Open Access Article
Mohd.
Muddassir
*,
Abdullah
Alarifi
,
Mohd
Afzal
,
Khulud Abdullah
Alshali
,
Naaser A. Y.
Abduh
and
Abeer
Beagan
Catalytic Chemistry Research Chair, Department of Chemistry, College of Science, King Saud University, Riyadh 11451, Saudi Arabia. E-mail: mmohammadarshad@ksu.edu.sa; muddassirchem@gmail.com
First published on 18th November 2020
In this study, Cu2+ perchlorate complexes of 3,5-dimetylpyrazole(dmpy), namely [Cu(dmpy)3(H2O)2](H2O)(ClO4)2 (1), were prepared and characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), infrared (IR) spectroscopy, elemental analysis, mass spectrometry, and ultraviolet visible (UV-Vis) spectroscopy. It was determined that Cu2+ coordinated to the nitrogen atoms of three dmpy molecules as well as to the oxygen atoms of two H2O molecules in a square pyramidal geometry. To balance the charge, two uncoordinated perchlorate anions and one H2O molecule were also present in the lattice. The resulting Cu2+ complex was involved in extensive hydrogen bonding, which stabilized the structure. The fluorescence properties of complex 1 were studied in acetonitrile at room temperature upon the addition of different organic solvents. It was confirmed that the complex exhibited remarkable acetone selectivity via a fluorescence quenching mechanism. At low concentrations, the fluorescence intensities were nearly completely quenched via a turn-off mode. Moreover, complex 1 displayed exceptional selectivity, fast detection time, and high sensitivity for Cd2+ in aqueous solutions via a fluorescence enhancement mechanism (turn-on mode). Hence, the prepared complex showed potential for application in Cd2+ detection. Notably, in an aqueous solution, complex 1 exhibited highly selective fluorescence enhancement effects (turn-on mode) with respect to Cd2+ and was not affected by the interference of other metal ions.
Furthermore, Cd2+ is a toxic heavy metal associated with different adverse effects as well as occupational and environmental concerns.5 Healthy levels of Cd2+ in the blood are <5.0 ng mL−1, with most results in the range of 0.5–2.0 ng mL−1. Acute toxicity is observed when the level of Cd2+ in the blood exceeds 50 ng mL−1, which leads to high blood pressure, anemia, pulmonary fibrosis, prostrate cancer, lung cancer, yellow discoloration of the front teeth near the gum line, and anosmia.6–9 The World Health Organization (WHO) reported that the tolerable weekly intake of Cd2+ is in the range of 0.007–0.5 mg kg−1 of body weight.10 Most of Cd2+ in wastewater originates from oil refining, solid waste incineration, coal and gold mining, fossil fuel combustion, rubber processing, and fertilizer industries. Its presence in water is a major environmental and health problem. Hence, the design and synthesis of new sensors for the efficient, selective, and sensitive detection of acetone and Cd2+ is essential in the fields of chemistry, environmental science, and biology.
Supramolecular coordination complexes are discrete constructs typically obtained by mixing soluble metal and ligand precursors, which spontaneously form metal–ligand bonds, generating a single thermodynamically favored product. Several ligands, such as nitrogen, oxygen, and sulphur-based ones, can stabilize metal complexes. Moreover, due to the electron donating ability of their nitrogen atoms, pyrazole-based ligands have been recently extensively studied. Pyrazole derivatives have been applied in many fields, including the biological and pharmaceutical industries. Based on the photophysical properties of these compounds, they have also been utilized in gas storage, luminescence, catalysis, magnetic materials, and most importantly for the purposes of this study, chemical sensing.11–18 Fluorescence sensing based on luminescent coordination complexes has attracted significant attention. It is characterized by a short response time, low cost, as well as high sensitivity and efficiency. In recent years, different coordination-based fluorescent sensors have been established.19–22 They have been employed to probe small organic molecules and metal ions via fluorescence enhancing or quenching. Nevertheless, the rational design and synthesis of luminescent coordination complexes with exhibiting the desired structure and properties remain challenging. Consideration of factors, such as the reaction time, pH, as well as choice of the auxiliary ligand and metal center, which affect the framework structure and properties of the resulting coordination complexes, is essential.23 Due to their biological significance and structure–activity relationship, numerous studies on the biological and luminescence properties of Cu ions have been conducted. In addition, owing to its presence in many metalloproteins, Cu is ubiquitous in various biological systems. Cu2+-based pyrazole as well as its derivative complexes have been studied for several years because of their remarkable properties both in the solid state15,24–26 and in solution.27,28 The pioneering work by Yang and coworkers demonstrated the great potential of a Cu complex, namely [Cu(tpp)·H2O]2n [Htpp = 1-(4-tetrazol-5″-yl)benzyl-3-(pyraziny-l)pyrazole], in the detection of acetone and Fe3+ ions through fluorescence quenching. The developed complex exhibited high sensitivity and selectivity.29 Moreover, Tripathi's group recently reported a copper terephthalate-based molecular organic framework (MOF). In this case, terephthalic acid was extracted from small pieces of waste soft-drink bottles via alkaline hydrolysis. The complex could be used as a sensor for acetone (detection limit of ∼20 ppm) with high sensitivity and selectivity.30
Nonetheless, the majority of examples involve fluorescence quenching using coordination complexes, while fluorescence enhancement (turn-on) or fluorescence shift is reported less frequently. Compared with the other two methods of fluorescence detection, “turn-on” exhibits higher sensitivity and is simpler. Thus, the development of new luminescent materials, which could be used as turn-on-based chemical sensors, is crucial. To continue our research on luminescent coordination materials, in the present study, we focused on the design and synthesis of a Cu2+-based dual-functional fluorescent sensor for the detection of acetone via fluorescent quenching (turn-off). Additionally, the sensor could be used for the detection of Cd2+ ions via a fluorescence enhancement (turn-on) mode. We report a dmpy-based Cu2+ complex, namely [Cu(dmpy)3(H2O)2](H2O)(ClO4)2 (1), in which the dmpy group is coordinated to the Cu2+ ion in a monodentate fashion through its nitrogen atom. The perchlorate anion acts as a counter ion and participates in specific electrostatic or hydrogen bonding interactions with the neighboring H2O molecules. Furthermore, we determined the molecular structure of 1 with a pentacoordinated Cu center in the crystalline phase by single crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis. The structural evaluation was complemented by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and ultraviolet visible (UV-Vis) spectroscopy, while the thermal stability of the complex was investigated by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).
X-ray crystal structure determination, topological analysis, and details of the fluorescence titrations are described in the supplementary material† (CCDC number: 1905852).
(Z = 2) with a pentacoordinated copper center. The important parameters of complex 1 are summarized in Table 1.
| CCDC No | CCDC 1905852 |
| Chemical formula | C15H28CuN6O2·2(ClO4)·H2O |
| M r | 604.89 |
| Crystal system, space group | Triclinic, P![]() |
| Temperature (K) | 150 |
| a, b, c (Å) | 10.1667 (12), 12.3453 (13), 12.6574 (15) |
| α, β, γ (°) | 62.592 (4), 68.790 (5), 68.138 (4) |
| V (Å3) | 1273.5 (3) |
| Z | 2 |
| Radiation type | Mo Kα |
| µ (mm−1) | 1.13 |
| Crystal size (mm) | 0.05 × 0.05 × 0.04 |
| Data collection | |
| Diffractometer | Bruker AXS D8 quest CMOS diffractometer |
| Absorption correction | Multi-scan SADABS 2016/2: L. Krause, R. Herbst-Irmer, G. M. Sheldrick & D. Stalke, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 48 (2015) 3–10 |
| T min, Tmax | 0.710, 0.746 |
| No. of measured, independent, and observed [I > 2s(I)] reflections | 76 237, 7831, 5408 |
| R int | 0.096 |
(sin θ/λ)max (Å−1) |
0.717 |
| Refinement | |
| R[F2 > 2s(F2)], wR(F2), S | 0.050, 0.104, 1.05 |
| No. of reflections | 7831 |
| No. of parameters | 340 |
| No. of restraints | 6 |
| H-atom treatment | H atoms treated by a mixture of independent and constrained refinement |
| Δρmax, Δρmin (e Å−3) | 0.80, −0.50 |
As shown in Fig. 1(a), the Cu2+ anion coordinated to the nitrogen atoms of the three dmpy molecules as well as to the oxygen atoms of two H2O molecules. The coordination polyhedron of the Cu2+ atom was tetragonal pyramidal (CN = 5). To achieve charge balance, two uncoordinated perchlorate anions and one H2O molecule are also present in the lattice and are involved in extensive hydrogen bonding (Fig. 1(b)).
The Cu–N bond distances were in the range of 1.987(2)–1.991(2) Å, whereas the Cu–O bond distances were in the range of 1.9784(19)–2.2278(18) Å. These values were consistent with those previously reported for similar Cu2+ complexes (Table 2).27,28 Surprisingly, there was a difference in the bond lengths of the coordinated H2O molecules, which was attributed to hydrogen bonding. All bond angles were in the range of 86.83(8)–170.70(8)°. Notably, all bond lengths and angles were in agreement with those previously established for similar complexes.23,24,31,32 The prepared molecule exhibited extensive hydrogen bonding between the bonded and lattice H2O molecules, bonded dmpy molecules, and non-bonded perchlorate anions. Specifically, two of the dmpy molecules displayed hydrogen bonding to two perchlorate anions, while the third dmpy (N1) molecule was not involved in any hydrogen bonding interactions. The oxygen atoms of both perchlorates (i.e., O5 and O8) showed intermolecular N–H⋯O interactions with the hydrogen atoms of the bonded dmpy molecule (2.897(3)–2.967(3) Å). Both of the coordinated H2O molecules (i.e., O1 and O2) exhibited hydrogen bonding interactions with the lattice H2O molecule (i.e., O3) as well as with two perchlorate anions (i.e., O5, O9, and O8) in the range of 2.725(3)–3.019(3).
| N1–Cu1 | 1.987 (2) | N3–Cu1 | 1.991 (2) |
| N5–Cu1 | 1.990 (2) | O2–Cu1 | 2.2278 (18) |
| O1–Cu1 | 1.9784 (19) | ||
| C2–N1–Cu1 | 128.35 (17) | N2–N1–Cu1 | 125.62 (16) |
| C7–N3–Cu1 | 131.08 (17) | N4–N3–Cu1 | 123.53 (15) |
| C12–N5–Cu1 | 134.20 (18) | N6–N5–Cu1 | 120.18 (15) |
| Cu1–O1–H1D | 120 (2) | Cu1–O1–H1E | 121 (2) |
| Cu1–O2–H2A | 125 (2) | Cu1–O2–H2B | 115 (2) |
| O1–Cu1–N1 | 86.83 (8) | O1–Cu1–N5 | 88.65 (8) |
| N1–Cu1–N5 | 170.70 (8) | O1–Cu1–N3 | 169.34 (9) |
| N1–Cu1–N3 | 91.93 (8) | N5–Cu1–N3 | 91.01 (8) |
| O1–Cu1–O2 | 92.95 (8) | N1–Cu1–O2 | 91.30 (8) |
| N5–Cu1–O2 | 97.05 (8) | N3–Cu1–O2 | 97.66 (8) |
The second coordinated H2O molecule showed weak hydrogen bonding interactions with the neighboring perchlorate anions. As a result, the perchlorate anions weakly coordinated to Cu2+ (2.2278 (18) Å). The two perchlorate anions and the lattice H2O molecule exhibit strong intramolecular adhesive forces and several of the oxygen atoms are involved in hydrogen bonding. Hence, the inter- and intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the complex is extensive. All copper atoms, centers of mass of the organic ligands, perchlorate anions, and water molecules are nodes of the underlying net in the standard representation of the valence-bonded structures. The underlying 1,5-c net of the 1,5M6-1 topological type is shown in Fig. 1(c).
The standard description of a hydrogen-bonded crystal typically involves a simplification procedure, i.e., representation of the molecular network in terms of a graph theory approach, taking into account hydrogen bonds between molecules. The simplification procedure usually consists of representing the molecule by its center of mass, retaining the connectivity of the molecule with its neighbors. All intermolecular contacts between a given pair of molecules are transformed to the same edge between the molecular centers of mass in the simplified net. Hence, such a description characterizes the way the molecules are hydrogen-bonded in the crystal. In this work, the standard representation of the structure resulted in the 1D underlying net of a new topological type (Fig. 1(d)). Furthermore, a description of the molecular packing can be obtained by taking into account all intermolecular contacts during the simplification procedure. The conducted calculations revealed that the 3D underlying 5,9,9,27-c net of such a package corresponded to a new topology with a point symbol for the following net: {318·418}{319·417}{38·42}{381·4176·590·64} (Fig. 1(e), left). The package predominantly included large complexes; therefore, molecules of H2O and ClO4− anions were removed prior to simplification. The obtained 3D underlying 12-c net was of a “bcu-x/14-conn; Im
m > P21/c (1/2a + 1/2b + 1/2c, 2a − 2b, −c; 1/2, 0, 1/2); bond sets: 1,2,4,5,7,8,9:bcu-x” topological type (Fig. 1(e), right).
Hence, the intramolecular hydrogen bonding evidently stabilized the molecule. All data, expressed as D⋯A contacts, are summarized in Table 3.
| a Symmetry codes: (i) −x + 1, −y, −z + 1; (ii) −x, −y, −z + 1; (iii) x − 1, y, z. | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| D–H⋯A | D–H | H⋯A | D⋯A | D–H⋯A |
| N2–H2⋯O2 | 0.88 | 2.56 | 3.050 (3) | 115.7 |
| N2–H2⋯O5 | 0.88 | 2.47 | 3.141 (3) | 133.0 |
| N2–H2⋯O8i | 0.88 | 2.34 | 3.071 (3) | 140.5 |
| N4–H4⋯O5 | 0.88 | 2.02 | 2.897 (3) | 171.0 |
| N6–H6⋯O8 | 0.88 | 2.13 | 2.967 (3) | 159.7 |
| O1–H1D⋯O3 | 0.844 (18) | 1.896 (19) | 2.731 (3) | 170 (3) |
| O1–H1E⋯O3ii | 0.837 (18) | 1.902 (19) | 2.725 (3) | 167 (3) |
| O2–H2A⋯O8 | 0.798 (18) | 2.14 (2) | 2.912 (3) | 163 (3) |
| O2–H2B⋯O5i | 0.809 (17) | 2.53 (3) | 2.961 (3) | 115 (3) |
| O2–H2B⋯O9i | 0.809 (17) | 2.24 (2) | 3.019 (3) | 161 (3) |
| O3–H3A⋯O4iii | 0.823 (18) | 2.03 (2) | 2.793 (3) | 154 (3) |
| O3–H3B⋯O10i | 0.831 (18) | 2.07 (2) | 2.882 (3) | 165 (3) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) TGA of complex 1. (b) FTIR spectrum of complex 1. (c) Absorption spectrum of complex 1. (d) Mass spectrum of complex 1. | ||
The splitting observed in this region of the spectrum was attributed to various factors. It is known that the fingerprint region is generally less informative than the lower energy part of the spectrum. The formation of the Cu2+ complex was further confirmed by the existence of medium intensity bands in the region of 413–415 cm−1, which were assigned to ν(Cu–O) and ν(Cu–N).35
The luminescence properties of complex 1 dissolved in acetonitrile were studied at room temperature. It was found that 1 exhibited an intense emission band at λem = 650 nm (λex = 267 nm). The formation of supramolecular interactions can sometimes increase the rigidity of a molecule and enhance the intra- or intermolecular interactions between ligands, which can be favorable for energy transfer.41 The fluorescence sensing experiments were performed by dissolving complex 1 in acetonitrile and subsequently adding other organic solvents, such as chloroform, toluene, ethylbenzene, carbon tetrachloride (CCl4), benzene, dichloromethane (DCM), dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), dimethylformamide (DMF), benzyl alcohol, iso-butanol, methanol, iso-propanol, ethanol, and acetone. As illustrated in Fig. 3(a), only the addition of acetone effectively quenched the fluorescence emissions of 1. Almost complete quenching (i.e., a 95% decrease in the emission intensities of 1) was observed upon the addition of acetone. In contrast, no decrease in the emission intensities was observed after addition of similar volumes of other solvents. While some quenching of the emission intensity of complex 1 was noted following the addition of alcoholic solvents, acetone exhibited the most evident effects.
It was also found that the quenching efficiency of acetone with respect to complex 1 was not affected by the existence of other organic molecules, demonstrating high selectivity (Fig. 3(b)).
The results revealed that complex 1 could selectively sense the acetone molecules and exhibited a relatively low acetone detection limit compared with other previously reported transition metal-based sensors. Importantly, unlike in the case of lanthanide-based complexes, 1 could be used for acetone sensing without activation.37,38 To examine the sensitivity of complex 1 for sensing acetone in more detail, the quenching efficiencies of 1 dissolved in acetonitrile were investigated at increasing amounts of acetone. As shown in Fig. 3(c), the fluorescent quenching efficiency rapidly increased at low concentrations of acetone. When the acetone concentration increased from 5.0 × 10−6 to 8.0 × 10−5 M, the fluorescence intensity was quenched by nearly 95%. The value of the association constant was determined to establish the strength of the binding between complex 1 and acetone at an increasing concentration of the solvent. The quantitative analysis was conducted using the Stern–Volmer (S–V) equation. The S–V plots exhibited straight lines at different acetone concentrations, demonstrating good linearity at low concentrations (ESI, Fig S1(a)†). In addition, the binding constant was calculated at 1.02 × 103 M−1 (R2 =0.9973), which is significantly greater than the values for previously reported fluorescent acetone sensors.44
The high value of the association constant demonstrated the remarkable potential of 1 for the detection of trace amounts of acetone. Furthermore, as shown in Fig. S1(b),† the corresponding detection limit obtained from the 3δ/slope 42 (δ: standard error) reached 1.78 × 10−5 M (R2 = 0.9856), which was lower than those of previously reported acetone sensors.45
To determine whether the fluorescence quenching occurred by complex 1 and not by dmpy, we conducted a control experiment involving addition of increasing amounts of acetone to a homogeneous solution of the dmpy in acetonitrile. As demonstrated in Fig. S2(b),† the successive addition of acetone did not cause any fluorescence quenching, indicating that quenching was specific to the structure of complex 1.
Furthermore, the low detection limit suggested that complex 1 exhibited highly sensitive acetone sensing abilities. Hence, 1 is proposed as a potential candidate for the selective sensing of acetone. The results of our study are consistent with the outcomes of previous works on acetone sensing, e.g., those reported by Zhang and coworkers.46 In addition, it was speculated that the mechanism of the fluorescent quenching of 1 during the detection of acetone could involve an inner filter effect (IFE) between 1 and the acetone molecules.47,48 It is noteworthy that the absorption spectrum of acetone (∼270 nm) overlapped with the excitation peak of complex 1 (267 nm).49 Upon excitation, competition for absorption of the light source energy occurred between the acetone molecules and 1. Thus, the large overlap between the absorption spectrum of acetone and the excitation spectrum of 1 is a consequence of this competition, which also lead to IFE and fluorescent quenching.46
Moreover, the C
O moiety of acetone could form hydrogen bonding interactions with dmpy. An electron transfer from dmpy to acetone during excitation might lead to luminescence quenching. Additionally, the selective fluorescence quenching effect observed in the presence of acetone could be attributed to the lone pair⋯π interactions between the dmpy moiety of complex 1 and the C
O group of acetone, which formed a stable acetone–Cu2+ adduct.
To establish whether the interactions between the C
O moiety of acetone and the framework of complex 1 resulted in fluorescence quenching, we evaluated the fluorescence behavior of 1 immersed in different ketone solvents. As shown in Fig. 3(d), the solutions of 1 in cyclohexanone, 4-heptanone, and 5-nonanone exhibited the strongest quenching. These results suggested that the fluorescence quenching might be caused by the interactions between the C
O groups and the framework of 1. Thus, it was determined that complex 1 as well as other Cu-based complexes could be considered as potential candidates for selective sensing of different ketone molecules. It is widely known that the physical interactions between the solute and solvent play a vital role in the fluorescence enhancing and quenching effects of small solvent molecules. Although sensing of acetone by 1 was not superior to using d10 metal or lanthanide-based systems, the complex developed herein shows better sensing capabilities than other transition metal-based coordination complexes. Cu-based complexes are typically utilized for the detection of water or anions in different solvents; therefore, application of 1 for the detection of acetone is a new finding.
The high selectivity for Cd2+ was attributed to the suitable coordination geometry and conformation of the nitrogen heterocycle. We also conducted X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis of Cd2+/1 after the fluorescence measurements. The XPS spectrum exhibited a typical peak corresponding to Cd2+ at 405.4 eV as well as a peak attributed to Cu2+ at 933 eV. These results confirmed the existence of Cd2+ ions in the framework of complex 1 (Fig. S4†). Based on the above outcomes, it was speculated that Cd2+ ions might interact with the dmpy ligand through Lewis acid–base interactions, promoting a more efficient energy transfer from the ligand to the Cu2+ ions. This resulted in turn-on luminescence behaviour of 1 and high selectivity and sensitivity toward Cd2+ ions.
Precise detection of specific metal ions in mixed solvent systems is crucial. Thus, we subsequently investigated the selectivity of the prepared complex in the presence of interferences. An aqueous solution of Cd2+ was added into aqueous solutions containing complex 1 and various metal ions, and the changes of the fluorescence intensity were monitored. As shown in Fig. 4(b), clear differences between the emission of Cd2+ and other cations were observed, which indicated that 1 was a promising luminescent probe for the detection of Cd2+ ions. Notably, the experiments showed that the fluorescence detection of 1 was not interfered by the presence of other metal ions, further demonstrating the remarkable selectivity of the complex.
It was determined that complex 1 displayed strong fluorescence, which was measurable even at lower concentrations. It exhibited fluorescence quenching (turn-off) and fluorescence enhancement (turn-on) in the presence of acetone and Cd2+ ions in aqueous environments. Hence, the present study demonstrated that fine-tuning of the structural features in 1 could lead to the development of new efficient materials for various applications.
O bond of acetone and the framework of 1 as well as the interactions between the Cu2+ ion and acetone. We speculated that the mechanism of fluorescence enhancement of Cd2+ ions might involve Lewis acid–base interactions of the metal ions with the dmpy ligand, which promoted a more efficient energy transfer from the ligand to the Cu2+ ions, resulting in turn-on luminescence behaviour of 1. It was established that the complex showed high selectivity and sensitivity toward Cd2+ ions. This article describes a promising approach for the design of multi-functional Cu2+-based sensors for both acetone and Cd2+ ions. The results described herein will be useful for further experiments conducted under more realistic conditions, which would expand the scope of utilization of Cu2+-containing complexes (e.g., DNA binding, DNA cleavage, cancer studies, and catalysis). Further studies will provide new insights into the nature of this important class of metal complexes and enable the design novel multifunctional metallosystems for applications in material science and diagnosis.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 1905852. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d0ra08073j |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |