Open Access Article
Fan
Yang
ab,
Yaru
Cheng
ab,
Yu
Cao
ab,
Haifeng
Dong
*ab,
Huiting
Lu
ab,
Kai
Zhang
ab,
Xiangdan
Meng
ab,
Conghui
Liu
ab and
Xueji
Zhang
*ab
aBeijing Advanced Innovation Center for Materials Genome Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, 30 Xueyuan Road, Beijing 100083, P. R. China. E-mail: hfdong@ustb.edu.cn; zhangxueji@ustb.edu.cn
bBeijing Key Laboratory for Bioengineering and Sensing Technology, Research Center for Bioengineering and Sensing Technology, School of Chemistry & Biological Engineering, University of Science & Technology Beijing, 30 Xueyuan Road, Beijing 100083, P. R. China
First published on 28th November 2018
Mature microRNAs (miRNAs) produced from precursor microRNAs (pre-miRNAs) by the RNase Dicer have showed significant potential for cancer diagnosis and prognosis due to their key regulatory roles in various pathological processes. However, discriminatory detection of low-abundance miRNAs and pre-miRNAs remains a key challenge since the mature sequence is also present in the pre-miRNA forms. Herein, we report a novel cascade reaction to sensitively distinguish miRNAs versus pre-miRNAs in living cells based on two pairs of programmable hairpin oligonucleotide probes with a simple sequence design. The programmable hairpin probes can metastably coexist until the introduction of miRNAs or pre-miRNAs, which can trigger a specific hybridization chain reaction (HCR), respectively, leading to the self-assembly of nicked DNA duplex structures and a remarkable specific fluorescence intensity increase. The system can readily and sensitively assess the miRNA or pre-miRNA abundance in a homogeneous solution. The intracellular miRNA and pre-miRNA expression level assessment in different living cells is realized. Thus, we provide a novel investigation tool for discriminatorily and accurately assessing miRNA and pre-miRNA abundance, which could be useful for the biomedical application of miRNAs.
MiRNAs play pivotal roles in an array of physiological processes.11 Importantly, the aberrant expression of miRNAs is associated with various pathological developments such as cancer and cardiovascular disease.12–15 Thus, miRNAs have received considerable attention as valuable biomarkers and novel therapeutic targets.16,17 Owing to the imperfect matching between miRNAs and their target mRNAs, cellular miRNA-mediated gene suppression appears as a highly orchestrated mode in which one miRNA may regulate hundreds of mRNAs and many miRNAs may regulate one mRNA.18 Meanwhile, miRNAs exist as several distinct isoforms called isomiRs with different seed sequences and lengths, and the concentration of isomiRs and pre-miRNAs changes dynamically during various physiological and pathological processes.19 Thus, characterization of miRNAs and their pre-miRNA expression levels can provide significant clues on their physiological functions.
Nowadays, the most widely used strategy for assessing pre-miRNA and miRNA abundance simultaneously is northern analysis that separates them based on size, but it suffers from limited sensitivity and radioactive agents.20 An altered quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) protocol with unique primers has the potential to distinguish miRNA and pre-miRNA. However, it is time-consuming and cost-ineffective.21,22 Molecular beacon (MB) approaches offer a significant advantage to sense specific miRNA or DNA, and enable us to distinguish the pre-miRNA and miRNA since the MB elicits a signal only in response to the complementary sequence.23 Owing to the fact that the fluorescence intensity is directly correlated with the RNA hybridization event, the “one-to-one” signal manner cannot satisfy the low-abundance miRNA or pre-miRNA analysis. Therefore, the development of assays with high sensitivity and good discrimination ability remains a key challenge.
The hybridization chain reaction (HCR) in which a target triggers the cross-opening of two DNA hairpins to assemble DNA polymeric nanowires.24–27 It preserves the inherent high specific properties of the molecular hairpin, and notably possesses significant signal amplification functions due to the cascading displacement reaction and assembled nicked polymeric duplex structures, leading to great potential for bioanalysis.28–30 Weizmann et al. reported a real-time intracellular miRNA imaging method based on the HCR with programmable oligonucleotide probes generating fluorescence resonance energy transfer upon miRNA-triggered assembly.31 Hyper-branched HCR and nonlinear HCR systems with high signal amplification efficiency have also been explored.32,33 However, the HCR system could not be directly adapted to distinguish the miRNA and pre-miRNA due to the presence of the mature miRNA sequence in its pre-miRNA forms and false positive signals for miRNA detection. The HCR system with rationally programmable hairpin probes for pre-miRNA analysis and discrimination of pre-miRNA and miRNA has never been explored until now.
Herein, we design two pairs of programmable hairpin oligonucleotide probes that specifically self-assemble fluorescent nicked duplex structures responsive to miRNA or pre-miRNA to sensitively distinguish miRNA versus pre-miRNA. The red stem region of pre-miRNA-155 is the miRNA-155 sequence (Fig. 1A), and the large loop (∼15 base) of pre-miRNA-155 was designed as a trigger sequence of pre-miRNA-155 related to HCR detection, which avoided the false positive signal triggered by miRNA-155.34,35 As shown in Fig. 1B, the mutual reaction from the four hairpin probes was kinetically impeded due to the fact that the binding sites were sequestered in either small bulge loops or double-stranded forms. The trigger pre-miRNA-155 hybridized with H1 to expose an originally sequestered toehold (Toe2′) to H2, which induced the fluorescent reporter to be freed up from the quencher and expose Toe1′ to H1, leading to chain growth of assembled DNA and a strong increase in FAM fluorescence intensity. However, the miRNA-155 could only specifically trigger the assembly of H3 and H4 and produce a strong increase in Cy3 fluorescence intensity. Consequently, the specific fluorescence intensity increase can be employed to sensitively distinguish miRNA versus pre-miRNA abundance.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of (A) pre-miRNA-155; (B) imaging of pre-miRNA-155 and miRNA-155 in living cells based on the HCR. | ||
:
1 (Fig. S3†). The catalytic amplification efficacy of our system was compared to a conventional molecular beacon (MB) without amplification (Fig. S4†), where H5 and H6 were the MBs recognizing pre-miRNA-155 and miRNA-155, respectively.
As indicated by time-dependent fluorescence analysis shown in Fig. 3A, both H5 and the mixture containing H1 and H2 exhibited a low fluorescence background signal. The addition of pre-miRNA-155 (20 nM) to the mixture containing H1 (100 nM) and H2 (100 nM) yielded a significant fluorescence increase (red curve), while a slight fluorescence intensity increase was observed when pre-miRNA-155 (20 nM) was added to the H5 aqueous solution (100 nM) (purple curve). The F/F0 value of the HCR system was 9.92 at 4 h, which was 3.29-fold higher than that of the MB strategy with a F/F0 value of 3.01. Both the HCR and MB systems for miRNA analysis exhibited a sharp and fast increase in fluorescence intensity after the addition of the miRNA (Fig. 3B). However, the plateau F/F0 value was 8.60 for the HCR which is 1.83-fold higher than that of MB detection. These results suggested good amplification efficacy of the HCR system for pre-miRNA and miRNA detection, especially for the pre-miRNA analysis.
The capability of distinguishing miRNA and pre-miRNA of the HCR and MB system was then systematically investigated. As shown in Fig. 3C, both of the HCR and MB strategy for pre-miRNA-155 detection displayed a negligible increase (F/F0 value of 1.17 for the HCR and 1.18 for the MB at 4 h) in fluorescence intensity after the addition of miRNA-155, indicating the good discrimination ability of these systems for pre-miRNA detection. As for the miRNA analysis, a similar slight fluorescence increase was observed after the addition of pre-miRNA-155 into the HCR detection system (Fig. 3D, red curve). On the contrary, the pre-miRNA-155 induced a significant fluorescence increase (Fig. 3D, purple curve) (F/F0 value of 1.25 for the HCR and 4.59 for the MB at 4 h) for the MB-based miRNA detection system due to a similar sequence present in its pre-miRNA form. This demonstrated the good discrimination ability of the HCR system for miRNA and pre-miRNA detection as a result of the inherent specific ability of hairpin probes and the rational sequence design that avoided the influence of a similar sequence present in both miRNA and pre-miRNA on the HCR processes.
The HCR system in response to pre-miRNA-155 and miRNA-155 with different concentrations in vitro was also explored by measuring the FAM and Cy3 fluorescence intensity after 4 h incubation as shown in Fig. S5.† The fluorescence intensity increased with the concentration increase of pre-miRNA-155 (Fig. S5A†) and miRNA-155 (Fig. S5B†). It showed a good linear relationship between F/F0 and the logarithm of pre-miRNA-155 (Fig. S5A,† inset)/miRNA-155(Fig. S5B,† inset) concentration ranging from 1 nM to 100 nM and 1 nM to 100 nM, respectively. The limit of detection (LOD) was calculated to be 820 pM/680 pM by using three times the standard deviation of the control, while the LOD of MB-based detection was 19.75 nM and 8.16 nM, indicating the superior sensitivity of the proposed system (Fig. S5C and D†).
Furthermore, the base-mismatch discrimination ability of the proposed strategy was investigated. The single-base-mismatched strand (mis-1), three-base-mismatched strand (mis-3) and five-base-mismatched strand (mis-5) presented a slight fluorescence intensity increase compared to the control (Fig. S6†). In contrast, the complementary pre-miRNA-155 target showed a much higher fluorescence intensity increase in comparison with other groups (Fig. S6A†). Similar results were observed for the miRNA-155 detection (Fig. S6B†). The F/F0 value of CM pre-miRNA-155 was about 3.93-fold and 7.00-fold higher than those of mis-1 and mis-3 strands (Fig. S6C†), respectively. For the miRNA analysis, the CM miRNA-155 presented a 6.07-fold and 9.18-fold higher F/F0 value than mis-1 and mis-3 strands, respectively (Fig. S6D†), which revealed the good base discrimination ability and potential of the proposed HCR for isomiR detection.
Two cancer cell lines (A549 and MCF-7) and a human embryonic lung fibroblast (MRC-5) line were employed to evaluate the intracellular pre-miRNA/miRNA detection of the HCR system. As a control, MB-based detection was also performed under the same conditions. All three cell lines showed a strong green fluorescence signal related to pre-miRNA-155, while strong red fluorescence derived from miRNA-155 recognition was only observed in the A549 and MCF-7 tumor cells and weakly appeared in the MRC-5 cell (Fig. 4A and C). This suggested that although all the cell lines possessed a similar abundance of pre-miRNA-155, the abundance of miRNA was different. Aberrant high expression levels of miRNA-155 were observed for both A549 and MCF-7 cancer cells, which could act as a potential biomarker. All the fluorescence intensities from the MB system were much weaker compared to the counterparts detected using HCR strategies, which further indicated the higher sensitivity of the HCR system (Fig. 4B and D). These results suggested that the HCR strategy could efficiently distinguish the pre-miRNA-155 and miRNA-155 abundance for all three cells, while the MB system could not satisfy the discrimination of intracellular miRNA-155 and pre-miRNA-155.
The abundance change of oncogenic miRNA-155 in MCF-7 cells was further investigated using miRNA-155 mimics and inhibitors as regulators. As shown in Fig. S9A and B,† the FAM fluorescence intensity related to pre-miRNA-155 showed a negligible change for the MCF-7 cells treated with miRNA-155 inhibitors or mimics compared to the control. However, the Cy3 fluorescence intensity associated with miRNA-155 showed a significant increase and decrease after treatment with miRNA-155 mimics and miRNA-155 inhibitors, respectively (Fig. S9A and C†). These results suggested the good feasibility of the HCR system to monitor the expression change of intracellular miRNA, even for low-abundance nucleic acids. To further validate its feasibility, the HCR system was also employed for analyzing miRNA let-7a and its pre-miRNA detection. It demonstrated good feasibility for sensitively discriminating miRNA let-7a from pre-miRNA let-7a in vitro (Fig. S10†). Furthermore, the CLSM imaging analysis showed that the strong green fluorescence signal related to pre-miRNA let-7a was observed in both MCF-7 and NHDF cells, while the strong red fluorescence signal associated with miRNA let-7a only was observed in NHDF cells (Fig S11A†). This suggested that the miRNA let-7a was at a high expression level in normal cells and at a low expression level in cancer cells (Fig. S11B†), which was different from the expression pattern of miRNA-155. These results suggested that the HCR system was readily extended to other miRNA detections with different expression levels.
Furthermore, flow cytometry analysis was employed to characterize the FAM and Cy3 fluorescence intensity in A549 cells (Fig. 5), which was consistent with the results of CLSM measurements. The HCR strategy presented much stronger fluorescence signals than the MB-based system, indicating the high sensitivity of the HCR system. The concentrations of pre-miRNA-155 and miRNA-155 in these different cell lysate samples were validated using the qRT-PCR with unique primers, which demonstrated a similar pre-miRNA-155 abundance among all three cells, and a lower abundance of miRNA in MRC-5 than in A549 and MCF-7 cells (Fig S12†), in agreement with the HCR measurements. These results further confirmed the high sensitivity and good discrimination ability of the proposed HCR system for pre-miRNA/miRNA detection.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Flow cytometric assay of A549 cells incubated with HCR probes or MB probes in response to (A) pre-miRNA-155 and (B) miRNA-155, respectively. | ||
:
1), 2 mL 5× TAE buffer (pH 8.3), 90 μL 10% ammonium persulfate (APS), 10 μL N,N,N′,N′-tetramethylethylenediamine (TEMED) and 6.2 mL deionized water were mixed. The gel was polymerized for 5 h at room temperature. Then, 5 μL of each sample was mixed with 1 μL of 6× loading buffer and added to the native polyacrylamide gel. The PAGE was performed in baths of ice at 100 V for about 90 min. After staining in 2× Gel-Red™ Nucleic Acid Gel Stain solution (Biotium, USA) for 30 min, the gel was imaged using an Alliance Ld2 (Uvitec, Cambridge, U.K.).
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8sc03305f |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |