. The phononic thermal conductivity of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers with taking into account the isotope scattering at 300 K along the y (x) directions, are predicted to be 72 (60), 65(44), and 33 (23) W mK−1, respectively. As expected, with the increase in the weight of chalcogen atoms, the lattice thermal conductivity decreases, which is also consistent with the classical theory that materials with a lower elastic modulus show a lower thermal conductivity. Normally the lattice thermal conductivity follows a ∼T−λ trend with temperature (T), in which λ is the temperature power factor and usually takes a value close to unity. The temperature power factors of 1.05, 1.03, and 1.01 are predicted for the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers, respectively, which are close to 1 and reveal that the phonon–phonon interactions in these systems follow the same trend of conventional materials. The corresponding power factor for graphene, MoS2, F-diamane and CrC2N4 monolayers has been predicted to be 1.32,25 1.02,26 1.1627 and 1.35,25 respectively. For the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers at 300 K, it is found that acoustic modes count for 86(88), 86(89), and 82(87)% of the overall thermal conductivity along the x (y) directions, respectively. This is an expectable finding because these modes generally show wider dispersions and lower intersection with other bands, and consequently showing higher group velocities and lifetimes, respectively, both resulting in facilitated thermal transport. In accordance with our results for mechanical properties, these lattices also show anisotropic thermal transport. As discussed earlier and from the basic structural understanding of these lattices, along the y direction more bonds are oriented along the load and heat transfer. From the phonon dispersions, it is also clear that acoustic mode shows wider dispersion and consequently higher group velocity along the y direction (Γ–Y path) than along the x direction (Γ–X path).
Fig. 8 Predicted lattice thermal conductivity of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers as a function of temperature along the (a) x and (b) y directions. |
In Fig. 9 the phonons’ group velocity and lifetime of the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers are compared. As expected and shown in Fig. 9a, with the increase in the weight of chalcogen because of the induced narrower dispersions of phonon modes and lower elasticity of the PdPX monolayers, the phonons’ group velocities are also suppressed. The maximum phonon group velocity in the PdPS, PdPSe, and PdPTe monolayers are predicted to be 6.91, 5.84, and 5.17 km s−1, respectively, which are by around three-folds lower than that of the graphene. For the phonons’ lifetime illustrated in Fig. 9b, however, the suppressing effect of chalcogen atoms is found to be much weaker than those for the group velocity. As it is clear, while the scattering rates for phonons are relatively close for different systems, the corresponding group velocities decrease noticeably with the increase in the weight of chalcogen atoms, resulting in a lower thermal conductivity. Our results reveal that the PdPX monolayers show moderate lattice thermal conductivity values, which suggests that with the application of these semiconductors in nanoelectronics, the thermal management issues can be facilitated. The PdPTe nanosheet at high temperatures nonetheless shows a rather low thermal conductivity, which along with its semiconducting nature might be useful for thermoelectric applications, which requires a further investigation.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1tc05297g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |