Open Access Article
Yanli Dou,
Haijing Gu
,
Shixiang Sun,
Weiguo Yao and
Dongbo Guan*
The Ministry of Education Key Laboratory of Automotive Material, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun, 130025, PR China. E-mail: guandb@jlu.edu.cn
First published on 5th January 2022
Conductive silicone rubber (CSR) is an outstanding stretchable conductive composite due to its excellent mechanical properties and stable conductivity. In this paper, silver nanoparticles were deposited on carbon black (CB) through a reduction reaction. The uniform dispersion of silver particles on the surface of CB as well as the grape-like branch structure of hybrid particles was formed by the condensation reaction of the hydroxyl groups of CB with (3-mercaptopropyl) trimethoxysilane (KH-590), along with the interattraction between sulfhydryl groups of KH-590 and silver ions. This sulfhydryl modified conductive carbon black/Ag hybrid filler (SMCB@Ag) avoided the high processing viscosity of CSR caused by the hydroxyl groups of CB. The percolation threshold of CSR made from SMCB@Ag was 5.5 wt% according to the percolation equation. With the addition amount of SMCB@Ag increasing to 10 wt%, the conductivity of CSR increased from 10−5 to about 101. Moreover, the conductivity of this CSR showed excellent stability with extension of storage time and increase of stretching-recovery cycles.
Conductive fillers including metal nanoparticles,18 conductive carbon nanomaterials19–21 and conductive polymers22–25 can form the conductive network in matrix singly. Metal nanomaterials such as silver nanoparticles (Ag NPs) and silver nanowires (Ag NWs) have prominent conductive properties and have been fully researched and applied in microelectronics.26 But the high density, low flexibility and high prices of Ag NPs and Ag NWs limits the stretchability of the composites and restrains their applications in mass production and large devices.27 Conductive carbon nanomaterials can not only provide the conductive properties to the matrix but also strength the matrix.28 Among the conductive carbon nanomaterials, CB can be applied in the large-scale commercial production of conductive composites ascribed to its low price, cost-effective and durable option. However, CB has bad dispersion in polymer matrix due to its big specific surface area and low density. Lots of hydroxyl groups on the surface of CB endow it tend to be aggregated. For example, in Chen's research,29 CB had obvious aggregation in isoprene rubber observed in the SEM images. Zhai et al.30 first dispersed CB in 1,4-dioxane to promote the dispersion of CB in matrix, and then fabricated a conductive TPU foam. This foam has superior durability and excellent response stability.
Conductive carbon materials and metal fillers are often used together to reinforce the electrical conductivity or mechanical properties of the composites by simple mixing31,32 or mutual modification.33–35 When this hybrid filler is used to fabricate filled conductive composites, it shows good dispersibility in the matrix. Surface metallization of conductive carbon nanomaterials is a valid method to compound multiple fillers to increase the flexibility of metal particles and reduce their consumptions. Many scholars directly deposited silver particles on the surface of conductive carbon nanomaterials by the reaction between silver precursors solution and reductant solution. For example, silver trifluoroacetate solution react with the hydrazine monohydrate solution on the surface of CNT/SBS foam.36 Silver nitrate react with glucose or dodecylbenzene sulphonic acid (DBSA).34,37,38 The conductive composites filled with this prepared hybrid fillers have good conductive strain sensitivity and thermoelectric performance in practical application. When receiving an external force, the distance between filler particles in matrix will change, and the conductive network will be destroyed. With the external force removed, the particles can partly return to the original state and re-form the conductive network, making the conductive composite have high conductivity again. However, in stretchable wirings, it is necessary for conductive composites to maintain good conductivity under external force and heating conductions.39–42 Enhancing the interaction between carbon nanomaterials and metal particles and improving the compatibility of fillers and matrix are very effective method to improve the conductive stability of conductive composites.
The use of silane coupling agent can enhance the interaction between fillers and organic matrix. The attraction between sulfhydryl groups and metal ions is applied to absorb metals in many fields.43 Zhu et al.44 modified silica cryogen with (3-mercaptopropyl) trimethoxysilane (KH-590) to selectively absorb mercury in wastewater efficiently. Huang et al.45 treated the liquid metal with 3-mercaptopropionic acid through the coordination bonding of sulfhydryl groups and liquid metal and further blended it in the PU matrix modified by PDA. Zhang et al.46 immobilized the Ag NPs on the surface of poly (glycidyl methacrylate) modified with sulfhydryl (PGMA-SH). Silver nitrate was dispersed and absorbed evenly on the surface of PGMA-SH due to the attraction between sulfhydryl groups and silver ions, which causes uniform formation of silver particles on PGMA-SH. Therefore, the attraction effect of sulfhydryl groups on metals can be applied to the preparation of carbon nanomaterials and metal hybrid fillers.
In this work, KH-590 was adopted as a bridge to connect CB and Ag NPs. KH-590 was first used to treat the surface of CB by the condensation between hydroxyl groups of CB and silanol groups in KH-590. Ag NPs were deposited uniformly on the surface of KH-590 modified CB (SMCB) by Silver Mirror Reaction attributed to the absorption of sulfhydryl groups to Ag NPs. Then, the prepared filler was blended in liquid SR to fabricate the CSR. A grape-like branch structure of hybrid filler (SMCB@Ag) was observed in TEM images. The dispersion of filler in SR was shown in SEM images. The four-probe test was used to measure the static and dynamic conductivity.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) FT-IR spectra of KH-590, hydrolysate of KH-590, CB and SMCB. XPS spectra of (b) CB, (c) SMCB and (d) SMCB@Ag. TEM images of (e) CB, (f) SMCB, (g) CB@Ag and (h) SMCB@Ag. | ||
In order to further clarify the change in chemical structure, Fig. 1b–d show the XPS spectrum of CB, SMCB and SMCB@Ag. Compared with CB, the XPS spectra of SMCB and SMCB@Ag showed new peaks Si2p, S2p and Ag3d. The binding energy peaks at 163.3 eV and 103.7 eV correspond to the S2p and Si2p in SMCB represent the introduce of KH-590 on the surface of CB in Fig. 1c.48,49 From the high-resolution XPS spectrum of Ag3d (Fig. 1d), it can be seen that the peaks with binding energy of 368.7 eV and 374.7 eV arise from the Ag3d core, indicating the characteristic peaks of zero-valent Ag, demonstrating that silver exists in the state of metal.50
The morphology of CB, SMCB, CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag are shown in Fig. 1e–h. The CB particles show flakes or clusters instead of grape-like shape due to the aggregation. The average diameter of pure CB flakes is about 200 nm, while it reaches about 350 nm after treated by KH-590, that is because CB particles were attracted on oligomers produced by the hydrogen bonds between hydroxyl groups of CB particles and oligomers, and then the covalent linkage is formed between them through the dehydration reaction, which makes more CB particles aggregate together. CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag appears the grape-like branch structure after deposition of silver, the aggregate CB particles are separated by the repelling effect of silver deposited on the surface of CB. SMCB@Ag has a finer branched structure compared with CB@Ag. The main reason for the difference in the microstructure of CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag is that the introduction of sulfhydryl groups on the surface of CB attracts more silver ions on the surface of CB and improves the uniform dispersion of silver ions. Because of the attraction of sulfhydryl groups to silver, SMCB will be deposited more uniform silver, which contribute to the grape-like branch structure of SMCB@Ag.
The microstructure of the CB, CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag are shown in Fig. 2a–c. Yellow circles underline the Ag NPs deposited on the surface of CB in Fig. 2b and c. It can be clearly observed that Ag NPs has a greater uniform dispersion on the surface of CB treated with KH-590. Fig. 2d and e show the element distribution of CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag. The greater the ratio of Ag peak and the C peak, the more the Ag content. Apparently, the Ag content in SMCB@Ag is higher than that in CB@Ag. The XRD patterns of CB, CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag are displayed in Fig. 2f. The SMCB@Ag and CB@Ag both have characteristic peaks at 38.1°, 44.3°, 64.5°, 77.4° and 81.5°, which are attached to the crystal faces of (111), (200), (220), (311) and (222) of Ag. However, the SMCB@Ag has stronger characteristic peaks than CB@Ag because the introduction of sulfhydryl groups makes the reduction process of silver ions more likely to occur on the surface of SMCB instead of forming a sliver mirror on the wall of beaker. Due to the attraction of sulfhydryl groups on silver ions, the sulfhydryl groups provide reaction sites for silver reduction, causing the uniform formation of Ag NPs on the surface of SMCB.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 SEM images of (a) CB, (b) CB@Ag, (c) SMCB@Ag. Energy spectrums of (d) CB@Ag and (e) SMCB@Ag. (f) XRD patterns of CB, CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag. | ||
Fig. 3 shows the conductivity of CSR and the dispersibility of fillers in SR matrix. The viscosity of CSR made by CB increased sharply even in a very small amount of CB due to the hydroxyl groups of CB (as shown in Fig. 1a), which makes it difficult to add more CB in the SR, as a result, the maximum content of CB is only 5.0 wt% in this experiment. After the content of CB exceeds 3.5 wt%, the conductivity of CSR increases sharply. As the content increases to 5.0 wt%, the increase in conductivity is gentle. While CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag has less effect on the viscosity of CSR. In Fig. 3a, the electrical conductivity curves of CB@Ag and SMCB@Ag in terms of the filler loadings can be divided into three parts (marked in figure) respectively. In part 1 and 1′, the CSR had poor conductivity. With an increase of filler content, conductive paths gradually formed in the SR matrix. A rapid increase in electrical conductivity of CSR occurred in part 2 and 2′. In part 3 and 3′, the plateau conductivity was found in CB@Ag/SR and SMCB@Ag/SR with high filler loadings, indicating a stable conductive path was formed in the SR matrix.
By comparing the three conductivity curves, the CSR prepared with pure CB has the lowest percolation threshold about 4 wt%, demonstrating that CB has the best effect on the improvement of CSR conductivity at low content. The low amount of CB is easy to cross the barrier and form electronic transition due to the primary particles composed of graphite crystallites.27 However, the maximum conductivity of CSR with 5.0 wt% pure CB can only reach 0.35 S m−1 through experiment. As for the SMCB@Ag/SR, with the SMCB@Ag content increased to 10 wt%, the conductivity of CSR almost reached to 10 S m−1. The conductivity of CSR filled with SMCB@Ag increased by approximately 4 orders of magnitude at a content of 5.5 wt%, suggesting that a conductive network began to form. Since the modification of CB consumed the hydroxyl groups on the surface of CB, the maximum amount of SMCB@Ag can reach 10 wt% and the conductivity is one order of magnitude higher than the highest conductivity of CB/SR. The deposited silver particles play a key role in the improvement of conductivity with the increase of filler loadings. Besides, SMCB@Ag/SR has the better conductivity than CB@Ag/SR because in the process of silver deposition, the introduction of sulfhydryl groups had a positive influence on the reduction of silver ions. The sulfhydryl groups became deposition sites for the deposition of silver ions and increased the amount of silver deposited on the surface of CB.
Conductivity of CSR is well depended on the formation of an efficiently conductive network in the SR matrix. Normally, the percolation threshold of fillers can be fitted by the classical percolation theory.51,52
| σ = σ0 (φ − φc)t |
Fig. 3c–e show the dispersion of CB and SMCB@Ag in CSR with 5.0 wt% CB, 5.0 wt% SMCB@Ag and 6.0 wt% SMCB@Ag. The 5%CB/Ag exhibited the aggregated CB dispersion in SR matrix. The formation of conductive network was mainly due to the formation of aggregated CB connected to each other. Compared to the 5%CB/SR, the conductive particles in 5%SMCB@Ag/SR have better dispersibility and homogeneity. The introduction of KH-590 and the formation of grape-like branch structure improve the dispersion of SMCB@Ag in SR matrix. Although the dispersion of SMCB@Ag was well, the conductive network was not fully formed with 5.0 wt% SMCB@Ag, which is below the percolation threshold. A stable and complete conductive network was formed in CSR filled with 6.0 wt% SMCB@Ag, therefore, the conductivity of CSR was abruptly improved, matching the conductive behaviour shown in Fig. 3a. The element distribution of CSR filled with 6 wt% SMCB@Ag is obtained by EDS and is shown in Fig. 3f–i. It can be clearly observed that C, Si, S and Ag dispersed uniformly in CSR. The percentage of each element is shown in Table S1.† Due to the mass fraction of filler was only 6 wt% and the Ag nanoparticles and sulfur was only a part of hybrid filler, only a very small amount of silver and sulfur can be seen in the elemental mapping. Although the very small amount of Si, S and Ag can be observed clearly, they have pretty good dispersibility, which demonstrates the good dispersibility of filler in CSR.
The thermal stability of CSR under different SMCB@Ag content is compared and shown in Fig. 4a. Two major weight loss can be seen for all CSR. The first weight loss could be attributed to the removal of H2O on the surface of CSR and degradation of a small amount of KH-590. The weight loss at 500 °C is due to the thermal degradation of SR matrix.53 By comparing the TGA curves of CSR with different filler loadings, it can be observed that CSR shows the best thermal stability with 6.0 wt% SMCB@Ag. The addition of fillers will damage the cross-linked network of SR, but the silane coupling agent in the filler will enhance the interaction between the fillers and the matrix. With the content increasing to 7 wt%, the SR matrix contained a lot of fillers and the cross-linking of matrix was mostly destroyed. The enhancement effect of the silane coupling agent was far from being able to compensate for the destruction of the cross-linked network. Therefore, 6%SMCB@Ag has the best thermal stability among all the CSR with SMCB@Ag added. Fig. 4b displays the tensile strength of CSR filled with different filler content. The tensile strength of CSR first increased with the increase of filler contents and then decreased. A maximum tensile strength appeared at 6.0 wt% filler content, which is similar to the results of TGA. At low content, due to the enhancement effect of nanoparticles SMCB@Ag, the tensile strength was improved.54 As the filler content continues to increase, the enhancement effect of the filler may no longer compensate for the decrease in mechanical properties caused by the destruction of the cross-linked network in SR.
The relative conductivity change is demonstrated by the conductivity change relative to the initial conductivity ΔC/C0 = (C – C0)/C0. The negative value of relative conductivity change indicates the decrease of conductivity with the extension of storage time. In the following experiments, the 5%CB/SR was adopted as a control group to compare with CSR prepared with SMCB@Ag due to the 5%CB/SR has the highest conductivity among CB/SR.
The relationship between electrical conductivity and storage time is shown in Fig. 4c. The conductivity of CB/SR has a sharp decrease in the first 24 h and after 24 h the conductivity gradually becomes stable. In SMCB@Ag/SR, the conductivity has no obvious change until stored for 360 h. In addition, the conductivity loss rate of SMCB@Ag/SR is controlled below 0.1, which is far lower than that of CB/SR. Fillers in conductive composites will migrate over time so that the initial formed conductive networks will be destroyed. The migration of particles (the box in Fig. 4c) decreases the conductivity of CSR. However, SMCB@Ag is hardly to migrate ascribed to the grape-like branch structure and the grafted KH-590. KH-590 in SMCB@Ag can not only connect CB with Ag particles, but also enhance the interaction between filler and matrix, which also hinders the migration of filler.
Fig. 4d–h display the photographs of CSR stretched up to 100% strain. The conductivity of CSR with different strains is shown in Fig. 4i. The conductivity of CSR reduced with the increased strains because the applied strain broke the original conductive network formed after the cure of CSR. The decline of CB/SR conductivity is more pronounced than CSR filled with SMCB@Ag because the grape-like branch structure of SMCB@Ag will extend and stretch under external force, thereby having a buffering effect resisting the external force. Meanwhile, modification of KH-590 on CB improved the interaction between the filler and SR matrix. In terms of the CSR with SMCB@Ag, with the increase of SMCB@Ag content, the conductive stability slightly decreased ascribed to the excessive fillers destroying the cross-linking of CSR. The cracks appeared in 8%SMCB@Ag/SR and 9%SMCB@Ag/SR, which results in bad conductive stability compared with 6%SMCB@Ag/SR and 7%SMCB@Ag/SR.
Fig. 5a–d respectively display the morphology of CB/SR and 6%SMCB@Ag/SR under 75% strain for single stretching-recovery cycle and 100 cycle times. There is an aggregation of CB in CB/SR for single stretching-recovery cycle at 75% strain and a conductive network is formed between the agglomerated CB particles. With the cycle times increasing to 100 cycles, the aggregated CB particles are separated under external force. 6%SMCB@Ag has no obvious aggregation after single stretching-recovery cycle and 100 cycles. Some conductive particles orient along the direction of applied strain, especially after 100 cycles. Regular particle orientation is observed evenly in 6%SMCB@Ag/SR. The group of conductive particles with a certain direction formed inside CSR after stretching can be called “Conductive tape”. Compared Fig. 5b with Fig. 5d, the former has no obvious “Conductivity tape” but that of 6%SMCB@Ag/SR is evenly dispersed in SR matrix, which results in a stable and uniform conductive network of SMCB@Ag/SR.
In order to further explore the cycle stability of CSR filled with SMCB@Ag and to compare it with CB/SR, the relative conductivity change of CB/SR, 6%SMCB@Ag/SR and 7%SMCB@Ag/SR at various strains from 25% to 75% for different cycle times are herein investigated, as shown in Fig. 5e–g. The same phenomenon appeared under the same strain for different cycle times that is in the first 10 stretching-recovery cycles, the conductivity of all CSR decreased sharply and after 20 cycles, the decline became gentle. Although SMCB@Ag can orient in a certain direction under a certain strain and re-form a stable conductive network, the re-form conductive network is far less than the original network so that the conductivity decreased with the stretching-recovery cycle. Based on the calculation of the ordinate value in Fig. 5e, the conductivity retention of CB/SR after 100 cycles was 48% but that of 6%SMCB@Ag/SR and 7%SMCB@Ag/SR can reach 76% and 83% respectively. Similarly, it can be concluded by Fig. 5f and g, 7%SMCB@Ag/SR showed the highest conductivity retention. Under the same strain conditions, SMCB@Ag/SR shows the better stability than CB/SR because the aggregated CB particles forming the conductive network will be separated by the external force and there is a great distance between them in CB/SR, which results in the decrease of conductivity. As for SMCB@Ag/SR, the grape-like branch structure of SMCB@Ag can extend and stretch under the external force so that the original conductive network is mostly preserved. With the increase of SMCB@Ag content, the conductive stability of CSR is improved because the increasing fillers form a more stable conductive network.
The CSR with stable conductivity is very suitable to apply in stretchable conductors,41,42 stretchable wirings and dielectric elastomer.39,40 The bulb lighting experiment of CSR is shown inside Fig. 5h. The CSR can be connected as a conductor in the circuit to light up the bulb. The comprehensive electrical properties of CSR and other conductive composite materials are summarized in Fig. 5h. The X-axis is the maximum strain of the conductive materials to maintain the initial conductivity, while Y-axis is the conductivity after corresponding strain. It can be seen that CSR in our work have a good electrical conductivity and conductive stabilities, its conductivity can reach the level of the conductive elastomer filled with carbon nanotube, carbon fiber or Cu NWs, and the cycle stability is higher than these conductive composites in the references. The specific data is listed in the ESI (Table S1†).
Besides, we also prepared the CB@Ag as a comparison. The experimental process was as follows: directly combine CB without being modified by KH-590 with reducing agent solution, magnetic stir for 30 min and then oxidizer solution was added dropwise. The reaction was carried out at 35 °C for 2.5 h. The purification method of the product was the same as above.
The reaction scheme of SMCB@Ag is shown in Fig. 6. The silicon methoxy groups are hydrolyzed into hydroxyl groups after KH-590 was hydrolyzed under acetic acid, which can react with the hydroxyl groups on the surface of CB. The functional groups of CB changed from hydroxyl to sulfhydryl due to the modification of KH-590. Sulfhydryl groups have a certain attraction to metal ions so that the silver ions are more likely to be absorbed and reduced on the surface of SMCB. Silver nitrate solution is added dropwise to control the reduction process and form uniform silver on the surface of SMCB. In addition, mutual exclusion between silver ions causes the formation of the grape-like branch structure of SMCB@Ag. The schematic illustration of these reactions is in Fig. S2.†
:
1. The addition of conductive particles affects the cross-linking of SR so that it is necessary to add a certain mass of hydrogen silicone oil (H) and platinum catalyst (Pt) to ensure the complete curing of CSR. The mass ratio of each component is as follows, A
:
B: H
:
Pt is 1
:
1: 1
:
0.15. After the glue was mixed well, the conductive filler was blended into the glue, stirred for 5 min and poured into the mould or painted on the glass plate, which depends on the next performance. The amount of SMCB@Ag changed from 3 wt% to 10.0 wt% and the amount of CB was from 3.0 wt% to 5.0 wt% because the exceeded amount will result in the granular precipitated product, which is difficult to cure into specific shape according to the research of this work.
| σ = 1/ρ |
Conductivity stability of CSR was tested by cyclic stretching-recovery treatment. The tensile strains were from 0% to 75% and the cycle times were up to 100 times. After each stretch, samples were held for 1 min, and the recovery was also kept for 1 min. The relative conductivity change was represented by ΔC/C0 = (C – C0)/C0. Where C is the conductivity of the CSR treated with different conditions, for example, storing at room temperature; stretching under different strains; stretching and recovering for a certain number of cycles. C0 is the initial conductivity of CSR without any treatment. The result is a negative value, demonstrating that the conductivity decreases in the static and dynamic conductivity test. The larger absolute value of ΔC/C0 indicates the worse conductive stability.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1ra08649a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |