Christian
Ritschel
a,
Joanna
Napp
bc,
Frauke
Alves
*bc and
Claus
Feldmann
*a
aInstitute for Inorganic Chemistry, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Engesserstrasse 15, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: claus.feldmann@kit.edu
bUniversity Medical Center Goettingen (UMG), Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Robert Koch Str. 40, 37075 Goettingen, Germany
cMax Planck Institute for Multidisciplinary Sciences, Translational Molecular Imaging, Hermann-Rein-Strasse 3, 37075 Goettingen, Germany. E-mail: falves@gwdg.de
First published on 22nd October 2022
[La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− inorganic–organic hybrid nanoparticles (IOH-NPs) with indocyanine green (ICG) and perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylate (PTC) as fluorescent dye anions are used for emission-based monitoring of the dissolution of nanoparticles. Whereas ICG shows a deep red emission in the solid [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 IOH-NPs, the emission of PTC in the solid [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs is completely quenched due to π-stacking. After nanoparticle dissolution, the emission of freely dissolved ICG is weak, whereas freely dissolved PTC shows intense green emission. We report on the synthesis of IOH-NPs and nanoparticle characterization as well as on the fluorescence properties and how to avoid undesirable energy transfer between different fluorescent dyes. The emission shift from red (intact solid nanoparticles) to green (freely dissolved dye anions), indicating nanoparticle dissolution, is shown for aqueous systems and verified in vitro. Based on this first proof-of-the-concept, the IOH-NP marker system can be interesting to monitor nanoparticle dissolution in cells and tissues of small animals and to evaluate cell processes and/or drug-delivery strategies.
Optical detection is usually related to a change in intensity rather than a change in wavelength and colour.5–7 In some cases, the change in the fluorescence intensity was used to the point of an on–off or off–on behaviour. Such fluorescent nanoparticles have been exploited, for example, to study cellular uptake, drug delivery, drug release, and all kinds of sensing effects (e.g., the detection of metal ions and the detection of molecules such as carbohydrates or antibodies), which can be partly performed in real time.1,5–7 However, a change in the emission intensity has the disadvantage of being concentration dependent, which either requires distinct on–off/off–on characteristics or normalization of the emission intensity on a suitable reference. In this regard, changing the emission colour as a response to a certain effect or parameter would be much more effective. However, such a wavelength shift is more complex with regard to the selection of fluorescence markers and has only been reported in a few cases to date.8
Aiming at fluorescence-based monitoring of the dissolution of nanoparticles, and specifically, differentiation of the intact solid nanoparticles and the homogeneous solution after nanoparticle dissolution, we examined different strategies involving two different fluorescent dyes. This resulted in several limitations, whereof an undesirable energy transfer disturbs the intended fluorescence features most often. We are now successful with a mixture of [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− inorganic–organic hybrid nanoparticles (IOH-NPs) (ICG: indocyanine green, PTC: perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylate), which show an emission shift from red (intact nanoparticles in aqueous suspension) to green (aqueous solution of freely dissolved fluorescent dyes) upon dissolution. This system of fluorescence markers – including synthesis, nanoparticle characterization, and proof-of-concept of the fluorescence-colour shift in the first in vitro studies – is shown here for the first time.
On the other hand, [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4−@LaPO4 core–shell IOH-NPs can be prepared (see the ESI†).
To monitor the dissolution of the IOH-NPs based on their fluorescence, a careful selection of suitable fluorescent dyes is essential. In this regard, we have evaluated about 50 different fluorescent dyes that are compatible with the IOH-NP concept. All these fluorescent IOH-NPs, however, showed only a single emission, so a particle dissolution only resulted in a decrease in the emission, which is much less indicative than a fluorescence-colour shift. Such a colour shift, however, requires the use of two different fluorescent dyes. The first dye should preferentially only emit in the solid nanoparticle but not show emission in solution, whereas the emission of the second dye should be quenched in the solid nanoparticle but be intense in solution. Due to the dilution in the solution, moreover, the second dye must exhibit a much more intense emission than the first dye. In addition to this default, further parameters need to be considered. Thus, long-wavelength excitation and emission are required in regard to the penetration depth in biological systems. Finally, energy transfer and/or overlapping emission of the fluorescent dyes need to be avoided in order to observe two different emission colours.
Although we have examined various combinations of dyes, an energy transfer between the two dyes could not be suppressed completely, so either significant fluorescence quenching or only a mixed emission colour of the two dyes was observed. The fact that the dyes are spatially close together with a high concentration in the nanoparticle volume, of course, favours the undesired energy transfer in comparison with the freely dissolved dyes in the solution. These restrictions were finally solved by two measures. First of all, the selection of the fluorescent dyes was most important. Here, we have used indocyanine green (ICG) as a first and perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylate (PTC) as a second dye (Fig. 1). Both are anionic and chemically fit with the concept of the IOH-NPs.10 ICG as the first dye is known for its weak deep-red emission.12 ICG is clinically approved and employed in a wide range of medical imaging and diagnostic procedures but most often as an absorptive dye (e.g. in histology) since its emission is weak.13 Due to the high ICG-load in IOH-NPs, however, the deep-red emission is even visible in suspension to the naked eye. Subsequent to the dissolution of the IOH-NPs, the emission of the free [ICG]− can be expected to be negligible. Perylene tetracarboxylate (PTC) was selected as the second dye. Such perylene-type dyes are generally known for their extremely intense emission with high luminescence efficiency14 and also show good biocompatibility.15 Due to the π-stacking of the molecules and the so-called aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) effect, the emission of PTC is completely quenched in the solid nanoparticles. After the dissolution of the IOH-NPs, however, the freely dissolved [PTC]4− shows a bright green emission.
In addition to the selection of the fluorescent dyes – as a second measure – it turned out to be essential not to combine both dyes in one nanoparticle but to use mixed suspensions with both types of IOH-NPs (Fig. 1). For such IOH-NP mixtures, the expected fluorescence-colour shift from red (solid nanoparticles) to green (dissolved nanoparticles) was successfully observed. In the case of IOH-NPs containing a combination of ICG and PTC, in contrast, two disadvantageous effects were observed. First, these IOH-NPs with combined dyes, again, show an undesired energy transfer with emission of ICG upon excitation of PTC (ESI: Fig. S1a†). Moreover and even more important, combining ICG and PTC in a single IOH-NP disturbs the π-stacking of PTC, so the PTC emission is not quenched in the solid IOH-NPs (ESI: Fig. S1b†). Overall, this points to the feasibility of the concept of mixing two different types of IOH-NPs, each of them containing only a single fluorescent dye.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Schematic aqueous synthesis of (a) [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 IOH-NPs and (b) [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs. |
After certain purification to remove the remaining starting materials and salts, [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 IOH-NPs with 90% ICG per total nanoparticle mass were obtained as a colloidally stable, deep green aqueous suspension (Fig. 2; ESI: Fig. S2–S5†). In contrast, the as-obtained orange suspension of the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs (with 60% PTC per total nanoparticle mass) only resulted in suspensions with low colloidal stability with rapid Ostwald ripening, causing very large particles (5–10 μm) after about 1 hour (ESI: Fig. S6†). Since the polar carboxylate groups of the PTC anion coordinate with the cation, this finding can be ascribed to the non-polar particle surface established by the perylene backbone. To decrease the particle size and to increase the colloidal stability, two options are possible. Thus, particle nucleation can be performed at an elevated temperature (95 °C) to promote particle nucleation. Alternatively, the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs can also be modified using a LaPO4 shell, which was established immediately after the nucleation process (ESI: Fig. S7–S13†). Aqueous suspensions of both [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs prepared at 95 °C and core–shell-type [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4−@LaPO4 IOH-NPs are colloidally stable over several weeks (Fig. 3c and 4c; ESI: Fig. S11†).
The particle size and particle size distribution of the as-prepared [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs were characterized by dynamic light scattering (DLS) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Since nanoparticles in water typically exhibit an expanded, rigid layer of adsorbed H2O molecules, the primary particle diameter was examined via DLS after dispersion of the IOH-NPs in diethylene glycol (DEG), which is known for its excellent stabilization of nanoparticles.17 Accordingly, DLS shows mean diameters of 103 ± 13 nm ([La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2) and 73 ± 12 nm ([La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4−) (Fig. 3a and 4a). Based on a statistical evaluation of >100 particles on SEM images, mean diameters of 84 ± 40 nm ([La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2) and 61 ± 15 nm ([La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4−) were determined (Fig. 3a, d and 4a, d). The different values of DLS and SEM relate to the larger hydrodynamic diameter obtained by DLS. Whereas a spherical shape is observed for [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 (Fig. 3e), rod-shaped particles are obtained for [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− (Fig. 4e). This finding can be again ascribed to the π-stacking of the PTC anion. Both types of IOH-NPs show negative surface charging as indicated by zeta potentials of −35 to −45 mV at pH 5–9 (Fig. 3b and 4b). An even higher negative charging was observed for the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4−@LaPO4 core–shell IOH-NPs with a zeta potential of −40 mV over the complete pH range (ESI: Fig. S11†), which also confirms the formation of the LaPO4 shell.
To prove the chemical composition of the [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs, different analytical methods were used. First of all, X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) indicates the nanoparticles to be essentially non-crystalline, which was frequently observed for other IOH-NPs as well (ESI: Fig. S2 and S7†).10 Only [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− shows few, low-intensity Bragg peaks, which can be ascribed to the π-stacking of the PTC anions (ESI: Fig. S7†). Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy reveals the presence of ICG and PTC in the IOH-NPs (ESI: Fig. S3 and S8†). Thus, the spectra of the IOH-NPs are well in agreement with Na(ICG) and Na4(PTC) as the starting materials. Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) confirmed the presence of lanthanum in the IOH-NPs. Finally, the cation-to-anion ratio was confirmed by total organic combustion analysis, including thermogravimetry (TG) and elemental analysis (EA) (ESI: Fig. S4 and S9†).
For the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs, as expected, no emission was observed for the aqueous suspensions due to the π-stacking of the PTC anions in the solid nanoparticles (Fig. 5b). Thus, emission spectra more-or-less show a zero line. In contrast, a solution of Na4(PTC) with a PTC concentration similar to that of the IOH-NPs shows strong absorption at 350–500 nm and very intense emission at 500–700 nm with a maximum at 517 nm (Fig. 5b; ESI: Fig. S10, S12 and S13†).
After examination of the individual [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs, the fluorescence features of aqueous suspensions containing both types of IOH-NPs were studied. The dissolution of the IOH-NPs was initiated by redispersion of the IOH-NPs in a phosphate buffer at pH 7 at concentrations of 10 μM, 100 μM, 1.0 mM, 10 mM, and 100 mM phosphate (Fig. 6). In the presence of phosphate, ICG and PTC are released due to the stronger complexion of lanthanum by phosphate in comparison with the sulfonate group of ICG or the carboxylate group of PTC (see Fig. 1a) according to the following equations:
[La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 + [HPO4]2− → [La(OH)]2+2[HPO4]2− + 2[ICG]− |
[La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− + 2[HPO4]2− → 2[La(OH)]2+[HPO4]2− + [PTC]4− |
The release of ICG and PTC is slow due to slow equilibration and due to the size of the IOH-NPs (60–80 nm). Since phosphate is omnipresent in the blood, cells, and tissues, phosphate-induced dissolution can be considered to mimic the particle dissolution under biological conditions with about 1.5 mM phosphate in the human blood serum18 and up to 100 mM as the intracellular phosphate level.19
The photoluminescence spectra recorded for the different samples confirm the aforementioned course of the emission intensity. Thus, the ICG emission decreases slowly upon dissolution of the [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 IOH-NPs (Fig. 6a). In contrast, the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs show no emission prior to beginning dissolution. After addition of the phosphate buffer, the PTC-related green emission increases significantly with the phosphate concentration as well as the proceeding IOH-NP dissolution and PTC release into the solution (Fig. 6b). In sum, the nanoparticle dissolution can be indeed followed by a fluorescence-colour shift from red (nanoparticle suspension) to green (solution).
After examining the dissolution of individual IOH-NPs and a mixture of both IOH-NPs, first in vitro studies were performed as a proof-of-concept (Fig. 7a). To this concern, mixed suspensions with both [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs were cultivated with MH-S mouse alveolar macrophages at 37 °C for up to 15 h. Similar to the suspensions, thereafter, the red and/or green emission was detected within the cells by fluorescence microscopy.
Time-dependent micrographs over 15 hours (Fig. 7b) as well as detailed micrographs (Fig. 7c) show both the red emission of ICG and the green emission of PTC, indicating the uptake of both types of IOH-NPs into the MH-S cells. Interestingly, red and green emissions are continuously visible over the whole observed time range. This is different from the aforementioned suspensions with individual or mixed IOH-NPs (Fig. 5 and 6). This finding can be attributed to two effects. On the one hand, the metabolic degradation of ICG and PTC in cells can be considered to be different so that the dye concentration may differ from ex vitro aqueous suspensions. On the other hand, the freely dissolved ICG and PTC are not released out of the cells, so they remain in the cell, resulting in a lower dilution effect in comparison with the great volume of aqueous suspensions. Detailed micrographs after the incubation, nevertheless, indicate a more granular structure for the red-emitting areas than for the green-emitting areas, which is in agreement with the presence of intact [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 IOH-NPs (Fig. 7c). In contrast, the green emission is more diffuse and the most intense at larger agglomerates of IOH-NPs (Fig. 7c), which points to the beginning of the dissolution of the [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs.
Thus, particle dissolution can in principle also be monitored through in vitro cell-based assays based on a fluorescence-colour shift from red to green, which is here shown for the first time with [La(OH)]2+[ICG]−2 and [La(OH)]2+2[PTC]4− IOH-NPs in macrophages. Additional studies are of course necessary to optimize and to fine-tune the relevant parameters and conditions. This will be even more interesting in combination with the evaluation of the time kinetics of different drug delivery systems, especially for the optimization of IOH-NPs that are loaded with certain pharmaceutical agents.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details regarding the analytical techniques and further data related to the material characterization of the IOH-NPs. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2nr03078k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |