Dingcheng Liang*a,
Qiang Xiea,
Jinchang Liua,
Fei Xieb,
Deqian Liua and
Chaoran Wana
aSchool of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing), Beijing 100083, PR China. E-mail: liangdc@cumtb.edu.cn
bBeijing Synchrotron Radiation Facility, Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100049, PR China
First published on 10th September 2020
Zhundong coal can significantly reduce the preparation temperature of activated carbon (AC) due to the high contents of alkali and alkaline earth metals (AAEMs) present in it. Moreover, because of its lower operating temperature and the presence of carbon matrix, Zhundong coal can effectively inhibit the release of AAEM during the preparation of AC. For these reasons, the preparation of AC from Zhundong coal is a promising approach for the clean utilization of Zhundong coal. Accordingly, this study was aimed to investigate optimum conditions for the preparation of AC from Zhundong coal. For this purpose, at first, Raman spectroscopy was used to determine the conditions for an optimal carbonization process using a coal sample; then, the evolution of the pore structure of AC under different conditions was examined by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and the N2 adsorption analyser. Furthermore, environmental scanning electron microscopy (ESEM) was performed to analyze the surface morphology of AC. Finally, by dividing the activation process into gas–solid diffusion and activation reactions, a mechanism for the evolution of pore structure during the preparation of AC was proposed. The results showed that the char with an amorphous structure and less graphite-like carbon, which was obtained by heating Zhundong coal from room temperature to 600 °C at 5 °C min−1 under the protection of N2 and then maintaining it at this temperature for 60 min, is suitable for the subsequent activation process. At low temperatures, the diffusion of H2O was dominant in the activation process, and the weak gas–solid reaction resulted in poor development of the pore structure; on the other hand, the CO2 activation reaction mainly occurred on the surface of the char due to the poor diffusion of CO2, and then, the produced pores could improve the diffusion of CO2; this led to significant development of the pore structure. With an increase in temperature, the H2O diffusion reaction was enhanced, and the pore structure of AC was completely developed; however, the diffusion of CO2 reduced with an enhancement in the CO2 activation reaction, leading to the consumption of carbon matrix by CO2 gasification instead of pore formation by the CO2 activation reaction. Therefore, proper utilization of the unique characteristics of H2O and CO2 during pore formation is important to control the activation process.
The preparation of AC may be difficult due to the high volatilization and release of AAEMs from the coal sample, which results in slagging and corrosion of the production equipment. Therefore, a comprehensive investigation on the preparation of AC from Zhundong coal is required. It is confirmed from the literature that temperature is the most important factor affecting the release of AAEMs from the coal surfaces.8 Compared with the high temperature requirement for coal combustion and gasification, the temperature required for the preparation of AC is lower; thus, the amount of the AAEMs released by volatilization is less,9,10 and the harm to the equipment can be easily controlled. Researchers have also found that the carbon matrix shows a significant inhibitory effect on the release of AAEMs from coal.11,12 Therefore, the carbon skeleton present in Zhundong coal can effectively inhibit the volatilization and release of AAEMs during the preparation of AC from Zhundong coal. It can be concluded from these studies that a lower operating temperature and the presence of a carbon matrix can effectively inhibit the release of AAEMs from Zhundong coal during the preparation of AC.
Previously, the traditional production enterprises of AC used to be concentrated in Shanxi and Ningxia provinces of China. However, with the development of coal resources in Xinjiang, the AC industry has gradually started to move to the west of China, and Shenhua Xinjiang Energy Co. Ltd. built the largest AC production unit in the world in 2014. Due to the lack of a complete breakthrough in the regulation technology of the pore structure of AC, coal-based AC has the limitations of high output, few varieties, and low quality, which lead to low-price sales of this type of AC as the base carbon. Therefore, the distribution of pore structure is the most difficult factor in the preparation of AC. Based on this background, this study was aimed at using a Zhundong high-alkali coal sample as a raw material for the preparation of AC. Based on the carbonization control theory reported in a previous study, the coal was carbonized into char with an isotropic, difficult graphitized, and amorphous structure.13 Then, according to the gas–solid diffusion and activation reaction, the evolution of pore structure was comprehensively explored under different conditions during the activation process. Thus, this study provides a theoretical basis for the targeted regulation of the pore structure of coal-based AC.
Proximate analysis (wt%) | Ultimate analysis (wt%) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mad | Ad | Vdaf. | FCdaf. | Cdaf. | Hdaf. | Odaf. (diff.) | Ndaf. | St,d |
a M: moisture; A: ash; V: volatile matter; FC: fixed carbon; ad: air dry basis; d: dry basis; daf.: dry ash-free; diff.: by difference; and t: total. | ||||||||
10.13 | 4.17 | 30.93 | 69.07 | 70.54 | 3.57 | 24.43 | 0.69 | 0.77 |
Ash composition (wt%) | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SiO2 | Al2O3 | Fe2O3 | CaO | MgO | K2O | Na2O | SO3 | TiO2 | BaO |
18.72 | 10.62 | 7.4 | 32.2 | 9.64 | 0.249 | 8.13 | 9.23 | 0.136 | 0.107 |
To determine the effect of temperature on the carbonization process, the carbonization experiments were performed in the temperature range from 450 to 600 °C in 50 °C increments under the following conditions: high-purity nitrogen was used as a carrier gas at a flow rate of 100 mL min−1 and the holding time was 45 min. In addition, the effect of the holding time on the structure of the char was investigated using different holding times, i.e. 30, 45, and 60 min, and the carbonization temperature was set to 600 °C. The corresponding samples were named as follows: temperature-char-holding time, for example, 600-char-45 indicates that the sample derived from Zhundong coal was carbonized at 600 °C at the holding time of 45 min.
The preparation of AC involves a carbonization process and an activation process. The procedure of carbonization is as follows: at first, the coal sample was heated to 600 °C under a N2 atmosphere (100 mL min−1) and held for 60 min. After the end of the holding time, steam (100 mL min−1) and CO2 (100 mL min−1) were separately introduced into the tube furnace. Moreover, the reactor was continuously heated until the target temperature was reached and then held for 2 h. Due to the good reactivity of the Zhundong high-alkali coal, relatively low activation temperatures were used, i.e. 700, 750, 800, 850, and 900 °C. Finally, heating was stopped, and the reactor was naturally cooled under a nitrogen atmosphere. The AC sample was obtained and named according to the following rules: agent-temperature-AC. For example, H2O-700-AC implies that the agent of AC is steam and the activation temperature is 700 °C. Note that the heating rate for both the carbonization and activation processes was 5 °C min−1.
Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS, Xenocs SA, Nano-inXider) refers to the phenomenon of X-ray scattering in a small angular range around the incident beam when X-ray irradiates a sample with electron density fluctuations on the nanometer scale; herein, the SAXS experiments were carried out to analyze the AC samples. The incident X-ray wavelength λ was 0.154 nm, and the detector-to-sample distance was 937.5 mm. The sample data was obtained in 10 min in an all-vacuum environment and was then background corrected and normalized using the standard procedure.
The pore structure parameters of the AC samples were examined using a nitrogen adsorption analyzer (Micromeritics, ASAP 2460). The specific surface area was calculated by the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) method.
Evaluations of the morphologies and surface compositions of the samples were conducted using environmental scanning electron microscopy (ESEM, Thermo Fisher, Quattro C).
Raman spectroscopy is an efficient method for investigating the degree of crystallinity, defects, and disorder in carbon materials.18,19 Thus, it was used to explore the evolution of the structure of the char samples derived from Zhundong coal under different carbonization conditions to determine optimal conditions for achieving a char sample with an amorphous structure and abundant initial pores. It was possible to fully develop the pore structure in the subsequent activation stage. The Raman spectra with the corrected baseline for the raw coal and char samples in the 800–1800 cm−1 range and the ratio of the D band to G band peak areas of different samples are shown in Fig. 1.
In the Raman spectra, the D band represents a disordered structure and the G band confirms the presence of a graphitic structure.20 Therefore, the band area ratio ID/IG is used as a significant parameter to investigate a crystalline structure or graphite-like carbon.21,22 As shown in Fig. 1(b), when the holding time was kept constant and the carbonization temperature was increased, the ratio of ID/IG increased and reached a high point at 600 °C. Thus, in the following experiment, when the carbonization temperature was fixed at 600 °C and the holding time was changed, the ratio of ID/IG was proportional to the holding time. The reason for the abovementioned phenomenon is the formation of polycyclic aromatic units by the condensation of the macromolecular network in the char with an increase in the carbonization temperature. During this process, the chemical bond between the macromolecular compounds is broken, and then, micromolecules are formed. These micromolecules deposited on the surface of the char, which resulted in a large number of defect structures and amorphous structures as well as an increase in the ID/IG ratio. Furthermore, the abovementioned process is prolonged with an increase in the holding time, and the ID/IG ratio becomes higher. According to the abovementioned analysis, the development of pores in the subsequent activation process is significantly dependent on the structural characteristics of the char, and the char sample with an amorphous structure and less graphite-like carbon is suitable for the preparation of AC. Therefore, the optimal carbonization conditions are as follows: Zhundong coal is heated from room temperature to 600 °C at 5 °C min−1 under the protection of N2 and then maintained at this temperature for 60 min.
However, since few initial pores are produced in the char obtained from the carbonization of Zhundong coal, the char is transformed into AC with a developed pore structure through the activation process. Therefore, all kinds of technical methods to adjust the pore structure of AC finally converged in the activation stage. The formation and development of pores in AC can be regulated by controlling the activation temperature, time, and agent. In this way, fine regulation of the pore structures of AC can be realized.
It can be observed from Fig. 2 that whether the activation agent was CO2 or H2O, the LOI of AC increased with an increase in temperature in the presence of both H2O and CO2, and CO2 led to a higher LOI change as compared to H2O. In the case of H2O, the LOI of AC was less than 50%, which meant that the pore structure of this AC was mainly microporous. During the process of CO2 activation, the loss on ignition was more than 50% when the temperature was higher than 750 °C, and these phenomena indicated that the amount of macropores in AC gradually increased with an increase in temperature.13 It can be easily observed that the pore structures of the AC samples prepared by CO2 and H2O activation are quite different. The deep reasons for these phenomena will be revealed in the follow-up study.
The SAXS technique is used to determine the porosity, pore size distribution, and surface area of carbon materials because it is fast and non-invasive and does not require any complex sample preparation.26 For this reason, herein, SAXS was used to explore the evolution of the pore structure of AC under different activation conditions. Fractal is a geometrical concept referring to self-similarity and scale invariance; moreover, fractal dimension can quantitatively reflect the irregularity of the material structure, and SAXS is an ideal tool to measure this parameter of the material.27 The SAXS logarithmic curves of AC under different conditions are shown in Fig. 3. As shown in Fig. 3, there is a significant linear relationship between lnq and ln
I(q), where q and I(q) are the scattering vector and scattering intensity, respectively. The results obtained in previous studies have confirmed that if the I(q)–q logarithmic curve results in a straight line, the pore size distribution follows fractal behavior.28 Thus, it was concluded that there was a distinct fractal structure in these AC samples.
In addition, the slopes of these curves are between −3 and −4, which indicate surface fractal in these samples. Then, the fractal dimension could be calculated by eqn (1), and the results are shown in Fig. 4.
Ds = 6 + α | (1) |
Furthermore, McSAS, a user-friendly open-source Monte Carlo regression package that structures the analysis of the SAXS by scattering contributions,29 was used to calculate the pore size distribution of AC. As shown in Fig. 5, the variation in the pore size distribution of AC under different conditions was obtained by fitting the SAXS data. The analysis of Fig. 5(a)–(c) revealed that the evolution process of the pore structure of the AC sample derived from H2O activation and the number of micropores and macropores in this AC sample increased with an increase in temperature. Fig. 5(d)–(f) show that with an increase in temperature, the number of micropores in the AC sample prepared by CO2 activation increased, whereas that of macropores decreased.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Variation in the pore size distribution of different AC samples under different conditions. (a) H2O-700-AC, (b) H2O-800-AC, (c) H2O-900-AC, (d) CO2-700-AC, (e) CO2-800-AC and (f) CO2-900-AC. |
Since the absolute intensity was not calibrated at the SAXS station, the specific surface area of the AC samples could only be characterized by a nitrogen adsorption–desorption analyzer. The effect of temperature on the surface areas of the AC samples prepared by H2O and CO2 activation is shown in Fig. 6. According to Fig. 6, the surface area of the AC sample prepared by CO2 gradually decreased with an increase in temperature. On the contrary, with an increase in temperature, the surface area of the AC sample obtained via H2O activation first increased and reached the highest point at 850 °C; then, with a further increase in temperature, the specific surface area of this AC sample decreased.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Effect of temperature on the surface areas of the AC samples prepared by H2O and CO2 activation. |
Since the activation process is a complex physicochemical process consisting of gas mass-transfer and heterogeneous gas–solid reactions, the evolution of the pore structure of AC was revealed based on the gas–solid diffusion and activation reactions. As is generally known, the molecular size of H2O is smaller than that of CO2, and the diffusion resistance of H2O is significantly lower than that of CO2.30,31 Moreover, researchers have confirmed that H2O more likely diffuses into the pores of coal char than CO2 during the gasification process.23,32 Thus, during the activation process, the concentration of CO2 on the surface of the char was higher than that of H2O, whereas the situation inside the pores of the char was opposite. By combining these results with the fractal dimension of AC, it could be inferred that the activation of H2O mainly occurred in the pores of the char, whereas activation of CO2 occurred on the surface of the char. As a result, the surface of the AC sample prepared by CO2 activation was rougher than that of the AC sample prepared by H2O activation.
In addition, the results can be well-explained based on the abovementioned inference. Because of the thermal gradient, the temperature of the pores in the char was lower than that of the surface. When the temperature was 700 °C, H2O activation mainly occurred in the pores of the char; however, the activation reaction was weak; therefore, the specific surface area of AC was low. In this case, the reaction rate was the main limiting factor for the pore development of AC. With an increase in temperature, the activation reactions in the pores and surface enhanced; then, the surface of AC became rough and the specific surface area increased. With a further increase in temperature, diffusion became the main limiting factor for the pore development of AC. Before the diffusion of H2O molecules, some H2O molecules were consumed because of the activation reaction, and thus, the H2O activation reaction mainly occurred on the surface of the char. As a result, a dense surface structure was formed due to the rapid reaction rate, and the fractal dimension and specific surface area of the AC sample were relatively low.
The CO2 activation reaction mainly occurred on the surface of AC. With the progress of the reaction and the development of pores on the surface of the char, the diffusion of CO2 became easier, and then, the pore structure of the prepared AC sample was well-developed. With an increase in the activation temperature, the reaction became faster, and the amount of CO2 diffused into the pores reduced; this made the surface of the AC sample rough. As a result, the fractal dimension of the prepared AC sample increased, and the specific surface area decreased; especially, the number of micropores decreased, whereas that of macropores increased. With a further increase in temperature, CO2 was consumed in the activation reaction before its diffusion. Moreover, it was found that the surface of the AC sample prepared at high temperatures was covered with an ash layer during the sampling process. This ash layer hindered the diffusion and activation of CO2; hence, the surface of the prepared AC sample became smooth, and the specific surface area decreased. Furthermore, because a large amount of carbon matrix was consumed by the CO2 activation reaction to produce the ash layer, the loss on ignition of the AC sample greatly increased at high temperatures.
By combining these results with the loss on ignition, it can be concluded that the pore structure of Zhundong coal-based AC will be fully developed by H2O activation at high temperatures or CO2 activation at low and medium temperatures.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Surface morphology of AC samples under different conditions. (a) H2O-700-AC, (b) H2O-850-AC, (c) CO2-700-AC and (d) CO2-900-AC. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Mechanism of the evolution of the pore structure of the AC samples prepared under different conditions. |
As abovementioned, researchers have proposed a hypothesis that the development of pore structure can be regulated to occur in a certain way during the preparation of activated carbon.13,23 In this study, it was proven that pore formation shows distinct characteristics during the H2O and CO2 activation processes. Therefore, proper utilization of the unique characteristics of H2O and CO2 during pore formation is important to control the entire activation process and realize the preparation of AC with a specific pore structure. In addition, the high content of AAEMs in Zhundong coal can significantly reduce the activation temperature; thus, the preparation of high value-added porous carbon material is a promising approach for the clean utilization of Zhundong coal.
According to the carbonization control theory, the char with an amorphous structure and less graphite-like carbon, obtained by heating Zhundong high-alkali coal from room temperature to 600 °C at 5 °C min−1 and then maintaining the acquired product at this temperature for 60 min, is suitable for the subsequent activation process.
Based on the idea of decoupling, the activation process was divided into gas–solid diffusion and activation reactions, and the mechanism of the evolution of the pore structure of AC prepared by the activation of H2O and CO2 at different temperatures was revealed. At low temperatures, the process of H2O activation is dominated by H2O diffusion, and the weak reaction results in a poor development of the pore structure of AC. Then, with an increase in temperature, the activation of H2O is enhanced and the pore structure of AC is fully developed. Due to the poor diffusion of CO2, the CO2 activation reaction mainly occurs on the surface of the char at low temperatures, and then, the pores produced on the surface of the char can improve the diffusion of CO2 such that the pore structure of the AC develops well. With an increase in temperature, the diffusion of CO2 is reduced by the enhancement of CO2 activation; this leads to the consumption of the carbon matrix by CO2 gasification instead of pore formation by the CO2 activation reaction. Thus, proper utilization of the unique characteristics of H2O and CO2 during pore formation is important to regulate the activation process and realize the preparation of AC with a specific pore structure.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |