Dominik Kurzydłowski*a,
Mikhail A. Kuzovnikovb and
Marek Tkaczc
aFaculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University, Warsaw 01-038, Poland. E-mail: d.kurzydlowski@uksw.edu.pl
bInstitute of Solid State Physics RAS, 142432 Chernogolovka, Moscow District, Russian Federation
cInstitute of Physical Chemistry, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw 01-224, Poland
First published on 16th April 2021
Tellurium trioxide, TeO3, is the only example of a trioxide adopting at ambient conditions the VF3-type structure (a distorted variant of the cubic ReO3 structure). Here we present a combined experimental (Raman scattering) and theoretical (DFT modelling) study on the influence of high pressure (exceeding 100 GPa) on the phase stability of this compound. In experiments the ambient-pressure VF3-type structure (Rc symmetry) is preserved up to 110 GPa. In contrast, calculations indicate that above 66 GPa the Rc structure should transform to a YF3-type polymorph (Pnma symmetry) with the coordination number of Te6+ increasing from 6 to 8 upon the transition. The lack of this transition in the room-temperature experiment is most probably connected with energetic barriers, in analogy to what is found for compressed WO3. The YF3-type phase is predicted to be stable up to 220 GPa when it should transform to a novel structure of R symmetry and Z = 18. We analyse the influence of pressure on the band gap of TeO3, and discuss the present findings in the context of structural transformations of trioxides and trifluorides adopting an extended structure in the solid state.
Apart from TeO2, four other oxides of tellurium are known in the solid state: tellurium trioxide (TeO3) and two mixed-valent compounds containing both Te4+ and Te6+ ions (Te4O9 and Te2O5).6,7 The phase transitions of TeO2 induced by pressures exceeding 1 GPa (=10 kbar) were studied intensively both experimentally,8–13 and by Density Functional Theory (DFT) modelling.13–16 Compression induces a substantial volume reduction in TeO2 (by about 36% up to 70 GPa), and an increase in the coordination number (CN) of Te4+ from 4 to 9.12
In contrast, the high-pressure phase transitions of TeO3, which contains the much smaller Te6+ cation, were not studied up to date. One of the probable reasons for such lack of research is connected with the poor availability of the starting material. Tellurium trioxide cannot be prepared by direct oxidation of Te or TeO2, but requires performing the thermal decomposition of orthotelluric acid, Te(OH)6. Moreover, there is some variation in the published recipes for the synthesis.17–21
TeO3 is reported to exhibit four different phases: three of them are crystalline (marked I, II, III following the notation introduced in ref. 21) and one is amorphous (IV). Full structural information is available only for phase I (often referred to as β-TeO3), which adopts a VF3-type structure (Fig. 1) exhibiting a coordination number (CN) of Te6+ equal to 6.18,20,21 Phase II is reported to adopt a hexagonal unit cell, while for phase III only information on unindexed powder X-ray diffraction lines is available.21
The ambient-pressure VF3-type structure (Rc symmetry, Z = 6)20,21 is composed of corner-sharing TeO6 octahedra with all six Te–O contacts equal in length. This geometry can be viewed as a perovskite-type ABX3 structure with vacant A-sites and tilting of the BX6 octahedra. The VF3 polytype can be derived from the non-tilted ReO3 structure (Pmm, Z = 1)22 by enforcing tilting of the octahedra (a−a−a− type tilting in Glazer's notation).23
It's noteworthy to point out that phase I of TeO3 is the only example of a trioxide adopting the VF3-type structure. This polytype is more commonly encountered in trifluorides. In this context, it is of interest to explore the high-pressure phase transformations of TeO3, and compare them with those of trifluorides,24–26 and trioxides, in particular, WO3,27–31 and ReO3 itself.32–35
Here we present a combined experimental (Raman scattering) and theoretical (DFT modelling) study on the influence of high pressure on the structure stability of TeO3. Our experimental results indicate that the ambient-pressure VF3-type structure (Rc symmetry) is preserved up to 110 GPa. In contrast, calculations indicate that above 66 GPa the Rc structure should transform to a YF3-type polymorph (Pnma symmetry) with a subsequent increase in the CN of Te6+ from 6 to 8. This transition is not observed in an experiment most probably due to large energetic barriers, in analogy to what is found for compressed WO3. Another transition from the Pnma structure to a rhombohedral phase (R, Z = 18) with a 10-fold coordination of Te6+ is predicted at 220 GPa. We analyse the influence of pressure on the band gap of TeO3 and discuss the present findings in the context of structural transformations of trioxides and trifluorides adopting an extended structure in the solid state (in contrast to SbF3,36 or AsF3,37 which form molecular crystals).
The spectra in the third run were acquired with the Alpha300M+ confocal microscope (Witec Gmbh) equipped with a motorized stage. We used a 532 nm laser line delivered to the microscope through a single-mode optical fiber. The laser power at the sample did not exceed 20 mW. The backscattered Raman signal was collected through a 20× long working distance objective, and passed through a multi-mode optical fiber (50 μm core diameter) to a lens based spectrometer (Witec UHTS 300, f/4 aperture, focal length 300 mm) coupled with a back-illuminated Andor iDUS 401 detector thermoelectrically cooled to −60 °C. The spectra were collected in the range of Raman shifts from 70 to 1720 cm−1 with the use of an 1800 mm grating resulting in a 1.2 cm−1 spectral resolution. The acquisition time was 1 s with 30 accumulations. The spectra were post-processed (background subtraction and cosmic-ray removal) with the Project FIVE software (Witec Gmbh). The position of Raman bands was established with the Fityk 1.3.1 software by fitting the observed bands with Pseudo-Voigt profiles.40 During the experiment we did not observe any Raman bands that could be assigned to the O2 vibron,41 which excludes decomposition of TeO3 into O2 and lower-valence tellurium oxides.
The projector-augmented-wave (PAW) method was used in the calculations,49 as implemented in the VASP 5.4 code.50,51 The cut-off energy of the plane waves was set to 800 eV with a self-consistent-field convergence criterion of 10−8 eV. Valence electrons (Te: 5s2, 5p4; O: 2s2, 2p4) were treated explicitly, while standard VASP pseudopotentials were used for the description of core electrons. We verified that using an extended basis set for Te, with the 3d, 4s, and 4p electrons included explicitly, did not alter the obtained results. The k-point mesh spacing was set to 2π × 0.03 Å−1. All structures were optimized until the forces acting on the atoms were smaller than 1 meV Å−1. Calculations of vibration frequencies (also using SCAN) were conducted with the finite-displacement method with 0.007 Å displacement. We did not apply any scaling of the theoretical vibration frequencies when comparing them with experimental values.
At selected pressures, we additionally calculated the intensity of Γ-point Raman-active vibrational modes using density-functional perturbation theory (DFPT),52 as implemented in the CASTEP code (academic release version 19.11).53 Due to the large computational cost of these calculations we employed the Local Density Approximation (LDA). This approach was previously successfully used to model the Raman spectrum of Te(II) and Te(III) oxides,54,55 as well as the pressure-induced changes in the Raman spectrum of inorganic fluorides.46,47 In our calculations we employed norm-conserving pseudopotentials and a cut-off energy of 1020 eV. The Raman activity of each vibrational mode (Si) was converted into the intensity (Ii) assuming the following relation:
We performed evolutionary algorithm searches for lowest-enthalpy structures of TeO3. For this, we used the XtalOpt software (version r12)56 coupled with periodic DFT calculations utilizing the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) functional.57 These searches were conducted at 50, 60,100, 150, and 200 GPa for Z up to 6 (an additional search at 60 GPa with Z = 12 was also conducted) yielding nearly 5000 crystal structures.
Visualization of all structures was performed with the VESTA software package.58 For symmetry recognition we used the FINDSYM program.59 Group theory analysis of the vibrational modes was performed with the use of the Bilbao Crystallographic Server.60
Up to the highest pressure reached in this study (110 GPa) the observed shifts in the frequency of the Raman bands are in good accordance with those predicted for the VF3 structure (Fig. 3). However, above 60 GPa we observe a new band developing on the high-frequency side of the A1g mode (Fig. 2b). The emergence of this band is most probably a result of non-hydrostatic conditions inside the DAC which, present even at lower pressures but amplified by compression, lead for a part of the sample to shifting of the frequency of the A1g mode to higher values (see Fig. S2†). The changes in the Raman spectrum were observed in all three experimental runs and at different positions in the DAC. The spectrum after decompression to 1 atm was identical to the initial spectrum.
Analysis of the pressure dependence of the relative enthalpy of various TeO3 polymorphs is given in Fig. 5a. Calculations indicate that the VF3-type structure is the most stable one at ambient conditions (≈0 GPa) – in accordance with experiment. Upon compression, a first order transition from this structure into the YF3-type polymorph (Pnma symmetry) is predicted at 66 GPa. However, the spectral changes observed in the experiment cannot be assigned to this transition, as the predicted Raman spectrum of the Pnma structure is very different from the experimental one (Fig. S3†). Calculation indicate one more phase transition at 220 GPa from the YF3-type structure to a polymorph of R symmetry. This process leads to an increase in CN from 8 to 10 and a volume reduction of nearly 3% (Fig. 5b).
The lack of the transition between VF3- and YF3-type structures in our room-temperature experiment is most probably due to significant kinetic barriers accompanying this process. These are a result of large changes in the Te coordination environment and molar volume (Fig. 5b). This notion is supported by the fact that the VF3 polymorph is dynamically stable at 66 GPa (vide infra). The lack of the VF3 → YF3 phase transition in TeO3 resembles the situation found for MgF2 and SnO2 where large energy barriers hinder the thermodynamically favoured phase transition from the TiO2-type structure to an α-PbO2 polymorph.62,63 To overcome these barriers laser heating of the sample would be required, in analogy to high-pressure experiments conducted for TeO2.12 However our current experimental setup does not allow us to perform laser heating of samples enclosed in a diamond anvil cell. Moreover leaser heating could lead to thermal decomposition of TeO3 (at ambient conditions this compound decomposes above 400 °C).21
The fact that the VF3 structure of TeO3 is metastable up to 110 GPa is further supported by phonon dispersion calculations. In the 0 to 141 GPa pressure range the Rc polymorph does not exhibit any vibrations with imaginary frequencies. However, upon compression, a softening of one phonon branch is observed at the F-point of the Brillouin zone, (1/2, 1/2, 0) vector, which leads to the appearance of imaginary modes at this point above 141 GPa. This behaviour was also observed at high pressure for the VF3 structure of FeF3.25
Both FeF3 and TeO3 exhibit a similar pressure dependence of structural parameters (although in different pressure ranges). For both compounds pressure initially induces a change in the structural parameters towards an ideal hexagonally close-packing (hcp) packing of O2− anions.24,25 For example, the c/a ratio increases upon compression up to a point where it exceeds that predicted for a perfect hcp packing (Fig. 6). After reaching a maximum (found at 20 GPa for FeF3, and 80 GPa for TeO3 – see Fig. 6) this ratio decreases upon compression. Interestingly in both FeF3 and TeO3 the F-point phonon instability appears at the point when this ratio becomes again smaller than the value predicted for a perfect hcp packing.
Distorting the Rc structure along the eigenvector of the imaginary mode, and subsequent geometry optimization, leads to a structure with four TeO3 units per unit cell and P21/c symmetry (this space group is the highest-symmetry sub-group of Rc along the (1/2, 1/2, 0) modulation vector). This structure, shown in Fig. 4c, is a distorted variant of the high-pressure phase of WO3 (HP-WO3),28 and exhibits 7-fold coordination of Te6+ (increasing to 8-fold upon compression). The Rc → P21/c transition is of first order (ΔV/V = −5.8% at 141 GPa). However, given the fact that it is connected with a phonon instability, it might be characterized by a small energetic barrier. It, therefore, could be observed during room-temperature compression.
SCAN calculation of the pressure dependence of the electronic band gap (Eg) for the high-pressure structures of TeO3 is shown in Fig. 7. The Eg value obtained at ambient conditions for the VF3 structure (1.55 eV) is underestimated compared with the experimental value (3.25 eV), but larger than that obtained in calculations utilizing the PBE functional (1.21 eV).64,65 Compression induces an increase of the band gap in all TeO3 polymorphs, especially for the VF3-type structure exhibiting octahedral coordination of Te6+. This trend is similar to what is found for ionic difluorides (MF2, M = Be, Mg, Ca),66 and in contrast to TeO2 where much smaller variations of Eg are seen.15 The band gap is predicted to decrease abruptly upon the Rc → Pnma (p = 60 GPa) and the Pnma → R (p = 220 GPa) phase transition.
Calculations indicate that the persistence of the VF3-type structure above 66 GPa is a kinetic effect as this polymorph, as well as the HP-WO3 structure, are thermodynamically less stable than a YF3-type polymorph (Pnma space group), which exhibits 8-fold coordination of Te6+. The lack of the VF3 → YF3 phase transition in room-temperature compression experiments is most probably a result of the large energetic barriers associated with it. It's noteworthy to mention that a similar situation is found for WO3. For this compound calculations indicate that a YF3 structure is the ground state structure above 20 GPa.31 However, it has not been observed in experiments conducted up to 40 GPa.29
We predict that above 220 GPa TeO3 should enter a post-YF3 phase with R symmetry (Z = 18) and 10-fold coordination of Te6+. We do not find evidence for a possible transition into the 12-fold coordinated LaF3-type structure (Pc1) adopted by rare earth trifluorides, nor to the 9-fold coordinated Cmcm phase proposed for WO3.31 Finally, we show that high pressure and compression-induced phase transitions lead to large variations of the electronic band gap of TeO3. The possibility of pressure-tuning of the band structure of TeO3 polymorphs is also of interest in the context of non-linear properties of this material.64
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Comparison of the ambient-pressure geometry and the frequencies of the Raman-active vibrational modes between experiment and SCAN calculations; ambient-pressure powder X-ray diffraction pattern of TeO3; comparison of the high-pressure Raman spectrum of TeO3 with that calculated for the YF3-type and VF3-type structures; computed structural parameters of the high-pressure polymorphs of TeO3. See DOI: 10.1039/d1ra02344f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |