Open Access Article
Anatol
Prudnikau‡
a,
Dmitriy I.
Shiman‡
b,
Evgenii
Ksendzov
ab,
Jonathon
Harwell
c,
Ekaterina A.
Bolotina
abe,
Pavel A.
Nikishau
b,
Sergei V.
Kostjuk
*bde,
Ifor D. W.
Samuel
c and
Vladimir
Lesnyak
*a
aPhysical Chemistry, TU Dresden, Zellescher Weg 19, 01069 Dresden, Germany. E-mail: vladimir.lesnyak1@tu-dresden.de
bResearch Institute for Physical Chemical Problems of the Belarusian State University, Leningradskaya Str. 14, 220006 Minsk, Belarus. E-mail: kostjuks@bsu.by
cOrganic Semiconductor Centre, SUPA, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of St. Andrews, North Haugh, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9SS, UK
dInstitute for Regenerative Medicine, Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, 119991 Moscow, Russia
eDepartment of Chemistry, Belarusian State University, Leningradskaya Str. 14, 220006 Minsk, Belarus
First published on 20th January 2021
Photoluminescent quantum dots (QDs) are a prominent example of nanomaterials used in practical applications, especially in light-emitting and light-converting devices. Most of the current applications of QDs require formation of thin films or their incorporation in solid matrices. The choice of an appropriate host material capable of preventing QDs from degradation and developing a process of uniform incorporation of QDs in the matrix have become essential scientific and technological challenges. In this work, we developed a method of uniform incorporation of Cu–Zn–In–S (CZIS) QDs into a highly protective cross-linked polyisobutylene (PIB) matrix with high chemical resistance and low gas permeability. Our approach involves the synthesis of a methacrylate-terminated three-arm star-shaped PIB oligomeric precursor capable of quick formation of a robust 3D polymer network upon exposure to UV-light, as well as the design of a special ligand introducing short PIB chains onto the surface of the QDs, thus providing compatibility with the matrix. The obtained cross-linked QDs-in-polymer composites underwent a complex photostability test in air and under vacuum as well as a chemical stability test. These tests found that CZIS QDs in a cross-linked PIB matrix demonstrated excellent photo- and chemical stability when compared to identical QDs in widely used polyacrylate-based matrices. These results make the composites developed excellent materials for the fabrication of robust, stable and durable transparent light conversion layers.
Polymers are attractive as host materials for QDs due to their low cost, simple processing and availability on an industrial scale. Dielectric polymers such as polydimethylsiloxane, polystyrene, and polyacrylates can be used as host materials for semiconductor nanocrystals due to their optical transparency in the visible region, high mechanical durability and extensive knowledge of their chemistry.21,23–25 One of the most important parameters determining the use of a polymer as a host material for QDs is its flexibility. It should be noted that most popular polymer-based materials (polyacrylates and polystyrene derivatives) are rigid matrices, limiting their potential for applications. Hence the practical interest is shifting towards flexible polymers, such as polyisobutylene (PIB), which exhibits excellent flexibility at ambient temperatures.26
There are various strategies for incorporation of colloidal QDs into polymer matrices without drastically changing their initial photophysical properties. One of the most widely used and simplest routes is the direct mixing of as-synthesized hydrophobic QDs with a solution of a polymer in nonpolar solvents, with subsequent evaporation of the solvent to create a solid matrix.27,28 The other approach involves the dispersion of nanoparticles in monomers or prepolymerized oligomers and in situ polymerization for obtaining nanocomposites with embedded QDs.22,24,29 Alternatively, nanoparticles can be synthesized directly in a preformed polymer matrix by decomposing suitable precursors under thermal treatment30 or light irradiation.31,32 Formation of both the nanocrystals and polymer matrix can occur at the same time.22 Nevertheless, irrespective of the preparation method of polymer composites with embedded QDs, there are two critical issues which should be solved. The first problem is the inhomogeneous dispersion of QDs within polymer matrices, especially at high concentrations in the composite; and the second one is the insufficient stability of the obtained materials under working conditions.
The issue of poor compatibility between colloidal nanoparticles and polymers should be solved to avoid aggregation, which affects photophysical properties of QDs and leads to quenching of their PL and to formation of an opaque composite with strong turbidity. Colloidal QDs can be described as a complex material consisting of an inorganic core capped with a layer of organic molecules (ligands).33 The ligands play a double role: on the one hand, they passivate dangling bonds on the QDs surface, on the other hand, they confer the compatibility of QDs with the surrounding media. This compatibility is very important as otherwise the QDs would be likely to aggregate, leading to a loss of quantum confinement and their distinctive properties. In particular, aggregation can greatly reduce PL efficiency. Modification of the surface through the ligand exchange process allows compatibility of colloidal QDs with different solvents and solid matrices to be achieved. For instance, originally hydrophobic CdSe/ZnS core/shell QDs were transferred to the aqueous phase by replacing initial ligands with mercaptosuccinic acid.34 Functionalization of low-toxic Cu–Zn–In–S (CZIS) QDs with 4-vinylaniline and zinc methacrylate ensured their efficient copolymerization with styrene yielding QDs-in-polystyrene bulk composites with homogeneously distributed nanoparticles within the matrix with preserved high PL quantum yield (QY) of the QDs after the incorporation.24
The other serious obstacle for the commercialization of polymer composites with QDs is their insufficient stability under working conditions. As well known, oxygen and water can lead to QDs degradation and to the deterioration of their optical properties.35 This is particularly relevant to Cd-free QDs, such as CuInS2 and InP which typically demonstrate lower stability than cadmium chalcogenide-based QDs.35 The most widely used approach to enhance stability of QDs is overcoating them with an epitaxial shell consisting of a wider band gap semiconductor material. In the case of CuInS2 or CZIS, zinc sulfide is the most suitable candidate for the shell growth due to its low toxicity, high stability, and small crystal lattice mismatch.36,37 Despite the fact that the shell confines excitons to the core, removes surface defects and protects the core from interaction with the environment,33 this approach is limited since increasing the shell thickness can lead to deterioration of their PL properties due to crystalline mismatch at the core/shell interface inducing significant lattice strain that in turn leads to formation of crystal lattice defects.38 The other approach to enhance the stability of QDs in solid composites is using host materials with low gas permeability and high chemical stability which allow for protecting QDs from oxygen and moisture even under harsh operating conditions.27 Among flexible polymers (elastomers) suitable as a host material for QDs three main classes can be distinguished: silicones, polyurethanes and rubbers with hydrocarbon main chain. The first two classes are characterized by a very high gas permeability (5.86 × 10−15 m2 s−1 Pa−1 and 8.93 × 10−15 m2 s−1 Pa−1 respectively)39,40 and are unable to protect QDs during operation. Among rubbers, butyl rubber (copolymer of isobutylene (98–99%) and isoprene (1–2%)) has the lowest gas permeability (4.29 × 10−17 m2 s−1 Pa−1).39 In addition to low gas permeability, commercial butyl rubber has a vapor permeability 4.79 × 10−19 to 1.16 × 10−18 m2 s−1 Pa−1 lower than most plastics (0.48–3.34 × 10−18 m2 s−1 Pa−1).41 Furthermore, it possesses high chemical stability and retains high elastic properties at low temperatures (Tg = −64 °C).42 Banerjee et al. and Bag et al. recently showed that compared to commercial butyl rubber, the cross-linked PIB-based star-shaped polymers exhibit better barrier properties, in particular, oxygen permeability of only 4.07 × 10−18 m2 s−1 Pa−1 and moisture permeability of 9.86 × 10−17 m2 s−1 Pa−1, which are highly beneficial for encapsulation of flexible organic solar cells.43,44
In our previous work, we developed oxygen- and moisture-proof polymer matrices based on PIB for the encapsulation of colloidal semiconductor nanocrystals with different composition and dimensionality.27 Since pure PIB is a soft polymer, we synthesized a block-copolymer of isobutylene with styrene poly(styrene-block-isobutylene-block-styrene) (SIBS) to improve mechanical properties of the composites. The nanocrystals were functionalized with a specially designed ligand, containing a short-chain PIB and anchor amino group, which provides excellent compatibility between nanocrystals and PIB-based matrices. It was also shown that semiconductor nanocrystals in PIB-based matrices demonstrated enhanced photo- and chemical stability.
In this work, we report a design principle of the QDs-in-polymer composite, which enables photoluminescent QDs to be incorporated in a highly protective cross-linked matrix without changing their optical properties. We synthesized a methacrylate-terminated three-arm star-shaped PIB precursor (PIB-MA) capable of fast hardening under the UV-light, forming a robust cross-linked polymer network. Using this approach, we solve the problem of the PIB softness and enhance the protective properties of the matrix. To test the encapsulation ability of cross-linked PIB-MA we used CZIS QDs, for which a special procedure for the modification of their surface was developed to uniformly disperse embedded QDs in PIB-based matrices. The mixture of CZIS QDs and PIB-MA may be considered as a colloidal solution that can be rapidly transformed into the transparent solid bulk composite with complete preservation of the optical properties of the CZIS QDs after encapsulation. The cross-linked composites obtained have excellent photo- and chemical stability of the embedded QDs in comparison to the composites with poly(lauryl methacrylate) (PLMA). Our results show that cross-linked PIB is a promising material for fabrication of robust, durable and stable transparent composites which may be used as color conversion layers in displays or luminescent solar concentrators.
:
1, v/v) mixture with subsequent centrifugation. The precipitate was dissolved in 5 mL of chloroform and precipitated by acetonitrile followed by centrifugation. The last procedure was repeated thrice and then supernatant was discarded and precipitate was dispersed in 3.5 mL of toluene.
For the treatment of the CZIS QDs with the mixture of 1-pentanethiol and DDT we employed the same procedure as described above, but 300 μL of 0.045 M solution of 1-pentanethiol and 300 μL of 0.045 M solution of DDT in toluene were used instead of PIB-SH.
The obtained oligomeric precursors PIB-MA with different molecular weights of Mn = 4200 and 5600 g mol−1 were used for fabrication of cross-linked QDs-in-polymer composites. In addition to the synthesis of appropriate QDs and PIB-MA, the procedure of the composite preparation included three main steps, which are schematically shown in Fig. 1b. First, the surface modification of the as-synthesized CZIS QDs was performed through the ligand exchange to achieve high compatibility between the QDs and PIB-MA. For this procedure we synthesized ((2-mercaptoethyl)thio)PIB (PIB-SH) with a molecular weight of 1000 g mol−1, which played a role of a specially designed oligomeric ligand containing thiol anchor group and PIB chain (see Fig. SI5†). As previously reported, the nanocrystals capped by the ligand with hydrocarbon chains with the same chemical structure as the polymer matrix form homogeneous composites.27,51 On the other hand, thiols are suitable capping agents for most semiconductor nanoparticles due to a strong affinity of the –SH group to metal atoms on the nanocrystal surface. Then, modified QDs were dissolved in a toluene solution of PIB-MA and deposited on the glass substrate using an ultrasonic spray-coater. The parameters of the spray-coater were adjusted to realize efficient toluene evaporation during the film deposition. In the final stage, mixture of QDs and PIB-MA on the glass substrate was exposed to UV-light in an inert atmosphere resulting in cross-linking of PIB-MA through radical polymerization of methacrylate end groups (see Fig. 1c) and in the formation of a solid polymer network with embedded QDs. Thereafter we tested photo- and chemical stability of the composites of CZIS QDs with the obtained cross-linked polymers based on PIB-MA with two different molecular weights, comparing them with the other polymers such as SIBS and PLMA.
To test PIB-MA as a host material for fabrication of QDs-in-polymer composites we synthesized CZIS QDs using the modified protocol described in ref. 48. This protocol includes a multi-step approach in which In-rich CIS QDs are synthesized first in the presence of DDT and then are treated with a large excess of Zn-precursor at high temperature to obtain CZIS quaternary nanocrystals with gradient core/shell structure. Thus synthesized CZIS QDs with the size of approx. 2.6 nm (see Fig. SI6†) demonstrated typical optical properties of I–III–VI semiconductor nanocrystals,52 such as absorption without a distinct excitonic feature, broad PL spectrum and large Stokes shift. They had relatively high PLQY of 52% with the PL maximum at 617 nm (Fig. 2a). These QDs are an excellent candidate for testing host polymer materials for a number of reasons. First of all, the I–III–VI group-based QDs along with InP QDs are the most promising Cd- and Pb-free materials for fabrication of solid-state optoelectronic devices with PL in the visible region.5,53,54 Second, a gradient core/shell architecture of the synthesized CZIS QDs allows conducting their purification and surface modification without changing their optical properties. As has been shown, the photostability of CIS QDs can be enhanced through increasing ZnS shell thickness.55 Nevertheless, since our main goal was to investigate the encapsulation properties of the cross-linked PIB in comparison with other polymers, we deliberately produced CZIS QDs with a relatively thin shell to observe changes in their optical properties on a short timescale.
The surface modification of CZIS QDs is necessary to provide compatibility with PIB-MA ensuring their homogeneous dispersion. Even though as-synthesized hydrophobic CZIS QDs can easily be mixed with solutions of PIB-MA in toluene, subsequent evaporation of the solvent leads to imminent aggregation of nanocrystals resulting in a turbid composite. Thus, to improve compatibility between PIB-MA and CZIS QDs, as-synthesized nanoparticles underwent the surface modification through the ligand exchange. The approach that we used for the synthesis of CZIS QDs, like most known recipes,56 involves the addition of an excess of DDT to adjust the relative reactivity of copper and indium precursors that leads to the formation of DDT-capped CZIS QDs. Since thiols were found to have a high affinity to metal atoms on the nanocrystal surface, it is particularly challenging to replace them with other ligands such as carboxylates or amines.52 At the same time, partial exchange of initial thiol for the desired thiol is possible despite low lability of the outgoing ligand. Thus, Lefrançois and co-authors have shown that treatment of DDT-capped CuInS2 QDs with 1,2-ethylhexanethiol in chloroform at room temperature resulted in the replacement of approx. 70% of DDT with 1,2-ethylhexanethiol.57
To facilitate the replacement of DDT with PIB-SH, the ligand exchange was performed in the presence of trioctylamine, since the addition of a base accelerates deprotonation of thiol groups forming thiolate anions.58,59 After treatment of CZIS QDs with PIB-SH and thorough purification of the modified QDs they formed a homogeneous dispersion in PIB-MA without any apparent aggregation or phase separation that evidences a presence of PIB chains on the QDs surface. Additional evidence provided results of the FTIR spectroscopy presented in Fig. 2b and SI7.† To remove the unbound ligands, the QDs were subjected to six times precipitation using chloroform and acetonitrile as a solvent and an antisolvent, respectively. In the FTIR spectrum of modified CZIS QDs the characteristic doublet at 1388 and 1366 cm−1 appeared clearly indicating PIB-SH attached to the QDs surface. This doublet is a result of the coupling between the symmetric bending modes of the two methyl groups in R–C(CH3)2–R moiety.60 In addition to FTIR analysis, the 1H NMR spectrum of extensively purified CZIS QDs unambiguously demonstrates PIB-SH resonances after the ligand exchange (see Fig. SI8†). As one can see in Fig. 2a, after the treatment with PIB-SH there were no changes in spectra revealing complete preservation of optical properties of the initial QDs. In addition, there was no remarkable change in PLQY (52% before and 54% after the treatment).
As-synthesized CZIS QDs with DDT molecules on the surface can be easily embedded in PLMA matrix forming transparent composite due to a good compatibility between lauryl-chains of PLMA and DDT. Nevertheless, for producing QDs-in-PLMA composite the QDs were modified with a mixture of 1-pentanethiol and DDT in the presence of trioctylamine using the same protocol as for the treatment of the QDs with PIB-SH. We assumed that the presence of alkylthiols with different chain lengths on the QDs surface may lead to the formation of a less dense ligand shell resulting in more efficient interpenetration of the lauryl chains of PLMA and the hydrocarbon surface ligands. In addition, since QDs-in-PLMA composite was used as a reference sample for testing encapsulation properties of cross-linked PIB-MA matrix, it was particularly important that QDs in the case of all composites were prepared under the same conditions including purification and post-synthetic treatment steps. As expected, after the treatment of CZIS QDs with a mixture of alkylthiols we did not observe any changes in their PL and absorption spectra (see Fig. 2b), PLQY values (52%), and FTIR-spectra (see Fig. SI7†).
After the ligand exchange and the thorough purification, CZIS QDs with tethered PIB-SH were dispersed in the solution of PIB-MA in toluene. The obtained solutions were sprayed on glass substrates using an ultrasonic spray-coater. Since PIB-MA oligomers (both Mn = 4200 and 5600 g mol−1) are viscous liquids at room temperature, the mixture of PIB-SH-capped QDs with PIB-MA on the substrate after toluene evaporation can be considered as a colloidal solution. The resulting “liquid” films were then converted into solid cross-linked polymer films (CL-PIB4K and CL-PIB5K for cross-linked PIB-MA with Mn 4200 and 5600 g mol−1, respectively) by exposing the samples to the UV-light in the nitrogen filled glovebox. After the polymerization we registered disappearance of the double bond of acrylate group in FTIR-spectrum of QDs-in-PIB-MA film (see Fig. SI9†). The cross-linked QDs-in-polymer composites obtained were found to be resistant to a prolonged soaking in chloroform for at least one month (see Fig. SI10†), which evidences the formation of robust cross-linked polymer network with embedded QDs. Moreover, we observed no traces of QDs which could be extracted from the composite into the solvent.
As mentioned above, to test the photostability of CZIS QDs in cross-linked PIB-MA matrices, we prepared composites of the same QDs with two different polymers. The first reference sample was the composite of PIB-SH-capped CZIS QDs in SIBS (Mn = 30
000 g mol−1 and Mw/Mn = 1.7 (Mn of PIB block = 21
000 g mol−1 and Mw/Mn = 1.2)). As expected, we observed an excellent compatibility between PIB-SH-modified QDs and SIBS. The second reference sample was the composite of pentane/dodecane thiol-treated CZIS QDs in PLMA (Mn = 236
000 g mol−1 and Mw/Mn = 2.2). PLMA is a widely used polymer for fabrication of transparent composites with hydrophobic QDs due to interaction of lauryl-groups of the polymer with alkyl chains of the QDs ligands.61 To correctly compare different composites we used the same conditions for their preparation, including the parameters of film deposition. All obtained composites were transparent films without phase separation, retaining bright PL under the UV-light excitation (see Fig. 3a).
In Fig. 3b the absorption and PL spectra of composites of CZIS QDs with various polymers are displayed. Comparing the spectra one can see that they are practically not altered after incorporating the QDs in solid films, which reveals perfect compatibility between the particles and the matrices achieved by means of the surface engineering. The absorption spectra show no scattering that is proof of the absence of large QD aggregates in all the composites studied. Although we assume the absence of large QD aggregates following from the results of optical spectroscopy, we cannot exclude the formation of small clusters containing a few particles in the film. This clustering typically results in PL quenching due to efficient energy/charge transfer between adjacent QDs observed in 3D networks.62,63 Our results, however, show that the whole incorporation process of CZIS QDs into CL-PIB4K led to only a slight decrease of PLQY from 52% to 49%, which is another indirect evidence of a homogeneous distribution of the particles in the matrix without formation of aggregates. Based on these observations we may conclude that fast cross-linking of PIB-MA leads to the formation of transparent solid films with a uniform dispersion of QDs. According to our estimations (details are provided in the ESI†), the cross-linked CL-PIB4K matrix has voids of size comparable to the size of a PIB-SH-capped QD, which results in perfect accommodation of the particles in the polymer. This is achieved owing to a strong interaction between the PIB-capped QDs and the matrix preventing phase separation. Furthermore, as shown previously, the cross-linking of the polymer reduces aggregation of QDs during the matrix formation due to kinetically entrapping the QDs between cross-linking polymer chains.64 In this way the polymer network surrounds nanocrystals and prevents their aggregation. Larger cell size in the cross-linked CL-PIB5K might be responsible for a slight decrease of the PLQY of the composite to 42% due to formation of small aggregates including several nanoparticles. At the same time, in the case of PLMA, we observed a more pronounced PL quenching (PLQY of 35%), because the linear polymer has no possibility of efficient mechanical trapping of QDs that leads to the formation of small aggregates in between polymer chains. This aggregation is most probably caused by still imperfect compatibility between the ligand shell and the polymer. The high value of the PLQY of QDs-in-SIBS composite (48%) comparable with that of CL-PIB4K-based composite is related to excellent compatibility of the polymer with PIB-SH functionalized QDs. In this case, the van der Waals forces between oligomeric PIB-chains grafted on the QDs surface and PIB units of SIBS are much stronger than in the case of QDs-in-PLMA composite, resulting in a decreased mobility of QDs, which prevents their aggregation. In addition to this, the presence of a bulky ligand more efficiently protects the QDs surface from interaction with oxygen and moisture due to steric hindrances leading to the PLQY increase.65
To test the encapsulation properties of cross-linked PIB-MA matrices in comparison with other polymer materials, we have investigated the photostability, including measurements in air and under vacuum to explore the influence of the gas permeability and chemical stability of the matrices. To conduct a reliable test of the sample photodegradation, we made a specially designed setup where the samples were excited at very high intensities using a helium cadmium laser. This provided an accelerated aging environment where the decaying PL output of the sample could be measured over time to ensure a clear comparison between the degradation rates of different samples. Samples could be measured in air or under high vacuum (∼10−6 mbar) to observe the role of atmosphere in the degradation.
Fig. 4 displays change of integrated PL signal of the composites of CZIS QDs in various polymers as a function of time under high intensity photoexcitation in vacuum and in air. As one can see, CZIS QDs in PIB-based matrices demonstrate significantly enhanced photostability in comparison with QDs embedded in PLMA. Among PIB-based matrices, CL-PIB4K exhibited the best photostability. We attribute this to the star-shaped PIB-MA with smaller molecular weight having smaller arms and therefore forming a denser cross-linked polymer network. The higher cross-linking density decreases permeability to gas and moisture and so improves the stability of the composite. With increasing molecular weight of PIB-MA the gas permeability of the cross-linked matrix increases until it becomes comparable to the linear polymer. This assumption can explain the similar behavior of QDs-in-CL-PIB5K and -SIBS upon testing their photostability in the air. In vacuum we observed different behavior of the PL intensity under laser irradiation. First, as one can see from Fig. 4, the PL intensity increased for all samples during the first minutes of the irradiation. We assume that this effect can be related to accelerated desorption of water, oxygen, and other low molecular products from the QDs surface under high vacuum and laser treatment. The test of photostability in vacuum allows us to estimate the influence of chemical resistance of the matrix on the degradation of the PL signal of CZIS QDs. As a first approximation, we associate the chemical stability of the matrix with the number of methacrylate groups per unit volume of the polymer. It is known that photodegradation of poly(alkyl methacrylates) results in the photolysis of ester groups accompanied by the formation of free radicals66,67 which can damage QDs leading to PL quenching. In addition, as can be seen from Fig. 4, the photostability of PLMA-based composites in air is much worse than the PIB-based ones. This can be understood in terms of the low air permeability of the PIB matrices protecting the QDs from photo-oxidation.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Normalized PL signal of CZIS QDs-in-polymer composites under air and under vacuum versus irradiation time with 42 mW helium–cadmium laser (442 nm). | ||
An additional test of encapsulating ability of the polymers was soaking of the composites in a concentrated solution of hydrochloric acid, the results of which are displayed in Fig. 5. As in the case of the photostability test, composites of QDs-in-PLMA and -SIBS were assigned as the reference samples. To determine the chemical resistance of the composites, photos of the samples under a UV-lamp were taken during soaking at appropriate time intervals. As can be seen in Fig. 5, PIB-based composites demonstrate excellent resistance of the encapsulated QDs to strong acid in comparison to QDs-in-PLMA composite. Encapsulation properties of polymer matrices are related to their chemical stability and low molecular substance permeability. The results obtained correlate well with the photostability test in air (see Fig. 4), where CL-PIB4K also demonstrated the best result. Thus, the matrices with higher cross-linking density impart better photo- and chemical stability to embedded QDs. Among them, cross-linked PIB-based matrices are one of the best existing options to produce flexible and robust QDs-in-polymer composites resistant to degradation in different media.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Description of the syntheses of SIBS, PLMA, tricumyl chloride and FeCl3·1.4i-PrOH; additional characterization; 1H NMR spectra. TEM image of CZIS QDs; additional FTIR-spectra. See DOI: 10.1039/d0na01012j |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |