Open Access Article
Ruili Zhang,
Debao Liu and
Ping Yang
*
School of Material Science and Engineering, University of Jinan, Jinan, 250022, P. R. China. E-mail: mse_yangp@ujn.edu.cn
First published on 16th July 2019
α-Fe2O3 with various morphologies including spindle, rod, tube, disk, and ring were synthesized through controlling the H2PO4− etching process. The concentrations of H2PO4− plays an important role in controlling the morphology change of the samples. Selected adsorption of H2PO4− ions resulted in anisotropic growth. In addition, the etching of H2PO4− occurred in the center of rods which resulted in tubal α-Fe2O3. Nanodiscs were created once the etching process occurred on the wall of the tube. The electrochemical test shows that disklike samples revealed excellent specific capacitance, rate capacity and cycling stability because of relative higher surface area and pore structure. For the CO catalytic oxidation properties, spindle samples exhibited super catalytic activity.
Hematite α-Fe2O3, as an n-type semiconductor (Eg = 2.1 eV), is the most stable structure iron oxide at ambient conditions.6 Benefiting from some merits, such as low cost, environmentally friendly, nontoxic, corrosion resistant and easily obtainable, the hematite has been widely used in the fields of catalysts, energy conversion and sensors.7–9 So far, the α-Fe2O3 with different morphologies including sphere, rod, wire, spindle, nut, rice and mesoporous structure have already been fabricated by a variety of processes.10–16 For example, hollow structures are obtained by controlled deposition of the precursors onto diverse removable templates via chemical etching or thermal decomposition. Namely, the synthesis methods generally contain sol–gel processing, micro-emulsion, chemical precipitation and hydrothermal method.17–20 Among these methods, a hydrothermal method offers effective control over the nucleation and growth by controlling the experimental parameters. Moreover, the obtained products usually present good dispersion, uniformity without agglomeration and high purity.21 In fact, the simple synthesis strategy without templates for hollow α-Fe2O3 hierarchical structures is still remains a technological challenge in spite of extensive research efforts.
In this paper, H2PO4− ions driven etching process was developed to fabricate α-Fe2O3 nanostructures with a series of morphologies including spindle, tube, disk and ring without using templates. The amount of H2PO4− ions controlled the etching process which determined the morphology of resulting samples. The morphologies and structures of resulting samples were fully investigated and the oriented dissolution and recrystallization formation mechanism was proposed by changing preparation parameters. In addition, the supercapacitor and catalytic measurements were performed towards electrochemical performance and CO catalytic oxidation properties.
| Sample | H2PO4− (mM) | Molar ratiob | Time (h) | Morphology |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| a The concentration of Fe3+ was 15 mM for all samples.b The molar ratio of Fe3+/H2PO4−. | ||||
| S1 | N/A | N/A | 20 | Quasi-sphere |
| S2 | 0.21 | 71 | 20 | Spindle |
| S3 | 0.43 | 35 | 20 | Rod |
| S4 | 0.64 | 23 | 20 | Tube |
| S5 | 1 | 15 | 20 | Disk |
| S6 | 2.5 | 6 | 20 | Ring |
| S7 | 3 | 5 | 3 | Disk |
| S8 | 3 | 5 | 6 | Hole in center |
| S9 | 3 | 5 | 12 | Ring |
| S10 | 3 | 5 | 20 | Ring |
:
15
:
5 and stirred for 1 h to form homogeneous slurry. The slurry was subsequently brush-coated on a nickel foam and dried at 70 °C overnight to evaporate the solvent. An individual electrode contained active material of about 3.0 mg and a working electrode was obtained by pressing an active material-coated Ni foam at 10 MPa. A three-electrode electrochemical system was used to measure the electrochemical behavior of the samples, where the active material, Pt foil and Hg/HgO electrode were employed as working electrode, counter electrode and reference electrode, respectively. The cyclic voltammetry (CV) and galvanostatic charge–discharge (GCD) measurements were performed using an electrochemical work station (CHI 660E, Chenhua, Shanghai) in a 6 M KOH aqueous solution. The electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurement was carried out by applying an AC amplitude of 5 mV at open circuit potential. The specific capacitance was calculated from the GCD curves using the following equation:| C = (I × Δt)/(m × ΔV) |
| CO conversion = [(COin − COout)/COin] × 100% |
Compared with samples S2 and S3, the rod morphology is seemingly obtained by cutting the tips of spindle. This confirms the etching occurred because of the reaction of excess H2PO4− ions with Fe2O3. This is ascribed to the dissolution of spindles along the long axis direction. Similar phenomenon was observed in literature.13 In addition, the diameter of samples increased with increasing H2PO4− concentrations. This is ascribed the re-growth of Fe2O3 on diameter direction because of Fe precursors generated by the etching. With increasing the concentrations of H2PO4− ions to 0.64 mM, the resulting sample become into tube-like morphology with average length of 160 nm and diameter of 100 nm (Fig. 1d, sample S4). For a H2PO4− concentration of 1 mM, the product was identified as disk-like shape with an average size of 126 nm (Fig. 1e, sample S5). In the case of H2PO4− concentration of 2.5 mM, the product was changed into ring-like structures with outer diameter of 130 to 160 nm and the thickness of the wall was about 40–60 nm (Fig. 1f, sample S6).
According to the morphology evolution in Fig. 1, it is found that H2PO4− concentrations play an important role for the resulting shape of samples. Similar phenomenon was observed by Chen et al.22 The morphology evolution mechanism is schematized in Fig. 2. Without H2PO4−, quasi spheres were obtained because of isotropic growth. With increasing the concentration of H2PO4− ions, the selected adsorption of H2PO4− ions occurred on the different facets of Fe2O3 samples. The adsorption of H2PO4− ions is very weak for the (001) plane because of the lack of singly coordinated hydroxyl groups.22,24 Thus H2PO4− ions were located on the prism planes of (110) and (100). The growth occurred along [001] direction, which resulted in the formation of spindle like Fe2O3 particles. As the H2PO4− concentration continues increasing, the tips of spindle-shaped particles were concaved to form nanorods. The driving force is the high activity of the sharp spindle tips, which are easily attacked by the protons in acidic solution. With the H2PO4− concentration further increasing, nanotubes were obtained. The formation of nanotubes can be described as dissolution of the spindle-shaped precursors from the tips toward the interior along the long axis, finally hollow tubes are formed. When the concentration of H2PO4− was high (1 mM), a large amount of surface adsorbed H2PO4− made the nanoparticles surface more negatively charged. Therefore, the electrostatic repulsion made aggregation of the nanoparticles difficult. Instead of forming spindle-shaped particles, nanodiscs were obtained.22 Similar to the nanotubes in the solution with a low phosphate concentration, the central area on both faces of a nanodisc was dissolved throughout the whole particle, a hole was made along the [001] direction and a nanoring appeared.22–24
To confirm the phase composition, Fig. 3 shows the XRD patterns of samples with different concentrations of H2PO4−. It is found that samples S1–S4 revealed pure α-Fe2O3 phase (all diffraction peaks matched perfectly with JCPDS file no 33-0664) without any other impurities. Moreover, all the diffraction peaks in XRD patterns are narrow and sharp, indicating ideal crystallinity. However, for the samples S5 and S6, apart from a pure α-Fe2O3 phase, the XRD peaks of Fe4(PO4)3(OH)3 (JCPDS file no 42-0429) phase were observed. Especially for sample S6, the XRD peaks of Fe4(PO4)3(OH)3 phase became high. This is ascribed to the reaction of H2PO4− ions with Fe2O3.25
To confirm the role of H2PO4− role, the FT-IR spectra of samples with different morphologies are shown in Fig. 4a. A distinct peak at 3450 cm−1 is ascribed to the bending frequency of surface hydroxyl group,26 and the strong absorption band centred at 573 cm−1 is due to the Fe–O vibrational mode, which is the typical lattice vibration peak of α-Fe2O3.27,28 Some weak peaks between 1010 and 1022 cm−1 confirm the presence of some phosphate impurity in samples.29 Fig. 4b depicts the Raman spectra of samples. Clearly, the Raman vibration bands at 228.31, 290.45, 410.48, 505.94, 656.11 and 1315.84 cm−1 indicated the formation of α-Fe2O3. The peaks at 228.31 and 505.94 cm−1 represented the typical A 1g mode, while the peaks at 290.45, 410.48, 656.11 and 1315.84 cm−1 are due to the Eg mode.30
According to the result in literature, the surface hydroxyl configuration on (001) planes of α-Fe2O3 was doubly coordinated hydroxyl groups, whereas on other planes, for instance the (012), (110) and (100) plane, the dominated surface coordinated hydroxyl groups are singly type.31–34 The H2PO4− in solution can react with hydroxyl groups by forming monodentate or bidentate inner-sphere complex.35,36 Thus, the adsorption capacities and affinities for phosphate to hematite were much lower for the (001) planes than for the others.
At low H2PO4− concentration, selected adsorption occurred on the planes except for (001) plane due to the special surface hydroxyl configuration. Thus, the (001) plane would grow quick compared with others and result in spindle-like structure based on the theory that the final morphology is determined by those planes with low growth speed.
| Fe2O3 + 2xH2PO4− + 6H+ ↔ 2[Fe(H2PO4)x]3−x + 3H2O | (1) |
With increasing H2PO4− concentration to 0.43 mM, the spindle-like products would form at first. At the same time, the H+ concentration would increase due to the continuous hydrolysis of Fe3+, which accelerates eqn (1) towards the positive direction. Therefore, the etching process would happen along [001] direction because of high activity of the sharp spindle tips and formed the final rod-like shape at the state of solution system equilibrium. For 0.64H2PO4− concentration, the morphology evolution is as same as the formation of rod-like product. The center area was completely dissolved and the diameter of the final tube became larger and the surface smoother than that of the spindle-like products. At a high H2PO4− concentration (1 mM), the resulting samples exhibited a disk-like morphology with the main exposed (001) plane. This is ascribed that the surface hydroxyl groups were intense protonized because of a high H2PO4− concentration and more H2PO4− ions adsorbed on the (001) plane with less Fe3+ adsorbed due to the electrostatic attraction.37 As a result, the growth of (001) plane was blocked and became a final main exposed plane.
The SEM images of samples are shown in Fig. 5. In addition, a time-dependent morphology evolution test and the corresponding formation mechanism was also given in Fig. 6. With a constant H2PO4− concentration, it is found that the samples underwent shape evolution with various time. When the reaction time was 3 h, the products present disk-like morphology with diameter of about 140 nm (Fig. 5a, sample S7). Prolonging the reaction time to 6 h, the center of some disks became thinner and small holes were observed in the center and the diameter increased to about 145 nm (Fig. 5b, sample S8). With further prolonging time to 12 h, thinner areas increased in the center of disks and the holes became large and some disks are penetrated obviously with an average diameter of 157 nm (Fig. 5c, sample S9). When the reaction time reached to 20 h, the holes became large and most of the products became into ring-like morphology. The outer diameter increased to about 166 nm (Fig. 5d, sample S10). Apparently, the outer diameter of sample S10 increased with about 26 nm compared with sample S7.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Morphology evolution of samples with different reaction time. (a) S7, (b) S8, (c) S9, (d) S10. | ||
Fig. 6 shows the formation scheme of ring structure. The dissolving process along the [001] direction of the disks results to the formation of the ring. Since different planes share different surface hydroxyl configuration and the reaction on (001) plane was accelerated to the right side of eqn (1) and the α-Fe2O3 was dissolved faster than that of other planes. So the concentration of [Fe(H2PO4)x]3−x in the solution was enhanced and the H2PO4− decreased. According to the equilibrium theories,38 the (012) facet can absorb the new produced [Fe(H2PO4)x]3−x and release new H2PO4− to keep balance of the solution system. Hence, the (012) plane grew naturally which gives a good explanation of the increased diameter in ring-like products.
| Samples | Specific capacitance (F g−1) |
|---|---|
| a At a current density of 1 A g−1. | |
| S2 | 272 |
| S4 | 310 |
| S5 | 360 |
| S6 | 330 |
The variation trend of specific capacitance as a function of current density for the samples is shown in Fig. 7d. At a current density of 10 A g−1, the specific capacitance of sample S5 (disk-like) electrode can also maintain as high as 260 F g−1 with 69.3% retention, which indicates that the disk-like structure is more beneficial to the enhancement of rate capacity. On the contrary, the sample S2 (spindle-like) sample exhibits inferior specific capacitance and poor rate capability. Except for the electrochemical behavior and capacitance properties of the products, a good cycling stability is of great importance. So we tested the cycling performance of sample S5.
Fig. 7e is the specific capacitance retention of sample S5 at a current density of 5 A g−1 after 5000 cycles. In the first 200 cycles, the as-prepared electrode exhibits a stable capacitance with nearly unchanged, in the following cycling process, the electrode also exhibits ideal specific capacitance with a retention about 70.5%, which indicating that the disk-like structures present an excellent cyclability. Also, the curves of charge–discharge time are almost unchanged for the first 10 cycles, indicating high coulombic efficiency. Fig. 7f represents the EIS measurements of samples with various morphologies. The Nyquist plots contain two parts: the semicircle at high frequency region and the curve at low frequency region. While the intersection of the semicircle and real axes represents ohm resistance (Rs), including the intrinsic resistance of the substrate.39 The diameter of the semicircle indicates the interface charge transfer resistance between the electrode and the electrolyte (Rct). The Rs values of the electrodes can be clearly seen from the illustration and follows the order: disk < ring < tube < spindle, demonstrating the best electrical conductivity for disk-like sample. The results consist with the previous analysis of the charge–discharge curves. The slope of the curve at low frequency region represents the diffusion resistance of OH− ions (Warburg resistance).40 It is found that the sample S5 performs highest slope value and more closer to the virtual axis, indicating smallest diffusion resistance. The reasons can be ascribed to the unique disk-like structure: the large specific surface area and considerable open space caused by the porous structure, demonstrating an ideal electrode material for charge migration and ion diffusion.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |