Open Access Article
Xuan Biea,
Man Xiongb,
Ben Wanga,
Yawei Donga,
Zhongxue Chen
a and
Ronghua Huang
*a
aSchool of Power & Mechanical Engineering, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072, PR China. E-mail: huangronghua@whu.edu.cn
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Hubei University, Wuhan, 430060, PR China
First published on 24th March 2022
A silicon polyester (Si-PET) was synthesized with ethylene glycol and phthalic anhydride, and then it was carbonized and hydrothermally coated with glucose. The formed SiOx with layered graphene as the 3D network had an amorphous carbon layer. The graphene oxide (rGO) after carbothermal reduction was completely retained in SiOx, which improved the conductivity of the SiOx anode material. SiOx were encapsulated with a flexible amorphous carbon layer on the surface, which can not only improve the electrical performance, but also effectively relieve the huge volume changes of the compound. Further, the key point is that, the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) film was mainly formed on the surface carbon layer. This would keep a stable SEI film during volume pulverization, and result in a good cycle stability. The SiOx/C-rGO material maintained a reversible capacity of 660 mA h g−1 at a current density of 100 mA g−1 for 100 cycles, a reversible capacity of 469.7 mA h g−1 at a current density of 200 mA g−1 for 300 cycles. The Coulomb efficiency was maintained at 98% except for the first cycle. After long cycling, the electrode expansion was 16%, which was much lower than those of silicon based materials. Therefore, this article provides a cheap, simple, and commercially valuable anode material for lithium batteries.
As a form of silicon-based anode, SiOx (silicon protoxide, 0 < x < 2) has attracted much attention due to its relatively high specific capacity (∼1600 mA h g−1), low charge–discharge potential and smaller volume expansion. The high-strength Si–O bond and the formation of Li2O and Li4SiO4 effectively reduce volume expansion. Nonetheless, the conductivity and electron migration rate of SiOx anode materials are very low, which would affect its electrical performance.9,10 The main method is to introduce carbon to improve conductivity and cycle stability while alleviating volume changes.11–15 The carbon coating could be achieved by chemical synthesis,16,17 in situ synthesis,18,19 introduction or modification of nanostructures,20 ball milling,21,22 and spraying,23 etc. Jiang et al.20 directly pyrolyzed (methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) polymer on the surface of silicon nanoparticles to construct a dual core–shell structure Si@SiOx@C nanocomposite. The introduction of graphene into SiOx composite materials is due to the unique single-atomic sheet structure of graphene, which exhibits good electrical conductivity, large specific surface area, and special mechanical properties. This allows graphene to be applied to the negative electrode material of lithium batteries to buffer the volume shrinkage in structure, improve the conductivity of the material, provide more tracks for lithium ions, and inlay space for silicon-containing particles.24–27 Bai et al.16 synthesized Si@SiOx/graphene hydrogel composite so that Si@SiOx nanoparticles can be evenly dispersed within the GH structure with a 3D network. Daniel et al.28 mixed polydopamine-coated Si NPs and graphene oxide (GO) through a simple solution mixing. The above methods have been proved to improve the performance of SiOx anode materials, and the pursing of Si-based anode materials about cycle stability is continuing.
In this research, graphene oxide (GO) was evenly dispersed in silicon-containing polyester (Si-PET), and then the resulting material was thermally reduced and carbonized. Finally, using hydrothermal of glucose to form a carbon layer on the surface. The obtained SiOx/C-rGO composite regarded graphene as the 3D network, and Si-PET was reduced to silicon with carbon on it. At the meanwhile, a double-layer structure of SiOx and carbon layers were formed on the surface. The advantages of this method is simple, low in cost, and feasible in practical application. It is worth noting that this SiOx/C-rGO composite has good electrical cycle stability. The excellent electrical performance of it due to the layer structure of graphene, which provides tracks for the insertion and desertion of lithium ions, increasing the conductivity of the material as well. The carbon–silicon structure obtained by reduction provides high capacity, and the flexible carbon layer with a certain mechanical strength effectively relieves volume expansion. The special structure is conducive to forming a stable solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer and reducing volume changes of active materials.29–32 Carbon coating can also effectively hinder the formation of silicon crystals and reduce the polarization resistance of the electrode, thereby improving the conductivity and electrical performance of it.33–35 This paper also studied the ratio of glucose hydrothermal coating. When the ratio of glucose to the coated material is 3
:
1, the performance of the material is the best. At a current density of 200 mA g−1, the specific capacity of it can still be 469.7 mA h g−1 after 300 cycle.
:
1, 3
:
1, 4
:
1, 5
:
1, respectively denoted as SiOx/C-rGO-1, SiOx/C-rGO-2, SiOx/C-rGO-3. SiOx/C-rGO-4.
:
1
:
1 on the thin copper foil. After vacuum drying, the electrode was stamped into a disk with a diameter of 12 mm. Finally, using the lithium electrode as counter electrode and Celgard 2300 as separator in a glove box filled with argon to form the coin cell CR-2032. The electrolyte consisted of 1 mol l−1 LiPF6 in a mixed solvent with ethylene carbonate (EC)/ethyl methyl carbonate (EMC) = 1
:
1 by volume. Charge/discharge measurement were performed by LAND (CT2001A) battery-test system in the voltage range of 0.01–2.0 V. Cyclic voltammetry curves (CV) were measured at a scanning rate of 0.1 mV s−1 within the potential range of 0.01–2.0 V vs. Li/Li+ using an electrochemistry working station (Squidstat Plus). The electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) test was carried out in the frequency range from 100 kHz to 10 mHz on an electrochemical workstation (Squidstat Plus).
C, indicating that glucose has been carbonized during the hydrothermal treatment.40
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) Powder XRD patterns of SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2 (b) FT-IR spectra of SiOx/C, SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2. | ||
The Raman spectrum of the SiOx/C-rGO-2 sample is shown in Fig. 2a. Although there is no obvious Si band, the D band and G band that typically characterize the graphene structure appear in it. The D band near 1330 cm−1 attribute to the structural defects on the graphitic carbon plane, and the G band near 1590 cm−1 associate with a strong tangential mode of the graphene structure. The ID/IG = 0.84, which can indicate the degree of graphitization of the sample. From the Raman spectrum, it is obvious that there is amorphous carbon in the composite. The X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) of SiOx/C-rGO-2 and SiOx/C-rGO-0 are shown in Fig. 2b. The three dominant elements C (C 1s), O (O 1s) and Si (Si 2p and Si 2s) can be seen. It is easy to conclude from the figure that the three main elements of the both composites are quite different. The XPS high-resolution spectrum comparison of the C 1s spectrum of SiOx/C-rGO-2 and SiOx/C-rGO-0 are shown in Fig. 2c and S1.† After the hydrothermal reaction, a significant peak appeared near 286 eV. The strong peak at 284.7 eV corresponds to the C–C bond in graphitic carbon, 285.9 eV and 290.7 eV correspond to the C–O bond and C
O bond, respectively.41 The peak area of the C–C bond is the largest, which indicates that the functional groups containing carbon–oxygen bonds in the complex have been reduced. Glucose hydrothermal coating, on the one hand, fully carbonized on the surface to increase the carbon content, on the other hand, the introduction of carbon-containing groups made up for the insufficient conductivity of the SiOx anode material. The O 1s spectrum (Fig. 2d and S2†) prove that glucose is fully reduced in the hydrothermal process to form an effective carbon layer, leading to a significant reduction in surface oxygen. The strong peak at 532.3 eV corresponds to the multiplicity of adsorbed H2O molecule at or near the surface, and 530.8 eV correspond to the metal–oxygen bond.42 Fig. 2e and f illustrate respectively the Gaussian fitting of the Si 2p spectrum of the SiOx/C-rGO-2 and SiOx/C-rGO-0. The peak of Si 2p can be split into four peaks, which correspond to different spins of Si element in p orbital under different oxidation states. Peaks at 103.8 eV, 102.8 eV, 102.1 eV, and 101.3 eV are respectively referred to Si4+, Si3+, Si2+, Si+,43 and the absence of Si0 in the composite is also consistent with the results of Raman spectrum. The proportions of Si in different valence states of SiOx/C-rGO-2 and SiOx/C-rGO-0 are compared in Table 1 according to the area of the fitted peaks. After hydrothermal reduction, the proportion of high-valence silicon is significantly lower, which demonstrates that a carbon layer has formed on the surface to cover the silicon oxide compound and part of the silicon is reduced to lower valence state. It is concluded that SiOx/C-rGO-2 is composed of silicon-oxygen (SiOx) and amorphous carbon, and the silicon element is further reduced to a mixed valence state after hydrothermal reaction.
| Sample | Si4+ (%) | Si3+ (%) | Si2+ (%) | Si+ (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SiOx/C-rGO-2 | 31.39 | 20.19 | 42.88 | 5.54 |
| SiOx/C-rGO-0 | 17.63 | 82.37 | 0 | 0 |
Scanning electron microscope (SEM) observes the microscopic morphology of the sample as shown in Fig. 3. The structure of SiOx/C without graphene (Fig. 3a) is flat and smooth, which is a typical SiOx morphology.44 The SiOx/C-rGO-0 with graphene oxide (rGO) added is shown in Fig. 3b and c, which are macroporous, and the graphene fold-like structure can be clearly observed at higher magnification. The necessity of introducing graphene has been verified, because the generation of holes is conducive to the lithiation and delithiation, so that it has better electrical performance.45 The hydrothermally treated SiOx/C-rGO-2 is shown in Fig. 3d and e. The graphene fold-like structure and pores still exist, but the pore size is smaller than before. The agglomerate structure that did not exist before can be clearly seen in the depression of the fracture (Fig. 3f), which is presumed to be an irregular carbon layer formed by hydrothermal reduction, and this inference was further verified.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 SEM images of composites: (a) SiOx/C ×1.00k, (b) SiOx/C-rGO-0 ×1.00k, (c) SiOx/C-rGO-0 ×2.00k and 10.00k, (d) SiOx/C-rGO-2 ×5.00k, (e) SiOx/C-rGO-2 ×20.00k, (f) SiOx/C-rGO-2 ×100.00k. | ||
The specific surface area and pore size distribution of these samples were evaluated by nitrogen adsorption–desorption measurements in Fig. 4a–c. The isotherms of these three materials show distinct hysteresis loops, which are type IV plots, showing the existence of mesoporous structures in these materials.46,47 Based on the multi-point BET method, the specific surface area of SiOx/C, SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2 are 6.065 m2 g−1, 8.165 m2 g−1 and 12.725 m2 g−1, respectively. With the addition of graphene and the formation of carbon layer on the surface, the specific surface area increased significantly. The specific surface area of the sample is improved by the hydrothermal method, which is beneficial to provide lithium ion migration channels, reduce power assistance, release volume expansion, and have better electrical properties.
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) test is carried out under air atmosphere, and the carbon is completely oxidized by heating to 750 °C. The weight increase of silicon into silicon dioxide at a temperature (<800 °C) is negligible. Therefore, the remaining weight after heating to >700 °C can reflect the carbon content of the composite. Fig. 4d is the comparison between SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-1. The weight loss increased from 25 wt% to 27 wt% after hydrothermal treatment, demonstrating that glucose by hydrothermal method does introduce more carbon elements. The thermal weight loss data of different ratios of glucose added are shown in Table 2. With the added amount of glucose increasing, the weight loss percentage of the sample becomes larger and the carbon content increases. The difference between the values is not great because the relative atomic mass of carbon is relatively small compared to that of silicon oxide.
| Sample | SiOx/C-rGO-1 | SiOx/C-rGO-2 | SiOx/C-rGO-3 | SiOx/C-rGO-4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ratio of glucose | 2 : 1 |
3 : 1 |
4 : 1 |
5 : 1 |
| Weight (wt%) | 27.75 | 29.56 | 30.38 | 32.17 |
The structure and morphology of the sample were characterized by field emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM), transmission electron microscope (TEM) and high resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM). From the TEM images of SiOx/C-rGO-2 (Fig. 5a), at low magnification, it is obvious that the graphene sheets are distributed in SiOx, which is consistent with the previously envisaged structure. Fig. 5c can more clearly see that the carbon layer is coated on the SiOx surface, and amorphous carbon formed on the surface of the sample, which further verifies the results of the previous XRD and Raman spectroscopy. The lattice lines in Fig. 5b are clearly marked, and the d-spacing measured 0.33 nm corresponds to the C nanocrystals, indicating that in addition to the presence of amorphous carbon in the sample, the carbonized graphene crystal structure is still intact.48 The d-spacing measured 0.27 nm corresponds to SiC structure,49 which is in agreement with the XRD analysis. The disordered domain in the Fig. 5c is an amorphous SiOx (0 < x < 2) microstructure. The actual morphology and structure of the sample are consistent with the above analysis of XRD and XPS, which proves that there is no silicon crystal in the sample. The STEM images (Fig. 5d–g) show the existence of the three elements, including C, O and Si in this sample. The silicon is obviously reduced near the edge of the surface, while the carbon has no obvious decrease, indicating that the hydrothermal reaction happened indeed in the SiOx to form carbon layer on the surface. What's more, the interface between SiOx particle and graphene is very tight without interstice from HR-TEM image. EDS line scan curve (Fig. 5h) also indicates the existence of C, Si and O. This is consistent with above speculations about its structural performance for electrical cycling stability.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 (a) TEM and (c) and (d) HRTEM images of SiOx/C-rGO-2. (d)–(g) Elements mapping and EDS line scan curve (h) of SiOx/C-rGO-2. | ||
:
1 is undoubtedly the most suitable, and the cycle performance of SiOx/C-rGO-2 is consistent with the structural advantages mentioned above. The first-cycle charge–discharge volt–ampere curve of the above sample is shown in Fig. S3,† showing the typical behavior of Si: the discharge curve is a plateau below 0.25 V, and the gentle slope of the volt–ampere curve between 0.3 and 0.6 V corresponds to the lithium insertion of Si and delithiation with LixSi phase respectively. The charge and discharge platform of SiOx/C-rGO-2 in the first cycle is significantly better than other samples, and has a higher first-cycle capacity.
The rate capability of SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2 was performed at different current densities from 100 to 1000 mA g−1, as shown in Fig. 6b. Compared with SiOx/C-rGO-0, SiOx/C-rGO-2 obviously has excellent rate stability and capacity recovery. The capacities are 676.9 mA h g−1, 471.9 mA h g−1, 431.8 mA h g−1, 281.6 mA h g−1, 234.4 mA h g−1 at current densities of 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1000 mA g−1 respectively. When the current density returned from 1000 mA g−1 to 100 mA g−1, the capacity rose again to 616.5 mA h g−1, indicating that the electrode material structure was not damaged under high current density test. The excellent rate stability is due to the flexible carbon layer formed on the surface by the hydrothermal reaction of glucose, which not only improves the conductivity but also acts as a buffer for the shrinkage and expansion of the silicon-containing electrode material. The activation process is also evident from the rate capability of SiOx/C-rGO-3 and SiOx/C-rGO-4 (Fig. S5†), which are the same as the performances in Fig. 6a. Moreover, as shown in Fig. 6c, the long-cycle stability of SiOx/C-rGO-2 is very significant. At a current density of 200 mA g−1, the reversible capacity of 469.7 mA h g−1 is maintained after 300 cycles, and the capacity retention rate is 77.5%; at a current density of 100 mA g−1, it still maintains 660 mA g−1 after 100 cycles, the capacity retention rate is 84.6% (Fig. S5†). However, the SiOx/C-rGO-0 has only 43.8 mA h g−1 after 300 cycles at 200 mA g−1, which is more than ten times lower than the former. This once again proves the improvement of the cycle stability after glucose hydrothermal coating. Fig. 6d shows the charge–discharge curves of SiOx/C-rGO-2 from 0.01 to 2.0 V at 200 mA g−1 in the 1st, 2nd, 50th, and 100th. The discharge curve between the first cycle and the second cycle has a certain difference due to the irreversible capacity loss of the silicon-containing material, and the low coulomb conversion rate in the first cycle is due to the generation of SEI film, inert lithium oxide and Li4SiO4.22 The Coulomb efficiency of SiOx/C-rGO-2 was 60.1% in the first cycle, quickly reached 90.7% in the second cycle, and then maintained at around 98% in the following cycles.
The cyclic voltammetry (CV) curve of SiOx/C-rGO-2 is shown in Fig. 7a. The cathodic peak at around 0.74 V (vs. Li/Li+) of first cycle is due to the decomposition of the electrolyte and the formation of the SEI film. During the formation of the SEI film, silicon dioxide is reduced to Si, accompanied by the formation of Li2O and Li4SiO4.9,11,50 The cathodic peak at 0.01 V corresponds to the alloying of Si and Li and the reversible reaction between Li and carbon (including carbon coating and rGO), and the obvious peak change in the second cycle is attributed to the further formation of the SEI film.51,52 During the anodic polarization of the first cycle, the insignificant anodic peak at 0.35 V is de-lithiation of LixSi phase.53,54 Fig. S6† shows Nyquist plots for the six samples (SiOx/C, SiOx/C-rGO-0, SiOx/C-rGO-1, SiOx/C-rGO-2, SiOx/C-rGO-3, SiOx/C-rGO-4). For a clearer comparison, the Nyquist plots of SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2 are shown in Fig. 7b. The Nyquist plots of the two samples both present a semicircle in the high frequency region and a straight line in the low frequency region. The former corresponds to the parallel combination of capacity and charge transfer resistance (Rct) and/or resistance from the SEI layer (RSEI), while the latter reflects Li+ diffusion resistance.55 The charge transfer resistance (Rct) of SiOx/C-rGO-0 is much larger than that of SiOx/C-rGO-2. The reduced resistance of glucose hydrothermally is due to the formation of a stable carbon coated structure, while the introduction of carbon improves the conductivity of the material, which is consistent with our previous speculation and subsequent characterization of the composite. The SiOx/C-rGO-2 Nyquist diagram after three cycles of charging and discharging is shown in Fig. S7.† The three curves are composed of two semi-circular arcs in the high frequency range and a straight line in the low frequency range. Obviously, it can be seen that the impedance becomes significantly smaller after the first cycle, and the material properties tend to be stable.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 (a) Cyclic voltammetry curves of the SiOx/C-rGO-2 measured in the voltage range of 0.01–2.0 V with a scan rate of 0.1 mV s−1, (b) Nyquist plots of the SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2. | ||
The formation of SEI film has always been proved to be a very important factor affecting the electrochemical stability of materials. Since the specific SEI film composition is still controversial, this article will not describe it in detail. However, it is not difficult to draw a conclusion from the chemical composition of the two SEI films, and we can distinguish them through element characterization. Fig. 8a–e and f–j are the high-magnification scanning electron micrographs and the mappings of SiOx/C-rGO-0 and SiOx/C-rGO-2 after 100 cycles at 100 mA g−1. The SEI film is a stable solidified layer that is insoluble in organic solvents.56 In order to further study the principle of the significant increase in the stability of SiOx/C-rGO-2 after the hydrothermal coating of glucose, the electrodes after a long cycle were soaked in an organic solvent to remove the residual electrolyte on the surface, and then they were ultrasonically dispersed in ethanol solution to test its in situ elemental composition. Although after a long cycle, the material structure has changed a little. However, the information about the SEI film can still find from its elemental composition. The phosphorus and fluorine of SiOx/C-rGO-0 are much higher than that of SiOx/C-rGO-2. On the basis that the remaining LiPF6 had been removed, the P and F detected were all derived from the already formed SEI film. The decrease of P and F after glucose hydrothermal coating is because the carbon layer formed on the original SiOx/C-rGO-0 in this study, the SEI film mainly formed on the carbon surface. However, the carbon layer formed by hydrothermal might fall off the surface during ultrasonic dispersion, and the SEI film on the surface would also falls off. Therefore, it is not easy for us to find an area with a special structure where the carbon layer is ultrasonically removed, and there is a significant reduction in elements. It can be known that after hydrothermal coating, the formation of the SEI film on the carbon surface is more conducive to the cycle stability of the material than the formation on the silicon surface. In addition, we also investigated the dimensional stability of the SiOx/C-rGO composite electrode after cycling.31 We compared the cross-sectional FE-SEM images of the SiOx/C-rGO-2 composite electrode before and after 300 cycles (Fig. 8k and l). Before cycling, the electrode thickness of the SiOx/C-rGO-2 composite was measured to be 10.52 μm (Fig. 8k), which increased to 12.22 μm after 300 cycles (Fig. 8l), and the electrode expansion was 16%, which is much lower than those of silicon based materials. The composite electrode has good dimensional stability in terms of structure. After long cycling, the structural properties of the electrodes are still stable, so the electrical cycling stability is remarkable.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d2ra00960a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |